The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
How AI is Transforming Content Creation, Marketing, and Sales PART 2
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
It's like one of those few things that happen in the history of civilization, right? Like the printing press or changing from horses to cars. Like it's that big. And it's gonna have that big of an impact. The internet. And it's like the the people like your guy that you're saying, right? When the horse, when the horses were the thing and the car came out, that guy is saying, oh yeah, right. Like they're gonna be able to put a gas station on every corner, right? And all the things that they said. And look at it, it's like there's nobody riding horses around. Well, I guess.
SPEAKER_00Who would sit in a room and watch a box with images on it all night long? You know, who would walk around with boxes on it? Nobody's gonna stop watching TV to uh to play on their phone all day long, you know. And then AR, like I don't even I I don't even know I have a TV sometimes. Like I'll turn something on on it and then I'll just be working on my phone, you know. Like I don't even really watch the damn thing.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. So but I don't either. I don't either. Yeah, it's like it was like the industrial revolution. There was the then there was the computers, personal computer, yeah, 80s, right? And then and then the next big thing was the internet, which took a little while to catch on. Yeah, so that was like another 20 years before it like really caught on. And then it was like social media was like the next level of because these are all big leverage pieces, like human leverage.
SPEAKER_00How can we keep people on the internet all the time? Yeah, and that's what social media did.
SPEAKER_02And it's like no, so there was like all these things took human leverage, which was the ultimate leverage, and like multiplied it, right? Like all these things, but like now that there's internet computers and now artificial intelligence, dude. That's like yeah, I mean, it's so much leverage that if you're not looking in that direction, dude, you're gonna be crushed.
SPEAKER_03And it's not it's it's not a maybe. Like this is fact. Like it's fact. Like you talk to the guy that owns the world now, the the dude that that um from NVIDIA, right? Like he just said, we have so much capacity for the software, right? Those hardware infrastructures there, and that'll just keep getting built. You know, they're they said they're nowhere near Moore's Law, like the end of Moore's Law, so it's just gonna keep doubling, right?
SPEAKER_00So crazy insane. Yeah, that's uh so I think that there's gonna be this division of well, it's gonna be like kind of like Wally, you know, with all the people the fat people on the station flying. I mean, I I envision uh I don't know how long this will take, but I and I'm this is not an endorsement for me by any means, but I envision a society where the division of wealth gets so great, but that the the people that own everything, who are gonna be the people that utilize and and harness the tools at the top, it's gonna be your your top, whatever, five percent of people, right? They're gonna be so far away from the bottom that they'll they'll that will pass universal base income eventually. They will, you know, I believe this. I there's gonna be this entire dependent, depressed little class of people that exist buying and consuming from this group of people that is living this entirely different life, you know, and they act like the division of wealth now is great, it's just gonna get worse and worse. Because, like you said, 47% of the people don't even know what chat GPG is.
SPEAKER_03So far behind.
SPEAKER_00You know, it's like to not even know what it is. Like, I mean, I mean, that doesn't make any sense. But um it's like Google, man. I still remember the first time I heard of Google. I was in seventh grade social studies. That's how old Google is. I'm 36, you know, not that I'm old, but I'm 36. I was in seventh grade social studies. We were using Web Crawler, and Belinda Nanny, my social studies teacher, said, Well, you guys should try Google. We had the little computers in the classroom, the like, you know, white box, you know, the old school. And um we got on, I remember getting on Google, and she was telling us, like, oh, Google is means a hundred, it's a hundred one with a hundred zeros. I still remember this, like conceptually, where it's at. And there are kids right now that are in school, guarantee you, people they teachers are there's certain teachers who tell them you should look at what chat GPT is, you know. Um, you should look at you look into that, and then they're using, and of course, then you get some of the teachers like, oh, you can't use AI to copyright stuff. There's no way around that. Have you seen the apps that kids use to do their math where they take a picture of a complex math scenario and it just does the work? Yeah. Oh man, we got screwed. Oh no, dude. Like, I had to learn math. The quadratic equation. Yeah, the or the uh well, you know, Pythagorean theorems and reflective properties and whatever. I don't even know what any of that stuff really is. I know what the Pythagorean theorem is, but I don't think I've ever had to use it. Right. So, you know, not an insurance anyway.
SPEAKER_02You gotta love the school system, giving you tools uh that you'll never use.
SPEAKER_00Right. They ought to be sitting there teaching you how to leverage chat GPT. Of course, teachers who knew that wouldn't be teachers, probably.
SPEAKER_02Well, yeah, then you you wouldn't be a good little uh you know, slave.
SPEAKER_00That's right, yeah. Yeah, I think it was um the second Rockefeller, maybe somebody that went to the Department of Education way back in the day and said, You're not making enough people to work in our factories. And so it was like the there's I haven't read like up on this, but I've heard about it before.
SPEAKER_02I think it was period. Carnegie.
SPEAKER_00Maybe it was Andrew Carnegie, and it was like we need steel mill workers, we need, you know, and you're you're you're not creating enough people to double them down. So the curriculum had to change to force them into that type of like prepare them for that role, you know. And so it's like, do you want your education to be preparing you for a role that you wouldn't choose? But that's what it does, you know, and it really hasn't adapted much at all.
SPEAKER_02So they started putting the school bells just like the the bells at work, damn uh just grooming, grooming the Americans in a nice little row, right?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, in a row.
SPEAKER_00Yep. Very interesting. Man, yeah. I mean, it it it's it'll be interesting. I mean, our industry, you know, it it's it's kind of funny too because we know we're on the Medicare side, and so it's like it'll impact us in some ways slower than other niches or you know, other industries, other age groups, demographics, right? Um, but in other ways it'll impact negatively. I I can see like the scams that are gonna come. Yeah, our generation, the generation that we serve mostly, and we'll do we do individual health from zero to a hundred, you know, but we'll we'll do Medicare, we do a little bit of small group, we'll do life, we'll do all that. But we're our focus has always been Medicare has been like the pillar of what we did. And um, that generation already gets scammed so easily. And now with AI and AI voice and like being able to mirror your relative's voice and all this. We actually have an employee whose sister, and she was like 35 or 40. The other day, somebody hacked her real estate attorney's email, created another email with a one after it. So what does this call her Joe Schmoe real estate broker or whatever? And then they put one at gmail.com and then took the emails that she had and started emailing her clients saying, you know, you haven't sent me your the down payment yet, or you hadn't sent me the check yet, to see what she this the scammer would get. Well, his sister, the guy that works for me, who's like 35 to 40, saw this and then said, Oh my gosh, I'm sorry, let me get it to you. And what is it? And they're like, it's 150,000, and then told her to go to this bank and wire it. This relatively young person went and wired this scammer 150 grand.
SPEAKER_02Oh my gosh.
SPEAKER_00And and so I'm like, think about like this 65 plus community, like especially 70, 75, 80. I mean, they're just getting and AI is gonna amplify that. So we'll we'll see the negative, I think, implications of it before we see it like absolutely decimate the cell size. But it's already and and the other thing too is like, you know, contacting clients, I feel like is one of the big or contacting prospects is already one of the most difficult things right now because the threshold for someone to actually answer their phone now is like all time low by a long shot, right? Yeah. And so if you're trying to do it like archaically right now, like let's say you're not even using automation, you're not even using if-then logic automation to get them to answer the phone.
SPEAKER_03Using their they're done, they're turning the Yeah, they're just too.
SPEAKER_00I mean, it's basically like you're just like sending a carrier pigeon to them if you're not using at least automation, but now with AI, like, I mean, because that bot will sit there and communicate with them 24 hours a day and sound like a human. I mean, every now and then, like you got we were talking before, every now and then it'll say something goofy, but it's getting better and better every day because it's actively building its own algorithm to function. So it's not like I have to go in and change it, it's changing itself as it has issues. You know, I might can change certain things to help it along, but it's changing itself.
SPEAKER_03Dude, I I tested our voice one that I built, and it it did I ran 120 leads through it today. We got two quoted from the first run. I mean, that's pretty good, right? I don't know how many answered. I didn't I didn't get into that part of it, but my office manager just came over. He said we got two out of it so far. And that was after two hours. So might be something.
SPEAKER_00I do think that you gotta you one thing this uh you know that would probably be my greatest concern being you know a distribution company in the insurance space is so far, in most niches, direct-to-consumer enrollment has failed, not completely failed, but most of them have like negative CPAs, they're like they're see not negative CPAs, but CPAs that are higher than their lifetime value uh, you know, from their clients, right? So um care, but carriers play different economics than brokers because they're not dealing with commission, they're dealing with premium. So their CPA could technically be higher than a broker's CPA or an insurance agent CPA. And now you add AI into it. I do believe that there's gonna be a lot of companies that are gonna evolve in the direct-to-consumer space, you know, both PNC, life, Medicare, health, every every sector of it. So we'll see, you know, how that evolves because it's funny because like it seemed like a lot of people were leaving that space. Like it was like, especially in PC, you know, it's like it's kind of imploded. You know, there's a lot of stuff going on in that market, a lot of stuff going on in every market, but yeah, um, like there's it's like they were starting to say, oh man, it's just too expensive to do business this way. But now all of a sudden AI is coming along. So there you know there's gonna be startups and private equity pumping into some groups that are going to be trying new things, and at this point, they might be more successful than they were in the past, which could be and that's one of those reasons that I'm talking about, these agents that are trying to get in right now. It's like, okay, get in, but you better move quick because if you're not if you know, I had like several years ago in Medicare, I had a um kind of a mentor or one of um several men, I thought a hundred mentors, but this mentor in his face and the what he was teaching me, he told me this is the land grab. Like, and this was probably eight, nine years ago. It was pretty soon after I got in. He said, This is the land grab. The next 10 years are the land grab in Medicare. And then the people that don't go and grab their share of the pie are going to really struggle to, you know, persist. Because at some point we're gonna plateau on how many people are like that growth factor of how many people are turning 65 and all that. Um, but I think that's in every niche right now because of AI. Like we're in this land grab. Go and grab your business, grab your, you know, get your processes in order, all that. Because what will happen, I believe, is there'll be further and further consolidation. Private equity has a high appetite for people that are doing things. Your algorithm, like your AI and your algorithm and your your automation and your brand ends up being worth a lot more than you realize because these private equity groups or these publicly traded groups that even carriers will buy that stuff because they it's shiny objects to them. They're like, man, if I could just get that, like it'll be worth way more. And it is worth more to them. Now, sometimes they'll screw it up because they'll come in and buy it and get the founder out of there, and then the founder was the guy that was driving the whole thing. Um, but I'm seeing a lot of them now where they're like with us, you know, we sold 51%, but we have 49% retained equity. So the concept is like keep the founder involved, engaged on the profit side of it, but control the aspects of it, you know. Um, so there's a lot of variables out there right now. It's a crazy, a crazy market in everything. Election year, AI, man, it just seems like there's gonna be some funny videos here.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. A couple questions. One is what do you think for that you see on the sales side with all your agents and everything that that you're working with, what are some of the most successful agents doing today that's might be a little different than the past?
SPEAKER_00I mean, man, so uh, you know, the the first ones that come to mind, the the you know in the Medicare space, the most successful ones right now are finding a very niche uh niche mark, a niche avatar using Facebook ads that speak to that niche avatar, messaging-wise, getting in front of them in either a webinar educational format or some sort of you know quick call to action, getting that that lead info into a high-level system. Like we have one that's called GoGoo, but there are many others where people just have their own high level, whatever, communicating quickly, trying to contact them fast, and then when they can't contact them with three contact attempts, it going into that pipeline we're talking about of AI and automation continuing to follow up and just using that lead bank. And then also one of the things they're doing that's that's impactful is treating that lead bank like an asset in itself that I can come through randomly and do broadcast messages to or create new ideas. But most of the the ones that are having extreme success, and these you know, more agents, people that evolve into agencies or FMOs, they're um they're having a lot of success in just thinking about rapid niche markets and trying a lot of stuff in COS6. Another thing is magnetic marketing, like the Dan Kennedy style, magnetic marketing is still working. Very creative, decent frequency, traditional touches. Like, I mean, I in the Medicare man, direct mail still works if you don't do it like everybody else. You come up with something, you know, where like we send, we wrote a book for Medicare consumers, and we mail that book to every person turning 65 and in several states with a letter, then we do a follow-up postcard, a follow-up postcard, and every one of them we're inviting them to webinars, you know, and then we have that evergreen webinar, and that's working really well. Now, a lot of people would look at what we spend on that and think, well, that's really expensive. But then you look at like the average first year return on ad spend that we're getting on those clients because we're targeting middle to upper middle income. Whereas in Medicare, so many of the people that are going to struggle in the next few years have been targeting low income. And I'm not saying like, you know, all policies have value, but I can't spend very much to get in front of a low-income person because they don't buy a lot of other stuff, you know. Whereas with magnetic marketing style campaigns where I'm dealing with people who are, let's say, in retirement, 50,000 to 200,000 income, but I'm I'm touching them with educational and comedic style quality marketing. When they call in or they go to a webinar and they respond, they'll buy the core Medicare policies from us, they'll buy additional cancer, they'll buy life insurance. And occasionally we have a sector in the office where it gets to our financial side and we'll do some annuities and other things. So that that lifetime value of that customer on average or that return first year return on ad spend is significant. Because so I can go spend $400, $500 to acquire a customer where other people are trying to acquire a customer at $100 because it's low income and they can't cross-sell them anything and they stay on the books eight months. But that's like that's like staying on a hamster wheel. And when you're in a business like insurance, like you got to be chasing the renewal aspect of it. So if I can if I can have a first year return on ad spend at all, but then have all that renewal income down the pipeline, that's the ones that are successful. You know, they they figure out a way to get off the ground enough to where they can spend more money on quality marketing and they trust the process. They don't drop a piece of mail, they don't run an ad and then turn it off and wait for the result. They just run it and run it and run it.
SPEAKER_03Consistency over time. Like that's a long-term strategy versus the typical agent. I mean, I I did it forever where I'd buy something, go, ah, we didn't get anything, and then freak out. And oh, we two months later we close them, right? And then it's like maybe we need to restart, and then yeah, that's the freaking monkey mind game.
SPEAKER_00Dude, I've I've done it too, man. Like it's not like it when I tell somebody to do something, and and then you tell somebody to do something, it's not like I'm saying I did that every time. I'm saying learn from my mistake. Yes, you know, um, you know, find a budget that you can stick with for a long period of time. Don't go blow your load in month one and then have to sit there and wait. You know what I mean? So a hundred percent.
SPEAKER_02It's like oh go ahead, dude. No, no, no, no, go for it. I can't remember. What are you most optimistic about in the next year and and what advice would you give other agents? Just like the last thing you said, I mean, the principles are all the same. It doesn't matter if it's Medicare, P and C, you know, the consistency of buying leads and and and like that principle is applicable against any type of business buying leads pretty much. Um pre-chapble business.
SPEAKER_00My my biggest um my the most exciting thing for our business right now is finding, I mean, like what I'm ultimate avatar of who I'm looking for right now. Our consumer side is pretty much on autopilot and continues to grow. But our on the agent side, I'm super excited about finding the strong independent agent that wants to become an actual business. You know, the guy who's figured out how to sell or the gal who's figured out how to sell. They're writing, you know, 150, 200, 300 policies a year. How do I build a team? And I don't mean go and recruit a bunch of people and into a pyramid. I mean build an actual team of employees. And I'm not knocking that. We have downline agents too, but like, how do I go and build a business out of this? You know, because the there are different hard parts in business, but in insurance, I it's it's gotta be, you know, the hardest part has to be just getting off the ground into a consistent momentum. And so if I can find that individual agent or that really small agency, and then I can help them with our tools and our events scale to the next level. That's what we're good at. You know, I don't I don't go out there and say, like, hey, I'm really good at taking, you know, brand new agents, you know, in. I mean, we work with brand new agents, you know, especially if I vet them and think that they have potential. But like mostly I want to find the agent that's looking to go from strong independent producer to agency owner in the the life and health Medicare sector.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, it's it's amazing. You get into this business and they teach you the product, right? They do it's just like here's the product, here's the product, here's how to use the system, and but nothing about business ownership, right? And like you said, to your point, we all show up here average, right? Like we couldn't do the other stuff. So we come to insurance and and it's like, oh, okay, cool. It's a you know full opportunity. And then we get trained on just narrow little piece that really doesn't help us advance the thing, you know, and then it's like finding the right mentors. Like it, if you're in your space, like finding people like you, hopefully people look to us and think the same way, you know, in the PC space, because it's like we did it, we could help people save a lot of time and a lot of frustration and a lot of money just by listening, right?
SPEAKER_00Oh yeah, dude. If I at this point, if I was going to get into PNC, I'd be coming to guys like you and be like, all right, what's the cheat code? Like, you know, and and and the cheat, and look, it's just not like there's a button to push and create a business, but you know, going to somebody and saying, What do I not do? It's uh almost as well as saying what to do, you know, like where where have you wasted the most money and time? Um because a lot of times the ideas you have are like, oh, I'll do it this way, and that would work really well. And then you find out no well that that you know, we tried that, or you know, or one of our people tried that, you know. So I think it's uh it's yeah, it's tuition. And and and if I can pay somebody else or a line or work with them in some capacity, um I in most cases, especially if you choose a good mentor, I mean, and look, I'm not saying there aren't like some snake oil salesmen and scam artists out in the world selling stuff. Like that just exists you know, there's bad, there's recruiters, uh, most of them are actually your typical old school recruiters, they have zero value add. Um and you know, and that's in all the sectors that I've seen in insurance. It's but if you if you have, if you find the ones that are really practicing what they preach, that seem cutting edge, that are doing things that other people aren't doing, and you work with them, whatever you spend with them, or you know, if you align with them or whatever, it's nine times out of ten, it's going to save you ten times, a hundred times the money, effort, and energy that you would spend just trying to figure it out yourself. And I've seen it before. I've seen people that are like, well, I'm just gonna try that myself. And I've done that. I've tried things, and I'm gonna try this. And sometimes I did it by necessity because I didn't know of anyone else that were doing it. But if you can find somebody that's doing it, and think the good thing about this era we're in right now is that there are a lot of people out there, you know, in individual niches. You go and find, like you can go on on social media and different areas and find it. And like if you're somebody that lists, most people that listen to this probably don't feel this way, but you'll see these people like, oh, if you could, if you're so good at selling insurance, why do you sell insurance and instead of doing this content towards agents? But that's horse shit. Like, I do the first of all, I do the content towards agents because it's fun. Yeah, it breaks the just doing the inside. And I do you come to my office right over here, guess what? All freaking day they're doing talking to Medicare beneficiaries, right? They're that's what we do. It's like 50% of all of our revenue in this big operation is coming from to the directory consumer side. From the actual agent side has been fun and it's growing, and I would like to do that, but that's almost like I had to graduate out of the hell, even some of my salespeople, eventually it's like I now I have another path because it's grueling to sit there and do that part of it forever.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_00So I'm gonna keep that operation going, but then there's this graduatory phase where some of those people then come over to marketing or they come over to agent support or recruiting or something like that. And it's it can be more rewarding to tell somebody that I'm gonna keep them on the direct to consumer sales channel as a full role as a top producer forever. Rough might make them think I don't know if I can do this forever. Yes, it's more money than I've ever made in my life, but it's it's rough, you know, and you got to do it while you got to do it. But once you see another way, it's like, okay. And that's what I want to show people is like, hey, let me show you how to do the hard work to build the engine and then use that engine to fuel other aspects and other avenues, you know.
SPEAKER_03Justin, we have to cut it off here, but I would like to ask, can we bring you back? Because this is freaking awesome. We'd love to have you back on, maybe do a part two at some point and uh keep it going. Mr. Jason has to run, he has an important meeting somewhere, and uh yeah. So let's do it.
SPEAKER_00Hey, I'll be back for sure, guys. I really appreciate you guys having me, and everybody that's listening should definitely subscribe to and follow the insurance dudes because they're putting great content.
SPEAKER_03Where can they find you, Mr. Bro?
SPEAKER_00Um, I would prefer Instagram at the Justin Brock or YouTube, uh YouTube.com slash Justin Brock. Boom.
SPEAKER_02Love it, man. Love seeing other people in the industry just killing it. So following you has been uh so much fun over the years.
SPEAKER_00Thank you guys so much.
SPEAKER_02Like what stuff, man. Thank you.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman