The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
AI Takeover? Will You Be Blockbuster or Netflix?
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
The Impact of AI on Insurance
SPEAKER_00The AI takeover. Are you gonna be Blockbuster? Are you gonna be Netflix? Definitely want to be Netflix, right? All right. So I'm gonna dive into a quick story here about an insurance agent. I know let's call him Jason. No, no, let's not call him Jason. Let's call her Josephine. Uh, Josephine has an agency out in Colorado and just close a big client. Uh, his team had a big day, closed somebody that was about six, seven thousand in premium. They call back the next week and start talking to the sales agents, saying, Hey, um, you know, I know I signed up, but I just came across this AI-powered insurance platform, and it promises that I can get better, um, better rates based off of how I'm gonna drive, not based on how I did drive. So his heart starts to sink, her heart starts to sink. And she may feel a little panicky, right? And the thought is is this the beginning of the end for the agency, right? Um, well, let me tell you, my friend, I am here by myself because Mr. Jason is not here, which is why I shared the story about Jesse. The answer is no. Well, the answer actually is probably or it can be no. Now, is it the beginning of the end for some agents? Oh, 100%. 100%. But it doesn't have to be, right? The key is to embracing AI. AI is very, very critical. I know that that you may have just rolled your eyes. Uh, if you're anything like my wife, anytime that somebody talks or brings up AI, you just get like, ugh, please stop it. I'm over it. Well, guess what? There is no getting over it. It's like saying uh back in 1996, I'm over the internet or I'm over email. Okay. Uh throughout history, throughout time, there's been many, or not many, but several very key movers of our civilization that have occurred. This is one of them. You can go back to fire, you can go back to the wheel, you can go back to spoken language, you can go back to written language, you can go to the car, the airplane, right? Significant things that have made a huge impact and affected our daily life and changed everything. The internet, remember how I don't know if it, well, some of you probably don't remember, but but I can definitely remember when the internet came out, I was so stoked. I mean, I was like, holy crap, this is what you know, this is what they've been talking about, or this is what we this is the future, right? And there were many people, like my folks, my parents would say, Oh, what is that? My grandpa, I remember my grandparents like, I'm not going on that. What is that? That's stupid, right? Um, and this is like back then, having a computer wasn't as important, right? But the internet put the computers on everybody's desk. So, what is AI gonna do, right? What things are AI gonna do? One thing that we know for certain that it's gonna cause um is job losses. It's gonna replace a lot of people, okay? Uh, if you haven't gotten down and dirty into the world of AI, I'm hope, hopeful that I could shed a little light on it for you. But uh by the end of this, you're gonna have some great information on what it is, how to use it, and and why it's so important. So you got to stick with me on this one. Uh, but this stat is the one that freaks me out, okay? Because it has really far-reaching consequences and nobody's immune to it. This will affect every single person in the country. Okay. Uh, it's it's such a big number, and it's gonna happen so soon that it's kind of scary. Okay. So, some some of the big thought leaders in the AI uh world conservatively estimate that 85 million jobs are going to evaporate by 2025. Now, this isn't something I'm making up to shock everybody. This isn't something that uh, you know, and it's not something that's secret. This is something that is talked about. Um, and and they're saying a conservative number. Now, I sure hope that I misheard that because I could guarantee that insurance agencies aren't going to be immune. Um, but here's the thing the agen this is what they got certain of is that the agencies that thrive in the new world that embrace the power of AI and don't fight against it are going to succeed and are going to thrive. Now, I've been elbows deep for well over a year. Um, and we've been using automations and and all kinds of things like that in our agencies and for other businesses for years. So making the leap was more of a oh, finally it's here for me, right? Kind of like for NVIDIA. Uh, if you don't, if you're not familiar with NVIDIA, it's what's driving, it's the hardware behind everything, right? Um, the AI requires a massive amount of processing power. And so there's these farms filled with NVIDIA processors uh just to just to run these things. So, what are they running? What is it? Well, it's called an LLM. Okay, so if you haven't heard the term LLM, uh you may find it uh interesting to know that it stands for not laser lunges metrics. No, it stands for large language model, and I'm sorry that you can't land every joke. So, what do these tools do? What the heck is an LLM? Where can I find them? Well, think about this. It's the engine, no, it's the brain behind automation. Okay, so if you can think back to chatbots back in um, you know, I from a year ago or even from a month ago to when they came out, chatbots. You know, you go to a website, a little thing pops up, it says, Hey, I'm I'm Zappy Zap chat. Do you want to, and then you you get to pick between five things. Not one of those, the thing that you need is not amongst the list of the five things, so you have to pick the thing that's closest, which isn't even close, and blah, blah, blah. Right? So those were not AI driven, those were just logic, and it was it was hard-coded logic. So what would happen is somebody goes in and just basically programs this thing, right? They they program the bot to if it does this, then this, and you only give them this choice, and it's a flow chart. So very simple, very annoying to interact with because it had no personality, uh, or it has a fake personality that uh is the same every time. Okay, so it has no learning skills, has no ability to adapt, has no ability to think on the fly, has no ability to execute anything really um beyond those instructions that's there. Okay, so now introduce what's just recently come out. Um, and and we're talking over the last year. Okay, so over the last year, if if you got on Chat GPT at the very, very beginning, then you're more familiar with it and the changes that have happened. But over the last year, it's insane how much faster, how much better, and how much more knowledgeable, and how much more can be done by one of these assistants, now they call them, right? A chatbot assistant. And anybody can make these things. So uh it's really good. Now, this isn't gonna when we go, we're not gonna go very deep into that. We're gonna stay high-level on this one. I'm gonna do a few episodes uh here and uh we'll we'll tear through. So, but let's let's talk about some success stories, okay? Um, I think that before we dive in, we get into the nitty-gritty of it. I think it's important just to hear like applic like application, right? Like, does this apply? And it does. It there's a billion use cases, even in your agency, even that don't need to be client-facing. Uh, so if if there's concerns about uh the C-word, not the bad word, well, some people call it bad word, it's not four letters. Um, but that C word is is a non-issue because we're not you can you can help by installing a lot of things that have nothing to do with the actual inner workings or mechanisms of the agency and aren't uh necessarily holding any information on the client outside of the system. So I think that's one of the biggest hiccups and issues that uh carriers have is their they consider the data, like the the personal data of the client, they consider that theirs. So we have to honor that, right? If that's the rule, that's the rule. So don't share the data, right? If you buy a lead, uh, I don't know. I I think that there's a I think that there's a uh a line there, right? Because if I paid for that data, then I own that data, in my opinion. Now I'm not an attorney, but I am Babylon. So we'll
Leveraging Automation for Agency Success
SPEAKER_00move on. All right. So let's look at these real world examples. I have one uh one agency that I've talked to, and actually many agencies, because we've we've brought this up in our elite group and uh and over with the teledudes and and and just uh a lot of the agents that we interact and serve um have used these for a multitude of different things, but one agency was struggling with high volume of of inquiries. So they they were a larger agency. I think it was like 15 billion, uh, 15 billion a premium, and and they have a lot of inbound calls, but they were running pretty lean, a lot like me. Like we're we have a you know, we're 12 million and and we've got less sales or less service people than most 12 million dollar agencies because we have a lot of automation in place to pick up that slack because it's a lot less expensive to handle some of the stuff that can be automated away than it is to bring somebody on, right? If we're gonna bring somebody on for a job that is gonna cost me 50K to have that person here, then I better get some kind of return on it, right? Now, I could build something for myself, create some automation to replace somebody that would be doing the 50,000 a year. And guess what? In addition to that, that person or that entity is never gonna call it sick, it's never gonna be cause any drama, it's never gonna do anything that I find annoying. Well, no, it probably will say something uh when I said jokes to it, but for the most part, it it will play better than most people, right? Now, it has to be directed, but again, so to people, so pretty interesting, right? Uh, what happened? So, so in the before they put this thing in place, uh people were getting voicemails, people were uh not getting calls back, they're getting pretty pissed. Uh, that's what he was telling me. So I just said, hey man, why don't you just put something in place that handles the traffic just to let them know? Like it doesn't need to even be the voicemail, just something like, hey, everybody's on the phone, we'll get back to you ASAP, and then put it that reminder somewhere so that that somebody knows how to do it. We pretty much set the same thing up over here so that no calls are run into voicemail, no calls are just disappearing. Uh, because depending on your carrier, there could be strange phone systems and strange voicemail systems in the background where nobody knows where they go. Just one thing that I've seen happen to me. Uh, so that's a possibility. And uh, so what does it do? What were the what were the big improvements? We got uh our response time is way quicker, right? I'm not getting complaints. Uh the other agency, same thing. I I just modeled what they did, uh, and he did what I'd asked him. So I guess I modeled what I'd what I told him. But um what do we do? Um, and he's able to get more Google reviews as a result. He created an automation that asks for Google reviews, sends them directly there, and uh used one of one of our tricks that we've talked about before, which is you could set it up where you have a uh like a W landing page and uh and you ask people what they would rate it. If they click a one, two, or three, you just send them to the thank you page and say thank you for your your thing. Uh is there anything we could do to make it a four or five or to get you to a five? And and we'll try to get some feedback because we definitely want to try to improve scores. Uh, and then if they're a four or five, it will kick them over to the Google page where then they're gonna leave the real review. So it's just a way to filter and make sure that we don't get people putt ones and twos and stuff. In fact, I've had people leave great reviews and then put a one because they think one is good, you know, like it's a one through five, and it's a one. I thought that Google made it pretty clear, but you never know with folks. Um, what else? So here's another one. Uh this isn't even this isn't even with the agency, but with um, but with teledutes and and and our marketing campaigns there. And since a lot of folks probably listening have probably been served the ads that we do, all these crazy ads with the AI pictures, we had something happen with the content provider or the host of our of our uh site. And what we did from that was, or I'm sorry, what what happened as a result from that, they they did something with the code that wasn't us, it was it was on their side, but it killed traffic. Like all of a sudden, we went from you know, we're we we have ads, we have 500 to a thousand hits coming in a day to almost non-existent, just organic traffic. Well, you know, like a hundred a day. So we were scrambling trying to figure out what to do because we have ads running, right? People clicking, no traffic. That's a problem, right? Um, so we actually had I took an assistant, uh, an AI assistant, I gave it all of the code from the web page, which is probably more than most agents are gonna do for stuff. But I it's important to understand like the depth of what it could do. So I had it analyze the code. It kicked me back a message saying that there were bugs in that code. That was not my code, that was uh click funnels code. So basically, the the site had had done something, had wigged out, and uh what we did was we were able to basically reconstruct the site, put it on a different platform, and get it up and running again. Um, and now we have it in there analyzing our our stats weekly to tell us what we should change because it could also look at uh where people are going on the site, all that kind of stuff. So I I know I went a little too far in the weeds there, uh, but it's real important to understand that you can put it on things that it understands and it's been trained on, and it's been trained on a lot of things, right? Like it's been trained on basically everything, at least at a high level, and it's gonna understand. And if it doesn't understand or it gives you a weird answer, you you continue to ask for clarification, right? Um, I I usually ask for clarification even if I get a good answer, because you never know, right? Like it can it can sound pretty convincing with a completely wrong answer, which is really interesting. So that problem solved less than a day the old way. I mean, we could have been down for weeks, but our it it increased our conversions. So as you folks are going to uh from an ad to uh to offer.thei neews.com, which is internet lead secrets, that's the ad, right? That's our funnel. So you go to Internet Lead Secrets, and we had a 40% increase in purchases on Internet Lead Secrets, um, just by well, fixing the code. And then it also gave uh throughout doing a number of split tests, it kept giving us recommendations on on which one to go with or which headline to change or which button to change color. So really crazy stuff, really, really deep, uh, interesting stuff. So, oh, and even on the back. So if if anybody that has got that before, right, anybody that's that's uh that's actually gotten internet lead secrets, you know that the second page has has a script or the the perfect script, and it analyzed the traffic on that and also improved that, which it should be a hundred percent take rate because that's a no-brainer. But at the end of the day, uh it is what it is, and and folks are skeptical. But yeah, that that that has been that has been very effective. And and you can use it for so many things, right? You could have it help you craft emails, have it help you craft uh copy for websites, have it, have it do anything. So, or uh anything with writing. But again, you don't ask it to write something for you and then copy and paste, or you will not look good. Be very careful. All right, so I have also made for you a uh uh a cheat sheet. All right, so I gave you a cheat sheet that has information on how to go on on what ChatGPT is, where to go. It has a uh some recommendations on what to do. So on that cheat sheet, it's gonna tell you to sign up. I would highly encourage you to pay the 20 bucks a month. 20 bucks. It's 20 bucks. Pay 20 bucks a month. I don't get anything for doing this. I don't I don't work for Chat GPT, uh, but it has changed my life. Get in there and you're gonna be way ahead of most people. Now, remember the title of this episode, Blockbuster Netflix. I'm telling you, the blockbusters of the insurance world are not going to have a Chat GPT account. That is a guarantee. And uh start small, right? Start small, do little projects, but but ideally, like this is where where an agency owner should be working, right? Working in the place that is generating the tools and resources and information that their team could use, or that they can use to trade their team, or that they can use to drive more traffic to their team, right? You get leverage as an agent the more that you can automate, the more that you can delegate, and the more that you can create and eject, right? I'm on here creating information to help you create information to help your team because that's what I do here, right? I don't go out there and sell policies, I don't go out there and take payments. I mean, I pulled up one day recently, and somebody was in the parking lot waiting for an appointment to talk to somebody, and they're like, Oh, are you Craig? I said, Oh no, I'm just here to, you know, I I don't meet with the clients. And if you like to, fantastic. Just ask yourself if meeting with somebody who has uh $2,000 in premium with you is worth the $150 for the time that you're spending. Is it worth it? Is it generating more, right? Yeah, I upsold a mariner's policy. Great. So you got an extra $10 a year for the hour and a half that you worked. What if that hour was spent on developing a new unique mechanism that would drive more traffic to your agency? What if that hour was spent making a video that explained to your team how to do something, or explained to your customers how to do something, or building a YouTube channel, or something else that's gonna make long-term lasting impact on your agency? And that's where I'm gonna leave it. We're gonna dive into Chat GPT next time, but make sure you go in the show notes, download the cheat sheet, okay? Um, and we will dive in and go deep. Thank you and appreciate listening. Make sure to uh if if you do want to check out, if you didn't check out the thing I was talking about, um, that we've totally revamped as a result of what uh of the tools that are out there. Head over to offer.theidudes.com. That's offer.theidudes.com, and you can download your copy of Internet Lead Secrets for a very reasonable amount. We put a lot of work into it, we'll and and it is very helpful. And uh it's not unfair to ask to be paid for our work. So we appreciate you, and uh, we hope we see you soon. Thank you very much.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman