The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
P&C Sales Success Found Somewhere Weird?
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
Creating a Profitable Sales Machine
SPEAKER_00Mr. Jason, you're never gonna believe this. You want to hear a story?
SPEAKER_02I would love to.
SPEAKER_00It is almost the end of the month here. I have four salespeople and have had four the whole year. It's just been four, and we've been really working it, doing a lot of stuff. We're on pace for 235K, and one of them is over 50k on pace.
SPEAKER_02That's crazy. And you're literally days away from the last day of the month. Yeah. So what's the deal? I want to know what's the deal. Give me the secret sauce.
SPEAKER_00It was honestly somewhere that I hadn't even expected. And it's something we've talked about a lot, but if you want to hear about it, Mr. Jason, you're gonna have to hang out till the very end.
SPEAKER_02Ooh, you're a teaser, Mr. Greg.
SPEAKER_00I sure am.
SPEAKER_01I are agent now. I am profitable. I am great. I am agent. We are agent. We are agent.
SPEAKER_00Okay, so I'm in the in our sales meeting and we're going through some of the numbers, talking about a couple of our comp things that we have going for for the team, and they're getting all pumped up, getting all excited.
SPEAKER_02I'm doing a lot frequently, right?
SPEAKER_00Yeah. You got to change it up. And and something uh you and I were talking about a lot was was doing shorter runs. Yeah. I I tend to get in these the long end of the year one, and um, I've always kind of done that. And and what what I've noticed, and I think you have too, is you get a little farther into the year, somebody gets behind, and all of a sudden they're so far gone they can't catch it. It's like a demotivator. 100%. Yes. So you gotta get pissed. Yeah, so like for for me, I I love the notion of it, but I think that it has to be above and beyond in something that's just crazy, right? Like just off to the side. And I'll and I'll talk about that in a minute, but I want to talk first about what we're doing every week. So we're doing something every week that's leading to really great weekly engagement from the team, right? So they're always fired up because they're competing weekly, right? For I love that, yeah. Yeah, and it's not it's not a ton, a couple hundred bucks here and there, um, but or a hundred bucks for the week or or fifty, or or maybe it's stacks if it's if it's um, you know, number of quotes, but it's always some activity-based thing, has nothing to do with results. So whether they asked a certain thing from the script on the call, who did it the most, right? And then they'll then we'll make a fun, spin the wheel, do whatever, right? So throw in some fun to it, they get all excited. And and when you do that, then they're they're thinking about oh, I'm gonna get to do this thing because I did this effort, and they're they're willing to do it, right? They love that. I love it, yeah. And so that's that's it.
SPEAKER_02That's the one thing that oh no, oh no, that's not it.
SPEAKER_00We're not even close. Yeah, I love it. Next thing, so let's talk about the big play because I think this is fun, and I and I threw it out there because I really wanted to see with the team how fired up they get. So I I teased it on the board, just said half a million dollar producer. I just wrote half a million dollar producer, big trip for 2025, find out more, and I just wanted to see what they would do. And all of a sudden they're asking me, they're asking Jazz, hey, what's this? What's that? What's 500 500,000? And then instead of giving them the answer, he started telling them, Oh, well, that is about 45,000 a month, 47,000 a month. And they're like, No, no, no, no, no, how much we have to do, and and so we just kept getting them excited, not telling them. I dropped it on them today, and and it's basically I I talked to a travel agent, had them put together a little package that I could that I could show them, a little five thousand dollar trip. And you may think, Mr. Craig, you're gonna give out five grand. I I would happily give out five grand if somebody writes five hundred thousand in premium for the year, right? That would make sense all day long. And I didn't just throw it out, I pull it out of the air. I looked at our lifetime value of somebody that we of five hundred thousand in premium and look at what that turns into. It for for us and for what we write, we're looking at at well over close to three hundred thousand in revenue if so if if a producer writes five hundred thousand. So can I afford the five thousand? Of course, right? All day long. I could afford a uh a much bigger trip for them, right? But there's a lot of listening that goes into that. There's a lot of yeah, yeah. No, but but honestly, like for them, they went bananas. They're of course they said, Well, do we get paid while we're on the trip? They have to ask those questions, but yeah, at the end of the day, it was all they do not. Okay, yeah, ah, come on, you're gonna trip. I don't know, we'll figure it.
SPEAKER_02It's gonna be interesting though.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I don't know. I mean, whatever I'm supposed to do is what we'll be doing.
unknownYeah, right.
SPEAKER_00And and I think the first bridge to cat to cross will be for them to hit that, right? Yeah, I like that. So guess what, Mr. Jason? That was not the one thing either.
SPEAKER_02Oh, so you're well, I'm so so far we have our weekly stack, which I love. I I've always loved the weekly, and I especially like it with teams. Um, and that makes it that gives that always gives a fun element into uh the weekly, the the Monday through Friday, the Monday and Monday through Friday. But now we have energy, yeah. You have to have that. Yeah, that's why when that's why we always get in these conversations, and um I now I don't like the long play, but if you stack the the weekly play with the long play, that's interesting because I I love that. I love that because then there's like multiple levels to it. You have to have the the short play because that's exactly what they're doing, right? They're going that every two weeks they're getting paid, right? So right around there, they're getting paid one of those weeks, has a has a commission check. So that's that's the level at which they're expecting things. So like if you can do weekly, you're on on you're on fire because there's they're seeing it, they can see the results immediately. But now we stack this really cool um long play on it, and I can't wait to hear what else.
SPEAKER_00Oh, and a little subset of the long play. I we also showed them how much total commission that means for the year, too. So that's an extra 30 grand in in commission. They're like, you get paid 30k and you get a trip. I mean, right? And yep, and so then it it's now connecting, connecting them to solve their biggest pain. Okay, now this is the one thing. Now, if you've listened to this podcast for any length of time, then you know that we've talked about something that everybody on the internet's talked about at one point, which is people are far faster to avoid pain, far faster to move to avoid pain than to seek pleasure, right? Right. So, so let's frame this situation with that, right? Um, I had I do have one that has been here, uh well, two of them have been here the same amount of time. One one came and was a very strong salesperson. Okay, so she's she's capable of hitting it more easily because it's not painful for her to do the activity because she gets it, she's a she's a she does does the stuff now. That's important because she's the person that the rest of them saw do it the first time. She's had her 50k month, they've seen it's possible, right? Right, and because they saw it's possible, they they went through the pain, even though you would avoid it, they they did go through it because it wasn't as painful. We made it incremental, like we just gradually over the last year kept moving them up until they were hitting it, and they saw um right that she was able to achieve it. Oh, call her Angie that Angie was able to do it, right? So now they'll now they see it. So this month, or no, last month, they all all of them were over 35k. Wow, they might have all been over 40, but it's close, they're all right around 40, which is the important part. All right. So now they've all hit it, and they all they all cleared their commission too. Like they didn't have chargebacks, they were solid.
SPEAKER_02So now first off, I want to congratulate you because I don't care what other BS companies say that oh, our sales agents reach this much and this much. We know the real numbers and most of it's BS, right? But like to have 40,000 across like as a let's say it's 38 or even 35 average for four sales agents is phenomenal. Yeah, uh a captive, right?
SPEAKER_00And it's and it's I think I think it's your belief as well as mine. Um, that if somebody could write 35, they can write 50. I mean, that's just a no-brainer, you know. It's like if somebody can't get past 20, then they're never gonna. That's it.
SPEAKER_02You know, my highest sales producer hit I think fifty-four thousand one month. Quevos, maybe maybe you're not supposed to say names. Oh, I I said huevos, eggs, rent cherubs, cherubs, yeah, yeah, but um, yeah, 54,000. And it was like that was the four-minute mile for me for me. So, yeah, I mean, I a hundred percent think you can do that.
SPEAKER_00I think 40k it at least in Arizona, 40k is the four-minute mile. Like, when they like all of them have now cracked 40, they got paid on 40. 40 is a big commission jump here. So, you know, my frigate bail was pretty high this month, yeah. And it will be high next month, but that's that's fine, right? Who cares?
SPEAKER_02Because it pays for itself. Do you want a freaking awesome sales team that is gonna pay you a ridiculous commissions in the future? So it might not be your return on investment, and we've talked about this a lot. Might not be it's not this this right. You went negative a little bit. This one, or maybe uh probably you broke even it's pretty close, yeah. But you know, you're gonna get a minimum of four. Uh, you're gonna get a minimum of five renewals, four renewals, I think. Yeah, four renewal minimum, minimum average, yeah, on those policies. It's free money at that point.
SPEAKER_00It's kind of money. You can almost look at at the like it's two businesses. You have your main, you have the business that's just sitting there and creating the recurring revenue on one side, and then you have your growth business on this side, and this one, the one that has the recurring, is helping fund the growth one, and then the growth one is kicking more back over to the it's like this symbiotic thing. But if you don't think of it like that, I think it it gets kind of worrisome, and then we're we're tracking the wrong thing, the wrong activity against the wrong outputs. Does that right?
SPEAKER_02You're you're not looking at like you like I like your analogy there, the two different sides, the growth units is an invest. You're an investor at that point. Yes, you're not just an agency owner, you are an investor, right? You're working on the business in the other one, but you're at that point, you're working as an investor.
SPEAKER_00Yes, it used to bother me when like somebody from some marketing company or lead company or whatever said your investment in this thing will be this, because I didn't think of it like an investment. I thought this is stupid. This is freaking stupid sales talk. But then when I started looking at this and thinking of it like this, like an investment, it changes, right? It's like okay, I'm taking I let's say I need to make money, and my business isn't making that much money, but I can I have access to a hundred thousand dollars. I can take that money, I can invest it in the market and get my eight percent, and hopefully it goes up this year. Because if it doesn't, then I'm really behind, right? Or I take that hundred thousand, put it in my agency, follow a process that I've that I know works because I've done it, and create a money multiplier.
SPEAKER_02100. Now let's get back to 54 or 50,000. Yes, you want to you're trying to get up to there.
SPEAKER_00So so they all clear 40. They all now believe,
Marketing Strategies and Agency Growth
SPEAKER_00and this is the part. Let's put a bow on it. This is the part that I can't believe, and and you cannot make this stuff up.
SPEAKER_02Oh, yeah. Okay.
SPEAKER_00They all told Jazz this morning after I left, and they were all pumped. They said, he said, all right, is everybody, you know, great. You always all clear 40 this month, you're gonna you're all gonna hit it next month, or is everybody hit 40? And and they all like agreed and said that they said, we can't afford to not hit over 40. So understand, like they now reverse the pain. The pain is no longer I need to do all this to write this, right? Which they were, which they'll figure out ways to avoid and never quite get there. Now the pain is I can't afford to not do that activity because I have to have that, right? So the pain is now losing the commission.
SPEAKER_02100%. It's the cost of not. The cost of not is everything. It's like not we always talk about this too when you're investing into like different marketing and all this stuff. What's the cost of not doing what's the cost of not growing your agency? Like for me, not growing my agency would have been, especially during the growth period of opening the scratch agency.
SPEAKER_00Wait, is this what you're gonna talk about on the next episode?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, let's just do that. Let's just do that.
SPEAKER_00Sounds like a really good job. I'm very interested in that.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, subscribe. Uh opt in for internet lead secrets. I think it's like seven bucks, but it's the awesome book that uh you'll get on internet lead secrets that we're talking about now.
SPEAKER_00Hey, and if you know what, if you don't want to spend the seven bucks, that's fine. Go down, you can go get the uh newsletter. Newsletter's free, and we're gonna give you great tasty tidbits, and then you probably and then you can taste them.
SPEAKER_02And that's a coffee dot nibb it nibble nibbit.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman