The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Why This Insurance Agent Doesn’t Know How To Turn On A Computer!
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
Well, hello, Mr. Jason. I guess this is a coffee talk. Is it is it coffee talk? Are we going back to the old? I think so. All right. Well, yeah, we had a lot of folks um sending some death threats and hate mail that we didn't have coffee talk. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Insurance to automate it to a agent now. I am covering the predictable and defective and profitable agent sales. I am great company. I am agent government. We are agent. We are insurance.
SPEAKER_01So we were just talking. Um, I love the story that you just told. Yeah. Just told of somebody, um, an insurance agent that uh that gave you inspiration. And you're you are definitely in a different spot than you were even when I met you with your agency and everything else. So I think that this if you stick around to the end of this, you're gonna get have a a few huge takeaways from the story that Craig's gonna tell. But Craig, tell me about this agent. That how did you go to this event? What what was it?
SPEAKER_00So there's an agent um in the carrier that we're with. Yeah. Uh, if if you're with this carrier, then you've heard of the green sheets, um, and you've heard of this guy, Bill Egger. Uh yeah.
SPEAKER_01How how many years ago was this?
SPEAKER_00This is 20 2017, so six. Oh, yeah, it 2017, 2016. I think 2016. Okay, yeah, 2016, because Neil and I went out there. So we went to um to Texas Leaders Forum, right? And um, I was like half as an agent, half as doing some other stuff, but but I went in and it was great. Tolga was there, it was like all the old guys that we talked about. And and I went to where were you and where were you at in your agency? Like, what was your daily man? It was it was tough. Like we were really good at sales, but we were really bad at prospecting. And what we didn't realize was of course we're really bad at prospecting because we don't have enough time in the day to prospect, right? Like we didn't we hadn't put that together yet, like we didn't understand that. And when you say we, you were in the trenches too. Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah. I mean, I was selling, so that's what how long ago is that? Four. It's 20, it's 2024. Happy New Year, Mr. Jason. Happy New Year, Sah. Jeez, we totally forgot about that. Um, yeah, so it's uh, you know, eight years ago, I was in there doing it. I mean, I haven't even I don't know how to do that anymore, but he was the he was the inspiration for that, right? Like I remember going to Texas Leaders Forum, Tolga was there, and Tolga was kind of like that too, not really as or not writing business, you know. He was he was more as the business owner, and as and a lot of the agents that we started connecting with and talking to, or I was talking to, um, are kind of in that place where they're more like pulling the strings, and they were real plugged in with Bill. And I just looked at him when he was up there and he said this one line that it was like that was it. He says, he gets up on stage, somebody asked a question about, well, when you do this, he said, he said, Whoa, are you you asking me about how to do something in the system in the computer system? I don't even know how to turn on my computer. Like that was what the age, the guy that's the agent of this very large book in out in Texas said. I looked at, I said, Wait a minute, he doesn't even know how to log into his computer. That's the best, right? I'm over here sweating, sweating, sweating. What is he doing that that's the case, right? And he was crushing it. Oh, crushing it, right? I mean, and he had other businesses too, right? He's running, he's running this event. He he created the green sheets, so he did he had all these other things, which I also was very interested in in that too. I didn't want to just be the agent and then that's it. Which there's nothing wrong with that, but you know, I get a little bored, so I want to do other fun things too.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, that is crazy. I mean, he was probably joking a little bit about the computer, but I mean, you and I, you and I when was the last time that you without I don't know much about the systems, that's for sure.
SPEAKER_00Right. I'm not the person to go to when you have a question about how to run the quoting system. There's people that are much better than me.
SPEAKER_01So the question is so you take this guy that doesn't know how to turn on a computer, he's inspiring. Now we're talking like we're kind of doing the same thing. So, what are the steps for an agent to go from being in the weeds, which we all have to be at some point, from in the weeds to be able to operate like this and being able to not just survive but kind of thrive in that?
SPEAKER_00Sure. Well, I mean, there's steps to it, right? You can't just all of a sudden say, I'm not gonna do quotes anymore. Right? There's a there's a gradual shift, you know. If um, like think of think of uh an estuary, right? The water comes in from the ocean, it mixes with this fresh water, and then there's a whole nother environment. So we have to we have to slowly do that. We can't just automatically like instantly pull ourselves out and expect everything to go well. I mean, I guess you could, but it's not gonna go well. So I think um at the beginning, the first thing that I did was stop taking phone calls. Like that was the first thing, like I said, and it was very, very, very difficult. Yeah, yeah. I was very stressed, and and and it's real interesting. Like, I've gone, you know, I've done a lot of things since then, like personally to work on on growth and and and you know, just taking all that, like applying that back, it's like such a control issue to have to answer every phone call and talk to every person. It's like so unnecessary, right? It's not moving the needle, it's a thing for me to think that me talking to Jim is the reason that he's gonna stay for 20 years, right? Like it doesn't matter.
SPEAKER_01That was that was the single hardest thing for me as well, and the biggest turning point. Oh, yeah, was when so I I did the same thing, came into the book, had to call everybody to make sure everybody doesn't leave, kind of thing. We all did, but I remember like two years into it, and I was still like I love talking to people, and I would come out and talk to people, and and there was all and I would always say, I got to that point of where where you were, and like other people where it's like, um, only you know, try to try to say that I'm busy and try to handle the situation. And then of course they would, but only half the time because the other people, but this guy really wants to talk to you. He said he knows you and and you guys have been friends forever, blah, blah, blah, whatever, right? Right. And and then so I'm still taking calls half the time, and then I'll never forget there was uh I was talking to what be uh who became my uh service manager, and I just had to tell her because there was so many I kept I I kept taking these conversations and I was growing the business, and I just didn't have the time in the day, and I was leaving late uh from work, and I was it was just so stressful. And I just had to tell her I I'm not gonna take anybody, no matter what. Like I that's the only way I can do this.
SPEAKER_00I can hear the stress in your voice thinking about it, right? Like, like putting yourself back in that situation. It was dude, it's the worst because you want to deliver, yeah, right. You want to be the good guy, like the good agent. And and I think the your carrier, um, the commercials, TV, whatever. There's this perception of the agent is this person that comes and talks to everybody and and does their claim and goes out to their house and does all these things. But guess what? He's a this person is also human and only has 40 hours, or let's say it's well, it's 168 hours. Okay, you have 168 hours in the week, but you can't spend all 168 at the office because you got to serve everybody, right? That's not serving everybody very well. Yeah, by getting the right people in place that can then serve them. Now things change, right? Because now you're serving the people who serve the clients instead of trying to serve every one of the clients because it's impossible, right? If you you you scaled for what you went from two million to to nine million or whatever, how much? Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_01So I mean it would never, yeah, it would never have happened. There's no, there's absolutely no chance. And right, it it's uh, I was just talking to uh uh one of our agents, Nate, um that's in our group this morning about he's an awesome agent, he's selling with his team, they're crushing it, they're doing a great job. But I was just saying, like, he he's a newer agent, and I was saying, like, one of those one of the things that you got to do at some point is there's going to be as a business owner, there's not really linear growth. And if there is linear growth, it's usually incremental, kind of a 2x thinking. But if you want to kind of 10x, um, you have to do these things that like you step back, like you either you take a big pay cut, you invest a lot of money in, or or something to make an impact in your business that that can push you to that next level. And one of it was when you pull back of being in the weeds, and then you now are not selling to uh leads and clients and stuff like that, you're now in the role of selling your team on the vision, on the mission, on the values of the company. And that's a hard transition because to your point of the ego, you are the one that's um kind of steering the ship, you're in the weeds, and you, you know, everybody's looking to you, you're the hero. And from the ego standpoint, you got to make somebody else the hero. And then also you got to take a pay cut because now you're not gonna be on the phones. Like there is a pay cut that needs to be taken to give to somebody else, but the leverage has changed. There's only 16 hours a day that you could possibly put into an you could possibly put it for your own hours. But as soon as you start leveraging other people's time with the money that's coming in in the agency or borrowing somebody's money, now you have infinite possibilities with the time because now you can hire multiple people to start doing these things, and that costs at the beginning, right? But then it builds over time, and it's a it's a tough transition.
SPEAKER_00It is, but it's it that's how you get the exponential growth because I can see like you talking to um to Nate and going through that in his in his mind. I would think that he's he's thinking, like, hey, I'm part of the I'm part of the thing, I'm in all the excitement, and I'm doing all this stuff. And what he's not thinking about is is all of this time that he's spending doing this, doing this, um, let's call it level one activity, right? He's doing level one activity when instead, let's say that's for a year he does that, right? So that's 40 hours a week for a whole year, how 2,000 hours, however many it is, right? So now he's now he's spent 2,000 hours selling, which he could have just had a salesperson do, instead of 2,000 hours focused on exponential, you know, the next thing. What was he gonna do? What's the next marketing thing? What's the you know, how is he or is he gonna go out and find spend all his time hiring three more people? Whatever it is, there's there's an infinite number of things that could scale his business quicker than him writing that business and play and doing that level one activity. 100%.
SPEAKER_01It is tough though. I I think that that's that mental mind shift to get kicked in the pants financially to make that step, and then also humility and um it's a lot more work at first, too. Right. Is is a tough is a tough transition.
SPEAKER_00It's funny because in the world of immediate gratification, if we're looking at okay, I can keep doing what I'm doing and it'll keep it'll it's okay, right? Or I could do a whole bunch of more work right now and it may work, right? Is the is kind of like what we think, right? It's like the emotional side of us says that, right? Come up with all the excuses why it won't work, and then on the logical side, we do the math, and the math, it's like the math is the math, and like even having the math sometimes, it becomes emotional, right? But um, that's the key. Sig that math, love it. Any other uh insights with the Bill Eggert? No, just um, well, the the green sheets were great. We I mean we don't really do that anymore, uh, just the way that you know technology is, but that idea of having uh a framework of different questions to ask, it was really good how they would follow up. So I think there's good takeaways, but I mean at the end of the day, it was it was I looked at him and I thought that dude is has multiple businesses and doesn't know how to turn on his insurance computer. I like that. Like I want more of that because I don't want to be stuck to this stupid insurance computer where I was actually I gave my I don't know if you ever did it, but I gave my cell phone out. So I have clients that would text me, hey, I need to add a car. And I would do it back in the old days, right? There's still one, there's one left, and I mean I stopped eight years ago, eight years ago taking calls. There's still one that still texts me. I mean, it's someone that I'm friends with, but I just forward it to you know, I'm like, here you go, jazz.
SPEAKER_01So well, cool man. This was good to do a uh playbook slash uh throwback coffee talk.
SPEAKER_00It's a coffee talk. We're talking about doodas, dogs, dogs, coffee, duels.
SPEAKER_01Anyone that's thinking about taking a leap in your agency, just do it. I mean investing in yourself is so much better. Investing in yourself or your business is so much better investing in other people's businesses.
SPEAKER_00Well, and it's a lot less expensive, right? Yes, pull out that hundred G, put it in the market, you're gonna take a big cut before you even invest.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman