The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Insights from the Frontlines: Stacey Brown's Take on Insurance and Tech PART 2
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
You know, if you're an agent and you're thinking I got you know five years left in my business and I don't want to make a lot of change, you might want to just sell out now, right? Because number one, you might be you might be losing market share if you can't keep up with these changes. Um and number two, a tech driven agency is probably gonna get a better valuation than someone with a filing cabinet and a Rolodex, right?
SPEAKER_01So I I want to bring up the the uh 4,000 pound bot that's in the room for uh what we're talking about today. So what so what's the deal? What are we gonna do about this? How how does chat GPT affect the insurance world? Like what what's gonna happen here?
SPEAKER_02Oh man.
SPEAKER_01What's gonna go on? Are we is that are there no more agents?
SPEAKER_02You know what I'm gonna do? You just made me realize this. Uh I'm I'm gonna make a note to sell. I gotta I gotta buy a freaking crystal ball. So for every so in the future, when people ask me these types of questions, I can just say, let me pull up my crystal ball. You know, yeah. Um I think uh you know, with a lot of technologies, um, I you know, I I've seen the movie, um but this one's this one's a little different. I think the thing that's different about this one is the speed uh at which it's being adopted and um the lift that it gives in in productivity, right? Yeah, and yeah the tools that are out there. Uh in the last two days, I've had two different people, one on the broker side, one on the carrier side, say to me, like they make it so easy for us nowadays, right? So it used to be like you couldn't do anything to a computer unless you had a uh a degree and spent years like reading you know books like like the ones behind Craig, right? Like you you you you have computer manuals too, and those are just color by numbers and yeah, color by numbers and joke books, probably, right? But yeah, it was really hard to be in a um yeah to to to do anything with with computers. Um you you were considered a genius if you knew how to. But you know, fast forward now, um we're all we're all we all are computer programmers. We set alarms on our phones, we you know, we we set reminders, we we we figure out how to program our remotes to record our favorite you know channels um and shows. It's um it's like technology is is is all around us, right? And and so um it's just keeps getting easier and easier and faster and faster. It used to be also that you needed a million dollars at least so that you could build you know build out a little data center and have a few servers that connect it to the internet in order to have like an e-commerce website, right? Um nowadays all you need is a is a is a credit card and and access to uh to to Amazon or or Etsy or Shopify or one of these platforms, right? And um it's just it's just amazing. Um so back to the question about Gen AI. There are infinite use cases and people coming up with uh ways to use um AI every day. Um and so I I think the important thing really is focusing on um there are people in the industry that are ready for it, they're open to it, they're saying, hey, I want to go figure out how to use this AI stuff because if anybody's gonna do it, it's gonna be me. I I've always been that kind of guy, right? When it came to technology, it was like, I'm gonna figure it out, I'm gonna do it. I'm not afraid to push the buttons, you know. No nukes are going off when I hit enter. So life is good. I'll figure it out. Um, but then there's the people who are like, they just don't want to change. They're they're hoping uh that they can keep doing what they do the way they do it until they reach retirement, right? And um and so what we need to have happen here is more people running towards technology because it's happening so fast, um, you you can't hide from it.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, agreed. I I've been telling a lot of people that recently is like like every day that you're not investing a few minutes into just understanding it or whatever, it's moving so fast that at some point it's like not knowing the internet, you know, it's like the the amount of leverage is gonna be. And I think I think if I did have a crystal ball, it would pretty much say those that um invest in that kind of leverage, because one person can now be do the the work of 10 people, at least with AI, right? I think the the people that don't go that direction are completely gone. Like I think it's they're gonna be so irrelevant, it's gonna be amazing. It's like trying to go back to insurance agents door knocking and writing, you know, writing out policy on paper. It's just how do you do that these days? I think that's you know the difference.
SPEAKER_02But yeah, I think it's interesting also to think when I think about it from you know the distribution side of the house and um you know the the big corporate carrier side of the house. Um on the distribution side of the house, um you know, these these a lot of these independent agents specifically, right? They they they don't have the resources. Um and and how do you uh and and what I've seen firsthand from just some of the agent um events I've gone to and and and had conversations with is kind of a fear over this stuff. Like when I tell them I'm with Insure Tech Hartford, they're like, InsureTech, you're bad. You know, it's like you're you're you're you're you're gonna destroy my business, you're gonna take all my customers away. And like they have all these fears. And you know, maybe to some extent, some of that's that's right, but it it's it's but it doesn't have to be that way, right? It yeah, and and um nowadays uh what I see in when I talk to agents is there's a growing population of tech-driven brokers and agents growing up in the industry, right? So I don't have like a metric on it, but um it's it's definitely a growing population of people who are really progressive in their thinking, saying, like, hey, I'm gonna be tech driven. Um, I'm gonna run a tech-driven agency. It gets really interesting in dynamics where it's like a multi-generational family um, you know, running the agency, and it's like, you know, well, dad built it this way and he doesn't understand that I need to run it that way. And I'm sure you guys have probably run into some of those stories along the way, right?
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Those are the best stories because if you can take proven processes of the past and then stick it with somebody who's super forward thinking, but holding on to the, you know, to the especially the values and everything and and some of the processes of the past and merging the two, that's where it's just unstoppable, you know. Um, I think too many times people either try to go too too much in one direction. It can't be all like AI and all that stuff still needs somebody to manage it. Like so it's like it's it's a tool, it's not a replacement. Like everybody's still black and white. It everybody has been. Every time some technology comes out, it's the internet. Oh, it's gonna take away all this. No, it's like those who you know, the the small shop on the street when Walmart came out and stuff like that, like Walmart could take them away. But like if they started selling on the internet, all of a sudden they the whole you know world is there, uh, you know, at the at the foot of their store. So it's like as long as you're using uh these tools that we have, then um it won't uh it's just a tool for you, it won't take away your job. But I think if you decide to to not let use the the the tools as leverage for your business, I think you're making I mean, I think you're just putting a uh end date on your business.
SPEAKER_01Bringing a knife to the gunfight. Like why why when everybody else has guns are you gonna show up with a knife? Well, you know, there's it didn't work out for the guy with Indiana Jones.
SPEAKER_02It's not gonna hate classic scene. Um how much you flip it around, doesn't matter, it's still a knife. Yeah, I forgot what he was gonna to say. Well, like the I think one of the number one pain points that a lot that all agencies still seem to have is that there's a lot of copying and pasting and re-keying of stuff that has to happen because you know, you want to get a quote from this carrier, now you want to get a quote from that carrier, and you need to get a quote from this other carrier. And you know, there are uh aggregators and other intermediary platforms coming out now that are getting some of the integrations down with some of these carriers that are kind of helping it, but it goes back to um, you know, a lot of the ages don't, you know, they're not either they don't have the budget, the resources, or the time um to figure out how to adopt the technologies that that that do that stuff. So it's just easier to keep paying somebody to copy and paste, oh let me go to progressive and get a quote. Oh, now let me go to State Farm and get you a quote, right? And then and then present all those options. It's um, you know, the the these agents of the future, I'll call them, are the ones that are figuring out how to automate that stuff. I saw one um company recently um that has like a super copy, super paste feature where like you you map it out to let's say you know, state farm auto quote and um and and and into uh you know maybe a progressive one. And so you enter in Mc Into Progressive. The next time you enter into uh to the state farm, you hit super copy and go into progressive and hit super paste, and it just fills in all the fields for you. So like there's some really not through an API. No, no, it's just through a plugin in the web browser, right?
SPEAKER_01Well, that's very interesting.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and and the mappings are all reusable and stuff. Um and and so it's it's it's stuff like that. It's like the agents that are looking at the productivity improvement things, because waiting for the back-end stuff to become all API and stuff like that. Like, first off, they don't want the the carriers are getting there, um, but it's still a really slow game. Most of them still don't have the majority of their products and and and stuff available through through API. And we're not even talking about claims, we're just talking about getting quotes, right?
SPEAKER_01Well, they don't want to share the client data either, right? I think that especially the captive ones get real protective about the client data, and so well, everyone's protective about all their data, right? Right, right, right. So, yeah, as soon as you have that API open, you know, there could be some issues, I think.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, so this one, so this one I was talking about, I think it's called Gaiafee. Um, and and they um, you know, there it's it's something that any agent can put in their web browser and just start being productive with it. And it's like a kind of a low-cost monthly license fee. And um I think it's one of these things that you know, kind of like you know, um chat GPT, when when people start to um when they when they start to see it, it's gonna like it's just gonna blow up, like everyone's gonna be using it. But there's there's lots of uses for tech. And I know some um some of the brokers are out there um making their own investments, hiring offshore teams and building uh their own integrations into different things. And um those are you know what I was talking about earlier is the more you know progressive agents. And I I really think for for the distribution side, that is the the long-term winning direction. And you know, if you're an agent um and you're thinking I got you know five years left in my business and I don't want to make a lot of change, you might want to just sell out now, right? Because number one, you might be you might be losing market share if you can't keep up with these changes. Um, and number two, a tech-driven agency is probably gonna get a better valuation than someone with a filing cabinet and a Rolodex, right? So I would think that that's incentive enough for for someone to want to make uh make that investment now as part of their exit strategy. Um is that something you guys see? Do you do you hear that from people? Or do you talk to a lot of agents?
SPEAKER_01Well, we're both in it with a captive that we can't say we're not allowed to on the uh on the thing. Um but yeah, I mean the the ones that are the ones that are doing the best to figure out how to scale. I mean, because because at the end of the day, it's it's about everything's so thin, right? Especially when you're with a captive, the margins are so thin that you have to have volume. So as long as you can beat the your cost per sale, you're you're winning, right? Like it doesn't matter, you're good. So and that's what that's what we see, that's what we do in our agencies, and um it's been effective.
SPEAKER_02Well, I know like um even in the captive space, uh you know, I I see a lot of you know captive operators and and owners over the years. And um if if what I was saying about you know agents and brokers um has has any truth to it, I think it's it's multiplied in the captive space, right? Because and a lot of it has to do with what you're talking about there. Like the margins are so thin, and like where's that investment supposed to come from? But like recently I ran into um this company, XN Capital. Um, they they are founded by uh this guy, Gabe, who um Gabe Weiss, who um he he had his exit with CCC and um and Safekeep, and and now he's he's starting up this this captive operator company, and they are trying to take the tech-driven approach to to captives, right? So it's it's really interesting to see somebody who's been a successful tech entrepreneur in our industry come in and say, I'm gonna build a tech-driven captive operating model. Interesting.
SPEAKER_01Well, that's called XN, like uh X-ray Nancy Capital.
SPEAKER_02Correct.
SPEAKER_01I forget what it stands for. He told me to store you xylophone um nimbus. That's right. Xylophone ninjas. And what was the that that other tool that you were talking about?
SPEAKER_02Uh is it Gaiafi? Let me see. Yeah, how do you spell that? G-A-Y-A-F-I. Um, but maybe I got it wrong because I'm I'm Googling it, it's not coming up. Maybe the name is is something different. You should you should ask Chat GPT.
SPEAKER_01I I don't what's that? Yeah. Um can I use chat GPT 3? I don't want to use one of my one of my credits.
SPEAKER_00Oh no, you can't.
SPEAKER_01Don't you hate it when you're really cooking and then you you type something that says you've already used up all your you're like, oh man, I gotta wait an hour and a half. I I don't know. It's Gaia. It's G-A-Y-A.ai.
SPEAKER_02Interesting.
SPEAKER_01Okay, that's really cool.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and they're they're still a pretty early stage startup, but what they're what they're doing is pretty amazing. And it's it's stuff like this that one day you didn't hear about it, and the next day everyone's talking about it, right?
SPEAKER_00Yep, 100%. What are your predictions? So let's go back to predictions of the crystal ball. What are the things that um going into the future you see are the competitive advantages for uh agency owners? And what are some of the things to kind of look out for? And I think we just kind of discussed the things to look out for, which is put your put your head under the ground while all this is going down.
SPEAKER_02Don't do that. Yeah, first off, I'd say, you know, the agent doesn't go away. I yeah, the agents that walk around worrying about that are worrying about the wrong thing. I think the right thing for agents is to be figuring out how to spend more time on the phone, right? And not with um, you know, not with their staff, but with customers and clients and prospects, right? I think the more that technology advances, the more important uh the human aspects of all of our jobs becomes. And uh we we I don't know if we'll ever get to a point where as it's coming out of my mouth, it's it's uh the the policy is coming out of the system, it'll never be that easy, but the productivity will continue to to to improve by leaps and bounds um for the foreseeable future. So what that means is as productivity improves, what do you do with the with the with the freed up resources? You go out and you sell more, right? So I think the agencies of the future are gonna be much more productive, right? Back to that, some of the earlier comments I was making around um you know the talent and um gaps that are going to be filled by technology, I do think that's a that's gonna be a part of it. Um but I I I really see that um it's more about people, it's more about learning how to um do better prospecting, spend more time and and create better relationships and more value for your for your clients. Love it.
SPEAKER_00Well, cool. And if anybody wants to uh get in touch with the the organization or you, uh what's the best way to reach out?
SPEAKER_02Well, our website's uh insure techheartford.com, and you can always email me, stacy.brown at insuretechheartford.com, or just ping me on LinkedIn. I'm there all the time as well.
SPEAKER_00Awesome. Well, appreciate it, man. This has been this has been awesome to talk about. We love to talk about the future.
SPEAKER_01The future, he's a he's a futurist.
SPEAKER_00I'm a futurist, and um he loves um futurama.
SPEAKER_02Let's sell more insurance, dude.
SPEAKER_01Love it, dude.
SPEAKER_02Thanks, Daisy.
SPEAKER_01We'll take some action action. Okay, nice talking, guys.
SPEAKER_02Anyway, thanks, guys.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman