The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Growth and Mentorship Navigation with Brandan Keegan PART 2
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
Yeah, one of the things I always say is, you know, building something complex is pretty easy. Building something simple is very hard. Yeah. You know, simplifying, like if you're if you if you are, you know, responsible for insurance claims at your company and you got to develop a process for how we're going to do it, building this complex process is pretty easy. Right. But but saying, wait, I want to simplify this so anybody can come in and work in the back end of my business. And and I can I can use this as a rotating job and bring you know young people in, and then they can step up. That's actually much harder. It you have to put a lot more thought into it, you have to put more governance into it, you got to put more um guardrails. And it's like, oh, this is really hard.
SPEAKER_00They fail more than anybody.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, they'll they'll tell you, oh yeah, you know, I closed 10 deals. I I pursued a hundred. Right. And I closed. And then there's somebody else that's like, wow, I only pursued 20. And you wonder why, you know, you sold a third. You know, you know, Michael Jordan talks about, you know, I hit X number of game winners, but here's how many I took. But those are people that got to to to greatness. But, you know, like like if if the three of us said, hey, let's go skiing for a weekend, and we all said, Hey, let's really push ourselves. I want to be a better skier. Well, if I never push myself, never fall, never go down a black diamond because I just don't want to fall and I don't, then I'm probably not really getting better. Right, right. Which is by the way, if I say I don't want to be better, that's fine. But if I say no, I actually want to become an expert skier. I want to become, um, I want to be able to be as good as my kids now as they're getting older. Well, then you're gonna have to sign up for, I might, you know, I'm probably gonna fall a couple of times today. I'm gonna try to to to do to do better. I'm gonna go on some tougher, I'm gonna challenge myself a little bit more. But, you know, sometimes we're just protective of ourselves. But, you know, in companies, you know, I look to leaders and say, are you creating a culture that allows um failure? And if you are in in and you talk about it, then you start to pull away fear. And I will tell you, if you're able to do that, you will grow faster because employees have so many unbelievable ideas, like just crazy good ideas, but they won't bring them forward if the feeling is if it works, it's great. And if it's not, I could I could lose my job, I could get in trouble. Um, that's gonna take me off the promotion list. Uh what whatever, then you know, you're gonna have a big percent not bring those ideas forward.
SPEAKER_00Yep. A lot of businesses are a fear-based organization, right? Absolutely, absolutely. That is not healthy.
SPEAKER_04No, it it's not. And what it does is it it breeds it then, you know, and then next thing you know, you'll hear things like, Yeah, you know, we tried that a few years ago, I wouldn't even bring it up. Okay, well, yeah. Well, if you tried it a few years ago, well, you know, well, let's take the business I'm in. Well, we tried that a few years ago. Well, if you tried telematics 10 years ago, it probably didn't work. If you tried electric fleets five years ago, there weren't as many chargers. So, but if you said we're just not gonna try this electrification thing, we tried it before, it didn't work. Well, for 10 years, 10 years you're gonna be left behind. You know, it's it's like it's it's like blockbuster not thinking streaming was gonna catch on.
SPEAKER_00Insane, right? Like, how do they not catch that? Like, and then eventually, right? Yeah, a little late.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, way late.
SPEAKER_00I saw the like I saw this meme, and it was uh it was a guy um in a very like one of the first cars, like a Model T or Model A or whatever it was, and he's on there, and then there's a guy look like looking up at him pointing, and he says, Yeah, but where are you gonna go and fill that thing up with gas? You can't do it like with a horse where you can just stop and and let the horse eat, you know. I almost spilled my water, yeah. But uh, it's funny, it's like you got to just be ahead of it.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, I mean, just you know, let's think back, I don't know, three years ago when there wasn't email, you know. You know, you know, in our uh we used to have um I know I know I know some of your listeners don't know this, but we had little floppy drives and little three and a half inch drives, and we saved our stuff on that and we walked around. You know, here's an iPhone that has more storage on probably any computer I had till what 2000, right?
SPEAKER_00Probably like more than the whole office building all put together, you know, it's crazy.
SPEAKER_04But but if you had this mental model of, hey, well, that's not gonna work, because you we weren't staying up with with with technology, technology is a great disruptor in in our society, you know, it in an enabler that allows us to do things, then you know, then business is gonna pass you by, you know, other companies are gonna are gonna pass you by.
SPEAKER_00So yeah, so you have people that are raised in this environment where they're where they're indoctrinated into into self-doubt, they're they go to work in a fear-based place. Like, how do you break them? Like you're the leader. Now it's your role to break that cycle.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, you know, it it really starts with just changing your mindset. And and, you know, again, I go back to that saying, have the courage to fail, faith to succeed. It's it's you know, finding, you know, where are you comfortable? Everyone has some space in their life where they are very comfortable. Um, you know, for for somebody, it could be video gaming. It's like, hey, I'm I'm I'm a risk taker when I'm video gaming. For another person, it could be a casino. Like, oh, all of a sudden they're this buttoned down person in the office and they never take a risk. They go to a casino and they they take a risk. You know, another person could be a hobby, you know, they're they're buttoned down at the office, they don't take risks, and they're a skydiver. So it's like everyone's got it in them. It's how do you bring that person out? How do you bring that person out to more dimensions of your of your life? And and and I think that's where it's it's finding that fearlessness inside all of us. We all have it. We were born with it. It's just channeling it. And sometimes if you're in an organization that really is fear-based, sometimes the answer is, you know, I probably need to go someplace else.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_04Uh and and and that that's okay. That's okay to say, if I want to get to where I want to go, if I want to um, you know, be in a more open-minded, this isn't gonna work here. That is perfectly okay.
SPEAKER_00How about the alter, the other side? You're the leader, they come and work at you. You have the right place, but now this person has really been beat down because of the way that it works. How do you help them?
SPEAKER_04Yeah, that's where, you know, you know, patiently coaching them up, mentoring them, leading them, um, you know, giving examples like tangible examples of program of other companies where it's worked. Uh, what I love now is so many uh colleges and universities have these things called like micro-credentials. You can go online, $500, $800. Um, sometimes it's even less. Sometimes it's freeware, uh, where you can take uh you can take a program on design thinking, you can take one on innovative thinking. And by the way, uh I've I've I've done a a number of these, and what I find at the end of them when they're done well is that was pretty simple stuff. That wasn't rocket science. Like, and you sit there and go, wait, I I just did that for six hours, and the only things I got I took away were A, B, and C. But what if you step back, don't be disappointed that they only taught you three things. What you should realize is I only have to do these three things to be more innovative. I only have to do these three things to communicate better, or or you know, whatever you happen to be to be focused on. And and you know, I try to take one of those every year and I try to move it around. And you know, a couple of years ago I took one on innovation, and I'm like, yeah, you know, it's it's it's it I think we all think of the big innovations. We think of the Teslas of the world, the Apple uh iPods of the world. And sure, those are big innovations and those get the headlines, but I mean, there's literally innovations around every single corner. Like if you opened up your pantry, there's innovations in food. If you opened up uh your garage, there's innovations in your garage door opener and how it works. And you know, hey, how can I get this on an app now? Um, wireless technology, they're everywhere. You just have to say, where am I gonna, where am I gonna bring my my innovative self, my fearless self out to play? And how am I gonna make my mark on the world?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. And it's funny too, because like I think when you're young, you you get taught uh about invention a lot. So everybody's trying to come up with like the new idea, the new thing where it's like innovation is really where things happen. Like, like most of like even the automobile was like a was an innovation in a sense where you know it took multiple, you know, the gas steam engine and like put it with wheels. And then like it wasn't it was more in even Ford, Ford. I mean, the cars were around, he just came out with a way that hey, we can actually make these mass produce them. So it's like innovation's really where it's at. And it's just taking a couple common ideas, sticking them together and presenting it. And I I I think that like I love what you said about the simplicity factor too, because I love what um uh Leonardo uh Da Vinci said, where like simplicity is the ultimate sophistication, and it truly is. Like even in my life in the last year, Craig can attest to this too. Like a lot of the stuff that we're not doing. Anyway, I'm not gonna bore you in any way in our business and stuff like that. It just got real complex. And when you're you're in a complex state, it's really hard to be um to have any kind of creativity. It's kind of hard to to have any kind of like growth within that. And really peeling it away from going down to simplicity makes things uh easy. I mean, it makes you be able to explore, like to your point, if you did the class, you learned three different things. I mean, the three things are gonna have uh you're gonna have you know thousands of thoughts about those three things and really be able to grow on them. Where if it was a thousand things, you'd forget about most of them.
SPEAKER_04And yeah, one of the things I always say is, you know, building something complex is pretty easy. Building something simple is very hard. Yeah. You know, simplifying like if you if you're if you if you are you know responsible for insurance claims at your company and you got to develop a process for how are we gonna do it, building this complex process is pretty easy, right? But but saying, wait, I want to simplify this so anybody can come in and work in the back end of my business and and I can I can use this as a rotating job and bring you know young people in and then they can step up, that's actually much harder. It you have to put a lot more thought into it, you have to put more governance into it, you got to put more um guardrails, and it's like, wow, this is really hard, but just having it be leaving it complex is is easy. And and and I think that's where you know I look at people who have had repeatable success, you know, in different industries, repeatable success over a long period of time. Generally speaking, they've been pretty iterative, they've been willing to change, um, they've been innovative. But if you go, if you say to them, what makes you great? They're gonna tell you some like, hey, I do these, uh, you know, Kobe Bryant, you know, I get up early, I go to the gym, I outwork my competition. You know, it's like you're like, that's the secret.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_04He would tell you, yes, it is. It is. And you're you're you you think it's you know, some elaborate plan he's got, and it it's not. It's it's just a few simple things done well.
SPEAKER_00Activity and consistency, right?
SPEAKER_04Yeah, yeah. Consistency is another big part. You know, we talk about simplicity, you know, you you then you need consistency with it. And you know, you you talked about, you know, Ford, that's what he brought with the assembly line. The assembly line, you know, made the vehicle easier to produce, faster to produce, less expensive produce, but a consistent product because people were doing repetitive things, which allowed them to become more as it was simpler, it allowed them to become more consistent and perform at a higher level.
SPEAKER_01Yep. Gosh, and I want to bring this back full circle. So with that concept of simplicity and and uh in leadership, and you've had a successful career of not only your your life or your uh your jobs, but also like your life, kids, you're still married. Um, what has been the uh part of the one percent? What has allowed all of that to work, especially with the ambitious uh career that you've had?
SPEAKER_04Yeah, what I'd tell you is I uh I I when I was I can tell you I was 28 years old, I got given an executive coach, and the executive coach sat me down and said, Brennan, you know, I I got this 360 report on you, and here's what I can tell you. He tells me all these things, and he said, you know, we really need to work on your EQ. And at the time, I was like, you know, what's EQ? And he said, emotional intelligence. And he said, you know, you it appears that you you've got the IQ to get where you want to go. It appears you've got the drive and you're personable. And I'm sitting there 28 thinking, like, hey, this guy's nailing it. I'm I'm the man. And then all of a sudden he hits me, all of a sudden he hits me with, I don't see you having a great career until you can in and conquer EQ. Because the difference between where you're at and where you want to go is is, you know, um, you know, like I was a very aggressive leader, like, hey, we're gonna go take the hill, you know, and it was like take the hill at no whatever cost. Um and and you know, I was more focused on my team's goals than maybe the company's goals at the time, you know, just different things that come with a little bit of of youth and ambition. And and I can tell you, I think what's helped me over the last say 20 years is is EQ realizing that, you know, hey, what happens today isn't gonna define me. Um, today's failure isn't gonna define me. Today's success isn't gonna define me either, you know. And I think we've had people that had a big success in their career and you know, they became all that, and they they read their press clippings and maybe got you know a big head and stuff. And you know, and as you're raising kids, you realize your kids, your your kids are gonna have wins and losses and and successes and failures. And how do you build them so that they're theirs? Because as a parent, and I saw it, like I coached foot uh sports for 10 years. I saw all these parents that really wanted to, you know, come take their kids' challenges on. It's like, wait, what do your kids advocate for themselves? There's nothing stronger than somebody advocating. But so for me, uh I would tell you that, you know, I I really uh I I've said this a thousand times. I wish I had that executive coach's name so I could write them a thank you once a year. But somebody catching me at a young age saying, you know, you've got all the IQ, you got all the potential, right? As a lot of people do, but you got to work on your EQ if you really want to like endure for the long term. And as a parent, man, it's way more EQ than IQ, right? Um, it's just way more EQ. Like we we all have the IQ to to you know tell the kids what's right and wrong, but yeah, we have the EQ to like help them uh navigate situations that like you didn't know you were gonna have to navigate. Um, and you know, and when do you let something slide and go, I'm not gonna get on them for everything, you know, right? And when when do you not? And to me, that's not that's not IQ. That that that that's EQ. And so I I think um, you know, it's uh if you want to have a a long, successful career, if uh a good marriage, a good parent, good community person, you know, having that balance. And I think uh EQ really, really uh, at least for me, has been something I've worked at. And I say worked at is that you never stop working on it.
SPEAKER_00It's a practice.
SPEAKER_04It is like you know, like again, I mentioned earlier, social media has brought in a whole new uh revelation of of you know, well, how do you handle that? How do you handle like not being invited? All your friends are at a party and you're sitting there going, well, it looks like they're having fun, you know, and you go, Hey, no problem. Yeah, you know, just how do you how do you handle all that? And I think EQ is the is a is a great differentiator if you have high aspirations.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, 100%. I'd I'd love to piggyback off that uh too with identity. So you talked about like having the successes and the non-successes and and you know, like how have you dealt with that throughout your career is being you you know, your identity as being a leader, as being a CEO, and then your identity is be coming home and and being the father that's supposed, you know, having that EQ and be able to withhold because there's like two, I I I feel like it's two different roles, right? When you're at work, you're on it. And when you're like at home, you you gotta listen. Like the the more you can shut up and just listen to everybody in the household, like the better job you do, you know.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, I gotta tell you, you know, I I I think I learned more about I've learned more about my kids uh driving them to sports when they've got their kids in the when they got their friends in the car than anything. Like I love driving because like sometimes I'd be like they're in the back seat, you know, you're driving down the road, and you're like, they have they have no real idea that I'm actually in this vehicle with them.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and and certainly you're not listening, right?
SPEAKER_04Like you're talking about their coach, you're talking about their school, they're talking about what they're gonna do, what they're not gonna do. And and I just think those are precious moments. Like if you take it in, if you take it in by and by the way, don't participate, right? Just take it in.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah, it's like fly on the wall, you get to see the real stuff, right? Like seeing them interact with their friends like little humans when and you know, especially like teens, what they start saying they're like insightful stuff and the way they behave, it's so interesting, yeah. Because it's different, right? It's you don't see that when you're just with them. Nope. No, it's pretty, it's pretty interesting. So for those of you with young kids, including Jason, like more of that, it's it's it is pretty fascinating, like as they as they get older.
SPEAKER_04And they and and and and this is everyone listening knows this, but and they get older quick, yeah, they get older quick. It's it's uh just you know, it you know, it's it's it's uh cherish like every moment you have with them. And yeah, it's something no matter how big your job, no matter how busy you are, you're never too busy for your family. You're just never, never too busy for your family. Just make that decision.
SPEAKER_00My son Kenzo is taking a gap year, he's in a van driving around the country doing climbing, like climbing, you know, doing mountain climbing. Yeah, and so um we're by ourselves now, it's freaking weird. Two of the two of the animals died, like we have one dog, and and my wife and I, and it's just bizarre, you know, it's like so quiet, yeah. So I mean you know the same thing.
SPEAKER_01So and now she gets to be annoyed with you because you're around all the time.
SPEAKER_00Well, see, the thing is she does, but then she tells me to go away and then I can do what I want. So it all works out. Well, we didn't even we didn't talk too much on on the FUD. So before we wrap up, why don't you talk about the FUD factor? Just give us give us that that in the details and the juiciness on that.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, so what I'd say it's really written for anybody, you know. I've got lots of stories in there from um from a high school kid that wanted to play Division I lacrosse, got recruited to play at Rutgers, and tells his story to uh to Zach Brown at McLaren Racing, who talks about how he came in when McLaren was at ninth and and you know, the worst they had been in McLaren's history, bringing them up to fourth. And then tons of stories in between of just you know common people that overcame their fears or overcame organizational fears and and and got that got their themselves, their their friends, their company uh to a different level. Um, and then through there, I I give very, I believe is very pragmatic, practical advice of how to do it. And you know, I have a few stories in there on myself, but I try to bring stories just that people can relate to again from a from a young lacrosse player to you know the CEO of an iconic company. And uh it's it's a short read. It's it's pretty easy read. And um, and it's uh it's really meant, it's not targeted at one particular uh age group or audience or level. It's it's uh you know, it was harder to write that way, but really targeted for you know an 18-year-old or a 50-year-old, you know, somebody wants to be better, somebody who's maybe stuck saying, like, what do I how do I get past this? And somebody that just um really is an emerging leader as well. Like, okay, I'm an emerging leader, I know I got to learn some things. What you know, what do I do? So pretty simple, straightforward, and then uh hopefully a fun read as well. Awesome.
SPEAKER_00Love it. You can find it on Amazon. Uh, we'll we'll throw the link in the show notes. Uh so hopefully that'll get some people over there grabbing that book. You can get it. There's a hardcover, there's a Kindle version, and you can do it, Jason. Audio book. I love it. Did you read it? Did I read it? Yeah, did you read the I mean was it for the audio version?
SPEAKER_04Oh no, I did not. No, I did not. I know you read the book because you wrote that. Yeah, I was like, that's a weird.
SPEAKER_00I didn't realize he was this unintelligent. Well, perfect. Hey, thank you so much, Brendan, Brendan, for coming on the show. It was awesome. Uh, a little little technical stuff at the beginning, but I'm glad that it worked out and it was awesome, man.
SPEAKER_04All right. Hey, you guys are great. Thanks for doing this. And and uh, you know, I I enjoy your audience and I enjoy your show. Thanks so much. Thank you so much. Thank you. Appreciate it.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman