The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Expert Leadership Advice With Phil Geldart PART 1
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
Hi, my name is Phil, and let me just tell you a wild story here. Before I recognize myself as an insurance dude, which is great. The uh, you know, we are we're a company that does experiential learning, which means we have all kinds of very cool stuff which we ship out. You got 150 people, they're all waiting for a great session, and we're there, and we did a session in the Bahamas, and we were ready to go. We opened the door to get to the boxes, and the boxes weren't there. Okay, how in the world can we have 150 people in the next three hours go through an experience that requires a ton of stuff? So, what we did is we took all our facilitators and they scoured the island for those little cute little umbrella thingies, those little pink umbrellas. They scoured the island for slices of lime and lemon, and we ran an experience around negotiation where all the things that you were negotiating for were slices of lemons, slices of lime, little pink umbrellas. And the participants thought it was fantastic because they thought that's exactly the way we customized it for the Bahama Islands. So it was a great experience. We fortunately avoided getting sued, but it was a lot of fun.
SPEAKER_00Wow, boom! I'm an experience, I'm an insurance dude. I get it, I get it.
SPEAKER_03You are, dude. I I love that. First off, that had to be very stressful. Um, but I love how like the like did they even question whether or not that that was they they said how how cool is that?
SPEAKER_01Man, we're in the Bahamas and everything is themed around the Bahamas. And we thought, you fold me you knew.
SPEAKER_04It's funny, like how we internalize and think that you know, if something changes, it doesn't go to plan that uh that oh no, it's wrecked, right? But a lot of times they have no idea, right? They have no clue. It's like a band, like a group, you know, the guitarist will say, Oh, I missed so many notes, and nobody noticed. Yeah, right. Maybe the drummer did because they're paying attention, but that's fun.
SPEAKER_03So I I would love to know, Phil. I'd like to know a little bit more about your company, but how did you get where you're at? What took you there from diapers to now?
SPEAKER_01Yeah well, I did a lot of Christian ministry in my youth, which meant I was working with kids, and kids and teenagers and college kids were all uh absolutely deaf on anything that was learning and boring, and sit in a class and kind of figure stuff out that way. And I when I went to university, I hated it as well. I just hated being lectured at. So I thought there's got to be a better way to teach people things and came up with what you would consider games, but they're actually experiences, they're really fun. You trek across the desert or you're in the wild west or you're up in space somewhere, and you go through this game and you are yourself, you're working with a team of half a dozen people, and at the end, the facilitator says, So, how did you do? And they go, Well, you know, we actually didn't do that well. Well, that's exactly the way we are at work, and as a result, you can then debrief the way they performed in the game to draw learning out. So that became an incredibly powerful way to help people actually learn, uh, which then helped my career to go really well because I was all of a sudden like a super trainer because I had all these games that worked. So that was really good. And then I worked for a phenomenally great leader, and I learned a tremendous amount about leadership. So I could then integrate my ability to teach with his knowledge around leadership, put the two together and continued to get promoted, and ended up actually in charge of uh driving profit through people and a large organization's HR function. But I wanted to do more ministry, my kids and parents were getting older, so I left, which was like jumping off the Queen Mary to a little bitty rowboat and went to Eagle's Flight, where our focus became teach people how to be better using these games. And here I am. Super cool. Quite the story.
SPEAKER_04Well, no, so I'm sure that everybody listening is curious about like the games. I like because this is fascinating to me. I too struggled with sitting in class. I would either fall asleep or totally zone out and not remember anything that was said. And you might do that on this podcast, you know. But let's hope not. Yeah, so like if if my wife is talking, that will happen. Um, if you know, there's if Jason's talking, especially, especially when Jason's talking. So so how do you and and I and I totally understand the notion of of gamifying it, that makes it interesting, right? Especially to yeah, to the monkey mind. So how does that work?
SPEAKER_01Talk, talk, yeah, to yeah, let's talk about it. So let me just say the game and the debrief go hand in hand. So I can run this game for five very senior executives at the four seasons and debrief it against their reality, or I can run it for 5,000 salespeople in Vegas because the game is the same. The only difference is in Vegas, we theme it up, everybody's in costumes, we bring in live camels, whatever, but the learning is identical. So I'll give you up, I'll put you in the seat. You think, okay, I've I've registered for this uh training class, I gotta go. I hope my phone is charged because I'm gonna be bored to death. I'm gonna spend the day on the phone. And you walk in and it's like, wait a minute, what am I? On the table, there's a map, this this big map, there's pith helmets, there's envelopes with money in it. He go, I think I'm in the wrong class. The facilitator comes in and says, Ladies and gentlemen, good morning. We're gonna be crossing the vast and perilous desert today. And I go, What? I mean, a course on strategic planning. I don't I don't quite get this. So he said, now if look around, you've got uh tables of five, and you've got about a dozen tables in this room, and you're all in competition. And your goal is to leave home base, which you'll see at the bottom right-hand corner of your map, and go to the mountains, which is the top left-hand corner. And between home base and the mountains, there's some squares. And every day you just go from one square to the other. And in our world, uh day will feel kind of like about three minutes, and you'll have 25 days. So they go, Oh, all right, I gotta start at home base and basically go up to the mountains and come back. What's in the mountains? Well, there's gold, and the longer you stay in the mountains, the more gold you get. So, oh, and because this is a uh market economy, if you're the first team back, you'll get more for the gold you bring back than the second team than the third team. So people go, I got this, this is a race, no problem. You say now I've already won. Oh, yeah. Well, a couple things you need to know. Um, there's uh sandstorms in the desert, and there's superheat in the desert, and you'll starve and you'll die of thirst. So before you leave home base, you probably should buy some water, and you'll see there's money at the table there, and you probably should buy some food, and you probably should be aware of the fact that you need enough to survive sandstorms and superheat where you eat a lot more and drink a lot more. And between you and the mountains, there's a very mysterious tomb of kings. Can't tell you too much about it. We don't know very much about it, but uh people are a little nervous of that. And over here in the corner, there's a very old man. He's very, very old and he's very lonely, and he'll talk to you. But anything that you want to ask him, it'll take him about a day to tell you. Now remember, I told you at 25 days, I told you it was a race, and you want to talk to the old man, you got to stay at home base and talk to him. So it's kind of slow, but he's got good information about the desert. And people go, okay, we get it, and I think we got it, and there's lots of different routes. And in fact, if you take the most direct route to the mountains, it's six days up and six days back. You have 25 days, so you should be able to spend six plus six is 12, minus 25. You should be able to spend 13 days in the mountains. In fact, you can only spend 10 because you got a camel and a poor camel doesn't get overloaded. So 10 days in the mountains, 10 bars of gold is the optimum. All right. So people buy their stuff and off they go. What happens? About those people die in the desert. They never make it back. They run out of food, they run out of water.
SPEAKER_00Of the ones that make it back, you usually have them come back and celebrate, hey, we've made it, we survived, we got like four bars of gold, we're fantastic, we got four, four, or maybe even five bars of gold.
SPEAKER_01And we say, okay, so let's just take a look at this. You all started with the same resources, you all started with the same information, but some of you actually didn't make it, and some of you came back with four or five bars of gold and you celebrate. Ten were possible. Why didn't you get 10 bars of gold? And they begin to say, Well, we didn't know what was happening in the mountains. So, well, did you talk to the old man? Well, no, we didn't. Well, why didn't you? Well, because it takes time. I know, but you had the time. Oh, yeah, you're right. We actually didn't think about that. Did you avoid the two of kings? Oh, yeah. Well, the moment you avoid the tomb of kings, you can't get up in six days. It takes you eight days. So before you even started, you were committed to do less than optimum. Yeah, but we didn't know about that. Well, you could have had information. There was information available. Oh, yeah, we didn't think about that. So the debrief, which lasts about an hour and a half, they realize we play Gold of the Desert Kings just like we do on our real world. We rush out, we don't do our planning up front, we're afraid of the unknown, we don't use the information that's available to us, and we don't maximize because maximize is 10 bars of gold. It's like that was unbelievable. That's exactly okay. So, how would you like it if for the rest of the day I show you how to get 10 bars of gold at work? How do you get 10 bars of gold out of a podcast? How do you get 10 bars of gold out of a sales call? How do you get 10 bars of gold out of a marketing initiative? And it's not just willing to work hard and get going and get started. There are some things you can do, which, if you had done them in Gold of the Desert Kings, would exactly relate to your job. So that game, all of a sudden, people go, Well, that's not really a game at all. That's just a metaphor for the way I live. But they're highly engaged, they have a lot of fun, they listen to the debrief. And literally, I will walk through an airport with an Eagle Slight t-shirt on, and someone will come up to me and say, I played Gold of the Desert Kings 10 years ago, and I still remember. Talk to the old man, don't avoid the Tomb of Kings. So we have, you know, I don't know, four dozen of these games. So depending on what it is you want me to teach you, I pull out the game, you play the game, we do the debrief, and then we show you how to apply the debrief on the job. So cool.
unknownWow.
SPEAKER_03Talk about I from a marketing perspective, talk about a way to differentiate. Like, like that's your game, right? That's you like you created that, right? Yep, yeah. And the game is his game.
SPEAKER_01The game is that's right. That's the game he plays. That's right, all the time. It's a game for so thanks for asking. But it's fun, you know, it makes learning so much more fun. People they they just love it because they go, I, you know, the whole point of learning, if you want people to be more accountable, if you want people to be better influencers, it's not about what you tell them, it's what they believe. You have to first build conviction. So, how do you build conviction? Oh, nice hat says believe on that. Nice. So you can't build conviction by lecturing someone. You can only build conviction by putting them in a situation where they perform in a certain way and they draw their own conclusions and realize there's a better way. Once you have conviction, your soil is tilled, and now you can put the seed in. So the game lets me build conviction. So then I can put the seed of here are the things to do differently. So that's why it's so powerful when you actually bring this into an organization, it actually changes the behavior.
SPEAKER_04I think, or it seems like it would also really lower their defenses, right? Like they come in and they're like, Oh, I don't want to talk to like I know how I am when I go to a place. Like, I'd like I don't want to talk to anybody. Oh, I'll tell Jason I gotta go, I'm gonna go to the room and hang out for a second. I need to, you know. And so there's always some way you you know, it's anxiety if social anxiety, a bunch of people you don't know, everybody kind of gets awkward, like the hiking dance or whatever. But then now there's a game, all of a sudden you're laughing, you're having fun, yeah, and now you're all best friends, and so you're in, you're engaged, right? Because you're you're turned on, and now not in that way, Jason. And now, yeah, you get that. That's exactly right. That is exactly right. It's so powerful, and then they're gonna listen to the part that they normally wouldn't listen to, which was the actual lecture, in a way, right? Yeah, because they're involved. It's like it's like assessing somebody with a personality assessment. Like, nobody wants to read about behaviors or whatever, but then if they take the test, they're like, Oh, I want the result, I want to read about this. It's me. Yeah, cool.
SPEAKER_03Man, I love that. Yeah, and even on a lower level, it I mean, how many times do we we talk? We always talk about our you know, our teams and our sales teams and having meetings all the time, but um what a great way to engage like a like a small sales team, just throw them off at the beginning, put them in a situation where they're all kind of working on something and and it's well actually, Jason, you too.
SPEAKER_01If we run a sales training program, sometimes it'll run for five days, we might have six different ones of those. One talks about ethics and how you're how you're perceived, one talks about partnership. So all the topics that your salesperson needs to master are buried in these games, and they just go, like, that's fantastic. I learned about partnership by going into the old less. I learned about making sure that my integrity is high by slipping out into the the days of King Arthur. It's just yet everyone is it's just compelling.
SPEAKER_03That's so cool. What are some tips that you would give some insurance agents that have a smaller property casualty insurance agency, like uh, you know, like the state farms, farmers? Um, I can't even say the one that we're with because legally they'll um chop our heads off in the in the desert. But yeah, what would I say to them about what? About um sales, like like just about managing our teams, like what are some what are some tips that you would give uh an agency owner leading their team?
SPEAKER_01So I would say think of the worst person you ever worked for, which they can do pretty quickly. Yeah. And so, okay, now what value did you bring to the organization working for that person? Not how hard you worked or how committed you were, but against your potential, what value? Pick a number from one to ten. So they would think of that number. You guys can do that right now. And I said, Okay, now think of the best person you ever worked for. Right? What value did you bring working for that person? Pick a number and subtract the two. So typically, you guys want to give me a number? What numbers would you give me?
SPEAKER_03I would say a one and like a nine.
SPEAKER_01All right. So there's an eight-point difference. Okay, so there's an 80% increase in value, and all I did was change your leader. So you think I'm gonna pay you, it doesn't cost me any more. You're you're a fixed cost. So why did I get 80% more value out of you from one leader to the other? It's because the great leader valued you, saw you as having worth, they saw your potential, they listened to you, they gave you an opportunity to contribute, they gave you an opportunity to bring all that you were to the job, what we call the sandbox. They gave you a big enough sandbox that you could do this. So if you say to me, what one bit of advice would I give to someone managing an insurance team, I would say you've got to understand whether or not you are fully releasing the potential of your employees. Because I will tell you right now, without ever talking to any of them, if I ask them that question and I go and say, okay, let me talk to your subordinates, your people, the team, your team, without exception, that team would say, I could contribute more. I could contribute more. So the question is, why don't they? It's not because the leader maliciously wakes up in the morning and says, Oh, how can I just make it really miserable with these people trying to impose my will on them and be the autocratic idiot? They just do not know how to be that great leader that you guys had. So if I can teach them here's what a great leader does to release the potential of the workforce, then your workers come and bring you things that they would never bring you: ideas, commitment, innovation, support, teamwork, all the things that you ask for. It all comes back to the quality of my leader. So most of the time I say, you know, if you're not happy with your team, you probably should go look in the mirror. It's not that your team doesn't want to be more, it's that you don't know how. And I don't fault you for that. It's not like you're an idiot. You're probably great, you probably sell a lot of insurance and you probably manage your team adequately. But are you managing it at a world-class level? Well, no, that's where the money is.
SPEAKER_03Gosh, such a theme today. I we I was just talking to one of our teams with Craig about uh something that I've been doing recently and every day uh reminding myself for my quarterly goals, and one of them is to connect more with my family, and one of the one of the ways to do so is to uh and I have it written down, I go over this every morning, is serve my family with zero expectation, which is a hard thing. I mean, it's a really hard thing to do. So, like every opportunity, serve them and don't be disappointed if you get nothing in return whatsoever, which you know, there's you know, a bunch of micro situations that normally I you know would want something in return. But I've been doing this now for a couple weeks, and it's it's paid me back like tenfold of anything that I would have expected, which is crazy, right? So just that little shift, and it's exactly what you're saying here. It's it's showing up and it's uh uh essentially serving your team with zero in return.
SPEAKER_01What you are doing is demonstrating the worth of the other person, and they are responding to that, which is and this is the way we want to be treated. We want our work now. I will, you didn't ask me this, but I'm just gonna jump in here. There is a Latin term called equal onus. Onus means burden or weight. So if you think about, I mean, I just talked about the importance of the leader, but there is an equal burden or an equal weight on the employee, in my mind, in my judgment, that they have got to step up and take the initiative. They have got to have the courage of their convictions, they have to speak what's on their mind, they have to ask questions, they have to demonstrate integrity, they have to behave in a way that reflects the fact that I'm honoring you for your potential. Okay, well, then demonstrate your potential. You can't just sit back. It's not a one-way street. So I think one of the things, and people don't quite understand this often, one of the things a great leader will do is sit down and say, look, I will treat you with respect, but I have expectations. And the expectations is you give me all that you can. And if if there's something that I'm doing that's inhibiting that, you tell me. But I am expecting you to bring your full self to the party. And I think that that second half is important. And in my experience, people respond to that. They go, Great. I I'm not I'm not adverse to it, but the fact that you have articulated it and demonstrated that you do expect me to perform to my fullest is a challenge, and I will raise that. Now, I'm expecting you to be a great leader, but collectively we'll change the world. But you do need both sides of the coin, I think.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, that communication is so important, and it's that's the proactive communication on the same subject that you would be coming negatively saying, Hey, you're not doing it, right? Nobody wants to hear I'm not doing it. So it's just being out ahead of it. And I was thinking to Jason's deal, it's all about that intention behind it, right? Like you had a you had a different intention behind it, not in it. I I didn't help her because I wanted to be able to, you know, go go to the events or whatever, right? Thank you. No, I didn't say the other, or the other one that happens with every in a lot of relationships, which is it, I did I did the dishes hoping that right, and and that that'll never work, right? Because now you're gonna be disappointed a lot of the time. And and instead, if the intention is, I my intention is just to serve, I think the energy behind that intention creates the perception that they have of how you're doing it, right?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and and I think the if I can understand, I don't want to speak for you, Jason. But your motivation was not to benefit yourself, it was to benefit them. And without that motivation, it looks manipulative. Yeah, you're pure pure of heart, so to speak. And without that, you go, Oh, well, that's really good. I'll just pretend like everybody's more important than me. That won't work. You you went there and said, I have no expectation, and therefore, that purity of intention, what I would call integrity, you know, your your character was what people saw and responded to more than your actions.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, yeah, definitely. I I could see that it and it's funny too, because it's like it's always like little, it's subtleties, right? It's like uh just being disappointed, it's maybe a little mad after something. Well, why didn't you do this? Like to something else, right? It comes out at a different time about something else, but like it won't come out at a different time about something else because you literally let it go and there was nothing built up. It's it's funny how like parallel this is, but I definitely agree with you. And when it comes to uh business in a workplace, there has to be an agreement of why we're giving you right, it's a two way street. I definitely think of that.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman