The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Overcoming Sales Challenges in the Insurance Industry with Jorge Carbonell PART 1
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
We're doing it. And we're back with carbs. It's the carbs. What's up, guys? And we really are back. This wasn't like doing a back-to-back and we're just pretending to be back.
SPEAKER_00Huh. Yeah. We really are back. We are.
SPEAKER_03Why do we do that? Doo do we do that? We do do that. Okay. No. I just wanted to say doo-doo. Well, now that we've lost everybody, uh, we have Mr. Carbinol. I would say he's like the what is he, the king of Ohio?
SPEAKER_00We're competitive. Yeah, we're up there. We're up there.
SPEAKER_02That was great. I am going to go. We are 8. We are insurance.
SPEAKER_03Just like Abe From Man, Abe Froman is the sausage king of Chicago. You are the insurance king of Ohio.
SPEAKER_00I'd like to think that.
SPEAKER_01You are growing like a weed, my man.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, man. We're putting a lot of work into it and uh it's been fun. Yeah, I know last last call we had, we've you know said we were gonna do a lot of things, and I'm excited to talk about some of the things we've implemented and some of the things we've learned and keep grinding.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and I think that you were hiring a bunch right around the last time we talked. Yeah. I love this conversation because it's the uh the old, you know, Marcus Lamonis from The Prophet. Who likes do you guys like that show? I look it up. Oh, it's the best. Oh, that's that's my jam. It is my favorite show. Well, what he does is he he invests in different businesses and stuff. And his thing is the three Ps. You know, every business has people, a process, and product, right? Those are the three Ps of any business. But it's the people problem. The people problem, I think, is the biggest problem in any business. The process, once it's documented, it's there. The product in this case is already, I mean, the product's not going to change, right? Right. But it's the people. It's the people that we always struggle with getting more production, keeping them, you know, uh entertained, um keeping them on the team. So uh it hiring stuff.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. People are the ultimate wild card, right? You don't know, you never know what can happen, right? Sally could get run over by the bus, or Sally gets wins the lottery, or it's always Sally. Yeah, Sally.
SPEAKER_01So how's the hiring going?
SPEAKER_00It's it's good. We've been leveraging, and that was uh a couple years ago. I I went away from them, but you know, and I and I had some opinions on kind of how the algorithms were working with ideal traits. And you know, I'll tell you what, we've had a ton of success with using that platform recently and uh really throughout this entire year. And we've really dialed in, making sure that we're rating and had and being consistent with the right questions, grading um our candidates consistently, and the process to your point is written down now. Uh we were kind of doing ad lib, you know, last year and it kind of bit us in the butt. But now, you know, we haven't had to let anybody go, and nobody's left in pretty much the whole year, which is great. We at the end of last year, we hired people and like within two weeks, we either let them go or they left. Mostly let them go because we noticed very quickly it was not a good choice. But this year we haven't lost anybody and nobody and we haven't had to let anybody go. We just had a hiring class of three people that they were hired on June 1st, two weeks of training, and all of them are at 25 plus items in two weeks.
SPEAKER_01There you go.
SPEAKER_00And they just started selling, right? All three of them? All three of them, yes.
SPEAKER_01So what was that process like? How did you I mean, the chance of having three people at once work out like that is pretty remarkable, I think anybody can say. So what was the what's the magic sauce in that?
SPEAKER_00I mean, we we started it with people, it's finding the right people that fit your your culture, right? So you can interview for that. Like make sure you have the right culture interview questions, make sure you have the right motivational drivers through I mentioned ideal traits assessments. Um, they have a tool now, which I learned in our elite calls, and this is one thing I turned on right away was they can do like these video pre-screening interviews. So it's like they apply for the role, they do the assessment, they do the video interview, and then by the time they get to our actual Zoom interview, we're like 90% sure if we're gonna like you or not already. So we're like really weeding out a ton of candidates. So you get you know, two, three hundred people apply, and it you can quickly dwindle it down with very little efforts, where previously we'd have to screen them and waste a lot of time and set up these kind of meetings and waste time that oh man, that was a mistake. So um, yeah, it's becoming much more efficient.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. What are some of the things that you're looking for? You you mentioned um to make sure that they would fit your culture. What are some of the things specifically to your agency that you're looking for?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, the biggest thing for me is you you gotta be self-motivated. We ask a lot of questions about, you know, if you're behind on your goal, you know, everybody gets behind from time to time. You know, give me an example where you felt behind your goal and what did you do to not only meet it but exceed it? You know, I I want real examples. And well, you know, I I've coached my managers at this point because again, we would ask this question and you get a very basic answer. Oh, yeah, I work really hard and up, no, ask more questions. No, give me a specific example and give me very specific, actionable steps that you did to make sure that you got back from being behind. So, yeah, being self-motivated is one of the biggest ones.
SPEAKER_01What's another one?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, another one would be people oriented, right? You gotta be able to have a conversation. The common theme is people, right? We're not robots, we're not talking to robots. You gotta be able to hold a conversation, you gotta be able to tell a story, right? And that's that's another one that we look at. And how do you And then closing, closing people to do that? How to tell a story?
SPEAKER_01Well, no, because yeah, like because everybody comes in, they're talking, like how how do you decide whether or not that they're able to carry on a good conversation besides the because I feel like people come in for interviews and they're just full so full of it, like they they have their spiel that they're saying, you know, it's hard to decipher whether or not that's like actually how they talk or if it's you know.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, one of the questions that we ask now is um, you know, tell me a time where you changed uh a customer's perspective on something. So you'd have to they'd have to give you a specific example of maybe somebody calling in and you know, whatever it the question was and they didn't agree with it. Well, how did you how did you change their perspective? So they're gonna have to use examples and and and why these things are changing in our industry, and they gotta be able to portray that. So most of the people we're interviewing are already licensed, um, which helps with a lot of that ramp up period. A lot of agencies are going through a lot of churn, right? A lot of companies are tightening their underwriting, so they gotta let people go, or they're dialing back down on their marketing and investment, which you know, people want to be with agencies that are selling and operating still, right? We're commission-based, performance-based teams.
SPEAKER_01So I love it. And then closing. How do you find a good closer, my man?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, the the closing is a big piece of the assessment, right? So one of the traits is being a closer or a salesperson, um, and then it gives you like different scores, and then you on persuasiveness and again just closing skills in general, but we're looking for somebody that can be confident with asking for the close, right? Most salespeople go through the presentation and never ask for the sale. I don't understand, you know, you put in all that effort, you you built this relationship, and you leave it up to them to decide the next steps. It's important for us to take control of the conversations. So those are some of the traits that we're looking at for people for sure.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think that that's one of the toughest ones. How do you get somebody to overcome that?
SPEAKER_00Overcome, overcome like an objection or overcome that the fear of asking for the sale.
SPEAKER_01The fear of asking for the sale.
SPEAKER_00Don't be scared to ask. It's just a question, right? I mean, again, you we've just spent an uh 30 minutes, 45 minutes, an hour with this person on the phone. You deserve that. You deserve to ask for that sale, right? So empower your individuals and give them that confidence that you deserve to ask for that sale. And if it's not you, then who else, right? Someone else is gonna ask for it. Why aren't you asking for it when you just put in all this work? You know you're putting them in a better spot if you're following our processes. And even if we're 20, 30, 40, 50 more a month, right? Is the value that you provided in your advice worth another $20 a month, $30 a month, right? That's a dollar a day. So you gotta be confident in your conversations, and that's just through training and development.
SPEAKER_01But how do you get Sally to do that? Because Sally's not doing it. You're frustrated as the business owner. How do you approach that conversation?
SPEAKER_00So this is someone that is already quoting, right? And we're just seeing through our standards of performance, she's got she's let's assume that she's meeting her quote goals and her talk time is up there, but her sales aren't reflecting that, right? Yeah. We're looking at the numbers.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, because I think that's a problem that a lot of people have in their agencies, is you have this person, you can tell they're trying, right? So then it's like, oh, I can't fire them. Should I fire them or not fire them? You notice that they're doing the work, like that's the next step, right? You have the person that's not doing the work, pretty easy to fire that person. You know, they're putting in five minutes of talk time. It's like, dude, you're out, right? Um, but then you have that person that you do like, the team likes them, you like them, they're doing the work, they're doing the steps, they're a hustler, but it they're just not closing anything. And it's like, oh, should I fire them or what should I do? Or how do I approach it? Because you're telling her, dude, you got to close. And she's not closing. So it's like, how do you actually convert that person to closing?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's that skill versus will, right? If someone has the skills um but doesn't have the will, then they're just not trying. We're gonna let them go, like you said. Somebody has a will, you can see they're putting in the effort, the activity. Like, I'm excited to work with you and help you get better. But yeah, that's just a development thing. I think some of the things we do is listen to calls consistently and meet with these individuals and and make sure that we're not we're not only training in a group setting, but also in a one-on-one setting and provide that feedback, right? Are you trusting the process and having the full conversation? Don't pick and choose the parts that you want to follow, right? Because you're gonna see that, right? Again, we're human, we have our framework, the conversation we want to be having, but then sometimes we get too comfortable or we feel uncomfortable with asking these questions, so they pick and choose what part of the sales questions they want to ask. So make sure they're following the whole process because that that lets you know if they deserve to ask for the sale. Because if you didn't follow the process, then you're right, you didn't deserve to ask for the sale. Follow the process, and then you can then we can fix the problem saying, Hey, ask for the sale, right? You follow the process, you know you're doing a good job, you know you're helping this this prospect, this client, be confident and ask for the sale. And who do you bank with? It's it's a very easy question to ask at this point in the process.
SPEAKER_01100%.
SPEAKER_00That's the fun part. It is the fun part.
SPEAKER_03And that's like that's the big shift for them mentally when they go from that place where they're afraid to ask, where the and then they actually realize, oh, I need to ask, and I need to accept that I'm gonna get no's, you know, 80% of the time, right? I think that you know, think back to when you first started at sales and you're alerted, and and it was like each call you wanted it to close. And you didn't consider, well, at least in from my my perspective, I wasn't really considering the numbers, I was considering each deal and like, ah man, I didn't, you know, and and thinking about how I didn't get that one, which would put you in this place of not wanting to ask, right? And so I wonder if there's some of that, but what happens is you've insulated and protected yourself from that, right? Because you've done it both ways, where you've you've been reactive, you've hired only when you needed to, and and you've learned, as all of us have, that it's highly ineffective and terrible, right? Because you end up hiring the duds and then you just have this site. You become proactive and you're always hiring with this framework that that you follow. Well, now you're getting the right people more consistently because you're doing the right things following that framework, which then has the right people going through your onboarding funnel, right? And you're on them. Like it isn't let me let them run for a month and then I'll come back and check if they're freaking asking, right? It's like, no, no, no. Like if they're not asking for the business, you know in the first week. And if if they won't, then they they're gone, right? I mean, I've been in both both of those situations too, and telling the person, you know, a month after they've started that they need to ask for the business is much different than telling the person on the third day, you know, when they're still shaking and afraid to pick, you know, when they're still working out the kinks. Because now they're they're more likely to be able to develop that skill. On the other side, I think that the habit of being afraid is just too entrenched.
SPEAKER_00How many sales reps do you have now? No, how many because you because you guys have been really picking it up this year. How many uh how many sales reps are you at? Five?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, and I want to keep it at five. Like I it's it'd you know, like once you get in a six, it's seven, and then okay, now you need a lot of people to to you need a lot more leads, which is fine, because it all works out, but it becomes more to manage, you know? Yeah, I find five is uh okay. I I trust my ops guy is gonna handle it, and you know, but start getting into the 50k payroll, things change. Absolutely.
SPEAKER_00And it's and it's just running your own race, right? Like you know, what are your goals as a business owner? And five items gets you to or not five, five sales reps gets you where you want to be. Like, that's where you're shooting for. So can't be too stressed about what other people are doing.
SPEAKER_03But like I know we can get to I know we get to 200 to 250 with five salespeople. So, you know, we're right there. We're good, we're on pace for 170. That's that's fine, you know, all day long. It cash flows and it's great, and we're growing.
SPEAKER_00So that's what it's about. From not growing your dying.
SPEAKER_01You just hired a couple, right? What? You just a couple of them are new though, right?
SPEAKER_03Um, yeah, new er. Two of the two guys. I have two guys now, and um they both the same thing because like you know, George, we I'm doing the same thing you're doing. We've you know, we're always talking and doing these these same similar setup. I mean, we have the the constant candidates coming in, and then it's to that the onboarding, and I mean they know they're they're on the phones and they're making calls, and they are asking for the business immediately, right? As soon as they quote, then they're gonna be asking for it. And and like I know that they're listening to the calls. Like, if they didn't ask, the rest of the producers are gonna be all over them because people were all over them about not asking. So it's part of the culture now. Everybody knows you ask at least three times. Not did you ask? It's like, did you ask three times?
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman