The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Insurance Narratives, Laughter, and Story-Telling with Larry Nisenson! PART 1
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
The wildest thing that has ever happened in my career involved me, a New York Giants fan, taking six other New York Giant fans to the Giant Eagles game at Lincoln Field and essentially seeing six minutes of the game, 15 minutes of punches, and the balance of the time in the back of a police car. Yeah, I would say that qualifies as the wildest thing. And I have to tell you, my agents loved it. My name is Larry Nisenson with Assure Allies. I'm from uh Princeton, New Jersey, and I am an insurance dude.
SPEAKER_02Oh that's a story. So what did your guys do?
SPEAKER_00Kind of like the skipper going out and getting mad on the on the pitcher's mound, like running out and getting ejected from the game. Is that what you did?
SPEAKER_03It's almost that bad, except I told these guys not to show up in our giant jerseys. You can't see I'm blurred out behind me. Huge giant fans. And these guys show up, we meet, and they're all decked out in not just in a jersey. They got the face paint, they got hats. They're going in, they want to go in with the foam finger and not the number one figure, if you know what I'm saying, right? They're going in the building. Yeah, yeah. I'm like, no, this isn't gonna happen, guys. No, no, no, no, come on, it's gonna be fine. It's you know, it's six of us. We're gonna no, it was brutal. We drank in the we drank entailgated, we went in. I don't even think we got the seat warm by the time it just started going down. Um, and then we were out, and we literally spent the rest of the time. You know, it's not like the old vet where they had a jail in the basement, but we were like cornered with the police before they tossed us out. Like, okay, guys, thanks for coming. It was awesome. Great seeing you. Crazy stuff.
SPEAKER_02Wow, that is hilarious.
SPEAKER_00Well, so what led up to that point? Certainly, you haven't been in brawls and in every uh stadium jail, hopefully. Or maybe I have not.
SPEAKER_03I'm uh I'm not a brawler at all, but um what but you you know anything about the Giants and the and the Eagles, it is smash mouth football all the time. And you have to know your place. Like I normally I've I live midway between Giants Stadium and and Lincoln Field, and I go down to watch the Eagles on occasion for the Giant game. I'm just not dressed all decked out. You know, you sort of sit there and you know do a polite golf clap. Maybe if something happens that goes your way. But these guys were having none of it. And how obvious is it to see six guys in red, white, and blue shirts amongst a sea of green and white. Like, you know, it's not like we were blending in anywhere. And it was uh it was it was brutal. It's actually the second football story I have. I won't bore you with a bunch of other stories, but I have a Ditka story that might be the funniest story, if not the wildest story, which I hired him to do a presentation for me by top producers. And and right before he gets on stage, part of it is gonna talk about leadership. We're in Chicago. We bring out a hundred top producers, and he's coming to do a like a 20-minute, 25-minute conversation about leadership, right? And at the end of it, he's gonna sign some footballs and do like three soft tosses into the audience for people to get signed Ditka footballs. And my hand to God, right before he gets, he gets on stage, he starts presentation, and the phone rings in his pocket. He looks at it, he goes, I gotta take this call. He takes the call and he doesn't realize that his mic, or he doesn't care that his mic is still, he's wired, right? The lavalier is in, and he starts cursing on the phone. What the heck do you mean about this? What the what are you talking about? And he's barking and screaming. He comes back, he's like, I gotta go do this thing. I'll call you in 20 minutes. And he comes back on the stage. Now, these are financial advisors we have in front, and he's sitting at the lecture and he raises his finger, he starts pointing at his finger. He's like, Let me tell you something. That was my daughter, and she just had her financial advisor stole money from her, and he goes off for 10 minutes about how he wants to get his hands and kill this guy, right? Oh in the meantime, I'm sitting there with the president of my division, and he's looking at me like Larry, what are I'm like, I don't know, it's Ditka. We have to, what am I gonna do? I mean, it's Ditka. Right. So he goes and he does the thing, and he starts to walk off. And his agent must have reminded him, you got to toss these footballs, right? So he walks back on stage, he picks up these three footballs, and there was no soft toss. He's firing bullets, three bullets into the audience, knocked somebody off their chair. I, you know, these were not 25-year-old guys, these were bank brokers, these are a little bit older. And so, anyway, it was a fiasco. We get our we get back the evaluations when it's all over. And I'm like, oh my god, we're gonna get panned. They're gonna be like, what kind of trip is this? The highest rated part of the show, the entire four days, the highest rated was Ditka yelling and screaming and firing those footballs into they thought it was staged. I was like, Oh my god, how do you repeat that? But that's it's so great. Yeah, what's the likelihood of having two football stories as the wildest thing that ever happens? Wow, yeah, so so Ditka is a ditka. Ditka is a ditka, he lived up to the name in exactly the right way.
SPEAKER_02Wow, that is wild. That is so funny. I can't believe I what what are the chances of him getting that call while he's with a bunch of financial advisors?
SPEAKER_03And by the way, who takes a call in the middle of a presentation, right? You're paid to get on stake.
SPEAKER_00It's probably the one call he would take is his daughter, right? 100%. It's like the one call.
SPEAKER_03And you know, he thought it was gonna be like this. Maybe he had a maybe she knew he was on, and he's like, Don't call me so he sees that it's an emergency and his right, right? Whatever it is, it was an amazing coincidence, and it turned out that happened that was in 2001. It was 2001. So think about it. Here it is, 23 years later, and I'm telling you, I can see him getting veins coming out of his neck, his face is turning red. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Oh, it's pretty cool.
SPEAKER_02So that's exciting. Yeah. So, did you ever think when you got into insurance that you were gonna have such exciting stories?
SPEAKER_03Uh, no, let's think about what we expect the insurance stories to be. I was at Nelba and I had one too many drinks. I was uh, you know, I wore the wrong color tie to a presentation. What would be the crazy story? Never those types of stories for sure. And I have to tell you, um, when I think back on my career, it's almost 30 years I've been in this crazy industry. It's been nothing but the most fun I could have imagined in our career, which is kind of cool because it's not what nobody thinks they're gonna have the most fun you could imagine in the insurance business. But it's awesome, it's awesome. Great people, great business, and oh, it was a plus. We get to help people out along the way, and who does want to do that?
SPEAKER_02Love it. How'd you get into it?
SPEAKER_03So, what I found out really quickly is I am a terrible retail salesperson. Everybody needs to know their strength. I started out as a retail bank broker asking, meeting with clients and asking for a check. And what I found out is I can appreciate how hard it is because I totally sucked at it. I was terrible. I felt bad, I loved the business, but just couldn't pull off the conversation with retail um clients and started. I had built a little bit of a group. And so I started spending time working with the financial advisors and training them how to ask the right questions and realized that what my strength was was helping financial advisors, helping insurance agents understand these crazy complex products that we have and telling them a story in a way that was really relatable, and then let them do the job that I was not equipped uh to do. And I'm not ashamed to say it. I think the world of retail agents who go out every day to talk to clients, to problem solve for them, to help their families, hardest job in the world, the most satisfaction, and definitely something I was not good at.
SPEAKER_02Wild. Yeah. I love the idea of like it's so funny. Like it doesn't matter how boring the topic or yeah, let's go with the just just boring, how boring the topic could be. Like the power of a story. It's incredible how much you can get through with that. And I think a lot of it, I think the good insurance agents naturally have that, right? They have that ability to be able to tell stories and talk. And then the the ones that do have a hard time don't see the difference. And maybe the the agents that are really good at telling it, they don't even realize it's like kind of their superpower.
SPEAKER_03100%. It's a hundred percent their superpower. And they tell it in a way, the great ones tell it in a way that nobody feels like they're creating a story for the benefit of a sale. They're just having a conversation. They're telling people who need some information, a story that translates that information to understandable, digestible bits and gets at whatever is the motivator for action, right? It really is. And when you see, you could see two people in a crazy way tell the same exact story. And one, you're like, oh my God, I would buy this thing in a heartbeat. This guy is genuine and sincere. And the other guy could read the same story, and you're like, no, it just is not resonating. And the and the great ones are truly amazing at it for sure. Yeah. I, by the way, was not one of those great ones. Shamwow.
SPEAKER_00Billy Rays. Um Billy Mays. Yep.
SPEAKER_02Billy Maze. That wasn't Shamwow. Shamwow was the guy that uh that um I think he slept with a hooker and got the remember it. Sorry, yeah, you're right.
SPEAKER_00OxyClean. I'm thinking of OxyClean is yeah, Billy Mays is amazing.
SPEAKER_02Remember the Shamwell? I don't know what. Sorry. Sorry, but that's Shamwow.
SPEAKER_03No, go for it. Don't go. Sorry, let's hear it. You can't bring up a hooker, Billy Mays, and not go with the story.
SPEAKER_02So if you if uh the Shamwau guy, what's his name? Um was Shamwell just like the towel that worked really good.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, yeah, right. It could clean your table. Yeah, you could use it for anything. You could wash your car and then clean the baked on dishes with it. It was amazing. Right, plug the hole in the boat. Yes, that's right.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and he always it was Vince. What is his name? Vince. No, Vince. Gosh. I believe his name is Vince. Look him up, look up um uh Shamwau guy. I think his name is Vince. And he got like he has a mug shot all over the internet. So I love that commercial. Remember that? This is Sham Wow guy, and he's like always he almost seemed like irritated. Like, all right, blah blah blah. I always thought it was the fun, funniest commercial, and he did a few of them. And that that was such a huge infomercial. But then looking back, I remember looking back, and all of a sudden in the 2000s or something, his mug shot comes up and he's all tore up, and it said something about him with like a hooker, and I don't even know. So like something went down. It wasn't worse than the Gary Bucey mugshot.
SPEAKER_03Right, it wasn't worse than the Gary Bucy mugshot, which might be the most classic of every mugshot of any mugshot ever done. That is a good one, yeah.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, that is a good one. All right, I totally derailed this. That's okay. So you know something about the old folks. I do, I'm one of the no, I'm not one of the I I will be at some point one of the old folks, but I'm not god willing.
SPEAKER_03We're all gonna be one of the old folks. I mean, uh, the alternative really isn't very cool. So let's let's hope younger dead folks. So that's yeah, exactly. And I do, unfortunately. So what's happened to these boomers? Dude, they're in a lot of trouble, I'll be honest with you. And here's why they're in trouble. We know the statistics, I don't want to get caught up on statistics, but right, there's 60, there's 50, 60 million people over the age of 65. There's 10,000 a day that are turning 65. By 2030, there's going to be 70 plus million people over the age of 65. And less than 5% of them are prepared for a long-term care event if it happens. And think about what our financial advisors and life insurance agents do. They're amazing at solving the three biggest challenges of adulthood, right? And sort of your finances. They help, they do an amazing job helping people save for retirement, figure out how they want to retire, sock away, max out your 401k, put some other money away, buy a house, and try your best to accumulate as much. And they do a great job at that, right? And then when somebody gets into retirement, either through the benefits of life insurance or through a financial advisor, they then start to get into the income phase and they do that in the right way. They draw down the right in the right method, whether it's a 4% withdrawal, whether it's using a life insurance for tax-free income, whether they're using some strategy to live in retirement for. Amazing job. And for those that are fortunate enough to have money left over at the end of the journey between our life insurance and financial advisors, they do an incredible job of wealth transfer. Those are the three stages of sort of somebody's financial life. What they do a really poor job on is talking to people about the single biggest impact to that retirement savings, which is a long-term care event, right? That doesn't matter whether you use the conservative number or of 50% or the slightly aggressive industry number of 70%. Some big number of those people are going to have a long-term care event, and they're going to need somewhere between 70, 80, 90, 100,000, $200,000 to pay for that event. And there's this enormous misnomer, this terrible belief around that group that Medicare covers that expense, and it doesn't. So there's this tsunami that's coming. We know it. I know it. Many in the industry are trying to raise the red flag as quickly as we can because we see around the corner. And we're just, we have not, for lots of reasons, which I'm always happy to talk about, we've not done a great job of creating education and awareness so that people can decide how they want to do it. Maybe people aren't going to do anything. Maybe they're going to self-insure. Maybe they're going to say, it's okay. I don't care if I don't leave my kids any money. I'll run this thing out till I don't have a nickel left. And I hope that before I die, the last check I write bounces and I've done my job. And there's nothing wrong with that. That's cool if that's what you want to do. We only want to make sure that people understand that this is coming for a large swath. And for those that are that want to plan for it, we want to help companies, agents, producers, everybody who's in the value chain recognize that there's modern ways to cover the long-term care expense. And that's what we're trying to do, just create awareness of the situation and the fact that there's more modern solutions than most people are thinking about.
SPEAKER_02So, what are those opportunities and how can agents have those conversations that are needed in order to uh shed light on that?
SPEAKER_03Look, it's a hard story to talk to people about. Let's establish from the get-go. Nobody wants to talk about their mortality, right? Worst than their mortality is nobody wants to talk about morbidity. Nobody wants to talk about being disabled. Nobody wants to have an unpleasant conversation around that. But that's what we signed on for, right? What we signed on for in this crazy industry is not just stories about Mike Ditka and the Philadelphia Eagles. We signed on to have hard conversations about prepping people. And there's plenty of resources out there to help agents and advisors educate their clients on what, on, on what and how they can prepare, right? They could go to the tried and true places that are, you know, places like AARP, they can go to LT the ILTCI organization, which helps around long-term care. They can go, if they're an independent agent, they can go to any of their carriers that they're working with. Everybody has plenty of information around the education of this. What I would say the biggest challenge is, is that agents generally, in my experience, and there are always agents that prove me wrong, which I love to see, agents are reticent, right? They're hesitant to want to talk about something they're not a resident expert in. And the long-term care insurance space is super complex. It's complex because it's got bad headline risk for people who own a policy and their premiums are going up. There's headline risk because carriers are leaving the marketplace. What so I get agents not wanting to talk about it. My advice to them is if you want to go back to your back office, if you want to go to your IMO or your wherever you do your business through and just get some education, that's awesome. If you want to go to an independent site, right, my company site, we do not sell a product. I want to be super clear. We are in the business of helping people figure out the financing of aging, right? So neverstop.com is where we talk about modern solutions around how to finance your aging. You can go there. You can just do a Google search on long-term care, modern long-term care solutions. There's plenty of places, and the products that are out there are amazing products. These are products that blend life insurance and long-term care and annuities and long-term care. There are new disability-based products that sort of bridge into long-term care. There's short-term care products. There's so much out there. And the price point these days, what every carrier that I've seen is looking to do, what we help carriers do, is create customized products. So even somebody who doesn't have a ton of disposable income can put a solution in place, even if they're just dipping their toe in the water. For us, the key is just having agents and advisors have the conversation because I really don't want to turn this into a downer at all. I'm an upbeat guy, but there is a cautionary tale to be told. And I told this story, I was asked to do my previous life, I was the chief commercial officer at Genworth Financial, big long-term care, big life, big annuity player. And I was asked to do a presentation in front of a group of compliance officers for some broker dealers, wirehouses, and planning firms. And I said to the person who asked me, You're not going to like my topic. I'm telling you, you want me to speak, happy to do it, but you're not going to like the topic. And the topic that I spoke about was around the litigious nature of society and the impact on EO insurance for firms and agents and advisors that don't present a long-term care protection story for their clients, whether the clients buy it or not. If you say that you're a financial planner or you tell a client you're doing holistic planning or you're involved in holistic planning and you go through with a client those three stages we cover, and you haven't had a conversation just to cover yourself, that says, by the way, are you aware that 50 to 60 to maybe 70% of people are going to have a long-term care event that could really invade the savings that you've worked your whole life to do? If you don't have a sheet of paper in your client's file that says you at least had that conversation, the wrong beneficiary is going to ask for that and say, my clients lost, my parents rather lost 20, 30, 40% of what they had saved for. And that advisor or agent could find themselves in trouble. So if for no other reason as a KYA, KYC, or protection, start to educate yourself a little bit and tell a story to your eight to your clients. Send them to a site if you'd rather them go on their own because you don't feel comfortable, or find a resident expert to help you have those conversations just to protect you and what your client's nest egg is. That's sort of the advice I've been giving over the past few years, folks.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman