The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
How Hiring Mistakes Drain Your Agency's Profits with iDudes Mailbag
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Are bad hires quietly draining your profits?
We discovered how the true cost of a failed team member can skyrocket to $74,000 in just six months and why neglecting this is crushing your growth. You'll learn the concrete numbers behind hiring mistakes, the cascading effects of turnover, and practical steps to build a pipeline of champions who keep delivering for your agency long-term.
We break down the hidden expenses you’re paying: the opportunity costs, the lost revenue from underperformers, and the real value of a solid hiring process. We reveal a repeatable system for recruiting top-tier talent, assessing candidates objectively, and avoiding costly mistakes that bleed your bottom line.
Plus, they share how the right team setup turns into a revenue machine, helping you hit bonuses and scale faster than ever.
If you're tired of the revolving door and want to create a team that sticks, produces, and propels your agency forward, this episode is your blueprint.
Learn to turn hiring from a headache into a strategic advantage because the right people make all the difference in your journey to scale.
The Insurance Dudes Resources
Join the Agent Elite: https://www.skool.com/agentelite
Best Seller: https://MillionDollarAgencyBook.com
Insurance Dudes Files: https://blog.theidudes.com
TeamIQ: https://teamiq.theidudes.com
Telefunnel Lead Callers: https://theidudes.com
ILB: https://insuranceleadbrokers.com
Insurance Agency Trader: https://trader.theidudes.com
If this helps, subscribe and hit the bell so you can catch every episode.
Follow Us
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/theinsurancedudes
LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/the-insurance-dudes-podcast
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/insurancedudespodcast
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
Now I can't find my notes.
SPEAKER_01I mean, what kind of mailbag is it if there's no notes? Well, check your mailbag, bro. Let me look here. I literally have no idea what we're gonna talk about. Craig wants to talk about something, and it's going to be an argument.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. That's why it's up on my camera.
SPEAKER_00Oh my gosh. How silly. That is so silly. Okay. So you know, I've I've said this for I've said it for a long time, and and we we tend to disagree on it. You think that it's far less, and I actually think it's far more. Do you know what I'm talking about? Look, I don't even know what we're talking about. You don't even know. Are you interested?
SPEAKER_01I am interested.
SPEAKER_00Okay. Well, that's a mail. There, there you go. That's a mail. That's it. Hang it up. So so I I believe, and I've because I've read it in so many places, I've seen it at so many places. I used to not believe it because it seemed crazy. Maybe. But the cost of losing a hire is fantastically higher than what you think. Yeah. And so, you know, the thing you see around the interwebs for salespersons, somewhere like 80 grand, I'll concede that that seems ridiculous, right? But you can't. But I think more along the lines of 40, 50K, if you hire somebody and and they don't work out and you had that seat vacant because you have that rotating door, right? You're doing the scramble. And I know that you've said multiple times, Mr. Jason, that you think, oh, it's like 10K, 15K. Okay.
SPEAKER_01I would say maybe that's on the lower end, but I think that what we've talked about before was like 160K or 300K. It was like these numbers that were silly.
SPEAKER_00That's what I'm going to get into silly town. So it it makes me think back to I'd love to bring up up Wolfgang Van Van Helsing, who I I hired, he came. This is before I really, well, I didn't do any assessment. There was no assessment at that point. And he had energy. He told me he was the best salesman in the world. Oh, best name and best salesman. Right? I mean, I thought, okay, this is a no-brainer. He he had a great handshake. Had a great handshake, couldn't stop telling stories. I'm like, this guy's this guy's he's gonna knock you out of the park, right? I basically hired him on the spot, which we know is probably not the best thing that you could do, right? I think it makes it seem like, well, that was sure easy. I'm the best, and then they come in and you know, they don't it didn't work out, right?
SPEAKER_01But I like it.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, it was fun to have a guy with that name, and if he's listening, he was a really good guy. It just wasn't a good fit, you know. She's a good wrestler. I don't think that people add up all of the things, right? Okay. So so let's take that producer seat. You have a seat with a computer and a phone and and all these things, okay, and all these costs add up, right? Every single month before somebody sells something, that seat costs money. There's a fixed cost to it. So what do you have? You have well, you have your uh base salary, right? So let's say, you know, somewhere some people are on the lower end, whatever, we're around 4K.
SPEAKER_01Okay, 4K.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Okay. You have to have if if you want them to be successful, you need somebody making dials on the leads, right? So let's say that's 1500 bucks. Yeah. We have leads. How many leads does somebody need? Go on the low end because most people don't buy. That's what I think, right? Yeah. I'd say let's say 20, 20 leads a day. Is that fair? 15?
SPEAKER_01Let's go 10.
SPEAKER_00Okay. I'll go 10. Sold. So that's 50 bucks a day, right? Thousand bucks a month. Okay. Ish, right? And there's there's all these different factors. We're gonna ballpark it here. Uh, what else is there? Phone systems, tech. Let's call that a couple hundred bucks. Okay. What else? So, I mean, all these things, the the lights, the rent, you know, if you if you part if you partion any of things, that stuff out. Now, you also have your time, right? There's got to be some somebody's got to train up. Okay. Does that cost anything?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Like, like, so what would we say? A half of another person?
SPEAKER_00Maybe, right? It's the cost of not, or it's a different kind of cost of not. It's the cost of the things that you're not able to do because you're doing that. Right. Fair, right? Whether whether you don't do anything. Let's call it 1K a month. You could be camping, you could be doing something fun instead of doing that, right? Okay. Let's go 1K a month. Yeah. So you're doing a a lot of things. It's like having that, it's like having a car at the driveway that you're making a payment on and it doesn't run. Yeah. So your thoughts so far?
SPEAKER_01That's cool. We're at, well, we'll call it S seven.
SPEAKER_00We'll call it 8K a month. So what else do we have here? Now think about this. The part that that really gets you, okay? Ooh. This is the part that you don't really ever, you don't really feel. The real value isn't necessarily in that first sale they make, right? The real value is in what happens over time as their sales compound and the lifetime value, right? So when you s when they sell a policy or they sell, let's say they sell 20K a month, right? They sell so you got whatever it works out to. So maybe you got 4K, right, for your first month, and then it's going to renew four times. So over the course of the lifetime of that thing, it's probably it works out to about 10K, right? Of lifetime value. A little bit less, 9K. Depending on yeah, I mean, depending on your cop and all that stuff. But but I mean, the the a quick, easy number is just say how a little less than half of your lifetime value or of of your premium that you sold, you could say lifetime value. If you want to do quick map.
SPEAKER_01I'd say maybe a little less here in California if you're with a captive. Sure.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, probably eight, right?
SPEAKER_01Maybe, maybe a little less.
SPEAKER_00Right. But it's like a it's like a fruit tree, right? Like the thing is gonna produce these these fruit, but you gotta water it, you have to put fertilizer, you gotta put it in the sud, you gotta do all these things for it to bear fruit, or you grow it and you don't do the right things. Now the fruit, now the tree's there, but it's not giving you any fruit. And then you got to get rid of the tree because it sucks and it happens again, right? So there's this cascading effect that occurs over time, right? Because you have that situation, which I know in being there before that it's just it's a it's a lack of a process, right? If you don't have that process where you're constantly recruiting, then this is gonna happen.
SPEAKER_01Yes.
SPEAKER_00Because somebody's gonna be gone. Somebody, one of them, maybe all of them, right, are gonna be gone. And if there aren't new little baby trees out in the out out back, the now you're in trouble. Because you got to go buy a big tree. And that big tree comes with its own set of problems because you rushed. Okay. Okay. So so if we have a lifetime value of eight, eight K on that, I I didn't want to go all the numbers, but I think it it is good to get in there, right? If you have that, let's say it's 8K a month, they stick around for I mean, how long would you say back in the day when you kept somebody too long? How long would you keep them for before you finally said, nah, screw it. This guy's pissing me off. You f you you know when you stop coming into work because you're looking it's been as long as six months.
SPEAKER_01I mean, you know, which is terrible. I would say as short as three months. Still three months, right? Right, right.
SPEAKER_00Like I the production or three months from the time they got in the door?
SPEAKER_01Three months from the time you know like they might not be the right person.
SPEAKER_00Right. So there's some other months behind that where they weren't producing anything too. Maybe a couple months, three months, whatever, right? Yeah. So now let's say that's six to nine months, always an interesting set of numbers. So you have six to nine months at 8k a month if they were writing 20, which now, I mean, that used to be the standard, right? Oh man, if they could just write 20, well shit. Now if they're not writing 30 or 40, it's a problem, right? So, and then 30 or 40, that's fifth. Let's say that's 13,000 to 18,000 of lifetime value per month. That's you know, ongoing stack. So there, do that math. What's we'll do the we'll do the best case. Six months in for a 20k producer, we'll go cheapo. One that's not even doing that awesome. If that's eight, that's 48 grand right there. Just in production it in in commissions, right? That you're not getting if it had been done done right and you had the right person there, right? So that cost of having the wrong guy or gal in the seat taking that spot. Still not convinced, are you?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, no, I mean yeah, I mean, it's it's definitely expensive.
SPEAKER_00Well, so that's but that's the loss of the that's the your loss of commissions, and then what's the salary on six months? 4K times six or twenty-fourk. Yeah. Now now that's hard cost. That actually came out of your pocket, not just being stole, you know, not something that you didn't make. But I mean those things that you don't see really do cost because because we both bid at both places, right? We bid at a place where we had a fully where we have a fully crushing it team. I hate saying crushing it. We have a team that's that's really knocking the cover off the ball, right? And everything flows, and then the renewals are hitting, and there's muddy everywhere. It's like, ah, who cares? How many monsters should we buy this month? Get 10 cases, who cares? Right? Like it doesn't matter. It's like there's just muddy everywhere. And then when there isn't muddy everywhere, and you start going, oh, I gotta, I gotta tighten up, I gotta tighten, and then all of a sudden it's at this downward spiral. Yeah, right.
SPEAKER_01Okay, so let's say we keep someone six months, they they suck from the beginning, they suck till the end, you got rid of them in six months. We're saying that all those costs, even if it's just 10 leads a day, all those costs add up to be eight K. So six times eight is 48. So that's 48,000 lost right there. And that includes the opportunity costs. That's the salary? No, that's all the it's what we originally did. Okay. 8K a month, right? And one K a month. Not the revenue. Huh?
SPEAKER_00But not including the revenue. But not including the revenue, yes. Right. So that's another 50 or whatever, 50-ish on the low end, if it's a 20K producer. Like if you if you had if you had somebody, like if the guy that left, because because the right things weren't being done for that person, they bounced, they left, but they were writing 20k a month. Right.
SPEAKER_01So we're saying that this guy that spent 48,000 barely wrote anything. Let's say he wrote a yeah, you know, they're gonna write 10K a month unless they're completely moronic, right? So the so that's in that time frame is 60 K. That means you lost out on at least 60K in revenue. 60 K, right? So what did you say your lifetime value is?
SPEAKER_00Did you say 60k a premium?
SPEAKER_0160 60k in premium, yeah. Okay, just call it 26,000 of lifetime value from that. 26,000. So we'll add the 26k to the 48k. So that's uh 74k by having the wrong hire.
SPEAKER_00Okay. Now let me take it up, let me take it up a notch. Ooh. Now, what if you had the right people? Like now think back to a team that was that you had that was really doing awesome, how easy it was to hit bonus. Yes. Now, now take a team where things just weren't going right. It's these years where it's like, oh no, now this guy left, and now this. It's like all it takes is a couple things to go the wrong way, and all of a sudden you're like, holy shit, I'm really gonna have to push it to get bonus. Oh no. Yeah, I'm not gonna bonus. Now, what does that cost you? I mean, for me, if we don't like if we don't max bonus, that's over 300k that we lose. Right. So tack 300k on top, right? Or take somebody. Well, let's just let's even call it a let's call it 100k. Yeah, let's call it 100k. I mean, even call it 50k. Yeah, that's a lot. It's a lot, and it adds up, and it's all down to that one, right? The the one that's one seat. Yep. Remember when everybody left when the guy stole my whole team? Yep. Ten people. That is pretty amazing, though. I mean, luckily the comp was a little different then, and and we made it back up, but whoo! That was a dicey time in history. Yeah, it's just like it's this domino effect, right? The wood falls and it cascades into all the rest of them, and everything starts to go sideways. And then in your head, instead of going, all right, well, that's the way it is, I need to really batten down the hatches here and and focus on a solid recruiting strategy and hiring and pipeline and managing that like I do with the leads, instead of doing that, it turns into scarcity because now you're freaking out, right? Right. And I mean, we've done this long enough, and there's been so many cycles, and even just recently with the whole phone thing, the whole phone system fiasco that I've had, like I've gotten to these places where I go, uh, you know, I'm free, we we only sold 3K today, you know, and freaking out, and then I go, wait a minute, I've done this before. Calm down. You know, there's always the it's okay to to have it, but you got to recognize it when it happens, you know?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and I think so. Just for context for everybody else, we've had this kind of conversation during marketing. And when you market something, you don't teach people stuff. So it's like, I think this conversation is one of those things that like will make people realize the actual cost of hiring the wrong person, but you have to have this conversation to realize the actual cost of it. So if you're marketing something, it's got to be third grade level, right? You know, if somebody has to accept it upon first read, not ponder and then realize. Well, yeah. But that's that's true. Yeah. So like, but like it is true. And you know, like, especially the bigger you get, the bigger the impact. So these numbers would be much bigger, kind of like your bonus of 300K um versus 100K in some agencies, 500K. So like it's a big, it's a really big difference.
SPEAKER_00Right. And sure, you're not gonna make the right call every single time, but if you if you put the decision down to one call and it's that one call that's gonna affect everything, because there isn't something in place to consistently take the risk out of that one out of that, right? Like it's it's not if you have the the Wolfgang situation, but there's 10 other lined up, and I could, who cares, right? Get rid of this one, bring in the next one, and just keep doing it. Like a like an NFL team, right? Yeah, you're not gonna see a or any professional sports organization, you're not gonna see them say, Hey, our team is solid. We're not gonna recruit this year, right? Like that's insane. I mean, somebody gets hurt, something, who knows, right? I mean, you could have your your best producer that always does everything perfect, not a normal best producer, but let's just say it's your best producer. They do everything, they come in on time, they're they're great, they do all these tags. They could win the lottery. They're not coming in tomorrow, right? That's it. And so you never know what's gonna happen. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01But being a good thing. So most agents don't, we've always said always be hiring. They're not in that mindset at all. So, like, you here's a couple, a couple things. Like, they're not even looking. If they were about to look, they don't have the assets lined up. What kind of assets? What about even just a job ad? Like, you know what I mean? What are the benefits of your agency? What are the struggles that most people have getting into other agencies and like having that on your resin or on your job posting because like you want to differentiate yourself? So, like having things ready to be able to hire is a good way to do it. Most agents also want just somebody else to do it. So then they'll hire these companies that'll hire an agent and you're not even hands-on on it. Or you do your own one-on-one interviews and you waste all your time to find, try to find a needle in a haystack. Right. And you're trying to find the perfect closer. And guess what? They don't exist. Like there's always something, right? And and that guy that's like, or girl that's amazing, it's gonna be one in a hundred. So unless you're running a hundred one-on-one interviews, you know, chances are you're gonna hire just someone who's who you're emotionally connected with. So it might not be the right person. I mean, are you really calling all the references? Are you really doing all those things? And how good are you at recruiting? I know me, like, I mean, I like everybody.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01So like that's why even in my worst. Yeah, I'm the worst. And that's why in my hiring process, I have to have a spot where I try to unsell them. I sell them and then I try to unsell them.
SPEAKER_00Well, and I know how hard it is too, right? Because you hate to have somebody not like you. And that's basically what you're doing to them when you say, Ah, you know you're great. I don't know if it's a great fit. You know, I don't, I don't know if you have what it takes, or whatever the the line is to try to push them away. That's tough, right? That's tough to say. Yeah. But it is, I mean, it's very powerful.
SPEAKER_01So I think the the like the the best way to deal with this problem, because it's such a big problem, is first you have to cast the net, right? So like you and I love indeed ads. Spend money on it. It's really not it's so crazy people will spend, you know, if they're desperate, five thousand dollars on a hire, but they won't run $200, $400 a month ads to get a a flooding of people coming in. You know?
SPEAKER_00Like preventative maintenance versus emergency maintenance.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, but like also like I mean, yeah.
SPEAKER_00If you set it up, like I think what you're saying, if you set it up where you have like, okay, maybe it's $300 a month or $200 a month to have a deed going, and you know, you have an assessment a hundred bucks a month, and you have, you know, a couple other things, that costs far less than DEF CON 5. Holy crap, I need somebody this second, I'm gonna pay five grand for it.
SPEAKER_01Right. Well, and I what I'm saying is like those other people that are you're hiring that are costing five grand, usually, I mean, that's not your process. So it's usually not the best hire. You know what I mean? So it's like you can, I I I think there's a certain amount of hands-on you do need for your own culture and everything with your own agency. So it's like, how do you do that? You can't go into a blind like we've done. So you got to have, like you said, an assessment, right? Something that is quantifiable that you're comparing everybody to. You should be doing it. So, like doing your own N D dads is awesome because you're getting a flooding of people. I know you and I do the group interviews, like group interviews, assess them and then and then one-on-one interviews. So it's like this filtering process, right? And you go down to the cream of the crop. Not only do you feel good about them because you talk to them, group interviews, also you can pin people against each other. You can see the way they work around other people because that's the most important thing. You can see if they're putting on their BS attitude, right? And then assess them so you can get some quantifiable, like what where where are the proficiencies and deficiencies, right? At least that that's quantifiable. And then you can bring them in for a one-on-one interview. This is a way you can go through a hundred people and it doesn't cost you that much time. And it doesn't cost you that much money to do it either. But I think part of it is like, dude, you gotta have a good assessment.
SPEAKER_00It's remarkable how similar it is to the entire telefunnel like lead process, right? It's all the same. It's the same. Like, look, like look at that. You're gonna, you're gonna you buy a hundred leads, you're gonna sell one or two of them, maybe three, right? And look at you you get a hundred resumes, you have one or two, maybe three hires out of there. Probably closer to one. So I remember, you know, putting an ad, looking at the 30 or 40, you know, first 30 or 40 resumes, and then calling five of them and one of them shows up for an interview, and guess who got the job? Like that's forcing it, right? You can't force it. If you force it, you're getting bad numbers. And you know, you may get lucky every now and then, but my experience has been that doesn't work. And so, you know, could if I was gonna give out tidbits of of what works, it's just it's consistency, it's the same stuff as with everything else consistency, process, and sticking with it. Yep. Even though it doesn't look like it's working at first. Because the alternative is holy crap, it's an emergency, I'll pay five grand. And guess what? They're doing the same thing. Like they're they're not doing it very and they're not even doing it customized to your situation.
SPEAKER_01And if they are, dude, there's no way they're doing it that good. Right. There's a lot of crappy hiring going on. Uh you know what I mean? Let's be honest. I mean, this is one of the most important things in your your business, right? We talk about the telefunnel, right? The sales funnel. And essentially that's just the sales funnel. The sales funnel in your is one of the is the biggest driver. It's the lifeblood of the body of your business. But dude, the second most important process in your agency is how people come in and out because that is going to happen. And how long they stay or how little they stay makes a drastic difference. I'll never forget, dude, I told you about that dude that was right down the street from my office. And he was selling good, right? Like a couple hundred thousand a month or whatever. And they were using him as an example of like this awesome agent, you know, they're they dumps. Um, they were using them him as an example. And so I asked him about his hiring. And he's all, yeah, I'm always hiring, man. I gotta hire like eight new people a month. And I'm like, what? He's all yeah. He's like, they they just they're rotating in and out of the agency so quickly. I'm like, oh my gosh. And their numbers that they were selling per agent were so low. And I'm like, this can't, this is not a profitable business. No. Like he was on a new contract, so he was getting all that enhanced commission and dude. That yeah, it's breaking even.
SPEAKER_00So it's a different situation.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's it's terrible. It was terrible. The business, the business model sucked.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01But that's why it's important. So, like, you have that, you know, customer journey, customers coming in, like, how much do they cost on the front end coming in? How do you make that a consistent model on the front end? How do you make the onboarding into keeping them and then also adding on more policies? That includes your LTV lifetime value. So it's not just what you're getting from the person on the initial sale, it's also what you're getting on the other policies and how long they stay. Like that drastically changes the economics of your business, right? And it's the exact same thing when it comes to hiring. How long they stay and how much they produce is a completely like you can have two businesses producing the same numbers, but that those numbers of how often they're hiring and how long the people are staying is will completely change the economics of what you actually take home. Yeah. And that's the other thing. It's like there's so many agents, you know, we always look at the vanity numbers, like how much they're selling and all this stuff. Well, dude, how much are they keeping? Yeah. Do you know what I mean? Like that's the most important thing to me. Like, are you like, or if they're not keeping, are they growing at a rate at like at some point they they gotta be keeping, right? Like, what what's the plan? Because I see so many agents that just dump money in and their processes look their processes really stink and they're not keeping any money. So it's like, what are they doing?
SPEAKER_00And I mean, for a lot of people, it feels like they're not keeping any money right now. That's what I hear out on the street. Then why do it? But these are I got my ears to the street, Mr. Jason.
SPEAKER_01I guess so. All right. Well, I think that was good. It was a good mailbag. You really helped me understand that we're looking at more, like the number was, and those were incredibly low numbers of the costs, but you're looking at 48, I don't know, 74K for a bad hire that was in there for that's on the low, low, low, low end.
SPEAKER_00And that's not saying but that's like not even that's without the bonus.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. So like give it a percentage of that bonus, too. You're looking at probably 100K. So that's 74K without the bonus. Crazy. Yeah. And that's a mailbag. That is a mailbag.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman