The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Insurance Brass Tactics To Avoid Failure | Insurance Agency Playbook
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
Bum bum bip bip boom bump bump welcome to brass tactics ghost monkey actics brass tactics ghost monkey actics the series where we uncover the truth about insurance marketing.
SPEAKER_02I'm Jason Feldman, and as always, I'm joined with my partner in crime, Mr.
SPEAKER_00Craig Witzinger. We're here to shake up the insurance world a little bit, exposed some marketing tactics that just don't work for PSD agents. Insurance students are autoffictive to inspect the IRAs.
SPEAKER_01How? Predictable, consistent, and profitable agents failed. I am great. I am agent development. We are agents.
SPEAKER_02We are insurance students. Dude, this is like the third time that we're doing this, by the way. We've it sure is. So we've had to sing the brass tactics, those funky actics multiple times. And it was hilarious the first time.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_02But uh yeah, you're you're probably gonna get sick of that in the future. But, anyways, that's right, Mr. Craig. Carrier management might tell you to try these strategies. But trust us, they're closer to terrible than terrific. Yeah, yeah. So let's start with the first tactic on our list cold calling. Everybody's favorite thing to do. Your manager might be pushing you to hit the phones and start dialing for dollars, or you might be having your team do this. But let's get real. Is this really effective?
SPEAKER_00Epso friggin' not. And that was not in slow motion. In fact, unwanted calls are gonna get you less than a 1% contact rate. That's right. Less than a 1% contact rate, Mr. Jason. Did I stutter? No, no, no, no. No, right. So plugging that contact rate, which is like one thirtieth as effective as regular leads, is gonna wreck you. And I'm talking from experience. Done it. Been there, done that.
SPEAKER_02Yep. Yep. I have too, Mr. Craig. But why is that? Why is cold calling so ineffective?
SPEAKER_00Do you want to tell them?
SPEAKER_02No, you go for it.
SPEAKER_00Okay. Well, it all comes down to turnover, Mr. Jason. So we've talked about the insane price tag of turnover before, right? We won't say Amy's name, but so it could cost tens of thousands of dollars in just the first month, right? That that cost of that turnover. So not only is cold calling ineffective mathematically, but it also gonna require a huge amount of effort to even close some of the results that you get. Yep. Yep. Can you break that down for us, Mr. Craig? Can I? I think you shall. I would be happy to. So let's let's say you want to get a 2% lead closing result, right? So that that's not percentage of quoted, it's just overall. So you buy a thousand, you sell you buy a hundred, you sell two. So uh like I had to change the math. Too many zeros. Um so so with cold calling, you need to make 15,000 dials a day just to keep up with somebody else who is buying um just regular leads and using a dial specialist. That's insanity. 15,000 dials a day. That's like it's incorrect, actually.
SPEAKER_02Huh?
SPEAKER_00I'm just kidding.
SPEAKER_02Oh you're stumping me, Mr. Craig. But that is a ridiculous amount of dials. That's like 38-hour dialing shifts. And each shift probably costs around 150 bucks plus other fixed costs. So you might, you know, save on making your salespeople dial, but you're losing in productivity and employee sack satisfaction.
SPEAKER_00Right. Yeah, I mean, I'd never even thought about it, like breaking down the numbers and doing it all like this until we started doing it all like this, right? But it's remarkable the shift in how you approach it and you realize what a lose-lose it is to go cheap. So, and that's not even taking account the fact that the people hate being interrupted by unwanted calls. So even if even if you're doing it and it were to get results, which it won't, it's just not a good look.
SPEAKER_02No, it's not. No, it's not only not a good look, like when we used to do this in our agency, those cold callers that were in the agency, they were separate than the salespeople, but man, the negative talk and the way the the negativity went around the office, it was horrible. I don't want I never want to be in an office full of cold callers again. It was awesome.
SPEAKER_00It's just a different caliber of uh of individual that's gonna settle for that, right? So it's unless yeah, unless it's outside, right? If it's elsewhere.
SPEAKER_02So if you don't want to do it, so why do we want to make other people do it? It's exactly mundo, as Fonse said. So if cold calling's out, what's the next to terrible tactic on our list?
SPEAKER_00How about um blasting out some generic email newsletters? You know, the ones filled with the boring insurance stuff, jargon and stock photos with smiling families. Oh, yeah. Yeah, I love those.
SPEAKER_02I can feel my eyes glazing over just thinking about them. I mean, people do you think that people actually read those things?
SPEAKER_00Hardly. Most of them go straight in the trash uh without even being open. I mean, it most of the ones that I get, like from some sort of corporate company that's trying to sell me whatever. I mean, it's just straight, right? It's ignored, it's gone. I mean, it may be coming, but I don't see it. Uh and there, you know, uh, and can you blame people, right? We're getting how many hundreds of emails every single day.
SPEAKER_02And then you give them those terrible things. It's it's so true. Right. If if you want to make an impact with email marketing, you need to be sending personalized, relevant contact that actually provides value to your uh to your list, right? Generic newsletters and carrier BS just doesn't cover it anymore.
SPEAKER_00Agreed. You need to be steep speaking directly to your audience's needs. So your market, whoever it is, you need to be speaking to their needs and to their interests. And you want to stand out in their inbox, so you got to be creative. Um, but then email marketing shouldn't be your only strategy.
SPEAKER_02No, no, definitely not as an insurance agent, that's for sure. Which brings us to the final terrible tactic on our list.
SPEAKER_00You ready?
SPEAKER_02Now, this is too much of a build-out for what this is.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_02All right, relying solely on social media ads, right? Now social media can be a powerful for insurance agents, but simply throwing money at Facebook, Instagram, uh, and all that stuff is not the magic bullet, right? Like it was back, what, in 2015, 2016?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's a different totally different landscape now, right? And the problem with relying on social media ads is you're competing. Now the big players are in the market, right? The ad costs have gone way up, and it's really tough to actually invest money and get back enough where you can keep your cost per sale down. So it just doesn't pencil.
SPEAKER_02Plus, even if your ad does catch someone's eye, there's no guarantee they'll actually click through and convert into a uh a customer, a client, right? Yeah.
SPEAKER_00And it's more tougher.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. And with the ever-changing algorithms and ad policies, it can be tough to get your ads in front of the right people. You never even know who you're really getting in front of.
SPEAKER_00Yep. Yep. Yeah, that's right. So, not to mention the cost, right? It's expensive. Social media ads can quickly eat up your marketing budget. It's really easy to go in there and turn it on, um, but you got to watch it because it can add up very, very quickly.
SPEAKER_02So let's break it down. We've established that cold calling, generic newsletters, and relying solely on social media ads are not the way to go. Right. But what should new PC agents do instead, Mr. Craig? How can they effectively market their business and attract new clients?
SPEAKER_03Hmm.
SPEAKER_00You like how I did that? The take your glasses off thing? He looks like that. And if you didn't see that, you could see it on YouTube. Uh well, that's exactly what we're gonna dive into, Mr. Jason, on the next episode. We've got three count 'em. Trace. Two, three marketing tactics that actually work, and we can't wait to share them with you. Ooh, I love that.
SPEAKER_02That's right, folks. In our next installment of brass tactics, those funky actics, brass tactics, tactics, those funky actics. I really just did that.
SPEAKER_00It's so good. Do not send this to our uh significant others.
SPEAKER_02Dude, seriously, if you know our wives, make sure that they do not listen to this. Okay.
SPEAKER_00That was a that was a big setup for a joke.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_00If you know our wives.
SPEAKER_02Okay, we'll be revealing the secrets to effective insurance marketing on those episodes, right? These are the strategies that will help you build your agency. And we like to call it a brand. Build your brand as the agency owner because that's really what it is. Like that you're building is a brand. Like all this houses under your brand. But also establish trust with your audience and ultimately grow your business.
SPEAKER_00Yep. So make sure you tune in the next time. Trust us, you're not going to want to miss it. And in the meantime, we want to hear from you too. What marketing tactics have you tried that just didn't work? Share your stories and struggles with us over at the group.
SPEAKER_02Yes. And that's the insurance dudes group on Facebook. You can Googly it and find it. Yeah. Yeah. And if you're a new pay PC agency uh owner feeling overwhelmed by all the marketing advice and BS out there, don't worry. We've got your back. Stay tuned for practical, actionable tips that will cut through the noise and help you make a real impact. Or you can just go to the iDudes.com for $7. Seven bucks. Seven bucks. We have uh internet lead secrets book, and it comes with a check list of everything you need to know how to dominate with insurance leads. It's a no-brainer. If you can't afford seven bucks, you probably shouldn't be an agency owner. Probably not. It's the cost of one lead. Yep. That's it. The cost of one lead will help you close all the leads.
SPEAKER_00All well, not all of them, 2% of them. That's right. Yeah. So before we wrap up, let's recap those key points from today's episode. First, cold calling. It's ineffective, costly, could lead to high turnover rates in your agency. Don't do it.
SPEAKER_02I love that. Will that be transcribed? How does that get transcribed?
SPEAKER_00We should do just like like Caesar. Yeah. And then go, he should have done that in Gladiator.
SPEAKER_02Second generic email newsletters are a snooze fest, boring, horrible thing that nobody wants. It'll no one's gonna open them. Your email contact rate's gonna go down. You're gonna be in the spam folder in no time. Spam. Right? The only spam impact with your email marketing. You need to personalize your content, make it look more like a letter and help your people. Give them actual value. Okay.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. And third, relying on social media ads is not a sustainable strategy. While social media can be a powerful tool, you need to be more diverse and have a real good marketing mix to truly succeed and use the things that work.
SPEAKER_02So there you have it, dudes and dudettes. Three marketing tactics that might seem appealing at first glance. You might be dabbling with it, but these are actually closer to terrible than terrific. And I'm gonna just keep saying that because I love it.
SPEAKER_00The three favorite closer to terrible.
SPEAKER_02Closer to terrible than terrific.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Don't worry. We're not leaving you hanging. In our next episode, we're gonna share those three marketing tactics that actually work. We've proven that they work, they work, we've done it. Uh tested and retested.
SPEAKER_02Sure. So you so you gotta stay tuned, right? You do. You gotta stay tuned if you want to know the answers to these questions, these burning questions, and they're good. Oh they're good. Are they ever? And they're gonna arm you up like a like a cup of of hot chocolate on that nice cold evening in the mountains with the with the snow amongst the mountain, the the mountain outside.
SPEAKER_00Breathe in that pine-filled air. Oh can you feel that? I can. It's really cool and refreshing. And until next time, keep breathing that cool air.
SPEAKER_03And we'll see you on the next brass tactics. Brass tactics, tactics, those funky tactics.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman