The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Gary Cooper’s Journey Of Success And Self-Discovery! PART 2
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
I thought I would have character when I became successful. But I had to build character to be successful. So I thought I would have character once I had the house and the car and the family and all that stuff. So I worked hard to get all that stuff and I got all that stuff. And instead of having character, I became a character.
SPEAKER_03It's funny though, the clearer you do get on those things, right? Because I mean, business and life are very should be synonymous, right? Like that's what we were talking about before, where you have the identity of the of what you do in your business. This happens a lot to uh sports people. My mom was a gymnast and she went to the junior Olympics and then she had a aerobics company and was very successful, and then got a little bit older, had some injuries, couldn't do the back walkovers and back hand springs that she wanted to do when she was 90. You know, she had to stop doing that at um, I think in her late 50s, something like that, maybe early 60s.
SPEAKER_04Still doing that in her 50s? It's crazy.
SPEAKER_03But but like but like she was hell bent on doing it in her 80s. But that was her identity. And when she couldn't do it anymore, and that had been her identity, it was tough for her. And we've talked to other people on here, and it happens in sports a lot. You know, you see like somebody in sports, like a football player that I mean, they trained for that their whole life, and then you know, no one plans for the after part, you know what I mean? So, so then that whole shift becomes crazy, and kind of like what you were talking about earlier. There's a grieving phase of that. You know, I I did that early on in my life when I I played music and you know, I used to tour with bands and we we had some success. And I just that was all I was gonna do. And at some point I wanted to get married, and I had to say, you know what, that's not the lifestyle for me, and I had to move on from that. But I had a super bad grieving phase that I didn't know about. It was in my late 20s, I didn't understand what was going on, and I just found myself lost and just sad and grieved. I had anxiety, like there's this whole thing that came with it. And I think everybody does that with certain things, and and nothing is permanent in life, and it's scary when you get so attached to these um personas, and it's like, you know, for us men, we get into business because you know, we have a family, we have this this goal, and and then when we achieve it, sometimes we get wrapped up a little bit too much in business, and then it's we're putting all those things ahead of our family, and then we get wrap up our identity, and it's like, wait a minute, we got to reassess what's going on here because it could tear a family apart and all that stuff. It's it's tough.
SPEAKER_00I'll tell you, you're spot on again. It's um I've witnessed I have witnessed my whole life, mature men. I witnessed it first with my granddad, but then being in healthcare my entire career, my entire life, I've witnessed men retire and die shortly thereafter. And now um I'm in a 12-step program here at a retirement beach area. We live in South Carolina right on the coast, so a lot of northerners retire here. They've been harassing our South Carolina coast like California's now harassing Arizona and Texas. Oh man.
SPEAKER_04They're not allowed. We're close.
SPEAKER_00So when I say harassing, I mean that as a joke. Um, right. They've been great for the economy and a lot of other things. But what happens is now that I see these guys, you know, these guys retire up north, they move down here in South Carolina, and two years later they're in a 12-step program. They have like they're a sailboat with no mast up in the ocean. They had direction every day when they woke up, and now they're like, I don't know, maybe happy hour starts at noon. Yeah, you know, and I don't think they would have done that at home. And so I totally agree with what you're saying. I think you know, I don't really talk about religion a lot, but I do talk about spirituality, and until I had my relationship with it, turns out to be that my childhood religion, but until I had a relationship where this is a story I tell, and I tell it because it's funny, it's huge, this huge, beautiful, beautiful African-American man. He looks like James Earl Jones and he sounds like him too. And I'm sitting there just busted, man. And I'm like, I'm just like a hopeless hobo. And he looked at me and he said, Boy, I don't care if you believe in God, boy, as long as you believe you ain't God. And that's a powerful statement. Because I think what us men do, we go through life being self-sufficient, and and if you're an agent, if you eat what you kill, that is tough. You're only as good as your last deal. Yeah, and every day you're keeping score, and so there is some relationship there where you have to play God in your life, you know, and so if you do well, I can see why you get a big ego, yeah. And if you're a surgeon and you're opening people's chests and fixing their hearts, can you imagine why your ego would be pretty big? I I can't imagine how big mine would be, right?
SPEAKER_04And then you're hanging out with all the other surgeons, solidifying each other's big egos, right?
SPEAKER_00And so I think that happened to me. Yeah, you know, this success came fairly easily. Now, don't get me wrong, I worked my ass off, but I've seen other people work harder than me and didn't have the success. So I had all this success, and then didn't necessarily make me quote unquote happy. So then this beautiful African-American man says, basically, you've been playing God with your life, and so I think spirituality can really help that stuff you were talking about, Jason. Yeah, it's like the good stuff in my life and the bad stuff in my life really isn't all me. You know, so when something's really I used to have these really high highs and really low lows, yeah. Imagine a huge commission check come in. Yeah, but look what I did, right? But now I'm like, hey, that's cool. Yeah, right, yeah, you know, and then now something really bad happens. I'm like, all right.
unknownRight.
SPEAKER_00You know now I now I look at them as seasons, yep, and I can get through the the great seasons just as easy as I can get through the the rainy seasons, and so I didn't have as I had just about as much to do with the really positive stuff as I did the really shitty stuff, right?
SPEAKER_04And you know, and and we everybody here on this and also listening would probably agree that you learn the most during the rainy seasons, right? You don't learn anything, you learn how great you are in the in the ones where you're winning, right? What and I'm being sarcastic, right? You think you figured it all out right before the freaking other shoe drops, and you and and it starts raining again, right? So it's so important. We learn so much when it rains, right? COVID, the people that went all in during COVID learned a lot, like we learned a lot, like we we grew a 10 million dollar company during COVID, right? Like, because know how to do it, and just working through finding the opportunities when when it is in that low swing and being able to go for it.
SPEAKER_00See, I think what um I think I'm sorry, Jason, go ahead.
SPEAKER_04No, no, no, go.
SPEAKER_00I think what happened with me is over the years I would run from those low periods because I didn't want to experience the pain.
SPEAKER_04Yes, right.
SPEAKER_00And we were talking earlier. I covered mine up with alcohol, I probably covered them up with boats and cars and fun things too, you know. But uh, or exercise, that was a big one for me. But look, we're not the only people in the world that cover their their problems up. There's eating, there's sex, porn. I really do believe there's an Amazon addiction. There is because look, you can hit buy, and then that shit feels good for a little while. Yeah, you're like, Yeah, I got this thing coming, and it's all cool. So we all run from pain. Who doesn't? It doesn't feel good, and then we find something that's temporarily good, but that's why again go back to the spirituality. You know, that's the only thing that lasts good for a long period of time, and it doesn't cost a dime, right? Yeah, I don't get it.
SPEAKER_04You can connect with that any moment, right? Like any second you can connect with that versus the other thing, you if you hold that attachment to the thing you bought on Amazon, eventually you're gonna be disappointed and and upset because right, like it never solves it.
SPEAKER_00I don't get fat, I don't get fat, I don't have to clear my browser history. Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_04So I mean, who really clears it?
SPEAKER_00I mean, you know, I'm an insurance dude, I can get away with it.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I personally love this conversation. I mean, this is something that I've been you know thinking about and and working on for years now, and I love I love um, and I think it's something that we all need to think about. I think I almost look at it as like a blessing. If you're able, it's like Maslow's hierarchy of need, right? If you're able to get to a point where you're just really thinking about yourself and you you can do a little self-work, what a blessing it is to be in a position that you can do that. Um, a lot of times there is pain in the background, and that's how we get to the point where we start doing that inner work. Um, but one of the that that's beside the point. What I was gonna bring up is Dr. Benjamin Hardy. He's one of my favorite authors right now. Um, he talks about your future self and he talks about this whole construct of, you know, our the way that society has believed in the past with psychology and stuff, is that our past kind of determines our present, right? Like all the things in the past brought us to the present, and then whatever we feel in the present will bring us into the future. Um, but he he kind of breaks it down, and there's uh a and I forget the different type of psychology, is um where the actually the future, the future determines your present. Your the future will pull you into the uh will pull your present into the future. So, you know, like it's like who you want to be, and we're what we're talking about, identities and and everything will pull you forward instead of those past things determine who you are. It's kind of like you're gonna let your future self determine who you are now. So now you start doing the actions of that future self. And then in our present self, we can reattach new stories to our past identity, our past stories, all this traumatic behavior, right? Or or traumatic um stories that have happened to us. You can take something like you were saying, Craig, the rainy seasons. You feel like crap in those moments. You might have lose things, you might, you might have done something to hurt someone, but like what did you learn through that? And if you can have a, you know, you can change that story in the present of your past and attach new meanings to it. It could have got, you know, it it made you who you are now. And who knows? Like, there might be a story of I know for me, like my dad wasn't around a lot when I was young, and I used to be really mad about it. A lot of that fueled it helped me get where I am now. So I literally do not feel any pain towards it anymore. I feel, if anything, more sadness for who he was as a person, but I I'm not mad at him. And so my story on my relationship with my father's changed over the over the years because my present self has changed and it's changed my past.
SPEAKER_00Well, that makes sense to me, you know. I got it. If I can put maybe my two cents on it, yeah, another weird way to say that is fake it till you make it. Um, you know, because I am so stupid simple, you know. If if I'm an agent in an agency and everybody's always thought I was a loser or a non-producer, and I always dress like it, and always carried myself like it, and always didn't make eye contact and stuff. Go to a new agency and start dressing different, start acting different, start carrying yourself different, start projecting who you want to be, like you were saying, in the future, yeah, and forgive yourself for whatever you thought you were, because that guy's gone.
SPEAKER_01Yep.
SPEAKER_00I call myself old Gary and New Gary.
SPEAKER_01We do that all the time, you know.
SPEAKER_00Old Gary was he was a knucklehead. Old Gary showed up late. He showed up late to every meeting, he would be unprepared, you know. He didn't call people back, he he, you know, returned emails whenever the hell he wanted to. Um he was a knucklehead. He was also pretty damn creative, you know, he's really creative, but he got away with murder. New geary is very punctual, he's prepared, he he does things that he says he's gonna do, you know, he tries to have more integrity than he ever had before. He gives people the gift of time, you know, where before he didn't have time for you, or if he was talking to you, he was looking at his watch or looking around the corner, you know, to see if there's somebody else he needed to talk to. So, you know, if I was another agent, kind of to use that thing that you were talking about, fake it till you make it, become new Jason by pretending to be who you want to be. And if you do that enough reps, it's like a muscle. You do that enough reps every day, and people will notice who you are before you do.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, true. The thing that you're doing, the actions, right? Like the only reason that it's faking it is because of in your own head, right? Like you're doing it, you're not faking it, you're actually doing it, but you don't believe it that you can do it or believe that you are doing it, so you think that you're faking it, right? Like, and I don't mean you, I just mean the royal you.
SPEAKER_00I know what you're talking, yeah.
SPEAKER_04So I think there's this, you know, you have to basically move your it's like this total mind shift to the new place, right? And the only way to do it is a trick, is to say, I'm faking it, and then there's a story, yeah.
SPEAKER_00And then there's gonna be haters saying, Oh, look at Jason, he's dressing all fancy, look at him, and then it's like, you know what? Screw those people.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, if you got those, then you're on to something, right? If there's people trying to pull you down, then you are doing something.
SPEAKER_00Yep, screw those people, yeah. They weren't your friends to begin with.
SPEAKER_03It is funny, it's like you do not achieve anything without the actions, and they will always come first. So it's really having that belief that belief, like, hey, I if I do the same actions as this other person, I can receive the same result. But it's hard to, I mean, it is it's hard to do that in our own head, and it's hard to do that because of those around us.
SPEAKER_04I have one I think that the so we were talking about moving from operator to to owner, right? And I thought I know that that Jason, like obviously, you did that, Gary. Jason's done it, I've done it in our agencies, and we see it over and over. So many agents that are still stuck in the they own it, but they also are are operating it, and they're also a producer and they're doing everything. And and if I, you know, maybe this will break through with them, but there was a time when it was very uncomfortable to hear the phone ring and not answer it. Oh, yeah, it was very uncomfortable to have somebody come in and say they're gonna cancel and not run over there and try to save them. But once all of those things were completely let go, like it's been two, you know, three years since I've taken a call here. Like, I can't imagine getting on the phone now because it's endless, right? There's 200 calls every day. Like, what am I gonna do? I'm not stopping any anything or fixing anything or moving the needle. I'm doing much, I'm much more effective being here, even if I'm only here for one hour to meet with the team and do it run a sales meeting. That's way more effective than me running around my hair on fire, trying to stay solve all the world's problems.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, you know, Jason, you were touching on something earlier about the Maslow of hierarchy of needs and all that stuff. Yeah, here's the way that I've seen it work in my life, and here's the way it was described to me. I thought I would have character when I became successful, but I had to build character to be successful. So I thought I would have character once I had the house and the car and the family and all that stuff. So I worked hard to get all that stuff, and I got all that stuff, and instead of having character, I became a character. Yeah, and instead, what I've worked on the last six years, almost seven years, is when I work on every morning before I get in the shower, I work on building my character and building integrity, and then I think success comes after character building always. And if we get success before character, we're always scared of losing it.
SPEAKER_04It puts us in a scarcity, yeah.
SPEAKER_00So that's probably one of the biggest lessons I've learned.
SPEAKER_03I love it, and I and I want to dive into the book. Um when when was the book released?
SPEAKER_00I think we released it in June.
SPEAKER_03And it's called The Success Paradox.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, here's a copy of it right here. Where'd I go right there?
SPEAKER_01There it is. Awesome. He's holding up Shiny New Beautiful Success Paradox. How long did it take you to write the book?
SPEAKER_00It took about a year and a half to actually write it. Um, and look, I never wanted to write a book, I never dreamed of being a book writer. I don't part of my identity is not being an author. Um so I got, you know, they normally get a ghostwriter, and I'm like, look, all my friends would know I didn't write it. So I'm putting the guy's name on the front of the book who who helped me. So the the reason why I wrote the book is one of our best friends, kid, committed suicide, and all these problems we're talking about, kids are dealing with them. And the biggest one that I dealt with, I believe, was comparing myself to other people. I think that started when I was really young, and I think a lot of you were talking about your dad um not being around. Mine was comparing myself to my dad, he was really successful, and I think I transferred his success to I'm nothing if I don't become as successful or more so than him. And when he died, I just picked somebody else and I started chasing them. And when Jack Buffington killed himself, I was about a year and a half into this 180 direction in my life, and I was like, man, it's gotta be hard to be a 20-year-old kid. Jack was 20 years old, and he was my kid's best friend and my wife's best friend from childhood's son. And we raised him together, and then 10 other kids in this small town of 10,000 people killed themselves that same year.
SPEAKER_03How many?
SPEAKER_0010. Wow. And so I had no desire to write a book. Um, and I wanted to write a book about kids. And Forbes called and said, Have you ever thought about a book? And I was like, Yes, I'd like to do it about kids. And they said, Well, that's not your story. Your story is you put these things into your business, and your business went from 60 million to 400 million, and that's your story. So I set it up in a nonprofit, and all the proceeds go to the nonprofit. And I would love to get somebody like Demi Lovato or LeBron James or Roy McElroy to write a book for kids to say, hey, Demi's very vocal about her stuff. I would love to get Demi to write a book to say you don't have to compare yourself to anybody because you're perfect the way God made you, you know, for that age group. Because there's a section in the book about social media, and I'm not a social media basher. Um, the way I describe it is did you know Alfred Nobel invented dynamite? The Nobel Peace Prize guy, invented dynamite, huh? So his brother dies, and he goes to his brother's funeral, and they screw up and they put Alfred's obituary on the front page of the newspaper in Paris, and they call him the Master of Death. And he's like, Holy crap, I invented dynamite, it's a good thing. Why are they calling me the master of death? So he spent some he spends the next couple of years changing his obituary, and he invents the Nobel Peace Prize, and he's as rich as Bill Gates at that time, and he donates all of his money to create the Nobel Peace Prize. Wow. So I would like to change my, you know, my dash. You know, I was born in 72. I would like to change my dash to say, how can we, you know, not bash social media, but say it's explosive like dynamite, depending on whose hands it's in. You know, so if you go on, set a timer, you know. If you go on, you know, don't compare yourself to a supermodel, you know, or don't compare yourself to Elon Musk, or don't compare yourself to the fastest man in the world if you're a white kid like me, you know, who can't jump, you know. If I buy Nike, if I buy Michael Jordan shoes, I can't dunk like him. You know, I tried that in high school and it didn't work. I actually had Ralph Sampson's shoes. Remember him? Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_03Super cool. Well, how can we get a hold of the book? How can our readers uh learn more?
SPEAKER_00So you can go to Amazon, that's probably the easiest place to get it.
SPEAKER_04Um they're gonna let you after you said those things about Amazon.
SPEAKER_00I hope so. Um wait a minute, you can go to um successparadox.com.
SPEAKER_05Yep, super cool.
SPEAKER_04It's great, man. I love it. I am gonna I'm gonna pick this up. I'm gonna sign up for your newsletter there on the webpage too, and get going.
SPEAKER_03That's awesome, man. You have gone through quite the transformation, and I just want to say uh it's it's so awesome to see somebody. Um, a lot of people that do become successful uh don't go that direction, right? They they they become um maybe a little bit more part of a problem rather than a solution. So just want to say thank you for for putting all this good out into the world and and now being a leader for for good rather than you know showing showing people what they can do and putting God first. I think it's super cool, man.
SPEAKER_00Well, dudes, I just want to know do I get a t-shirt or like a hat or any kind of merch?
SPEAKER_04Yeah, we can arrange that.
SPEAKER_00Like, do I get an insurance due shirt?
SPEAKER_04So I can take you got to take a picture with it, put it on the screen.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, put it. I'll put it on uh LinkedIn. Nice, yeah.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, that will be sent to you for sure.
SPEAKER_00That'd be fun. I'll have fun with that.
SPEAKER_04Cool, awesome. Gary, so good to have you on here, man. Thank you for uh for coming on. And you went the distance, did the whole hour crazy. We did it.
SPEAKER_00It's weird. We made it happen. It's fun talking to you guys. You are a lot of fun. Uh thanks, man. Thanks, Gary.
SPEAKER_04Have a great rest of your day. Take care, man. See ya.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman