The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
Shoot Us A Message!Welcome back to another thrilling episode of The Insurance Dudes! Today we're joined by Craig, the word of mouth wizard Pretzinger, and Jason, the referral renegade Feltman. Buckle up as we dive deep into the dynamic world of referral marketing—a gold mine for boosting your agency’s growth that too many overlook. Referrals don't just amplify client trust and loyalty; they're the top-tier short cut to acquiring clients who are more likely to engage and less sensitive o...
Are you talking about the stuff for Thanksgiving? Referrals. I'm not. That's right. I are agents.
SPEAKER_01
Now by the covering predictable and profitable agency sales. I am Craig Futter. I am Jason Feltman. We are agents. We are insurance. I'm Jason, the referral renegade Feltman. Welcome back, Growth Warriors. Today we're unleashing the power of one of the most effective, yet often overlooked strategies for growing your agencies. And that's referral marketing. And don't forget, I'm gonna I'm gonna say this every time. Any every time I have a different name, I'm gonna repeat it within the opening, which is I'm Jason, the referral renegade Feltman.
SPEAKER_00
I love how you're leaning into becoming uncomfortable. And I am Craig, the word of mouth wizard Pretzinger. And I guess I get to say it twice. If you're not actively cultivating referrals, you're leaving a ton of money on the table. But don't worry, we're here to help you change that.
SPEAKER_01
Let's start with why referrals are so insanely valuable. Think about it. When a client refers someone to you, they're essentially putting their reputation on the line. They're saying, I trust this agency so much, I'm willing to recommend them to the people I care about, the people that'll give me crap.
SPEAKER_00
Exactly. Yeah. And because of that personal endorsement, referred prospects are more likely to trust you right off the bat. They're predisposed to like you and do business with you, Mr.
SPEAKER_01
Jason. Not to mention, referrals tend to have a higher lifeline, uh lifetime value than other types of clients. They're more loyal, less price sensitive, and more likely to refer others than themselves. Mmm. It's the gift that keeps on giving.
SPEAKER_00
But here's the thing referrals don't just happen by accident, Mr. Jason.
SPEAKER_01
No, they don't.
SPEAKER_00
Mr. Jason, the referral renegade.
SPEAKER_01
That's right.
SPEAKER_00
To generate a steady stream of high-quality referrals, you need to be proactive and you have to be systematic.
SPEAKER_01
Yeah. Oh, that's right, Mr. Craig, 100%. The first step is to understand the psychology of why clients refer. Typically, it's because they've had an exceptional experience with your agency, that they like you, right? And that they want to help uh others have the same experience. They feel a sense of loyalty and appreciation.
SPEAKER_00
Yep. And on the flippity flip, there's also psychological barriers that can hold clients back from referring, even if they're happy with you. They might worry about being seen as pushy or might simply forget to do it, right? Everybody's busy.
SPEAKER_01
Yep. 100%. And that's why it's so important to make referring as easy and natural as possible. Uh, one of the best ways to do that is by identifying your agency's best referral sources and nurturing those relationships.
SPEAKER_00
Yeah. Think about it. Which clients have already referred you in the past and who have expressed a lot of enthusiasm and appreciation for your services? These are your raving fans, the ones who are most likely to refer you again in the future.
SPEAKER_01
Your agency has raving fans of insurance? Raving. Well, all right. Make a point of staying in touch with these clients. I mean, they're worth their weight in gold. Not just about insurance matters, but the personal lives too. They're humans. You can send all kinds of things like a handwritten note. I know I'm not a big fan of paper, but dude, there's nothing better than a handwritten note on their birthday. You can have Sally in your office or Bertha in the back do it for you. Why is Bertha in the back? Well, because that's where she sits. Oh. Okay. And invite them to exclusive events like your summer cookouts in front of your agency, like Mr. Craig does in his um in his American flag Speedoes, or just give them a call to check in and say, what up?
SPEAKER_00
I love wearing the American Flag Speedos when it's 115 out and we just grill it up in the tuxin. In the tuxin. So another key aspect of building a referral engine, because I want to keep keep to business here, Mr. Jason, is having a systematic approach and process for asking for referrals. So many agents feel awkward about this, but the truth is, if you've provided great service, most clients are happy to refer to you.
SPEAKER_01
You just need to ask. Yeah. The key is to ask at the right time in the right way. Typically, the best time to ask is right after you delivered positive results or experience for your client. They're feeling good about your service and are way more likely to be receptive to your requests. This literally just happened recently in our agency. We're getting back into sales where we weren't allowed to sell in California. And uh our sales agent just started doing this referral uh system where he uh kept asking for referrals. Finally, a few people started uh being more and more receptive to his referrals, and then he would give them a uh, you know, quote them, talk to them for a while, and then ask that referral for a referral. And he's been able to daisy chain those and started this domino effect. And and now he's starting to close a lot of them.
SPEAKER_00
That sounds like a total game changer.
SPEAKER_01
It's a gum changer.
SPEAKER_00
In terms of how to ask, you may be wondering. So this is important. Be specific, make it easy for them. Instead of saying, if you know anyone who needs some insurance, please do me a favor and send it my way. Right? Don't do that. Don't do that. Don't ever do that. Try something like, hey, we're always looking to help more people like you. If you have any friends or family or colleagues who could benefit and have a great experience like you just did, um, here's some great ways to get them over to us.
SPEAKER_01
I love how you just told them that they had a great experience, which is a great marketing tactic too. Tell them a great experience. Don't be afraid of that. It's not cheesy because if you you know you should have given them a great experience, let them know that it was a great experience. Right. Who cares? Don't be afraid to offer incentives or rewards also for successful referrals. I mean, it's like dude, you're buying leads, anyways, maybe or maybe not, but we all know leads can be uh a bit pricey. So if you normally spend X amount on a sale and now somebody gives you a referral, I mean, why not cut it in half? Yeah, why not give them something? Something. It could be something as simple as a gift card to a local coffee shop, which I'm sure is Starbucks if you live in this on planet Earth, or a discount on the next policy renewal, which you can't really do. I don't think you could do that. Heck, you could rebating, you know, give them a policy review. I'm sure there's something. Come on. Yeah, there's all kinds of stuff. There's something. The point is to appreciate, uh, to show the appreciation and to make them feel valued.
SPEAKER_00
I mean, that's it, right? Technology can also play a big role in making referrals easy and trackable. There's tools out there that allow your clients to refer you with just a couple clicks, right? Um, they can automate the process. We have a process uh that's worked really well that the with the email um through the you know, you set it up a compliant thing and it goes out and and asks for the review. And and we get a lot of reviews. If you want to see um, oh, another uh another, I'm sorry, we get referrals from the reviews, and we do get a lot of we I'll bonus my folks on reviews because people look at reviews before they jump on, right?
SPEAKER_01
That's a form of referral. Well, sure. Yeah, yeah. Ultimately, though, the best way to generate referrals is by providing exceptional service, which we we should be doing this anyways as an agency. You will you want to be the best, right? And when you consist and you want your team to do this. So if you treat your team well, they should be treating your clients well. When you constantly go above and beyond for your clients, referrals can they it can happen naturally because people want to share that positive experience with others, but you gotta ask. You gotta train your team to ask.
SPEAKER_00
Totes McGots. Yep. And to recap, so understand number one, the psychology of referrals, right? Understand that they're not gonna offer to do the referral, and your people aren't gonna ask. It's something that you have to initiate. Um, we need to identify and nurture our best referral sources. Uh, you could, you know, if you segment your book, you could look at who you know hits a certain threshold, maybe they're the best referrals, whatever. Figure out who is the best, and then implement a system and process for asking. Leverage technology and above all, provide service that's worth talking about.
SPEAKER_01
If you do all those things consistently, you'll be amazed at how your referral business starts to grow. And it's not, it's not gonna be overnight. It will start to grow, like like it's incremental at first. So just keep doing this consistently. It's the ultimate form of social proof and can fuel your agency's growth for years to come. And honestly, if it's better than buying leads. I mean, it if you're buying leads, anyways, this is a way to lower your lead costs by implementing this, right? Right. Because now you're getting more sales.
SPEAKER_00
Because it doesn't cost any extra. And if you ask every person, you will get a referral.
SPEAKER_01
100%.
SPEAKER_00
It's the same way people say internet leads don't work. Well, they do, but only you close 2%. That's the way it works, right? So you have to buy 100 to get two. That's just the way it works. Yep. So um, and you want to put this into action? Guess what? Mr. Jason's favorite. We got a referral marketing checklist. Craig loves the checklist and he busted them out for you. Listen to me. If you don't like any of these things, just shoot us an email and I won't make any more. He spends a lot of time on this, no joke. I knew. I put these things together because I think that it's there's value to them and uh we're gonna help you grow. Yep. And if not, rip it up, send it back uh to the office here, and I won't tell Mr. Jason that you sent it.
SPEAKER_01
Well, you can Google where Craig's office is. Just I'm just saying. Okay, so you can download this checklist right below in the show notes. And if you have any questions or success stories, please share with us. We'd love to hear from you. You can uh shoot us an email, leave us a comment on the social medias, or Google Craig. Yeah, Google me.
SPEAKER_00
Why not? Remember, your best clients, though, are really who you should be Googling because they're gonna be your best marketers, and you can empower them to spread the word and watch your business soar to new heights.
SPEAKER_01
Well, I guess that's all for today, referral rock stars. Ooh, that's right. You heard that from me. Until next time, keep vowing, keep bowing. I'm sorry, Mr. Craig. I'm starting to get the giggles, but keep wowing your clients, all right, and keep reaping the referral rewards.
SPEAKER_00
I love a little alliteration. This is Craig, the word of mouth wizard, and Jason, the referral renegade feltman.
SPEAKER_01
Signing off.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.