The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Matthew Murray's Unique Path in Building a Successful Insurance Agency PART 1
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
Hey everybody, my name is Matthew Murray over in Murraysville, North Carolina. The craziest thing that ever happened to me in my agency is I walked in during COVID to someone getting their hair cut with their barber in the office.
SPEAKER_01And who are you? Oh, you already did that. Yeah, he said he's Matthew Murray. Okay, but you gotta you gotta do it, and I'm an insurance dude. Oh, we didn't tell him that.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, you didn't tell me that before. Craig. Okay, do it. And and I'm an insurance dude.
SPEAKER_01I'm gonna go. I am going to do it. We are insurance.
SPEAKER_02We are insurance. I mean, the one thing that Jace and I like, if if somebody says, and I'm an insurance dude, we could be anywhere. We'll just go boom. That is the thing.
SPEAKER_00I like that. You know, I say I say all the time that the only people that want to talk about insurance are insurance agents. Insurance isn't sexy, but the money's X-rated, right? And so I find, you know, I do a podcast, I train agents all day long, and I'm like, man, I love insurance. And but it's like the best repellent in the world if you're at a party, you go, hey, I you know, I sell insurance, right? And people walk away. Yeah. It's so true. If I don't want to talk to somebody, I just be like, hey, I sell insurance, like, oh, I got it. I'm like, see ya.
SPEAKER_02Ned the head, needlenose head, got the shingles real bad in seventh grade. Yeah. That's right. Bing!
SPEAKER_01Bing. Well, cool, man. Yeah, how did you get into this crazy world? Take us back to uh when you were young and dying to just get dive into the insurance world. God, that must have been back when I was 60.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, right. When I when I went to bed praying at night saying I'd like to sell final expense insurance on a commission only basis, please. Like no one, no one's ever said that prayer, right? Um, I was uh I dropped out of high school twice. I never never went to college. Uh I became a finance manager, which is Southern for Finance, and uh my office got broken into twice in one week, and they blame me for it. So as a 25-year-old dude with no college education that that live was living, you know, two hours away from home that got fired, my friend said, Hey, you want to do something with some old people and some insurance? And I said, 100%. I'm coming to work on Monday. And I watched this guy that made a million dollars a year. We're gonna air quotes it because I don't really know. Who knows to this day? He's still a mentor of mine and we talked, but he dressed in a fancy fit suit. He said, blah, blah, blah, commission percent. You know, if you collect a $50 check, we're gonna pay you $315. And then he went on to the next slide. And I remember sitting front row at this uh sales, you know, event thing, you will. And I raised my hand real high and I said, Can you rewind the tape like five minutes for me? And he went, What? And I went, I have three questions for you. Is that legal? How many times can I do it in a day? And where the hell do I get my license?
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_00And that was on a Monday. And on Monday, he said, Um, you know, you can you can do it as many times as you want, as long as you have your license, and you should you study and get your test and blah, blah, blah. And I said, What if I pass it tomorrow? And he said, Um, yeah, I mean, technically you you could get it. You should study. And I said, Well, no one ever asked the doctor what they made on their test. They just know doctor. So I didn't study. I passed with a 71 and got my insurance license the next day. No way. Yeah. And then I on Wednesday, I got, you know, my actual license. You had to take the exam, Pearson View. Wednesday, I got my actual license. This was in Columbia, South Carolina. So I just drove to the Department of Insurance in South Carolina, paid the fee, got it the same day, got contracted on Thursday, and on Friday, um, they they told me about these things called leads. Has anybody ever heard of leads? And I was like, You're gonna give me people that want this stuff too, and you're gonna pay me? I was like, This is the best job of the world. But the lead wasn't an actual lead, it was a walk list, it was a mailing list. And so I just had an Excel spreadsheet. And the first door I knocked on, her name's Miss Jocelyn. I'll never forget her. I knocked on the door, she thought I was the police, and she opened the door and I said, Hey, you filled out a card about insurance. She goes, No, I did not. And I said, The only reason I'm here is because you did. So we got to do this. And she says, Come on in. So I sat down with her and I got real close with her and I said, Mary, Jocelyn, I don't know what I'm doing. But what I do know is if you give me a $50 check right now, I'm gonna make $300. I didn't say that. I said, I should get you exactly I did the math at $10,183. And she looked at me, she goes, For real? I said, Yes, ma'am. That's what he told me. And that's what he told me. We and she didn't even know I didn't she didn't know the company. She said, You write the check for me. I wrote, I did it for her. Oh my god. Did the application she got approved? I knocked on six doors that day. I got into four homes because four people were home. I did the exact same presentation and sold four policies. The next Monday.
SPEAKER_01On your first day, you were like the superhero. But but this is your third day, like since you heard of this, right? Yeah, Monday I heard about it. Friday four, six.
SPEAKER_00Monday, you didn't even know what insurance was. Couldn't tell you. The next Monday, the because they had the it was a it was a big recruiting model, you know, MLM type, yeah, type place. Uh Monday, I go, I'm sitting there like all pumped up. I got, I'm like, damn, got I got all this money. And the guy starts talking again and does the exact same presentation of how much money you can make. And I raised my hand again and he went, yes, sir. I said, when do we get paid? He said, What do you mean? I said, I got four applications here with four checks for $50 each. By my calculations, you owe me $1,260. And he said, You got you did four? And I said, Yes, sir. He goes, Did you send these to the home office? I said, You didn't say anything about a home office. You just told me to collect checks. He goes, Wait a second, you got four fifty dollar checks? I said, Yeah. He said, What if it cost more? What if they wanted more? I said, You didn't tell me that. You told me to collect a $50 check. I was that dumb when I first got. I was legitimately just tell me what to do. I'm gonna go make money. Yeah. Right. Oh, it's so good. And so he goes, You want to teach the class? And I said, Boy, do I ever, this is the best thing in the world. So I started teaching agents on how I would they're like, How did you do it? And I'm like, I just walked up to him and thought give me a check, and they need this much insurance. Um, but then you know, reality set in and I sit in the home office, and the people did get approved, but the commission percent wasn't exactly how it was, and a 50% advance, and blah blah, you know, all these different things started happening. And I worked there for about two years and started to learn, and then I just kind of transitioned into a more of a broker and uh just kept going from there.
SPEAKER_01I love it. That is so so many lessons within that that period of this of the story, the first five days, because I love the fact that how many times this is the best sales lesson on the planet, A. You don't need to know anything about anything before you do something. And a lot of times, almost everybody that I talked to about sales or even just doing a new venture is like, okay, I need the list, I need the the all the background, I need to like be the best at whatever, right? You just went in, took the test. You could have failed it, who cares? Like you know, you just did it, you took action. And then the other thing was the fact of uh you you knew nothing about the product, but you you just went to sell it. I mean, that is it's almost like you put the least amount of thought possible, which created the most amount of results.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. I I decided to become ignorant in what I was doing.
SPEAKER_02Well, you were you had to sell yourself instead of the thing because you didn't know the thing. You know yourself, which is creating the rapport, boom. 100% because that's all sales is, right? 50% of it minimum is rapport, right?
SPEAKER_00Yeah. There you go. But I didn't they never ask me what company it was and all this stuff. I just said, look, I'm I'm giving dollars for pennies, you know. I I couldn't believe it. I said, look, and I I'm country, so I had like the the paper applications. I'm like, look, they even told me like I got this king called a conditional receipt, and I like I like licked it, I didn't have scissors, you know, I did that and like ripped it off. And I was like, you know, if they say you're approved on the phone and you give me a check, if I leave here, an acorn hit you on the wrong side of the head, you're covered. This is the craziest thing. I was like, I can't believe this. This is real. And they're like, Really? I'm like, I'm telling you, they keep telling me it's real. And I just kept selling, just kept selling.
SPEAKER_01But dude, that's how simple it really is. But like the complication comes within, right?
SPEAKER_02What do I say when they say this? What do I everybody future trip?
SPEAKER_01The policy, yeah. It's like all those things.
SPEAKER_00So well, yeah, people people get ready to get ready.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah. Yeah, you're ready to get ready to get yeah. My first sales job was selling cars, which probably was one of the best learnings or you know, things to just get thrown into. I didn't know anything. The first month I was salesman of the month because I didn't know anything. Like, I just would go up to everybody, just everybody. They call it on the when you work it, they call it an up, like taking an up. So the people that walk on the lot are ups. And like I learned very quickly that you can't just hand out the the brochure, right? Like that I was I was basically selling it for the guy down the street. And one of the older guys came and he said, Hey, you just need to freaking close them. You can't give them the thing or they're gonna walk down to Toyota and buy a Toyota because you did all the work, and now the other guy just has to close them. So, you know, finish it. And so I started he told me what to do, and that was it. I just but it was because I was taking all the new ones and I didn't like pre-qualify them or think they couldn't do it or whatever, right? Like you just went in, it didn't matter. It didn't matter how bad their house looked, you know, it didn't, it didn't matter. You just freaking went in there and they were gonna buy, and you were excited about it. And I was excited about these stupid Chevy Malibu's back in '98, you know, and made people buy it. I mean, it was a great car, yeah.
SPEAKER_00It's and I I know I sold a very specific type of insurance. It was final expense. It still is final expense. I'm a final expense nut. I know it sounds weird, but I'm more of a senior citizen nut. It's it's grown into hospital indemnity and Medicare and all these different things. But I'm a I was a final expense guy because it was very easy for me to understand. You are going to pass away. Proof. Yes. You need this. I have this. You want this. The sale was over for me. It was like, and even today, I train agents all day long and they come up with all these crazy objections. And it's just like when you realize there's only really seven main objections that happen. That's it. It comes down to the people don't trust you or it's not affordable to them.
SPEAKER_02Right.
SPEAKER_00But if I sit down with somebody about life insurance, I look at them as they're crazy if they don't want to buy from me because why am I here? Right. You know what I mean? Like I set an appointment, you filled out a card, you filled out a form on Facebook, right? Less than 1% of people fill out a form. You would never, ever, ever walk to your mailbox, bring it back in, sort through the mail, find a working pen, put your personal information on a card, lick the envelope, walk back to the mailbox, put a stamp, put it back in the mailbox, and put your flag in, right? That's crazy. But that's the demographic that is final expense in Medicare. And so it's kind of like if Craig ordered a pizza and he said, Hey, instead of spaghetti sauce, I want peanut butter. And instead of cheese, I want half cooked spaghetti noodles. And instead of pepperonis, actually, I want pepperonis, but I'm gonna put gumballs on there too. We'd all agree that's a really weird pizza. Less than 1% of people ever would do that, right? But if I knocked on Craig's door and I held the pizza like this, and Craig looked at me dead in the eyes and go, I didn't order that, I would look at him like he's crazy. Because the only reason I'm holding this pizza and I have a job is because you ordered this. Right, right. And so the mentality of for leads for me was very simple. People did an action in order for me to have a reaction to be here. And so it's a very, very simple thing. And then I started learning about, you know, marketing and leads, and I got really good at Facebook leads and just got in the mindset of a senior citizen. And it's been it's been fun ever since, man. I've been I love it.
SPEAKER_01So what was the next hurdle?
SPEAKER_00I mean, that that had to be tough when you realize like these policies didn't go through, these guys are kind of what the the biggest thing that that I had to overcome very early was because I was so new and naive and ignorant that I didn't get the contract that was even street, that wasn't even like an okay contract to give out to an agent. And I quickly realized I was at the bottom of this pyramid scheme. And so for the only way for me to get to the top is if nine people die, quit, or change their mind. But I love the pe the culture that I was with. It was some of the best training that I've ever received, ever. They taught me how to dress, they had to taught me to talk, they taught me how to walk, they taught me the Colombo method of selling. You know, one more thing. Yeah, just hey, just real quick, one more thing before I get out of here. You could do that, just keep going and keep going eventually. People are like, All right, I'll I'll freaking buy it from you, right?
SPEAKER_02Oh, wait, yeah, there's I love it. Yeah, just real quick.
SPEAKER_00But they taught me those things, but I I realized that I wasn't going to move up because of how the system was set. There was a guy that had a 120-point contract. I had a 50. So that means there's so many people in between. And I'm going, Well, how am I supposed to get to there? And they were like, Oh, well, just keep selling, just keep selling. And I would go and recruit, and because I was their I was their main recruiter because I was good on stage and talking to people and getting to so all the new people would come up to me and be like, Man, are you doing like, is this really fun? I'm like, Yeah, it's the greatest job in the world. You talk to old people all day long and they teach you stuff and you get make money. Like, this is the best thing ever, you know. Um, but the the hurdle was was trying to figure out and being okay with leaving that culture in in knowing or not knowing that I'd still be friends with those people today because I love people. I like, you know, making friends. And so I thought, well, if I leave this place, then they're gonna hate me. So I had to get past that. And I can tell you that those people don't hate me, that those same people offered me a job when I left my previous position, that they still want me to work with them. Yeah. Right. And they love me. And we're still friends, like we're still friends, you know. So it if if you're an agent, if you're watching this and you're you're kind of like, man, I'm kind of stuck in this thing, you're not. The insurance business is such a good opportunity for anybody, and it's kind of like it's like an upside down tree. Once you get rooted, those roots spread out everywhere. You have so many opportunities. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02So what what year did you start?
SPEAKER_002015.
SPEAKER_02Okay. So a lot's changed in digital marketing and the and the landscape. There was uh some kind of weird event happened in the middle there between uh today and everybody got sick. Yeah, somebody got sick. I don't know. Something, but uh, but talk about how you've adjusted the mechanics of your marketing as as time has progressed and as you've become higher up on the food chain.
SPEAKER_00I I wouldn't say that much has changed. It's more of uh from the marketing's perspective, the only thing I would say has changed rapidly is the how fast people intake information. So when's and I'll go super nerdy here if you want me to, but when when someone's scrolling through Facebook, you've got about a one point one to one point two second chance to get them to stop on your ad. Yeah. And if you pull if anybody pulls out their phone right now and looks at their Facebook, it's gonna be something relevant to you, something relevant to you, ad. Relevant, relevant, ad, relevant, relevant ad. And no one can tell you what the 14th ad on their Facebook profile was today. Right. And so it's the the the the trick is is to get them to fill out the information that you need as soon as possible and get them back to Facebook, get them back to where they were at before. Don't disrupt. And then most people tell me, most people have told me in my career that as soon as a lead comes in, you're supposed to do what? Call them wrong personally.
SPEAKER_02No, but I'd be well, I was the answer, what most of the people would say.
SPEAKER_00That that is yeah, exactly. That's what they that's what they say. But I think that's wrong because I, for the first after about a year of doing the first company, I didn't want to pay for direct mail. So I started learning digital advertising. And all I did for the next year to two years was I was doing Facebook ads in 2017. I would go to that person's house, and this is my entire presentation during those two years. I'd go, Craig, I know you're gonna buy insurance from me because why the hell else would I be here? You fill out a form on Facebook, right? About this. What I want to know is what made you click on this? Was it the picture? Was it the the wording? What did you not like? What did you like? You know, what is your experience as a client from seeing all these new things? And so I have hundreds and hundreds of copious notes of clients telling me what they like and didn't like about the process. And so I adjusted the process to make the client experience feel like it's not even sales. Does that make sense? Yeah. So it's it's, you know, we all use automations and CRMs and blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. Right. But the ones that, you know, as soon as Lee comes in, dialer, cis call, Mary, you must be looking for insurance right now. No, I was sitting on my couch watching a TV show and I saw your ad. So I kind of, you know, slowly but surely allow the seniors to engage with me or the automation, if you will. And it takes about a 20 to 25 minute ramp up period. But then the propensity score of that person filling out uh an appointment or actually remembering why they filled out a form is much higher if you allow them to stair step their way into it versus being like, you fit out a form about insurance. You better, you better call me right now. It's it's changed so much. And now, because of the FCC rules are changing, you know, there's a there's a lot of one-to-one stuff that a lot of agents that don't know how to market, um, it's becoming more of a superpower in today's economy.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. A lot of opportunities being created right now.
SPEAKER_00100%.
SPEAKER_01So, what would you say are a few tips that you would give someone who uh might be less capable in that venue that might be everybody is just as capable, copy, but don't paste.
SPEAKER_00Copy and enhance. Kanye West, as crazy as he might be, copied other people's things and made it better, right? So you can go to Facebook ad library right now and look up an ad and copy somebody else's ad, but then mimic it, master it, make it your own. You know, mimic what they're doing, master it, and then make it your own thing.
SPEAKER_02Model it if it works, yeah.
SPEAKER_00If it's if you see a Facebook ad on odd and it says it's been running for two months, it's a pretty good likelihood that that's a good ad. Where can they find that? Facebook ad library.
SPEAKER_02Look at that.
SPEAKER_00Jason was curious. Yeah, listen, it's it's completely free because of uh what happened in 2020 during the election. Um, they made it to where very transparent where all ads have to be able to be searched, and so all you have to do is as is a Google Facebook ad library, type in whatever type of insurance you want to copy, you'll see all these different types of creatives and pictures and ads. Okay, screenshot, save that onto your desktop and make something similar, but then make it your own thing. Right. And start testing it, you know. But you you have to be willing to lose a little bit of money in order to get better at it.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah. I feel like some new things have come out over the year, over the last year. Uh that I can't have uh in the tech world. What kind of things or how have you used like LLMs, you know, the the various like you know, anthropic or or chat GBT, like how have you incorporated these new tools that are so insanely different than what we had access to before?
SPEAKER_00I s I steer away from them.
SPEAKER_02Oh, interesting.
SPEAKER_00Um, I think and again, I'm speaking more from a uh senior-focused final expense Medicare, hospital indemnity type client. If technology is weird for me, you, and you and most people on this call because it's evolving really rapidly. Think of how scary it is for a senior that they don't even know if the if the person they're talking to is a real human at this point. And so if you can go away from it and be like, hey, I'm a real person. I'm from here. It's me. I'm gonna, hey, you know, they feel like, oh, the sigh of relief that comes from that is immediate trust factor. Now, I'll use Chat GPT for Excel formulas and you know things that I'm really bad at. But when it comes to advertising, I stay far away. I know it sounds weird. I think the AI will it get really, really advanced to where it's almost kind of crazy. I mean, who knows if you guys are even real at this point. I got I got invited to come on to some uh famous podcast, and I don't know. You guys sound like you're you're surrounded by pillows. Who knows if you guys are real at this point? You know, not real. Exactly. But you sound fantastic.
SPEAKER_02So um if you want to have some fun, go go to uh I'll I'll tell you uh uh at a different point. I'm not trying to plug my other thing, but I have uh uh another thing that's all AI, and uh it's it's interesting because it's it's it's goofy and wonky. You can you can like the voice you can't tell, I don't think, but the uh the video's a little weird, but it's all AI. I think that there's a lot to to learn from that. Like it it is definitely something that's gonna um replace a lot of tasks, right? Like at first everybody was having the shock and doom, doom and gloom, everybody's jobs gone, 80 million jobs, all this stuff. Now it's more like, well, maybe not that, but a lot of tasks, right, are gonna are gonna get AI'd away. And I think the folks that are able to capitalize on some of that are probably gonna be a little bit ahead, be able to move quicker. I definitely think that you can't be putting something in front of customers that's gonna freak them out, but people are gonna become pretty used to, at least on the front end, seeing these conversations, you know, like with a like a vo you you can't even tell the difference with some of them.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah, 100%. I mean, I use I use Chat GPT quite a bit from like Excel spreadsheets and video editing. I mean, it's insane. Oh, yeah, what it can do. I mean, it it cuts down the the frames, the time frame from something that used to take six hours, 20 20 minutes.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Once you set the rules on it, it's it's crazy what it does.
SPEAKER_02It's wild. Yeah, yeah. And that's what like I just look from from a bit like a actually like a business aspect, like not even client-facing, like let's just leave that off. But like business wise, there's so many things in an agency that agents, you know, we're PNC, but we do some life, you know, your final expense. There's all this day-to-day crap that people do that they get that basically eats into the time for a for uh sales first organization, right? Like, really, at the end of the day, all of the agents need to sell, right? That's it. Selling, sure. Like their number one activity is to talk to people, to have these appointments like you had, or for our sales agents to be on the phone doing home and auto quotes. Like if they're not doing that, it's costing us money, right? And if we could like do do account paperwork or processing billing or renewals or whatever, like all these things that that classically we would have a human do that really didn't require a human can make us so much more nimble, you know?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I I I agree in a lot of ways. I'd I'd also say that like a dog chasing cars. I'm not sure what to do when I actually caught one, but I don't I don't I'd I'd say that AI is not gonna take anybody's job. It's the person that doesn't understand AI. Yeah, their job will be taken. You you have to make AI your, for lack of better words, we're gonna say a B word. We all know what I'm saying. We know what I'm saying. You gotta make it, you gotta make it your own thing. Like I I speak my Chat GPT, like that's not good enough. You need to do better. Rewrite this. Like I train it. The the prompts prompting Chat GPT is more important than Chat GPT.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Well, that's learning how to get it to write the way that you write and act and speak the way that you speak is the important part of how to categorize. Write me an essay on donkey and talk about the differences to the different types of donkeys and how big their teeth are and what most people call them, and this is what uh how I want it written. Yeah, you know, prompting it, it'll spit out exactly what you need. But if you have to keep going back in and keep going back in, it's gonna get worse and worse and worse.
SPEAKER_01Yes.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, 100%.
SPEAKER_01That's the intelligence part of the artificial intelligence is that you can continue that conversation and get it better. It's just like training one of your team members or something, I think. Yeah, exactly right.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman