The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Unlocking Insurance Success | Wisdom from the Expert Andy Neary PART 1
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
The wildest thing that has ever happened in my agency was trying to help a poor employee consumer get the healthcare they need at the right facility, at the right provider. Unfortunately, I sent them to a place that was not covered by insurance. Little did I know I was absolutely putting the employee in a bad position until the day they showed up at my office cubicle to absolutely wring my neck. That was one of the scariest moments in my career because I thought I was going above and beyond, but all I was doing was creating more problems for somebody who was, let's be honest, living paycheck to paycheck and relying on my advice to get the care they need. One of the lowest moments in my career. Hi, my name is Andy Neary. I am with Complete Game Consulting in Oconnamawalk, Wisconsin, and I'm an insurance dude.
SPEAKER_01I are eight.
SPEAKER_03Oh right, there we go. Why dive a little deeper into that? That's crazy. Oh man. Somebody stormed in the office.
SPEAKER_00It was so I uh this is going back 15 plus years. And I was I had sold a health plan to a group here in Wisconsin before we moved to Colorado. And I knew there could be network issues because they were looking from some cost savings. So we went with a specific plan that helped save a little money, but was an adjustment on the network of health health insurance, the health care hospital providers. And I knew this couple needed help because they were seeing uh they were going to a certain facility that wasn't going to be covered. So I tried to help them steer them to another facility to help them make sure it's covered. Unfortunately, I steered them to another one that was not covered. It was something for their child, and I thought I was doing the right thing, but I wasn't. And yes, the father, the dad ended up standing behind me in my cubicle one day and somehow, somehow was able to walk his way into our office. And man, you fast forward to today, it probably would even would even be scarier with as much uh angst and stress that there is in the society today. Yeah, yeah. I don't know if they'd get in. Yeah, that's a good point. So this is way back, right? Yeah, this is 2000, probably 08-09.
SPEAKER_03Oh eight, oh nine. So you were like 21. No, I was I would have been pushing 30.
SPEAKER_00I was about I was about a good 10 years. I was trying to I was trying to help you there. No, man, I'm willing to admit when I'm wrong.
SPEAKER_02Well, I think we've all had, unfortunately, stories like that where you know, whether or not we were early in the insurance career, I I came in. Man, I had only worked in an office for a little bit in an insurance office. And then I came in and I'm trying to I took over an agency and I had to like pretend like I knew what was going on. I had zero clue at all. And yeah, steering people in the wrong direction was uh definitely happened a few times.
SPEAKER_00My issue is I used to be a horrible people pleaser. Oh and I still have that from time to time. And I think what what happened in the past is I would want to help people so much to help them avoid a problem, or or if I knew I had potentially created a problem, I'd go above and beyond to try to solve it. Yeah, but more often than not, it just created a bigger problem, right?
SPEAKER_03And and it it eliminates your ability to effectively do anything, right? Because you're spending all your time on all this it locks the office down. Micro crap. Yep, yep, yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_02Have you done the disc profile?
SPEAKER_00Years ago.
SPEAKER_02Were you a high eye?
SPEAKER_00Yes. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Same here. It's so funny too, because it's like there, there's like a like a dichotomy to that, right? It's like you're you're such a people pleaser and people like you, and you're like you're worried, like you get people to like you, you want people to like you, so you're willing to do anything, and and but with that, there's a lack of honesty too, because it's like you're not willing to just say, like, no, or I don't like that because you know, you think you're doing the right thing, yeah, but you're not, and like you said, it only negative, it only hurts your credibility and and trust.
SPEAKER_00I talk about it now, you know, early in my career from a sales perspective. I always won the likability game. So prospects liked me, they'd take meetings with me. I never I had a problem establishing the credibility to get hired early in my career, but I was a likable guy, so I always got caught in the friend zone with prospects, and that's a bad place to be.
SPEAKER_03Oh, yeah.
SPEAKER_00You didn't push hard enough at the way, they like you, they'll take meetings with you, but they're never gonna take you seriously enough to hire you.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, it's like it's a balance, right? You have to you have to make them like you, but not too much 100%.
SPEAKER_00But you have to you it has to be mixed with credibility for sure. Yeah.
SPEAKER_03Well, so in working with agents so often, like how do you uh what do you see out there with regard to that's a big problem.
SPEAKER_00I think there's a lot of advice. I talk to a lot of sales directors in this industry right now, and the biggest challenge they have is their producers are good when they get referrals. It is so hard to find pure hunters these days. People wanting to go out and find their own business. It is a big challenge in the insurance industry right now.
SPEAKER_02So, do a lot of people want them, like the agent, to go find business?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so you have a lot of agencies today that hire a producer, right? Yeah, and it's let's face it, one of the reasons I my business exists is there's just a there's a lack of training, there's a lack of of good coaching in the industry. And right a lot of agencies just hire a producer, and it's almost like this, all right, go get them. And and they want them to go find their own business, rely on their own network. And what they're what what they're finding out is this producer they've hired is really good if you give them a lead or give them a referral, but to ask them to go find their own business, it's it's a challenge. There's not there's not a lot of producers who have that drive and that discipline to go find their new their own business.
SPEAKER_02Well, what do you feel about that? Because I'll tell you how I feel about that.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, go. I'd love to hear your perspective.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, the like what business says, Hey, uh, you know, I got this business, I'm not gonna get leads or anything. I'm just gonna you you go get the lead and then you close the lead. Uh like that's like why not just start your own, you know, like no other industry does that, right?
SPEAKER_00Yes, but you understand marketing, my friend. A lot of this insurance. I'm just gonna say it. Insurance, I think, is way behind the times on marketing. I agree with you.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, what about on technology?
SPEAKER_00100% a good a good agency, right? In 2023, should have a marketing strategy to be constantly providing good leads for producers to go uh close, but they're not, they're they're relying that happen, man. I don't know. I I've I've seen it for a long time. Um I I call it the traditional insurance two step. I see the marketing strategy in this industry being buy a big list of leads, you have no idea if they're qualified or not, and then just hammer them with phone calls. Um, versus what can we do from a marketing perspective to create a lot of name recognition, a lot of brand recognition, but also create inbound leads for our producers. That's the goal, right? There's not a lot of that going on.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, so crazy. And what about the pipeline? Do you think that agents have an understanding of what they how many quotes they need to do? Like what so we're PNC, right? That's been our our our world is the PNC world. I know that there's a lot of you know healthcare and life agents and all that listening too, because it applies, but in the PNC world, uh the name of the game is quotes, right? We we need quotes. And for many years, I had no under I had no understanding, and it and it's interesting because the math is very simple, right? But for some reason, it's not something that everybody talks about or we figure out, or maybe because it's so obvious you don't even put it together. But it's very easy to determine if I want to write X, I need to do Y.
SPEAKER_00Right, and then you just fill it in. 100%. I someone was I was just talking to somebody over the weekend about this. Had I gone to college knowing I was gonna get into insurance, right? Because very few of us got in this by design, right? I would have gotten two degrees finance or finance, which I did, because you've got to know numbers. Yeah. And I would have gotten a psychology degree because understanding the buyer is so key. But going back to your point about the math, this is a game of math, isn't it? I mean, yep, if you want to if you know your numbers to hit the the certain level of revenue you want to hit for the year is going to require X number of wins, right? AORs. Just reverse engineer the math. Okay, so I need how many proposals then to generate that number of AORs? Cool. How many first meetings do I need to generate that number of proposals? And I tell producers at that point, throw away the sales number, the revenue number, throw away the proposals and just focus on the number of intro meetings you need. Or whether your KPI is quotes, just focus. That is your KPI, focus on nothing else. How come? I was just saying how come? Yeah, how come? Why? Why do we want to look at that? I think because too many producers, in my opinion, every year, every January, they sit down and they create a big sales goal, right? And it's usually a revenue number, a quarter of a million dollars, 300,000, 500,000. Let's be honest, most of them do not have a plan of attack to get there. They just set a big number, and then the whole year they sit there and they stare at that number. Right. And they at after about three months, they start getting nervous. If they would just say, Hey, I know that if I get 30 quotes this year or 50 quotes this year, I'm gonna hit that number. And all I do is I focus on that 30 or that 50. I think it makes the goal definitely more palatable and more realistic. And as long as they pair it with an actual plan of action to get to those 30 quotes, it's gonna happen.
SPEAKER_03It's like they're they're only focused on the result, but not the steps it requires to get to.
SPEAKER_00What do they call that? The leading indicators versus the lagging. Yeah, they're focused on the lagging without saying, wait, but what are the leading indicators to get there?
SPEAKER_03Would you get in a boat and look at and go, okay, I want to go to Italy. So you take out the map, and all you do the whole time is stare at the map as the boat is driving.
SPEAKER_00Exactly.
SPEAKER_03We'll get there. I'm looking right at Italy. The wind's blowing the right way, isn't it? Yes.
SPEAKER_02Craig, I would not get in that boat with you if you were listening.
SPEAKER_03If you were driving the boat to Italy across the I'm driving the boat to Italy and I have the map, and I'm looking at Italy. I see Barcelona right here, Italy. Barcelona, Italy. Well, there's our first there's our first problem. We're not going to Barcelona, Italy. Oh no. I know it's jokes. Come on. I just take the same classes you guys did. It's Sydney. Whatever.
SPEAKER_02So this is crazy. This is such a good topic in the sense of like there's so much delusion. First off, I would have to say because of the recurring revenue and we have a retention, like it's it's one of the only industries that we can actually not have some sort of way of acquiring business, because that is so important that we can actually not have that in place and still have a business. Most of the time, if you don't have a way to get sales, you don't have a business.
SPEAKER_00Thank you. So I would hug you if I could right now, because I need more agencies to hear that.
SPEAKER_02You know what I think, and this is my opinion, and I'd like your take on it, is I think that there are a lot of agents out there. And this is not going to be a popular um comment. Oh no. Oh no. Automatically losing losing viewers or whatever. But like they're just employees, they're not business owners. And it's like time to like take off, it's time to put on the big boy pants and become the business owner and realize that, dude, if you want to like double your income, take out half your income this year, put it into marketing, and make it happen.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I couldn't agree with you more. If we got more producers to think like entrepreneurs, even if they don't own the agency, they'd do much better. You're running your own business, it might just be under somebody else's roof, right? But you're running your own business. And what you just said, you know, I if you go into most agencies today, and let's what's the rule of thumb? 10% of your revenue should be spent on marketing. Most of them are probably spending two or three percent. Right. If that. And most producers, here's where I think the problem starts. And that when 10%, I think, is is low. And I agree. I agree. Yeah. But I think another challenge, a problem that's been created in the industry, and I was a recipient of this at one time when I was a producer, is a lot of these producers get hired with these huge salaries, two-year guarantees. So they come out of the gate comfortable. And they might even be handed a book of business. So, to your point, because we're an industry that is so recurring revenue rich, you have producers getting hired. And I put air quotes around producers because let's be honest, they're not really a producer, right? They're coming day one, they're comfortable with a salary and some business revenue coming in from existing business they were handed. How are you gonna incent that producer to go out and build a great book of business? It's difficult if they don't have the drive or the discipline, right? Because there's no pain, there's no pain, they're coming in, there's no pain from day one.
SPEAKER_03Well, yeah, look at it. Where's the pain? The pain is doing work, so hey, over here I'm making money, I don't care. Yeah, right. I mean, that's not everybody, but if you're not entrepreneurial, seems like yep.
SPEAKER_00I had a I have a friend of mine who runs an agency in Indiana, and I love how he views it. He says, When I hire producers, Andy, I view them as intrapreneurs right now. They're they don't own their business, I do, but they're entrepreneurs. And if someday they came to me and said, Hey, you know, thank you for what you've done for me. I'm now gonna go start my own agency. He's like, I couldn't be prouder of them.
SPEAKER_03Intrapreneur, that's a Patrick Bed David word.
SPEAKER_00Oh, yeah.
SPEAKER_03He's been on here. Has he really?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. Oh, your job. Now I feel honored.
SPEAKER_03Gee, I got mad at Jason Jason. He got mad at Jason.
SPEAKER_00Wow.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I love that you're shocked, and it's probably because of Craig's uh Barcelona comment that we could get him on, but that's okay.
SPEAKER_00And you made him angry.
SPEAKER_03I really, you know, I I I am familiar with the fact that Barcelona is the capital of Spain, okay? I do know that it's and I didn't Google it or Google Matt.
SPEAKER_00I I I I just saw a video on YouTube this morning with Pat Patrick Bet David. He was on somebody else's podcast, and the thumbnail said Patrick Bet David may have just gone too far, so I'm curious to what he said in the video.
SPEAKER_03Oh, that's marketed though. It's beautiful.
SPEAKER_00That is good. That's awesome. Congratulations for guy, you guys to get you guys to have guests like that on the show. Again, I'm honored to even be here.
SPEAKER_03It's been a while, but yeah, he was a good one. He was fun. He was fun.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, good dude. Um super cool. I like I love this topic because um we run we run a program where we help agents get their uh their sales agents leads. Awesome. So what we've seen, I mean, there's there's two types of agents that come into this. Those who understand hey, you gotta spend a little bit and like you know, make make it flow, fill the pipeline. It takes a little bit of time, and that's the way, and those agents are the ones that just blow up, like are selling a ton. I mean, and then we we still have some that are smaller operations, but like they they feel the pain a little bit for a while, and then dude, that's when they fill the pipeline and then the consistency happens, but you got to invest.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I I couldn't agree more. You know, when we work, we take a little different angle from coaching and training with producers. We we really focus on the message. I tell people I think the core pillars of a good marketing strategy, and in in our industry, insert the word prospecting for marketing, right? Yeah, you got to know four things. Who are you talking to? What are you saying to them? How are you saying it? Where are you saying it? If you have a clear picture of what you're doing with those four things and you apply the work to it, whether you do it or you help somebody help you do it with leads, you're gonna do well as long as you stay consistent. But the word you just use, Jason, consistency. That's where people struggle. It's are you willing to get up? I just put a post about this out this afternoon. Are you willing to get up every day and do the boring SHIT every single day? Yep. Nope. Yep.
SPEAKER_02It's just like working out. Like who it's like the crazy people at the beginning of the year that work out for a week, start feeling the pain, which of course you always go backwards. It's a lot more pain and and a lot of breaking down of muscles, and it sucks. And again, and no results. Were like the well, the results that you're getting are horrible. Yeah, your feedback, your instant gratification is pain. You're in pain, you're in a worse spot than when you started working out, you know.
SPEAKER_00I tell I tell our clients when they hire us about 90 days in after doing what we teach you, you're gonna say, This neary guy's full of crap. You're gonna think like this doesn't work, but then all of a sudden something no, I don't lead with that. But when I get when we start working, when we when we start working with them, I'm like, it takes time, this takes patience, and you're gonna hit that point where you don't believe it's working, and then all of a sudden you get that one sign it is, and then another, and then another. And before you know it, you have that hockey stick effect. Yeah, and we've seen it with our clients at that 90-day mark, they kind of start questioning, and then all of a sudden it's like, ah, I get it, and then they take off. Have you read The Dip? I have not.
SPEAKER_03It's a little book, it's it's cool. It's called The Dip, but I can't remember the author's name now. It was around here somewhere, I don't know where it is, but um, we talk about that a lot because it's you you get the thing because you want the results and you're super excited, and you start doing it, but nothing happens. So either either you give up and eject, right? Or or you keep going, but it's still it takes a while before the hockey stick happens, right? And that's the dip. Like right typically we give up on things right before we're about to break through. And you know this. I mean, you've coached people, so you see, you know, if they when they drop off, they were right there, right? And they were probably in the most pain that they've been in the whole time, but it was just about to happen, and we see it, we see it a lot. Uh yeah, it just depends if it's not a good fit or whatever, or they don't want to do the work, right? Because you have to do the work, you have to put it, you have to understand how the thing flows. It's just it's it it takes time, like like you said. So, how do you how have you now now understanding the concept or the understanding of the of the dip, how do you navigate that with your clients? And what would you say to anybody that is starting something and and maybe not seeing those immediate results?
SPEAKER_00You know, I think it comes down to starts with it starts with what is your weekly plan? You know, when it comes to the what activities are you doing from a prospecting perspective? And what we what we try to coach our clients to do is, you know, the three of us have all been taught how to create, let's call it linear awareness, right? Cold calling. I know how to call one prospect at a time. That's what I was taught early on, right? I've got I can I can email one prospect at a time. I was taught how to go door to door in industrial parks, right? I can knock on one door at a time. Today, with all the technology and the tools we have, you got to create exponential awareness with it, which is what can I do to get one message in front of many prospects at one time? Right? Email newsletters, email campaigns, social media content, public speaking, webinars, whatever it is, podcasts. If you mix the exponential with the linear activity you're doing, you will create activity. You almost can't not. I really believe that. But at but but what is that plan of action every single week? Because here is what happens if you don't have a plan. If you don't have a plan, you will always resort back to what's easiest. And believe it or not, picking up the phone and dialing is easy. You may not get any results, but at least you can check off those 25 calls you made, right? And so what we really try to get them dialed in on is that weekly plan. What are you doing every week? Yes, you still have to pick up the phone, send out some messages directly to prospects, but how are you mixing the exponential awareness in there to create the credibility and the recognition? And if you do that every single week, you will create activity for yourself. And the and the and the icing on the cake is when you start creating inbound activity, when somebody actually reaches out to you because they're getting your emails or your social media content.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman