The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Mastering Cross-Selling with Carson Porter
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
I didn't want to get into the elongated details.
SPEAKER_04Right. Right.
SPEAKER_00I try to keep it flat in it. I don't want to get too crazy with it. You know, don't want to make it hard. Yeah, no, don't make it hard. Hey, I'm Carson Porter. The wildest thing that's ever happened to me is I had a commercial specialist close a policy and uh five minutes later got a dick pic from our client. And so I had to turn around and talk to that client. We went ahead and canceled his policy, and um then he sued us for it. So what a wild time, but y'all know what? I'm still an insurance dude.
SPEAKER_04Boom! That's a hell of an intro story. Just freaking went through it and wrapped it up, and it's boom.
SPEAKER_00I didn't want to get into the elongated details.
SPEAKER_04Right. Right.
SPEAKER_00You just threw it in, got in there, and got out, pulled out. I try to keep it flaccid and I don't want to get too crazy with it, you know. You don't want to make it hard. Yeah, no, don't don't make it hard.
SPEAKER_04Well, this is getting messy. The software approach is much better. Anyway, tell us a little bit about your background, Carson. As hard as it was to become an agent.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it was throbbingly hard. Well, so I uh actually was born and raised in the automotive repair sector. That's where I had my first two businesses. Um, a little over 10 years ago, decided to get into insurance for uh a whole bunch of reasons. We can go down that road or stay away from it if you want to. When I first got into insurance, I sucked. I started as a captive multi-line doing home auto life. What color? Red, white, and blue. Ah, took me a second there. Yeah, big eagle. Um, anyways, uh actually was a really great place. I think had I gone independent right off the bat, I I would have failed. Um, a lot of people want to crap talk on the captive model, but you know what the captive model does better is it cultivates agents. Uh there's just so many more resources there for that, but it comes at a cost, right? It comes at a uh very dear cost. Um, but yeah, the first five years of my career were spent there and was able to figure out how to sell life insurance very well. Um, I get a lot of attention for that now, life insurance and annuities. But we also scratch grew a multiple, multiple million dollar uh property casualty business in um in less than five years as well. Left there, went independent, uh, done well as an independent. When I did that, I went primarily uh just life insurance and annuities only. Um and we're actually just getting back. I've got somebody in my agency with property casualty experience that wants to head up an operation. So we're actually diving, diving back in. So um lots of fun. We do lots of things. We run a mastermind, we call it agnostic mastermind. We don't care what carrier company or IMO or whoever you're with, we're here to help you screw your bias, screw the this product's better than that. Let's just, you know, talk realism, help real agents make real money in the real world, right where they're at. Um, and a lot of that again is around life insurance and annuities. And um, that's what we do. I don't do anything for fun, I work all the damn time. I've got a gorgeous wife that I'm probably gonna lose because I don't give her enough attention. Um I've got the two most beautiful that's a joke for anyone listening. Well, and she doesn't listen, so it's okay, right? Yeah, it's not like she's gonna listen. And there's no one in Idaho in Idaho Falls, so dude, right? No, she uh she's the most amazing person uh ever. I'm so glad that I get to spend my life with her. And well, that I've gotten to spend this life so she could wake up tomorrow and realize how how uh bad of a decision she made in choosing me, but no, we've got the two most beautiful boys, we do a lot of outdoor stuff. Um that's me. I like long walks on the beach in the nude. I'm not really fit, so I try and do nighttime walks. Uh what else?
SPEAKER_03I love it, man. So you live in Idaho Falls. We were just talking. Um, I'm actually looking at Boise, and that's kind of where we left off because it started getting interesting. Craig's wanted us to record. So um I did, you know.
SPEAKER_00So what do you recommend Boise? I love Boise. I think Boise's a cool spot. Um I actually have a really, really good friend. We do a lot of business together. He had a farmers agency for years, uh, sold that and went into the commercial leads business, and he's killing it. Um does a really good job with it, actually. Um Kelby Steele. If y'all don't know him, you ought to check him out. I'll make an intro if you want. Kelby, yeah, let's talk to him. Kelby commercial leads, um, commercial leads, yeah. Super cool. What kind? Uh commercial, business insurance, you know. Just all everything? Um, yay and nay. Um, I know when I've talked to him, he really he prefers captives, but not necessarily because he prefers captives. It's simply because they have their market clarity lists are so much more well dialed down. Um and it's that's a lot easier, it's easier to market to the niches, right?
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Versus independents are like, I'll take everything. And and the smart, the wealthy independents don't take everything. They're like, I do, you know, commercial, like I do over-the-road trucking, I do uh, you know, business property, and I do like you really niche down, and that's the money is is really in finding those focus markets. So um yeah, he likes partnering with agencies that that will niche down.
SPEAKER_03Isn't it crazy? Like when you're a captive, all the captives complain about only being able to write whatever, right? And then they go into independent. And I've talked, we we I mean, we've had a lot of clients and talked to a lot of people that will go independent, and then like the complaint is like we don't know where to place them, or it takes so long to quote with everyone, and it's like, dude, what are you doing? Like, you know that you're not supposed to quote with everyone, you know, like three people that covers different.
SPEAKER_00They might have access to you know 14 different home and auto carriers. Yes, they don't quote them, they'll drop in easy links or turbo rate or whatever, they'll run it and then they'll take like their top two or three preferred, as long as as those come out quoting decently, they might go finish the quote out real quick, find one that's gonna meet or beat what they currently have, and then they'll make a value-based sell on the back end. If nothing, like if it's not one of those top two or three, but they have a carrier they never use, and that carrier's competitive, most of the time, those agencies are just hitting the client back up. Sorry, there's not a lot more we can do because even though they can go win the policy on price today, the cost of servicing that policy on the back end, working with a carrier who you're not familiar with their policy, their SOPs, their appetites, their it costs a lot of money to do that.
SPEAKER_04I was just saying, it's just a totally different model in and of itself, right? And how they the approach, because we're like we're power growth, right? Leads, telemarketers, the whole thing, you know, blasting activity through the agency, whereas they're they're more selective up front once they have a critical mass, right? And then they just kind of the turn word is not the right word for it, but it is in essence. If somebody comes up for renewal and it doesn't and they're not happy, it's just move them over, right?
SPEAKER_00Yep. Yeah, yeah, it's it's an interesting model, but we did even as a captive, we kind of stuck to that model. I realized early on, like not from day one, because my first six months I almost went bankrupt. But once we really started clicking along and moving with it, we realized, hey, my job isn't to have access to everybody and find a product for the person. My job is to find a person for the product. And so we started using uh it was a service back in the day called Quote Fire. It was live transfers and and hit and miss. I I'll leave the testimonial on the side for now, but we wrote a lot of business um by just taking live transfers and we knew our product really, really well. We could pound a byline quote out in five minutes or less. So client's still there on the phone, we're still asking them about you know the kids and the ashes of their loved ones on the mantle and all that, and all of a sudden we've got bindable policies ready to go. That was profitable business. Chasing uh a $2,000 per year account you're gonna make $180 to $250 on per year, like you can't quantify your time well that way. So right.
SPEAKER_03I I have a question for you. So you're I mean, you're running with a bunch of um a bunch of agents that are do running life and and annuities and everything. What are you doing these days to cut costs on the front end? Like to your point of what you were just saying, it's like uh like you could chase down people and build relationships over long periods of time. I mean, like there's but like what are you doing to really speed up production?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so my number one thing, and I know there's it's hit and miss, I don't buy leads anymore. Um, but I also know agents who buy leads, and if that's your way in, great, do that. Um, I partner with agencies who don't sell life insurance. So I'll take a P and C agency who doesn't sell life insurance or a Medicare agency or health insurance, um, and I won't wait for their referrals. Um, I'm not saying screw their referrals because I I love referrals, but I don't trust their their, not their ability, but their willingness to be driven to give me referrals, right? So what I do is I wrap them into a contract. That contract, it wholly protects them. You know, they're the integrity of their relationship with their client. I'm not gonna offload this data to someone else. I'm not gonna um but I get a download of their whole book of business. We'll pull two, three, four thousand people at a time and um, and then we go market to that and cross-sell it. Zero dollars up front, small revenue share on the back end.
SPEAKER_03Well what what does that split look like?
SPEAKER_00I typically am gonna give like 20 to 30 percent of street level commissions. Um, I get paid quite a bit more than street, but that's not for me to share with somebody else. That's due to my hard work. Uh so we'll give them 20 to 30 percent of something they're not selling, anyways, and their competitor might be selling it and stealing their clients. So it increases persistency, increases profitability. They do nothing for it, they just get mailbox money. Um, and it it goes again a long, long way. So a lot of our partners will end up paying 20, 50,000, 100,000 per per year out to these agencies, money that they weren't getting for lines of business that they weren't representing. Um, and at the same time, again, increasing their productivity, profitability, and and persistency is a huge one because we're reselling them back to their client all the time. Like, hey, yeah, no, we can't help you with your you know, home and auto insurance. Uh, but even if we could, we wouldn't. You're with you're with Jamal. Jamal's got the best damn program on the market. He may not have a good price right now, but Jamal's not the insurance company. Don't beat him up for an insurance company's mistake. Stick with that dude. He's gonna take care of you for the rest of forever. Like, we're reselling them on the back end, so there's a a lot more than just the check they're getting back in revenue share.
SPEAKER_03Right. I love it, dude. You listen up, captive carriers. I know you got to sell life insurance, but what if you sold life insurance to these people? And so did Carson.
SPEAKER_00Check this out. This is one thing we actually do. Take farmers, for example.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_00I told y'all I typically try and keep like carrier names out, but farmers' agents, as an example, have a requirement, and it's not a requirement, it's 15 apps per quarter, and if they go 15 apps per quarter, they can get like a 30, 35% bonus on premium.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Plus the data we have on increased persistency. Uh, the way I sell life insurance and the way I'm I teach others in this mastermind we have, are when we sell life insurance, we sell property casualty as well. Like if we're talking about retirement, for example, or or whatever, one of the best buffers, liability buffers you can have for your retirement is an umbrella. So if I'm sitting here telling your client that and I'm like, hey, by the way, you know, million bucks, it's $200 a year typically. It's very inexpensive. Let's get you talking to your agent again. Oh, it turns out you don't have the underlying limits. Well, now we're going 100, 300 to like 255 or or you know, 500 flat combined or uh total combined limits or whatever to get the underlying and dropping a million dollars. So we're increasing premium for our partners and increasing profitability and productivity on a on that primary line. And then again, so with farmers agents, we we we have farmers agents in our program. We have independents in our program who are hungry and aren't getting in front of enough people themselves. And we're like, hey, learn the farmer's program and go sell farmers insurance for this farmer's agent. Okay, and there's some things we need, there's some key pieces we need to put in line to be uh compliant uh with that, obviously. But go do that as a side hustle to you growing your your business in essence, and in doing that, this farmer's agent's gonna hit their 15 apps per quarter, they're never gonna miss that bonus again. Uh, they're always uh gonna be on the leaderboards. And what what agent out there doesn't like being on the leaderboards? All of them like being on the leaderboards, they all want to make toppers, they all like let's be real. Um so you're always gonna hit that. Oh, and by the way, we're going to increase uh the premium on the book and the persistency on the book in in doing all this.
SPEAKER_03So they would write for farmers and then they would also write on the side for themselves, right?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah, and and to keep it compliant at the end of the day, because if they contract with farmers as a subproducer or under uh what is farmers called there, protege program, um, they have to go captive at that point, which which kind of kills you. You're dead in the water, versus, hey, I'm not here to make any representations warranties or anything like that. I'm here to do the legwork. At the end of the day, the agent's gonna run the quote, the agent's providing the proposal. All I'm doing as the independent is I'm talking life insurance in general. So I'm educating you on life insurance in general. We might be talking about like a mortgage protection solution. I'm educating you in general. And by the way, here's the proposal your agent prepared. If you want to take steps forward, um, like I'll help facilitate that. But but the independent's not gonna take those steps forward. The independent's gonna link the client back up with that agent's office so they can take the application and get it into underwriting, right? So there's um uh, like I say, a few key things we want to make sure we hit so we stay compliant. We don't want to piss off farmers, we don't want to piss off any of the carriers. Um but as long as we're able to do those things and make sure we're not getting anybody in trouble, it becomes ethical, profitable business for everybody, the client included. They're picking up coverages that they wouldn't otherwise have because their agent isn't good at helping them understand how imperative those coverages are. If that makes sense.
SPEAKER_03Do you do that for other carriers?
SPEAKER_00Um, yeah, yeah. Uh we we've had or we've had, we've helped agents with State Farm, uh, American National, uh I don't know, we can uh countrywide. Super cool. Yeah, how it it doesn't matter. We've and we've come up on compliance. We've had we've had run-ins with compliance all over the place, but at the end of the day, when we're able to document, because that's another thing we teach is document, document, document, disclose, disclose, disclose. When we're able to provide all that evidence that uh, hey, we're not doing anything in a non-compliant manner. We're this is how we're doing it, and here's every specific example. Um, oh, and by the way, y'all are making a crap ton more money uh because of what we're teaching people to do, we've been able to overcome those barriers every time.
SPEAKER_04I'm sure that uh it requires a significant amount of of educating to move them to move the agent past or into that conversation and then get them to to under understand and accept it because it's a with with all respect, and I'm thinking of of myself in in the past and the way that I approached entrepreneurial situations, like I was I was very close-minded um as an agent to opportunities that came. You know, A for compliance, right? There's a lot of fear from the carrier, so always very careful about that. But then just from the oh, I have to put out money for you know, it's like it's it seems like for some reason, as soon as you become an agent, you're so tight with the money, right? And and then that's what makes it tight for growth, right? You just can't grow if you don't invest. And um, I don't know where I'm going here with that. What do you see as the obstacles that they put up? And then how do you walk through that?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, the first one is pride and control. Everybody's like, I don't want to give you access to my you're gonna steal it. And it's like, well, some sometimes you're not gonna overcome that obstacle. When I'm teaching agents to go make these partnerships, we actually have a whole program built around it. It's called Once Your Client, Always Your Client. We've got good looking PDFs and everything. Like, this is some real shit. But the first thing we teach them is this is sales like anything else. You have to go sell an agency on working with you, right? You're not gonna walk into five agencies and come out with three of them wanting to work with you. Like if it takes, if I'm cold calling, I expect to make 100 dials in order to get 10 to 20 people to even pick up the phone. And out of that 20 people who even pick up the phone, I expect uh maybe 20% of that to even be willing to have a conversation with me. 20, maybe 30%, right? And out of the ones who are even willing to have a conversation, how many are actually like it's it's a game of numbers, right? Yeah. So if I'm gonna go recruiting agencies and I want three agencies, I might have I might have to go talk to 50 agencies to find three. And people get scared of that hard work. That's the I mean, there's there's a lot of really great things about insurance agents, and a lot of insurance agents aren't scared of work, but too many are. Too many are. They came into this business for the time and money freedom, but guess what? Time and money freedom is a purchased commodity. You have to go make some freaking money so you can buy that back for yourself.
SPEAKER_01Yep.
SPEAKER_00It's not inherent because you have a freaking LLC, such a pet peeve of mine, if you can't tell. Um but so we'll teach them that number one. Because if if you walk through any orchard, no matter how bad a lot of the apples are, you're gonna find some good apples in there too. You will find low-hanging fruit. So that's the first thing. Maybe you weren't the person to partner with, but the dude next door was, or the gal next door was, right? Um, and then as we move into other obstacles, we have things like uh, again, compliance. Hey, here's some case studies on compliance. We've actually been able to overcome that. We're not gonna do anything that's uncompliant. Uh, I'm worried about my client's data. Hey, we are Privacy Act and HIPAA compliant. Um, you're Privacy Act and HIPAA compliant, and we're gonna put a Privacy Act and HIPAA compliant contract between us protecting your client's data. You're not distributing client data outside of your organization, right? You're just repurposing it through your own organization. We are coming in as an extension of you. So it's a think of it less as a another business taking your business and doing something with it, and more of a fractional resource, right? So it's no different than having a fractional CFO, a fractional COO, a fractional marketer, right? Um, and that's that's all it is. Like it's crazy how many agencies are willing to hire somebody to go knock doors, but they're not willing to hire somebody to rework their own data. And that data, uh have y'all ever watched the show? Um, what is it? Um Gold Rush. Oh, I thought you were gonna say 90-day fiancee. Oh no, no, no, no, gone in 60 seconds.
SPEAKER_03Um is that where they go? They go and they they uh what do they set up those machines everywhere to go through the yeah?
SPEAKER_00So they're they have two primary modalities of finding gold. Okay. The first is they have these these big screens. They scoop it out of, they just scoop dirt up, run it through there, and they find nuggets. Okay, and that's what they kind of do like the first one-third of the season. But then like these guys spent millions just to be on that land and then all the equipment and everything, and they find a couple million dollars worth of gold that way, you know, the big, easy nuggets. But then they're out of land, they scooped all the topsoil up or whatever. And they're only like a third of the way through the season. So what do they do the whole rest of the season? They run the same damn dirt through a finer and finer filter over and over and over again. And the majority, you get to the end of the season, and they dump out all their gold and they weigh it out, and it's like they've got like four big nuggets, uh you know, we'll call them McNuggets. Um they've got, you know, a couple smaller nuggets or whatever, a handful of smaller nuggets. But the majority of their weight, like 80% of the weight they have in gold, is gold flakes they got from refining the dirt, from rerunning the dirt through a finer filter, right? So my point is like especially with Captives. Um, and y'all know this when it comes to like quotes not sold, rerunning quotes not same shit, but it's crazy how many agents are willing to go buy new leads, go buy more leads, go buy this, go do that, and not invest a single damn dollar into working the dirt they've already worked when the majority of the gold is there. Hiring somebody as a fractional resource to work that dirt for you, number one, it's not um uh an automatically non-compliant, they're just compliance measures we need to meet, right? Um, and then we move on from there. And the reality is, is the same tools that found you the nuggets, those are not the same tools that are gonna get you the majority of the gold. And if you are a nugget creating machine, like most agencies are, you are not equipped to find filter for that. You need to hire a fine filter. Like you got to switch out the equipment a third of the way through the season to find all the extra gold. Does that make sense?
SPEAKER_03Oh, I love the analogy. Uh we we our the process that we use in our agencies to to sort through leads is what we call the telefunnel. And we we have a bunch of uh dialing specialists and a process that sifts through the leads. And we always tell people it's the same thing. Like most people think internet leads suck because they're just they're getting the big the nuggets, right? But those nuggets will go to somebody else because they're the ones that will close on three calls. But it really where it picks up is when you're on the 30th call and you start closing the 30th to 60th dial, those people don't the retention on those people are fantastic because it takes 30 to 60 dials to reach them. So like being able to have the right tools in place to to close all the all the other leads, the leads down the funnel is is where the gold is. That's where the you know, so I I love that analogy because it's it's like it's like once a principle works for something, it usually you can apply it to like everything.
SPEAKER_00Uh-huh. I I love that you guys are telling people to call folks that much. It's it's not annoying, it's pleasantly persistent as long as you're not a douchebag without it, right? Yeah. Like the difference is are you being a douchebag or are you not? Because you told me to call you, so here I am.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. My favorite thing is, and I tell our agents this all the time, is like nothing's better than when you call somebody too much and they go, first off, everybody's worried that they call them too much and that they'll complain. One out of 10,000 people complain, right? So, like, once that person complains, like, dude, I love what I do, and this is that important. I believe that this is that important for you. You can apply it to any kind of insurance. And if you don't want me to call anymore, you need to let me know because I have a duty to make sure that you get covered.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_03Because that's how passionate I am about this. Most agents aren't that passionate about it, but I am. But if you don't want me to ever call you again, you don't see the importance like I do, tell me to never call. I'll take you off my list. I'll never call you again.
SPEAKER_00I love that. I think that so many agents are afraid of number one, the work. But like you said, if if you have the tools on the front side, the work isn't, it's not any harder. If I'm gonna make 200 dials today, what does it matter if I'm dialing this person for the 18th time or dialing that person for the the first time? Like my job isn't to my job is to make the 200 dials because I know the numbers work. If I dial 200 a day, everything else works out, right?
SPEAKER_03The only difference is the cost of leads, right? Because at that point you're the mixed difference the cost of leads.
SPEAKER_00And then um the other fear that they have is things like FCC compliance and um uh you have uh all these, all these different they're they're afraid, well, what if I get that complaint? Well, again, if you have the right system from day one to uh like any basic CRM, for God's sake, like I can show that they opted in, they asked for my call, and I called 30 times and then they complained, but they never once bothered to give me any kind of notification that said, please don't reach out to me. They could have answered the phone, they could have texted, they could have emailed, they could have done any number of things, but they didn't. I'm fine. When you have all that data cached in one quick, easy area and you can just export that to uh compliance officers, it like it's not some big, you know, you hear these horror stories of I was under investigation for months and I had to give them every client ever. Number one, no, I didn't because I proved it so damn well with the one client. They were like, yeah, it's a waste of our time. Number two, even if they wanted every client ever or every phone call ever, great, it's all in the same damn CRM. Let me export everything instead of one thing, have fun with it, you know. Um, so yeah, agents need to quit being afraid and just quit being cheap. Get the right tools, the right tools might cost you 100 or 200 bucks a month, and then go to work.
SPEAKER_03And it multiplies the efforts, right? You're doing the work of with the right tools, you should be doing three times the amount of work of somebody without the tools, and that's being generous. Like they're or that's not, you know, it's probably a lot more than that. Oh, easily.
SPEAKER_04It seems like like as agents, we operate on emotion a lot instead of the logic, right? I mean, it very we have every number, every single number, right? We we know we know how many dials it takes to get to whatever. We know all of we know all of the things, right? And we know all of the data from from the carrier. We can create the equation and be a like for all intents and purposes, pretty damn accurate, right? Right. Um I was I wish I knew the I remember the line from my cousin Vinny. What is it dead on dead on balls accurate? Is that right? Yeah. Um, so it's it's remarkable knowing that, and then understand that we're in a recurring, in a recurring model, right? Like what you just said about the persistency and the profitability, like it's not just, oh yeah, you're a little more profitable. It's significant, right? Like every every increase in retention, it leads to a significant amount more of renewals. Like if you have an 80% retention, you have five renewals, right? If you have a 90% retention, you're at 10, you double between nine, uh, you know, between 80 and 90 percent. So it's I don't know, it's just it's just huge to understand like those additional lines, whether it's you know, you're adding that lifeline, whether somebody's doing mono and then they don't they don't bundle it. It's so critical to do that.
SPEAKER_00Well, and then reinvestment, like it is it is so easy to cross-sell. So like one of the first things I teach life and they could be life only agents to do is go partner with a PNC agent. The easiest cross-sell for life insurance is off a PNC. Because you have so many, like when nobody ever woke up horny about life insurance, right? Like you've never been rampantly aroused because somebody might get a check when you die. Right. You know what I mean? So we have to create better conversations. Those conversations are so easy to create off of the data we have when we know we have a property casualty client. For example, I have a homeowner who has a mortgage e-clause. I know that they have a mortgage. If they have a mortgage, they have need for mortgage protection insurance, uh, life insurance. And they might already have life insurance, but do they have mortgage protection life insurance? Right? That is an easy to create conversation. And that cross-sell, like it is so easy. So you're already there selling the homeowners, you're explaining coverage, and you're like, hey, we've got we've got, you know, coverage a dwelling, this and that and the other. And by the way, you're covered for, you know, you have cash on hand, you're just screwed because if that burns in a fire, nobody believes you. And um, you know, you're you're explaining all this other stuff, and you're and you get all the way to the bottom, and you're like, oh, hey, by the way, you know, I noticed you have a mortgage. Most of my clients feel like they would like their mortgage protection insurance to protect somebody from more than just the bank. The mortgage protection insurance you may have through the bank, through your through your escrow, only protects the bank. I hope you don't mind. I took the liberty to put together this quote. It's $30.2 uh $32.12 a month to guarantee that if you choke on a cigarette butt tomorrow and you lose your ability to pay your mortgage, your family gets to keep your slice of the American dream. Do you feel like you work hard enough? You want me to include that as part of your plan or not? Like, that's the cross sale. It can happen that fast, right? And if they're like, yeah, and you know, all it is from there, great. We do this for a special kind of life insurance policy. I'm gonna have to ask you a couple health questions. You might have to shit in a shoebox. I don't know. We'll see how crazy it gets, but um, we'll get that added on there, right? So easy cross-sells, by the way, that pitch on on uh a homeowner's client, it's like 30 plus percent uh closing. Like it's so simple, so easy. Okay. So it doesn't take a lot of time, and then a lot of times property casualty agents aren't gonna cross-sell this because they're like, oh, it's it's tedious, and and I'm getting to where the money makes sense here in just a second. That's easy. And then when I set up the right system, I don't spend 45 minutes on the phone asking them, you know, did you have Rickets? Did your daddy have rickets? Like, no. I shoot them a link to uh we we use surveys. We we have a really well put together um survey, so page after page instead of a single form, right? And it asks them the major like 99% of the questions on uh a life insurance application. They fill that out. There's a little disclaimer this isn't the app. I'm gonna use these answers to fill out the app and send you the formal app to review an e-sign in just a minute. So we just shoot them a link, they fill that out, comes back. I have one of my team members take a few minutes to copy and paste those answers into an e-app, and away we go. We're like 10 minutes at this point into selling a life policy. It's a $400 a year premium. That may not be much, but guess what? A $4,000 a year premium, it's the same amount of time invested. It's the same thing. So we do all that, and now figure this. The average mortgage protection policy, for example, is around $1,200 per year. Why? Because we're not insuring 20-year-olds for $100,000, right? We're uh on a 10-year term. We're doing like $15,000 to 30-year term on $250,000 to $500,000 on a 30,000, $40,000, 50-year-old. It's typically $1,200 per year. And if we take an average agent commission, let's just say $1,000 per year or $1,000 up front, right? On an agent commission, or let's say, let's say uh $500 up front, even. Let's say all you make is $500 on it. How much property casualty premium did you need to sell to make $500 this year? At 10%, it's $5,000, right? At higher percentages, it's less. But what you are doing with that 10 minutes of work, like it took you an hour's worth of work, two hours worth of work to find, call through, quote, bind, follow-up on property casualty, and in 15 to 30 minutes, we just doubled your average account revenue for the first year. Your ability to reinvest and buy more leads, invest in better systems, hire more people literally doubles with a sliver of additional work.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. 100%. And the revenue is so high on life and annuities. Like I mean, coming from the P and C world, you know? And to your point, it's just so much more work. It's so much work to get that person than it is to cross over.
SPEAKER_00And that's the point, right? Why would you not just rerun the dirt? Just run it through a finer filter. And if you don't have the bandwidth or the capacity, why wouldn't you bring somebody in to do that same thing? And if you're gonna bring somebody in, why do you care if if they're part-time for you, part-time for their own agency versus part-time for you, part-time for the the General Mills factory?
SPEAKER_03I would actually, you you know what's you know what's bananas about this whole thing? Now, I'm not gonna do this, so if you're listening, carrier, don't worry about it. But um but like it would I've worked with a lot of um life guys for the company, the carrier that that uh that I guess I in partnership with. But they there's not much incentive for I mean there is incentive for them, but they're just they're freaking lazy, dude.
SPEAKER_00They're not like the one I was told not to say. Yeah, okay. So we we can bleep that by the way, but dude, yeah, even that carrier, there's a ton of incentive because their growth model, they can grow way, way faster through acquisition, right? I've got a buddy with them out of Vegas, they can grow way faster through acquisition, but they have to hit their percent of PIF every year on life insurance to be allowed to acquire next year. Right.
SPEAKER_03That's well, what I'm saying is the agency owner does you're 100% right. The agency owner has a huge uh incentive. But what I'm saying is like the the life only agents that they're supposed to partner with.
SPEAKER_00Uh-huh.
SPEAKER_03So like if they're if it's a life only agent for the captive carrier that they're that they're like the laziest people ever. So to be able to use somebody outside of the carrier life agent that actually wants to kick some ass and work out a deal to make it beneficial on both sides should be allowed.
SPEAKER_00Because it should be. It's a win-win. It it's discouraged. Um, but we we've been able to overcome, you know, even in that scenario, we've been able to overcome that multiple times, even with home office involved. Um just had to have the right protections and contracts and indemnity in place and and uh you know thing things along those lines. But um yeah, the incentive is there for the agent, the incentive's there for the company. Yeah. At the end of the day, they are incentivized to want to make it work. For those, uh I know some really, really great life specialists in those type of capacities. I know way more for every one great one that I know. I probably know, I don't know, 10, 20 lazy ones that are like, hey, if it's if it's not a lay-down sell, I'm not gonna follow up. I'm not gonna, but now you have these agencies who want to grow through acquisition reliant on that person not following up to be able to grow through acquisition, um, it's a lame duck model that that could use some improvement, in my opinion. Um, but yeah, the ability to use additional resources goes a long way. Uh, one of my biggest points I contend is that if that, like if they were to hire a part-time person, let's say I was an agency and I hired a part-time uh uh, you can call them whatever you want, CSR, market or whatever, to just call my book of business and line, like just put my life specialist on appointments, right? And but it was part-time, like, hey, they're coming in two, three hours a day. My company would not balk, they wouldn't even bat an eyelash if that person's other job was at the grocery store. They wouldn't. They wouldn't care. The only reason they care is because their other job is not at the grocery store. And they're this, it it's this um scarcity mindset. And it's amazing to me how many people want to preach abundance and then live scarce. You don't get to live in the two worlds at the same time. And so a lot of times it just takes a conversation. I've found this as I've uh not only been a captive and an independent, but I've been a top producer on both sides, and I've gotten to sit not just at leadership summits and field leader meetings and those things, but I've gotten to sit on boards helping design product, gotten to sit on marketing boards for carriers and do some cool things. I never thought I'd be able to. And here's what I found 100% there's always the rule of thumb, and that's what gets preached. There's always the exception to the rule, and that's what we have to guard ourselves from because too many people want to take advantage of that, right? But there is nothing, there is no um, there's there's pretty much nothing unless it is flat out illegal at the state or federal level that is not up for negotiation. If you're a producer, you have a business plan, a business model, and you can show how a company is protected and edified through what you're trying to implement. You just got to be intentional about it. You got to be an entrepreneur, somebody who creates value where it didn't previously exist. Sometimes that means putting all those great ideas on paper and presenting it as opposed to a simple reseller. If all you're doing is reselling someone else's product, you're a reseller. And that's okay. That's a phenomenal thing to be. But yeah, if we want to start getting into these conversations and doing these things, we got to become entrepreneurial. And um, being entrepreneurial requires hard conversations backed with uh backed with assets.
SPEAKER_03So I love it, man. That's a that's mic drop right there. So tell us how uh we can get a hold of you. Don't no, I'm joking.
SPEAKER_00Um stay away. Yeah, stay away. I don't want to grow anymore. Um, no, you y'all can find me on just about every social media platform. I probably do the most on Facebook. Uh my handle is the same everywhere at C Porter389. Um send me an email, Carson P at Revagency Syndicate.com. That's R-E-V. Isn't Rev your engine, right? Um how else can you get a hold? Don't show up at my house. This is Idaho. We're gun totin state.
SPEAKER_03Um, and and you're running around naked, too, apparently.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, well, some people might enjoy that. I know you don't, but some people might.
SPEAKER_01Binoculars and in the bushes, all sorts of creeps, all sorts of creeps. It's disgusting. Yeah.
SPEAKER_04Bushes.
SPEAKER_03Cool, man. Carson, awesome hanging with you today. Appreciate it, man. I I hope uh more people um take this conversation a little bit more seriously. It's it's just it's we we talked to a lot of uh uh captive, uh not just captive, but like P and C agents, and it's just like there is a huge opportunity with life, and it's not the easiest one to switch over or to but like dude, just get involved. There's plenty of upside.
SPEAKER_00Oh, yeah.
SPEAKER_04It's a no-brainer, it costs nothing and it increases it, it improves everything, and you make money.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, there's literally no I like those kind of deals. Literally no downside. So I appreciate y'all. No extra work.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, it is interesting the scarcity thinking of like, oh, you're gonna mess my people up. It's like dude, your people are messing your people up. Like a pro calling actually providing something that's gonna be of value actually undoes what the people that work for you do. What Snally did. Yeah, what's Sally did because Solid. It's always Solid. And that's the funny.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman