The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Culture!
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
It's a coffee talk. It's a coffee talk. And if you've never listened to us before, don't just go away because we said coffee talk.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_01You don't want to hear about this culture.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. I want to talk about culture because I know we're going into the new year. Happy New Year, Mr. Craig. Oh, happy new year, Mr. Jason. Yeah. Well, you know, I one question that uh always comes up is about culture in the agency. How do you build a team that's uh, you know, happy? How do you build um and and you and I have had many times that the agency was great or the agency wasn't great, right? So what are the ingredients? What are the elements that make up a good culture in an agency? And I have a few of them for you. Oh, do you? I do. Incurance students are automated to itself by our agency. Now by encouraging the state, predictable, and profitable agency sales. I am a great company. I am agent value. We are agents. We are insurance. One fact about this is a great culture in an agency is by design. It doesn't just happen. So if if you're not thinking about this, if you don't, if you're not really thinking about how do I make uh this agency great, how do I what what do I have to do to my for my team, not to my team, but for my team, in order to create a great culture. And I know I thought about this so many times when I first started in it and man, horrible at the culture. But I realized that more coffee, yeah, which is part of it, right? Offering them uh it's it's an offer, and that's what's crazy. And we just talked about um selling and uh when it comes to our team, like you know, moving back from that selling to towards the uh to to new clients and our our current clients, but then moving into helping our team, and that's who that we're selling now. So that's that's what I think is incredibly important, and and not to even if you are selling on the front end, you have to look at it like you're selling to your team as well. Yeah, and so how do we sell a good culture in our in our agency? Um, do we? I have three three things, three things, and as we're starting the new year, I think every agency needs to do these three things. Oh first, yeah, get your pin out, maybe lick the end of it, and then so you so it'll yeah. First thing is core values. Oh, yeah. Core values. What are core values and why are they important? Well, why why why are they important? Why? Because these this is the way we operate, right? Yeah, this is um the quick guide on how to handle any situation in the agency, and so many times we're quick to show a process of oh, this is how you make notes or like like a tactic, but we need a philosophy, we need a way to handle every situation, right?
SPEAKER_01Like selling with integrity, right? Like having something like this is our one of our values, right? Right. And it and it's it's also really important that they're not just BS, like you see a lot of like the really big corporations and they have all their values up on the wall, and then you know, you talk to the people that work there, like, yeah, none of that, right? Yep. So I think I think that a lot of folks maybe get a bad taste in their mouth about values because of that. And you know, a lot of people have come from the corporate world where it just was sort of said but not done, right? But I would guess that at some point when those values were established, they were believed and they did they did do it, right? And then at some point it gets too big and all that happens. But for us, it's really important because it helps to make decisions, right? You can look and say, Oh, this is this aligns with our values, let's do that right, right?
SPEAKER_00So really critical. And you can you can come up with it with your team and figure out like the way I describe this is if somebody does your core values, they should be the perfect team member. So if they do all of them, then they should be like uh the perfect person for your agency. So how do we do this? And to your point, is uh, you know, is it can't just be wishy-washy. So if you have a core value, um like integrity, list it, but then tell the www. So why is this important to the agency? Uh not the world wide web. W w h w. Why it's important, how it can be used in the agency, and give examples of of of that, right? So w. I know I started switching the stuff around. The we. Yeah, the we I like it. But yeah, so um that's the first one. And and the best way to use the core values is to hire, and anytime anything goes wrong in the agency, link them back to the core values. Well, this is not following the the values, and this is what we do here. Yeah, yeah, this is what will he do here. This is what we will he do here. So that's it. And then the second one is mission.
SPEAKER_01Oh, and this is not just some position, no, no, it's not, Mr.
SPEAKER_00Craig. No, not some position your agency's in. But what is what is what is the mission of your agency? What is the thing that you're all of your agents and you can get behind? How are you going to operate? Um what are you guys striving for? If you were in a boat and you're rowing, what is this island that you're getting to, this heaven island that you're getting to? Right. What is the mission that you guys are on? And I think it's important to come up with that mission that everybody can stand behind. It's the it's the batteries, it's everybody's batteries in the agency to keep going.
SPEAKER_01Oh, it's an electric. Yes, it's definitely electric. And then the leads are the gas, right?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so mission incredibly important as well.
SPEAKER_01Um, and well defined, right? Like it has to be articulated and not just something you slap together, like we're here to help people get insurance. Um probably something a little stronger, right? At that point, I would say peel the onion. Why? Right, because they might lose their things. Why? But why something bad might happen? Why?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so that yeah, yeah, and and it's it's gotta be, it's gotta be a way that you guys operate. It has to be like we're we're doing things differently because um one great one that I love is uh the Apple Think Different campaign. It's like such a cool manifesto, if you will. Like, like that's something that you could stand behind that they're trying to change the world, you know. Uh and that's where like a mission needs to be it needs to be deeper, it needs to be something that you know the whole team can stand behind that they can be proud of that. When they're not feeling like it, like the batteries. The reason why I said the batteries is because when they don't feel like operating at 100, it gives them a reason why they gotta kick it in high gear.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and it gives the consumer something to align with too, right? Like you're you do this, so they the team understands they do it for this reason, and the consumer realizes they do it for this reason, just like uh uh like Nike, but like what you're saying, right? Yeah, or I'm sorry, like Apple. Yeah, um, it's it's the same thing, right? It's it's aligning with the consumer because the everybody is different, everybody's an individual, right? Everybody likes to look at themselves as an individual, so boom, it hits right on the right on those heart strings. Yep. So if you can do something like that, yep, 100%. And then the third. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00And the third one is the vision. Nobody, I and I think we get we get lost in this. Uh, this is another thing that we're talking about this morning. Was we get lost in this as the owner, that we don't overcommunicate enough with our team on the vision of the agency. You know, what is this place going to be like in six months, 12 months, three years? Uh, one of the things that keeps coming up is AI, AI and all this stuff. So, like with this new world ahead of us, what we've dealt with with 2020, what we've talked about working um remote or not remote, like all this stuff. What is your vision for the agency of the future? And in particular, your agency, and how like you got to have a vision statement that can communicate to your team on the future, and it's gotta be a bright future because that's the thing that will pull them forward. The the mission gives them the batteries to keep going when they don't feel like it, and the vision is the thing that pulls them forward. Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_01I think the vision also is a great reference point for looking at the team. And if you notice that it's not resonating with some people, then you know that you have the right people on or you have the wrong people on the team, right? So really good as a temperature gauge. And again, it's like all of these things, right? As they all work together, they they all make the decisions instead of being about the person, it's about these principles, right? It's about yeah, about these, this vision, about these. So it's so important to have it all documented because now it's not about the person, right? Take all the defensiveness out of it.
SPEAKER_00Yep. And it and you have to give the whys behind it, the whys behind each core value, the why behind the mission statement, the why behind the vision, um, and how how it how it uh pertains to them, not to you as the agency owner, but to them individually. And I think that when you get real clear on this and you think of the agency that you want in the perfect world, design the core values, the mission, and the vision around that, and get real clear on that, and then start holding everyone to that and start bringing it up in meetings, start preaching it, right? Then in six months, in 12 months, you will have that agency that you dreamed of. Yep.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's a hundred percent. Like we're our own worst enemy in that we won't we don't believe that we can do the thing that we see the other people doing, right? Like, yeah, I never thought that we could be at 12 million or whatever, right? Like, I don't yeah, just didn't seem possible because the cash flow wasn't there. I had every excuse to not be able to do it until I did it. Yep.
unknownRight.
SPEAKER_00And it's just like okay, this whole thing of culture and stuff has to be by design. You you have to be intentional about this, uh, otherwise it will go to the default. And I'll tell you one thing working at in an agency as an LSP is so freaking hard. And the hardest thing to do is to hire new people and get them trained up to be proficient and to be a part of the team and to to to get them up and running. Like that, that takes up so much of your resources in your agency, time, money, I mean, you name it. Um, and then you're putting yourself uh at risk of it being the wrong person and derailing, you know, what you've built up in your agency. That I mean, we we have to take this uh seriously and put intention behind it. Otherwise, it it will go awry at some point.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. In the pro in the last one, we talked about like the what we did, right? Like what were the steps? And it was it was pull ourselves back, not talk, and then focus on the culture, right? Because the the thing that was broken in my agency for a decade or almost a decade was was the culture. There never was a culture. And I remember saying, How does you know, how does this agent have such a great team? I can't, as soon as somebody comes in, then somebody leaves, and it was always it was because we were always desperate, right? Doing it desperately, we didn't have we didn't have the the values, we didn't have any of these things laid out, and we expected it just to fall into place. And it's like you said, it's by design, it's very intentional. But once it's there, it's there, like that's it, right? You're not gonna change it next year. Oh, you know what? We decided to we don't want to go with integrity this year, right? Like, no, once you have the things in place, because they're your values, they're there. That's it. The hard work is done, right? Yep, now it's all just gravy and easy and candy and unicorns. Yeah, it's still hard, but but it's more effective. 100%.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_00So if you enjoyed this, like, subscribe. Yep, join the group. Oh, join the newsletter. Can they pound the like button?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, or yeah, just oh maybe not that motion. That was weird. Yeah, that might be that that might be aggressive. No, it's donkey Kong with the hammer, and that's a
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman