The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Growth and Mentorship Navigation with Brandan Keegan PART 1
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
So the wildest thing I ever saw happen at an insurance agent agency is when I was running a 10,000 unit fleet and the insurance agency came out. They sat down with me and they said, based on the driving skills of your 10,000 drivers, you are uninsurable. And took off and I needed to find a new broker. We had a lot of bad drivers, a lot of bad drivers, a lot of accidents. And uh so that was uh that was the craziest thing I saw was finding out that we had a company that size that was uninsurable.
SPEAKER_02Oh that is crazy. Well, why don't you introduce yourself to everybody?
SPEAKER_00Yeah. So my name is Brennan Keegan. Uh I'm an insurance dude and I run merchants fleet.
SPEAKER_03Oh right.
SPEAKER_00Wow. Was there a gap? You know what here's here's what it was. Like we had uh we had 10,000 drivers out there, and they were bad drivers. All of them.
SPEAKER_03All of them.
SPEAKER_00That's a lot of bad drivers all in one place. Here's the thing like at the company, like we reported everything as an accident. If there was a fender banner that got reported as an accident, when in reality probably shouldn't have reported that as an accident. So it just it was just uh the mod rate was high, we were uninsurable. We actually um had to self-insure for two years, improve and uh and then and then go back to market. So pretty crazy. So let me ask.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, go for it. You self-insured a 10,000. I mean, I guess I guess that's what count a lot of counties and cities will end up doing, right? Because they have the big coffers, but still it's a lot of risk, especially if there's 10,000 bad drivers.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, we have to we have to post a lot of money up. It was it was uh it was a big challenge. We we got it, we got it under control. We went back, and uh, I can tell you one thing we did. We uh in the company I ran out, Merchants Fleet, we we're a commercial fleet company. We got 200,000 uh vehicles on the road, and we're big fans of telematics. We want to pro we want to proactively know, hey, what hey, what are those, what are the drivers doing on the road? How can we prevent it? Create a point system, you get so many points for being uh hard braking, speeding, whatever, you know, and and you're out, you're out. So, but we didn't have telematics uh back when I just told that story.
SPEAKER_04We happen to know a few large carriers that really are into uh telematics. Can you name them? No, actually, I'm not oh, you can't name one of them, yeah. So uh yeah. But uh it's interesting though, because we'll I mean, we as agents hear a lot about telematics, and usually it's like uh maybe with a little apprehension from some of the agent force out there, but like from your angle, especially having that many drivers, wow, how valuable that can be for you.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, well, you know, I've got uh I'm just thinking, you know, one one of my clients, they drive um uh you know big F 250s and they're they're they're pulling things, pretty pretty heavy things. And every week she'll get a report of you know all the bad drivers, and every week she'll have somebody trailering over 100 miles an hour. Wow, yeah, you know, and that's just you know, that's that's just not good. And and and there's so many use cases for telematics and in driver behavior, and ultimately it's it's you know, the the the companies want their drivers to be safe, but they also want the people on the road where they're driving to be safe. And um, I'm pretty confident that the uh the insurance agencies, you know, want that out there. You know, it's uh it's a lot less risk to to insure. But yeah, the telematics, you know, you get it you get an exception report every morning at 8 a.m. comes in, tells you all the uh all the bad things that some of your drivers did.
SPEAKER_02Dude, I mean a truck, a two an F250 pulling something going 100 is like a death machine, like that thing is just whatever it hits is gonna die.
SPEAKER_00And and here's what's crazy it happens weekly, and they know there's a telematics device in the in the truck, and they still do it.
SPEAKER_02Well, it's because they've already drank five beers by then, so then it doesn't they don't care anymore. I don't know, but uh yeah, that's pretty insane. Um now just uh hopefully Elon's not listening to this, but I know that with the telematics, there are ways of there are ways to beat it, right? There's like ways to game it, like hard breaking. Then you just you end up, you know, you could drive through the neighborhood and go like get get get up to speed and then like just drag the braking out so that so what do you know that Greg? Huh? And how do you I have the Tesla app and I have to because I get you know I know that I have a hard break, so I have to fix them. That's why I hope Elon's not listening. Hypothetically speaking, of course. Yeah, yeah. Yeah, have you caught any of that? Have you caught it?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, oh there's heartbreaking, there's idling, you know, um, and uh, you know, getting off the a little bit of the with the telematics device. One of my favorite applications is uh, you know, one of our clients, you know, they get the report every day, and at the end of the day, they send it to HR. And you know, I was asking, well, you know, uh, help me understand why do you send this to HR? They go, well, you know, a lot of our guys are contractors and some aren't the most honest, and they put their time cards in every day and they say, you know, I work till five, but yet the truck left the job site at 115. Or, you know, and and then idling, you know, um, you know, idling is a big thing. Just uh, you know, emissions is is something our clients are really focused on, and you know, heavy idling times when did the vehicle need to be idling? And and and that will report back. But you know, there's the the speeders, the the people that aren't where they're supposed to be, then there's route optimization, just getting people to where they need to be faster. And and then there's uh you know, hard breaking, um, speeding, and then just uh just just little things like idling, which is more you know environmental and and you know what's best for the vehicle, what's best for for for usage.
SPEAKER_02Crazy. So I'm assuming you didn't start your career with 200,000 uh vehicles rolling on the road. Yeah, take us back to the humble beginnings, like what where you where you found your passion and and and kind of walk us through that experience.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so say if I took you back like high school, college, I always um I always liked student government. Um, you know, always liked uh kind of uh being in the student government, uh what went to an engineering school, learned how to program. I liked program, I liked technology, and I started at a company uh that Ross Perot founded back in the day called EDS. I was a programmer. Oh you know, and and what's funny is after a couple of years they said, hey Brennan, we really think you're good with people. Now, what I didn't ask at 23 was does that mean I'm not good at coding? Which I I I I really want to go back and ask them because I I I think I think they put a period at the end of the statement, you're really good with people when it should have been a comma because you're not as good at coding or present there. Yeah. Yeah. But uh, you know, so so then, you know, I started my leadership journey and and you know, from there on, I've uh, you know, I'm uh actually today is my 26th wedding anniversary, and I've been a CEO, president CEO now for 24 years. And really, really like leadership's my passion, just uh going into companies and and helping people uh grow, develop, uh, you know, attracting good talent. Now, but the way I got to merchants, what's interesting about that is you know that 10,000-person client, uh, the 10,000 fleet? That was 2009. I was actually merchant's largest client at the time. Wow. And then, and then um, you know, being more from the technology side than the vehicle side, you know, they asked me to join their board and help them build out the technology at the company. And the only warning I'd give your listeners out there is, you know, hey, if you're a board member and you keep making lots of suggestions and you kind of bug them enough, eventually they say, Hey, buddy, you think you think you got all the answers, you think you're so smart, why don't you come run the place? Right. And and uh then then you do, then you do, and and here I am.
SPEAKER_04Super cool. It is funny, like um how synonymous like leadership is with I mean, you being married for so long, like that's that is a leadership role that's probably even harder.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I would say my wife has a harder side of that of that journey. But uh, do you have kids? I do, I do a 19 and 21 year old. So so uh it's been fun watching their journeys.
SPEAKER_02You are one year it in all three things past me. So I'm 25 years married. I have my son is 18, and my daughter is well, my daughter's 22. So, yeah, yeah. That's funny, yeah. I got you on that one.
SPEAKER_01I don't know, whatever.
SPEAKER_02Crazy. It's so we're both old. No, I'm I'm slightly younger.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, you I'm looking at you. You look like you're staying young. Uh you're doing you're doing well over there.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, uh um, it's just you know, all the knick-knacks around me, keep me young. Right.
SPEAKER_00Are you out in Huntington Beach as well? Are you out?
SPEAKER_02No, I'm in Arizona, Tucson.
SPEAKER_00Okay, there you go. There's keeping keeping you warm and young out there, yeah.
SPEAKER_02Leathery skin.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_04But it's just so like the reason why I asked you that is because that that whole like being passionate about leadership and leadership is so important in the workplace. I mean, I just it's like one of those skills and um things that like when you are married and you have kids, you start taking a little bit more seriously because you understand how much uh it is needed and and what an impact you can make.
SPEAKER_00I just wrote an article the other day, I think it just came out maybe um what's say on Monday, and it's on you know, parenting and mentoring. And you know, how do you parent your kids, you know, but also how do you give them some mentorship? And it's just uh, you know, it's been interesting. You know, my my dad called uh high school and college years as the valley of ignorance, you know, when you're younger, you know, your your parents are the smartest people, and as you go through high school, they're your parents' IQ generally goes down until senior year when you know they they're you know the lowest IQ, and then it picks back up. But you know, it's it's been funny, even to see with my own kids as they're starting to, you know, my daughter like, look for an internship. What am I gonna do after school? And then they're friends. And you know, I just took um uh my son's a senior in high school and took all a group of his friends away. And you know, all of a sudden they're asking me, like, what do you do? And where what should I do? And it's just neat when you start to um, you know, see young kids like look to other people and say, like, how you know, how did you get a job? How did you decide where you were going to school? And and I love those conversations, especially with young people, because if you invest in them, if you invest in them, you can legitimately change the trajectory of a 20-year-old's life. Yeah, just with, and by the way, not with magical advice. Sometimes the advice is absolutely so basic.
SPEAKER_02It it's almost always that way, right? It it is, it is. But like we were we were just talking earlier about something I read in a book, and and basically it's it's the whole, you know, keep your friends closer, your enemies closer thing, which it's like this makes sense, but then reading through these examples, it's like, ah, it's so obvious, you know, and just something that you don't like, all these great things that are so obvious that just you don't apply, right? Yeah, and then you struggle, struggle, struggle, struggle, and you're like, Oh, maybe I should do it this way. And that was the original way that we should have done it when we were looking at it the first time, right? Yeah, why do we do that? Why can't we take the known thing that that the guru or the person that is mentoring us is telling us and just do it? Why do we have to go, no, no, I gotta do it this way, and then I'm gonna fail, fail, fail, fail. Okay, I'll do it that way.
SPEAKER_00You know, I think it's as simple as we're all units of one. You know, we're each unique, we've we're all on our own journey and we're all like building up our experience and our know-how. Now, I do think, you know, maybe people that get somewhere earlier, somewhere could be uh college, it could be uh uh first promotion, it could be um buying a house, whatever it is. I think those are people that maybe were better at listening to those around them. And and and I know, you know, I had mentors in my life, and you know, I I think one of my mentors at one time probably kept me out of jail for homicide when I was running hot after a meeting. And, you know, uh other mentors, you know, like made things that were really big in my head, you know, like, wow, I can't believe this is happening. And they're like, it's a blip, it's a day, it's a week, you know, you got 30-year career ahead of you. And but when you're in the moment, it's it's big. It it's you don't have perspective. Um you know, so I think that's something, and and you don't have perspective because you you don't have perspective, you don't have experience, you haven't been through it. Uh, you know, we have interns here at the company, and and you know, you talk to them and you realize, you know, wow, you know, a 20-year-old is is a 20-year-old, you know, they're they're learning, they're they're learning things for the first time. They, you know, it's it's what do I wear in the office? You know, like they they don't know.
SPEAKER_02Um the like because we were all there, right? Like you you see them do it and you think back, you're like, oh wow, I remember when I learned that thing, and and it's just nuts that they don't know it. And for the last 30 years, we have, right?
SPEAKER_00Like, yeah, yeah. And in and you know, in in in some ways, the environment now, I think for a young uh person with aspirations, I think with the hybrid and remote, I actually harder because you know, like sometimes you just do you know, being at home and in remote, if that's your job. I like I I look at some of the lessons I learned, they were just by being in, like watching the person next to me struggle. I remember at one point, you know, they said, Brendan, we want to put you in sales. I had no idea how to sell whatsoever, but I remember listening to this guy, Jeff, I sat next to, like listening to him on calls with clients and and asking them, how do you prepare? If I were remote, I just wouldn't have had those learning experiences. So, you know, one thing I tell young people in their careers is whether you can be remote or hybrid, go to the office. There's just stuff. And by the way, it's really tough getting the next promotion or next assignment when you're not known. Yeah, and and when you're remote, it's very easy to forget a young person, forget for that matter, anybody, when they're remote. Yeah. Versus, hey, who's the guy that sits in the third row? He he's a really hard worker, he's here all the time. Who's that? Yeah. Sometimes that's the person that gets that little break, and it's just because they were there, they were known. One of my mentors called it the law of physical presence. He goes, You gotta be there to show up. If you want to play the big game, you gotta show up.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, you can't play in the Super Bowl remotely.
SPEAKER_00But just think of that. Just the law of physical presence, just show up. Like it sounds easy, but you know, like it's it's sometimes it's not.
SPEAKER_02The hardest part of going to the gym is just going there.
SPEAKER_04There you go. Right. It is funny though, like uh that is that is the thing, right? And the default is to not go into work because the the benefit is that you can work remote, but like then it's like, what's your competitive advantage to your peers? I mean, definitely going in because right, because at least 50% of them are choosing home. That already puts you in the lead uh in the lead above 50% of the employees at work. So I think that's a that's one of those great leadership pieces of advice for younger people. Um, because I feel the same way. Like if my employees are eager to come into work, it's like, wow, thank you. Like, um, I mean, it there's a there's a certain level of confidence and buy-in that you feel when somebody actually wants to come in.
SPEAKER_00Well, also what I just think of like just think of my day today. So, you know, you've got your calendar, it's laid out, and then there's things happen. Well, if you want those things to happen and somehow maybe land on your desk with more responsibility or more whatever, like sometimes it doesn't go to the most qualified. Sometimes it goes to uh who's known, who's available, who's around, who's got and and again, if you're not there, well, you know, I you know, uh uh I'm a big Patriots fan on the East Coast. You know, Bill Belichick used to have a line the best ability is availability. You know, if you're on the injured report every week, it doesn't matter how good you are. I can't play you. So, you know, the best ability sometimes is showing up, sometimes being present, being available. Um, and and that, you know, we just when we had our interns, we did a little thing uh a couple weeks ago. And when we were saying goodbye to them, they said, Hey Brennan, you know, what's some advice? That's one of the things I said is you know, be known and also know what you want. Like, I can't help you get where you want to go if you don't know where you want to go. But if you if if you're if you're if you're a 23-year-old and you come to me and you say, Someday I'd like to work in finance and I'd really like to understand more about accounting, and I can put that in the back of my head. A project comes up and I can go, Oh, what about Charlie? But if if if I say, Hey, what are you looking to do? I don't know. Right, I can't, I can't help you get to I don't know land.
SPEAKER_04A hundred percent. It's funny, it's like full circle, it goes back to what you were saying earlier of how you became chairman of the board, was because you were there and you kept chiming in.
SPEAKER_02And they're like, Well, you squeaky wheel, baby. Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_00And just, you know, I I I uh you know, I say that and and now let's go to the boardroom. Let's go to the boardroom. So we were just at interns, we'll go to the boardroom. You know, as a board member, you've got a responsibility to kind of you know listen, absorb, but also give back. And, you know, in you know, too many times, and and I'm thinking nonprofit boards, you know, whether it's with your kids' soccer team or school or or or a public company or private company, it's it's you know, are you showing up in in governing or are you showing up and adding value? And and it's not, you know, it's like let's say you have four board meetings a year, showing up to the board meeting, that's the minimum. That's like going to practice if you're uh high school athlete. That's the minimum. You know, do you do you want to do you do you want to start for varsity? Do you want to make varsity? Do you do you want to play in college? Practices are the minimum. You know, what are you doing outside of practice? Are you are you lifting? Are you conditioning? Are you so you know, if you're now a board member, so we'll go from intern to board member, show up to the meetings. That's like going to practice. Like, of course you go to the meetings. But, you know, I are you learning about the industry that the company's in? Are you researching their competitors? Are you thinking of ways they could improve their top line, their bottom line? Are you are you at a conference and you network with somebody and you go, you know what? I want to put you in in touch with this company that I'm on the board of. And it it's no, think of it, it's no different. One might be a 21-year-old, one might be now a 50-year-old. We're kind of doing bookends there, but you know, it's it's uh it's shown up, but then it's like now it's defining what is my value add? What more can I, what more can I do? What more can I offer?
SPEAKER_02Right. Yeah. So it seems to me that if somebody isn't showing up, there's some level of of maybe fear, uncertainty, unsure, uh like not feeling good about themselves, self-doubt. Um, I know in in your book, Flood Factor, which is back there behind you, you talk you talk about like overcoming these things, how to how to overcome these things and why kind of why they're in roaming around in our head. Could you could you go into that a little bit?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so you know, like when we were all born, we actually didn't have fear, uncertainty, and doubt. And then unintentionally, the world started imprinting it on us. So, you know, one example I use in the book is, you know, as kids, we probably all skateboarded, and yet, you know, parents will say, Hey, put a helmet on. Well, no way. But but the kid was this kid's like the kid was not thinking, I'm gonna get on the skateboard, I'm gonna fall.
SPEAKER_02Right.
SPEAKER_00Like there was that was not in a five-year-old, a 10, it wasn't even in their thought process, but we we injected it. And you know, and by the way, we we do, you know, all sorts of this. So and next thing you know, someone's saying, like, you know, hey, am I gonna make the team? And then it's like, you know, I'm not gonna try out. Well, because it's easy. If I don't try out, then I'm I'm not gonna, I'm not gonna fail. And I'll tell you, today, I think there's more expectations on people than there's ever been. Social media puts like um pressures where are you cool? Are you invited to the party? Uh, are you doing fun things with your family? You know, I like that shirt that you say everyone in a while. I wish my life was as good as yours is on Facebook. You know, it's like, hey, you know, there's this, there's this, you know, uh, you know, expectation out there. So that actually creates that accelerates fear, uncertainty, and doubt. And, you know, as you look to overcome it, one of the first things is, you know, I have a saying, have the courage to fail and the faith to succeed. You just have to say, I'm willing to fail. I'm willing to fail. And, you know, short of of you know, certain jobs, like if you're in the military, you're in law enforcement, you're you're in healthcare, you know, most of us have day-to-day jobs that if you fail, things are gonna be okay. Things are gonna be okay. So I'm not suggesting that, you know, if you're the receptionist at the hospital, you try surgery, not going that far. But, you know, if we don't have surgeons that are that are pushing for new procedures, uh, we're we're never gonna solve um, you know, uh the diseases and illnesses. But there what I find interesting is is culturally, companies can take that fear away where you talk about your failures, you talk about your successes. I know here at Merchants in the last five years, you know, we're a 60-year-old company, we went from 500 million to uh two and a half billion. We have this tremendous growth, but we talk about our failures. We talk about businesses we entered that just failed, and what that sends a message to others that you can start a business or you can have an idea, and it's okay if it fails, as opposed to um, well, you know, that team's no longer here, you know, you know, or sweeping under the rug and not talking about it. But, you know, I've never met anybody in any profession doing anything that's great that didn't fail. I don't know. Well yeah.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman