The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Why Insurance Sales Problems Are Not Sales Problems | Insurance Agency Playbook
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
This is an insurance playbook, and we're going to talk about why your insurance sales problem is not a sales problem. I am agent. I am Craig Funny. I am Jason Felton. We are agents. We are injured.
SPEAKER_01What up, Mr. Craig? What up, Mr. Jason? That is crazy. How is it even possible that your sales problem can't be a sales problem?
SPEAKER_00I know. I know. And that's what we that's what we always think, right? Is that that um anytime we're struggling with sales, we think, oh man, it's a sales problem.
SPEAKER_01It's a sales problem. And then so what do we do? So I think the first thing that that I've done over the course of my career is they're not selling well. Um, we're gonna run out and and really work on training them to sell better, right? It seems like the natural thing to do, right? Seems like the right thing, yeah. So we get them in, we buy some kind of uh coaching platform, get them in there and train and train and train and train and make them these incredible salespeople. And then what happens? We're still getting the same results, same results.
SPEAKER_00How's that maybe a little bit better?
SPEAKER_01Maybe a little bit, right?
SPEAKER_00Slightly, yeah, slightly.
SPEAKER_01So we were experiencing this, right? We we were sitting here trying to do this. In fact, Mr. Jason and I, to give you a little backstory, the reason the way that we met was I was selling him a coaching program to do sales, right? And and as we started building out uh the marketing component and really figuring out what would drive the most quotes in our agency, we were at the same time trying to get really good at selling. And what we noticed was the very thing we've been talking about.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. And I remember during that time, I bought a bunch of sales stuff. I was on a sales. Yeah, you always make fun of me for how much stuff I buy, but I bought every course, every book, and everything because I knew that that was the thing for me and my agency. It was like, dude, I was making nothing. I think I made 60 grand the first year, like netted around 60 grand, and I was like locked into a $750,000 loan payment for 10 years, and I was it's like this this sucks. Like, I this this can't just keep going because um yeah, I don't want that life. I mean, not that that's bad, but like I did not want that. So right, right.
SPEAKER_01Well, and so so when we started putting pen to paper and we're watching, we're watching these results, we we noticed that when our people were doing more quotes, they wrote more business. Go figure, right? And and we're thinking, oh, wait a minute. So we have we have different variables that we're inputting into this thing, one that's further towards the front, right? One that can make a bigger impact sooner, and that's more quotes. Yeah, so it's interesting trying to solve the I need to make more sales, so I'm gonna train them to get better at selling, but not look at the thing over here that actually is really gonna move the needle the most, which is more quotes, right?
SPEAKER_00Right, and there always has to be a through line from the beginning. So the beginning would be making sure that there's enough people for them to talk to up until the end where you convert them to a client, right? Yeah, and and it's like all the every single touch point in between needs to be looked at. And what's fascinating, I didn't even realize this until we opened that second agency and we started selling a lot, is that and we started, you know, we had a big team of around 15 people at that time. Yeah, crazy. And I was looking at all the different skill sets, everybody had different skill sets, right? Based on numbers, you would say, I used to always look for people that were the best salespeople, and you could you could say, oh, this person is the best salesperson, but when you look at the numbers, all the touch points and everything else, whoever followed the process, even the worst salesperson would get a very similar number. The swing point between a great salesperson and the worst salesperson, all things being equal, all the touch points being equal was a very slight difference of result. Very slight. So it became well, it's the process rather than uh the person, right? It's the person that can follow the process that that has the um the advantage, so it's more of a mental fortitude thing. It's like and and that's when you and I started getting really into uh you know teaching like the mindset stuff to our teams, and that's honestly so much more powerful. You you almost, and that's where you were saying at the beginning of this, uh, that the sales skills, the sales skills are important, but uh all you need is a few of these like theories, right? The the a few of these principles instilled in your team, and then you need less tactics if you can get them to perform consistently, and that's the hardest thing, right?
SPEAKER_01And in the beginning, I think it can help if you have one really good salesperson just to prove that it's doable, right? Because I remember like forever, my my salespeople were stuck, and I mean this is before you know we opened the third and all that stuff, but but um they were stuck at that 2025, like to above 25, almost impossible, right? And it really it really felt like if somebody like got to 29 or 30, it was like whoa, they crushed it, and and it was it's all in here, right? We probably weren't feeding them enough enough quotes, but they also didn't believe like 25 was the amount, it's kind of like banisters breaking the four-minute mile, right? Nobody could beat the four-minute mile because nobody could beat the four-minute mile, but as soon as somebody believed they could do it, they did. Yeah, and now everybody beats it, even you, right?
SPEAKER_00And and if you can even take that to the agent. We work with so many agencies, and a lot of them come in and don't believe as well. They're like, All right, well, let's see if this works. It's like first off, anything works if you work it. Anything, even mailers, you know. I think mailers are garbage. I mean, but it it it they do work.
SPEAKER_01That's fine if you want to pay more, you know. Right. But if you do it and you follow the process and you do it for long enough and you track and measure, yeah, that'll work. Right. It won't work as well. I mean, you could get the same output, but maybe it's gonna cost more. That's the problem, right? Like, I mean, after testing, and that's where you get right. If you can load them up with enough quotes, then now you have data and you can look at which thing that I'm loading them up with the most quotes actually gets the best results, you know, the best CPS.
SPEAKER_00And I would say I think you can get the same CPS with mailers, maybe, yeah. So I would say that the reason why you probably won't is because going back to everything that we're talking to about now, consistency and having the process, there's it's impossible to track a lot of that and measure and and be able to follow the KPIs. So, although that you could get the same numbers, and I'm sure some people do, but there's no way to monitor that so that it can be done consistently, like you can do if um, you know, following a process of of leads coming in, like like definitive leads, like you know exactly this, like these 10 people, their names and everything, and then tracking it all along your CRM and then following that. And like there's no way that you can't have that level of accuracy with mailers unless you're tracking every single incoming call and tagging them as um as a lead and then tracking it back to the marketing material.
SPEAKER_01And there's well, there's also no way to know how many people open it, right? Right. Okay, I mean, and and that's an important detail when you're spending tens of thousands of dollars because you need to to get the volume from the mailer, and you don't even know how many people opened it, it's problematic, right? That's like saying I don't know how many people when I made dials actually pick the phone up. And the second piece is arguably the well, the second piece is the next most important piece, right? Because if we don't know our contact rate, if we don't know what they open, then it's hard to make the next decision, right?
SPEAKER_00And I would argue that it's a like what if it's a branding play? If you have an independent agency, sure, it could be a little bit of a branding play as well, but if you are a captive, you are promoting the captive agency, and what's crazy is they could take that material and then call in, and then the call gets diverted to the local agent, and you did the marketing for it. Yeah, that's bananas, it's bananas. I don't want to spend money for Sam's agency down the street, right?
SPEAKER_01Right, yeah, so that's a little tangent on yeah, well, that's good stuff. I think we could put a button in it because we're 1024 in. Cool, and you know what? Most people don't get it uh get an audio timestamp like that, so you're welcome.
SPEAKER_00Do us a favor, subscribe, whatever you're listening to right now. Subscribe to this, and um, we have a few other subjects that I know you will be dying to hear because we have uncovered some secrets that uh we excited to share with you.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, if you want to hear uh a little bit about how one of my folks is gonna is on pace for 53k this month, maybe you want to listen to the next one.
SPEAKER_00Ooh. Or click below for internet leads secrets, and we have a little uh are we is it seven dollars? Seven bucks, seven bucks. You get a book on um everything internet leads and how to close them.
SPEAKER_01Yep, it's the best seven bucks you could ever spend. That's it, and that was a go.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman