The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Changing Workplace Perspectives and Strategies With Eric Yaverbaum! PART 1
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
When I'm a kid, kind of new in the business, my agency is representing Domino's Pizza. Uh I'm at the National Awards and I'm sitting at the head table, which was, you know, in the presence of greatness, Tom Monahan's at the table. He owns the Detroit Tigers. He's the guy who started Domino's Pizza. Uh, this is the head table for I don't know, 5,000 people were there. I don't know how many were there, but I'm sitting next to Joe Thizman. This was right after the Redskins had won the Super Bowl, uh, now the commanders. Um, and the waiter is coming around and he takes the tongs and he puts the bread on the little bread plate. He takes the tongs and he puts a pad of butter next to the bread. And Theizman turns around to the waiter and says, Can I get another pad of butter? And the waiter says, No. And Theisman does a little bit of a double take and he turns around and says, You know who I am? And the waiter says, No. He said, I'm Joe Seisman. I'm the quarterback of the Washington Redskins. We just won the Super Bowl. I'm the reason everybody's here today. And the waiter, without skipping a beat, says to him, Do you know who I am? And Sizman says, No. He said, I'm the guy in charge of the butter, and that's all you're getting. It was a great lesson in being humble. And today I am an insurance dude.
SPEAKER_02Wow, I love that he kept with that. That was a good idea.
SPEAKER_00That particular day. Um, and you know, when I was younger, and you know, I've been around fame and fortune my entire career. I, you know, I'm a little bit starstruck and I'm a kid. That was a big honor for me to be at that table. It it was uh when he started his speech that that particular day, he told the story of literally what had just happened at the table, which everybody thought was hilarious.
SPEAKER_01That's so cool.
SPEAKER_03Oh, so he flipped around and worked in the uh what had just happened. Yes, it's fantastic.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_03Taking on his feet. I you know, I saw Joe. Um, he spoke, he was a keynote at an insurance thing that I went to in uh New York, I don't know, probably eight years ago. But he was really good. He he did this thing about like everything changes in one instant and he snaps his finger. It was really good. I'm sure you if you've known him, then you've probably seen that speech before.
SPEAKER_00No, I don't, I uh you know, uh I don't know him, I just know he beats or did when he played my giants on a regular basis. That's about it, besides that meal.
SPEAKER_03Well, so for so Eric, for folks who who don't know you um and haven't heard of of you, what tell us about a little bit about yourself, a little background, and how you kidding?
SPEAKER_00I mean, you know, there's only a couple, but uh I'm Eric Javerbaum. Nobody's ever heard of me, and you can't spell my last name. Um, yeah, I've been uh uh uh PR agency for 42 years in New York City. Sold my first one, uh went to work for Wall Street who bought me, didn't really like Wall Street, it wasn't my thing. Um, left. I worked on the transition team between uh Bush and Obama administrations, and then I started uh started the agency that I run now. I also write books. I've written seven. I'm a New York Times bestselling author.
SPEAKER_03Cool. Awesome. I wear a lot of hats. So so uh, and I'm assuming a book just released. What's it talk about?
SPEAKER_00I I do have a new book coming out. Okay, um, my biggest book was Leadership Secrets of the World's Most Successful CEOs. Uh, that book sold over a million copies.
SPEAKER_03That's awesome. Congratulations.
SPEAKER_00Thank you so much.
SPEAKER_03Super our our first will draw off in January.
SPEAKER_00Ah.
SPEAKER_03So I can appreciate how much effort and time that took to do seven of them.
SPEAKER_00Jeez, yeah. Well, I'm I'm never gonna stop there. Is now I thought I and I all of my clients, I insist, I tell them all, you must write a book. It's the best calling card you'll ever have. The amount of attention that you get for it. You know, I've been in in the news for 40 years. I believe one of the biggest reasons that I've been, I mean, I've done some interesting stuff, but the the press in general is always interested in in authors.
SPEAKER_03And there's a pretty high barrier to entry for that because it's a lot of work.
SPEAKER_00Oh, yeah, it's a lot of work. I mean, uh when I was younger, uh, you know, I ran a very traditional PR agency. When I sold it, we were ranked the fifth uh best agency in the country to work for. And I was also writing books when I wrote books while running a traditional PR agency, it was, you know, it was a 24-hour a day sort of thing. I my day job and then write my book all night. Yeah, it's a lot of work.
SPEAKER_03So so being ranked as one of the top places to work, and obviously being somewhat of an expert in this whole notion of employees and and movement of employees and doing different um strategies to bring people on in this crazy world that we live in now. Yeah. What what kind of things did you do to create this environment that that you would be ranked as one of the best places to work?
SPEAKER_00Well, you know, that was before. This is now, but uh if if I could get ranked again, it would be higher. I mean, seriously, the uh I uh for all that I've done, I get credit for a lot of stuff. I mean, uh newspapers and magazines write about me. I'm on podcasts, television, radio shows. My whole career. It was never me ever, even though I get all the credit and it's always my name, it's everybody that works with me. And uh trying to uh create an environment that works for all of us so that we can actually enjoy what we do for a living has it it's it's always been important to me. I mean, I learned that as a kid. I've been doing it for four decades, and you know, fast forward to today, you know, it's a different workplace. There is uh contrary to what you know investment banks would like you to believe, or you know, even the Fortune 500, the notion of the Monday to Friday nine to five work week is it's it's over. It's we're we're never gonna we're not doing that anymore.
SPEAKER_03Right.
SPEAKER_00So, you know, while everybody's trying to figure out, so what are we gonna do? Um, you know, some companies are doing, you know, hybrid, some companies are operating completely virtual, and some people, some companies are saying, no, you have to come back to work or you'll lose your job. The companies that are saying you'll have to come back to work or you'll lose your job, people are saying, okay, I'll I'll pass on my job. And that's just literally what's happening. So, you know, what do you do as an employer to make an environment that works for everybody? Because this entire new workforce, and you know, my in my career, you know, I managed kids in their 20s, 30s, 40s, 50s when they're becoming adults, 60s. You know, the new generation, uh, they're not uh they don't want to commute to work every day, they don't want to have to get you know dressed for work every day. They and they did find that during the pandemic, depending on what industry you were in, they could actually do their jobs, they could do it well, they could do it virtually and get as much, if not more, done. Uh and you know, knowing that they're not gonna want to come back. And I to me that's understandable. It and again, it does depend on what industry you're in.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, super interesting conversation. We we had a very similar one recently, and it's it's funny because it's like not to the fault of anyone, right? Yeah, that was one of the the topics was like it's it's not to the fault of anyone that 20 2020 happened. It's not to like you know, businesses did not decide, hey, we we can only work from home for a long time, and then you know, employees didn't even really decide that, then they were stuck in those situations, and now you know, being back into a situation where hey, we're coming back into the office. A lot of people got used to that. You can't just take that away from somebody, even though the business didn't decide that it is what happened. There and there can't be a finger pointing here, it just is what it is, and how do we move on or create yeah?
SPEAKER_00It it's a um, you know, I think it's kind of an undercovered, an undercovered issue, in particular in in New York City, where we have, you know, 40, 45% vacancy rates in commercial, you know, with commercial real estate. The reason that we have that is because people aren't going back to work. My agency, you know, we had the uh I would say esteem honor of working uh uh with one Vanderbilt, which is a brand new building, you know, in the city that was, you know, you finished construction during the pandemic. It's a hundred beautiful floors of of corporate America, uh, considered the most it's the most expensive commercial real estate in Manhattan. It's the the address is prestigious, the building is beautiful, and I would just go floor to floor to floor to floor and see what what's corporate America building? This is during the pandemic, and they were all they were building space, you know, office space like I'd never seen before. The the vast majority of it uh uh was clearly planning for a hybrid, you know, workforce to come in some days, not come in some days.
SPEAKER_03What what kind of things were you seeing when you said they were building things that hadn't been seen before?
SPEAKER_00Well, it's just you know, the yeah, I mean I look, I grew up in a world where I, you know, I have a I have an office with a door and right a conference room, and well, all everything in my office stays in my office when I leave. Uh and and it's all there the next day. Offices that they're not being built that way anymore.
SPEAKER_03Right. Bean bags and basketball hoops.
SPEAKER_00Um, well, I I had beanbags and basketball hoops. Yeah, so I'd have that. I mean, I I I I did start a company so I could wear sneakers to work, literally. That is not an exaggeration. That is literal. But you know, the the thing about it was, you know, in our particular case, you know, I'm I'm running uh, you know, a public relations agency. Uh uh it's national. We had offices in the West Coast and on the East Coast. We did close both offices, and we've been virtual ever since. The interesting thing about that and the transition, I mean, the pandemic, you know, the pandemic was crazy. None of us ever seen anything like this in our lives in so many different ways, including professionally and you know, working. And as an employer, uh, we had to make you know some pretty quick decisions because we got some weighty overhead that can't even be used. What do you what do you do with it? In our particular case, uh, and and and by the way, this is not you know not a unique story, but you know, growing up as an employer in New York, we always had some, we call it summer Fridays. Summer Fridays were basically finish your if your work's all done, you can leave you know in the middle of the day on Friday and go wherever you're going for the weekend, uh if your work's done. You know, cell phones came around, laptops came around, uh technology, the proliferation of technology, and you know, we sort of morphed a little bit into uh and were my you know, my current agency, and and we've been doing this for almost 20 years. You had to come in, you had to come in the office three days a week. This is long before anybody was you know talking about do you come back to work, do you not come back to work. So we were set up to be to do this, to do this virtually, uh, and it worked. Not, I mean, for my particular agency, uh, you know, we grew and we dropped a ton of rent, you know, from two big office spaces on the east and west coast. But then you get to the issue of well, okay, so productivity, how is it? Can everybody do that? Because everybody's, you know, it's it's you got to be very disciplined if you're gonna if you're gonna work from home. Yeah, that's one issue. And some people are um very, you know, driven. They like it a lot, they get a lot done. Uh I could see productivity go way up, but what I could also see, um which has always concerned me, um, you know, isolation and you know, the whole notion of nobody's we're not hanging out at the you know, the the water cooler. You can't just drop in the office of, you know, you can't just stop by my office, you can't have a 10-minute conversation with me that might be, you know, construed as me being a mentor, which I actually believe mentors are very important. So, how do you make up for that? Um, and most importantly is you know, uh people's mental well-being. And then that project that I mentioned you at one Vanderbilt, um, that was being they finished construction of that building in the first year of the pandemic. Uh, we helped uh uh to open uh a project called Summit, which everybody Google it. Anybody come to New York, check out Summit, it's cool. Um, so we so the we we were there every day. So we did get out, and we do a lot of events, so we do get out. I think if everybody who worked for me was at home 100% of the time, it wouldn't be great for their mental well-being. I think it I think it is important to get out, I think it is important to socialize a little bit, and I think it is important to be around other people, but it doesn't mean that you have to go back to the you know, the old days in the traditional, you know, workspace, which there's no, and I represent a lot of developers in Manhattan, nobody will love that I said that because everybody we we want to bring people back. I mean, cities get hurt. I mean, my city definitely gets hurt when you have 40% less people commuting in every day to buy their coffee, to maybe shop before they go home at night, have lunch, go to a restaurant. All that's 40% down because we got you know less people in the city, and you know, we got a lot of vacant uh office space.
SPEAKER_03Is the traffic better?
SPEAKER_00Uh there's nobody nobody in the history of New York ever said traffic was better.
SPEAKER_02Well, what what are some of the antidotes to to to that?
SPEAKER_00Well, I I do think, you know, uh I look uh to me what we have, um, which is unique, uh this is gonna be different for every single solitary company. I think what we got is magical. I mean, my people love it, they are more efficient, the business has grown, the clients get more done for them, everybody's happy, but you can't do that, you know, in in every industry. It there is an issue of attracting, you want to attract the best and the brightest. The best and the brightest, a lot of them are like, yeah, I'm not coming into an office five days a week. So if you want to appeal to them, you better have some flexibility built into your workplace. And some people do. I think that more people uh I have no intention ever of opening offices again. Uh it it works this way for us. Um, but you know, I I think the vast majority will have some sort of hybrid, you know, come in a couple days a week, two, three days a week, so that there is a touch base. But I go into these, you know, big offices, you know, that you know, in the old days, everybody had their fancy offices, all the senior executives, and it's not like that anymore. You're you're sharing a desk because you're not, you know, you pack up your laptop, you go home, pictures of your family, you know, what or whatever it is. Offices look different uh than they used to look.
SPEAKER_03Well, it used to store all your stuff too, and now all your stuff's on that laptop, it doesn't matter, right? Like all you you move to a different screen. It's pretty interesting how like that's you know, there was no computer at one point, and you probably could do the same thing. Then there was a computer, but you're kind of anchored.
SPEAKER_00Now it's well, computers. I mean, well I mean, uh we were you know, uh for as long as I've been in business, I I've always been, you know, we're we're Mac based, except for accounting. And uh as you should be. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02And that's a no-brainer.
SPEAKER_00Everybody has laptops now. And I I even remember like you know, September 11th, which was for me that was our view. Um we watched we watched it all, but I remembered while that was all going on, you know, trying to figure out okay, damn, what what do I do? I'm responsible for everybody here. I got terrorist attack going on down the street. What do I do with my people? And I one by I mean, we came up with you know, uh our own little system so we could make sure that we were taking care of everybody and everybody could get home. But I remember thinking one by one as people would walk out of the office, is it really callous of me to say, take your laptop with you? And I didn't, I because I did feel that way. I mean, you know, right was the end of the world that day.
SPEAKER_03Bring the deck, hurry, you gotta finish.
SPEAKER_00But they you know, in Manhattan, they closed the southern part of the city for a long time. Uh my agency is two blocks north of where they closed. Wow. So we got to go back in. I mean, after give or take a week. If if we were if we had been south of Canal Street, everything in my entire company I would not have been able to get to. Nobody would have been able to get their computers, and we would have been out. Wow.
SPEAKER_03So, you know, I mean how many hundreds or thousands of companies did that and you know, that that did happen to. It's wild.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_02That is crazy. Yeah, when when the pandemic hit, um, you know, I'm in California, so definitely different situation. Uh, but when it when it was the day to go home, that's what we did. But we it was a totally different situation than than yours.
SPEAKER_00Um well uh we did have, I mean, on the day that we said don't come in, or how I don't even remember how that exactly worked, everybody didn't have their laptops. We needed to get the laptops to everybody because I knew that uh I I didn't know for how long, but I had a pretty good, you know, idea that it might take a while. Um, so we had to make we you know, we had to figure out ways to get that meant somebody had to go in, somebody had, and and you know, nobody wanted to see anybody, everybody was you know camping out in their own space. But uh so you know uh it it it it didn't come without its challenges, and and you know, we had a lot of people sick, including me, but we made it work. And you know, I what I always say you know about that time, but it it wouldn't matter what the time is that you know it if ever there was a time to uh figure out how to make it work, that was a good time to figure it out and make it work if you wanted to get paid.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah. I remember we we as soon as they told us that we literally I told my whole staff, like 15 of us, we're all going home, and I said, take your laptop or take your computers, and we'll just work from home. I and to your point, yeah, they said two weeks, but it was like you they're not shutting down football stadiums and then two weeks later go, you know what? Right, it's cool, we can go back.
SPEAKER_03It was a money pit two weeks, yeah.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I had a pretty good idea that that was gonna last for a while. Yeah, no idea it would last as long as it did. Right. I have any idea how you know how many people would be down in my office, you know, getting COVID when everybody was we were all pretty freaked out in the beginning.
SPEAKER_03I mean, I and I had a bad case of COVID right in the beginning when nobody knew, you know, was that you know when they were building when they started putting the structures up around all the like cashiers with wood and bolts and plexiglass, I'm like, oh, this is this is not a temporary deal.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, but you know what, I mean, look, we made it through. I you know, I don't want to curse all of our luck, but in retrospect, we got through it. I mean, in the beginning, you know, that when they were asking everybody to stay at home, I was saying, like, I can I could stay at home in in my nice place, sitting on my couch. I mean, I'm not going I'm not going to combat in a war. I'm just staying home. Right, right. I still have air conditioning, I still got a refrigerator, still got a bed to sleep on. Whether it it seemed to me to be not such a uh not such an awful thing, you know, to be doing. Well, questions in everybody's mind about, so how are we going to make this work now? We didn't really have them because we had been doing, you know, we we've been using technology for so many years to be able to work remotely. To us, it wasn't such a big deal.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. And it's a good, it's a good thing to look back because I mean, going forward, that's not going to be the only time that something's going to happen. So I mean, I think going forward in the future, especially with AI and everything else that's coming into play, it's like, how do we get better? How do we move fast like we did during that time and and equip our teams with the tools to be able to handle any situation?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, you also have a lot of companies that that you know that were born, you know, in a pandemic. And so they were born a lot, like uh, you know, I was born in the, you know, in a traditional nine to five or you know, in my case, more like 7 a.m. to you know, midnight uh environment. But uh, you know, that not the the the whole notion of that's not how companies were born. I mean, it if you're if you're running a company or started a company um and you're under five years old, you were born in a different era. So, you know, it's it it it it you know it's like the generation, you know, we we were joking about technology before we you know went on air here. Uh a whole generation that was born digital. I I wasn't born digital. I need I need all the kids around to help me figure out how to do use all the technology. But as long as we use all the technology, you know, don't then then we can work this way. And it it it is appealing, you know, it's one way you attract people, definitely. And it's also can can be, you know, kind of a buzzkill to somebody who wants to go and work somewhere and they say, Well, yeah, you gotta come in every day. Yeah.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman