The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Rudy Surovick’s Advice for Insurance Agents Facing Tough Times
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
Starbucks.
SPEAKER_00Ooh, uh STP. So uh and it was a great concert. Started two hours late. There's uh someone overdosed on the plane. So it was awesome. It was awesome. So it was in our little hometown, Erie, Pennsylvania.
SPEAKER_01That's awesome.
SPEAKER_00What tour? I have no idea. I was like 15, 16. I am not a music buff by any means. Uh my boys rag on me all the time because my favorite band is Train. Pat Monaghan's from Erie, Pennsylvania as well. Oh, wow.
SPEAKER_03That's awesome.
SPEAKER_02That is awesome. I love Train. Yes, good band. That's awesome. Well, thank you for sharing that. And for the millennials that are listening, STP is Stone Temple Pilots.
SPEAKER_00Welcome on. I bought a counterfeit shirt for 10 bucks on the street. It was great.
SPEAKER_02Huge win. It was awesome. Those concert uh t-shirts have remained at about 30 bucks for a very long time.
SPEAKER_00Right. Money was tight back then.
SPEAKER_01One of the bands I played in back in the 90s was able, we opened for STP Vertical Horizon nine days on the on the Ford tour. And in Texas, it was like during the summertime, we drove straight shot from California to Texas in our underwear because the van didn't have AC. Played the show and then drove back. Did you drive back in your underwear? Um you know what is right after the show. Um Vertical Horizon in nine days. Yeah. Uh we it was right after the show, so we drove back that night. So maybe in the underwear. Maybe. But it wasn't that hot at night. Well to compare with the day.
SPEAKER_02Well, uh Rudy, you're a you're a power agent. And uh we'd love to hear how how'd you get to where you are um with the company you're with and and and you know w who is Rudy?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so um Rudy's story. Well, you know, I I got the N D hat on because I figured you'd look at that. You know, like bring back memories from the uh the movie. So um, but true story back in high school, I was a below average athlete, but I started every basketball game my senior year, and uh there was nothing better than hearing people just chant Rudy, Rudy, Rudy. So uh but uh fast forward, I moved my, you know, we um I worked for an independent agency for I think 13 years. Um I got into computer consulting right out of college, had a degree in MIS, uh, did that for about a year or so. Um the guy I was working for, um doing consulting a lot, and it was one of our clients, offered me a job in insurance. I said, I have no idea what it is, read the book uh on the plane for a honeymoon. Uh wife was excited about that, and um he offered me a job. Um, so I ended up going in insurance, you know, started doing commercial insurance sales, did that for about I don't know, four or five years and got promoted to uh sales manager. Um I managed our New York uh operations. Uh we had like five or six offices western New York, Buffalo, that area. Um, and then we also had um five or six agencies in Pennsylvania that I helped out manage on the producer side. Um so huge, you know, huge operation, like 85 million in premium when I left. Um great relationship with the guys there. Um I still visit the guys all the time. And um, but I had a midlife crisis, told my wife I wanted to buy an agency, moved from Erie, Pennsylvania to Atlanta, Georgia, packed up at the time our four kids, uh, had a bunch of relationships with trucking companies, so we everything got loaded into a semi um and moved to Atlanta, Georgia. My sister-in-law lived there, so I bought an agency there. Um, first one was uh you know just under 3 million in premium uh when I bought it, and then um been with uh doing the captive gig ever since. Crazy, man. What what ages were your kids at that time? Uh so uh I'm trying to remember correctly. So I think it was one uh must have been like one, four, seven, then nine. I got five kids, man. I'm like you. So I got right now I got I got a three, a five-year-old, an eight-year-old, uh 11-year-old, and a 13-year-old. And when I go to the prescription counter and they ask for the kid's birthday, I go, uh uh, and they look at me like I'm like, I'm I got five kids. Just give me a second here, okay? Right.
SPEAKER_01I had the same exact experience getting um medication. I couldn't remember my my daughter's birthday. I just had her last year, and we got so many kids, I couldn't remember the exact date. I mean, I I didn't sleep, so yeah.
SPEAKER_00So we have a picture of um, you know, we had all kinds of relationships here in in Pennsylvania, and uh so I had a you know semi-loaded, I got that for like two grand for them to ship it down for you know, I had no money at the time. You know, like it was like, you know, I sold my house, I was building a house down there. Uh I didn't know if the the sale was gonna go through. It was just a crazy time in our life. So I have a picture of all of our kids in these giant cardboard box. It was used for uh plastic, um, like a plastic manufacturer, and they hold all the different you know, plastic component parts. But the kids are sitting in there, I'm like, hey, packing up my kids, getting them on the trucks.
SPEAKER_01That's awesome. What did your what did your wife think?
SPEAKER_00Uh so you know, we were it was a perfect solution. It was like we were moving right next to my sister-in-law, we're gonna be a mile away. But we lived in our own our own community here in Pennsylvania, um, you know, forever. And she, you know, when we got there, um, you know, we were we made it work, and then um eventually, you know, we we ended up spending we spend most of our time in Pennsylvania now. Um so we go back and forth between Georgia and Pennsylvania, but most of it's in Pennsylvania.
SPEAKER_01And and you're with a captive now, right? Yes, sir. So what was that like, the transition?
SPEAKER_00You know, believe it or not, um the captive portion of it uh was pretty daunting because when you go from the independent side, you have access to 70 or 80 carriers, you can put that one customer with you know any of your 15 personalized carrier, you can write everything, you can do everything you want, right? You go to the captive world, it's like you got one guy, right? You know, you got one player, and you're like, well, how am I gonna make this work? And uh so for a while there um in 2016 at Captive, I was with me, and they took massive rate increases um in Georgia, and it became a huge, huge issue because I was looking at 25 or 50 percent rate increases, and my wife's like you know, my wife's like, why did we do this? You know, you're you're miserable. Yeah, she's like, you are absolutely miserable. And it, you know, so I always use that you know, scenario. I said, okay, well, I'm gonna make this work. So I gotta quote 10 customers to write one. Okay. I used to write, I used to quote one customer with 10 different carriers. And you know, I listened to your uh recently the um your gentleman that you had on that did the uh commercial raider. Um yeah, yeah. So I mean we had easy links and all of the raiders back in the day, and but at the end of each one of those, there was always one piece of information that was missing, so you had to go back and hit two or three carriers. So it was always, you know, you were spending an additional amount of time. So, you know, I'd rather have those build up my database, right? You know, so um, so once I did that, and then um, you know, we briefly talked, Craig, via message, and um I think Jason, we even chatted before. I got in direct mail, and um for me it's been great. Um, you know, mortgage referrals and direct mail, uh, our lead product for us is homes. So it all depends on where you're at. You guys know that?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Which bait are you gonna fish with? Exactly. So you're pretty, I would say you're pretty uh narrow and deep with um with the that lead source, right?
SPEAKER_00Oh yeah. I mean, I um I get to, I mean, I mail out for like 12 other agents um right now. And you know, we have a little sweatshop at the office that we call. Um, you know, so we're basically um, you know, and I bought all the equipment and I don't make very much money off of it, honestly. I just use it to pay for my postage, is what I'm doing. Um, I'm not really trying to get rich off of it. And um I keep uh another funny story is I had a guy that uh worked for me. Um he left um for sports management to go out to Utah. Um he came back and at the time I didn't have my ECP, so I just didn't have a spot for him. So he wanted to come work, you know, for the the company that we represent, and I got him a job with another agent. And but he works out of my office. So his wife works there running my mailroom. He works in my office, not for me, but for another agent. And I'm really big in that. Um, you know, working with other agencies to really try to, you know, pull our resources, you know, because you know we all employ like 10 or 11 people, but none of us can really spend the kind of money you need to to really market or you know find different tactics that actually work without you know sharing that cost.
SPEAKER_01Yep. And and I love that because you you went in hard on um on mail, which you don't hear a lot of these days. And I don't think that there's any wrong way, like whatever works in your market, but you went deep on it. I think a lot of people they dabble in this and that and the other thing. I mean, who knows where your ROI is coming from? And I'll uh if you're doing five different things, I I tell everybody this like if you're doing five different things, there's no way to figure out which one's working and which one's not. So it's like causing such a headache.
SPEAKER_00And when we were in the commercial world, we only did uh X stating off of uh work comp mods. So we've pretty much focused on work comp mods, and you could look at different states and you could pull up the work comp mod, figure out the X state, call the prospective client and tell them, hey, look, your mod went up from you know 0.76 to 1.2. Did your agent tell you you're gonna have a 54% rate increase? And and they would be like, oh no, we didn't they didn't, and and that's how we got on the door. So, you know, when you can take that and you can bring that over and figure out, okay, well, what how does that relate? Well, X dating on homeowners, right? You know, for me, you know, it's like okay, you know, we go with different companies that put you know supply us data that can get us the X dates, and then we can actually find out, you know, close to when they're an OLUS. And insurance is 100% timing, right? 100% time.
SPEAKER_03Yep.
SPEAKER_00You know, like you think about it, why does that customer call you? They call you because they had a bad claims experience, they had their rate go up, their agent's a jerk, you name it. It's all about timing.
SPEAKER_02Yep. So you're able to look at that with that data, know when their homeowners is gonna come up. Can you even further slice it and look at if whether or not that company's gonna have a rate increase? Do you go that far down in the weeds?
SPEAKER_00So we used to um use the data that our you know our region uh supplied us um for rate increases, and then our for some reason our region quit doing that. And I would just basically use our database of uh current customers that we would just do um re-quoting. And I like to call our re-quote process selective requoting. Okay and so what we would do is we would X date based off of when claims were gonna fall off, when um when uh someone was aging to the perfect age, you know, so we selectively re-quote based off of coming up, like our company would be 100% clean, their company would still be dirty. Two weeks from now, we might not have the best price, but right now we have the best price before their renewal comes up, right? So when we can time that 100% perfectly, we're gonna win.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. And then uh but but then also it is a numbers game. So to get too too narrow and targeted may be counterproductive because what you have to you're in the 0.25 to 1% open rate now with mail, right?
SPEAKER_00Uh way less than that. I mean, uh yeah. I mean, you're looking at um I'm seeing about 0.6 of a percent that we're actually getting uh open rate. Okay, you know, or response rate, you know, more so than open rate. So when you're looking at that numbers, you're still I don't focus on you know color or anything on the mail piece. I just do black and white, keep the cost as low as possible, and try to double my output instead of spending a ton of money on the actual mailer.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. So you went all in. You bought the the equipment, you bought the cost yeah.
SPEAKER_00I guess. I don't know. I mean yeah, I I also think about it as like, man, if I stop this, I have all the equipment here. Um and if I stop mail, then what where am I at, right? You know, and I I think about it all the time. It's like, you know, hey, what happens when the direct mail dries up? You know, like it already did. Yeah, you know, I mean it's you you think about it, but maybe the direct mail is the new internet 3.0, you know, so you know, yeah, you know, because you know, everybody's buying live transfers, right? You know, everybody's doing data leads and telemarketing, or you know, a lot of people are. Um, so what really works? And I looked at it from a standpoint too of if I had three or four people just dialing that were licensed and they make 200 dials a day or 300 dials a day, what am I really paying them to do?
SPEAKER_03Right.
SPEAKER_00Right? You know, I'm paying someone $20, $25 an hour, $30 an hour, whatever it ends up being, to dial a phone number and hopefully get somebody on the phone.
SPEAKER_02We were just talking about that on this uh this webinar we just did. And it's like it's having the right places or the right people in the right places paying the right amount for their value, right? Exactly. Yeah, having somebody make $15 an hour to make cold calls is the absolute wrong spot. And in addition, you're burning out a $15 an hour asset, right? Because our our staff are our most expensive asset. And it costs, I mean, just the $15 an hour is one thing, but what about all of the training costs associated with interviewing, your time spent, the whole thing, right? It's it's tens of thousands of dollars. So you do not put them on there when there's a there's an alternative, you know, that you can get them for very, very less expensive than that.
SPEAKER_00Exactly. Yeah, and so you look at it from that standpoint too, is that you know, your work environment. So a lot of people want to come work for me. Um, true story. Uh I recently, last week and a half, I get a text message from a lady that left me. She's having her own issues, um, needed to work from home two or three days. I don't offer work from home. I have one individual that works from home. I just I personally work from home. I know the challenges that happen, and I want you to be at the office. So she called me and said, Hey, can I come back to work for you? She said the job I took isn't what they told me I'm making 200 dials a day. I said, I'm sorry, I just don't have that opportunity right now. You know, if something changes, you know, I'd I'd love for you to come back. Last week I had to let somebody go because of attendance. The the guy when I'm letting go tells me, he said, Bruy, I I I no lie, he says this is the best job I've had in 25 years. And I said, uh, hey, you said you were great. And I said, but you need to be at work and I can't have this. I said, get your life straightened out, give me a call in a year, and we'll pop again. You know, so just leave the door open, right? You know?
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Well, and create that that reputation too. You know, if you have the reputation of being Darth Vader and creating a crappy culture when you're lifting them up by their neck, uh, you know, nobody wants to be there.
SPEAKER_00I'm Dart Darth Vader at home. I can't get Darth Vader at work, you know.
SPEAKER_02That's true. With five of them, you're just live constantly.
SPEAKER_00That's right.
SPEAKER_01It's like, oh a teenager and what's the youngest?
SPEAKER_00Three. She's actually she she'll be three on St. Patrick's Day. So I kind of uh have a little thing where I told my wife, I was like, damn, why did we have a kid on St. Patrick's Day? When she gets older, this is gonna be trouble, you know.
SPEAKER_03So it's true.
SPEAKER_00Okay.
SPEAKER_02So it hasn't always been rainbows and unicorns. What what have been some of the really tough things that you've had to navigate through and four-leaf clovers?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, for sure. That's right. Well, you know, Lucky Charms now does have the unicorns with the four-leaf clovers, so you can have that every morning to start your day. So it is it is her favorite cereal, too. So um, but no, I mean, some of the biggest challenges were um, you know, moving, you know, 800 miles away. You know, you always have that thing. You go to these training courses, or you know, the region wants you to go through training and um they want you to bring your list 100. And I I go to them and said, hey, I give you list 100, but there's nobody I can quote in this entire state. I know two people, whatever it is. I said, but I tell you what, I'm gonna succeed, you know, whatever it is. It's okay, just fill it out with sales genius. So, you know, like when you're moved that far away and you start up, there are some challenges, um, but uh that rate increase that you know we didn't anticipate, no lie. I was literally selling life insurance policies to pay my mortgage. Um, you know, at that point, you know, we moved, we built a house, and you know, you guys know how it is with a loan with your agency. It's I mean, you you know, everyone thinks you have a decent sized agency and you know life's great. No, I mean it it's it's really difficult um to actually you know see it through. And then you get to the point where you see it through and things are starting to go good, and then you decide, hey, I need to scale this up. And when you start scaling things up, you better have you know be able to see in that crystal ball what you need, you know, like service people, and and um you know, you look at it from that standpoint is that you know, when you bring somebody on, how do they mesh with everybody? Um all of that's all of that, all of that basically has that impact on you. But my biggest struggles honestly were you know 2016 having a rate increase, not worrying about you know being able to write new business and looking back at it, it was the best thing that ever happened because it cleaned my book of a lot of uh accounts that I probably didn't want. Uh when I took that book over, the retention was 81%. It dropped down to 78% during that period. And now we sit at 89% uh return.
SPEAKER_01Nice.
SPEAKER_00So, and it's all staff. I mean, it's not me. I mean, I I really don't do anything all day, Ryan will tell you that. But um, for the most part, you know, it we just looked at it from the standpoint of, you know, we just took a proactive stance with renewals, and um we to this day we do that as well.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and there's always risk jumping at an opportunity, right? You saw the opportunity, you had the vision, and then shit fell apart. And and it's like, okay, well, now I have a challenge and I gotta figure it out. And when when the stakes get raised where it's like, if I if I don't sell this, I don't eat, all of a sudden you're at DEF CON 5 and you make it happen. You know, I think some of the some of the darkest times in in my business career were when it was like, well, shit, do I eat? Or do you know what do I do? I mean, you figure it out. Exactly.
SPEAKER_01Real fast. I think a lot of agents probably feel like that. Um we've talked a lot that feel like that right now. I mean, what are some pieces of advice you just give them specific? Going through that, what would you have wanted to hear at that time now being on the other side?
SPEAKER_00Well, luckily for me, I mean, I was on the side where I managed 11 locations. I knew what was going on in the insurance. I had that insurance background, right? Um so at some point, you have to spend money you don't have, right? I mean, Jason, you know that, and Craig, you know that. But you have to time that perfectly, right? So if you're spending money in a time where you're not at the most competitive point for whatever company you represent, you're wasting money. And it doesn't have to be super competitive. You just have to be able to win, what, seven or eight percent of the time, whatever it may be. But when you're at that moment, you have two options. You either have to basically thin out and basically run lean and mean, or you have to basically, I would say get the marketing down first, right? You you get the marketing down, everything else will fall into place. So you have to be able to take that risk to basically spend the money on the marketing when you know that you're competitive. Sure.
SPEAKER_02And a lot of these cars, I mean, you can use a line of credit, you can use a credit card, whatever. I mean, I I prefer the the Amex because I get all these points. But I mean, dude, uh if you once you use it and they see you paying this thing, they'll give you unlimited money. You know, like way more than you need for marketing. So, you know, $150,000 limit, you're not spending that, right? Right. So nobody's maybe Jay. But but the rest of us of us peons, you know, we can get by on a $25,000, $50,000 thing and we have 60 days. Like we have to get clever. I saw somebody post in one of the Facebook groups that um I don't know who it was, some lender is sending out things saying, hey, we'll loan against your TPP. And it's like they were insulted by that. I'm like, what do you mean? That's an opportunity. You can borrow, you can leverage your business to get cash because that cash in your business is worth nothing. Who cares? Right. Right? And you know what? If it doesn't work and and everything falls apart, it's a business, you're done. You know, get out. But you know, so there isn't it's not the end of the world if it fails, right? There's exactly but it's the end of the world if you cut expenses and think that all that down the road something's gonna change, because it's not, right?
SPEAKER_00And for me too, the other thing that helped out a lot tremendously was the power of the renewal. I mean, you don't really realize it until you start forecasting that renewal and what kind of impact that'll have for your agency, because you can spend money you don't have, right? Because you know you're gonna have it in six months. And you know, any size agency you look at it, you know, it it basically you can make things work. Uh, I'm confident, right? Um, you know, the one of the things in the captive world that was beneficial for me was, and and I didn't even realize it at the time, but if you go in the captive world and you're in one of those bigger cities, what happens when someone moves to your city? They usually decide between one of the three big players, right? And they're they're not going to Rudy Sorovic's insurance agency, you know, because who the hell's Rudy Sorovic, right? You know, so you know, if you had a really cool name, maybe it would make a difference, but they're not buying from that name, right? Especially on the personal line side. On the personal line side, I it's very hard to grow very rapidly unless you're marketing tremendously. If you're on the commercial side, it's a different world. Um, you can grow by you know making you know introductions and things like that, but to grow rapidly in you know, tenfold or 10x, whatever you want to say, you really have to market.
SPEAKER_02You have to inject activity into the agency. And whether it's mailers, whether it's leads, whether it's calls, whatever, you've got to do something. Because compressing those expenses, it's it it does it's not enough. Like, oh, I'm gonna move to a smaller place. Great, you save 500 bucks. Who cares? Right? You need to spend at the level that's gonna generate an ROI. And there's lots of proven things. I mean, you have an equation, right? It's 0.6. You're gonna get calls on 0.6. So you can figure out very simply if I suspend 10k and my cost is 50 cents, whatever. I can do it myself. I could call Rudy, I could have him do it, whatever, but you're gonna get a return on it, right? Exactly, 100%.
SPEAKER_00And you know, you guys you guys know the math. I mean, it ends up for me, it's four to five thousand dollars in spend per salesperson, true salesperson in my agency. That'll generate roughly 30 to 40,000 in premium. And you have to know those numbers going into it. And when I opened up Scratch, or I actually purchased smaller than 1.5, um, got the benefit of going full scratch in May, I knew I was gonna succeed, you know, just based off of the numbers. Um and when you know that it's a pretty good feeling, right? You know, when you know it's it's it's and you don't freak out.
SPEAKER_02You know, you're not freaked out because you don't get the immediate result. The mailer's a couple months, right? To see the result.
SPEAKER_00It's exactly right. And once you're in it, there's just such a long tail on it, people don't realize it. We still have people that in one of my offices, they walk in six months after they receive the mailer and say, hey, here's this mailer quote. Um, we're interested in the quote. And you know, we can say, Oh, that's great, but you know, we don't really identify that as being six months, you know, it's just my staff say, Hey, guess what? You know, someone came six months ago, you know, they got a mailer six months ago, and and uh and I I started putting a picture of my family on there. My wife still doesn't know it, but I put a picture of my family. You know, get that sympathy, you know, sympathy, man. This guy's got five kids. Let's give this guy a call and see if you know I think I got better response on it, tell you the truth.
SPEAKER_02Rudy and the orphanage. That's right.
SPEAKER_01Because you're a real dude, like it's a real person, right? Yeah. Like you got a family, like, like it's it's a huge and I we always say that when in the office, like talk talk about your story, like the agents, like tell them about your story. You know what I mean?
SPEAKER_02Like the big the big brand is the hook, right? It gives some visibility, but then it's it's gotta be differentiated by you know, who are you? Yeah, who are you and kind of real people.
SPEAKER_00What do you offer? You know, what's different, you know, than that guy down the street, you know, and yeah, and most of the time it's it's the people you have, right? So if they can call Sally or Timmy or whoever it is and talk to them and they can get a real life person on the phone that understands what they're going through, they're more likely to buy from you. Yeah, you know, and I I kind of laugh at it because my wife says, Well, why don't you still sell? I said, Honey, I said, I hired people to do things, right? And one of them is to sell insurance policies. And she goes, Well, every day that they don't sell a policy, you're really upset. And I said, Well, I understand that. And it it's it's all these metrics, you know, like you know, you go to bed at night and you know when you wake up, you're gonna look at that metric and say, Okay, well, it it didn't move that notch enough, right? And then each month that metric resets, right? And then every year that metric resets. And you know, eventually the metric no longer becomes what's on that computer screen, it becomes your bank account, right? Because ultimately, you know, you're doing that for your family so your kids can go to college or whatever it may be. Um, but you know, we're all driven by metrics, unfortunately, right?
SPEAKER_02Yeah. But but also the flip side of it is it's it's beautiful because it's there. We're not guessing. You don't have to guess. That's right, right? I mean, you don't have to guess, you don't have to reinvent the the wheel. Like if somebody wants to do a mailer, they can ask you, and you could either say yes or no or whatever, but but they can get it done. Or you do, I I I'm sure you would tell somebody how to do it if they wanted, right? Like so 100%, yeah. It doesn't so it doesn't matter. I mean, at the end of the day, the the opportunity to to have the knowledge to do it is there. Like I did I do leads, and you know, it's it's a telemarketer, producer sale, right? And and I didn't have to reinvent it. Jason was doing it. He he spent the 200k to figure out how to do it. That's right. I'm like, hey, look, you know, thank you. And and he and he tells me, right? So it's pick pick a lane and stay in that lane. You know, two months in, I was freaking out. I've talked about a million times, but I'm I'm here here I am spending 15k. And we wrote, oh, we wrote 5,000 in premium. What's what that doesn't work? And then the next month it's a little bit more, it starts creeping up, and then boom, the machine's going. It's like a big train that just starts to take off, and but when it gets momentum, it's going, you know?
SPEAKER_00Right. And you know, the the funny thing about it is too is that you can offset some of the spend by having top-notch producers, right? So if you have a top-notch producer, they can go and they can go, and and and you're spending 3,000 and they're producing 50 or 60,000, right? But guess what happens? When that person leaves, right? Then you're like, oh, what happened? Um, you know, because I was spending like two grand a month on marketing and writing roughly 70,000 in premium before before I did any marketing. And it was because I had a really strong closer and she was phenomenal. I mean, she did great. But when she left, I said, I'm never gonna go through this again. And so I all made it about marketing, 100% about marketing, and training my staff on how to close deals. And once we did those two things, I'm confident today, I love my staff, but if one leaves, I think we won't lose any, you know, any actual, you know, we're not gonna have a down month just because we lost one person, right?
SPEAKER_02And you're always looking, right? Always looking.
SPEAKER_00Always looking, yeah. I just hired a girl, she she she brought a resume into the office. I never knew it, but I interviewed her. She had experience with you know that the company that has that red in it that we're competitors against. And so I can't so yeah, she but she was bilingual. Um, I have huge need for that in my area, seven years experience. Asked her where she dropped her resume off. Um, she said two or three other agencies down the road. I made the offer five minutes later and had her in my office uh two days later. Started sales. Exactly. Good salesperson. That's right. And you know, and I said I'm not gonna let this one get away. I didn't need a person, but I said, you know what, I'm gonna make this work, and we did. So um, you know, and my thing is I'd rather have more marketing and less people because I can always offset the people with other staff in my office too. Because I have a couple service people that could fill in for sales. Um, but I'd rather spend the money on marketing. Because guess what? If you're getting fed people that call in that want leads or want insurance, then you're more likely wanting to pick up that phone because you know what's gonna happen, right?
SPEAKER_01But I was gonna say there's a few questions that um in the in the group that people are are curious about. Uh we'll we'll go with the top one, which is what is your best marketing technique? Could you just real quickly go over um what your process is on that, if you don't mind?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so you know, we do direct mail and we do it 100% based off of targeting uh extates um through a three or four different vendors. Um, and basically um we do it twice a week in my office. It's a hundred percent bulk mail. Um, my my goal is to get out more, spend less on the actual materials in it. People are looking for the lowest price quote that's out there.
SPEAKER_01And that's it. So you what is that what does that uh postcard look like?
SPEAKER_00It's actually a uh we tried postcards. I spent about 10 grand and got two calls off of it. So that was a bad investment. So it's actually a full-fledged quote, uh homeowners, with uh a cover letter that is uh talks about public records. So just basically saying that, hey, you know, we got this information from public record, send it out, um, good responses on it.
SPEAKER_02So you eliminated the creep creepiness factor.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, exactly. So that's what it's all about. It's try to take away that one, where did you get that information? And we have a lot of success off of that.
SPEAKER_02Did you see a tick up when you did that?
SPEAKER_00I've always done that. Actually, believe it or not, for the last three years, we've always done that. Um, one of the vendors recommended it, so we actually do that with every vendor we use.
SPEAKER_01That's awesome. And how much does it cost to send out a letter for you?
SPEAKER_00So uh basically, if you were to say, Jason, you know, Rudy, can I sit can you send them out for me? It's 43 cents a mailer. Um that's all everything in. Um so that's what it basically costs.
SPEAKER_01And what percentage close?
SPEAKER_00Percentage close. Okay, so 2018 we were around like 22 percent, 2019, 16, and 2020 close to 12 percent. So why is that happening, Craig?
SPEAKER_02Why is it dropping? Yeah, um, because you're spending more and you so you have a higher volume? No, uh, saturated, saturate, more people are doing it.
SPEAKER_00Exactly. So there's two things that are happening. So basically, I'm hitting the same people over, but I'm also coming again against 12 other agents that we all represent the same company because you know when they get that mailer in, it's all a timing. So who determines on what time they open up that mail? So now I come out and say, Man, I'm still hitting on direct mail, and we get all these agents that are excited because Craig and Jason are the insurance dudes, they're pimping me, and everything's good, right? So now we got five more players in the market, right? So yeah.
SPEAKER_02But he who remains consistent will win too, right? Exactly. Exactly. You're right. Rudy, thank you so much for yeah.
SPEAKER_00Well, I gotta I gotta I gotta congrat I gotta congratulate you, bro.
SPEAKER_01Oh, thank you. Best in company company, Mr.
SPEAKER_00Jason. I I actually should be taking pointers right now, Craig. What do you think?
SPEAKER_02Uh yeah, he knows what he's doing if you want to get into the into the leads, but you have your lane. I don't know, man. It's working. It works.
SPEAKER_00That's the that's the best thing, actually, honestly. You know, two best things is that you know, working with other agents that are so open, you know. I've never been with a company that have been as open as you know, the company that we work with. Uh, it's really good. And then the second thing is we can all do it a hundred different ways and still get results, right? You know, right? It doesn't matter.
SPEAKER_02So track and measure and and don't give up after a week. I mean, yeah.
SPEAKER_00So you guys gonna be in Vegas? Yes, yes, someone has to go up on stage, man. Yes, yeah.
SPEAKER_01Are you gonna rock an insurance dude's jacket?
SPEAKER_00Are you gonna rock the jeans or are you gonna go full-fledged, you know, five-piece suit tucks? What's what's it gonna be, man? I want to I want to know the gear.
SPEAKER_01Come on. Like a smooth dog suit with insurance dudes all over it. I want to do jeans so bad. I'm not a suit guy. It's been done.
SPEAKER_00It's been done, man, every time. So I might do it. Do it, man.
SPEAKER_02Well, Rudy, no time. How how could somebody get in in touch with you with you if they uh wanted to have mailers sent or if you're even taking people?
SPEAKER_00Uh in the show notes or whatever, why don't we we'll just put uh Rudy at OakhillINS.com. Okay. So you you have that email too, I think, Craig.
SPEAKER_02So I do. I do. Rudy at OakhillINS.com.
SPEAKER_00You know why that's Oak Hill Insurance? Yes, that's the that's the street address of my agency, man. That's I'm still creative.
SPEAKER_02So hey, that's an awesome name. You can send Rudy a a letter in the mail if you like. And he will open it. That's right. You'll get a hundred percent open rate. There you go, man.
SPEAKER_01Thanks for all you do. Thank you. Have a good one.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman