The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Balancing Family, Health, and Business in the Insurance World with Nicholas Sakha
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
Are you guys still buying a bunch of leads that just like the lower cost leads and then just having and running them through your sales process and your funnels?
SPEAKER_04I felt at that point like it was me against my family almost because I had all these big like we're doing this, we're doing this.
SPEAKER_01When you get really good at creating content, you can create your own ads. And that's something I've done as well.
SPEAKER_04You're gonna get a higher percentage close rate if you are producing content.
SPEAKER_01Just I think your social presence helps in more ways than just uh referrals.
SPEAKER_05Hey, I'm curious. You have the YouTube, and then you have the TikTok and the other and Instagram. Do you have a way of tracking and measuring the results that you get from that in the way of clients?
SPEAKER_03I are agents. I am agent. We are agents. We are interested.
SPEAKER_01My name is Nicholas Saka. I am an agent here in Las Vegas, Nevada, and the craziest thing that has ever happened in my agency is I didn't hire and spend enough money to begin with. I should have done a lot of the things I'm doing now sooner. That's all I've got. My name is Nick Socket, and I'm an insurance dude.
SPEAKER_04Boom! Dude, I am so excited to have you on. The last time you came on, you were in your car, and it was like 20 minutes. It was like really quick.
SPEAKER_01You let me know you let me know like five minutes in advance. I was like, well, I mean, I guess I could pull over and and do a podcast. I've always wanted to be a guest with you guys, so let's do that.
SPEAKER_04That's funny. That's so crazy. But that was five years ago. I was just uh looking back on that, and a lot has happened from them.
SPEAKER_05Was that pre pre-Tucci?
SPEAKER_04That was pre-Tucci.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Oh, uh 2020? Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_01That was pre, yep. Uh I just got my second location, and um and it was yeah, it was right before the the craziness of that year.
SPEAKER_04That's so wild. Yeah. I we I've had a couple kids since then. You've had a kid since then. You launched something super cool. The creators, uh insurance creators. Insurance creators. And also, yeah, I mean, you've done, I mean, you've nailed uh all of the social medias. So I I can't wait to dive into that too, dude. Because uh it's been really cool watching you from the beginning. And if you didn't listen to the first one, Nick and I started uh the well, we can't say the name because we'll get sued or something like that, or maybe just lose the agency. But with with with the company that we uh sell for, we started together and we were in the same classes in Chicago. I I'm allowed to say Chicago.
SPEAKER_05So that was cool. Is Ball State University in Chicago or where is Ball State?
SPEAKER_01We I have the you know what? Give me one second. Uh if for those that are watching it, I have our our class photo. One sec.
SPEAKER_05Oh so how many people were in your graduating class?
SPEAKER_01Here, let me cover.
SPEAKER_05Just to be clear, I'm talking about the university ball of ball state.
SPEAKER_03Boom and boom. Yeah. Look at that. That's awesome.
SPEAKER_01Yep. I just showed our class photo of me and Jason in the same room at the same time in 2016. 2016.
SPEAKER_05That's right. But ball states in Indiana.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_01I don't even know where ball state is.
SPEAKER_05Indiana. Munsey.
SPEAKER_01I that same thing.
SPEAKER_05That's where Greg McCamin is from. No, I just Googled it. It's it's in here. I I actually used Google. It's been a long time since I've used the Google.
SPEAKER_01I I don't I don't you I don't know where a lot of these college towns are. I have to Google it sometime. The other day I was looking up where uh uh it's it's uh not Boise State, but it's another Utah football team, and I was like, what's this? Where is this team from? And I'm like another Utah, like five teams in Utah, so it's crazy.
SPEAKER_05Well, Boise State is not one of the five teams in Utah. I can tell you.
SPEAKER_01No, it wasn't that one, but it was uh, I mean, you start naming them. Um it's one of the ones that doesn't have Utah in it. So I'm just goes to show that I'm not that much of a college person.
SPEAKER_05I knew now.
SPEAKER_01It was BYU.
SPEAKER_02I was like, where are they from?
SPEAKER_05You should know that they're from Utah.
SPEAKER_02I didn't know that.
SPEAKER_01I didn't know it. But yeah, lots has happened. Lots have happened, lots has happened in the last couple years, and it's been awesome. And I was telling you guys before we clicked record that I I've I've loved seeing what you guys are doing. You guys have always set the standard. And Craig, the way you travel, the way you uh um travel with your family, and then your age and the way you've built your agency. Um Jason, just seeing how much you guys have both grown, and I'm just I'm just trying to just tag along, man. That's all.
SPEAKER_04Dude, I your social content is so on point, it's so funny, dude. It and it's crazy too, because I know we both started. I mean, we kind of started doing YouTube stuff, and the we started the podcast, and and you were put we we were all kind of putting out stuff um together. And man, your stuff blew up and it got so good. It goes back to it goes to show like the more you like time that you put into something, the more effort, like the consistency of something, you know, whether it be sales, how you're talking, like I wish I would have done what I did, you know, to to start the agency. Like, it's just so funny that consistency and folks leads to this point where you hit this tipping point and then everybody sees the result. They're like, Oh, you're so good at this stuff, you know?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. It's so true, so true. And I think the biggest thing that made some of my stuff go viral was on at least on Instagram and TikTok, was not making it all about insurance. I feel like I made a lot of it about insurance, and the moment that I just started making just fun content and stuff that doesn't always have to be tied to insurance, that's when like it was more relatable and and just got more eyeballs as a result. Um, but I'm always like re referring back to insurance to remind everybody like, hey, we sell insurance, you should hit me up for a quote.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. It was really the it was the um how you mesh those two together that really like dude, it's it's gotten so good. Like it's so funny. And um, it's funny that you said when I stopped talking about insurance, because that's exactly what we tell salespeople. It's like if you're on a sales call, stop talking about insurance at some point. And you know what I mean, and relate to people. It's just funny how like all principles relate to each other.
SPEAKER_05But they're all backwards from what we do or wired to do. Yeah. Yeah. Oh, I don't want to do it every day. You gotta do it every day. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and yeah, exactly. When you're on a sales call, the last thing, you know, even building partnerships with lenders and realtors, not talking about insurance is probably the key. It's just get to know people and and then of course, you know, do all the basics, like provide more value and and educate uh the whole the whole nine, but just connect with people. And I think that's what I've been able to do with content and and humor. I leave with a lot of humor, and that gets people's guards down. I'm not taking life too seriously, I don't take myself too seriously. Um, I take my business seriously, but uh, you know, just just having fun just having fun.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. It's funny that you say that too, the one factor. Because like uh I was talking to one of my coaches recently, and we were just talking about fun. And it's like as soon as you lose that fun factor with whatever you're doing, it just it's it's such a like it's it starts weighing on you. It it I mean I guess it just starts stops, you know, starts losing the fun and you don't want to do it anymore. Um, but it's so important to have that fun factor. And I I think that that's definitely the key with your uh content is that it is fun to listen to. You don't have to be an insurance agent. Uh but I'll tell you one thing, if you're watching your stuff, you're laughing at I'm sure anybody in Las Vegas or anywhere in Nevada, if they see your content, they're gonna and they're looking for insurance later on, they're gonna think of Nicholas Soccer. They have to.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, no, absolutely. It's it's the easiest way to connect with people, and and and it's a delicate balance too, because you don't want to always only talk and um only make fun and games, and so it's just this delicate balance of making sure providing value, which I hope to do with like my YouTube channel. Some of the stuff that has done the best for me has been insurance. Like at first, I wanted to talk, like so. When I came out of my YouTube channel, I wanted to just see what was gonna stick. My first video was three things I learned after buying my first house. And it I prolonged and procrastinated on dropping that episode for so long. I'm in the new house that I just bought, my very first house, and I hit record, and the video's awful. And I probably tried to film it like three or four times, and I ended up not even using one of those videos. I I go to my office uh or I built out my office later, and then I finally like filmed a good version of it. And funny thing is, is uh I just was putting out a bunch of different content on YouTube to see what would stick, and then insurance stuff was popping off. It was like doing the best, and uh it's very niche PNC insurance. Um not that many people are doing it, you guys are doing it, and maybe like three other people, but uh but that seemed to do well, and and we just we just stuck with that. And but finding that balance of education and entertainment.
SPEAKER_04Yeah.
SPEAKER_01How do we do both? And uh, and I think somebody called somebody actually coined it or termed it edutainment.
SPEAKER_05Yeah.
SPEAKER_01So yeah. Yeah. I love it.
SPEAKER_05Patrick Bet David. Was it PBD? Yeah, probably. He's I know that he's talked, he's said it. I don't know if he coined it, but yeah. I've who we've had on here. And he got upset at Mr. Jason.
SPEAKER_01Really? Yeah, what'd you do?
SPEAKER_04Yeah, I like asked him the same question twice. Something like that.
SPEAKER_05We were so tired. I think we did like eight episodes in one day, and it was like that was so bad, and and it was him last after many people, and then like he's he asked, and I'm like, oh shit. He just asked that question, and then like he said something. It was kind of funny, it was funny, you know. Oh, but he was he was annoyed, not my favorite.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, probably the the the last person you want to repeat a question to and and tell and communicate that you weren't listening.
SPEAKER_05Second to last. The last is Garrett White.
SPEAKER_02Oh, really?
SPEAKER_05I would not want to repeat to him.
SPEAKER_02Man, I mean we all make mistakes.
SPEAKER_01I I still feel like I'm learning and and and just figuring figuring things out. And totally I love what you guys are doing. You guys are uh reinvesting, you're always trying new things, and I think that's what keeps it fun for us. We're speaking of fun, is for whatever reason, after like seven years, I I I every year, every year I have found something to challenge myself. Like, what am I gonna do this year? Because I'm I I become like bored and happy with my results, and I'm like, all right, I'm bored. Tom just created some chaos, and then I'll do something that creates a bunch of chaos in my life, and then I'm like regretting it for like four months. Like, why did I do this? Like opening up in Oregon. Um, that was stupid. And I remember driving in Oregon, I'm like, why am I here? Like, I've never set foot in this place, and it's beautiful, place is gorgeous, absolutely gorgeous. It's way better than Vegas. What am I doing here? And I was just tired, I needed some sleep, and the next day I woke up and attacked the day. And but just creating some chaos and then making it calm and peaceful, and then getting bored again and creating more chaos. I don't know if you guys can relate, but whether it's been like a bunch of Airbnb, and that's been a very stressful thing.
SPEAKER_05Oh man, it sucks. I can relate to that. It sucks.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. I mean, especially when the county's not on your side and they're giving you $25,000 fines.
SPEAKER_05Oh well, you gotta follow the rules too. That's important.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so I'm I'm hopefully getting the permit, but whether it's that or opening up an organ or creating my community or just putting out content on social media, that's been my life. But I think I'm ready for a year of focusing on my health and my body.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01You know, like I just I just I don't want to create more chaos right now. I think that's gonna be the next chaotic thing is like, I don't know, let's do a bodybuilding show or something. I don't know.
SPEAKER_04It's it's so weird, dude. Like everything changes with kids. And like you start you you get a lot more introspective. Craig and I went through like a couple rough years, last couple years, super introspective, and like spending more time with the family, backing off, you know, like we've said, with the agencies a little bit, and um yeah, regret regaining time, health, all that stuff, dude. And it's like it's crazy. But um, but dude, you got you gotta have it's like I know there's the there there's that whole thing with hustle culture, but dude, I I'll be honest, like when I first started doing all this, like I got into insurance to coast. You know what I mean? Like that was part of the appeal about insurance agencies. I was like, oh, my family, uh, my wife's uncle was able to go to all the kids' soccer games and was able to spend time with the kids and be home early. And that's why I got into it. And for me, I got caught up in the sales, and then I wanted to be best in company, and I was doing all the stuff, and I was like pushing, pushing, pushing, and like the home front was getting destroyed. Like, like for me, like like my wife and I's relationship was not that good. I had a the worst relationship with my second to oldest boy because I wasn't around that much, and I was building and building and building, and um and we just had it we we're both ADHD. So it's like we we both like will blow up, you know what I mean? So it's like we just had this bad relationship, and then I felt at that point like it was me against my family almost because I had all these big like we're doing this, we're doing this, and and then um Craig went through something and we were able to like step back and I was pissed about stepping back, you know, from the agency, pissed about stepping back from you know our business with the insurance dudes and all that stuff, but like, dude, it was the best thing that could happen because I easily could have lost my family or something like that, you know what I mean? Like you you like what you started it for ends up changing, like it it changes, you know what I mean? Um, and then it's just going back to those roots of like, why did you start doing this? You know?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's it's it's hard to figure out like what we what we want. When we're wired this way, we're constantly trying to take things to the next level. And there is an element of social media where we were just seeing other people perhaps doing so much and creating so much, and and then there's that competitive spirit where it's like if that person can do it, then I know for a fact I can do it. And um, but yeah, there's there's so many other areas that we don't consider where we might be seeing somebody's tip of the iceberg in business, but who knows what the relationships are like or what their health is like, and um and so on and so forth. But uh yeah, that's that's I'm just going out, you know. I'm I'm definitely in um kid kid, uh having a child it's been a game changer because I am used to just being completely free and just saying, like, I'll go to Cabo or I'm ready to travel. Like while my wife was pregnant um in like the uh in March, we went to it uh Japan and Italy back to back. We were gone for the entire month of March. Oh, the best and then now uh be and then now not being able to travel. Uh we just got our passport, so we're gonna figure something out, but don't worry, you'll have freedom in about 25 years. Yeah. Are you guys gonna have more kids? You know, uh we we certainly want another one. Um, but I'll be honest, there's times where I'm like, I think one will be okay, you know. But but then again, I'm like, no, it can't just be one. I need a son, but if it's not a son, then I have a decision to make, you know, an executive decision where it's like, do I risk maybe having a third uh girl? Uh but we'll we'll see. Whatever God wants, you know, I'm gonna leave that up to God and continue to just just build and and just uh enjoy life. But I I I really admire that about about you, Craig. Uh just be you stepping away from your business and making that a priority. I think that it's really cool that you do that, and I look up to you in that respect. I think you went to I don't know, maybe it might have been Peru or South America. All over.
SPEAKER_05A lot of places.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_05It's been pretty cool. We're at Costa Rica for Christmas. Um we spent some time in Incendidos this summer, so that was nice. And just like it's it's awesome, you know. But you could you could do most everything remote anyway, but there isn't much that needs to be done with the agency. It you know, as long as you get the right people in place, then it's worth it, you know. And I was gonna say to both of you guys, yeah, we push and we go extreme, and the key is is balance, right? Which is the hardest thing is is is balancing. But I think like mentally, uh something that you know, you get as you get towards 50, things start, you know, changing mentally, like, oh shit, I'm on the I'm on the back nine now, you know, and it starts it starts to mess with you a little bit, you know. My dad died last year, which was another thing, and and it, you know, that's still really hard. Um so it's just uh a lot of things start happening. You're like, oh wow, so mom's going, right? You know, it's like you know, that's the next thing on the horizon, wonderful. And you know, so there's all this stuff going, um, but with balance and and then or going really hard, we we're gonna pay for we're gonna pay to win. Now we're either gonna pay with money or we're gonna pay in health or we're gonna pay in relationships, or we're gonna, but we're gonna pay somehow, right? So the key is that balance. If we don't have that balance, we're really screwing ourselves up. And and it and to Jason's point, I had the same thing with my wife because I'd be I could I could work for 20 hours a day or I could not work at all, right? But if I if it's tough there, it's really easy to justify working 20 hours here, but then what happens, right? Like then it's a cycle because I'm gone, you know, there's there's more problems because there's problems, I'm gone. So you have to be really mindful of the cycles that start happening as a result of what you're doing, and then the justifications too, because I think we sit here and go, Well, you know, like as a dude coming home and talking to their wife, and if they're complaining, oh, you're why do you work so much? Why why can't you be here? And you're thinking, This I am working, like I'm working to pay for this, you know. You so so then you start justifying, and then there's resentment. So you just have to be careful about all that. There's a little over-explanation of everything.
SPEAKER_01I think the good thing, one of the good things is my wife definitely has a big vision and and and she wants some of the same things that that I want, so I know there's alignment there. Yeah. And so it kind of gives me uh the thumbs up to keep you know, to keep uh doing what I'm doing and to keep creating this chaos. Because I think we just we things don't get easier, we just become better. It's been the story the last eight years for me. And um, but yeah, there's certainly growing pains and And uh biting off more than more than you can chew.
SPEAKER_05And so Luckily we wake up every day and forgot everything that happened the day before, and then we do it, you know, we keep going, right? And maybe we remembered some of the lessons, but it's like uh you're like I don't fear risk because it's like I don't it's like okay, yesterday I felt shitty because of what happened, but it's like you wake up, it's like you're recharged again, you know? Forget it. That was a learning experience. As long as you chalk it up as lessons, and we say it in the book too. You know, it's like it isn't it isn't I wasted 20 grand on leads, it's I invested 20 grand in tuition to learn how to make the leads work. Now it's time to use those leads and actually get results from them instead of saying, Oh, I spent 20 grand and didn't get anything. This sucks, leads suck. To think that leads suck is is pointing the finger at the wrong thing, right? Because what else is there? I mean, it's all it's it's humans, right? They're humans with a phone number and an address. Like it's the ah, there's no, you know, there's no special ones.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah. Are you guys still buying a bunch of leads that just like the lower cost leads and then just having and running them through through your sales process and your funnels? Um, because I recently I recently started buying some higher intent leads, and uh, who knows if it's gonna be a mistake or not. I they literally just started coming in like yesterday, some like $25, $30 leads, I think. And they need to close at a 30%, you know, they need to close at like 25-30% for me to justify it.
SPEAKER_05So yeah, you're not even gonna get in touch with enough to close 30%.
SPEAKER_02Right.
SPEAKER_05So like no matter how high the intent is, they're not answering, they're only 10% are answering the phone or 15%, whatever the number is, right? It kind of depends on the market, but in your market, I would guess it's even lower, right? Because it's just Vegas is such a transient place, and people are probably less likely to answer unless you get the old people up in Boulder City.
SPEAKER_04So I was just in Vegas two days ago. Mr. V.
SPEAKER_01When you guys are in Vegas, you gotta come by it to my podcast too.
SPEAKER_04It was for my wife's birthday. We went to NASCAR race. She's a huge NASCAR fan. Oh, nice. We stayed at the Cosmopolitan for a couple days.
SPEAKER_01Nice, man. Yeah, if you guys are both ever. I know there's gonna be some sort of a conference you'll both be at. Definitely need to get you guys out here for uh for a for an A1 podcast. That'd be awesome.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, definitely. That'd be awesome.
SPEAKER_01Dude, your studio looks great, man. Thank you. We we got to merge three offices into one, which has been the best thing. I know you guys run remote. I still I guess I'm old school. I like the in-office. We're open to remote, but we still got the majority of our team members here. We've got an office in Oregon, but really just like a shell, like set of service over there. But but it's nice to have this nice office where all of us can fit versus three separate ones, which is so stupid. And uh the footprint. And then our podcast studio. So it's it's really cool. Um I I like, and then some of our my team members do work from home, like they got a home set up as well, so we offer that flexibility. But I know I gotta get with the times and and try a little bit more uh more remote.
SPEAKER_04Dude, so we're my team's remote, but I I still have an office. Like I'm I'm at the office. There's no chance of staying at home with four kids. Like I wouldn't have to do.
SPEAKER_05I don't even have kids at home anymore, and I just can't stay home.
SPEAKER_04But uh, but yeah, dude, I'll I'll be honest, like I look back at like my 2019 when I had you know a staff of 36, and I was like, you know, half well, half of them were dialers and half of them were in the office, you know. 18, I think we had like 18 people at at max, or maybe 15. I don't remember. Anyways, there's a lot, there's a lot of people, it seemed like, in the office, and I love the energy, dude. I love the energy of people, and now it's like I come into work and there's like no one here, and it's like I don't feel it, you know.
SPEAKER_01It's different, yeah. It's different for sure. Uh but I I I like the in-person. I never I never stopped. And then it also makes it easier for the to create content when when you're in person.
SPEAKER_05So and meetings. I mean, the real life meetings in the room in the morning is so much better than Zoom.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. No, for sure. But yeah, and then also having even like when you have partners or when you have people that uh guests, so Vegas, I'm lucky enough to have a place where a lot of people are coming to town, right? I'm not in Little Rock, Arkansas. You guys would never join me for a podcast if I was in Little Rock, right? No offense to you know, my folks out there, but just not a place that conferences are dying to be held.
SPEAKER_05I don't think I'll ever go there.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, but here in Vegas, everyone's here, so I can steal somebody for an hour and and collab with them and and get to get to share some space with them.
SPEAKER_04So do you like living in Las Vegas?
SPEAKER_01It's getting it's getting busier now, but I I do love it. Uh this last summer was really hot. And I know, Craig, you're you're from Arizona, so this last summer was different. This was different. We were in the tolerate summers, but this last summer was longer and hotter. And so this last most recent summer, I was definitely sold on buying a California summer house, like San Diego or something. Um, and when I talked to all my California friends, I'm like, well, isn't it more expensive? And they're just like, yeah, just make more money. True. I'm like, yeah, I mean, you're you're right.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, 1400 bucks a foot right by the beach. It's insane.
SPEAKER_01But it's better than like having a spot in Hawaii or Florida where you have to jump on a huge flight, right? Like California is boom boom, you know?
SPEAKER_05So and you get to pay the same as Hawaii, so who cares, you know, without the flight.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. No brainer. We all love to be in Hawaii, but it's uh it's just not as easy to get to.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, the types efforts, I think it kind of is a screw job.
SPEAKER_01It'd be harder to work out there for sure.
SPEAKER_05Screw job over there.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_05So hey, I'm curious. On the on, so you're you make the you have the YouTube, and then you have the TikTok and the other and Instagram. Three things that I'm not on very oh, YouTube I go on, but but the other two not so much. Um, but do you have a way of tracking to measuring the kind the the results that you get from that in the way of clients? Like do you just because I know for most agents they're sitting here going, well, I'm never gonna freaking do a YouTube channel because you know you're not gonna get anything. Or even if you do get anything, like there the real reason is because you know, pulling out the phone and talking to it makes you not able to talk, right? And then you then you freak out like you were explaining, like, oh, I gotta post it. Like, you know, now we're all over it, but but back then, like our first few times, it's scary as heck. Like, you're like, oh my god, everybody's gonna judge me, and you know, whatever. It's like, oh well, right? But yeah, can you talk a little bit about numbers to just for somebody that's looking into that?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. So for me, when I look at when I look at the following categories, when I look at personal referrals, I think personal referrals is social media, at least how I use it. There's no such thing. It's like it's it's like social media is such a part of our world now that I think unless it's a customer referral, a customer referral can be considered, you know, non-social media because you just asked the customer if they had a good experience and then they referred somebody over. Um but uh the last couple years I've had my team really like really tell like ask our customers where how did you find us and how did you connect with us? Uh there's uh Nick's personal referrals and NYX personal referrals, which is like my own little lead category, uh, they close at the highest close ratio.
SPEAKER_05What's it called?
SPEAKER_01Uh Nick's personal referrals.
SPEAKER_05Oh, NYX. Oh, right, right.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_05Nick's. What is a NYX? Oh, oh, your name.
SPEAKER_01Got it. And those uh those close at a high close. But we we've tracked where the business has come from. I think lenders, uh, mortgage partners and lenders is something we've tapped into. Uh we've got a few insurance partners where if we know, you know, uh uh an insurance office out here and they're not able to close somebody. But when I looked at all the data and I totaled it up for the last five years, it's been roughly about a thousand items a year that has come from from uh like so 5,000 items and about a thousand items a year that has come from like those different categories. And so just understanding that there is no such thing as, in my opinion, a personal referral without it being without me having touch pointed them on social media. I see what you mean. You know, um, when you're putting out as much content as me, it's all connected, it's impossible.
SPEAKER_05And when you look at it, it's like reinforcement, right? It it's like, yeah, okay, just you and I don't mean to cut you off, but I'm sorry. I have now. Um it so it's if it's a thousand items a year, it's like I don't think that it's that you could argue, okay, I did these all these videos, I got a thousand from it. But what you can say is, had you not done those videos, maybe it's 400 referrals, right? Instead of a thousand referrals.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_05So it definitely amplifies your presence.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. And I think that there's this uh digital real estate effect too, where people are gonna always think about me because of of what we're what we've been doing. And I didn't hire somebody to help me with this until like eight months ago. So you were that low. Now we're seeing I did it all myself like a psychopath.
SPEAKER_02Oh man. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01And so now I don't have to think about posting. It's it's being posted on all my platforms. Uh he he's here in office, one of my best friends. And so when I'm not here, he's working with my team, he's creating content with them. And so we've and you know, that might not be scalable for a lot of agents. Um, but uh I just, you know, with all the things coming up and changing as well, like the one-to-one consent, consumers getting smarter. I I don't think it's any better time than now. And you know, you're just it's just like the proof is out there. You're seeing YouTubers coming out with uh a product that's competing with Gatorade, you know. You're right, and they're putting Gatorade, giving them a run for their money. You've got YouTubers fighting Mike Tyson, and so I think uh it's just a massive opportunity. Who knows what will happen with with leads? Um, I think leads will always be a it's still my bread and butter, right? Leads are still 70% of what we do, maybe he's like 65.
SPEAKER_04Uh well, they're all leads at the end of the day.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah, internet like but internet leads, it's still and then they're also when you get really good at creating content, you can create your own ads. And that's something I've done as well. Uh, and I'm still always trying to figure that out and crack the code per se. But you you create content, you run ads on it, and then now you're generating your own leads, and then you just gotta track and measure if if if it's doing better than internet leads that you're buying from like an Everquote or all web or whatever, right? So but yeah, so as far as tracking and measuring, I that's what I always say. It's like it's all connected. And the my biggest message to agents is you're spending the time on social media, anyways. If you pull up your stu your your analytics, it's gonna tell you that you just spent two hours on social media apps today, anyways. Stop consuming content, start producing content. It takes about three to six hours a week to create content, and and that could be that could help your online presence and and get you more referrals and and and so on and so on and so forth. So just just swapping. You're swapping scrolling with creating.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. And dude, it it is crazy, like it is crazy the effect that it does have. Because Craig and I have talked about that before. Like when we started the insurance dudes, it all of a sudden it hiring became easy easier at the agency. And then you realize like a lot of the new people in the agency, like they saw your stuff on social media, and that was I mean, you could tell it was a driver of why they might have been, you know what I mean, like hired. Like I d you get that vibe when you see people, whether or not like, oh yeah, I saw your stuff. Like it's almost like they're not impressed, but like it shows I guess it shows a little bit more authority than the guy next door that has nothing.
SPEAKER_01So it's a million percent.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, so like I I think it's one of those things that what's what hard do you want? Do you want the hard of not putting out any content and dealing with losing your agents and dealing with uh, you know, when somebody googles you that they don't see anything else? Like like the coolest thing is when you are buying uh leads and you're doing content, those leads are I do I remember at one point we were getting 2,000 views a month uh on our Google profile. And they were l looking at all the social media stuff. So it's it's like you're gonna get a higher percentage, uh, a higher percentage close rate if you are producing content. Is it directly correlated with the content that you made? Not directly, but it does position you a billion times uh differently than the guy next door that you know has filing cabinets.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. It's hard to quantify, you know, and it's just like instead of trying to overanalyze it, it's just uh I'd rather be safe than sorry. It's like the guy that was overthinking the website, you know, um in the in the the 2000s era, right? Yeah, uh it's the same people that are probably overthinking, uh no, we can go down further down that rabbit hole. Uh I don't want to even say that because my ADD will probably take a step further. But it's it's hard to quantify. Like looking at my team right now, two of my top producers and my sales manager came from just me making a post saying I was hiring.
SPEAKER_06Yep.
SPEAKER_01And people seeing my content, falling in love with the culture, the agency, what we do, and then saying, hey, my cousin's looking for a job, or my nephew's looking for a job. My son, my one of my top producers is my old manager from a bank. He he managed me and um and he sent his son, and he's been one of my top producers for two years in a row. This year he'll probably lose it, but um what else? Uh just I think your social presence helps in more ways than than just uh referrals. It helps with uh uh mortgage partners, lenders, because lenders and realtors and that they're looking to increase their social media game as well. And so when they see that you have a social proof, they're willing, they want to work with you. And and that that that does help because social media helps their industry so much right now. I have a buddy on TikTok that started making great videos, and all of his deals come from TikTok. Um lenders are lender, I think. I'm a part of a mastermind of a bunch of lenders that are and they're just teaching them um social media, and so I'm a part of it because one, I wanted to learn more about social media, but two, I wanted to be in a room full of lenders. Um so yeah, so that helps.
SPEAKER_05So yeah, I it's it's really hard to quantify, and I know there are numbers, nerds like you guys that are like, show me the data, and I'm like, I mean, I don't think there's data from from that standpoint, but but there is data in the measuring effect, the measuring stick effect, right? Like, what do we do when somebody when we're not sure, like, is this thing for real? We Google it, right? So what happens? Like it would some when Lead comes in, goes to my teleteam, teleteam transfers it to the to the sales agent, sales agent talks to him, says, Hey, this is Allie down at uh down at uh ball state university, and we're we're doing this or that, and then they go, Whoa, whoa, where'd you say you're from? And then she says, Oh, you know, Google Craig's name, and she they Google my name and fling fling, they could go to six pages down, and they're still I'm still on Google, right? And and I mean five years ago I wasn't, but now they're and now there's a book, and now there's you know, a there's there's all the podcasts and all the different stuff. It's like they instantly think, holy shit, this guy, you know, oh that's that's a good one. And and same with the hiring. And and I'm not saying it, I'm not like I just can't fucking believe it. It's crazy, right? Like it's just because we got indexed in this system, people believe us. And I mean they they should because I do have proof. But they should.
SPEAKER_04But if only they knew.
SPEAKER_05If only they knew that I'm wearing shorts right now. Under shorts. No, I have real shorts on.
SPEAKER_01But yeah, uh it's it's it's been awesome. Who knows where where the social media stuff goes will continue to grow into. And um who knows what's gonna happen with the insurance industry. You know, there's there is yeah, we don't have to go down that rabbit hole either, but um, you know, you guys ever think about going indie?
SPEAKER_04Yeah, hell yeah. I mean, dude, I I don't care. Uh what are they gonna do? Fire me. Um dude, of course. I mean, I just got screwed for two years.
SPEAKER_00I peek over the fence every once in a while. I don't do nothing about it, but I peek over the fence and just go, hmm.
SPEAKER_05You know, it's interesting. Everything always looks better.
SPEAKER_01Absolutely.
SPEAKER_05I know, but I know I mean numbers-wise, likely it is better, but it's a lot of work.
SPEAKER_04I I I I'm gonna be a little bit uh controversial here. But the the cool thing about indie is you actually own your clients in a way. You could sell them diapers if you own your leads.
SPEAKER_01Well, let me say let me say this. My buddy, my buddy is uh I just got to know him this year. He's uh he was a Medicare guy, sold his agency for like 70 mil. And I'm like, our multiple could never pay us 70 mil. And and so when I asked him about it, he's like, well, it was probably like the right time as well. So it wouldn't, but then it got me thinking, I'm like, dude, does Medicare sell at a way higher multiple than than a PNC agency? And so I got my you know, it just got me my my mind working. Um not that I have a desire to sell Medicare, but but still, like at a higher multiple, like I think you can convince me.
SPEAKER_04It's not Medicare. The reason why it sells higher, especially over $10 million books of business, is because there's so many um funds that will take on insurance agencies and they'll buy them to be a part of their fund. And you know what I mean? So it's like it goes for higher multiples, but you have to have you can't have like the lower end agencies, it's got to be at least like 10 million. But we know a guy that sold what was it, 70 million? And I think Berkshire Hot Hathaway bought his agency. Oh, yeah.
SPEAKER_01Um maybe we know the same guy, it's uh Justin Brock.
SPEAKER_04Oh, yeah, we know Justin. I thought you're talking about I thought you were talking about the ClickFunnels guy. This is yeah, this is a different guy, but but we just had Justin Brock on uh a few months ago again. But yeah, he he crushed it too, man. I mean, there's a there's a huge market for independent agencies, but uh so like going back to that whole independent versus I mean like for the average person that wants like an agency and wants to like it makes it makes a lot of sense to be in a captive agency. You get a lot more money up front, you know what I mean? Where a lot of these other people have to rely upon their own marketing skills, they have to play the long game for sure.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, we get a lot a lot more instant gratitude, however, plus all of the support from the company.
SPEAKER_05I mean, could you it like all of that support? It's tremendous.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_05I don't know what you're laughing about.
SPEAKER_01So you know what though? I think that the biggest support has been people like you. People like I mean, there's so much like support from all these different people that are putting out content that have come out with training platforms. Like we can we can name them. And as long as you're connected with those people, you're listening to the insurance dudes and you're, you know, you're you're getting the right information, I think that that's that's where like a lot of the the support um definitely comes comes into clutch. Uh but what was I gonna say? I I was talking to a few people have reached out to me for for like coaching, and and I don't like to make the full commitment of being someone's coach because my mind is so on you know a lot of different things, but I'm willing to help when I can. And sometimes just talking to people that are starting scratch, I reflect and I'm like, damn, how did I do it? Because I'm asking them to do a lot, right? I'm like, yeah, so so you need to keep hiring. You you in your first six months or so, you're gonna have to sell yourself. You know, you're gonna have to be your top producer, you're gonna have to coach, train, and develop and always be hiring. And you're gonna have to track the data. Don't make the mistake I did, where it's like you didn't track data for five years, and you're gonna have to do X, Y, Z. It's post on social media too. Don't forget that. And I'm like, There's so much. This is a lot, you know, you're better off like just buying an agency. Uh but yeah, I'll look back and I'm definitely wondering. You know, I'm realizing that this isn't easy. It's not for the for the for the what's the what's that what's that saying? The faint of heart.
SPEAKER_05So of your class, I don't know, it looked like there was 25, something in there. How many are still agents?
SPEAKER_01I've I've talked to Jason crushing it. I I don't know of the rest. I don't think the rest are are there. Really?
SPEAKER_04Dude, there's a so I talked to Phyllis. She's um Phyllis from the office. She's selling uh up north and she's selling independent now. Uh Tony down in I I talked to Tony down in Texas. Um what's Tony up to? Tony! Gosh, he was we we talked a lot about the agency.
SPEAKER_01I know another guy that's gonna indie uh in out there in Minnesota, but I don't think that many that that many people have have survived the storm or they've just exited.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. Have do you remember David Rodmacher? Sounds familiar. He was the short Asian guy? He real skinny dude. Had the family that was all agents as well. I don't think so. Oh man. I I hung out with him so much at that we became really good friends, and he passed like a couple years ago. Oh, crush me, man. He had a big family, uh family of five. The father of five. Yeah, it was it was brutal. But he was doing really well before he passed, but man. That's unfortunate. That's what a good dude. He was he was an awesome friend that I met out of that out of that crew.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Well, Craig, I'm glad. I know you had a a bit of a a scare. I think you had something removed. I'm glad you're doing better, brother.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, they had to take away my man parts. No, I'm just kidding. So I no, I got it like a an obstruction in my intestine. Like, and the doctor, like they had to do emergency surgery. Like, I was I by what I was went home because I didn't feel good, and then my stomach started hurting more and more, like quickly, to the point where I where all of a sudden I was like, holy, like my wife said, You need to go, do you want to go to the urgent care? And I'm like, No, I'm not going to the doctor. And then, like, 10 minutes later, I said, You I like she was in a meeting on her, you know, in her office at home, and and I'm like, Come here, I need to go. Like, we she had to walk me out, and then I got in the root in the emergency room and it was packed. And I started screaming because I'm like, I'm not waiting in this freaking line. So I started screaming and making a big scene, but it also like hurt that bad that warranted it. Like, I didn't care. And they brought me back and they're like, Holy shit, we have to do emergency surgery. You're gonna ex, you know, your test is gonna explode, you're gonna die. And I'm like, what? Well, they didn't tell me, they told my wife, and she's like, huh? And you know, like it dude, it was nuts.
SPEAKER_01Like, I'm glad you're I'm glad you're good. Man, that was I don't like I don't like reading stuff like that, dude.
SPEAKER_05It was gnarly. Yeah, that was crazy year last year. I mean, the only thing the doctor could say was, well, I mean, really do good at chewing your food.
SPEAKER_01Oh, well, I saw you you weren't chewing enough.
SPEAKER_05Uh I don't know. I mean, that's the he he has no idea. He said, sometimes, no pun intended, shit happens. Oh, oh shit. Oh no, not twice. I just did it twice. Shoot.
SPEAKER_04Dude, it's the fun stuff when you get older, right? Next thing you know, you gotta you gotta get the prostate checked out, you gotta get the backside checked out, you got some polyps here and there. Oh man.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, start getting things grown more hair everywhere. It's like, what the hell is this?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah, definitely. I mean, it is probably the food, but that's a whole other rabbit hole. Yeah, it's the food that they're feeding us.
SPEAKER_05Well, I read it I'm reading a really cool book called 10% human, and it's about microbe, uh, the microbes. You know, like we're covered in microbes, like these little tiny trillions of them, and they do have all sorts of functions. It's very interesting. I'm only in the first chapter, I'll let you know next time.
SPEAKER_04Dude, I can tell Nicholas, we're on the same page, man. I like this year, it's like I found out that my cholesterol was high, and I was like pre-diabetic as of the beginning of the year, but I was working out and eating healthy. I was just after 2020, I pretty much door-dashed everything. So I was getting all the all the food, and man, like what a difference it makes when you go organic, you don't have the seed oils, and like dude, they're trying to kill you. They wanted to put me on stuff on on the you know the subscription service of the government, and I was like, screw that, I'd rather just eat healthy.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_04But yeah.
SPEAKER_01No, my my dad, uh, my dad had to start dialysis um like a less than a year ago. Oh shit. And he's miserable. He he's he's he's absolutely hating. And he he pushed it off. He almost had to die for him to finally like get on it. But uh, yeah, it just doesn't seem fun, and you gotta take care of yourselves, you know. Yeah, stuff we don't like to talk about, but it it it has to be done.
SPEAKER_05So I'd say you pay for it one way or the other.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's really good. You're paying for something.
SPEAKER_05Yep.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Or no, it's uh it's coming out of a certain bank account.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, what bank account are they coming out of? I'd rather pay with money because who cares? You could you could get more of that.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, just don't overdraft, you know? Don't be overdrafting your accounts.
SPEAKER_05Well, yeah, hoarding the money does nothing. You can't hoard the money because you lose money by hoarding it, right? It needs to be out there working, so make it work. And yeah, I mean, until this, there was no way it worked in the agency, like, or I didn't put it in, right? I didn't believe in it. But once once that came, I mean Jason convinced me. I almost gave up, you know, on leads. They suck. It's so hard. You know, it's challenging, or it was back then because there was no resource, you know.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_05But we wrote a book on it.
SPEAKER_01Million dollar agency, get your get your copy now.
SPEAKER_05I didn't say it. Nick did.
SPEAKER_01Uh, and you gotta have a school community, correct?
SPEAKER_04Yeah, we just started that the agent elite at school.com. It's in the show notes.
SPEAKER_02Love it.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, we wanted to get our group on Facebook sucked. It was and it was so spammy. So we wanted just we wanted to build a community that was just agents. So we're moving over to school. We got a bunch of we got the book in there for free, we got a bunch of free stuff, so that's cool.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, my community is on school. I was I wasn't gonna use it until the mastermind that I was in was using it, and then I was like, you know, it's I can get down with this. It's pretty good. Yeah, and it didn't. This smelled school wrong, but and Hermose's a heck of a salesperson, so you know he sold us all 100 million.
SPEAKER_04I love that when we started this, you said that you get nervous, you got nervous of posting the video, and um you know, you still feel like you're learning a lot. I I love that because I mean, dude, we feel the same way. So it's like I know that people see a lot of content coming out from you or from us or from other people, and it's like you feel like, oh, well, they do it. It's we only do it because we've done it, but it's like it's still, I mean, it feels weird at times, and it's like no one's like naturally just like good or anything like that. So it's it it's just something to do. Like it, it's like a you gotta get on the gotta get in the arena.
SPEAKER_01What I've been telling people is stop you're you're hesitant because you're making it about yourself. And the moment you can get a get over yourself and just think about the audience that you could be serving through the lessons you've learned by sharing you, by sharing your knowledge, by sharing your wisdom, sharing your uh being vulnerable. And people think, you know, social media doesn't have to just be your highlight reel. Yes, you should acknowledge your successes, but you should also acknowledge your losses as well, because people are gonna connect with your losses way more than they'll connect with your your your wins. And people like when you're real, raw, and vulnerable. That's that's where you actually connect with folks and and and get them to uh to to resonate with you. So stop thinking about yourself. Start start thinking about who you can serve. Like you're being selfish in a way by not sharing. And once you get over that, you'll you'll you'll be better off.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, I love the frame of it's it's it's not about you, it's about them. So if you really do frame it that way, because it is, right? You're trying to help people if they see something that they didn't know and it helps them, like that's a big that's a big deal. So it's like definitely framing it that way and looking at it that way.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, you can make a piece of content out of anything. And you know, but last before we you know wrap this up, one thing I've been saying over and over again recently as as I've been on these podcasts and events and things like that is has been I I made a piece of content with a line at Starbucks, where my mom works at the MGM at the Starbucks, and one day I one day on a hot summer day, I went to go visit her and to go just say hi and to get a frappuccino or whatever I was getting. And I see this long line and I take a photo of this line with her and the you know, working behind that line, and she waves me over and she says, like, hey son, like she sees me all excited, even though you know it's a long line of people, she's working her ass off, and people hardly ever tip. Um, and she she already has my drink made, and she gives me the drink, and she just delivers it to me with the happiest smile on her face, positive attitude. And and I take a picture of this line and I I I post it and I say, This is why I got started in business because my mom has worked at Starbucks for the last 15, 20 years, and I want to make sure that she retires and she's taken care of because I don't want to have to see her have to work. And this is why I started my insurance agency, and this is why when I don't feel like it, I show up anyways, because I it doesn't matter how I feel, I need to make sure mom gets retired. I need to make sure mom gets to quit this job at Starbucks. That's a piece of content. Yeah. A line at Starbucks, and we all have these things that we can share, and I think a lot of people just hold it back because maybe they think it's stupid or they think that, oh, who who I don't know what to share about. Like, dude, you don't have to post about deductibles or collision or comp.
SPEAKER_04That's not a magnet. They don't want it anyways, they don't care.
SPEAKER_01Like be you, tell your stories because that's your competitive edge is being able to share what makes you you, and nobody else can share those same those same stories. So get over yourself.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. I love that. What a cool what a cool story. And and going back to what you said earlier about like sharing your you know, your struggles and stuff like that, it really does connect people a lot more. A lot more. And what's what's crazy about it is it's the hardest thing to do. And it's really hard to post that honest stuff about yourself.
SPEAKER_01So um what you don't want to share is probably what you should be sharing, not all the time. Not all the time. I got I saw Craig's face, his mind was thinking of something clever to say. So I was like, let me let me let me clean this up, let me tie this up.
SPEAKER_02Not everything.
SPEAKER_04We're going streaking.
SPEAKER_02But yeah.
SPEAKER_04Super cool, man. Well, I we appreciate you taking your time out of your day to to join us, and uh, I know you're a busy dude, so um, congratulations on the baby. Thank you. And you know, the family and uh all your success with the agency, man.
SPEAKER_01I appreciate you guys. You guys have always, like I said, when we started this off, you guys have uh inspired me in big ways. And if there's anything I could ever do um uh to repay you guys for for just your friendship and um and the information you guys have put out that has made me a better agency owner, just let me know. Um appreciate you guys.
SPEAKER_04Man, thank you. Oh, we feel the same about you, man. Yeah. Seriously.
SPEAKER_05You're crushing it. It's it's the best to see you know to see you do well. It's awesome. Thank you guys. I stepped on Jason, sorry, dude. And that's the pot.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman