The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Expert Leadership Advice With Phil Geldart PART 2
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
In today's world, I don't need you to tell me how to get it done. I need you to support me in the doing of it. That's what I need. And therefore, I need to trust you. So trust is kind of like the currency of the age. Wow, how can I trust you? Well, you demonstrate integrity and character and honesty and empathy. Okay, now I trust you, so help me do this.
SPEAKER_02I are interested now. I am interested in it. I am right. I am interested.
SPEAKER_01We are able to R. What what happens if somebody clearly like you lay that out there and they're just like, whatever. They're they're not buying into this.
SPEAKER_03Yep. So the answer to that is you think of an hourglass. So you take an hourglass and you flip it over, a bunch of the sand just goes and it drops right down. Some of it just kind of takes its time, it's on its way down, and some of it just hangs around on the side, I think, like forever. Yeah. But ultimately it gets there. What you have to decide is is this person who's obviously not sort of an early adopter and just flows right down, are they just having to wrap their head around what this is all about? I don't quite get it. I'll get there if you give me time, or are they just culturally not aligned with you? And so I my advice is give it time, be patient. Everybody's different. Help people to see what it is that you see and stay with them. But at the end of the day, if they're clearly not on board, I say, look, I appreciate the fact that you don't have the same point of view about people as I do, and I respect that. So unfortunately, you're gonna have to go find an organization that aligns with your culture instead of this one. That's okay. I that's not a judgment. It's just that this is the way I'm gonna run my team. And if that's not the way you want to be run, no problem. But go find a place that you're more comfortable.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_03But that is rare if you are willing to help the person make it down through the hourglass. You got to be willing to do that. And which comes back to do you value the potential of people, right? Give them time to get where they got to go. Sorry, yeah.
SPEAKER_00At what point do you make the determination that maybe you want it for them more than they do?
SPEAKER_03So a simple test is whether they are influencing negatively those around them. If they're beginning to have a negative influence around them, then you're you're past the point. It's time to act. Because a person who is struggling to get it is not a negative influence, they're not a positive influence, but they're not a detractor. But when you see that they're starting to uh work against you, then you gotta act.
SPEAKER_00Oh, yeah. Because then it's just insidious, it just can destroy the culture, yep, quickly.
SPEAKER_03And and you lose the respect of your team because they're saying, Why is he letting that guy get away with that? That just doesn't make sense to me. And then your whole credibility is down, so you have to have to manage that.
SPEAKER_00So in this world, what can happen a lot is it it's challenging to find the folks that are gonna perform in this in at the um at the level that we need to be successful because the margins are small on the PNC side. Um and then when you get a really, really like I've I've done this a couple of times where you have somebody really, really strong, but they affect the they affect the rest of the team. And Jason's had it too. And I think a lot of people listening probably have have stuck with that person way too long because of the hey, I I'm getting a lot of production here, you know, double everybody else, but at the end of the day, they wreck everything.
SPEAKER_03Absolutely. And it's a tough decision for a leader to make. That's one of the that's one of the classics, you know. They're high, they're high productivity, but they're we're bad for the culture. But at the end of the day, the impact that they have is far greater for for bad, far greater than you realize. Now, again, if you're a great leader, you're not you're not like an idiot. You think, okay, this person is definitely not a good cultural fit. So I'm gonna have to act on them. But I don't have to act today. I can put a plan in place and do it in a way that doesn't hurt the business and you know, transition, groom somebody up. So it's not like it's not like it's out of the blue. You see it, you know, you see it coming. You should you should be taking steps and say, I'm gonna try to help him or her, but if they don't turn around, I have a game plan in the back of my pocket ready to go. It's gold of the desert kings. Don't rush across the desert until you've planned for the food and water, then go.
SPEAKER_00Do you do you see that a lot with bit with business owners, especially in smaller organizations where maybe cash flow is needs to be managed very carefully?
SPEAKER_03Um I would say it is less cash flow and more lack of appreciation for how to lead. So if I were to give you a quick example, let's say you start out early in your career and you get a job as a uh a laborer on a road crew, and your job is you know, you you dig the ditches and you move the dirt around and stuff, and then you're you're hardworking, so they promote you. So now you got a little team. So you're still digging ditches, but you're also showing the other guys, you know, which shovels to use, which shovels not to use. Well, they promote you, and now you got thebacco. Hey, you get to drive the backhoe, that's pretty cool. But you also get to hire the crew. Now you're managing the backhoe, and then they can promote you again. Now you're managing the backhoe in the trucks. And before you know it, instead of just at the end of the day having a beer with the boys, at the end of the, you know, you're two or three years into your career, you're managing people. You got men and women who are looking to you for leadership, and who do you hire and how do you deal with problems on the on the job site? And you wake up and go, man, like I'm spending more time with people than I am on things. So what do you do? You use the skills that got you promoted. And the thing that got you promoted was I'm good with things. I know how to make, I do this and this happens, I do this and that happens, I do. So you apply your the things you have learned to your people. But people are not things. So that's why you have in organizations senior folks who are not good people managers because they're treating the people like things, like, okay, I you know, I tell them what to do, I do this, I organize that, but people are not things. So the issue, especially in smaller organizations, is they're incredibly good at making the sale, dealing with the customer, you know, doing all the insurance stuff that you got to do with the forms and the legislation and the government, but they're never been trained to deal with people. So now I got to deal with a person. I deal with it like I deal with anything else, you know. Okay, do what I got to do with now, put it aside, move to the next task. But it doesn't work like that.
SPEAKER_01So I would say it's less cash and more skill. Sorry. I was gonna say, um, just even like my journey, or and I think that this is the way most people get into this business, but what gets you from being a good or just an employee into a business owner, and then becoming like like a somewhat good business owner is like a lot of sweat equity, a lot of that working, working, working, and then when you get to that point that you need to put somebody there, you know, a lot of us aren't that great, and you're trying to make it work, and the next thing you know, you're right, like you you're treating people like things because it's like okay, I'm working on all these pieces and it's gotta work to make the the thing cash flow. And it's like, well, why don't they understand the the because you're you're you see the money, you see the time, you you know, you're getting home late at you know from work because you know, and not spending time with your family, so you have that pressure. So there's all these like like internal pressures that no one gets to see, and then you like put those pressures on the on the people, and it's like sure, it's crazy because when you do kind of take more of a inward approach and you start working on yourself, the things that you're talking about, like working on yourself and and communication with people, you start relieving that tension, and everything starts working out a lot better, all because of it. But you it's it's hard to see that.
SPEAKER_03Well, yeah, it's very hard to see it. And if you are a small business owner and you have never seen great leadership, and I share what I'm just sharing with you, they think you're from Mars. What are you talking about? I don't I don't even know, I don't know what you're talking about because they have no vision for what it can be in their mind. You know, if I need to do more work, I I run the backhoe for another four hours. If I need more work, I tell you to work harder. It's the same thing, you're a backhoe. It's just they do not understand. And one of the most difficult things is to get a senior person who has not actually thought this through or had the skills to wake up and realize that actually people are their greatest asset. They everybody knows that, but they don't act that way, they don't think that way, they don't perform that way, they don't behave that way. They treat people like things. And so I have a problem, change the person. No, no, you have a problem, make the person better. I don't know how to do that, so I'll just change them. So you never get past mediocrity. Because great people are not great people don't come like off the assembly line. They're groomed, they're trained, they're coached, they're guided, they're helped. And where does all that come from? Your boss. Well, if your boss doesn't do that, you're never gonna have anything more than an organization of competent but relatively mediocre people because they're not being challenged to be brilliant, because you're not challenging yourself to be brilliant. Interesting.
SPEAKER_00It speaks it speaks to the importance of having mentors, of coaching your team, of being that person for them, and you know, and uh as the leader of also learning, right? Because a lot of times, like you said, we go in not knowing how to do any of that. Maybe we're really good at the job, but we're no longer doing the job. Now we're we're teaching other people how to do the job because that's leverage, right? Like we're not gonna ever have business leverage if they're not doing the job. So now it's like we need our job is to get good at showing them how to do the job, exactly.
SPEAKER_03Which comes right back full circle. How do you do that? The only way to do it is show them a mirror of their current behavior and the consequences. I can tell you forever, but they will not listen to me. But if I put them through an experience and they conclude for themselves, they go, Oh, you know, that's right. I that's what I do, and that's the outcome. I could do it better. Show me how. So, without that experience, it's just a lecture and they wait for you to get out of their office so you can get back to their paperwork.
SPEAKER_00Oh, it's very difficult to break cognitive dissonance. Yes, exactly. So they're like already, this is the way I I mean, you know, all of us have had those epiphanyes where you're like, holy shit, I do that, you know, like I mean, I it's crazy.
SPEAKER_01So it's crazy too. You're talking about like changing somebody that somebody that's in your organization that is not performing optimally, like, we have two decisions. One is we can just bark orders, throw a bunch of consequences out there, which is I mean, it's the area that we tend to lean to because we're irritated, we're upset, and all this other stuff. But everything that you spoke to is going the absolute opposite of that, and it's encouraging, it's helping, it's you know, pushing ahead, creating a better situation, everything that that's the opposite of art.
SPEAKER_03It's valuing, it's valuing the potential within every human being. You know, I I had an interesting story. I I was in a room once many years ago, and the the chairman of the board of a huge company was talking, and he was talking about uh the importance of people. And a lady put her hand up, and uh, it was a tech company, and she stood up and said, Excuse me, may I just make a comment, sir? And he said, Sure. She said, I have a PhD in nuclear physics. I work in a rocket propulsion lab. I am a rocket scientist, and I will tell you, I am now in leadership, and it is way harder than being a rocket scientist. And she got a standing ovation because people think leadership is just something you do. But this lady, you know, the phrase, well, it's not rocket science. She said, You know what? Being a leader is the hardest thing I have ever done. And she is right. But if you don't understand that, you treat it as if it's something you can just do in your spare time. Well, we all speak, so I'm a good communicator. We all listen, so I listen really well. Yeah, what's the problem with that? The problem is you get you don't get 80% greater value out of your workforce. That's the problem with that, right?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so so would you say empathy is the bit is one of the most important skills of being a good leader?
SPEAKER_03Yes, I I'm not sure I'd call it a skill, I think it's a an attitude, but it's certainly one of the most important attitudes to have. I think the skills are the things that you master to let you demonstrate your empathy. So so with J Jason had to using your example again, you had empathy for the situation in your family, but you had to go do something about it. It reflected in your behavior. So I think there's things like empathy, I think there's things like integrity that drive you to a behavior. You need to learn the behaviors, but if you don't have those core things at the beginning, it's a lot harder.
SPEAKER_00Interesting. So empathy is is the result of the activity that you put into getting to it. Empathy is seen as a result of what you do.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. What would you say the values of a strong leader are?
SPEAKER_03The values as opposed to the behaviors, you mean?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, like what like as a temperature test.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, so I I would say the most important, which you've probably heard me say about six times already. Yeah, I would think the most important is to recognize the worth of a human being. You know, there's a lot of talk today about diversity, equity, and inclusion training, and we do it. But really, at the heart is do you respect the other person? So respect for a human being is an important value, which valuing what they can bring is an important value. I think one of the most important things is what I would consider character, which is missing in today's world, like in spades. If I say something, you can rely on it. It's true, it's not something that I just say. Um, it's if I promise to deliver, I will deliver. If I commit to something, you can rely on it. Those accountability, those types of things. But those are aspects in my mind of character. And I believe that today's workforce is looking for those kinds of things in their leaders far more than tell me what to do and tell me how to do it. I they're smart. Today's world. Okay, just tell me what to do. I got it. But I need you to demonstrate character, honesty, integrity, worth, the sense that I'm important, the sense that family is important, the sense that our community and our society is important. Which, you know, many years ago we tried to teach that into organizations and they just forget that. Today, those are far more interesting. People are interested in that because they're realizing that human beings are, especially in the North American workforce, human beings are looking for that kind of leadership because you can figure out how to get it done so efficiently in today's world. I don't need you to tell me how to get it done. I need you to support me in the doing of it. That's what I need. And therefore, I need to trust you. So trust is kind of like the currency of the age. Why how can I trust you? Well, you demonstrate integrity and character and honesty and empathy. Okay, now I trust you, so help me do this. And then I then I will literally, then the the guy I worked for the the last career before I went to this one, he was phenomenal. We would do anything for him. I mean, not immoral or anything, but because we trusted him, because he cared for us. Now he was ruthless and he was a tough businessman. But because he cared, you'd say, okay, I feel safe to go out on the limb and do the best I can. I'm not gonna get my knuckles wrapped if I mess up. You're there to help me fix it. But you know, you're gonna tell me to fix it. That's fair. So I I come back to all of those values that you've asked about are manifested in the in the team member saying, I trust my leader. I trust you. And if you have trust, you can lead people a long, long, long ways. I remember I was in a situation once where a leader had to close a factory. And uh he was I'm gonna bring everybody together and tell them we're gonna close the factory in a year and why we have to do it. I said, That's ridiculous. Are you crazy? They're all gonna leave. He said, No, I'm gonna treat them like adults. They are adults. This is what I know. I know I'm gonna close it in a year. So I said, Okay, well, on your head be it. He brought them together and he said, Here's the situation, here's why I'm telling you now, here are the consequences if I don't close the factory. I really hope none of you leave. And if you do, I respect that and we'll give you a fair package. But I need you for the next year. The performance of the factory went up for that year. It was unfortunate. No way. I know it's a huge lesson for me. Huge. And I walked away and said, Wow, treat people like human beings and adults and maturely, and they will respond accordingly. It was it was a phenomenal thing for me to see. It was so foreign to me. But I learned again from that particular leader that he treated people with respect, he earned their trust. He didn't hide behind it, he didn't pretend something. He just said, Now I can't tell you everything legally, I but I can tell you what I can tell you, and I'll tell you. And people said, Okay, we got it. And we got that you need us, and when it's over, you'll look after us. Okay, we trust you. Amazing. So those kinds of leaders get the 80% that you guys said you, you know, you had when you found a great leader. So it's not magic. In other words, it's we're not talking about something that is abstract and can't be mastered. It begins with being willing to behave that way. You got to be willing, back to your example, Jason, where you were willing to do things that didn't benefit you. You got to be willing to earn the trust of your people, even if it means being more honest and more respectful and more transparent. But the payback is off the charts.
SPEAKER_01I love it. Mic drop on that one. I it is crazy. Trust is the ultimate. I mean, yeah. Well, we've I I've had those, I've had those um those jobs. There was a couple in particular that we would do anything for the owner or the manager, and it was uh, I mean, they really it was we all trusted them more than anything, and like we would do anything for for them, ethically, of course.
SPEAKER_00And how much easier is that for the owner just to behave as a leader because they're gonna be there, right? Like you're either gonna behave like a leader, don't, and then all that frustration is gone on the back of the right. Absolutely, you're so right. You are so you're not over in the group of the agents saying, Oh, I'm so tired of employees, they're the worst, right? You're over here going, Man, I love my team, we're crushing it. Yep, exactly, exactly. Love it. I've had both teams, I've had both of us. All right, well, you understand. Yeah, I've been I've stood in both groups, right?
SPEAKER_01Well, cool, Phil. This has been absolutely phenomenal. We don't want to, I know we started a little late, so I don't want to take too much of your time, but like, how can people get a hold of you? What's your what's it what's the info?
SPEAKER_00And you gotta tell them about the the new book, yeah, or the most recent book.
SPEAKER_03Well, I've written several. Uh, there's a new one coming out from Forbes, uh, which will be in I think July, middle of July. The best way to get a hold of me is philgeld.com. I've got a website, it's all there. Uh, I run a company, but I've also got a website because people tend to want to say, well, what do you do and how do you do it? And I can point them to the company. So philgeldart.com, thank you for asking me. And so do I qualify here as an insurance dude. Oh, all right. It's a privilege, and I appreciate it.
SPEAKER_00I am gonna pick up in search of the gold of the desert kings. I'm very interested in that. Okay, we hope you enjoy it. Well, cool. Thank you, Phil. It's been amazing to have you on. It was a pleasure. It was a pleasure, fun to chat. Thanks a lot. Thank you.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman