The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
How To Avoid The Highest Cost In Your Insurance Agency | Insurance Agency Playbook
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
The Cost of Not Taking Action
SPEAKER_00It's a playbook, and I'm going to tell you what is the highest cost in your insurance agency. Tell me. I are agents. Now I am predictable. Profitable agents detailed. I am a great profit. I am agent. We are agents. We are insurance. So we were just talking about on the last podcast, we're talking about your agents, right? And the cost uh we can't afford to not hit these numbers. Right. Right. That's what they were saying. And it just triggered in my brain, I'm like, dude, that's what we talk to a lot of agencies about. And like, I tell the story a lot about what was the cost of me not opening up the the other scratch agency um the other a few years ago when I did. Now, at that point, I had uh three kids and I was having another kid, or I was going to, like, that was the debate between me and my wife. And I wanted to open up the scratch agency. We we were able to. There's incredibly high commissions at the time, and it was the worst time that I ever could have done this. Like, like it was such a pain point between me and my wife. And we decided to do both at the same time. So it it actually aligned by like one or two months, I think one a month apart between the opening of that agency and having my kid. And and I was aggressive. I wanted to open with 15 sales agents. I think I wanted to do like 18 was on the plan, but I think I got like I got to 15. And so you can only start hiring. I think we started hiring maybe a little like almost two months early, but like really got aggressive the last month. But like it was like a ramp up.
SPEAKER_01It's so like I think it's so hard that that time when you're like hiring for a place that you don't even have and have no cash flow, right?
SPEAKER_00Right, yeah, yeah, zero cash flow.
SPEAKER_01And you know, like logically, I have to do it early, otherwise, problems, right?
SPEAKER_00But I don't want to spend, you know, it's the yeah, and so I didn't so I had a I had a bonus from that year that I got from from the prior year of investing a lot, and and it was basically all the X extra money, and that that was like the beginning of it, right? I was gonna invest all that in it, um, and more if I had to. So it was a very hard time to do it, but I did it, and we got through it, and actually I had to make a deal that I would work less um if I opened the scratch agency, but just give me three months um of of working a little bit more, and so that's what we I did, and I held to it. I was actually home by 5 p.m. every day after the first three months. So and I've worked and yeah.
SPEAKER_01I think it's important to recognize for you, like it's big, is that not only did you you did that and you said I'm gonna work less and go home at five, which I can attest that you did because there were times when we needed to do stuff and you're like, I got out.
SPEAKER_00And you're we're talking on the phone as you're driving home and pulling in your that's when we did the the whole teledudes telefunnel agency, and um there was a lot going on at that time. Yeah, it's crazy.
SPEAKER_01Oh well, yeah, that's what I'm sorry, I totally dropped off, but but what was what was happening is we're talking three months before, like so you're going in, and now we have three months before COVID happens.
SPEAKER_00Oh, yeah, yeah. Remember that I asked everybody on the call if they remember COVID, and everybody did, so yeah, yeah, and it was a crazy time in my life, so and I and I and I there was a lot of pressure, and I look at that point and I think I could have not have done that, right? And then and I could have saved that bonus money and everything, but the cost of not doing that would have been around. It's in the millions, yeah. Yes, yes, yeah, in the millions of dollars. So no joke, like the cost of not doing that would have cost me over a million dollars for sure. Like, we're talking way over.
SPEAKER_01But I mean, like honestly, I think that decision, I I know for me, because I bid it was 12, 13 years of of doing okay, you know, like having some some bonuses some year, you know, we maxed it one time, but never consistently, month after month after month, crushing it, right? Yeah, and it it that opening that thing was life-changing. Like if I didn't open up that that agency and do what we did back then, if I had said, you know what, I'm not sure. And then when COVID came, if I said I'm not sure, like yeah, it's a total I'm I'm not having we're not having this conversation. No, there's no such thing as as teledudes or any of that. I wouldn't have you know four sales producers doing 250 this month, like it's just like it's it's insane, and it would have cost millions of dollars.
SPEAKER_00And now you have multiple properties that are generating income outside of uh the agency, so there's a lot one decision. So let's let's what is that principle then? It and it's really the cost of not. I don't know if for anybody listening, if you haven't heard of um a book called 10x is greater than 2x or 10x is easier than 2x, and it's by Benjamin Hardy. And it's like it's really the science behind making a 2x move rather than a um 10x move. And so, really, the principle of the cost of not, the cost of not doing something, if there's a great delta in that, a lot of the reasons why we don't take a 10x jump, the reason why we don't take an investment is because there's a lot of pain in it, right? There is pain in it, it's hard. It was hard for you, it was hard for me. Like there was a lot of times where it's like, holy crap, the wheels might fall off, but it it made the 10x jump in your life, it made the 10x jump in my life. Even your friends and family will deter you, right?
SPEAKER_01Like, hey, I'm gonna I'm gonna go big. I'm gonna like I remember telling somebody I'm probably gonna be spending well, half a million on leads this year, and they're like, What are you freaking crazy? Why would you do that?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I was spending more than that.
SPEAKER_01Well, yeah, whatever.
SPEAKER_00I yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_01I mean, I just did the I'm like, okay, 50k a month, probably somewhere around there at one point, you know.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah, at one point I spending like 80,000 a month on yeah, and and prior to doing that, I never spent 80,000 a month on anything, so um that's scary when you first do that, right? It's freaking terrifying, especially when you're ramping up and you're and you got all these crazy bills. But dude, here's the thing it doesn't matter. Why is that funny? Why is that funny? Okay, so my son, his favorite phrase is well, he he only did it for a little bit of time, but he started this phrase. He's now mind you, he's like five years old at the time, and he would you'd say something to him, and he goes, It doesn't matter. So it would piss us off. He would use it at the best times ever, kind of funny, but like dick move, right? Like it's like, oh dude, you're such a punk. So he kept saying it. Well, I flipped it on him and I started saying it to him. Now he didn't like it so much, so he stopped saying it. He stopped, oh, that's mean, that's mean. I was like, dude, you came up with it. So, but regardless of that, now me and my wife say that uh about a lot of stuff because dude, guess what? It doesn't really matter. Like, like you'll get through it. Like, there's you know, there's little bits of pain and stuff like that. Like, what's the worst that could happen? But really, when you start thinking about like what's the worst that could happen, it's the cost of not. What's the cost of not doing something? Right. I know when I started my agency, the cost of me not figuring out sales and everything. I mean, my life, I would be making 60 grand a year, right? So I haven't even made close to that in I haven't made even close to 10 times, 10 times that in the last few years, right? So it's like the cost of not doing that was incredible, life-changing, right? So, what's the cost of not? Everybody's so concerned. What's the cost? Everybody would like to your point with the leads and the expenses that it costs in your agency. What's the cost? Like, oh my gosh, that costs so much. Well, you know what? I know a lot of agents that have a small book that are putting very little to nothing into it, that are always complaining about their bills and stuff like that. The cost of not for them is life-changing, right in the opposite direction. Yes, you you know what I mean. So, what's a little bit of pain to get past and into whatever you want? So I really hold tightly to the principle of the cost of not the exactly what your agent said. What's a we can't afford not to do this? Like, yeah, there's things like letting yourself down on a lifestyle that you want, you can't afford not to do that because you're gonna live an entire life beating yourself up. Oh, I could have done this, and I like you beat yourself up all the time about today could be your last day, yeah.
SPEAKER_01Right, like yeah, every single person involved in this conversation right now, and everybody we know today could be their last day. So, do you wanna go like I'm very glad that back in back then I decided to go all in and now where we are over the last four years because of the that decision, even though it was very painful at the time and very scary, because it it I can't imagine the other side of it. Like, I would be I would be in a lot of pain right now if if I didn't do that, right?
SPEAKER_00But yeah, it took us it took some pain to do it too. It does, it always does. It's not a linear growth, like as you as a business owner, if you want to be uh self-employed, then you're gonna be taking two X steps, and you can gradually get to like you're only gonna take gradual steps every year at year year, but if you really want to be truly become like a business owner and business investor, like you're actually investing, like you need to make some some some decisions that are two steps back to go five steps forward. Yeah, it is never linear. It there's no way that like if you look at any company, there's no way any company has taken big big leaps without taking steps back, without going in the red, without doing things that are easy, like like the easy steps are just little investments and little this, right? But guess what happens? Time's going by, time's going by, time's going by, right? Selling a million dollars in an agency is that a lot or a little? Some people say a lot, some people say a little, right? But what's the variable of the difference? Is the time if you write that in two months, dude, you're a rock star. If you write that in 10 years, you suck, right? It's the same, it's the same amount of pain, it might be over a longer period of time, and it definitely nets a different return.
SPEAKER_01I think I could safely say that the spouse of the one who's takes 20 years to get to a million and premium versus the one who writes the two million is gonna be much happier, and then that means that that the agent is happier, right?
SPEAKER_00And the spouse also is gonna give you crap either way, maybe, right? Maybe, maybe, because it will take that con it for me and my wife, very hard conversations, like very rocky relationship around the time, but that was one of those times that in our relationship we went through it, and I think that there is a trust factor that was built through that that wouldn't have been built any other way.
SPEAKER_01Sure, you know, it's good, it's not all smooth sailing, right? Like I think those those those rough seasons are what make the good seasons even better.
SPEAKER_00I was just talking to Brian this today about if you build if you plant a plant, right, and you have support for that plant and it grows and its stock grows, right? Yeah, compared to a plant that is has wind and everything else, the two different plants as they grow and they're and and they grow to their uh full extent, the one that has had the help that had that like branch or whatever tied to it so that it grows straight and all that stuff, to compare it with the other tree that had all of the um the wind and everything against it, yeah. That plant that didn't have the help is 10 times stronger than the one that had the help, right? Because it had it was growing in wind, it had to build up the strength, it had to the roots had to go deeper, it had to be stronger, right? So when we do this for ourselves and for our family and for our teams, it's might be a little painful. The wind could be painful and it might feel like it's gonna blow you over, but at the end of the day, you are gonna have the strongest uh trunk and the strongest roots at the bottom of that.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, you just gotta link up with the with the right folks that'll support, you know. That's right, yeah, 100%. But not like the stick, not that make you weak. Not the stick, no, not the stick, not the stick. Well, this I look at the stick, the stick is like having a job that's corporate, that's safety, like be safe, right?
SPEAKER_00It's the safety net, 100%. It's the safety net, it's not ever taking the risk, it's not risking the win, right?
SPEAKER_01I mean, for all intents and purposes, if you're doing 2x or you know, one and a half X or 1.25x, then it is like a job. That's what you do in in the corporate world, right? Right? You claw and scratch and stay safe and and and move up, you know, in incremental pieces, and that's not the point of owning a business. If you if you have the business, you you are able to position yourself to have that 10x. Right.
Sales Strategy and Growth Vision
SPEAKER_01And I used to think it was crazy, like, oh yeah, it's just sales, it's sales talk, but then you see it, then you do it, and all of a sudden it's like, holy crap, now I want 20x, right?
SPEAKER_00Right, 50. Yeah, we we had a rough year last year, like like last year was very difficult for me because we couldn't sell in California in our agency, and it really sucked, it really did, especially after you know, knowing what I know now. And so last year was a very 2x year for me, but it put a lot of things in perspective and knowing what I know now, and and knowing what I've you know, what I've been able to to do and been through and stuff has really helped me cast a vision for the future that I'm excited about. And yeah, and uh it's time to do some more of those 10x moves uh this year. So yeah, let's do it.
SPEAKER_012024, 2024, 10x or more. That was a 10x poem. That's a insurance dude's poem original. Yes, and you you may reproduce it as you head on over to Internet Lead Secrets at the main site. Just go over to the iDudes.com and you'll yeah, or click the link down below.
SPEAKER_00Link down below, subscribe. Just join us on this journey. Let's 10x together. Let's not 2x. If you're in a season of 2x, sometimes we have to do it, but you know, let's let's 10x the season. Give us a holler. 10x and that's a coffee. Coffee talk playbook.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman