The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
The Heart and Hustle of Insurance Agency Success with Jorge Carbonell PART 2
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
"In-House Scaling and Agency Systems"
SPEAKER_03You have the same underlying fundamental process, right? And it's just like, okay, what can I absorb in-house as I scale? And like as you get as you scale, it makes more sense because it's just it's more efficient if they're in-house. It's more, you know, every it costs less if it's in-house, but you can't afford in-house before you're at that point, right? Because it's too expensive. And that's where somebody like Gary or or you know the other ones out there are are really good at filling the front end of the funnel. It's like buying lease. It's buy our eight.
SPEAKER_02I think what what's interesting about the whole situation with your ops manager is it makes me think of uh I had some situations in the past where I put people in charge and then I'm kind of micromanaging.
SPEAKER_03Oh yeah.
SPEAKER_02You know, like checking on the stuff, you know, do the like it's like I've had uh multiple situations where people have told me, dude, are you gonna do this or am I gonna do this? Like uh I can't imagine you doing that. If somebody yeah, if somebody comes to you, are you gonna override what I say kind of thing? And it's like, damn, like I don't even mean to, but so I've been trying to be uh much more conscious of that over the many years the last many years. But it is funny the more you give someone autonomy, it shows like A, they take ownership of it, or they don't, right? Either way, it's kind of I think we do that because we get scared like things will fall apart, right? But like if it falls apart with that person, they're the wrong person. Or it gets better with the person and then they're the right person. But we get scared that like maybe this is the wrong person, and maybe that's not you know, maybe that's why we're doing that.
SPEAKER_03But uh and that's why you're training to the process and not like to the personality, right? Right. You could identify the process of the city. Right. Yeah, you you find the personality that'll fit in the system, not like it was before typical Craig fashion, you know, try to try to jam the problem so we can make a solution. It's like, no, don't put the square peg in. If it, if I'm not gonna build my agency around the people, let's let's create the system that works and then find the right players to play, right? Belichick Belichick isn't like, oh, you know, whatever, we'll go grab some guys from the high school and uh we'll we'll just figure it out. No, he has a system, and these players will play well in this system, and that's why he gets them, right? Then he videotapes the the who's Belichick. It doesn't matter. So cruiseball coach, right? Cruise ball coach. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02It's funny, um carbs. I I don't know if you know this about Craig, but we kind of figured this thing out within the last month about him. Is that Craig likes to find um solutions and then finds problems that those solutions can solve. Work it backwards. It's interesting. It's an interesting way to hey, look, okay, you're gonna do it the other way, and we're gonna meet somewhere in the middle, it's all gonna work out. He'll find something that's really cool that that can solve a lot of problems. And then he starts trying to see, okay, if I use this, what problems can I solve with it?
SPEAKER_03Okay. So to prove that that we both have ADHD, I'm gonna switch the subject real quick. Jay, have you George,
Technology Chat and Relationship Banter
SPEAKER_03have you seen the rabbit R1? And no, it's not a thing for the ladies. It's a different thing. It's a tech.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Uh Jay, Jay posted about it. That thing is crazy. Did you order? No, I did not order it. What?
SPEAKER_03No, I ordered it. So this thing does it work. I I don't know. We'll find out. I mean, if it does what it says it'sn't been released yet. Huh? We should get affiliated for this. Yeah, it's not out. I think we pre-ordered, I think. But they're releasing it in like waves. So it's 200 bucks, and you don't even get like there's no service, right? There's no service to pay for.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think you have to connect it to like other apps or Wi-Fi or whatever.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. And then you connect it to DoorDash and all that. Yeah. And like you literally would just go, uh, I'm hungry. What should I get? And then it's gonna go, you want tacos, and then you go, Great, order me some tacos, and the tacos show up. I mean, are you kidding me?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it integrates with all your other apps, and then it's just all voice AI generated. I mean, it's it's it's pretty cool. I mean, uh, technology is is just rapidly getting better and better. I mean, um, let's talk about something that is out. I know I commented on one of Jay's posts also. I know you said you were getting that Vision Pro. Oh, yeah. Did you end up getting it?
SPEAKER_03We both got it.
SPEAKER_00Is it you both got is it pretty sick? I mean, what what can you do with it?
SPEAKER_03I mean, it's pretty cool. I haven't done I haven't used it a ton for work. I we need to do some stuff where we're like you could do it on Zoom, it makes a cool little version of you that's in Zoom. That's kind of what can happen.
SPEAKER_00But yeah, yeah. Can you have different computers? So, like when I first saw the videos, I was like, Can you have like actual um a bunch of productive screens up at the same time? Like I have three monitors in front of me right now. You can have like can I have six actual screens? You can have a zillion screens.
SPEAKER_02There's a caveat to that. So you you can have a one screen of your computer. You can't they oh yeah, that so far they don't have it where you can do multi-screen of your computer computer, which I assume that they'll come out with that when you know, at some point. But you can blow it up to like a hundred and twenty-inch screen and then reduce the uh pixels down so that so that you can put apps everywhere over that 120-inch screen.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, like a giant movie theater.
SPEAKER_00Gotcha.
SPEAKER_03But you can put up on the side, like your email over it's so cool.
SPEAKER_02But it's got a bunch of built-in apps. So you can put like one thing that's cool is like uh the Safari browser, you can have like a hundred Safari browsers around you. So you put so you can have your MacBook giant screen, then all the native apps, like uh messages and um tons of iPad and iPhone apps and um uh tons of safari browsers. You can have all that stuff around you too. So you don't so you won't need as many screens from your MacBook. And then they all interact together. So it's pretty cool.
SPEAKER_03And then you also like you could either be sitting in your office, like you just see through it just as a little you know fuzzy because it's like digital, you know, or you could switch it and you could be like in Yosemite, and you're just like sitting on the snow outside of the forest, like with your computer stuff everywhere. Doing quotes.
SPEAKER_00Well, yeah, sitting in Yosemite doing quotes.
SPEAKER_03I mean, I don't do any quotes.
SPEAKER_00I know I'm just thinking how many quotes I could do at the same time with a 120-inch screen and just stuff everywhere, like it's that.
SPEAKER_02That is interesting. Yeah, you can um 50 quotes going at the same time. It's cool at night in bed when the lights are off, like it'll still work. Even the hand gestures will still work in the dark. Really? Yeah, so like I've been in bed when my wife has gone to bed early and um done it. Now here's the other problem.
SPEAKER_03Wait, you didn't you just did you guys just went to sleep? No, she went to sleep and then I wouldn't. What would happen? Like she came into bed and just went to sleep? Like, doesn't weren't you did he miss a step?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, right. Dude, I've been married. I've been with her for 20 years now. I met her 20 years ago. We started dating 20 years ago this year. Well, isn't that crazy?
SPEAKER_03Not to be competitive, but I got you beat. How many years? 26 this year. Wow. Yeah, crazy. You are old. I know. We got married young. Dude, she was 20. Was she 21? 23. She was 23.
SPEAKER_02Wow. My wife was 19 when I started dating her. I was 24.
SPEAKER_03Good job. Is that I don't know. I think that's a good job. It seems creepier now than it did, Greg. Well, I mean, if you were 18 and she was 13, it definitely would be creepy. Maybe illegal. Definitely, I mean. Well, that took a strange turn.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I thought we were talking about Vision Pro.
SPEAKER_03Vision Project. So what else? Um the AI is pretty cool. I've been leveraging that. Yes.
SPEAKER_00I'm sure it has it, yeah.
SPEAKER_03Oh, but Vision Pro? No, I I it doesn't really have anything.
SPEAKER_00You're talking about like ChatGPT and all this other stuff that you know.
SPEAKER_03Well, it's wild because I mean ChatGPT is a baby, right? And it it's something else. Like that just is something else. But now all the other ones are like just releasing so quick, and I don't know how much it impacts agents, you know, from a day-to-day, but but there are a lot of tasks and like quick things you can you can you can operate quicker, right? Like with the information that you can gather.
SPEAKER_02Do you guys use that in the agency yet?
SPEAKER_00Not not so one of so my my ops manager started using it to to for email replies. And uh it's funny, I I started, I was I gave her feedback and I was like, hey, you're just great responses, and then she started doing them like faster, and I look at it and I go, I start noticing a couple errors. I'm like, you're using Chat GPT. So it's like it it makes humans process a lot faster, right? Because it's giving us the information and we can, but it it can't replace us, right? There's still a lot of stuff that we need to reject and and and humanize it, but it does a phenomenal job, right? We just gotta be able to proofread it and make sure that it makes sense for that correct scenario.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. Like you're not writing, you're not writing articles and blogs and copied and pasted it and all of a sudden you have something. Like that, that you're gonna not look good if that happens, right?
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_03But there's but definitely like idea, like idea generation, uh, just like the that little thing right there, the email, that email trick, like it's funny because I've been utilizing it, but I have not been correcting it and sending it to Jason. Anytime I he emails me, I reply with uh the AI, but try to get as goofy as it can go. And then I I'd say he says bad words when he replies.
SPEAKER_02Well, I call it shitty craig AI. That's what what did you do with real Craig? Yeah, where's where's real Craig? That's shitty Craig AI. So that's what we're doing over here. Yeah. So like what's cool, I love that idea. One of the things that like kind of do with Chat GPT is set up uh your own GPT so you that you can make your own GPTs now and have it self-prompt. And so what is what I think is really cool for people to do in agencies is start putting like, okay, you are writing as you know, George Carbonal, uh, you are an agent for this. Give it all this kind of context and then tell it you are gonna reply to all these emails, uh, giving this kind of tone. And and if you whittle if you prompt it really, really, really, really well in the description so that it uses that as a reference, and then just start pasting um your emails in there, it will give really good responses. The but you have to prompt it real well. And then you could share that GPT with other people in your agency so that um so that they can use the same prompting. Right. That's a really cool that is a really cool way to to uh start using it in the in the office.
SPEAKER_03And you have uh like nice crisp email without really any mistakes. I mean that you have to read it. You you have to proof it because sometimes it's wonky. Like like it earlier today when I replied to you, like it, it thought you had the attachment, but I was sending the attachment, you know, like it did it couldn't figure that out, but I just kept it because it was funny.
SPEAKER_02But that's not even Chat GPT, that's some crappy program that you have. Yeah. Spark, it's a really good email.
SPEAKER_00It'll get you 95% there, which is I mean, I think that's amazing.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, yeah. Well, the to remove this, the the typing process on emails, I mean, that's huge, right? Because there's just so many.
SPEAKER_02The the other one that I love that's an easy one for everybody in the office, and I think it's like eight bucks a person, is Grammarly. Have you guys used Grammarly? That one's good. I freaking love it.
SPEAKER_03There's a thousand of those ones.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, it's like a little icon and you type, it doesn't matter what uh program you're on, you type out and it'll correct everything. It'll and it'll give you ideas of the like for the sentence to re-word it so that it it makes more sense and it sounds more professional. So if you're using chat GPT with Grammarly, really easy to correct whatever GPT puts out there. But Grammarly is one of those things. I'm not the best writer. So when I write something, Grammarly always correct it's usually I flip it around because the old ADD kind of stuff. Like I'll put the end at the beginning or something like that, and it'll help me. Grammarly's good.
SPEAKER_03I I didn't like the little green thing. It was in the way of my icon of my my mouse, so I killed it. It has so like like he described it how it works, and and it functions great, but but it puts this little green like tab on the corner and it just drives you crazy.
SPEAKER_02So are you gonna bring her home? Yeah, I'm gonna bring her home. So, like, next, let's do this again and let's check in. So uh one of the things that I'll check in on is uh you know, starting up the sales again. I'll kind of give give you guys an update about that. I know um bringing um my dude back should be interesting, should be fun. We're trying a new system. I'm gonna get involved in into some some new tricks that I might have up my sleeve for sales, plus using the old tricks, plus I'm excited. So I'll I'll get you guys up to
Developing a Strong Recruitment Strategy
SPEAKER_02you.
SPEAKER_03At this point, it's a good time to to be listening and watching. Yeah, I'll fire up, fire up leadson with the I'm excited for the next episode to to learn the systems.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Yeah, we'll see how that goes. If that goes really well, there'll be something. George, we might we might do an event out here in California, FYI.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I saw a little sneak peek to that. I'm excited. Um yeah, I remember we we we did the ignite um a couple years ago now, pre pre-COVID, and um that was a huge success. That was awesome. A lot of good relationships and good networking and takeaways. Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_03Super cool. No, it was post-COVID, wasn't it?
SPEAKER_00Was it?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, it was post-covid because I I had to wear a mask on the plane. Oh gosh, those days were terrible. So this is the worst. I would it made me inter COVID. I'm on I'm in on a plane with a mask on, sneezing. Oh I mean, you know, I can't I know I can't control, but geez.
SPEAKER_02Your allergies during COVID were at an all-time high, and I've never seen anything like that. And the responses of people when you were in public was the best thing I've ever seen in my life.
SPEAKER_03It was I could I could have had a gun and been shooting it, and I would have got a lesser reaction than than having that mask and like the little fiberglass tickling my nose, and I was just sneezing and uh so what what are we checking in on you guys for when we get back? Yeah, I have uh we we've always got great things going. I'm gonna do uh I'm gonna grab some stuff from Jazz and uh we'll talk through that. Uh see where we're at. Talk through. Any accountability stuff? Yeah, we can do accountability.
SPEAKER_02Well, what are we gonna be accountable for for the next couple months? Who? We'll check in with you in two months. A month or two. Is it that long? Huh? No, I'm saying by next episode.
SPEAKER_03I thought it was gonna be more every week.
SPEAKER_02That's what you said. Are we doing this every no? Oh it's gonna be like a m every month or two. I'm just gonna dance then. I'm also doing uh working out consistently uh with physical therapy.
SPEAKER_03And if uh if we get a thousand likes on this uh episode, then Jason will live broadcast every single workout for the rest of the year. I can do that.
SPEAKER_02Even my physical therapy when I'm on the weird machine. Oh, that'd be great. Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, just live, just live stream that. What about you, Carson? So um, we just had six people start with in the last three weeks. So uh I think that's uh a huge piece to see because we we implemented a new training and onboarding and development um strategy for our agency. We have a dedicated leader that's just focused on owning all of those processes essentially. So this is her really second class now because we had three people start two weeks ago, another three people that started last Monday, and then we have another three people starting March 4th. Um back up on Monday. So um, so yeah, we're gonna start measuring uh what the success is of this program and how many people we retain from that and see what the lift we get. Uh, because we know we need good people to keep scaling, and um, it's it's a grind, it's a grind of and it we talked about being consistent. This is one of you know, buying leads, you gotta be consistent with buying your leads and your marketing. You gotta be consistent and not turning off your recruiting funnel. That that's yeah, there's always gonna be somebody that is leaving or it has to be coached out, whatever the case is. Yeah, is that in-house that you're doing that? Yeah, yep. Wow, cool. Yeah, we started it in um late November. We transitioned um one of our rock stars into that role, and then um, and yeah, we I worked with my business coach to kind of develop the processes um that we're you know, she's gonna consistently follow, and you know, from interviewing to onboarding checklists to what do the first two weeks look like in scheduling to how do you grade the act so okay, we're training them on uh build and rapport. Okay, that's great, but how do you actually grade what build and report looks like to give that feedback in real time? So you're breaking out every little thing.
SPEAKER_03Oh, I have one for you. Have you have you heard of read AI? Read.ai. It's a screen cap, so it'll or um it's it like records the zoom, so it goes in Zoom, and I you may be able to do phone calls, but um it it coaches based on what they say. It's it's pretty interesting, it's really cool, and it gives feedback on engagement. So if they do any quotes on Zoom, it's very, very useful. Like we've used it with Jonathan here for uh for the telephonal uh stuff. He's our sales guy.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think my CPA uses that because I get like everything in text after the meeting kind of thing.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, it it re it like there's a lot of them that do that. This one was I because it has this coaching aspect, it's really cool. So I think that would help people too, you know.
SPEAKER_02So continue carbs.
SPEAKER_00You were yeah, I mean coaching to each process and grading it. I mean, it's and then and then she's actually leading those individuals through the first um at least the first 30 days. So that's it's like this, it's like her own pod, right? And then as she um recruits them, trains them, develops them onto with the rest of the you know, the rest of the crew to graduate to the senior sales rep.
SPEAKER_02Love it. Productize. You productized the hiring and onboarding.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, because it's it's non-stopping, and you know, I've I've you know, shout out to Top Tier and Gary, I've used them for a ton of stuff, right? Uh, but I think it's a it's a business development like maturity stage where like this is never gonna stop, and you have to realize that recruiting is never gonna stop. And if you just gotta have that, you know, just like Google has their own recruiting team, right? Like they have their own team. You you just have it's just a step forward in that process.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, you get to when you're yeah, when you're smaller, you you should not have all these processes in your agency or business, right? You're you're just you're using other people's specialties, but as you grow, yeah, i i it becomes such a need. And the size that you are, it makes total sense because that is an ongoing thing.
SPEAKER_03So you have the same underlying fundamental process, right? And it's just like, okay, what can I absorb in-house as I scale? And like as you get as you scale, it makes more sense because it's just it's more efficient if they're in-house. It's more, you know, every it costs less if it's in-house, but you can't afford in-house before you're at that point, right? Because it's too expensive. And that's where somebody like Gary or or you know the other ones out there are are really good at filling the front end of the funnel. That's like buying leads. Hey, if I could buy leads that to get me quotes, great, then I'm gonna do it. If I could buy people to run through my funnel, great, I'm gonna do it. You know, but at which point is it is it more effective for for it to be in-house versus the other side, right? When did you see like when when was it at what point in scaling did you see that it was more of a benefit to have it in-house?
SPEAKER_00Um probably a few, but it was probably October when I realized like I because what happens is I start to we have our team, right? So we got we have we have the team, and then we we lose a couple people, and it's like, oh shoot, I need to make a call, I need to say, hey, I need to turn this on, where really I should just have it consistently, right? I buy leads every day, right? I got transfers coming in every day. This is just one of those things that I just need to be doing every day. And if she's not actively training and recruiting, well, she can use her time to start developing um whether some of the new people that recent, you know, recently graduated through the classes or just anybody that needs further assistance because she's been with me for four years. Um, I mean, she's awesome, right? She understands what we're trying to do. Um, so it was just, and that's one of the reasons we've kind of taken a step back in production because I took the super high performer and I pulled her out in November, and that really hurt us. I mean, she was doing 60, 70 items a month, but really the goal is to replicate her, you know, right.
SPEAKER_03It's having the long vision, right? If if you understand this is a marathon and today's results are, you know, okay, so this month sucked. Get over it, move on. It's a long, it's the it's the long game, you know. Sometimes it it's a tough, it's a tough one when you know that it that that made you miss bonus, uh, right? You gotta wait. But you guess what? Another year is gonna happen. If the other year doesn't happen, then you don't have to worry about it.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Because you're not around for the other year to happen. Well, we have something to check in on me for, and carbs, not really anything to correct.
SPEAKER_03Well, okay. I had I've had four, I've had four sales folks for for a long time, and I've had the same thing happen where you get you do get um you get comfortable with with not having the the hiring machine going, right? And I think with the options that are out there, there is a quick fix if you need, or maybe a perception of a quick fix. I don't think there is a quick fix because you never know, right, how long it's gonna take. So, yes, you definitely have to have it going. And I Jazz and I met when I got back from Costa Rica, and I thought, geez, we just in case, right? Because some people have been out, and it's like, okay, we I we got to get consistency going again. Because I don't change the leads, and I know you like you just keep leads on because if you if you move that, then now you have less players and and less stuff to work with, and then in two weeks you're really screwed, right? And then that's when you get emotional, you're like, I'm done, it's over. So you can't do that, right? So uh we got we did get we hired one guy. No, no preno. Yeah, no, no point, no, two weeks. That was it. He he was on the phone for a week, and and really I was like, Jazz, why did you why wasn't he just on the phone for the first week? Because he'd be gone, we would have saved a week, right? So, but he's learning too, right? That like that's the thing, it's giving autonomy, they're gonna make mistakes, but they're gonna learn from the mistakes. And and I think it's a much better lesson learned when you go through the mistake because you feel the pain, you have to freaking work through it.
SPEAKER_00Well, you're giving the hundred percent the personal question better than answered. I told you we started this in November. The first three people that she hired all we either let go or quit within the first two weeks. So we were so you know, she's she's a high performer, so she was super hard in herself, and again, it's just encouraging and learning, learning from the mistakes, and you know, she she owns that process, so it was like a failure, right? Um, so yeah, so everybody she's hired is still here so far. So we're good right now, and they've been selling for for a week now, and you know, they got some of them have six items, some of them ten. So next month we should we should be in a good spot.
SPEAKER_03We gotta remember that piece, right? Like, like we we're entrepreneurial, and so we sort of we fail, and then we forgot that we fail, we just keep doing it over and over, and then we get the good one onwards, right? And then it works because that's consistency, right? It's another version. Here's another iteration of being consistent. Fail, fail, fail, fail, you're gonna win eventually, right? And
Supporting Employees for Success
SPEAKER_03and most most folks who are are are in a working atmosphere, that's why they're working. They don't want they don't want to fail, right? They don't like failing, and and it's not comfortable. And so, yeah, it's important to support them when they go through that and help like that's a such a huge thing to be able to give that perspective to people. Like, hey, it's okay. Don't like you're all stressed out, don't worry about it. Like, you know, if if it happens again and again and again, then you know, now we gotta talk about something here. Like it's not clicking. But I mean, man, it's great when they make a mistake, right?
SPEAKER_02Well well, the big win of uh if somebody comes in and doesn't work out after two weeks, you you just won. Because like usually with other agencies and companies, it can take months or years. So if you can figure that out earlier on, you like that's a win. Like that's a huge win. Um but I do want to circle back around to Craig. What are we gonna check in on?
SPEAKER_03So you did I did it finish. The so we hired another guy who we're very we're very pumped about, and and I can go ahead and that'll be my thing. I you you guys, you know, everybody's talking about their team, so we'll we'll look and and look at his development. He's he's actually on the phone taking transfers now. He's been he trained for a week, so cool. He's ready to rock. I mean, you know, he's or he's not taking transfers, he's creating transfers right now. Nice. Then he has to do 80 quotes, 80 households. Love it. Yep, but he's a talker. He is a talker, so you know, not out there as much. That's a carved corner. That's a carved corner. Grab yourself a corner.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman