The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
5 Reasons Why Insurance Leads Don't Work | Insurance Agency Playbook
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
Five quint quintessential.
SPEAKER_01They still don't they? Yeah. Because leads are not the way to get clients, are they? No. And you know what? Especially especially when they're bad leads. Yeah. For all you haters out there, it's like, oh, internet leads this, uh, mailers this. Dude, here the bottom line is we have to have leads. We need people. So don't be a hater if you you're into mailers. I mean, it's still leads, even though you want to, you know, tear down the entire forest to get one sale. You can do it that way.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. I remember when, well, I barely remember back when I was young, but over at Merrill Lynch, you know, same, same type of thing. It's a funnel, right? You got to make dials, you got to make contacts. From contacts, you got to make uh set the appointment and that whole thing, right? Same, same situation. And it was very difficult, especially whilst young, to focus on the activity and not the result, right? With that, when you're younger, you have that that need for immediate gratification. So it's really hard to go, man, I have to make a hundred dials today so that I book an appointment in a week that's gonna lead to a sale in a month, right? Was really challenging, and that's where I think even some discussions we've had in some of the groups online is around that, right? Like, right, but we know at the end of the day, to what you just said, you have to have quotes, right? Like, and the only way to get quotes is to have people, right?
SPEAKER_01And you already have the you're already paying for the people, so the best use of the person that you're paying, let's say a hundred and something dollars for for the day to put as many people in front of them as they can because then you're getting a better value, yep.
SPEAKER_00And and so and you pay them a hundred dollars a day. How much did you pay to get that one quote from that person? 100. What if they did 10? There you go, 10 bucks. Oh, wow, that seems better.
SPEAKER_01That does seem better. So, and I I'd like to say, like, the emotional part that you talked about from Merrill Lynch is what they're feeling every day, and us as the uh business owner, we have to uh be cognizant of that and um know that. So, like, like what can we do to help? So, here's five reasons why they don't work. Let's dive into number one. Yes, yes, the person doesn't make enough calls. If you're not making enough calls on your leads, then guess what? Leads ain't gonna work. No, I'm talking about mailers, I'm talking about even if they walk into the office, like you gotta call them back, right?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, well, I would argue that there is not a single producer in this country who makes enough dials to make leads work. There's not one, no, and you know why? Because we know how many dials it takes to make contact, and then how many contacts it takes to get to the quote. So just by default, there's there's not enough time in the day for that producer to make enough dials, at least from on those internet leads, repetitively, right? We did it, and they what happened? They left. Yep. So now that we got a little catch catch 22, huh? They don't make enough dials, but they need to make the dials, but they can't, right?
SPEAKER_01And even so let's go further down the funnel and just talk about like the quote and the follow-up to the quote and everything. Yes, I I would say that there's still never enough, like your sales agents, and and so many times I would ask sales agents before it was automated in the agency. Um, how many, how many times did you call that lead back? Yeah, and it was always like, oh, six, seven, eight times. And we go to find out it was like three times. It's like three, usually max cap out of three, right? Yeah, it's like, dude, call them back, text them, email them. Like, don't, you know what? They don't do it because they feel like they're bugging them, but like, yes, bug them. And when they say you're bugging me, say, Well, this is very important to me. I think it's very important to you, and and I'm passionate about what I do. That's the only reason. If you don't want me to call you, tell me you don't want good coverage, and I will never call you again.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I remember I remember talking to so many producers and and getting them to move past the the thing in their head where they say, Well, I'm not gonna call this one because they just never answer. Well, none of them ever answer until they do. Yep.
SPEAKER_01Okay, so number so number two, the reasons why uh insurance leads don't work, the team ejects from the phone call, does not stay on the phone.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's like the it's like the old saying, never trust a skinny chef. I think you never trust a quiet salesperson.
SPEAKER_01You that beginning of that phone call conversation for anybody for any leads that you're buying, nobody wants the quote, nobody wants to talk to you, nobody wants to talk to you, right? You're the unwanted guest at that at that point, so it's like unwanted pest, yes, unwanted pest. At that point, just stay on the phone, just keep talking to them. It's so unnatural to do that. Most people don't do it, but like that's the skill that needs to happen, yeah. Otherwise, those leads are a waste. Gotta flip them from that unwanted pest to the welcomed guest. That's it. That's it. All right, number three, does not connect with the prospect.
SPEAKER_00At first, when I read that, I thought you meant like doesn't connect, like the the call doesn't ever happen, but that's number one, doesn't make enough phone calls. I know what you mean with this. It's like the one with the with our uh with our wives, yeah. We don't connect enough. So you're gonna sleep on your side of the bed, right?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and and the thing is is that like going through a quote, there's so many like pieces of information that you need that it can turn very robotic quickly. So it's like when you're talking about insurance, don't talk about insurance, like connect with the person. And and if somebody's do in your agency and they're doing a lot of quotes and stuff like that, they're gonna try to get through it quickly, they're gonna default back to not connecting as much, but that connection is everything, yeah.
SPEAKER_00And they need to be at the the height of their emotional game on every call, right? Yeah, what happens at the end of the day? Well, you know, they're a little drained, they're a little tired, and this is the tough part is you do not want to be drained at the end of the day because this is the time of the day where the most action happens. Like people are answering the phone more, we're getting some more transfer, like all that stuff happens, so they need they need to be focused. Yep.
SPEAKER_01Okay, so number four, this is this is all true. This is the top five reasons that that it that leads do not work in all agencies, like these are the top five. And number four is the agent talks them out of getting the policy.
SPEAKER_00Don't you have a an example of this happening in my office way back when? And you heard it while we were on a call, yeah. And I was like, Did you hear that? What did he say?
SPEAKER_01I think he literally said he said, like, or or you could it was like at the end of the conversation, and he gave like he like said something, and then he said, Or you could, or I could just call you back tomorrow and you can think about it, and right, and it was like, wait a minute, why like literally closed him?
SPEAKER_00He said, So all I need to do get this started is bla bla blah, and uh I can it, you know, he said it, and then he waited and then he said, Or I can honor all of your excuses that you have right now, and we'll just talk tomorrow.
SPEAKER_01But then not only did he honor it, he kept like talking about it. So then I'll just call back tomorrow and then figure it out, and then you can just like like like he kept unraveling what he just did, and but I thought it was funny because that's I mean, that's what you hear everybody in the office do because they and they don't realize what they're doing, right? They think that they're like, oh, this is gonna help them out even more. No, it's not right. If we all spent a hundred hours a day making decisions on insurance and like like you know, what colors to wear, it's like we would never be making important decisions. Well, like you do spend a lot of time on colors to wear. Oh, yeah, I do. So I mean, it's just like it's more empathetic to save everybody's time. Time is worth money.
SPEAKER_00Well, you know, they sometimes they I remember somebody here saying like shopping with their wallet, like you do not want the producer to shop or the sales agent to shop with their own wallet, right? Maybe somebody uh you know a 22-year-old sales producer is gonna have a different perspective on a $2,000 premium than a 50-year-old. Yep.
SPEAKER_01So I'm gonna give you the number one thing out of these five things, right? Well, we're up to the point where we've done the quotes. So agent Sam has enough quotes now. So what is the number one reason why uh insurance leads suck even if you get enough quotes? Here it is, because the agent doesn't follow up enough after the quote and fast enough. This is one hundred percent, dude. The difference in close rate on this one thing, I guarantee you, if you follow these five things, your agents will dominate.
SPEAKER_00But like this one, dude. Well, this one you can everybody on this, everybody listening can can think back to this happening, right? Yeah, like where their person goes out of town because they uh their sales agent goes out of town to take vacation, whatever. What happens when they get back? Dead, right? Yeah, all of a sudden their pipeline's dead because all those people who they needed to follow up with during the time that they were gone now didn't get followed up with enough or fast enough, and they're all gone. They're all they all got geico. Yep.
SPEAKER_01So what what do you mean by this? Well, this is the number one thing that you're gonna hit for your salespeople. Well, they don't get paid till Friday. Next Friday, they're getting paid, then they put the task out to that day. And guess what happens? Craig's agency closes them. Why? Because, and this is the number one thing. Write this down right now. I will today change my CRM to follow up with every single day. Well, it's gonna annoy them. They told me to follow up next week. I don't care. We've beta tested this like so many tens of thousands of times, like they need to follow up every single day. 80% of a conversation will be lost within 24 hours. That is like science, right there. I don't have the the scientific reference for it, but I know I've read that somewhere that somebody will lose 80% of a conversation within 24 hours, so they're not even gonna remember what the rest of it, like in the next the next 48 hours, is gone, so they have nothing after three days, yeah. And for us, it might be a lot sooner five minutes for me, right? So that's it, dude. Have your agents follow up every single day. Well, what am I gonna talk about? Talk about the talk about the stuff that you connected with. It doesn't matter, they're not gonna answer anyway. Yeah, that that is the truth. Call them every single day.
SPEAKER_00That's it. Well, think of it, like think of just numbers-wise, to beat a dead horse. If if you had a hundred people and you didn't call them because you don't want to bother them and make and call them too many times, how many of those people are you gonna close? None, yeah, none of them are gonna call back when they said they're gonna call back. If you bothered, right, quote unquote, bothered them by calling them every single day. How many of that hundred are gonna close? Some amount. Yep, right? And if we continue forever to call once a day, forever, until they say either buy, don't ever call me, I hate you. I mean, eventually they are going to buy.
SPEAKER_01So now you know the top five reasons of why leads don't work. Flip those around, actually do those five things, and now leads work. Now you just need to put a lot of those leads in front of your agents, and then guess what happens? The magic months later, you're selling a lot of policies. Yep. You get through the dip, and then it just that's it. So if you like this, please subscribe, and we will see you soon. Hey, don't we have a web page? You can't end the end the thing quickly, can you? Bye everyone.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman