The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Insurance Brass Tactics 3 Ways To Thrive | Insurance Agency Playbook
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
Insurance Sales Strategies
SPEAKER_00Fast.
SPEAKER_01Go for the fast effects. I are agents.
SPEAKER_00Now I am profitable. Agent detailed. I am a great profit. I am agent. We are agents. We are insurance. Dude, I don't know if I've I have it in me to do that every episode.
SPEAKER_01And I don't know if the listeners have have the ears for that for every do you think that the Beastie Boys would give us permission to use just a sample? I mean, don't they do don't isn't that what rappers do? Is is put a do you have to get permission?
SPEAKER_00I think the rappers do that. Yeah, yeah. They've been doing it for more. When I said they, I meant the rappers. Oh yeah. Just to be very, very clear. Very difficult to use to be very, very clear. Very difficult to use pronouns these days. Yeah, what is they referring to now? Shit. Do we have to re-record this one?
unknownNo.
SPEAKER_00Nope. And if we offended you, then you probably I don't even know how you would like this.
SPEAKER_01I am definitely offended because I can't even say words that are like every third word of a sentence.
SPEAKER_00Okay. All right. So on this episode of the insurance dudes, my dudes and dudettes out there, if we've offended you, then uh this probably isn't the podcast for you. Of course, as you know, it's the show where we separate the wheats from the chaff. Yes. When it comes to insurance marketing strategies. And I'm Jason Feldman.
SPEAKER_01And I am Mr. Craig Pretzinger, and I have not heard you talk about separating the wheat from the chaff in such a long time. It's such a pleasant return. I almost said shaft. I you know, so many things that you can't say. So let's just replay. Let's skip all that. Replay what happened last time. So we took a hard look at some of the most commonly recommended tactics uh that some of the people that that think they have it in our best interest are are trying to give. And uh we looked at them and exposed why they don't cut it. So in today's competitive landscape, uh, we saw that we need to move on. That was like, what? And so, Mr. Jason, what do you think?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, we craig and I have the live. So I don't know how well this is gonna go. But uh yeah, well, we're not just here to tear things down, are we, Mr. Craig? No, no, we promised our listeners that we do a deep dive into strategies that actually work. Remember, we set up a whole ending where we talked about you know, sitting out in the in the cold with a warm cup of Joe. Oh, in the pine, the crisp pine air, something like that.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. Uh like Lake Arrowhead, something local to you.
SPEAKER_00Yes. And we talked about the agents that get that all-important benchmark of 10 quoted households a day.
SPEAKER_01Yes, that's right, Mr. Jason. 10. 10. When I heard that, I just thought, what? So that's the number that separates the good from the great in this business. It could be slightly lower, slightly higher, depending on where you are. Anything, everything we do though, every strategy that we've been in that we've been using has been focused on hitting that number. Everything rotates around our quote per day, our our quoted households per day per producer.
SPEAKER_00Let me give you the why on that. Why isn't it more and why isn't it less? Well, we've realized this that most quotes are gonna be, let's we optimize for 30 minutes, right? So at 10, that would be five hours of talk time if they maximize the 30 minutes of talk time for the quotes. Hit me with some maths. Nobody, dude, once you start going over that into 12, 14, whatever, they're going to start skimping on the quotes. It it gets it gets closer to terrible. Yes. I mean, extremely yes, closer to terrible. So so we this metric of 10 might even be too much, to be totally honest. It might be eight, but you can go over under two, and there's an argument for that because of you know, margin for error and all the other stuff. So that's why we do the 10. And I just wanted to give the why behind that because sometimes the why makes more sense. Uh I don't do anything without a good why. Well, so but then I think the sorry, go ahead. I was gonna say, you tell me something to do without a good why, I ain't gonna do it. No matter if it's the best thing ever. Right. I need to know. Yeah, you this is true.
SPEAKER_01I can vouch for what you just said. Yeah, my son's just saying the the other thing is is on the the quoted, is that we're just gonna move on. So let's start with the live transfers. Number one, this is where you're gonna be buying buying the leads that are already on the phone and they're ready to talk to one of your agents. So the appeal here is obvious, right? It eliminates a lot of the front-end stuff, a lot of the prospecting and chasing.
SPEAKER_00Yes, like those cold calls we were talking about last week. Right. But there are some serious drawbacks to this approach. Great. Now I feel like we're talking about Amy again. Oh no. The first is consistency, or rather, the lack thereof. Why is that? With live transfers, you're at the mercy of the lead provider. Um, and some of those might get flooded with calls, and other days you might not, right? So, like, right. What do you do? What do you do when it goes down?
SPEAKER_01And it makes it it makes it totally hard to plan and allocate. You can't, you don't know what to do with your resources, right? So your agents are either twiddling their thumbs, or worse, or the or they're super overwhelmed, and neither is good for morale.
SPEAKER_00And now you got issues, right? Yep. And the second issue, talking about issues, is the cost. Live transfers are expensive. These can be like 50 to 100 bucks. That's 20 times more than you pay for uh the typical internet lead.
SPEAKER_01Right. And if you assume, so let's just let's just for for for uh we're gonna play devil's advocate. It seems that they're great, and we're gonna we're gonna assume a high close rate of 20%. I don't we don't we don't hit high, huh? Okay, yeah, let's do that. So um, so 20% as as an assumption, okay. I'm just not at the A game today. Um, but a 20% assumption is is pretty high, so I think it's safe to to use that. If your cost per sale is still gonna be 250 or more, so that's like best case scenarios, and that's a tough number to build a profitable agency around if that's gonna be your your best.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I agree. But perhaps the biggest issue with live transfers is the loss of control over your data. We've talked about this before, but you know, we gotta we gotta keep talking about it. When you're buying internet leads, you're building a valuable database of prospects that uh you have their information that you can nurture over time. People don't want to buy right away. Like in our agency, I think uh we get five to ten per. Yeah, I wouldn't even say ten. Really, it's like five to eight percent is a one-time, first-time close. People these days they need a little bit more time.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. And that's that's the whole uh that's the whole nature of it, right? As you know, that if you if you put in inputs now, it still takes a little bit of time to to work its way through. So that's that's real important. We're and then uh with with live transfers, you only get that one shot, right? You get that one shot at the sale, and then you don't get to keep the data, it's gone. So I'll tell you, in this business, data is the asset. Yes, and we close we'll close people. We've had reports back of people being closed in the 200s. So somebody recently just said that they got somebody at two something, which is insane. Like they were really, they were really stretching it out. Um, but we know that, right? It's the same way in in almost anything. If you look at your sales funnel, if you look at the people that come to us and and uh and do all of these things and talk to us, it they don't just the first day, right?
SPEAKER_00Yep, yep. And life transfers uh often seems like the solution. I know I have thought it was the solution in the past, but they're actually very expensive, unreliable, and it's very difficult to get to that uh amazing target that we're talking about, the 10 quoted household target a day.
SPEAKER_01Right. Yeah, very difficult. So now let's look at direct mail, the big papery elephant in the room. This is the traditional approach, right? It's like I'm talking just buying a bunch of stuff, sending out from mail house, targeting a list of prospects, and hope they call in for a quote.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, direct mail can work, but it's slow and it's a costly path to 10 quoted households. In our experience, a good mailer might generate a uh like a 75 0.75% call-in rate. So for every 10,000 pieces that you send out, you might get 75 calls. And it's ridiculous to track. I mean, it's so much easier with internet leads, don't you think?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's just extra stuff. I and this is the thing is if you present it to your team, your team's always gonna want the mailers of right because the team wants the easy way out, but the team doesn't care about how much you're spending, right? And I care more about them getting the results, so I'm gonna spend on the thing that's gonna get the better results, which is actually gonna benefit them more because they're gonna they're gonna make more money and everybody wins.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Yep. And the costs add up quickly, right? A Miller uh might cost a dollar per piece or or something like that. So you're looking at a crazy investment uh just to get those those 70 calls. Okay, so if your agents are able to quote 100% of those calls, which is very optimistic and unrealistic, but let's just say uh and you're close and you close at the industry average of around 16%, you end up with 12 sold policies.
SPEAKER_01Oh, wow, bingo! So that puts your cost per sale at over 800 bucks, and that's assuming everything goes perfectly and with really good numbers. So in reality, you're likely gonna be seeing an acquisition cost of over a grand, uh, especially in the beginning, and or even higher in the beginning uh per household.
SPEAKER_00Well, that just doesn't sound very sustainable for most agencies.
SPEAKER_01No, Mr.
SPEAKER_00Craig. No. So you might be able to make the math work if you have a very high lifetime customer value, but it's still a risky and expensive way to grow. I don't like it. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01If there's an option out that cut that that is is has a proven track record to perform better and do it less expensively, then that's where I go. So that brings us to our third option. And I get to I get to deliver the winner here, Mr. Jason. Real-time internet leads.
SPEAKER_00That's right. Winner, winner, chicken dinner. With internet leads, you'll be getting a constant flow of fresh, targeted prospects that deliver straight to your agents. Hey, Craig, when you buy something, do you go on the internet and googly it and type it in? As a matter of fact, I do. So would you, I mean, is that the first place you go, or do you go to Sears or JCPenney first? As a matter of fact, the first place I go is the internet. That's right. Get with it. Like if you still have that old school mentality that internet leads suck and that uh, you know, they're just, you know, this is a this is a a fad, a trend. Dude, the internet's here to stay. I don't know if you've read the news lately. Look at look at the stock market. All right. Who who are the where are the billion-dollar companies? Internet, it it's all internet. It gives you the most leverage. Get into this. Yeah. All right.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Anybody with resistance on that, I mean, I I'm a I'm a little older and and it took me longer to to really convert to it, but it it's it's just a no-brainer. Um, anybody that that isn't is gonna get left behind. And and we don't say it like to upset anybody, it's just man, we really don't want people to be left behind.
SPEAKER_00And if it does upset you, you got to get with it. Good. Yeah, take that anger and go dominate out there. And these
Advantages of Real-Time Internet Leads
SPEAKER_00are the these people have actively expressed interest in the types of policies you sell, and they're out there seeking information on it. Oh, but so many people they sell it to more than one agent, Mr. Jason. Yeah, yeah, they do. But here's the thing that same person's gonna go walk in. I uh so my agency's uh well, I guess it's not here anymore, even though now it's just my office. I don't even know if I'm supposed to say that, but who cares? Um, but in this uh in this complex, there's also the other big carriers in this complex. What are the other big carriers? The farmers and the state farms, uh-huh. Uh so two farms uh and two states, I guess, right? Three carriers. You only mentioned two. Yeah, but I can't mention the other one for legal purposes because I'll be stupid apparently. And nor have we. Yeah, nor have we. I've stayed in the rules. Now, the people that walk around to all the agencies to get all these quotes, like like whoever gets a quote from us is gonna get a quote from them and stuff. Yeah, yes, people do seek out different areas. Who cares if the lead's getting sold to multiple people? That same person is reaching out in multiple areas too. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01So it's like you can't run from it. And so based on the the data, which we talked about a little bit before, we know if eight if only eight, it's like eight to fifteen percent, it kind of fluctuates there, but but of first contact calls, like you know, you quoted it for the first time and it closes, it's only eight to fifteen percent. It's small, right? A very small amount of those people. So so think about it. In the same way, when somebody's walking around shopping or doing the same thing, right? It's it's they are going to look, so it's not it's not a function of who's the best at closing, it's a function of who's the most persistent.
SPEAKER_00Craig, give me uh start with number one. What are the three advantages here? It's I'll tell you what the first one is right there.
SPEAKER_01So you're typically going to buy uh high quality internet leads for around four to five bucks. That's a fraction of what you pay for a live transfer or a direct mail lead.
SPEAKER_00That's right. Second is speed, and that's what you were alluding to earlier. Yeah speed with real-time leads. Your agents can be following up with these leads uh and prospects in minutes of them submitting their information. Right. And that is crucial because the faster you respond, the higher your chances of setting that quote and that appointment. That is right.
SPEAKER_01And thanks for getting me back on track, Mr. Jason, because I did go off on a tangent. But this is a third scalability, super important, right? Um, with internet leads, you can dial up, no pun intended, your volume. Um, you could dial it up, you could dial it down based on your capacity and your goals. So um, while we don't ever encourage quick changes, it does give you that option. And if you want to hit 10 quoted households, you can buy enough leads to make that happen, no matter what. That that's that's a fact.
SPEAKER_00Yes, hashtag tax. Supply and demand. There is way more supply than demand here. And there always will be. That was remember, that's what one of the first things that uh a lead provider told me. I came very close to an account manager, and he said, if you can like if you can make internet leads work, don't ever worry about supply. And that's when we were running out of supply of live transfers, because those things do run out of supply. Anyways, let's talk about the most important thing here. With internet leads, you own the data. Yeah, every lead you buy is a new entry into your database. Right. Right? A new prospect to nurture and follow up with over time. So you better have the rockin' CRM. And if you do, ooh, that is some equity.
SPEAKER_01Yep. And if you get the right kind, which you read about in the internet lead secrets, we talk about all about those, and Mr. Jason talked about that in a second. But if you get the right kind, it's gonna work because you then can build a sustainable, profitable agency. The math works, like it's all about the math. Like anybody that thinks that, oh, this sucks or this, it's it doesn't matter. It's the math. I mean, we have a hundred million dials, it is the math. So um it does work, and and we know that you can do it. So um you got to fill that pipeline, right? You got to get the right leads, you got to get them in there, and you got to be calling the right people.
SPEAKER_00100%. And when you couple real-time internet leads with a well-designed sales process and CRM and skilled team of agents, hitting 10 quoted health house households becomes not just possible, but inevitable.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I remember back in the old, like back before we had everything all in place and did this, and and and I even believed that internet leads worked. Like my my sales agents probably, I don't know, two or three households a day of quoting. And and when I ask, I mean, that seems to be pretty much kind of you know, par for the course. So it's scary, like the difference, right? It's just so remarkably different that I remember just going, that's not ever gonna happen. But no, it does happen. The people that are succeeding are doing it, and it's totally doable. You just gotta follow the formula. 100%.
SPEAKER_00Well, of course, this is just the starting point. Generating the lead or generating the leads is one thing, but you also need to have the right process in place to convert those to clients.
SPEAKER_01That's right. And we'll be diving into the future episodes, the scripts, the strategies, the key metrics that you're gonna need to know and that you're gonna need to be tracking to optimize your sales process and get the most out of every lead.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. So this is it. This is your accountability to become an elite agent out there, right? Listen, every week we're gonna we're gonna get you there. But for now, the message is clear. If you're serious about hitting 10 quoted households and building a thriving agency, real-time internet leads is, in my opinion, our opinion, the only way to go.
Take Action for Success
SPEAKER_00Yep.
SPEAKER_01So start testing, start tracking, start building, do that pipeline, and stay tuned for more brass tank tanks.
SPEAKER_00And what can they go check out? They can go check out Internet Lead Secrets at the iDewes.com. Just go over there. Let's go. But until next time, this is Jason Feldman and Craig signing off. Remember, in this business, action is everything. Action takers are money makers, they say. So don't just listen, implement, iterate, and dump.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman