The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Matthew Murray's Unique Path in Building a Successful Insurance Agency PART 2
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
People are going to die. And my wife is Romanian when we say morta este imminenta, which is death is imminent, right? And the closer that people get to death, the more they experience death. You know? Things happen. Your mom's 80. It's you're going to see your mom because you know that statistical likelihood of her passing away is higher than ever before.
SPEAKER_02I feel like a lot of our uh listeners are P and C agents maybe that are, you know, trying to sell more life insurance. It's a tough conversation. It's a tough transition. There's a lot of false beliefs when it comes to that conversation, a lot just being scared, you know, oh my God, I don't want to talk about somebody dying. What are some tips, false beliefs that you see agents coming into this conversation about final expenses and how can they overcome them?
SPEAKER_00They take the common objection that somebody already has insurance as an okay objection. Most people have life insurance through their job. Most people do. Right. It's very simple. Do you plan on working until you die? The answer is always what? No. Okay. So when you leave your job, what insurance do you have? None. None. Perfect. No issues. That's what I'm going to take care of. And I know it's a weird thing, and this is how I always say it. I know it's a weird thing talking about this to a random 34-year-old dude, you know, death and dying. But I promise you, me and you are going to talk about this one time. And then after that, you never have to worry about it again. Sound fair?
SPEAKER_03Ooh. I like it. Dude, you build up the fear that they all hate, which is talking about death, and then assure them they're never going to have to talk about it again. That's like, oh, thank you. Let's do it.
SPEAKER_00Where do I start? Luckily for you, I've been doing this for eight years, nine years. This is all I do. So I'm going to navigate these waters fast than you've ever seen.
SPEAKER_03I like fast.
SPEAKER_00Perfect. Me too. I'm not going to prod you. I'm not going to poke you. I'm not going to make you pee in a cup. You know? And listen, I'm the insurance man. So just don't lie to me. I got to ask your age if you're a woman. I might even have to ask your weight, but no one's going to know but me and you. Let's go ahead and knock it out. Okay. You know what I mean? So it's more of like, listen, I know you don't want to talk about it. No one does, but let's have it now. And you don't have to worry about it ever again. And you, anytime anybody ever brings it up, you can go, I got insurance through Matthew Murray.
SPEAKER_03The founder of Murrayville.
SPEAKER_00Founder of Murrayville. We got to get a post office first before I can run for mayor. Um I'm working on that. I'm working on that.
SPEAKER_03I mean, I have seen some towns with a post office that's like the size of a closet.
SPEAKER_00Listen, I'm gonna, it's gonna happen. I'm gonna run for mayor. Win or lose, it's good publicity.
SPEAKER_03I mean, I don't see how somebody named Matthew Murray couldn't win the race for mayor of Murrayville. It seems like a can't lose opportunity.
SPEAKER_00I'm I better not lose because I'm gonna be the first mayor.
SPEAKER_03You'd be the first mayor of Murrayville.
SPEAKER_00It's it, dude.
SPEAKER_03The goal remarkable.
SPEAKER_00I appreciate it. I appreciate it. Yeah, no, life insurance conversations can be weird, but it's only weird if you, as the agent, makes it weird. It's not it's not as weird as people think. What's weird is when you say things like, if you die, yeah. That's weird. That's a weird thing to say to somebody, right?
SPEAKER_03If you die.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, you know, but people are gonna die. Uh, and and my wife is Romanian when we say morta este imminenta, which is death is imminent, right? And the closer that people get to death, the more they experience death, you know, things happen. Your mom's 80. It's you're going to see your mom because you know that statistical likelihood of her passing away is higher than ever before.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, dad died last year. I mean, I have proof.
SPEAKER_00It's it's scary, it sucks.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, right?
SPEAKER_00But like, do you have something in place? If you do, great, I'm gonna review it. If you don't, great, we're gonna talk about it. Do you see how there wasn't an option there?
SPEAKER_03Yep.
SPEAKER_00Yep. I got your home and auto quote right here. Perfect. Okay, if something would happen to like when if you pass away.
SPEAKER_03If?
SPEAKER_00Yeah. When you pass away, if you pass away during this mortgage, oh yeah, how long is your mortgage? Uh it's another 20 years. 20 years? How much do you owe on it?
SPEAKER_03790,000. Your wife work? No, she's well, I mean, she's she's the big you're the big moneymaker, aren't you? Yes.
SPEAKER_00You're the big money maker, aren't you?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, Burger King.
SPEAKER_00All right. Now in this situation, you're dead. Mary, what are you gonna do when he dies? If the if the more if he dies tomorrow and the mortgage needs to be paid.
SPEAKER_03Well, I mean, I could only see one option.
SPEAKER_00You know, it's it again, it's kind of this weird, this weird thing, but like mortgage protection insurance is a term policy designed to take care of the mortgage. You know, if the person were to pass away during a certain time period of the mortgage, it's gonna pay off the mortgage. Very simple concept of a life insurance. It's a life insurance policy, it's a term policy. But just as you've gotten really good about, hey, can I can I quote you on your home and auto? I don't know PNC, so I don't know that if that's how that's brought up, right? But if it if it was, it's as easy as saying the same exact thing.
SPEAKER_03We we do the same thing. Hey, we got a request for your quote. Uh we're gonna go ahead and and wrap that up. We just have to confirm some stuff, right? Our our callers, our we have the the callers that preset, like they they just quickly make sure somebody that somebody answered the phone because only one in or ten in in a hundred leads answer the phone, right? So those ten get found, pushed over to the producers quick, right? And then the producer does the hey uh got got your information here, just have to confirm a couple things. Oh, I'm at lunch, I can't talk right now. Oh, great. Great, great news, it's gonna be really quick. Do you still live at 5555 East First Street, right? Boom, boom, boom. Rattle through it. And then if we keep them on the phone for two minutes, we're gonna quote them. And it's just a fact. 100 million dials. So uh it's been pretty interesting. It's like it's the same thing for you, right? You once you understand the mechanics or the the the the numbers for you for your funnel, it's just plug and chug.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, you just reverse engineer it, and and then it I know that any agent, if they have 20 conversations about this and they quote it out, if they suck, and this is the important part, and you will, you'll close 30%.
SPEAKER_03Right.
SPEAKER_00But here's the best part you're gonna suck less every week. And the compounding effect from 30% to 50% is ridiculous amounts of dollars. You just get better at quoting and you get better at the objections and things to say or things not to say when someone says something. It's it's again, I need to think about it. What would you say to that?
SPEAKER_02What would you like to think about?
SPEAKER_00I just, you know, I need to think about, you know, I got to talk to my wife, but see, you you've you've given them the option to open up to anything. I'll say, Craig, actually, that's a good idea. Uh, there's three things I want you to think about before buying an insurance policy. One is do you like the company? Do you like American Amicable? Do you like how long they've been in business? Do you like their financials? Do you like their credit business buyer rating? Do you like that company? Sure. The answer is usually going to be yes. Is the second thing is do you like the price? Is the price affordable? Is it too high or too low? I can make a go up if you want to.
SPEAKER_03No, I just like to look at, you know, I've always gotten three things, one from each place.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and the price is good, right? You've already you've already done a couple of those. Yeah, it's okay. But the third and most important thing is do you like the person getting it to you? And if you don't like me, I'm terribly sorry. I can go and hang up on it. Oh no, I like you. You're cool. Then what else is there to think about?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, you make a good point.
SPEAKER_00I gave them the things to think about and had them think about it live. Right. And then I told them there's nothing else to think about. But if you say, what do you need to think about? That gives them so many opportunities of random things to say, and now you're trying to undo that. Right? So that's a objection that I love the most because I want you to actually think about it right now.
SPEAKER_03Let's do it. Yeah, agree. You agreed. Think about it. Yeah, I love it.
SPEAKER_00Let's think about it for sure.
SPEAKER_03Would you run through that one more time for Mr. Jason? Because sometimes he doesn't catch it all.
SPEAKER_00Sure. Uh, you know, you I need to think about it, Matthew.
SPEAKER_03This is this looks okay, but I need to think about it.
SPEAKER_00Perfect. Actually, there's three things I want you to think about before buying an insurance policy. Will you do that for me?
SPEAKER_03Sure.
SPEAKER_00Sure. One is do you like the company? Do you like company A, right? You know about hopefully if you're selling them, you know a little bit about the company, right? Yes. Do you like the price? Is it too high or is it too low? Is the price affordable for you? I can make a go up if you want me to. I can make it go up if you want me to. No, the price is good. Okay. And the third and most important thing is, do you like the person getting it to you? Because if you don't like me, I am so sorry. I must have failed.
SPEAKER_03I I love the phrasing of it too. Do you like the person? And then it's back to you.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, because you're selling yourself.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. But you're saying the person, like, you know.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Yeah. It's so different. You like the person getting it to you? If you don't like me, oh man, I'm so sorry, man. I messed a screwed up. No, I I like you, man. You're a really good guy.
SPEAKER_03Okay.
SPEAKER_00Then what else is there to think about? Let's go ahead and knock it out.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, you basically put it on them where if they say no, they don't like you.
SPEAKER_00Exactly.
SPEAKER_03Oh, it's so solid. That is awesome.
SPEAKER_00I love I love sales, man. I could talk about sales objections and closes all day long. It's my favorite thing to do.
SPEAKER_02What are like as we are, Craig was talking about AI and the world a shift in. Um, what are some of the things that we are ex or that you're excited about uh going forward? And what are some things that agents need to look out for?
SPEAKER_00I think that the in the life insurance world, in the Medicare world, a lot's change really rapidly. Uh Medicare is, you know, CMS government run, if you will. And things things change very rapidly. If it's government run, by a stroke of a pen, something can just change overnight. And but with big change comes enormous opportunity for those that know how to navigate the waters. We all, we all, and this is Jim Rohn, we all get the same wind. It's how we adjust our sails, determines our destination.
SPEAKER_03That's how you do it.
SPEAKER_00We can all get to shore. If you guys are going against the wind, I'm just going to turn my boat a little bit and ride the wave and get to shore quicker.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Things, things are forever changing. There's always a thing that happens. This, these big, you know, and we were all in these big Facebook groups and these wild changes happen in the industry and everybody freaks out. Yeah. Yeah. Right? COVID happened. This the crazy thing happened. Oh man, things are crazy. Look at us today. Look how much has changed today. We navigated those waters and changed rapidly.
SPEAKER_03Right.
SPEAKER_00And the people that did change during that time made millions of dollars.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, buddy.
SPEAKER_00And and there's there's things that are changing today, still with AI, with marketing, with insurance all over the world, different types of insurance. You could just get lost in insurance all day long. But when you understand it and you can be calm and chaos, be a beacon of light for people, they're gonna want to come to you.
SPEAKER_02That is a mic drop right there.
SPEAKER_00Awesome, dude.
SPEAKER_02Hey, thanks, man. Where can people get a hold of you? Where where are the social media channels that you're on?
SPEAKER_00And uh mostly mostly on Facebook. Uh that's where I I spend most of my time. Um, but I'm trying to understand Instagram. It's still weird to me. I feel like an old man, you know. Um but it's it's Matthew Murray on Facebook. I'm meta verified for whatever that means. Uh same thing on Instagram. Um, it's Murray the Marketer, is what my handle is on Instagram, and I'm on TikTok as well. Uh, you're just gonna see a bunch of me in my uh random walks uh of me talking about my dog and random things that are happening and random sales closes. Um but I just love at any point, if I can ever help anybody, I'm just here to chat. If I've got free time, I'll chat. The problem is is I keep telling that to people, so I get less and less free time.
SPEAKER_02Right.
SPEAKER_00So, you know, I have a YouTube channel. Uh I I study the the mindset of an entrepreneur or a business owner, and it's called business backstage. It's kind of flipped now, so I wish I could do it. But it's my grandfather ran the first and largest real estate school in California. And when people would make a lot of money, he would bring them into his office and he'd be like, you know, what who are your buyers? Who are your sellers? How did you do this? How did you source this? And he would find the common denominator of what made a successful real estate agent. And it wasn't because they were white or because they were black or their their heritage or anything like that. It was something inside of them that unlocked one day. And so, you know, he's passed away, and I was driving one day with my wife, and I have all these crazy business ideas, as most entrepreneurs do, and it just clicked for me one day. And I was like, oh, I am going to have a podcast room in my own house, and I'm gonna invite people to my house, and I'm gonna do a podcast with them and learn about who they are, why they own the business they do, and like what is it about them that makes that that makes them want to hunt for steak versus being fed soup. And there's there's something something drastic happened in someone's brain, you know. I something changed in that person. And there's a common denominator there, and I'm there to research it for the rest of my life. So insurance makes me money. Uh, the this business backstage thing is a dream or a hobby of mine. So it's on YouTube, it's on Spotify, you can go watch it. Business backstage, Matthew.
SPEAKER_03I'll tell you right now, you keep doing that with just that that goal, and it will become the main hustle.
SPEAKER_00I appreciate it, man. That means a lot.
SPEAKER_03I mean super cool. Dude, I mean, we have very successful insurance agencies. I'm not saying it to you know be some weirdo, but but like the they're great thanks to our awesome teams, you know, running with the playbook that we put out there, but the side hustle, insurance dudes, became basically the main hustle.
SPEAKER_00So I appreciate it, man.
SPEAKER_03Helping. Just help.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I I fell into love with podcasting from my practice company or my previous company. The owner at the time said, I want to do a podcast every single week. Matt, go build out the podcast room. And I built like a $10,000 to $15,000 studio with all the right equipment, right? And I knew nothing. Nothing. And then I was like, hey, the room's ready. He's like, I don't want to do it anymore. You do it. And I was like, All right. And I just started interviewing, you know, insurance agencies that were working with our agency. Yeah. Right. And and all I was doing was just I was getting to talk to multimillionaires about their business. And I'm like, okay, I know you're we all know you're an insurance because you're here, but like, why insurance? Why did you start? What is this? And so I started falling in love with podcasting, and it really grew the c it helped grow the company. And then I was like, oh, I'm supposed to be I think I'm supposed to be podcasting and just making content and insurance will happen. So I love the advice. Thank you so much, guys.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Awesome, man. Well, we appreciate you uh jumping on the podcast and hanging out here with us for almost an hour now. Almost an hour.
SPEAKER_00Well, with a little break, because I talked about AI, I made it a little bit longer. So it was only three minutes.
SPEAKER_03And you made nice with it.
SPEAKER_00You did. So I've been winging it for 34 years, boys.
SPEAKER_03If you learned something today, it's just be careful what you say about Mr. GPT. That's it. Well, thank you so much, Matthew. Awesome to uh have you on, and uh in your group, and uh thanks, man. Thanks for what you're doing for A.
SPEAKER_00Absolutely. Thank you, Gingo.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman