The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
How To Raise The Bar For Your Insurance Agency Expectation’s | Insurance Agency Playbook
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
Well, hello, Mr. Jason. Hello there. I like the believe hat. You know that? You like that? I like it, and I know that. It's the first step. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02The first step to believing is believing. It's the first step to any outcome. That's true. You gotta believe it. If you don't believe it, then what happens? Well, you will you won't behave and then you won't become. Oh, behave. Oh, behave.
SPEAKER_01It's current students are automated to itself. I are agent. Now I am great. Predictable. In profitable agent. I am great profit. I am agent helped. We are agents. We are interested.
SPEAKER_00So that's interesting that that hat takes us to where we're gonna go. I I noticed something here in uh in the agency. And we know that everything is kind of cyclical, right? We go up and down, and and we can we can have some great months. And what'll happen is maybe we take the foot off the gas a little bit or start getting a little bit lazy with some stuff because now we just won the Super Bowl, we had a great month, and then it starts to yeah, or you take seven vacations right one year, and you don't have the the right people working, and then all of a sudden it goes crazy. Who knows, right? Any anything could happen, right? So I know I and and you're right, I've been out a lot, and what I what I've noticed is I think you can't set the expectations so high that when you're gone or when you're not involved directly in the day-to-day operations, the expectations sure you can set your expectations anywhere, but I think that at least in my experience, having expectations too high, maybe the same or better than than I would expect of myself to occur if I'm not there, is unrealistic, right? Those are unrealistic expectations because I don't think that anybody who works for you is ever going to care or be more passionate about your business than you, right? For them, it's job, right? And so by default, the more that somebody is away, the more the owner is away, the greater likelihood that things are gonna start to atrophy a little bit, right? Things are gonna well, maybe we will skip a meeting, or maybe we're gonna stop listening to calls, or maybe we're gonna, you know, some some little little parts of the process start potentially falling off. Sure. Now we're not fully optimized. And then eventually, right? Because we know that that there's some lag, right? There's some leading and some lagging educators, but but whatever we're following, there's a potential that now because we stopped doing these things in a couple months or even in a month or in a couple weeks, whatever, in some time frame, we're gonna start getting that decline. And it's gonna and it and it may be difficult at that time to identify exactly the cause of the decline, right? Yep. So in sharing my story, and I know I'm eating up. Do you you have anything you want to comment so far?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and I know the way you are because I know the way I am, and I we're very similar, and I think you know, and I think that we probably have a problem that uh not a lot, I think agents probably have less of a problem with, so I don't know how relevant it is, but uh is being consistent with checking those um KPIs, yeah, right? You you you expect like certain KPIs and you might set the expectation out there, yep. But our employees know that sometimes we forget about them for a while, so it's like are they going to keep asking me or whatever? And then it falls off, and then you go back to them like, oh, I didn't know we were still doing that. It's like right dude, come on, yeah.
SPEAKER_00When did when was the um the memo that circulated that said we're no longer going to be tracking our quotes?
SPEAKER_02Right, right, right.
SPEAKER_00Like, why why would that make sense? So, yeah, totally, right? So we we get we get to this point where okay, we have all the tools and the resources, right? You and I have both built the thing because we know that we cannot be as consistent personally all the time. So, in doing so, we create the process that creates the consistency, right? So we don't have to deal with that. So I know if our sales are this, then it means I should have, or well, let me go the other way. I know that if I spent this much on leads and I have this many people making dials, I have this many people doing quotes, I have a pretty good idea how many quotes need need to be done to get to a certain result, and based on a certain spend, where I should be, right? Like a pretty good gauge, like for historically. So we know we know what we need to put in and we know where we need to get, but if we we take our hands off the wheel and put it on cruise control, we may not be watching some of those leading indicators that are gonna tell us that we're gonna have some problems. So I'll give you an example. I go back to like as I noticed that I get back from Portugal, gone a month, then I go to Hawaii, gone almost another month. So that's two months, not very engaged. And I hope nobody none of them are listening because, well, you know what? I am, I do hope they're listening because they'll know that I am much more engaged and looking at those numbers now. So those numbers, I was I was getting lazy at looking at, right? And it's easy. Look for the week. Four if I if there's four producers, there should be 40 quoted households a day. That's 200 quoted households for the week, 800 for the month, not very difficult, right? So I know okay, week one, did we do 200? Week two, did we do are we at 400? Week three, are we at 600? Did we hit these leading indicator numbers that have to be hit in order to get to the result that we want to get? Right. And as I look back, guess what? What? Nope. So, and it wasn't terrible, but it's like seven, right? Seven, seven, everybody's getting seven, eight instead of ten. Well, okay, that's 30 less. So if if if they're doing 30 less quotes over the month, do you think it's safe to say that we did 30 30 less business?
SPEAKER_02Yep.
SPEAKER_00Guess what we did? 40% less, 30% less business. Like the numbers always work out, right? Yeah, and it's so so it's so funny that we have the formula right in front, we know the path, and still it's challenging just to manage all of the pieces, yeah, sometimes, right?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, it's funny too, because like there's leading indicators, which are all the activity leading up to the thing, and then you have your lagging indicators, which is after the thing, like after the sales, and then like we had this conversation the other day about a post that we we did in the in the in the books of face, and like we're talking about like which is better, right? And the thing is, is like you do have your leading indicators and your lagging indicators. Your lagging indicators are gonna be the thing that you feel. You're gonna feel that. Why? You're gonna feel that in the pocketbook, you're gonna see it on the sales. The sales is the lagging indicator in the sale pipeline. The leading indicators are the activities, so it's very important for us as a high performance agent, if that's what you want to be. If you want to be one, you have to be paying attention to the leading indicators because that is going to represent what's happening in the future. Your lagging indicators are in the past, so that has to do with the leading indicators of a month ago or two months ago.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, if you're making decisions on on your based off of sales, then you're driving by looking in the rearview mirror.
SPEAKER_02And I think no matter what we're doing in the office, like you can like the pros have all leading indicators, whether it's on service, on um just like every part of everything that you're doing, you need to figure out those leading indicators, and that is what you need to control instead of being because a lot of times we get those lagging indicators and then we get emotional about them. I can't believe that's not happening. It's like, why how can you not believe it? Right, right. Like, because but what was it that led up to that? If you have poor retention, if you have uh a bad loss ratio, then you need to put in those leading indicators. Like, what are the indicators that like that would show that those policies are written poorly, that you're getting the bad loss ratio? What's showing the um that people are leaving? Like, what little things can we do? And how can we create those KPIs, those leading indicators, so that we can know whether or not we're gonna get that poor outcome. Right. And if we focus on the lead on the front end, like prior to the thing happening and and create the systems there, then the things won't happen. We won't have to be a mo like, don't ever be emotional about the result of something. Use the result of something to show what's actually going on because the result going back to the believe behave become, yeah, it's like once something has become something, it's because of the prior activities. Yes. Like, don't be mad at that, just look at it as like, okay, we suck at this right now. So, what are the things that led up to this and what can we do to change it? Put that in place and don't be mad at the result because the results will change as long as you have a system in place that that you're constantly looking at the KPAs, your your team knows exactly what to do to change it, and then stay consistent daily.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I love it. I love everything you just said there, and I think that it's it's so great. You just said there. I love it. You complete me. No, the the I love uh now. I don't even know. Now I don't even know what I love. No, the I'm just messing with you. So I'm I'm thinking about how I mean even even fairly recently where I'm talking about that where the sales are lower and I get upset, right? I'm I'm over there getting upset, maybe complaining to you. Mr. Go Lucky doesn't get as upset over there, and I go and and I know that you've looked at me and said, Well, maybe you're mad at yourself. It's really hard to hear, especially when you're mad and you realize it is on me, right? Like I'm mad that they didn't write 120 when they should have written 120, but instead they wrote 90. But then it's like, had I been looking at the leading indicators, I would have known seven seven seven every day just doesn't get you to where I needed to get. They have to quote 10 new households each. If it was 10, 10, 10, guess what? We would have done 120. I wouldn't have to be mad at myself. Yep, because I actually would have looked at those things, right?
SPEAKER_02So it's like yeah, and if it's hard for you to like follow up on those things, and it's it's a like then have your manager, your team, like text you those numbers, you know what I mean? Like every week on Fridays, if there's four people in the office and it's supposed to be what did you say?
SPEAKER_00Well, minus 10 quoted households works it works it out. That's the four agents 40. Yeah, so 200.
SPEAKER_02So there's should be 200. So then it's like 200, and then what was the actual number? And why what where did the other three go? Or third, you know, 25, and how are we gonna make it up the next week? Like, that's what I want the service manager to text me every single Friday because that is the most important metric in the you know what I mean? Like, set up stuff like that that that can help you in your agency. And if you're like me and Craig, you're gonna need that stuff, and that's what we do to like make up for you know make up for lost time. Well, if for us, it's like we're we're not gonna be the most um detailed on that, but like put somebody in charge of that one thing that you know what I mean, so that you don't have to do it.
SPEAKER_00I mean, this is of one of the highest value activities of the agency, right? I basically wasn't really plugged into anything, and that's why this wasn't done. If I'm gonna if I'm gonna not, and and so it's important if I know this is the highest value thing, I definitely should not be answering the phone and helping somebody with a claim instead of doing this, right? Like right, and I think that well, I know that for many years I would find the other thing, reactionary thing that's much easier just to handle instead of the proactive thing that actually is gonna that's actually gonna contribute to better results, yes, and I know that probably came off cold that if somebody has a claim to not help them, but I know what you're saying. Well, no, because you know what? There's somebody else in the office that's much better equipped to do it, right? Do it better, and and that's what they should be doing, right? That's what the team should be doing. If the team was the ones holding themselves accountable for doing 10 quoted households during the day, then it's not gonna happen.
SPEAKER_02Well, it's it's like this you using your time as an investment, looking at it as an investment, what's going to serve you in the future, what's gonna pay off over and over and over again, setting that those systems up, like you focusing on that is going to pay off time and it's gonna be compound uh results, where it's like if you handle that immediate thing, it's just the what you're handling that day, and it's done. So it's squashed, it's gone. It's like it you're not getting the compound results from it. So I think that the high-level um agent need to needs to look at the compounding result type thing. Like, how do we take our time with 10 minutes today that will pay off dividends in the future? Right? Dividends, which is it's hard to do. It's not the easiest thing. It's not, it's not. You gotta do it. Do you want to sign us out, Craig? Can you do that?
SPEAKER_00Well, if you haven't been to our web page on the uh worldwide web, that's www.theudes.com. There's a great cartoon of Mr. Jason over there without his believe hat. And if you like this, go ahead and hit the go ahead and pound the subscribe button with one of those hammers from Super Mario Brothers. Yes.
SPEAKER_02Uh a link to the hammer uh to the Amazon link will be in the comments below. Can you get those now?
unknownNo, I don't know.
SPEAKER_00From the Koopa Trupas, right? Oh no, they have boomerangs. Anyway, we'll see you on the flippity flip.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman