The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
From Stable Job to Independent Operator With Nathan Glass
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
In this episode, we’re honored to have Nathan Glass, founder of Utopia Risk, to explore the strategies behind making smarter business decisions. Nathan shares his insights on identifying the right people to work with, whether it’s for hiring, partnerships, or long-term collaborations. He dives into how everyday conversations reveal values, why understanding someone’s life outside of work matters, and how subtle red flags in planning or approach can signal bigger issues down the line.
Listeners will gain practical guidance on building trust, aligning with the right people, and knowing when to step back early, turning every decision into a more intentional, thoughtful move for their business.
Join the elite ranks of P&C agents. Sign up for Agent Elite today and get exclusive resources to grow your agency!
🔗 https://www.skool.com/agentelite
Grab our newly released book at a discount!
The Insurance Dudes Weekly 5-Min Read
Tips, Tricks, and Wizardry for Everything Your Agency Touches
Subscribe for a treasure trove of knowledge, and never miss out on a golden nugget again! Our newsletter is the map to the hidden gems of insurance mastery.
Subscribe Here
Ready to Unearth the Goldmine of Internet Leads?
Unlock the Alchemy of Turning Internet Leads into Gold with "Internet Lead Secrets"
Dive into the strategies that transformed us into Midas of the insurance world, writing over 10mm in annualized auto premium amidst global chaos. Grab your copy before it vanishes!
Check It Out Before It’s Gone!
Teledudes Telefunnel™ Agency Growth System
On-Demand Masterclass: The Treasure Map to Lead Mastery
Step into our world where leads are never cold, and revenue streams flow like rivers of gold. Register now and discover the X marks the spot of agency growth.
Register And Dominate!
Is Your Agency a Sleeping Giant or Just Sleeping?
FREE Agency Growth Diagnosis with Jonathan Cuevas
Don’t let your agency be a ship lost at sea. Book your growth call now and let Jonathan, the captain who steered Jason's team to $250k a month, navigate you to the treasure island of your business goals. Get your growth plan, tailored just for you. It's time to wake the giant within.
Book My Agency Growth Call Now
Dive into an episode where entertainment and enlightenment collide, and walk away with a toolbox that even Feynman would envy. The Insurance Dudes are on a mission: making the complicated uncomplicated, and having a blast along the way. Are you in?
#LEGO
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
The answer that I received in terms of how much is your agency worth wasn't what I was hoping for initially. 83% of agencies out there are less than a million in revenue.
SPEAKER_03While you're scaling, what kind of pieces that you're putting in place to get to that like next revenue level?
SPEAKER_01We're 15 months in right now. We launched July 2024. It's easier to take a process that's already there, make modifications to it, than it is to build it from I'm curious if you have any build secret questions you asked to try to gauge what kind of values the person has, what does the entry look like? What does the exit look like? Because a lot of these aggregators, the entry is not so bad, but the exit is bad. That she was just leaving the grocery store one day and a bike hit the back of her car. She didn't think anything of it at the time. The guy was fine. But of course, 12 months later, she gets slapped with this $4.3 million lawsuit. And that's when I saw like the the breakdown of how these lawsuits work. And it was, you know, $40,000 in medical bills, $100,000 in loss of wages, and $4.1 million in pain and suffering expense. And it was like, Jesus. So yeah, that that was the craziest thing. Everything got settled out all right in the end. But that was pretty crazy.
SPEAKER_00Wow.
SPEAKER_01So I I'm Nathan Glass, and I'm with Utopia Risk in Sacramento, California, and I'm an insurance dude.
SPEAKER_04Boom!
SPEAKER_03Boom!
SPEAKER_04That is a big lot. What's that? I had a premature boom.
unknownIt happens.
SPEAKER_03It happens. Um that is wild, dude. That is a crazy amount of money.
SPEAKER_01It was, it was. And you know, I I keep it to this day so I can show people the the breakdown of how I mean in California, you hear about these things. And it's an entirely different thing to say, hey, this is an actual lawsuit. This is how it broke down. So yeah, it's definitely a big talking point with clients.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, and those stories are solid gold. It's funny, I was just telling my team about that. One one of the one of my newer um employees, the team members, uh, you know, we're talking about the price of the issue out here in California, right? And it's like the the price just keeps going up for all the insurance companies, and it's like everybody's like, I can't believe it. And it's like, well, this is what happens. Like, your story is exactly like that. That is the story. I had to tell them of a story where a lawyer's a kid got sued for um you know over a million bucks uh, you know, for hitting a homeless person that threw himself threw himself in front of the car.
SPEAKER_00Right.
SPEAKER_03You know what I mean? And the kid, the kid was a really upstanding kid that was a son of a lawyer, and yeah, I mean he was getting sued by the parents of this homeless guy that was on drugs. But like I mean, that that is not the kid's fault.
SPEAKER_01Like, you know, but like we live in California, so I mean it it amazes me every single time I drive through Southern California, the number of are you injured billboards? It's yeah, I mean, I was doing it a month ago, and I would say 75% of those billboards are are you injured? Call us and we'll get you money.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, do you ever see Sweet James?
SPEAKER_01Oh yeah.
SPEAKER_03Oh yeah. There are thousands of Sweet James all over Cal because we'll go camping all the way up north. Yeah, there are thousands. Sweet James used to come into my work and I used to hang out with him here and there. Oh yeah. Um really cool dude. Uh but really cool dude. I had no idea I I didn't even know who he was, and I didn't see the billboards until later.
SPEAKER_01Right.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. So crazy. Then his wife was on Real Housewives.
SPEAKER_01Oh, no way.
SPEAKER_03Oh, yeah. Yeah. And the only reason why I know that is because of my my wife. Because I I don't like those shows.
SPEAKER_00Right. Yeah.
SPEAKER_04So Nathan, uh so before how long had you been uh an agent when this happened?
SPEAKER_01So I had been an agent a few years. Um I mean, I I got started in the insurance industry basically right out of college. And when I moved to California, I found uh uh a company that rhymes with charmers, and so I I worked for them for a while uh on the district level, and so I kind of got me you know familiar with the insurance industry, and I was recruiting, training new agents, and then also there was a lot of essentially mergers and acquisitions that was going on there. So, hey, this guy wants to retire. Well, let's bring on a new agent to to acquire that book of business. And so that that was my first few years, and then I had the opportunity to to be the acquirer, so I bought my own agency about uh nine years ago, and so I had that for eight years before I ended up selling that last year and going the independent route.
SPEAKER_03Oh, spicy, because we got a lot of those lately, especially here in crazy California.
SPEAKER_01Yep, yep.
SPEAKER_03You know Dan Kedajima?
SPEAKER_01Yep.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, yeah, he's my reputation.
SPEAKER_01I've never met him, but right, right.
SPEAKER_03My rep well, it's same um same company. I mean, from your cryptic message, I kind of figured it out. I think it rhymes with charmers. The company that we're with rhymes with ball slate.
SPEAKER_01Oh, very nice.
SPEAKER_03You like that? Also Ball State University. You can't say their names because well, we can't say our names because um I mean who knows? They'll probably just take away the agency. I can say farmers all I want.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, we can say Well, cool, man.
SPEAKER_03I mean, that's so I mean you were that's that's a while. Um that must have been a hard transition mentally, uh, especially after putting in that kind of time at that that agency.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it it definitely was. And I mean the the time between the decision and letting my higher ups know, my manager know, hey, this is the the route I want to go, and the time it actually happened was about 18 months. It it took a while. So there was definitely preparation time, but as I was looking back at my my experience there, and I I wouldn't have changed it for the world. I mean, it it helped me get really my my foothold and where I wanted to go and cut my teeth there. But it was it was really early on in my career I knew I wanted to make the jump eventually. I wasn't gonna be a lifer with that company for you know a multitude of reasons, but the transition, no matter what, is is difficult. I mean, that's they're the company that I was familiar with, they developed me, and they provide such a good life for me and my family. And so to jump from this thing that I had built for years to something brand new from scratch, starting over, it's it's not an easy jump. And so that was that was definitely something that uh yeah, it was difficult.
SPEAKER_03How did you sell it?
SPEAKER_01So uh, you know, the way that Farmers goes about it is essentially the manager is the one kind of playing the game, so he's figuring out all right, this person wants to sell, this person might want to buy, let's play matchmaker type of thing. So it's it's a very closed bubble, and you don't really have a ton of choice in the matter, unfortunately. And just because at the end of the day, it's it's corporate that's approving these, you know, people that want to buy, and so people from the outside of the industry, even outside of the company, aren't necessarily the ones that they're going for. So by the time I sold, they were really looking at consolidation, trying to make larger agent fewer larger agencies, and so it was just a matter of who was within side of that district that was looking to buy at that time.
SPEAKER_03Crazy. So so you sell it.
SPEAKER_01Yep.
SPEAKER_03Um, did you have a plan?
SPEAKER_01Like next step. I I mean, luckily, I I had some time, right? I had some time to plan it out, and I knew exactly what I wanted it to look like. But what you're not really prepared for in even in my conversations with other people on the independent side of things, people that had made that transition before, it just it's an entirely different thing to go from something where they built the car for you, you're you're driving it, you're making you can change the color, you can you know do this little thing to the car. But essentially, they built the car. You just got to go drive it. And to jump into something where you're building the car, you got to make your decision in terms of your agency management system, your CRM, what type of business you want to write? Am I gonna be 100% commercial on personal lines? Am I gonna just do both? What you know, where's the focus? And so the decision overwhelm, I think, was probably the biggest adjustment, especially early on. And timing is a little bit of everything as well, because I jumped into independent when it was really difficult to get carrier appointments, and so luckily I had found a good aggregator that is has been amazing, they've been really supportive, and so I've been able to get some of the key carriers as a result of that relationship. But I mean, if I didn't, yikes, I I wouldn't have been struggling to find carriers to even write with.
SPEAKER_03Is that like when it comes to the aggregator, can you take your clients from the aggregator?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, the and that was really one of the decision-making processes for selecting that aggregator. Was what does the entry look like? What does the exit look like? Because a lot of these aggregators, the entry is not so bad, and it's not so bad as long as you're with them, but the exit is pretty ugly. And I was at a conference a couple weeks ago, and I don't know if you're from familiar with Carrie Wallace, she does a lot on uh valuations for independent PNC agencies, and she was just talking about things like the aggregator you're with, even your agency management system, because some of these agency management systems they own the data. You don't own that data. And so if you want to take it off of their platform, you need to pay them. And so all of these things entered into it for the data you entered in, your clients that that was all the stuff that you entered in, but they own it.
SPEAKER_04That's criminal. Sounds simple. It's similar to something. I can't quite put my finger on it.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, exactly. But but these things also have a massive impact on the valuation of the agency. And so one thing that was really important to us is we were evaluating which one was gonna be the one we decided to go with was what that exit looked like. And so we pay it a small little fee to get it out, and that's it. It's all yours. That that's it, and so um I I've been really happy with that decision. I think that was one of the the better decisions that we we made early on, and just because you know what, they might be the right fit right now, maybe not in five years, ten years, you know, down the road. And so making that transition, that ability to move and and be flexible in in this industry, I think is really important.
SPEAKER_04That is wild. So it's not like a lot of folks diving in would be thinking, okay, I need to be be clear on the aggregator, I need to be clear on the the exit of the aggregator, but then I also something that probably they just sneak in there is that is that data thing. I mean, I can't believe that.
SPEAKER_01Right? Yeah.
SPEAKER_04Wild.
SPEAKER_01It is.
SPEAKER_04What else do you find that was that opened your eyes as you're doing this?
SPEAKER_01Um, you know, it's really easy to build it accidentally as opposed to build it on purpose, just because there are there are things that'll come your way. And if you take everything that comes in, all of a sudden you built something that you didn't necessarily intend to. And so just also knowing when to say no as opposed to just always saying yes, and it's really easy, early days. All you're looking for is putting revenue on the books, and to it's really difficult to say no at that point in time, but it's also the most important time to say no because saying yes, you know, we were looking at this possible acquisition that was in the the transportation space, and it was like, well, we don't do transportation right now. My business partner has a little bit of experience with it, but we don't have the systems and processes set up to facilitate a transportation book. So is now the time? No. Later down the road, when we bring on somebody that's more well-versed in transportation, sure, we can look at acquisitions in that space at that time, but right now, not so much.
SPEAKER_04It's fascinating to that world. It's it's so there's so many different avenues you can go down. Transportation. I mean, you could cities and counties or whatever, right? All these different things that you can do. What what are you looking at?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, we mainly work with contractors, restaurants, real estate investors, and manufacturing. So those those are kind of the core four that we operate in. Uh, my business partner is uh fluent in Spanish, he's a native Spanish speaker, and so we have a really large and growing book of people, uh Spanish speakers, and so whether or not it's these these guys, and they they run amazing businesses, you know. Just this guy with 22 tacarillas, and he's smelled, you know, sells 25 million dollars worth of tacos a year, and it's just like how in the world he sells 25 million dollars worth worth of tacos. It's it's insane. Um, but yeah, that that's really where we've we've had the experience and had those processes dialed in, and so we're we're really growing in those particular areas right now.
SPEAKER_03So you and your business partner started from scratch?
SPEAKER_01Yep, yep. So we actually met back back in the old days on the captive side of things, and we just always stayed in touch. And he went off and did his thing, I went off and did my thing. Uh, he likes to tell me that he saw the light before I did, so he moved on uh onto the independent side before I did, and but he was working for somebody else. He was a producer for another firm that got bought out by private equity. And when they got bought out, he said, you know what, this that's not the direction that I want to go. And it just so happened that I was starting something new, so we we joined together and started this from scratch.
SPEAKER_03So did you guys both bring money and what like what did you guys bring to the table and and talk about the scaling aspect of that? Did were you guys were the sales producers or yep, yep.
SPEAKER_01And so he uh we we really both brought some clients, a lot of referral partners, and he is very, very uh sales focused. He's he wants to be out in the field 24-7, 365. Um, and so I complement that with a little more of the running the business, the operation side of things. Um, so I I get I get on the sales side as much as I can and sales and marketing. Um, but yeah, we just we noticed A, we got along really well. We had always gotten along well, and then B, we had very complimentary skill sets. And so it was just a really good match for us, and and I think it was uh I can't imagine doing this by myself at this point. It's just been so much fun doing it as a team and having the the right complementary skill sets within the organization. Um, so he heads up our our Texas office in San Antonio, and then I'm here in Sacramento.
SPEAKER_03Oh, that's so cool. Well what was so what was your first hire within the company? So it's you two, you're slaving away. What what part like at what revenue did you guys decide to like okay, this is our first hire, this is our second, and so on.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so fairly early on, just because the the service side of things is it it can be it can bog you down really, really easily. And so that was that was our first hire, and then also fairly early on, was also just a marketing assistant. And so it's one thing to produce the content, it's also you got to get it edited, you got to get it uploaded, you know, there's just all these little things that are time consuming. And so um, you know, it's where where he thrives, where I thrive, are actually the revenue-producing activities. What can we do to make sure that anything is that is not one of those items is being done somewhere else? And so it's it's always an evolving process. It's something we look at monthly, quarterly, where we say, okay, this is our process, and we we evaluate our processes as well, saying, Okay, maybe this is entirely broken. We just we do a lot in the ENS space, and so agency bill and premium financing and stuff like that, and we were just like, This is this sucks. I mean, it's it's time consuming, it's not fun, anything like that, and so we just completely changed that process where it took you know, probably anywhere from 30 minutes to an hour per client, to where it's five minutes done. And so that sheer time savings, and that wasn't even an internal hire. That was hey, the premium finance company can do X, Y, and Z. You hand them the stuff, they take care of everything else. We just gotta make sure they did it right at the end of the day. So, everything like that is is something that um is really important to us right now, and especially moving into the future, because it's not always gonna be people that are taking over those processes, it's gonna be automations. And the reality is that in order to it it it's gonna be almost like training a kid, right? So to teach my my five-year-old how to do something, I have to break it down very simply, step by step, because she's gonna take it very literally, and that's gonna be what our world is turning into from an automation point of view moving forward. So everything you're doing, if it's not done really step by step, literally, easy to explain, easy to understand, then you're gonna be missing the bone, you're gonna have to redo everything at some point.
SPEAKER_03It's wild. The automation works really well for people that are very process-oriented. The same people that were doing well when it wasn't automated because they had you know the checklists and and the the uh the book inside the agency of like this is the process, right? And now it's like automating that process, but man, it can get messy. If it goes in messy, it comes out messy.
SPEAKER_01That it does, that it does.
SPEAKER_03Well, this is uh awesome. So what um like like like revenue, like what what what what kind of scaling are we talking about? And and how how if somebody was getting into this and transitioning the reason why I ask you this is because I think there's this is probably uh an unpopular uh I'm probably gonna say something put my foot in my mouth, but I don't I don't care these days. Um but there's probably a lot of captive agents that are gonna eventually transition to independent because eventually it just doesn't make sense. Um so like like talk about like the revenue and like how how while you're scaling, what kind of pieces that you're putting in in place to get to that like next and r uh revenue level.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. So I I mean we we're fifteen months in right now. We launched July twenty twenty four. So we're we're still early days and we just this month surpassed what took me Seven years, eight years to build on the captive side. And so it's it's gone really, really fast, and we've only accelerated over the past couple of months. And so we're gonna we're gonna be seeing some significant growth, and that's just organic growth. We are also growing acquisition-wise as well. And so I know you had uh Brandon Wolf on from the PE perspective of acquisition, and where we're seeing where we're operating is really below that radar. So the the 200,000, the 300,000, 400,000 range, where it's these, you know, agency owners, sometimes an assistant, small team, but solid business. And there's uh there's really a breakdown. 83% of agencies out there are less than 1.25 million in revenue. And so there's so much opportunity from a almost like a microacquisition point of view, because you know, we've we've had three LOIs, so letter of intent, so offers accepted this year. We decided to back out of two of those because they did not pass due diligence. Um but at the same time, we're we're growing organically, but we're also a growing growing via acquisition as well.
SPEAKER_03What are you looking for um in those sizes? Like what like A, why do they fall out? Who do you use to go through that that due diligence process and part of it is personal experience?
SPEAKER_01I it really helps being somebody that's run an agency for many years, so you kind of know what to look for and what not to look for. Uh there was one recently where it was like, wait a minute, these these financials don't look right. Why don't they look right? Well, it's because premium payments was in the operating account, and so there were one account, and it was like, yeah, we're out. So uh we you know, you could probably he's probably doing everything right and everything above board, but it was just it was something where it was a little too messy for for us to move forward with, unfortunately. Um, but you know, there there are brokerage websites out there that we we sometimes use to get into these conversations. Um, but also, and it it's hard because I've been there, I've done the exit. Um, the answer that I received in terms of how much is your agency worth wasn't what I was hoping for initially. But you know what? That that is what it is. It was worth what it was worth, and I accepted that and moved on, but not everybody's willing to. Uh, one of the first ones that we looked at that we decided to back out of at the end of the day, they were just uh asking and very firm-footed in terms of this is what we think it's worth. And it was more than five times revenue, and we just did not see how it could be worth more than five times revenue given where it was and the parameters around it. And so some sometimes it's just valuation clashing. Um, sometimes it's financial, but when it really works out, we find that there's really good personality fit for us being really commercial focused, uh it's either heavy commercial or 100% commercial, and not that we can't because the more and more agencies I talk to, uh the number of people that are even in their mid-70s that tell me I have no idea what my clients look like because I haven't seen them in decades. You know, it's a very, very remote agency oftentimes. So it's not like we can't operate in too many other states, but there's just so much opportunity in California and Texas where we already have offices. That's that's really where we focus.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, I would think the agent force is is is growing eld is growing older, right? And there's all of these books that are just coming up where they've just held on to them.
SPEAKER_01Yep, exactly.
SPEAKER_04So you said times revenue. I'd al I'd been under the oppression in um the independent space that that they looked at ebida.
SPEAKER_01Is that oftentimes what I've noticed is that one when they're below a million dollars, especially below five hundred thousand, it's really it's an owner operated, they're kind of taking whatever is not a core expense, and so they operate more on a times revenue, and as you grow the business, there starts to be more business profit as opposed to just hey, you know, there was an extra ten grand this month, I took ten grand, you know, then they start to switch that conversation over to Ibada.
SPEAKER_04And what what is that multiple? Like, what are we what is what is your sweet spot? Like, what are you looking for if you were selling, and what are you looking for when you're buying?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, a lot of the stuff we're looking at is between two and three, that's where we notice that it works best for us. Um, private equity is an entirely different math equation. They're playing different math than we are. We're looking at, all right, can this support the debt service and the expenses? They're saying is as Brandon said, we're trying they're trying to get money off the table. So, how much can we get off the table? So they're looking at it from end valuation point of view. We're looking at it from all right, can this business actually sustain the expenses that it's gonna incur with the current expenses plus a debt load? So we notice usually in the the two to three space is what we we come across the most.
SPEAKER_03Gotcha. That's awesome. Interesting.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_03Did you guys move into um Texas because of your partner or right?
SPEAKER_01Yep. Okay. So so we met when he was in Sacramento and then he shipped out of here in 2020, and so he's been in San Antonio, and uh we like I said, we just stayed in touch, and he comes here, I go there. But yeah, it's uh it was a marriage of convenience that has worked out very, very well.
SPEAKER_03I didn't if it I I didn't know if it was for premium because premium out there is insane. Right.
SPEAKER_00It really is.
SPEAKER_03We have a lot of clients out there, and it's like I mean, the numbers compared. Uh it's like banana's crazy.
SPEAKER_01It is. Like when I used to be on the captive side and they would classify California as a mid-premium state. I'm like, what are you talking about? Our premiums are crazy, and then you talk to somebody from Texas, like somebody from Houston, and it's like our homeowners' premiums are 10 grand for this, you know, 2,000 square foot house. I was like, what are you talking about?
SPEAKER_04So it's insane.
SPEAKER_01It's nuts. It's nuts.
SPEAKER_04Texas, Colorado, Georgia.
SPEAKER_01Yep. Crazy.
SPEAKER_03Places to do home. So you said that you were able to do in basically one and a half years what you were able to do in eight years. Um what what contributed to that?
SPEAKER_01A lot of it was where we're playing. So on the the captive side of things, I was really personal lines. I didn't really delve too much into the commercial side of things. And just the way they were they were approaching things with commission reductions and everything like that, um, you know, significant premium increases. It it just it became difficult to really grow at a significant pace. And so where we operate right now is usually in the small, the mid-market size on the commercial side of things. So, you know, it used to take 10 to 20 clients before to what is one client now. So that obviously just uh accelerates that growth when you're talking far fewer numbers in terms of clients.
SPEAKER_03Do you um when you sell commercial, do you down sell personal lines as well?
SPEAKER_01Not right now. Part of that was because of when I made that transition, nobody was accepting new appointments on the personal line side of things. And so it was partially hey, I I was already for a little bit of a break, and like I mentioned, wanted to intentionally grow the commercial side, so that that was uh the big priority. But the other part of it was really the fact that nobody wanted to write it at that point in time. So I mean, I I think traveler still, for many, many agents, has uh two households a month cap. And it's just like, okay, you're not gonna be growing your personal lines book too quickly at two policies a month, two households a month. So there's that part as well. But as that starts to open up, um, you know, that is gonna be another opportunity for us to add something that we're familiar with, we have the processes, we can just plug and play there.
SPEAKER_03100%. What about commercial what about um uh financial services?
SPEAKER_01Uh, you know, my partner came from the banking side of things. Um, I spent a little bit of time exploring the financial services side, and it's not something that we have even considered moving into. We've just really had a really good core and really want to develop this side of things because we see our our approach is really prevention first. That's that's the first and foremost. And so when we go into a client, we're not talking about insurance, we're not talking about the protection side of things. We go prevent, then protect. And so for the way that we're building things out, the needs that we're seeing and the conversations we're having, we're you know, we're basically at capacity with just the commercial. And so when we look at adding something like a personal lines or venturing into a transportation side of things or financial services, the way that we look at it is not gonna be, hey, we're gonna start this from the ground up again, it's gonna be via acquisition. And because that zero to one, that those building out of those processes, it's very time consuming. And so, you know, there's this analogy that on a short flight, 10 to 20 percent of an airplane's fuel is spent in that takeoff process. And so as we look at adding other niches, other lines of business entirely, it's gonna be through acquisition because we avoid that zero to one problem. It's easier to take a process that's already there, make modifications to it, than it is to build it from scratch nine times out of ten.
SPEAKER_04And you may get the people too.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, exactly. I mean, you're not just you're not just acquiring the processes, there's the people, so hopefully some service, some sales, maybe even some marketing, and so it just becomes a much easier proposition.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. If if you started uh from scratch today, would you start by acquiring rather than starting?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I if the opportunity arose, absolutely. And I think for my background, what I've seen, you know, especially if if you have the experience, you know, if you're making that transition from captive to independent, and you have the ability and the opportunity to acquire into that transition, 100%. And there's just uh you know, if nothing else, you're used to making a decent income here, all of a sudden income dries up a little bit when you're starting with zero, right? And so you got to build into that. Um, so if if nothing else besides that, but you're just there are so many more doors open when you bump into that that you know amount of revenue. So if you have an extra two grand, five grand, whatever at the end of the month after you pay yourself, and you get to spend that on a new staff member or marketing or whatever, it just you have so many more choices, so many more possibilities to really accelerate that growth from there.
SPEAKER_03Makes sense.
SPEAKER_04I I was I was gonna comment on the um on the financial services because right when he said it, I saw your face just was like, you know, like the the typical uh PC, you know, you came from that world, it's like right? You know, it's like it is interesting because you left, you left where there was a lot of control to where there's a lot of independence, right? And I think all that does is add some handcuffs when you have uh there's just more regulation, more things to be concerned about, more paperwork.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, absolutely. And you know, I had even I had even explored that route. And there's uh a friend of mine who had uh a firm, he was, you know, the this certified financial planner, and I actually did a lot of guest speaking for his classes because he kind of had a very interesting niche and he was looking at moving on to something else. He was done with financial planning, and so we had talked about me going that direction a little bit, and I think it's is very, very appealing to me on a personal level, but I also see uh some of the things that are happening in our industry, happening in that industry with consolidation, with um, you know, even fee compression as they put it. And the model that I would want to have in the financial services, it it wasn't his model. You know, the for me, I just the way that I operate is more the the consulting fee, the you know, the fee as opposed to the fee-based or the commission um for assets under management. And so um, you know, it's it's a very I talked about kind of the fit on the acquisition side of things, making sure it fits the direction you want to go. And when I was looking at that particular opportunity, it just it wasn't the right fit for how I wanted to grow the business. And so it was best to just say, you know what, that's not the right opportunity, but that's not to say that we're not gonna come across an opportunity that is that model, and we can plug and play that model.
SPEAKER_03Um are are you how how are you acquiring these smaller companies? Are you guys reaching out individually? Um, because I know I've gotten letters in the mail, you know, like like I think that stuff works, you know, like the the guerrilla marketing side of it.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean that that's definitely part of it. There are brokers out there. I have really gotten ingrained in the MA community, and what's really interesting is everybody around me, nobody does insurance. Everybody, you know, I got tons of people interested in home services, you know, your plumbers, your electricians, stuff like that. Some people focused on larger construction companies. Um, I got a guy that is buying a hospital. I got another guy that wants to buy an insurance carrier. So if you know any carriers for sale, let me know. Um so what um what I've just noticed is they're always outlooking. They're always they have their finger on their pulp, the pulse, and there are so many agents out there, and a lot of times it's just a matter of, hey, you know, this guy over here, he was having a conversation here. This networking event, he ran into somebody in his 70s that is you know an independent agent, and hey, he might be looking to move on, and so that's it it kind of happens all over the board. Um, but yeah, some sometimes it's just reaching out, cold outreach, you know it. It's um I I don't usually contact the people that are you know in their 30s and 40s and even 50s, because that's not I I mean I wouldn't if I were somebody that's uh even in my 50s looking to move on because if you build it right, it's it's really a great thing that you can continue to do. You know, I was talking to a guy a couple weeks ago, 78 years old, finally ready to hang it up. It's 78. And uh we were meeting with him, and he's like, you know what? I might still keep the office just as a place to get away from my wife occasionally.
SPEAKER_03And it's like smart man. All right.
SPEAKER_00Only 800 bucks a month, that's worth it. So um, you know. So yeah, it's all over the place.
SPEAKER_03That's funny. Um, I'm like, I'm all I'm all over the place. But back to like the acquisition side of stuff. You were talking about two to three times what you spend. Uh what are banks what are what are banks looking at as like are they looking at that two to three times and going, you know what, this is a great deal. I will finance X amount.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, a lot of times they like to see their ideal structure, if you will, is they like to finance 80% of it. And so in that two to three range, they're usually okay financing 80% of it. Another 10% coming from the buyer, and they normally like to see about a 10% earnout. So just making sure, especially in the commercial space, a lot of times there are some larger clients that make up a larger portion of the book. And so just a little bit of incentive to make sure that the seller is at least massaging that relationship over the you know next one to two years to make sure that that client those clients continue. Um, so that's that's where I see most lenders really, really comfortable. Obviously, on the lower end, they're you know, sometimes that number bumps up in terms of not 80% but 90-95%. But that's a typical lender. Um, there are other ways of financing these things sometimes, but I I haven't seen, you know, my friends outside of the insurance industry and MA, they they do all sorts of crazy stuff. It's like, um, you know what? That that's really cool. You guys get to do that. I don't see that flying in I've never seen it fly in in any of the deals that we've done.
SPEAKER_03Right. So you're saying out of pocket agents looking at 20%.
SPEAKER_01Right, yep. And and normally you can get that down 10, sometimes even 5%, if there's the the more concentrated the top 10 clients, the more it starts to make sense that an earnout is included in there. Just because the the seller understands, okay, all right, this is $200,000 in revenue, but fifty thousand dollars from the top ten clients. Well, I understand five of those top ten go away, this drops down significant for you. So they they understand it, they comprehend it. A lot of them are okay with that. So you're not normally thinking, all right, I gotta come up with $500,000 out of pocket or or what have you. Even $200,000, sometimes you you don't need to really come out of pocket with that, especially on these smaller ones.
SPEAKER_04It probably depends on the bank too.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_03Is do you find the sellers um more uh do they want to make sure that the buyers are legit because of those kind of um those kind of situations?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. And for us, the more we can establish that relationship with the seller, really the better. I mean, whenever possible we go and meet with them in person just because uh, you know, Zoom is great, it's fantastic, so at least I can see you're a real person, hopefully. Um, but it's another thing, especially in older generations, it's a totally different thing to sit down and whether or not it's coffee or lunch or just hit the office and have that conversation because you start to get a feel for who they are as a person and they get to Get a feel for who we are as people because you know what? It's especially in these situations where there's earnouts. Um, you know, we were talking to a gentleman earlier this summer that he got burned. He he did the earnout and he got some money up front, but he was doing a pretty hefty earnout. And you know what? They said, sorry, we're not gonna pay you. And he had to take him to court and get that money um as much as he could, but at the end of the day, he couldn't get all of it, and so he had to make sure that his non-compete was broken, because otherwise he was he was stuck, and he was he didn't have any other options, and so he had to make sure he could break that non-compete, get his clients back, reestablish himself in the industry, and so there's stories like that out there of people getting burned a hundred percent, and that's why for us the relationship, you know, not only from us to them, but them to us, is so important because for first of all, if we're gonna acquire somebody, we want to make sure that they're not trying to pull one over on us, sell it to us, establish something new, grab all the clients, resell that, but also that there's that trust established that okay, if there is an earnout, especially that you guys, you know how to run this thing, so you're gonna take care of the clients, you're gonna make sure that the revenue stays on, and so that earnout is is gonna be possible, um, but also that you're gonna pay it at the end of the day, because that is that's a it can be a gamble. And you know what the reality is, not everybody is gonna come through with their word at the end of the day. It's important to do everything you can up front to make sure that you vetted them.
SPEAKER_04So I'm you've had it you've had plenty of these meetings now at this point, I think, right? Or or at least a fair amount. Yeah. Um, I'm curious if you have any uh like little little secret questions you you ask to try to gauge what kind of values the person has and and you know be able to can I trust this person?
SPEAKER_01Right? A lot of it when we're just we're just chatting about other things. I mean, it's it's not even necessarily the conversations around the business or about insurance or anything like that, but you get to understand somebody when you start to hear about you know everything outside of the business. And then when it comes to the business side, you know, there's little things about all right, really get them to expand on what they're doing after the fact. And so there was one that we we backed out of after that initial conversation just because he was very clear that it was gonna be tight after he sold the agency, and so he's probably gonna have to go back and work, and he doesn't know anything besides insurance, so he's gonna go back and work in insurance, and there was just this it was rubbing us the wrong way in terms of how he was approaching it, and so those I I don't have a magic question. I wish it did. I'll keep on working on it. Um, but it I think it's like as you get to know a client, when you get to know that client, you get to understand them, their situation, and you can kind of gauge early on. Okay, is this gonna be a good client? Is this gonna be a client with a lot of claims? Is this gonna be a client that never pays their bills? You know, all those things you can normally have a hunch about early on, and uh, you know, part of it's probably a little bit of repetition in those situations, but also we're all people that just build relationships for a business, and so we're pretty good at tuning into people most of the time.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, that's great. Are you bullish on California? Because the, I mean, dude, our commissioners nuts out here. Did you hear about the misappropriating funds? Yeah, all that stuff. Yeah, then our governor, right? Like, like this is just banana. So, like, what do you feel about since you're in California and Texas? What do you feel like about California?
SPEAKER_01Um, you know, I I've had conversations on both ends of the spectrum, and it's really, really difficult to understand what direction it's gonna go. And I I think they need to come to the table, have a heart to heart, and talk about what the reality is. Because the reality is the carrier's exit, what does that do to the insurance market? It tanks the insurance market. Everything's going to ENS, a lot of it on the home side of things is already heading that direction. More things on the commercial side are heading that direction, and there's more flexibility in the ENS market, but also with that comes a lot more cost. And so we're just, in my opinion, um at this really interesting inflection point, and I just really, really hope that uh the the powers that be and the right people are at the table having right, honest conversations about what it's gonna take. And as I've been talking to carriers over the past 12 months, they're more optimistic about the direction things are going, but then again, general liability is seeing an overall um you know combined ratio well owned into the 120s, workers comp is starting to become a hard market again, and homeowners was heading in the right direction, and we had the Palisade fires, and so that kind of changed that conversation, so it's it's really difficult to see, and what I've been telling so many clients is historically things have been this way, but I think we're in uncharted territory, which is very unnerving to be in. Um, but also there's so many businesses, so many uh families that rely on our guidance, and so you know, like you staying on top of things, what is happening, it's it's really important because everybody else needs our guidance. You know, we we we really need to make sure that we're yeah, an advocate for them at the end of the day.
SPEAKER_03100% yeah, and it's almost like I mean it's like one of those things like when things are difficult, like the obstacle is the way, right? Like so it's like when things are difficult, I like being in difficult situations because it makes most people crumble, so your competition is less, you know, you have less competition. But then again, the the future of it is uh it gets a little scary. But I don't know, man. Uh you know, some crazy stuff happened. It's I mean, on the if you're a part of a captive, you get hosed, right? When you're when you're independent in these kind of situations, it's it's a different story. So cool, man. Like final question for you. Thank you, A, thank you so much for not like just crazy knowledge and information. Um and I love I love that you made this leap and and you're just it's like what you were able to do in a year and a half is is so cool. Um where what what are you really excited about in this next year? Uh with the technology, the the business in general, uh what do you see is like the this is our homing beacon?
SPEAKER_04You can't say chat GBT six.
SPEAKER_01No, no. Um you know there's you kind of mentioned when you were talking about those difficult situations and what that does. And so for me, whether or not it's the insurance marketplace or with AI, there's such a significant change that we're gonna be going through over the next one, two, five years. Um, I was I was at a presentation where somebody laid out what they think is gonna happen with AI over the next five years. I was like, that is mind-blowing. And he's like, we're probably being conservative with that time estimate. Um, but at the same time, that breeds obstacles, which breeds opportunity. And so whether or not it's on that side of things, or we really just see um a massive opportunity to provide a really good option for those that are looking to exit, move on um in the insurance world from an MA point of view. Um, you know, there's there's just so much uncertainty, but at the same time, that breeds opportunity. And yeah, super excited about it.
SPEAKER_03That's awesome. Nathan, thank you so much. Uh how can your services, how can people get a hold of you?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, check us out, utopiaris.com. Uh find me on LinkedIn and uh happy to connect.
SPEAKER_04Awesome. Thank you, Nathan. Yeah, thanks, guys.
SPEAKER_03Appreciate it.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman