The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Escaping the Handcuffs: Gensler's Journey from Captive to Independent Insurance Success
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
Boom.
unknownBoom.
SPEAKER_01Boom. How are you doing? Is it Gensler? Gensler.
SPEAKER_03Gensler. Gensler. Gensler.
SPEAKER_01Oh, Gensler. Yeah. Way to go, Craig. I followed his lead.
SPEAKER_03And I get it wrong every time. Some people try to put an I in there, but it's really an E, so it's Gen.
SPEAKER_02Gens.
SPEAKER_03But it's something I've dealt with my whole life. So Yeah, same.
SPEAKER_02I still answer to it. Yeah. I've answered a much worse. Right. So it's a good thing.
SPEAKER_00I am not going to be able to do it. I am 8. We are HR.
SPEAKER_02Well, welcome, man. It's great to have you on the show. And uh we'll start with what we always start with, which is what was the first concert that you went to?
SPEAKER_03Lollapalooza 95. Oh man, that's a good one. So who's the headliner? Yeah. Metallico's headliner.
SPEAKER_02Ah. Good. Was that the third one? Fourth? I went to one. Lollapalooza one.
SPEAKER_03I don't remember which one it was. I was just so jacked that I got to go to a concert.
SPEAKER_02I can remember a lot of the band. So at La La Palooza 1, the headliner was Jane's addiction, and we were in the front row. Right. Which was incredible. And he Perry jumped out into the thing. We were holding him up. Like it was Susie and the Banshees, Body Count. Remember Ice T or Body Count?
SPEAKER_03Yeah. Yeah. Oh man, you're that's way back machine.
SPEAKER_02It was crazy. Yeah, it was really good. So, and you know what? It might have been in the 80s, actually, or 90. I don't know. Who played number three besides Metallica?
SPEAKER_03Uh, see, there was um Soundgarden was there. Oh wow. Oh man, drawing a blank now that I'm on screen.
SPEAKER_02It's okay.
SPEAKER_03But it was crazy.
unknownYeah. Yeah.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. Because that's what we did in high school.
SPEAKER_02That's what you're folks that don't know who you are, Travis, why don't you give a little background, talk about how you got in the insurance business and and that and what you're doing now?
SPEAKER_03I started just like everybody else by accident. I actually had nothing to do. I just came off of a bad deal with a marketing franchise and I needed something that was consistent. And so I was like, you know what? I used to mow yards for a guy up the street that uh was an agent, and he always seemed to do pretty well. So, you know, why don't I do that thing since he made some decent cash at the he wasn't hurting ever no, and so I was like, yep, let's look into it. And I actually started out as a farmer's agent right after Zurich bottom. Because growing up, I had no idea it was all state farmers, state farm. I had no idea how big the insurance industry was. So started with farmers and from there made a few decisions, ended up being independent a couple years later just because of uh some things that I couldn't do that I wanted to do. And fast forward 10 years later, here I am still on the independent side. Love and life.
SPEAKER_01That is awesome. So so tell us uh what were some of those things, or just mainly tell us the story of the journey with those things and then how it's different.
SPEAKER_03Well, you know, when you get started, you know, they always have you start with your friends and family and start working down through your network, and then you start networking into, you know, other centers of influences, and you know, everybody runs through the same cycle. And I started getting into some upper middle class, higher net worth type of clientele, and and I started running into issues where the the company wasn't comfortable with the size of the account or the umbrella size, or just because the houses were, you know, two, three million type of situations. And and I was like, but these are good people. I want to take care of them. I couldn't. And so then I started, I was like, well, if I can't do this, then I'll go do some commercial. And then I realized they were even worse at commercial because they tell you they want to do commercial, yes, train you on commercial. They and then I ended up being the number uh this is this is hilarious, number 12 commercial writer in the state for that year for farmers in Missouri, and it's because I wrote 22 duplexes on a commercial policy.
SPEAKER_02What on one?
SPEAKER_03No, I broke them up into 12 because I had to meet my numbers.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_03Because you have to qualify and show them your producing numbers, and so I wrote it on this location, it was on this policy. I mean, that's how the game goes. Yes. And so somehow I was, you know, ranked top commercial producer, and I'm like, this is such a joke.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_03So it was right about 2010, 2011, we had a ton of tornadoes and stuff roll through the Midwest, and rate increases started going through the roof after I just spent two and a half years building uh what I thought was an amazing book. And with a captive, you know, company because I couldn't do anything outside. And so then I started seeing these things walk out the door because I couldn't compete at all. And I was like, two years of hard work just right out the door. And so I started paying attention to the cancellation requests that were coming in, and I was like, who are these companies? Because I grew up only knowing State Farm All State and farmers, and I was like, shoot, this is this is a bigger deal than I expected. And so started looking into it, and I was like, I need to be over there on the independent side just because of what I wanted to do. That was the best fit for me. So made my opted for early retirement with that company and uh made my plan and and moved on.
SPEAKER_01That's awesome.
SPEAKER_03That's where I am now.
SPEAKER_01Are you at your house right now? Is that your house?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, this is this is my office in the basement.
SPEAKER_01Nice. Yeah, you have an office outside the house?
SPEAKER_03We do. I downsized a couple years ago because paying for office space just seemed kind of dumb to me. And I noticed there was people just sitting in their office playing on their phone, and I was like, why am I paying for office space for you to just sit there? So you don't have an office now. Go out and sell something.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_03Got rid of the office I work from home most of the time now, and I just go visit the office when I have to. And I just designed our agency to be mobile so we can do business anywhere. I don't have to be tied down. Everything's everything's on the cloud.
SPEAKER_01Love it. What do you uh on the independent side? I know you have you definitely can do some cool marketing stuff. What are you doing marketing-wise?
SPEAKER_03You know what? The most valuable thing that we've done is just built an email list and stayed in contact with those same people year after year. You know, you know what's you know, it's funny is marketing's like this cool buzzword, but the basics still work and they work better than a lot of the cool things that have popped up in the last couple of years. You know, because then we all get into insurance to build an asset that's going to continue to generate money. And when it comes to marketing, there's only two things that you can turn into an asset, and that's your email list and your website. Yep. Those are the only two things that you can control. If you're on the captive side, you can still go build your own website as long as you don't put their logos on there. You can still brand yourself, you know. So create an asset that you can control. And so those that's basically what we've done. And I did, you know, it's probably about two years ago. I figured out I was like, man, if I kept track of every person that ever requested anything from me since I started, I wouldn't ever have to talk to anybody again if I talked to them every year and said, Hey, would you give me a shot? Because eventually it's gonna the rates are doing this with every company. I'm gonna be competitive, or they're gonna have a bad claims experience, or somebody's not gonna respond to their phone call, and I'm gonna have an opportunity. So just staying in touch year after year with the same people over and over again. And that will drive more business than anything else that you want to try to do if you do it right.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, you've built out automation to help you do that.
SPEAKER_03You know what? It was a couple years ago. I've always been a tech guy, and it always irritated me on how slow the insurance industry is to technology. It was the most painful thing for me to go to insurance because then they were like, here's our system. And I'm like, this is like from '83. We're, you know, 2010. So it was one of those things that I kind of took it upon myself to go um figure out what I could use uh and develop some stuff. And that's, you know, two years ago, I created uh a little bit over two years ago, I created the automated insurance agency group on Facebook to pick other people's brains on what they were doing with technology and realize that everybody has the same problem. Nobody knows what to do. So, you know, it's it's one of those things that uh me, even though I love technology, you still have to take the time to try things and learn things and fail at things and then retry things again to figure out what you want to do and how you want to get there. You know, so over the last two years, we just I take time, I set time aside. Uh, I call it hammer time. And I just I just put my feet up and I'm like, okay, what am I gonna do? And I try to work through some stuff in my head. You kind of get some downtime. Hammer time sounds really aggressive, but it's really me just sitting back, like staring out the window, like trying to work and map things out. Because you got to think about the customer experience.
SPEAKER_01Do you wear parachute pants when it's hammer time?
SPEAKER_03Right. That's the only thing. I need to I need to get some.
SPEAKER_02Look over Jason's right shoulder, and you may see.
SPEAKER_03Oh, that's right.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, it was MC hammer right there.
SPEAKER_03There you go.
SPEAKER_01This is about to be in the back wall.
SPEAKER_03Oh, that is big time. Ice little nice ice baby. Yeah, can you do the dance?
SPEAKER_01No.
SPEAKER_03No, you need to learn the dance.
SPEAKER_01I know, I do. I can do the dance.
SPEAKER_03I had a friend, I had a friend that could do that.
SPEAKER_01Used to, yeah. I had a friend that like literally shaved it the sides in his head back in the yeah, back in the places if if you can figure that one out all day long.
SPEAKER_02Well, so it it hasn't always been easy being independent either, right? Like figuring that out. I think failure is probably something that we have to embrace as uh entrepreneurs. What are some of the things that you had to struggle through and then you learned from and got better as a result of?
SPEAKER_03You know what? Failure is probably my favorite thing, to be honest, because somebody uh a handful of years back was like, Man, you're the luckiest dude I know. And I was like, why is that? And he's like, Everything always seems to work out for you. And I was like, Yeah, but you haven't seen all the times that I've failed and got back up. And but you got to learn from it. You can't do something and not learn from it. So if you learn from it, you should be able to improve yourself so you don't make that mistake again and you know be able to move forward. So, you know what? I've I've probably failed more than anybody out there, but that's also what's pushed me further ahead into the forefront of everybody just because I keep I'm willing to try things. I mean, we're an insurance, we understand risk. You know, sometimes you need to be a risk taker and just try things and that'll get you somewhere. Sometimes it won't, but sometimes you learn what you shouldn't do.
SPEAKER_01Right. And if you don't do anything, you're gonna end up like Sears. Right. They didn't do anything.
SPEAKER_03Who?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, exactly. But no, it's true. It it's a hundred percent true that it you have to try stuff like that. It has to be built in if you want to be a business owner at all, especially these days where everything is moving so fast, right? If you're not trying different stuff continually, like to your point, having hammer time, right? If you don't, if you don't do that, then you're gone. Like just consider yourself done. I mean, I hate to say it.
SPEAKER_03I honestly believe in the next five to seven years, agents that aren't trying to move forward with technology, you're gonna be hurting really bad.
SPEAKER_01Yep, I agree.
SPEAKER_03I mean, just look at around you. I mean, everything, you know, the customer experience is the biggest deal, and a lot of it's driven by technology. And I had one of my reps in today, and he's like, I can't believe we are still talking to agents about the fact that they are using paper files. Right. And I was like, What's a paper file? I mean, here's a piece of paper, but that's because I got to fill it out for my tax lady. She hasn't figured it out either. We need to do it electronically, you know.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it is crazy.
SPEAKER_03Simple things.
SPEAKER_01What's even crazier is that there would be no other industry. Oh, there is no other industry. Well, there's maybe accountants, but there's not many industries that can do that still. The fact that agents can still get by, can still make a lot of money being able to have files and you know, crazy staff that's like filling out paperwork that's over. I don't know, just like all the mundane stuff. It's like crazy to me.
SPEAKER_03Well, it's you know, I've talked to hundreds of agents over the last couple of years, and what I think it boils down to is the ones that aren't moving forward are becoming less profitable, and you're gonna work yourself to death.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_03You're literally killing your staff with work because it's unnecessary. There's systems that can help you do things.
SPEAKER_01Yep. I wouldn't be able to, I mean, I leave I leave at work at five every day. Like I have to. My wife makes me because I can I can work all the time. But like I have to do that. Like that's the deal I made with her. Right. And there's no way that I would be able to do that without technology. No, it's crazy. Yeah.
SPEAKER_03No, you gotta have a good balance, and that's the only way to happen, you know, make it happen.
SPEAKER_01Yep. What are some things that you're excited about being more on the tech side? What are some things that you're seeing in the trends in the industry that gets you excited?
SPEAKER_03Oh man, I I love the fact that this whole thing called uh insure tech, and there's actually investment in different programs, not only to make the agent or the agency's life better and more profitable, but also more importantly, to assist with the experience the consumer is having with us. You know, because technology is not all about making your life easier, it should help it make it more consistent and drive that customer experience because it's 2020 and like if you're not focusing on customer experience with your office, if you're a slam and jam type of situation, they're the retention's gonna start falling off because people are expecting certain things now. And if you're not if you're not driving that, you know, you're gonna have a hard time moving forward.
SPEAKER_02If you can't create value in a world where our product is perceived as a commodity, then yeah, buy, right?
SPEAKER_03I think if you look at like, go back and look at the travel agents, for example. You know, they got hammered by technology. But if you've paid attention in the last year or two, they're starting to come back around because people had bad experience doing it themselves. And now they want somebody to justify the decision that they're making. They may do the research, but they still want that human element to just justify like, am I am I really doing the right thing? Especially with a complicated product like insurance. Right now we're kind of in that tweener stage where you know people think they can do it online, but we get new clients all the time that were like, man, we had a terrible experience. Well, you didn't buy comprehensive incollision. You let the app tell you you were saving 75 bucks, but it's because it was state minimum limits with no physical damage coverage at all. Right. Of course, they're not gonna pay for your card. So hey, let me help you figure out what to buy. So I th that trend starting to come back around.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I definitely look at it like it's like it's supposed to be a tool to help a business. Not you can't, I mean, I guess you can build a business around it, but really I think the magic is when you have the two because it can be tech alone is very frustrating. Right. There's those times where it's like you lose your mind because it's like, dude, can I just talk to somebody to help me out? Maybe even on the back end, right? For us as agents, it's like, oh, like you're trying to overcome some sort of problem. And it's like, I mean, I do that all the time, and I'd love to call be able to call like tech support, but you know, I can't.
SPEAKER_03So it's like but that's a prime example. I mean, we suffer the same things with other businesses. You know, if we're getting irritated with that stuff, they're doing it with our offices too. So if you get tired of punching a one for English and two for Spanish, and then you know, drilling down through the menus to figure out who to talk to, our consumers, when they call our office, are doing the same thing. Yeah, you know, they want to talk to a live person too, and they're looking for help. Beautiful. You're calling me. Yes, that's what I want you to do. It's exactly it's opportunity.
SPEAKER_02Every time that phone rings is opportunity. And if you can drive those ring, right? I think as the business owner, that that's what we need to do, right? Is to make those phones ring so that they're happy and they're on the line, they're on the phone quoting, right? Their highest value activity. Right. There's nothing more important for a producer to do than to be on the phone talking to somebody to sell them insurance. Yeah, building relationships. To your point before, the technology is awesome, right? Yes, oh, and it does speed things up for the consumer, right? But they think that, oh, well, since this is here and I can do it, I'm gonna get a great result. The problem is they don't know what to put in, right? They don't they look at what they had before, they're like, Well, this is what I had. Well, the guy that gave you that before was some schlep in a call center at a lizard factory and didn't know what to put. We really pick on pick.
SPEAKER_03Well, they deserve it because they're not giving anybody any help.
SPEAKER_02No, no, when you see policies that are 250, 500, 10.
SPEAKER_03I mean or you see the uh policy that left you and came back because they had a bad experience. Yeah, you had at 500 limits and it was dropped down to 5100, and they were told it was the same thing.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, they were overcharging you.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's so crazy. It's so crazy. And they all, you know, you always hear that like you are sell yourself, sell your agency. But like honestly, when you think about it, you are the competitive advantage. Like you are it. The technology is not necessarily the I mean, it's the competitive advantage to get somebody on the phone or something, but you are the competitive advantage when you're comparing yourself against somebody else. You building that connection is something that you can't, you'll never be able to build in tech ever. So it's like the more you develop those skills to be involved with somebody, like those interpersonal skills are like so important.
SPEAKER_03It's the relationship is the trunk card.
SPEAKER_01It is.
SPEAKER_03If you have the relationship, you've got the advantage. And technology can help remind you when you need to do things, but it's not gonna do it for you. Right. Don't don't let it make you lazy. You still have to build that relationship.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_03You still have to follow up, you still gotta call. It's a tool. Yeah, it's a tool. And you know, you use the tool the wrong way, you're gonna build something really crappy. Use it the right way, you're gonna build something awesome.
SPEAKER_01Right. And you might even bust your hand up, right? That's awesome. So, what would you what would the number one piece of advice you give somebody that's coming into the industry that's that you've learned that would help them the number one, like if it was your last day on earth?
SPEAKER_03Oh man, you know what? I and I think I think the entire industry struggles with this. If you're getting going, as you get going, write down your processes as you go, because that will save you a boatload of time in the future when you have to hire somebody and you're like, shoot, how did I do that? Because you're so you know, robotic doing it yourself. Yeah, get it written down from day one and tweak it as you go, but just get something on paper so that way when somebody steps in, you can say, Hey, here's how we do it, and it makes the training process easier.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, dude, you're the first person that said that, and it's a hundred percent true. It's kind of it's like hiring when you need to is the wrong time to hire. And it's like same with that. It's like we always we bring somebody on and you're you're teaching them, you're like, dude, I gotta write all this stuff down. And then once they're trained, it's like, all right, cool. Done, right, done.
SPEAKER_03And then it's like, I gotta write that down, and then the next time I'll do that before the next one comes on. And 13 people later, you're like, why is this so jacked up in here? We're all doing it different ways. Everybody just decides they want to do it their way.
SPEAKER_01So true. And yeah, your justification when you're smaller, when you only have two employees or something like that, it's like, well, I'm just gonna bring one person on, like, but then you know, three years later, you're 30 people into it, and you're like, What the hell am I doing?
SPEAKER_03What the hell is everybody doing?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, you don't know.
SPEAKER_03And your operation becomes so inefficient because everybody's fighting each other. Like, man, that's probably the talking to the agency owners the last several years, like everybody suffers from that. Nobody does it. Nobody wants it's the stupid thing that you need to do that nobody is willing to take the time to do because we're too busy right in business. It's gonna kill you later.
SPEAKER_02We can't scale. You have scaled chaos if you don't have some kind of process of onboarding. Right.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, process is the only thing that'll help you scale.
SPEAKER_02Yep, yep.
SPEAKER_03Because eventually you're just gonna plateau and you can't figure out what's wrong. And then you've got three people you're paying, you're like, I have no idea what these guys do, and everybody's doing too much stuff.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. Having the processes written down as dumb as it like, even the dumb process, even stuff that you know people should just inherently know. It's like just write it down, and then you never have to deal with it again. Right. So simple.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, and it's easy to update. Put it on a Microsoft Word document just to get started. And you know what? It has an edit button. You can go change it if you need to. Like it's not hard. I mean, it might be for some people, but right.
SPEAKER_01That's funny. Love it, Travis. Thank you so much, man. Awesome. Um, that was fun. Is there any final thought that you'd like to throw out there for anybody that would that you think would be of huge value?
SPEAKER_03Oh man, I would just say if you're not focusing on learning technology right now and figuring out how to become a modern agency in the digital world, you need to start listening to some podcasts, reading some books, join some groups that are focusing on that and just get involved in the conversation. And even if you're not a technology person, just being around it, you'll start picking things up, and that will help your agency in the next five to seven years when it's going to be critical that you're doing those things.
SPEAKER_02100%. Because the dude or do that down the street is. Yeah. And they're gonna they're gonna run laps around you.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. It's you know, we got, you know, I was talking to somebody about buying an agency uh a couple days ago. I just went out of focus. And the conversation went to well, how well do you do technology in your agency? And what kind of data and how is your data organized? And that's gonna be a a piece of what goes into the the purchasing of agencies in the future. Yeah. So if you're not organized, if you don't have good, clean data and you're not using technology, I'm just gonna steal your business. I'm sorry to say it, but I'm coming at you.
SPEAKER_01Well, that brings up a good point with the with the, especially on the indie side to sell your agency. I mean, if you have that day, that data is really what you're buying, right?
SPEAKER_03You know what, even on the captive side, that's so valuable.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_03Just to know who you're dealing with and who your target customer is actually buying from you is, that helps in your marketing. You don't have to quote everybody, not everybody's a good fit. Once you figure out who is a good fit, you can stop wasting your time on the front end by saying, nope, you don't qualify, but you got to collect the data to figure out who's a good fit. The companies are gonna tell you to quote everybody, they just want numbers.
SPEAKER_01Totally. We always say, uh, you know, you hear it all over the internet with an inch wide and a mile deep on your marketing. Yeah, and and these days, because of data, we can't we can literally do that, which makes it so much easier because it's like, okay, this is what we're good at. Okay, let's go hard in that area, fire waste, energy, yeah, and all this other stuff. I love that.
SPEAKER_03That would be it.
SPEAKER_01Yep, cool, man. Well, thank you so much, Travis.
SPEAKER_02Travis, thank you so much.
SPEAKER_01Awesome to have you on.
SPEAKER_03That was super fun. I enjoyed that.
SPEAKER_01That is awesome. Yeah. All the way from Missouri.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. Kansas City, Missouri, the Missouri side.
SPEAKER_01Yes. Huge value bombs, I would say. Value nuggets. Oh, yeah. Nuggets. We can't, not bombs. Not bombs. Can't say bombs.
SPEAKER_02That's a different plug. Well, he did come on our podcast. Right. Yeah. John Lee Doomas. But uh well, cool.
SPEAKER_03I'll drop them wherever.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Drop whatever you want, wherever you want. Love it. Thank you, Travis Gensler. If somebody wants to look you up, how can they find you?
SPEAKER_03I'm on LinkedIn. Just search for Travis Ginsler, automated insurance agency.com is where we do all of our tech talks. Cool. So feel free to connect with us there. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Cool. That's awesome, man.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Love it. All right. Thank you for being an insurance dude, and it was great talking to you.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, appreciate it. Okay. Bye.
SPEAKER_02Have a good one.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman