The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Unlocking Insurance Success | Wisdom from the Expert Andy Neary PART 2
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
When I look at the most successful advisors in our industry and I compare them to everybody else, and there's a lot of people stuck in mediocrity, right? And I said, okay, what separates the best from the rest? Drive and discipline, definitely in that category. But Jason, it goes back to something you said. The best also invest in themselves. 100%. You would you would be surprised how many advisors come to us for help, but then want their company to pay for the investment. Yeah. And it's like, guys, it's never going to work that way. It won't. You have to put your own skin in the game. Exactly. You have to pay. Exactly. You have to invest in yourself. Even when it feels uncomfortable, even when you don't think you have the money right now, going all in on yourself, betting on yourself is the best thing you can do.
SPEAKER_01I am it's so funny. I don't think a lot of agents think about the fixed costs that they have, right? They have this um agent, and to your point, a lot of them are expensive. Um they have them sitting in a seat and you're like, go out and get business. And it's like, dude, you could bring them business so much more inexpensive than it costs for them to go get business because it's going to take them hours and hours and hours just to reach someone. But like, dude, they're sitting there, they're your most expensive cost. Why not, you know, spend a little bit that will be less expensive to get people to them so that they can actually close the deals.
SPEAKER_02100%.
SPEAKER_01But we don't do that.
SPEAKER_02I mean, just think about the math, guys, right? It's it's not that difficult today for an agency to have bringing at least a hundred million dollars of premium if you've if you've got a few producers, right? Right. If we use the math 10%, which we all think is low, that's a hundred thousand dollars on marketing. Do you know what a hundred thousand dollars of marketing would do for your agency if you used it the right way? Yes. Your producers would have more leads than they know what to do with. Yes. But that's the problem. We've done it. Yeah, and you guys have proved it.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah. No, it's crazy. I and I know I I understand like the the the there's a there is a pain element. There's a you know, you're scared and stuff. There was one point that when I first started doing this, uh, that we built up to like we were doing $80,000 a month in in um marketing spend. Uh and I was like, my stomach was hurting because I was like, this could go sideways, like you know what I mean. But it was um really just knowing those numbers, understanding that we're still doing the same thing we did on the littler scale, but on a on a bigger scale. But like, there's no way that we would have even come close to the same results without that kind of spend, and it came back to us exponentially in return.
SPEAKER_02Hundred percent.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's it's it's uh I mean, I understand the emotional behind, there's a total emotional, but to your point earlier, there's a math element to it. So if you know the math, then the let the math guide the emotion, not the emotion guide the math.
SPEAKER_02I'm in a group right now, my own coaching, and uh one of the mentors that leads the group says it to us all the time. The only difference between you guys running your businesses and somebody like uh Patrick Bet David or Ed Milet or or Lewis Howes, they spend a heck of a lot more money on marketing and ads than you do.
SPEAKER_00Right, more leads, higher price product. I mean, it's all it's it's the same thing, right? A business is just moving the how much does it cost to bring them in? How much the lifetime value? You know, here we go.
SPEAKER_02If we got if we had more agency owners understand that game of math, I think we'd have here it kind of goes back to where we started the conversation. One thing that drives me every day to do what we do is I feel not enough agencies know how to grow organically anymore, because that's why you see a lot of most of the independent selling. I don't think they're selling out of out of desire, they're selling out of need, they're done, they're tired, they're they're just I need to sell. And it's why MA is the number one strategy for all the big houses. Nobody knows how to grow organically anymore because there is a lack of of agencies that understand what you two understood, which is wow. Yeah, we we apply marketing a good strategy to our our game plan and throw some ad money and dollars at it. Holy cow, this thing turns into a machine.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, few hundred. Well, and you tell and it's and you test it, you don't test it at an eighty thousand dollar spin, you test it at a freaking five thousand dollar spend, and then you oh, it worked, right? Yep, and I think that that's where like I was in that same where you're hit with so many things, and the agent comes in, especially like a captive PC agent comes in, they're learning all the stuff, they're learning how to be a boss. They're there's there's a million different people marketing different marketing uh things to them when at the end of the day, the the cheapest cost per sale, right? Acquisition cost that there is is buy an internet lease, put a bunch of dials on them and transfer them to your people and and closing them. Like in this world, right? Like that's you're not gonna find anything else under what three four hundred bucks uh acquisition cost, which you have to have. It can't be higher than that, or you're not making anything, right? And so, yeah, it's it's it's just it's wild that then there's other people like, oh, I'm waiting for the phone to ring. I'm gonna aggressively stare at this thing until it rings, and it nothing happens, right?
SPEAKER_02They they end up they I got a question for you guys, though, on this, because I I really this this topic, I love this topic because did you guys hit a point when you had your your marketing dialed in with this and you were generating leads and you almost like consistent predictable leads, where you said we could probably go apply the same concept to another industry. Did you ever hit that point? Yeah, yes, we just hit that ourselves because we're in the process of building our own game plan here, right? Yeah, and it hit me because I'm like, wow, once you see what it takes or how to build this little machine, you're like, I told my team the other day, I'm like, we could literally take this process we've just built and apply it to another product, yeah.
SPEAKER_00You do it to anything because it's the same numbers for everything, right? Like I had I can I can talk about conversations I have with my wife here because she won't ever listen. Um but she was talking to so she works in in biotech, and you know, they launch products and whatever, you know, that treat cancer and or test for cancer, something. And you know, it's good she's not listening. Um, but she walked through the you know, here's the development, here's it, and then I just like I rattled off the you know, here's the metrics. Like when you did when it goes to market, this is what they need to do, they got to cover the RD with the you know, and and it's just this it's the same thing, everything works the same. And she's like, No, you don't understand our industry works different.
SPEAKER_02I'm like, No, it's it's okay, but they may call it different things, but same process.
SPEAKER_00All the same, all the same thing. Yep, it's it's and it's everywhere, yeah. And and often, like what's interesting is MA like going and buying those other agencies is a quick path to to growth, right? And and it's easy if there's a bunch of extra cash, or if they're going at a low multiple and you finance it for cheap, or where they'll do a carry back, whatever, right? There's a lot of opportunity there, but we've actually we put the numbers side by side, like spending and growing uh organically, or you know, paid organic uh to do your business can be less acquisition cost when you put the numbers on what you get when you actually buy something, right? And there's also that at there's the the people that leave, right? You're losing 20% when you buy it. So it's just interesting when you actually go and look at the numbers because a lot of folks talk about a lot of things, but they don't actually put the math on it, and that's what I love.
SPEAKER_02I love that math, and it but I think it it's it goes back to Jason. You said something earlier. We talked about patience or lack thereof, yeah. Right? It's are you willing to show up every day, act urgently in the moment, but put patience to your long-term vision. You know, and how what I mean by that is like I get up every day, right? I love the process, I'm sure you guys are the same. You get up, but you have to act urgently in the moment, the activity, but put patience to it as well because you know what you're doing today is gonna set up a big tomorrow. And I think that's where some agencies fall short when it comes to how do we use marketing to create that big win down the road. They lack the patience to say, I am spending dollars today, knowing this is gonna create an amazing reserve, uh, return a year, three years, five years from now. I think they're too focused on whatever I spend today, I want to create a return next week.
SPEAKER_00Right. It's like I I think this happens with with every type of marketing thing that that we as agents get. So everything will work as long as you do it, right? Unless you're like insulting them, like you you can knock on doors, it'll work, but you have to do it forever, right? You don't just do it for a week and then stop. You can send mailers, it'll work, but you have to be consistent. And so we know that applying action is going to create a result, but that's just a fact. It's the law, it's it's law, right? Like that's the laws of nature, right there.
SPEAKER_01One thing that I believe is that I think the more you can delay gratification in your business, like the more goodwill you can put out into uh the world, the more you're gonna be able to return when you ask for something. So, like, and then I think like like when you look at uh really big baller business dudes, they understand this the most. They understand like the long term, like the longer, longer play. And I and I've thought about this a lot. And you see really good marketing people do this where they're just giving away forever ever. Gary V talks about the jab jab jab right hook. But let's take it back to Jesus. Like now, the reason being is it's the the Bible is the number one selling book of let's just take away all the relationships. I mean, it does have time on its side for being the double, and it was first to market. The number one selling book of all time, yes, right? All first to market that Jesus did is give the whole time, and we're still talking about them, right? So that's like to me, like the ultimate play in like reciprocity is just give, give, give, give, and never really ask for anything. But like, I I so that's an extreme example, but like us as business owners, like the longer that you can delay the gratification, like the bigger the returns will be.
SPEAKER_02I couldn't agree more. I I think if you go at it with the confidence that I'm not going anywhere, I'll be here five years from now. And that allows you to wake up every day again, act urgently, but be patient about it, confidently patient. But you said something else, Jason, that I think is really important. What you're saying in your marketing is if you spend, if you focus your marketing on giving, um, the same mentor I mentioned earlier uses a phrase called save the best for first. Share your good stuff. It almost gives you this air of I how do I say this? Because I I feel it when I reach out to prospects. You almost owe me a meeting because I've given you so much, right? Not that I'm saying that to them, but in my head, I'm like, this guy owes me a meeting. We have given these this team so much content, they're gonna say yes. And I I think I think you're right. The more you just focus on giving, it tends to create amazing inbound opportunities. And when you actually apply the outbound activity, it it elevates your outbound activity to levels that you've never experienced before.
SPEAKER_01100%. And and you can even relate that to your staff. Um, you can relate it to dude, to yourself. You know what I mean? Like the more you can create margin for yourself, the more like you like doing what you do, the more you can create a situation where your staff shows up and are excited about work, the more they're going to be excited and and sell to, you know what I mean? Like it's just it's exponentially better to to create uh to to give. And I think so many times we can be frustrated as business owners and kind of lose sight of that. And then we get into this uh like mindset of like fear, and um where we're not giving as much, we're like, well, why aren't why aren't you doing this? Why aren't we doing you know what I mean? And it's like, dude, that's that cycle is is how you how you can really uh go down in flames. Okay, you know.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I think the traditional hand-to-hand mark uh prospecting combat we've all dealt with early in our careers is we our activity was always we do something with wanting something in return, right? I mean, that's a cold call. A cold call is I'm picking up the phone with wanting something in return. I send one email to a prospect hoping it creates an appointment. I'm doing it to get something in return, versus what if we just pumped out marketing every day without wanting a dang thing in return, and then eventually we'll ask. But when we ask, there Gary V talks about this, they almost feel guilty, so they say yes because we've given them so much, right?
SPEAKER_01100%. Love it. What are some tactics that you can help some agents out with? Uh, why don't you give them some give give them some?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, here's here's a giveaway. Well, it kind of I'll say it goes back to who are you talking to, what are you saying, how are you saying it, where are you saying it. You know, if I could just share some nuggets there, you know, when it's wait, when it's comes down to the who, we actually use uh uh an exercise we call the five-star prospect profile, which is number one, tell me who your favorite client is today, and then tell me why. And the only re answer you can't give me is because I make the most money out of them. Right, yeah. But but when you dig into the why, it comes down to demographics and psychographics. And the way I love to describe psychographics is if you're looking at an athlete, the demographics of the height, weight, and speed, all the stuff on paper, right? The psychographics is okay, how's that athlete when he or she's on the field, when it's crunch time? How do they act? How do they behave? How do they perform? Prospects are no different. Demographics are all the good things on the paper, the industry, the number of employees, number of rev size of revenue, whatever it is. But psychographics is who are these people? What do they believe? What do they stand for? And if you cannot clearly identify who the best fits are for your agency that way, psychographically, your marketing will turn into gold if you focus your marketing on the psychographics. I love that. That's number one. Number two, then is what are you saying? I don't know if you've guys if I could grab it. Uh, I'm actually a certified guide by Story Brand. I don't know if you ever guys you guys ever read the book building a story brand. Yeah, but um, it's storytelling, right? It's there's a hero with a goal who has a problem who needs a guide with a plan to have success and avoid failure. If you just use your marketing to tell that story, by the way, the hero is not your agency, it's your prospect. Right. I you guys will be shocked how many times I do that exercise and I say, So who is the hero? And they go, We are. I said, Oh no, your prospect's the hero. If you apply storytelling to your marketing, it gets exponentially better. And then the how are you saying it and the what are you saying or where are you saying it? It just comes down to are you are you putting out video content, podcast content, articles, blogs, and where are you putting that stuff? Are you on LinkedIn? Are you on Instagram? Are you doing webinars? Are you doing podcasts? Are you sending out email newsletters? If you do all of that stuff, you almost can't not create activity if you apply the cold calling and all the other stuff you have to do. If you're clear about who you're talking to, you're gonna find the right people. 100%. But it comes back to the secret we've been talking about. Are you willing to get up every day and do it over and over and over again?
SPEAKER_00Yep. So what is what do you say to folks that that are kind of waffling on getting up and and doing it all over?
SPEAKER_02Oh, if I had an answer to coach discipline and drive into somebody who doesn't have it, I think I'd be worth tens of millions of dollars. Um it's hard. I think drive and that's why Tony does it. I will I will tell you, um, our best clients, ironically, are typically former high-level athletes because we have a lot of them in the insurance industry. They get it. Yeah, the ones that we tend to coach, if if I went, if you went through our roster of people we've worked with that have had a ton of success, they probably play a college sport. Sometimes even we just worked with a guy who's in the insurance industry that was a defensive back in the NFL for seven years.
SPEAKER_00Think about the level of consistency and discipline they've had their entire life.
SPEAKER_02I I said it I put it this way athletes like that don't need to be told to work out, they just want to know what the workout is.
SPEAKER_00They need a coach because they've had a coach their whole life. I mean, you know, they get it. Yep. They're like, look, I'll do the stuff. Tell me what you do.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I think so. For for if I'm a producer right now and I'm struggling and I'm listening to this, I think it's gut check time. Look in the mirror and say, Do I have the drive and the discipline? Am I willing? And discipline, I think, can be taught because that's time management. That's sure how are you taking care of your health, how are you sleeping, all those things that going in go into being productive every day. The drive, you've got to you've got to gut check yourself and look in the mirror and say, Do I want to do I love this enough that I want to do this every day? Yep. And by the way, if the answer is no, no harm, no foul. Go do something else, but find a way to do something you love.
SPEAKER_01100%. Dude, it that that's true. That's the that's the con that's my go-to with employees. Like, like the wrong employee on the team, that's the conversation. Do you want to do this? You know what I mean? It's like that's my move. I get them to fire themselves.
SPEAKER_00I yeah, well, the because there's a mislight. And he's like, it worked, right?
SPEAKER_02There's a miserable. You're giving them the space to know that it's not a it don't be don't feel bad, right? No, if you don't love this, you're not a fit, but don't feel bad. Like, go find something you love.
SPEAKER_00I think that's so such a better approach to just be like human human and be real and go, look, you know, instead of this cat and mouse, and and hey, you know, you're not and beating them down until they quit or you know, just exiting them. I mean, if they didn't do something wrong, they're just not cutting it, then it's like have that talk, you know. We you could be that person that actually changed like course corrects them, like they don't get it or they don't love it, or whatever, or or if Matt, gut check yourself on this. This may make people unhappy. Maybe they don't like the way that you're running it, right? I mean, I've I for many years did not run this very well, and you know, they didn't like me. The people didn't because it was I was Darth Vader. Darth Vader doesn't win hearts and and loyal employees, right? It requires it, it requires a lot of skills. Uh, psychology, I think, being one of them, probably, you know.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, well, I'll share this, guys. I mean, I one thing I haven't shared with you guys on this show. Um, I I I just said to you guys that, you know, I've been fortunate to work with some high-level athletes that are now in the insurance industry. Well, that was my story. You know, I I played, I spent a couple years in pro baseball. And my story, when I got to pro baseball, I got away from all the things I did in high school and college that made me successful. The drive and the discipline, the work off the field when nobody's watching. And it's why my pro baseball career lasted two years. What team? Milwaukee Brewers. Oh, cool. Oh, cool. But it's also how I spent the first 10 years of my insurance career. I wasn't disciplined, I didn't have the drive. I wanted what took you nine years in nine weeks. Yeah, give me the hack. I don't want, I don't want to hard, I don't want the hard work. Yeah, same everybody's, you know. And I've it took me a long time to get back to that. Oh, wait, there is no secret to success here. This is hard work. It's all the work I'm doing when no one's watching that matters. Uh oh, it's just like baseball when I was in high school and college. When it clicked for me, that's when my career changed.
SPEAKER_00And you said, oh, wait, maybe I'm not right about everything, right?
SPEAKER_02Exactly. I was I was a terrible employee for 10 years in this industry.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's crazy. It's but sometimes we need to go through that to realize that, you know what I mean? And then once once you realize that, I mean, I was I was the I was a bad person in my 20s, like not even a bad, a bad, I was a bad employee. I was not a you know what I mean? Like, like there's other things that I needed to learn, but like through that, I learned a lot about how to perform by performing very poorly. Um, and that's why I think yeah, team sports is so good. All the employees that I've ever had that have had team sports experience understand what it's like to talk to a team, how to perform, how to train, how to interact with each other. I mean, it's just it's it's so great. And I wish I would have done more team sports when I was younger because I probably could have learned a lot of the lessons that were very difficult in my 20s and 30s uh a lot earlier. That didn't help me.
SPEAKER_02But you're right though, you have to go through those low moments to finally hit that rock bottom, whatever that rock bottom is in your life or your career to come out of it and say, okay, I got to do better. Right. But when I look at the most successful advisors in our industry and I compare them to everybody else, and there's a lot of people stuck in mediocrity, right? And I said, Okay, what separates the best from the rest? Drive and discipline, definitely in that category. But Jason, it goes back to something you said. The best also invest in themselves. 100%. You would you would be surprised how many advisors come to us for help, but then want their company to pay for the investment. Yeah. And it's like, guys, it's never gonna work that way. It won't. You have to put your own skin in the game. Exactly. You have to pay. Exactly. You have to invest in yourself, even when it feels uncomfortable, even when you don't think you have the money right now, going all in on yourself, betting on yourself is the best thing you can do.
SPEAKER_00Yep, we've done it. I mean, we've spent a uh a lot on our coaches.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, 100%.
SPEAKER_01Andy, thank you so much, dude. You are awesome. I love this conversation. If somebody wants to get a hold of you, what's the best way?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, uh, I will tell you if they wanted, we have a free training. If I can just throw out there, broker marketing playbook. All they got to do is go to completegameplaybook.com and they can download that. Uh and it's about a 15 minute training, really nice training, or come check me out on LinkedIn. I'm there every day. Andy Neary, let's connect. Let's love it.
SPEAKER_00Awesome, Andy. Thank you so much. Appreciate you being listening. Yeah, that's been awesome.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman