The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Insights from the Frontlines: Stacey Brown's Take on Insurance and Tech PART 1
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
Man, the wildest thing that I've ever seen happen in insurance. Um, when you've been around uh a number of mergers and acquisitions, you get to see all the different interesting ways in which cultures come together. And I think one of the wildest things um that that I seen was a bunch of Americans trying to adapt to uh French culture, right? So um, you know, when AXA bought Excel, um I'm no longer with the company, so I guess I could speak more publicly about this stuff now. But uh when AXA bought Excel, you know, we had um we had one culture, right? And uh I I came from the Excel side of the house and I had gone through a merger with Excel and Catelyn, and um, you know, but it was really uh they called it a merger of equals, and it really was, right? Like culturally, we were very similar, you know. Um we had our own, everybody had their own politics and things like that, but the culture was similar. What the AXA merger was totally different, right? And I thought I knew what governance was. I had no clue what governance was until you know Mother AXA came to the house. And I I don't mean that to sound as a negative thing. There was some some really positive stuff to that, but man, what a culture shock it was. What was one of the big shocks with that whole well? First off, it's it starts with little things, right? So a French accent when you're your ears not tuned to it takes a little bit getting used to, right? From an American perspective. And uh and and so there was a little bit of that, but it it really was uh the the the it seemed like the amount of governance how there had to be like uh every time I turn around, like I thought I knew how to do my job, but I didn't because I kept finding out there was another committee I was supposed to have talked to before I came to talk to these people, right? And and it was just um it was it was very different. It was very different than what I was used to personally. Um it it was um yeah, I was highly empowered. I was an executive, I made decisions, I paid the price at times when those weren't good decisions. Uh I see where this podcast goes. I probably just set myself up for another question. But uh yeah, that that was uh that just having to get used to um a you know a new structure and a new way of of making decisions uh through more consensus-driven uh decision making and stuff was was kind of a big big shift for me. Doc, and who are you? Oh, by the way, yeah. I'm Stacy Brown, and um I'm I'm I work with Insure Tech Hartford now. It's an organization I I started back in 2017-ish, and I work out of Hartford, Connecticut, and I'm an insurance dude.
SPEAKER_03Love it. Welcome. Yeah, that's that's hard. So I mean the culture's oh, sorry, go ahead. Go.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, well you go. I was just gonna ask if you thought the culture, the culture clash was a pay to the axa.
SPEAKER_00Look, I don't mean to make it sound like it's bad. Um, it's just different, right? And what I think added to it for me personally was uh all the work that I'd been doing on the insurre tech side of the house for the last several years. And I was spending a lot of time with startups, small organizations. Um, I was running my own organization essentially with Insure Tech Hartford. And if I saw something, I pivoted, I moved, I did it, I went in that direction, right? So as the controls became tighter on one end of the equation, like through my corporate job, like the autonomy was in increasing in my entrepreneurial side of the house. And so these were just like, you know, you talk about two legs and two canoes. Well, the canoes were like going in different directions, and it it it I and it was starting to, you know, be uncomfortable for me. So, but uh like I said, I don't mean to make it sound like what was happening there was bad or negative, there's a lot of really smart people, they're very methodological about um what they're doing and why they're doing it and how they're doing it. And um, you know, I I came to realize a long time ago that when you're like a small scrappy startup, um, you've got a lot more to gain um and not a lot to lose um on a relative basis, right? But if you're a multi-billion dollar, or in the case of AXA, a trillion dollar uh um have a trillion dollar balance sheet, right? Man, there's ever anything you gain is only minute in comparison to how much is at stake, right? So the amount of controls you have to have in place, the bigger you get. Um, it just to me, it just makes sense. Right. It's interesting.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so now it's at the mature that the mature point of its life cycle, and that's that's I guess why it ends up being declined at some point, right? Because you can't really at some point it's like too expensive to try to grow. How do you grow?
SPEAKER_00Well, M A, exactly. Yeah, right, right. You spin off the underperforming assets and free up capital to buy new ones, right?
SPEAKER_01It's a totally different way of operating, it's just interesting, you know, because we're down here at the very micro level, right?
SPEAKER_03And they they probably try to minimize the um the amount of accidents. Uh-huh. Yes.
SPEAKER_00You probably wrote that one down last night, didn't you?
SPEAKER_03Oh I was I was holding on to that for like 10 minutes here. And I'm like, when can I use this?
SPEAKER_01There'll be a few more. Spoiler alert.
SPEAKER_00Oh, there's plenty more where that came from, I'm sure.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, don't think that was the last one if you're listening at home.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, count how many whoever can count how many um acts of jokes we will make, uh, report uh to the iDudes email, and you will uh receive a prize. That's right. I like it. All right, Stacey. So break it down. Let's talk about uh the uh Hartford Insure Tech. Insure Tech Hartford. Yeah, what the heck is it?
SPEAKER_00And we keep doing putting it back. It's easy to do. Um it happens all the time. And uh it didn't help that for a while we had something in town called the Hartford Insure Tech Hub, and people were confusing our two organizations all the time. And um, but in heart Insure Tech Hartford is an organization I started. Um, really, I'd say that the the earliest days go back to 2016 when I was you know seeing the trends that were going on in the industry around um Insure Tech, right? It wasn't even called Insure Tech yet. It was just like, hey, investors are putting money into startups that are tech driven and they're gonna disrupt the whole industry. And everyone was like, oh my God, what is it? What's gonna happen to it? And um when I was looking at it, I was like, hey, you know what this reminds me of? It like it reminds me of the dot-con days. And I was like, I want to be a part of this somehow, but there was nothing like to be a part of. So I just started reaching out to people in my network that I knew and saying, hey, we should get together and talk about this stuff. And that that's kind of how it took off. And so it's kind of grown a lot, you know. It what we we we eventually gave it the name Insure Tech Hartford, and it was really about community building around the the Hartford area insurance community, which is super strong. There's like 50,000 jobs within a one-hour radius, and all all working for uh the insurance industry, and um, so it's pretty rich uh insurance, um, you know, resource-rich environment. Uh, but there was no insure tech anything, right? So um, so I just started having meetings and people started showing up and it just kept growing. And the the funniest thing was uh the pandemic actually caused acceleration because instead of like stopping and focusing on my my day job, uh I said, you know what, I'm gonna go online and I'm gonna start, you know, running virtual events, and then we started having lar audiences that were way larger than anything we were doing in person. So uh and it became more of a global brand. So that's where we are today, right? We're we're still uh a community, but it's more of a global branded community. And I did leave um, you know, uh AXA in 2023, and I've just been focusing on this community-building stuff. And so this year I've I've I've been working with partnerships and in and helping launch communities in in within Sure Tech Atlanta and Sure Tech Chicago. So we're taking um the lessons that I've learned, the the playbooks and the the resources and and things of that sort, and um just helping build other communities. Super cool.
SPEAKER_03So like talk about building the communities, like what do the communities rally around, like be besides just the sure tech? Like what's the what's the goal, what's the uh pursuit?
SPEAKER_00Well, that's really it, right? It's it's about um how for me, I I feel that it's about driving innovation in the industry, right? So I spent a lot of years doing that on the carrier side as a as we we kind of drained the the pond on that one, I think. But um, but now I'm doing it from the outside, right? And there's there are so many different angles to the insurance industry, and um and and and they're all ripe for innovation. And um the thing is that you can't do it on your own, right? And in the olden days, we used to sit in our cubes and you know, if we we were being innovative, if we researched something on the internet and brought it into a conference room and talked with our peers about it, right? Um, but nowadays be the ability to mash up and bring people together with different backgrounds and skills and stuff like that is amazing. Uh, not to mention the the way it helps to bring talent into the industry as well, right? So entrepreneurship and innovation is has brought a lot of new talent into the industry over the last few years. And I don't know that uh people are are are really thinking of it that way, right? But we know that the insurance industry has uh a bit of a talent crunch, whether you're on the distribution side or or the carrier side or anywhere in between. Um, you know, the the the future uh it isn't looking as bright when you look at bodies coming into relative bodies going out of the industry. Uh so certainly some of that slack is going to be picked up on uh on the technologies and the innovations coming out. So all the more reason why we've got to push the needle forward on innovation. But the communities themselves are really just about bringing those people together and making those connections happen. We do other things too, you know, like we we do hackathons, uh we have an annual uh pitch event, and we do a lot of partnership and collaboration events with other uh organizations too. Cool.
SPEAKER_01So it's to get it's to get the information out about all the different insur tech solutions that are out there.
SPEAKER_00That's that is definitely a part of it. You know, it's really about putting opportunities together, putting people together to create opportunities, right? Um, you know, whether it's as startups looking for VC, um, an experienced um person in the industry looking for their next role. Um and students, we do a lot of work with getting students engaged and involved in the stuff that we're doing. Um, you know, I was I've I've been you know helping out with uh with teaching at University of Connecticut at times, um, you know, got involved this summer in an actuarial boot camp for for high school students organized by a local organization called CTIFS. So it's it's more than just the work that happens at our events, it's really uh ties back to to community, um, but it's all meant to help drive the industry forward. Interesting. Love it.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, that is interesting. What what kind of trends are you um seeing? Like I'm I'm sure that when you started this, that it kind of built up a unique angle, right? Like it, I'm sure it's not exactly how you started it, right? So, what what kind of things have you seen come about from putting all these cool people together?
SPEAKER_00Well, I'd say one of the wildest things here also is that I didn't set out to do anything. In fact, earlier today I was asked, so like what's the ultimate goal and objective of you know, insurre tech Hartford, Chicago, Atlanta, etc. Like what what's what's the ultimate thing? I'm like, you know, I wish I I wish I can actually tell you that. Um, because from the very beginning, I didn't I didn't set out to do any of the stuff that I'm doing today, right? I go back to my story there where I I just wanted to get together as as an insurance IT guy. I wanted to get together and talk with other insurance IT guys about what is this, uh, how is tech gonna disrupt our industry, right? And it's just I've kept an open mind to the things that come at me. And so I think um the the opportunities that that's created are things that like you know, rewind the clock to you know, 2015. If you would have told me, like, oh, you're gonna be, you know, skiing with uh with with with a group of investors and startup CEOs that you pulled together with a you know where the people in the room had a total market cap of six billion dollars, I'd been like, ha ha, yeah, right. Like, I don't even ski. Right. And that that's the that's that's the honest truth, right? So our first um ski trip event that I collaborated with David Gritz, who who does the Insure Tech New York co uh community with Tony Grit uh Tony Lou, the um David and I partnered on this ski trip event first in in 2022. When I agreed to do it with them, I said to him, I was like, oh great, now the only thing I have to do is learn how to ski because I had never skied in my life, right? And it's just things like that, the opportunities that have have come out of just moving forward with an open mind and asking myself, I can't how can I instead of thinking of why it's hard or why I can't, right? Yeah, and also I'd say mindset-wise, um, I didn't realize how many years I um I'll I'll say the other thing, right? So I I I realize now that we could all just make more pie, right? When in in the corporate environment, it was kind of like there was an annual budget, this is what we were spending in IT this year, and really the only way people felt like they were getting ahead in their IT career is when they got bigger slices of the pie. But because the pie was picked, fixed in order for someone to get a bigger piece, that meant somebody else had to be getting a smaller piece, right? It was like really hard to have that growth mindset that um I think that's a big part of what has driven me out in entrepreneur land too, is the fact that, hey, you know what, you do the same thing I do. That's cool. How do we collaborate? How do we do it together? Maybe we can make the pie bigger, right? So um just a very different, very different world.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, the corporate world is protect the pie and then keep layering with more managers. I don't understand that whole idea, but it's tough.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's it's also an indication that you're doing well, right? Right, yeah. The PETA principle? Uh-uh. The the PETA principle. Uh well, I guess I'd have to Google it to make sure I get it right, but it's something along the lines of uh in corporate, people get promoted to their highest level of incompetence. That's uh so once you get to a level where you're not getting promotions anymore, it's because you're not competent enough for the next level. So at the peak of of where you're reaching your incompetence.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. Yeah. And then I'm sure time has to play in that because at some point, the like I've been with them so long, I should just be promoted.
SPEAKER_00That comes in where it's like part of the mentality of that world, right? Where it's I don't want to say entitlement because people work hard and they um they they want us, they want to feel like they're they're growing, they want to feel sometimes sometimes it's hard to tell if is it is it change that you want or is it actual growth? And is it growth in in what in corporate world they do a really good job of of keeping us focused on this thing they call a title, right? Yeah, so you know, grow so so that whole manager concept, right? It ties back to that as well, right? Oh, sorry, go ahead. Well, just title means so much, right? Yeah, and in entrepreneurial world, it call me what you want.
SPEAKER_01Call me janitor, I don't care. It it it's um it is interesting because uh and my wife works in that world, and like when she's you know, when I give ideas, uh because some usually she doesn't want an idea, but of course I offer the idea. Um that goes over well, and you know how that goes. However, it's just the way that she'll play it back is it's always oh no, you don't understand, it doesn't work like that here. You can't do that, you know. It's like, well, you can't do that because you because you're just you're accepting that. You can do whatever. How does that go over? It doesn't go over well.
SPEAKER_00I mean, it is tricky. I understand. Um, I lived it for 20 plus years, right? And I understand is what I could say. And there's nothing wrong with it. It's good, it's you know, there's a safety net around it all, it's it's highly structured, um, and it's and it's really it's really good for for for allowing having framework for people to come out and be solid contributors in society and do well for themselves, right? Not everybody is willing to, you know, throw the hat on, jump on the horse, and just start heading west, right? Like that's that's scary crap, I can tell you firsthand.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it is, it is, and it's a good point. It's probably you know, the vast majority of people fit better into that role that where they need the structure, they need the they need the direction, right? Yeah, it helps. There's the crazies that are like, I don't care, you know, I'd rather work 80 hours to not have to work 40 hours.
SPEAKER_00Right. Yeah, I had I remember an entrepreneur guy um I met in Asia once. He he he told me something along the lines of, you know, he was he he used to work in corporate and then he was an entrepreneur when I met him, and he said um that he felt that a a dollar he earned working for himself was better than two dollars earned, you know, working in a corporate world, right? And that's just how some people feel. Um yeah. Again, it doesn't make people in corporate bad or wrong, it's just it's different, right? And in your comfort zone is typically on one side of that fence or the other.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Well, and the two dollars is tied to exchanging you do this, you get two dollars versus I choose to do this, I'll get a dollar. And you know, if you're if you're entrepreneurial, you you you choose. You're not letting anybody else tell you. And that's I think what and if you don't want to show up that day, you still get the dollar. Yeah.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman