The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Overcoming Sales Challenges in the Insurance Industry with Jorge Carbonell PART 2
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
And you're all still in office.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. We haven't had a lot of success with the remote. I didn't put any effort into it, so you know that's probably on us. Maybe I need to be involved in that, but that's not something I want to own. So I don't want remote people at this moment.
SPEAKER_01I are agent. I am profitable. I am great. I am agent. We are agent. We are insurance.
SPEAKER_00Are you 100% remote, George? I would put 98%, yes. We have um service people, and now in one of the offices, we've turned it into like a hybrid because now they're in like a rotation. So they're working in an office two or three times a week, and then the other two or three times, whatever it lands on, they're at home.
SPEAKER_02Would you talk a little bit about managing that process? Because I still haven't had a ton of success with the remote thing, um, aside from during COVID, but you know, different story. So we have a few groups that so the carrier-specific groups or the or the iDudes group, you know, we see it a lot, people asking about remote, which indicates that it seems to be a struggle, right? What are some of like a couple tips that you could maybe offer that would help people?
SPEAKER_00You're interviewing for the right people. It goes back to again, the culture fit is we're a remote culture. So are you self-accountable or have to be on you know the entire day, right? I'm I'm not trying to be on you the entire day, and that's why everybody posts their numbers at the end of the day, right? We also have a daily meeting, daily sales meeting, and that's kind of like our halftime, um, because we do it in the early afternoon. So it's like, hey, what do we do the first half of the day? What do we got to do to meet or exceed our goals the second half of the day? I mean, from a process person or like a logistical perspective, I I have like a freaking mini FedEx store in my house because I'm like constantly sending equipment back and forth. So yeah, that's fun.
SPEAKER_01That's fun. Yeah, for us it's been interesting because you know, we can't, we're in California. We got a whole can of worms out here. But part of the agency I'm kind of enjoying because we were going hard for a while. This year, you know, we have sales goals, so we're hitting those sales goals, but we've been a hundred percent remote. 100%. My office manager had to come in one day to fix a computer, so that's the only the only thing that we did.
SPEAKER_00But do you still have a brick and mortar, or did you did you close that down?
SPEAKER_01To be honest, and I don't know how much the they them are gonna be upset, but um I put it remote and then I still have an office.
SPEAKER_00Oh, okay.
SPEAKER_01You know what I mean? So it's like my office, do whatever I can walk around in my boxer shorts if I want to, which is nice. I don't wear boxers, I wear briefs, but uh I could I could walk around in the Speedos if if uh if I wanted to. But I like having an office like a like a location, a because I have way too m many kids at home, and then uh just in case if anybody needs to come in, and I've used this as the safety place, like, okay, hey, if anything goes wrong, then we have the the hub to come back to. But man, it's been really good. I just talked to my service or my yeah, my office manager this morning, and I talked to her here and there, but I mean not a ton because I've had her for since I started. And we we have our salesperson back, he's hitting his numbers. Uh, we're doing a lot with referrals, like a lot with referrals. We're hitting some some great numbers with and m 80% of it's hitting uh from referrals now. So that's that's nice. It's funny, like one of the things that I've been realizing is I'll jump in when when needed, but I never jump in like I used to. Like I would jump in like, hey, a couple days are slow, right? And I don't do that now. Like I will wait it out, which is very painful for me, and then I'll have a conversation. So, and when I have that conversation, like all we do is tra so let me take a step back. What I do to track my people, it's only uh behavior-based. So they have a spreadsheet that they fill out every day, and it's all behaviors. Call, you know, there's calls, whatever, right? How many like the type of call that's going out, um, talk time, like all the things because we put together a formula. Hey, if if Sally, we'll just say Sally, Sally's not real, but Sally from the Sally's doing all these different behaviors, then I'm totally cool. And so, like, you know, of yesteryear we used to do like screen recordings here and there and stuff like that, but like we don't do any of that stuff anymore. It's just I look at the behaviors. Like if the behaviors are there, then it should be good. And then I'll meet with them every once in a while. And it this has been I I've been doing this over time. So like we've been we've had just uh one person in the office for a year now, and then it went to nobody in the office. So then I would jump on people with when the behaviors would slow down, but I would do it too soon instead of giving them the opportunity because they're people, right? There's gonna be a bad day here and there or whatever, but I give them the ability to self-correct. Since I've been able to do that more this year, now they are, and when I talk to them, I say, listen, this is all on you. I'm not gonna hover over you. Like if you can't self, you know, you know, like if you can't self-motivate, these are the things that are needed. Like I see, you know, last week you had a rough week, or or two weeks ago, you had a rough week. And you need to be the one to self-correct because I don't, I'm not gonna do it. I like refuse to do it. So since I've done that and I've pulled back more, it's it's doing well. It's working out really well, actually. So now we don't have anybody in the office. And Mr. Jason let go. I I had to let go.
SPEAKER_02It's driving me bananas. I mean, it is pretty amazing because it's so it's like an illusion to think that we could control all these things, right? Yeah, and so you know what number one, congratulations because it's freaking very, very, very difficult to not jump in, right? Especially the way I think that all of us agents are, right? Like we're hardwired to jump in and help and help and help and help and help and help, like the the you know, especially from the days when we're answering phones and helping clients, it's just nonstop, right? It's just nonstop insanity when you're in the trenches. So then when we take ourselves out a little bit, we do it to our people, like how we were doing it before, right? And which is highly ineffective. I mean, we we learned here at iDudes, like managing people like that, what happens, right? Like it's so it it like jumping in, jumping in, jumping in, they don't like it. Um, and it's really, really difficult to be discerning and stop yourself. So good job.
SPEAKER_01That's nice.
SPEAKER_02It is hard, man. But but it's amazing how much better you feel from doing that, right? Like, I mean, I'm not I jump in still, but I like try to if I start firing off a text to somebody about something I just thought of, then I'm like, wait a minute, maybe I should just put it on a note and I'll address it at the meeting. And I think everybody feels much smoother when it's like that, right?
SPEAKER_01It's so much, yeah. And then a lot of those things, uh, the next day you're like, well, this isn't a big deal. Maybe this might be a big deal, but then all of a sudden it's like self-corrects. The amount of problems that you actually have when you do that boils down, like you can whittle it down to either a core problem or just a bunch of little problems that go away. They go away.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. It's amazing. I remember when I first stopped taking calls and talking to clients, like, you know, think of all the things that we had in our mind, you know, oh, they're all gonna leave. Oh, with the pretentious gonna, you know, all these things that you think are gonna happen, and none of it happens, right? It's just like, oh, okay, this is the way it is now, right? Like it it and it's such a relief, but the stress to get to that point is wild, like what we put ourselves through.
SPEAKER_00I'm just smiling because I'm not there yet. One day.
SPEAKER_02But see, you can be you can be there right now, but in your mind, you believe that you have to be there.
SPEAKER_01Well, I think it's different modes, right? You're like, I'm in much smaller mode than either one of you guys, so it requires less. Craig, you're more in cruising mode, and then George, you're in builder mode. Builder mode, you have to be on. Yeah, you know, like you can't be in Craig, like you can't travel around like Craig and be a builder mode unless you want to just burn money. You know what I mean? So it's like you, it's like just different phases of it. And going back to what you said, George, we're all in different phases, and that's what I hate about some of these groups and stuff. Like, uh, and I've been guilty of doing this, is like preaching my doctrine to other people. And it's like, uh, but it's we're all in different spots, we're all we have different goals. Based on those goals, there's a straight line to get to those goals, and it's gonna be different depending on the goal.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, different fears, different desires, different skills, yeah, different beliefs.
SPEAKER_01But builder mode is fun, man. I I missed it so much. Like, I'm I miss it so much. It's ridiculous. It was such a good high. Uh yeah.
SPEAKER_02Have you ever done a time thing? It's the worst, but but it's really good when it's done. Like you a time journal. So you like you track every 15 minutes, you write down what you're doing for the day, and you could do it for as long as you can handle it, but you know, from a day you'll get a pretty good idea if you do it every 15 minutes, very difficult. But then you go back and look at it, even wait a couple days and look at it and go, holy shit, I spent a half hour and and you'll see all these things that you actually can eliminate that you think you had to do or that catch you off guard and you end up doing because it's easier just to do it. But the problem is we all do these things that oh, it's just easier if I just handle it. Like I'm the king of it's it's just easier if I just handle it. And what happens is you spend all day long handling all these things that you shouldn't be handling.
SPEAKER_00I was uh I was texting with uh with the agency a couple weeks ago, he's like 60, 70 million or something, and we where it's like a friendly competition, and I'm always talking crap to him. And uh he's like, dude, you're like three or four re-orgs from being where I'm at. And like I that really like made me pause and think, like, holy smoke, that he has some merit to this. Like, there's there's levels to scaling and how big your organization gets to support that level of demand from not just customers and prospects and marketing to to the people themselves and what they need to be successful, yeah. Um, so it's it's it's crazy.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and your your business has different needs at different stages, right? Like you hit certain places where you can't do anything, like you hit a ceiling unless you change stuff, right? I mean, insurance probably easier to scale from that perspective because it's just like you know, add more leads, add more collars, you know, just just keep adding the tinker toys, but still, you know, you get to those points where it's like, okay, you get to a certain point where you can't run the show anymore, you have to have an operator, right? Like, and then the next thing up, right? Then the operator has departments or whatever, right?
SPEAKER_01So it could get wacky. So the false belief is every stage is more work, right? That's not actually true. But I think to level up, because we all fill our days with 24 hours of stuff, right? And we all operate from our identity of who we are. So you have to change your identity to get to the next step. So removing all the stuff that you're used to doing, that's hard to do. So leveling up is hard initially, but it's easier once it's solidified. You know what I mean? So it's like every now, now I've gone backwards big time. Like I had to get rid of my whole sales team because of the California stuff. And now, in order to get back to where I was, it would be an incredible amount of work. Where it's like, if I would have just stayed where I was at, and let's say none of that stuff did happen, it would just be these incremental steps and it would it would start compounding like George. It's like it compounds and compounds. So, you know, it's it's like it goes back to that whole thing where consistency is like consistency trumps intensity every day. Like if I listened to this and I was, you know, Jason six years ago, I'd be like, dude, I could never get where George is. But I've seen what George has done and I've seen what a bunch of uh people in our community have done. And it was just like these steps where they they just kind of got to that next step, they pushed themselves, and boom, and then they're at that level. And then George is always doing that thing, like, how do I level up? You know, like I'm gonna buy another agency. Okay, like even though you know you just hired this team and you could just sit there and and have the success at that level, you're like, what do I do? And you just just add another piece, and you add another piece, and it just builds over time. Yeah. Uh yeah. It's like compound interest, it's the eighth wonder of the world, according to Benjamin Franklin.
SPEAKER_02Super cool. The building. Yeah, building is fun. I understand your your place because I think we're very similar. And like to peel it all off because somebody else created the situation and now you can't do it, it's very daunting and like to to even consider like rebuilding, right?
SPEAKER_01Like, well, I just I can't like yeah, my and they're yeah, they've set a ceiling to like you can't.
SPEAKER_00The maths, the math doesn't work.
SPEAKER_01The math doesn't work. It'll it'll work in two to three years. So it's like I just sit around at the from yeah, I do outside businesses, I guess. So OBOs, right? Is that what we put on our papers?
SPEAKER_00Yeah. OBAs. OBAs. So George. Outside business activities.
SPEAKER_02We've known you the whole journey, right? Like you, we met you when we were figuring this stuff out. What have you seen or what have you felt like you've changed along the way? Like when you came in, because you did it a little differently. Most people will incrementally scale. And I mean, you did have some incremental, but they were bigger increments. Like I think you started with eight with eight callers and tons of leads, and and really diving into how you were doing your, you know, growing your agency. So you started fast and hard and then went from there. But what like emotionally, how was that for you to where you are now? Like old George, what was old George like if if this version of George that is here now were to talk to that George, how would that guy respond to you? Like, hey, I'm gonna be riding half a million, or yeah.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, keep it up, just just keep grinding. Yeah. I mean, look, I had some really good perspectives coming in just because you know, if you got somebody that's coming in with absolutely no experience in the industry, like it's a different perspective. That's why you should always work with a high performing agency or or get in the business and do it yourself before trying to jump out and open a whole business up, right? So I I had a a vision of like what this could look like, and it's crazy because when I opened it up, it was like a hundred items was like you are just absolutely knocking the ball off the cover.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_00And you know, that was what I wanted to do, right? So I've been in that's what we started to do. It took me like eight months to get to that, much longer than what I thought I was gonna need. But you know, again, it's just about grinding and out and consistently pushing. But now, like it's a whole new game. Like, you what the because of how the compensation has been updated, at least for our company, and and a lot of carriers are different, you know, they're they're switching it or moving a lot of that compensation or front loading it to new business. You have to find ways to really scale your new business acquisition. And that's what we've done. We've really taken that in stride. The cash flow works in our market and it gives us the opportunity to continue to push the needle, and we just want to see how far we can take it. I I think uh it'll be a disservice for the business as a whole and for my leaders and for the salespeople in my office if I didn't try to continue to push the needle, is how I see it.
SPEAKER_02And you can't buy more beach houses if you don't push it.
SPEAKER_00Right. Yes, we can't buy more beach houses.
SPEAKER_02I mean, listen whoever's listening to this, you guys have to freaking see the size of Georgia's beach house. I I don't think I've ever seen a house this big on the beach.
SPEAKER_00Oh man, yeah, it's it's it's comfortable. It's a good investment property.
SPEAKER_02Freaking gigantic. How many square feet? Is it 5,000 square feet or something? 4,000 feet?
SPEAKER_00It looks like it because it's it's raised, right? It's in the flood zones on the beach, so it's it's it's raised. So it looks like it's three stories, but it's really two stories. But um, yeah, it's like three or three, two hundred or something.
SPEAKER_02This is really cool, really cool place. Yeah, it's booked fully booked.
SPEAKER_00We got it booked uh nearly like 90% from March through October, so we're pretty excited. Nice what what beach is it on? Navarre beach. So it's like 30 minutes west of Destin.
SPEAKER_01Okay.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_02I had a heck of a time going there. So now I'll get your special license. I lost my driver's license before we landed. So try to get my rental car and the whole thing. Oh my god. What a what a nightmare. Craig, you want to make a million dollars?
SPEAKER_01Get a get a videographer to just follow you.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I know, right? It'd be a lot like uh Steve-O or something.
SPEAKER_00I just watched Jackass 3 actually. We were in in Florida for like two weeks and we just saw that. And yeah, I think that's the only place that we're playing, was in Florida.
SPEAKER_02Jackass 3. Florida, man.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Thanks, thanks for the plug for the house. Absolutely. Yeah, bypass property management companies, reach out, definitely give you a sweet deal on the beach for your family.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, it's on here, I'm sure. The link will be in the show notes. Or if you want. Just email George. Well, what else? What's um so this is a great corner. What one piece of advice do you have for somebody who has now been an agent for three months and is starting to freak out?
SPEAKER_00Take a deep breath. I mean, seriously, I mean, that's that's really the position I was in when I met you. Honestly. Like, I was like, holy smokes. Like, I just got punched in the face by Mike Tyson. Um, but yeah, take a deep breath, connect, get get into the communities like this, really try to understand what you have to do to be successful in this business, and then start writing down what your processes are gonna look like. Like you have to have a consistent process. If you don't have a consistent process that your team is following, then you have nothing to measure. And if you can't measure it, you can't get better, right? Even if your process doesn't work, right? Like if you have a consistent process that doesn't work, you can pick apart that process and figure out what the root cause is, what's different sections you need to tweak, but you gotta have consistency. You can't just let people jump in and start having whatever conversation they want. It doesn't work like that.
SPEAKER_02Like 90% of the agents, like I did that's how we did it. We didn't have any processes forever, right? And it's like what a mess it becomes, you know. And so, I mean, that's you know, the first few years. I had the little manual that they have, but it's outdated, didn't even, and we didn't follow it. So when people get hired, you know, it's just like free flow, free flow, and that doesn't that's there's no you don't get anything from that. And it's it's interesting. Like that's what I would tell old Craig if I went back and talked to him, I'd say, Hey dude, processes because you can't remember the you know, the next time they ask you, you don't remember how you did it the last time, so then it's different, and every time it's different, and then it's like going to McDonald's, you know, in in Tucson and then going to McDonald's in Ohio, you get the same Big Mac, right?
SPEAKER_00They have consistent processes and recipes, right? And that's what you need to create in your organization. You can't create a different experience to each prospect and each client. Like you gotta have the same, assuming, top class experience, right? That's what you should expect for your people to provide to the prospects and all the investment that you're putting into this.
SPEAKER_02Because as one of our former guests, Laura Harris, once said, you cannot scale chaos. I like that. Well, you can, but it'll be very expensive, and and you're gonna have a lot more. Do you want to scale profit or do you want to scale chaos? Nice. And that's a carbs corner. Carbon, carbon corner, carbon corner, carbon, carbon corner.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman