The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Top 5 Psychological Sales Principals | Insurance Agency Playbook
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
Bump bump bum bum bump.
Psychological Tactics for Insurance Sales
SPEAKER_01That's great. Uh uh uh uh uh you gotta sing it now.
SPEAKER_02Brass tactics, uh those funky actics. You're not gonna make the noises? I don't know. So as as everybody knows, uh we're we're testing this new segment called Brass Tactics, those funky actics. Uh so if you could, when you subscribe, just go ahead and uh leave a review and just tell us what you think of brass actics. We'll take the five stars, and if you have anything wrong with it, you can write that out. Uh, but welcome to another mind expanding episode of the insurance dudes brass tactics.
SPEAKER_01I'm Craig Pritzker. I love it. I love the pause there, and I'm Jason Feltman. Insurance dudes are automated to escape being handcuffed by our agency.
SPEAKER_00How? By uncovering the state that's degreing predictable, consistent, and profitable agency sales. I am Craig Pritzinger.
SPEAKER_01I am Jason Feltman. We are agents, we are insurance students. Today we're diving into the fascinating world of psychology. Ooh, and how you can use it to supercharge your agency.
SPEAKER_02It's true. It's true, Mr. Jason. We're gonna share some of the powerful persuasion techniques that we uh have used that is gonna help you, you, Mr. Jason, and you, Mr. Insurance Dude and Mrs. Ms. Dudette. Um, you're gonna come overcome all these objections. You're gonna close more deals than ever before. I'm telling you.
SPEAKER_01I love it. And this is something that we always need to tune up, right? And you want to know the best part? These techniques are based on proven psychological principles, not just some gimmicky sales tricks by the insurance dudes.
SPEAKER_02Exact mundo. We've studied the masters of persuasion from Dale Carnegie to Robert Ciandini, and we have distilled their wisdom into practical, actionable strategies that you're gonna start using today. What do you think about that?
SPEAKER_01I think it's Robert Caldini, is what I think about that.
SPEAKER_02I say what I want.
SPEAKER_01And I think it's actually with a C H, like a Chaldine, but it's not spelled that way. But, anyways, whatever. So let's kick things off.
SPEAKER_02I'm not reading anything. What? I'm not reading anything. I don't know why you would see any spellings.
SPEAKER_01All right, let's let's kick this off with the first principle. Reciprocity.
SPEAKER_02Ooh.
SPEAKER_01What do you think of that?
SPEAKER_02Is this the idea that some when someone does something nice for us, we feel compelled to return the favor?
SPEAKER_01Oh, you nailed it.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, well, so you could use this in your insurance sales by offering value up front. And whether it's helpful, uh like a helpful guide, a free consultation, even just a genuine compliment. When you give first, your prospects will be more likely to say yes when you ask for their business.
SPEAKER_01Dude, this is like the that is it's so crazy too, because we don't think about it enough. Well, but like it, and you can relate this to your team or anything else, like just give. Like, how much do you feel that once somebody gives something to you that you kind of owe them something? And it's like, why don't we do that more in in all why in everything in life, right?
SPEAKER_02Totally, totally. And you know what? If they hang around and they're on the next episode, we may give them something.
SPEAKER_01Oh drop that little nug. Just a little nug.
SPEAKER_02You know, why not?
SPEAKER_01All right, let's dive into another powerful principle, and that is social proof. People are more likely to buy when they see that others like them have already made the same decision. You know what this reminds me of? Something we did in our agency that was uh super powerful was we were having everybody drop testimonials on Google and Yelp. And then when we were selling on the phone, one of the first things we say is, Here, here's a link to our Google, check it out. Right? And it switched. People automatically said, All right, these guys are legit.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. It's it is great. It's remarkable how we don't like anybody, but for some reason we trust everybody when we're buying a product.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_01Weird.
SPEAKER_02But that's why test testimonials, case studies, they're so effective, right? You you're able to showcase how you've helped other clients solve the problem that you're talking on the phone with this person, right? It's gonna help them achieve their goals. It builds instant credibility and it builds instant trust.
SPEAKER_01Yes, it does, Mr. Craig. All right, but what about pesky objections? It's those things that our agents love, right? You know, the ones that can derail even the most promising sales conversation.
SPEAKER_02Totally. It's crazy because you'd be having the best call of the world and all of a sudden it's just goes south, right? Um, and that's where the principle of reframing comes in. So we need to reframe. Instead of trying to argue against the objection head on, you acknowledge it, then you reframe it in a way that highlights the value of your solution.
SPEAKER_01That's right. For example, if a prospect says something like, I'm not sure if I can afford this, you might say something like, I understand that price is a concern, but let's look at this investment in your family's financial security. Can you really afford not to have the right coverage in place? And then possibly even give an example of something that's happened in the agency.
SPEAKER_02Boom, shaka laka. You just split the script and made them see the situation in a whole new light, Mr.
SPEAKER_01Jason. That's right. These are just a few psychological strategies we'll be unpacking today. We've got a whole toolbox full of persuasion secrets that will help you take your insurance sales to that next level.
SPEAKER_02So grab a notebook and get ready to take some notes, and let's dive in, Mr.
SPEAKER_01Jason. All right. Insurance sales superstars. Let's dive into some powerful psychological tactics that can help you take your sales game to the next level. The
Psychological Tactics in Sales
SPEAKER_01first one is all about building rapport and creating a connection with your prospect.
SPEAKER_02Oh, that sounds intriguing, Mr. Jason. How do you go about doing that?
SPEAKER_01Well, let me tell you, Mr. Craig, it's all about mirroring and matching. Oh. You subtly match your prospect's body language, uh, tone of voice, and even breathing patterns. When you do this, they unconsciously feel more at ease and more likely to trust you. And if you're doing this on the phone, it's incredible how actually doing having your agents do this at their desk makes a big difference, right? So, like if they're smile, like sometimes we'll make them smile or just have them be aware of it. Like, smile. Like if it feels like someone's smiling, you know, on the phone, smile with them because you can hear it in somebody's voice.
SPEAKER_02Totally brilliant. You've nailed it again. It's like you're speaking their language without even saying a word.
SPEAKER_01Exactly. And speaking of language, the second tactic is all about the power of words. And it's called reframing.
SPEAKER_02Yes. And we talked about it, we teased it a little bit, but reframing, it's kind of like putting a new spin on something, right?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yep. It it is so important uh to reframe things for people because they ain't gonna do it themselves, right? So uh in sales, reframing means taking a perceived negative and turning it into a positive. Yeah. For example, if a prospect says, I'm not sure I can afford this, you might reframe it by saying, I understand that affordability is important to you. Let's explore some options uh that can give you the coverage you need within a budget you're comfortable with.
SPEAKER_02Hmm, I see. So you're shifting the focus from the price objection to handling the solution that works for them. And it's brilliant because it's so important that we've done it twice.
SPEAKER_01Bingo, Mr. Craig. And let's go into the third tactic, and it involves association. Right? This is where you link a specific word or phrase with a desired emotional state.
SPEAKER_02Well, being a sociopath narcissist, I don't understand anything about those emotions. So can you give me an example?
SPEAKER_01Craig, you're not. Just because your wife tells you that doesn't mean it's true. Or my wife. All right. Uh let's say. What's that? All the wives call me that. Yeah, well, all the I if you're a guy out there, you've probably heard it. Let's be honest.
SPEAKER_02What?
SPEAKER_01Moving on. Yeah, sure. All right. Let's say you want your prospect to feel more confident and empowered when they think about working with you. You might use specific phrases like peace of mind consistently throughout the conversation. Over time, they'll associate that phrase and the positive feelings that you've created, and they'll be able to more likely take action with you.
SPEAKER_02Genius! It's like you're planting the seed in your in their mind. It's like inception. You know it. Top thing. Yeah. Good. I had a guy, I had a um a sales guy that was really good. Uh, and he was with me for a while. And one thing that he would do on the as he was going through the policy, he would keep saying, This is a great policy. Oh, I love this policy. Genius. Kept doing it the whole time. And I mean, by default, the people would end up loving the policy, right? He's just telling them.
SPEAKER_01Would he ask towards the end of the policy, what do you think of this policy?
SPEAKER_02Oh, we love it.
SPEAKER_01Well, it's a great, I mean, obviously, it's a great policy.
SPEAKER_02Obviously. I mean, it's you, it's all you've been saying about it.
SPEAKER_01All right, let's dive into the fourth tactic. It's all about paying attention to your prospects' nonverbal cues.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Uh, like facial expressions, body language, and tone of voice. Again, easier to do in person, but really pay attention to those uh the, you know, the vocal cues uh on the phone and really pay attention to what you're doing behind the desk. Because I guarantee you this if you're slunched over and you're like thinking about lunch, going out to lunch, and you look like Eeyore, you probably sound like Eeyore too.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Yeah. So, and that's why we bring it up again because it is that important. A lot of people overlook it, um, especially when we're doing phone sales, right? Most agents uh that are getting results are buying leads, they're they're calling them, and they they have their team on the phone doing tons of quotes every day. Well, you have to be watching that because it's very easy to slip into a monotone uh way of delivery. And um, and we catch it all the time. And you just have to take them off, pump them back up, get them going, you know.
SPEAKER_01Yep. Yep, exactly. Like being attuned to their not non-verbal skills, uh signals, I'm sorry, you can build deeper rapport and steer the conversation into a more uh productive direction.
SPEAKER_02Well, I love it. I don't care what anybody else says. Now, what's the fifth tactic?
SPEAKER_01Uh I'm gonna dive into that, but I I just want you to, Craig, isn't this the best uh insurance podcast on iTunes and Spotify and all that?
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Wouldn't it make sense to just subscribe? I mean, since it is the best insurance podcast.
SPEAKER_02I mean, I don't want to call anybody insane, but I'm certainly subscribed to it.
SPEAKER_01Right. Okay. The fifth one is all about helping your prospects visualize the positive outcomes they'll experience by working with you.
SPEAKER_02So this is different than visualize world world peas.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Okay. Unless you're um instead of just features and benefits, you paint a picture of how their life will improve. Is that what we're talking about?
SPEAKER_01Spot on, Mr. Craig. You might say something like imagine how much more secure uh you'll feel knowing that your family is protected no matter what happens. You'll be able to sleep easier at night and focus on things that matter most to you.
SPEAKER_00Hmm.
SPEAKER_02That is powerful, Mr. Jason.
SPEAKER_01That's why we're it's the best, that's why it's the best insurance podcast out there.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. By tapping into their emotions and helping them in a better or helping them see a better future, you're making the decision to work with you feel like the natural choice is basically what you're saying.
SPEAKER_01Also natural. Absolutely, Mr. Craig. Always remember people make decisions based on emotion first. And then they justify with logic. And this always happens. Think about everything that you're wearing, the cars that you're driving. I mean, everything. And by using these psychological tactics, you can create a powerful emotion connection that makes saying yes feel right. Like saying yes to the fact that this is the best insurance podcast out there. Right.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, if you're listening, you love this podcast. I can't wait to start using these in my own sales conversations, nor can I wait to tell all my friends about subscribing to this.
unknownRight.
SPEAKER_01I bet it'll make a huge difference.
SPEAKER_02You know what?
SPEAKER_01Oh my friends would love it. I guarantee they will. And the best part is these brass tactics, these funky actics are subtle and ethical. You're not manipulating anyone. No, you're simply which, by the way, you kind of are. But here's the manipulation has a bad connotation, anyways, because we're always trying to manipulate people. When you say that I saw this movie that I really liked, and you're trying to explain all the cool things that happened to it, that's manipulation. So it's got to all right, anyways, I digress. Uh, you're simply communicating in a way that resonates with them on a deeper level.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, it's the beauty of psychology and sales. It's all about understanding how the people think and feel and using that knowledge to build genuine trusting relationships.
SPEAKER_01I couldn't agree more, Mr. Craig. So to recap, let's recap this. You ready?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, let's recap.
SPEAKER_01All right, because these are brass tactic. Those and they're very funky, these actics. All right, building rapport, reframing, reframing, dude. I like by the way, when we talk about this, you can use this in life and you can use it on yourself to create more abundance in your life. I swear to God it works. All right. Yeah. So number one is building rapport, reframing association, uh, paying attention to nonverbal cues, and helping them visualize positive outcomes. Five powerful psychological tactics every insurance sales pro should master, not just sales pro. I mean, dude, if you're a human on this planet, those five things to be aware of will change your life. Yeah, 100%.
SPEAKER_02Um, and you know what? I can't be more grateful than I am right now, Mr. Jason, for you breaking those things down. It was incredible. I'm sure listeners are also eager to try them out for themselves.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think so too. I mean, since they're listening to the best insurance podcasts out there and subscribing right now, um, I think that they can uh value that as well. And remember, like any skill, these uh funky actics, these tactics, I can't say it. Um, just take practice and think about them, be aware of them. Um, and don't be afraid to experiment and see what works best for you and your team and your all of their unique uh selling styles.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, that is great advice. And I have an additional piece of advice, which is if you want to continue to get these uh great tips, ticks, tips, tricks, tactics, acting, tactics, strategies, handouts, gifts, all kinds of great stuff. I would subscribe to the best podcast uh uh in the insurance world that exists. Well, and that this one. This one, yes.
Boost Insurance Sales With Internet Secrets
SPEAKER_02And if anyone wants to learn more about how they can boost their insurance sales, where should they go, Mr. Jason?
SPEAKER_01Check out Internet Lead Secrets. That's right. Or sign up for the newsletter. Where can they see Internet Lead Secrets?
SPEAKER_02Oh, they could see it over at offer.theidudes.com slash internet dash leads dash secrets.
SPEAKER_01Oh my god.
SPEAKER_02It's a mouthful, but it's a great site.
SPEAKER_01That's crazy. Just Google the insurance. I mean, on our website, we got Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Oh, I guess yeah. Just go to www.theidudes.com and there you can subscribe to the newsletter.
SPEAKER_01It's so crazy. All these all so many letters and dashes and hashes and tags. Hashes. Oh. What about the bots? And the bots. And then we also have the newsletter. Dude, this newsletter's just getting better and better. We're we're we're going all in on 2024. Craig's got all kinds of things working over there. He's working on all kinds of things.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, cooking.
SPEAKER_01On the newsletter.
SPEAKER_02Sometimes he tells me to stop, but I just keep cooking.
SPEAKER_01He does. He does. He just goes deeper into the techniques, and and we do, uh, deeper into the techniques and provide a ton of value, value, and insight. Uh insight.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. So deep that this that this deepness has its own term that we can't say on this podcast.
SPEAKER_01Truth. Truth.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_01All right.
SPEAKER_02Anyway, well, let's uh let's I guess that's it. Let's uh let's put the bow tie on this.
SPEAKER_01That's it. Wow, Craig. This was an awesome masterclass in persuasion.
SPEAKER_02Hmm.
SPEAKER_01I feel like I could sell ice to an Eskimo.
SPEAKER_02I don't know if you can say Eskimo.
SPEAKER_01Oh, that's not the word these days.
SPEAKER_02No, it's Kokomo. Down on Kokomo. And that's tactics.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman