The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Challenge, Change, and Continuous Innovation: A Conversation with Jeremy Utley PART 1
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
All right, so I am looking at the results of this vote and thinking, oh no. Oh no. Oh yes. Oh yes. And that's when I realized this team was the exact wrong team to be making the decision. I'm Jeremy Utley, and by day I'm a professor at Stanford University, but by night I'm an insurance dude.
SPEAKER_00Insurance dudes are automated to a state really helpful. Why are agents now? By uncovering the secretly predictable, consistent, and profitable agency sales. I am a great presentation. I am Jason Feldman. We are agents. We are insurance dudes. Love it.
SPEAKER_03Welcome. Welcome to the show. So for folks that aren't familiar with you, uh, why don't you tell us a little bit about your background, how you got to be in a freshman. I want to know the reason for the story. Well, you're right. We did do it. You guys draw the hook in your direction. I was gonna go in a little, then weave the hook, then then come back to it. I don't think you were in a classic storytelling form.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah. I believe him.
SPEAKER_03That's fine. That's fine.
SPEAKER_02I believe him. So uh I'm Jeremy Utley, author, co-author of Idea Flow, the only business metric that matters, which was recently actually a cool story. Just last week was uh named by Thinkers50, one of the top 10 innovation books, which is very exciting. And uh I've been teaching at Stanford University for the last 15 years or so, leading executive programs and entrepreneurial accelerator and leadership labs for students from business school, medical school, law school, engineering, and then professionals that want to bring some of the stuff that we call design thinking into their organizations. And the moment that I brought you into was a moment at the faded Silicon Valley Bank, where a group of high performing leaders that we had brought together were pitching their uh innovation ideas to a particular team. And I realized the team who was selecting the ideas was completely unequipped to make the best decision.
SPEAKER_03Talk more about that.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, so so basically what we do when we go into organizations is we're seeking to build capacity. You think about innovation not so much as an event like a hackathon or a sprint where it's like, we get the idea, then it's back to business. We think about innovation as it's a capacity that you have to build. It's uh not only an individual capacity, but it's an organizational capacity. And so we teach students at Stanford, you know, grad students at Stanford primarily, but then we get brought into organizations to cultivate that capacity in the organization. And years ago, Greg Becker, who's a CEO of Silicon Valley Bank, had brought us in to do that. And he said, Hey, I want, I want you to work with my 30 kind of senior most leaders who report into the C-suite. We want to develop them as high potential leaders. We've got nine or 10 different strategic areas of inquiry, and we'd like for them to use the process that you've pioneered at Stanford. So let's choose one of the projects as kind of a learning vehicle. I think we chose something like debt financing for startups. Everybody admitted, hey, we got to reinvent this thing. Let's all in parallel, and that's something we can come back to if you want, but basically nine teams in parallel, all trying to solve that problem. And then at the end of two or three days, we're gonna pitch solutions we've co-developed with entrepreneurs to the team that's responsible for shepherding this work forward. Now that's the exact wrong team to be making the selection. And it's it's there's a lot of cognitive bias at play, which we can nerd out however much you want to. But the basic gist is there were, you know, a call it a spectrum of with any portfolio, right? There's a spectrum of outcomes. There's some kind of wacky stuff, there's some low-hanging fruit, obvious stuff. There's some really high potential, but potentially a little bit more risky stuff that comes out of these nine teams. And I had pulled the members of the kind of startup debt financing team out of their respective teams we had mixed them up into to be the jury, and they're gonna select the ideas to move forward with. You think this is obvious, right? They're the people whose job it is to do this stuff. And I'm watching, I having done this for a bunch of years, I kind of have a little bit of an intuitive sense of what is high potential, what's not, etc. And I'm watching the jurors, and my first thought is they're grading the nine ideas in the portfolio. Honestly, my first thought, guys, was they don't understand the grading criteria. Because they do yeah, they don't speak English. It's like it was so backwards. I'm like, surely there's something wrong because they're selecting the worst ideas, right? Objectively, you know, and I'm objective in this situation, the worst ideas. And then I but I realized no, this is gonna be awesome. Because rather than rescue them, I'm just gonna bring them in and we're gonna unveil the winner.
SPEAKER_03Make the train wreck happen or watch it happen.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I mean, that's my job. I'm basically like, I'm not a train conductor, I'm a train wrecker, right? So we come into the room, there, you know, all of the leaders there, all of the senior leadership team, Greg Becker, the C former now CEO, is there, and I say, All right, folks, um, jury, let's hear what the uh what the two ideas that you selected are. And they say the two ideas, and there's just you can hear a pin drop in the room. And I said, actually, real quick, would you raise your hand, just raise it high? If you would have selected either of these two ideas, nobody in the entire room raised their hand. And one of the members of the debt financing team goes, Are you serious? And then multiple people in the crowd go, Are you serious? Wow. And it was just this amazing moment where you realize the people whose job it is to innovate are not the people who can select the most innovative idea because they're thinking in terms of is it doable? Is it going to meet our budget? Does it align with what we already think the answer is? Right, all this stuff, and so they they bring all of those biases to the selection moment, and they're not they're fundamentally the wrong people to be making the selection.
SPEAKER_03It's the it is the epitome of round of putting the round peg in the square box, right? Like that they're in a square, and and you're talking entrepreneurs, bank is just as soon as banks involved, you know, it's just like they can't do it, they can't do it.
SPEAKER_02But I mean, I see I can't tell you all the night. I I remember, I'll tell you another story, just you know, for kicks. Um maybe 2012, we're working with one of the world's largest uh hospitality companies in the hotel space, thousands of locations around the world, which now you know it's like one of five people. Um and we are we're standing with the senior management team talking about our kind of area of expertise, which is disruptive innovation. And the chairman of the board, and mind you, this is now 12 years ago. So if I look young now, imagine how I looked then. Um, he patronizingly put his arm around me and said, Jeremy, I don't think you understand. We haven't had a disruptive innovation in hospitality in 50 years. And I had happened to just randomly, as it were, uh, I had checked Wall Street Journal earlier that day, and Airbnb had just closed around in fundraising for something like a valuation of like $12 billion. This company, the entire company was valued at a fraction of that. And I said to the chairman of the board, I said, What about Airbnb? And do you know what he said? What are you doing? That's not a hospitality company.
SPEAKER_03That's like that's like blockbusters say Netflix isn't a movie company. They're not a movie company.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, they're not a rental company, right? And we we we find ways to conveniently define our market in a way that we're the only one, right? And that's that's part of kind of the institutional bias. But anyway, I've you know, idea flow is largely about our adventures and misadventures trying to drive innovation in organizations. Thankfully, we've had some successes too. But what you see is human beings, with all of our faults and cognitive bias and things like that, we just you bring a bunch of people together. It doesn't make us better sometimes, it actually just amplifies some of that underlying stuff. And you you read a bunch of that in the pages of the book.
SPEAKER_01Oh, I love it. What an interesting conversation. Um, audience is is primarily, we have an awesome community of insurance agents. And I I think a lot of times um the insurance business as a whole gets stuck in a box. And even our agencies, you know, we get kind of like in a box too, the way things that were done and and the way things always have been. So it's really hard when we're talking about innovation in general to just think outside the box. Think about hey, just because it's been done this way doesn't mean like this is the only way. Like, what about all these other things that are happening? Right.
SPEAKER_02Well, and and what I would say there, just to kind of put a fine point on what you're saying, is when the world is static, expertise is an asset. When the world is changing, expertise becomes a liability. And and what most folks don't appreciate is the extent to which the world is changing, right? And so what you see, like one of my favorite examples of this historically, I'm a super nerd. You have to be to be a professor of Stanford. And so I read a lot, and things that I love is the story of the um of the skunk works at Lockheed Martin's. So this is like they're responsible for tons of the big time innovation in aviation over the last quarter, you know, half century. Um, and famously, in the kind of Cold War era, the US government was seeking to develop a aircraft which had a lower radar signature. The problem is, you know, we're flying bombers over, and the USSR is really gifted at shooting down our bombers. And so we need a lower radar signature. And there's not a lot of progress with kind of conventional approaches. Well, this young guy, Dennis Overhauser, uh, reads an obscure Russian math paper that the Russians hadn't bothered reading. It had been out for over 10 years. Overhauser reads it and he's and he tells Ben Rich, who's running Skunk Warts, you know, it seems like there are formulas in this paper that would inform a new design. Do I have permission to explore a new design? Bentrich, you know, it's a young guy, you know, he's he's relatively, which is to say his time's not super expensive. All right, have at it. So he takes like six months and he comes out with what would become the stealth bomber, by the way. It's a it's an aircraft that registered one one thousandth of the radar signature, the next best that had ever been designed. Yep. And at Lockheed Martin at Skunkworks, they called it the hopeless diamond. That was the internal name because everyone was convinced this thing had no hope of flying. And actually, one of the head aeronautical engineers joked, I mean, somewhat jokingly, said, Dennis Overhauser should be burned at the stake. Because I have I have slide rules older than this kid. I have slide rules older than this kid. And what does he does he not know what flies, right? And you know what? It's true. It's it's technically true that the stealth bomber is unstable not on one axis, not on two axis, but on all three axes, it's unstable. Interesting. So if the world doesn't change, that means it can't fly. Now, that's in the same time period that computer stabilization was coming into being. And all of a sudden, stability, the definition of what makes for stable is changing. And the conventional paradigm of what makes for airworthy is changing. And so you end up with this radical innovation, but it had to come from somebody who was, you could say, unfamiliar with prior art, right? And the challenge for a lot of folks is you rise through ranks of the organization and your and your credibility is built upon your expertise. And where the challengers and where the disruptors usually come from is someone who's questioning a fundamental premise. What if unstable is okay? You know, I mean, and there's tons of examples of breakthroughs coming from basically somebody with a novice's mindset. And so for a lot of leaders, the question is Am I the kind of leader that a young person or that a can have a stupid idea with? If stupid ideas aren't safe around me, we have no hope of innovating.
SPEAKER_03Well, every innovative idea starts off stupid, right? Like Copernicus said, No, we're not the center of the universe, and all of a sudden, you know, he's got problems. Totally. He pissed off a lot of people.
SPEAKER_01Absolutely.
SPEAKER_03It's the best, right?
SPEAKER_01It's like, yeah, it is funny, like, like the the line between crazy and genius is so thin, yeah, right? Yeah, like you know, everybody's crazy until they do it, and then they become genius.
SPEAKER_02You know, I mean, one of my favorite examples too, just historically, is I think Lord Kepler, he he uh he was, I think it's Lord Kepler, he whoever it is, he's presenting at the kind of worldwide association of physicists in 1900. This is four or five years before Einstein's Anis Mirabalis, right? It's like major breakthroughs and he proclaimed from the stage the only thing left for physics is more precise measurement. There's there remains nothing left for physics to do, you know, is the world leading authority prior to E equals MT squared, prior to general relativity, prior to like foundational theories now that have changed how we understand the world as we know it. And the world leading expert at the time says there's nothing left to know.
SPEAKER_01So crazy. Okay. So I want to get more into innovation, but now I want to go back. What got you started? How did you get into Stanford? And and what what started this um curiosity? Uh well, I think how did I get in it?
SPEAKER_02It was an admissions oversight.
SPEAKER_03We also need to know your SAT score. For real?
SPEAKER_02I don't even know my SAT score.
SPEAKER_03Okay.
SPEAKER_02Um, but I I uh, you know, my my background is I'm in finance. I was a management consultant, um, doing kind of very conventional management consulting kinds of things. I had my heart set on moving into economic development. I had spent, when I was in college, I had spent a summer in Bolivia setting up an accelerator for a university there. Um, after, you know, before going to business school, I spent a summer in Zambia working at an AIDS orphanage. And my heart was really set on doing economic development. I decided because I hated my management consulting job so much, I decided to sign up for two more years of it following business school because that's you know the smart thing to do, and which gave me kind of very much a uh uh kind of a free summer, so to speak. Whereas a lot of folks in business school got to use that middle summer as it's got to be their pivot moment for me. I could be more entrepreneurial, a little bit more liberal in my search. So I ended up at a startup in Delhi, India, just outside of Delhi, in Noida, India, doing solar lighting. And I'm, you know, spreadsheet monkeying, you know, I love a pivot table as much as anybody else, even to this day. I'm in recovery. My name is Jeremy. And um, while I was there, there are these amazing designers building these revolutionary products for people in poverty. And I didn't know about design as an approach to the world, as a worldview, as a problem-solving methodology. I knew about design. My wife's a fashion designer, so I knew about design as like a capital D kind of design, not like this lowercase D way of viewing the world. And that summer in India really changed my life. And so I came back to Stanford, that second year of business school, thinking I'm gonna take every class I can at the design school just to learn about this stuff. And ultimately it ended up derailing my life. And what was supposed to be kind of a one-year faculty extension um ended up being, you know, 14 years of teaching graduate students and professionals, basically. That's so cool.
SPEAKER_03So for people like Jason who don't understand the concept of design, why don't you go into that a little bit? Ha!
SPEAKER_02Yes, thank you. You yeah, you strike me as someone who doesn't get it, Jason. No, uh design. I mean, the the fundamental premise of design is basically put the human being who you're seeking to uh innovate for at the center of your work. Understand them deeply, care about them. I mean, you know, imagine this. Actually care. Care about a person who you're designing for, could be your client or your, you know, whatever that might be. Um, and then generate uh an enormous volume of ideas fueled by this sense of care and passion you have for this person and their problems. And then rather than kind of deciding on which one's the best, admit you probably don't know and try a bunch of stuff in as scrappy and low resolution and low cost and high, you know, velocity a manner as possible with the people for whom you're designing in order to determine which of your directions is worthy of further investment of time, resources, et cetera. So it's like a very rapidly iterative, high empathy, uh, high divergent thinking where collaboration, diverse perspectives are valued. And, you know, a lot of people can think in terms of a sprint. They go, okay, let's do all of those things in tight sequence, and now let's all get back to our jobs. And what my belief is, is that there's actually it can imbue your life. And these mindsets and these orientations can be something that becomes a part of your existence, not just a part of a product development cycle, but actually a part of your existence. So that's really the premise of idea flow is innovation is not an event, it's a practice. And despite being overhyped to the nth degree, it remains yet undercultivated as an individual competency and as a as a team-based capability. And so we are seeking to create a change in organizations where folks actually, just like they monitor their, you know, FICO score, or just like they monitor their BMI or their hoop, you know, sleep score or their steps, they're as mindful of their creative health as they are other aspects of their health.
SPEAKER_01It's crazy. Um two things that can be very hard for a business owner is to A be highly empathetic of either our team or our our customers, clients, right? Because you get so involved with the daily business stuff, right? But um it's just like how can we have how like what tools help can help us get there? And then the other one is following up on that one, is the um the idea of being okay with a bunch of failure, right? It feels horrible. A lot of times innovation is terrifying in our own business because it's like you're watching the dollars. It's kind of back to that whole empathy thing with our clients and our team. It's like you get so in this box that you're like scared to try stuff and you create a culture of the, you know, don't fail, you know, instead of like, let's try stuff, let's innovate.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Yeah, I think the trying stuff is really critical and recognizing the the world is just changing so quickly. And the it's it's the as Darwin says, right, it's not the strongest or the fittest, but it's the one that's most adaptable to change that survives. And so having that sense of adaptability that if we're not changing, we're probably if we're not progressing, we're probably regressing, you know. Um, and creating rewards and incentives and a culture that appreciates experiment, you know, as Jeff Bezos said, failure and invention are inseparable twins. I love that expression. If we're trying to make something, we're going to fail. It's that's part and parcel of the even the scientific method, right? The hypothesis-driven testing. You're gonna fail a lot of times, and that's fine. It's the in science, it's not failure, it's learning and it's refining the hypothesis. Um, in terms of your question around empathy, I mean, one of the things that we teach people to do is it sounds crazy, but it's go where your customers are, talk to your customers, and don't have an agenda per se, but be willing to be surprised and allow them to take you in unexpected directions. You know, like one of my favorite stories, my one of my you know, now teaching partners, uh Carrie, uh Kelly Garrett-Ziegler, KGZ is what we call her. So amazing woman, amazing uh designer who was at Vans and now she's at Pearson, but she told the story of the time she was at Mattel, and she said they wanted to create a product um for parks. And their goal was we want to create something that families take out into the world, maybe to playgrounds and kind of because you're always looking for ways to expand your footprint of your product. And they've got kind of hot wheels and things like that. They're in the living room, they're in the bedroom, but man, what if they get in the park? And she said that we started talking to parents in their homes and we were asking them about when do they feel relief, when do they feel like they're they're able to um let their kids explore. And she said, for whatever reason, we ended up in the bathroom over and over and over again. We're in the bathroom because the bathroom is actually the place where finally, when a kid's in the bathtub, mom and dad can chill. And it's actually not at the park. And so she said, Kelly said, all of a sudden, we have this huge, it's like we could either insist on no, no, no, we have like we've mocked up some outdoor designs, or we could say, like, what could we do in the bathroom? I love it. And because if it's actually about one of their kind of design directives, was creating more bandwidth in the life of a parent and engaging a child, how do we how do we extend bath time in a way that create gives space to parents, right? And so they they allowed themselves to kind of be taken off track, if you will. Another example. Just because I think it's something, if you're not interacting with the customer and you're not trying something with the customer, you're never going to learn this stuff, right? So foundational thing is you got to interact with them, you got to try stuff with them. But then the question is, are you so married to or wedded to your idea that you can't hear, you know, disconfirming evidence, in which case your toast, or are you holding it loosely and you go, well, take me off-road? You know, like my friend Philippe runs the innovation lab at Michelin. And he said they wanted to get into kind of off-road space tires, and they had this really cool prototype where basically, you know, folks who go off-roading need to adjust their tire pressure. And he said, We had this really cool kind of you know remote controlled thing, like you just pop it in, you know, into the dashboard display and it would adjust your tire pressure. He said, What we learned is people actually enjoy needing to be the guy who's got to get out and kind of like, you know, and and like relieve the pressure. Like that was there's something about the tactical experience, tactile experience that was really satisfying to them. So he said, We kind of this we built this technology, but it didn't really matter. But he said, one of the things we started hearing over and over again was they feel like they don't know where the best trails are. And they're kind of on trails that other people are already off-roading, but their skills are kind of going beyond this trail. And they ended up in this space where they're developing a product that where basically you unlock the ability to discover new terrain as you improve your ability. It's got very little to do with automated kind of tire inflation or deflation, but it's true to where the user is taking them. Yeah. But again, they're putting themselves in front of the user, uh, trying something. I would argue they would never have discovered the trail opportunity if they hadn't been attempting with the tire deflating opportunity, right? But if you're not willing to allow your your vision to kind of go off the rails, you're never gonna discover the real opportunities.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, and I think the way that it's set up, you become the with big, bigger companies, right? Like the as the expert advances, they're gonna be more set in their ways because it's what got them there, yeah, right. So there's that that bias, and they don't want to hear it. Oh, that's more work, man. I already did all the work. I want to sit up here and collect my free.
SPEAKER_02Well, and we already know how to deflate tires, but like what do we know about trail? Like, right, let's just try to find somebody who wants their tires deflated, right? Because we already know how to do that, right? Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_03Let's not let's not do something new. Let's just do the thing that we're doing and find the right people. No, exactly. Exactly. But there are people, we already have them. Like that's it's more important.
SPEAKER_02One of my favorite, just while we're talking about Philippe, shout out to Philippe if you hear this, by the way. You're an insurance dude, Philippe. Um of the things that he said it that I that I really love is he said, you know, his lab, if you think about getting back to this question about failure as well, Jason, he said one of the primary services his innovation lab offers the organization is they kill things cheaply. He said that the organizational instinct is to spend a lot of money on something that ultimately doesn't work. And one of the really great things they do is they learn quickly and cheaply. We shouldn't fund that. He said that, and that's everybody appreciates failing for $100,000 rather than a million dollars. That's great. He said the problem is a lot of times, like an executive will come with a billion-dollar post-it, right? They've got like this one, this is the billion-dollar idea. Right. Yeah. And he said, the prow them empirically that's not a billion-dollar idea. And he said, the problem is that's my only post-it. Right. And so, how do you build that sense of we got we got loads of other possibilities? What we need to do is churn through them quickly, not just put all of our eggs in this one post-it basket and really hope it's the right one.
SPEAKER_03It's it's very similar to the concept of MVP, right? Minimal viable product. This is like minimal viable idea. And you just bring as many as possible because then you're going to be able to funnel them into the minimal viable product.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, we were inspired by this research by um his name's Dr. Dean Keith Simonton out of UC Davis. And one of the things that he he studied breakthrough thinking across disciplines, across domains, across uh geographies and time periods. And what he found was the single greatest determinant of the quality of your ideas is actually the quantity of your ideas. So if you want better ideas, you need more. And very few people are thinking in terms of quantity. So here's a here's a fun example. Jerry Yulsman is the uh, he was an assistant to the late great Ansel Adams, the American photographer. And Yulsman teaches photography at the University of Florida. And he'll he'll basically he'll divide his class in half. He says, Okay, you you want to get an A at the end of the semester, and everybody does, right? To half of the class, he says, you've got to turn in a truly world-class photograph. I'm gonna bring in a distinguished jury of my photography peers. They're gonna evaluate the quality of your work. And to get an A, you got to have a spectacular photo. To the other half, he says, okay, quality doesn't matter, but I'm gonna count. It's about tonnage. I'm gonna count how many photos you take. And if you take over a hundred photos in a semester, you get an A. It doesn't matter how bad they are. If you take over 90, you get a B, etc. etc. And then he brings in the jury, but importantly, the jury is blind to the condition. They don't know that. So the jury is evaluating the quality of the photos, all of them. And the thing that shocks the jury, and it shocks students too, it doesn't shock Yulsman because he's seen it for so long. Yeah, the students whose job it is to get an A can't do it. No A's are awarded. The students whose job is to turn in a bunch of photos get lots of A's. And it's it's going back to this Dean Keith Simons and stuff. The yeah, as Eisenhower said, I think uh quantity has a quality all its own. And when you start to orient around quantity, you end up generating much better ideas. But it but how you approach the market and collaborators and and everything and problems changes a lot when you think in terms of volume rather than than quality.
SPEAKER_01I love that because how do you get good at anything? You do reps, yeah. That's just it. Exactly. Exactly. You don't buy 10 leads, you buy 100 leads because everything.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman