The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
The Walk of Fame - 5 Hiring Hacks for P&C Agency Success | Insurance Agency Playbook
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
Good afternoon, Fettis. How are you doing? The Walk of Fame, five hiring hacks for PC agency success. What a great way to follow up the walk of shame. This is a fantastic way. So now we're gonna we're gonna help speed this up, right?
SPEAKER_01Oh yeah. Because if you can eliminate the friction and then add on strategies that will actually work in your agency.
SPEAKER_00So let's take what we learned from all of those mistakes and let's dive into number one of five. But first, insurance is I are in now. I am profitable. I am great. I am able to felt we are able. We are interested. Number one, slow down to speed up. Oh, what do you feel about that?
SPEAKER_01Slow down to speed up. Well, I think we need to fire fast, hire slow. Ooh, we talked about the biggest mistake being that we don't do that, right? Like that we're we're too quick, we're trying to move. It's grilled into us, right? It's the pace of our society, and we need to we need to pull back. And when you actually get yourself into that flow state where you're where it's working, we have a flow, and there's constant candidates coming into the refundal, it changes it, right? You don't have candidates as a scarce commodity when you have an abundance of them. All of a sudden, now you can pick and choose. When you have enough or even too many people in the agency, you have a lot of options, right? You don't have to get this person, you can go for the best of the best instead.
SPEAKER_00Yes. And pro tip if you are firing someone, the best way, the most empathetic way to do this is to have them self-select out. How do we do this? One of my favorite things to do is get real clear on exactly what we expect. Have the conversation with them. This is what this role needs. This is exactly what is needed to be done daily. And if it's something that they don't want to do, say, hey, we have these uh KPIs that you need to do every single day. You've agreed to do them, but you're not doing them. Is this something you actually want to do? Or is it not? Because if you wanted to do it, you would do it, and if you didn't want to do it, well, you're not. So is this the wrong position for you? But you need to be honest with me about it, right? Make it about the the KPIs, not about the person. Yes. So you get them to come to the realization that they don't want to work with you. This is a great move, it's one of my favorites. Um, and then it's their decision rather than yours, yeah.
SPEAKER_01And for anyone who watches curb your enthusiasm, you could always foist them. Right. Truth, yep. All right, number two. Number two, culture is king. Love it. Yeah, we got it. We must involve our team, we must create a a sense of camaraderie there. You've probably found if you if you're running daily meetings, how much that's helped. Uh, but culture is king. So when you involve your your team in interviews, when you involve your team in the selection process, now they have buy-in not only to the process, but to the candidates as they come in. Yep.
SPEAKER_00And Napoleon Hill wrote a book and he talks a lot about this concept of a mastermind. Um, think and grow rich, right? Was that it? Or laws of success. Well, one of them has mastermind in it. And so the idea is this is you take two people together and it multiplies, you know, one plus one equals three, in other words. And so when you're able to build a good team that are all rowing in the same direction, like the Lakers of the what was it, the late 90s? Was that the Lakers time? Well, whatever.
SPEAKER_01But I think the 80s, late 80s, you be magic and everybody.
SPEAKER_00It was like yeah, well, what about Kobe?
SPEAKER_01Oh, Kobe, the baby rest of peace. Uh, yes, that was 90s, yeah. Well, but like it's so true.
SPEAKER_00Like, if everybody's way better than Jordan, or it has if you have a good culture in your agency, it's gonna ex like exponentially get better. Like, the all boats are gonna rise with rising tides, right? So, yeah, even though it's really important to have the right culture, it will drive your agency.
SPEAKER_01Yep, and it makes it fun. Yep, like when the team shows up somewhere where they like to be, that's it's good, right? You're gonna get more productivity out of them, they're gonna enjoy themselves, you're making them have a better life. And you're gonna well, I would much much rather my team go home and when they're talking to their family, they say they love what they do versus I hate getting up every morning, right? Like that, that's not great. And if they hate getting up every morning, it's probably gonna become something that you may feel the same way because if if it just has that energy of the workplace, it's not great.
SPEAKER_00A hundred percent. Yeah, yeah. So, number three, skills over experience.
SPEAKER_01Yes, we we need to look at skills, at work ethic, at drive, way more than experience and knowledge because we can always teach knowledge, right? They're gonna gain experience, actually. But if they're the if we're able to mold them now and they haven't ever done this, then the experience that they gain will only be through our lens, and they're gonna be much more effective in our agency.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I've always seen that drive, um just that like that drive goes so much further than experience in an agency. It's almost as if if they've been in an agency for a long time, they're like a worn-out shoe. There's not much soul in that. Oh no, you didn't. Yeah, I did. I did that. That was good stuff. Yep. So number four.
SPEAKER_01Number four, due diligence is a must. Ooh. Yep. We talked about background checks. I'm gonna talk about it again. So we want to have the strategy of looking, you've got to look at those at their at the full package and do that due diligence. We're gonna look at their resume. Now, resume tend to have some colorful exaggerations at times, so be mindful of that and really dig into that resume in the interview. We want that's due diligence, right? You're you're asking questions about the resume, not are you sure you worked here for this, you know. No, but you know, put them in a situational question involving that work and try to figure out if if they're being as honest about what they what they said they did as they as they say on their paper. We want to also uh make sure that we do assessments, whether you do a disc profile or you do uh sales strength, whatever you do, we want to you're gonna get you're gonna be gathering information, right? It's almost like you're you're the doctor of hiring and you're gathering all of your intel to make that diagnosis. And the diagnosis is hired or not hired. Yep.
SPEAKER_00Chance marginal, I think it's very important to so we talked uh last week about checking references, but dude, having assessments is so key because you need some sort of constant. That's why we ask a lot of the same questions in interviews, even if they're ridiculous, just to see the response so that we can understand like the the different responses per person. The only way that you can tell if the response is is uh wild or maybe it's tamed down or whatever is to just pin it against other people. So, same with assessments. Assessments, it's not a set in stone type thing, but if everybody's getting asked the same questions, you can see how they'll answer them against the other people that are coming into your um agency. So assessments are key, key. It quantifies, yeah.
SPEAKER_01Well, you're able to set that just like anything else, any other process, you're able to create that benchmark and then know where somebody lies compared to that because it every agency is different at different profiles, may perform better in different agencies, too. So, like we say with the folks with teledus, it's setting their initial metrics and their benchmarks, it's the same thing with everything. We need to determine, you know, when when you go to the gym, if you have a trader, they're gonna figure out what are your base weight, what can you lift, right? How much can you curl? How much can you bench press, all the different things because now we're gonna be able to track and measure growth. Yep. And then the final one. I love number five because we talked about how so onboarding like a pro, you've gotta onboard like a pro. Remember, when somebody starts, this is their impression of their new career. So if they walk in the door and right now you're building the plane as it's taking off, they're not gonna have the best feeling, right? They're gonna have this like, eh, what the heck? I'm not sure about this. It's like think back to a job that you started where somebody was vastly unprepared for you to start, and and what you got out of that job and how much you were, how much you really contributed versus somebody who took you in, mentored you, told you what was gonna happen, and then all of those things happened according to plan, right? It's it's it's the difference between amateur hour and being a professional. So it will take you a little time, a little time to think things over. Yeah, just kidding. That's a the song quote. Take take a little time. Uh yeah, sorry, I I digress. No, it's gonna take it'll take some time to put that together, but once you once all this stuff is there, then it's the same thing over and over again, right? You can make loop videos, you can do whatever you need to to automate it because a lot of this stuff can be automated. Doesn't mean you need to explain how to log into the computer 4,000 times for each person, it just you have a video, you know, make a system.
SPEAKER_00But look look at it this way: if you can cut down what takes three months to happen, sometimes in some agencies, six months to happen, if you can get it down to like a month, think about how much money you're actually saving. Because if the person, so so there's two points to this. First one, if the person can do what would normally take them three months in one month, and they're five thousand a month, that means you just save ten thousand dollars by being able to uh slim that process down to a one-month area. So that's number one is that you'll save money. Number two is that a players like a to be with other a players, they like to be on a winning team. Going back to like the Kobe reference, right? Kobe wanted to be on a winning team, he didn't want to be on a bunch of crappy people's teams, you know. That's why he was with them. Yeah, that's why he's at the Lakers. So when you offer onboarding that is like a pro, like, here's the process, this is what is expected of you every single week. Well, now that person, if they are an A player, feels very confident about this new job. Where you might have lost them if you just had them sit down and shadow somebody else and kind of be bored, you know what I mean? To like challenge, you want to be able to challenge your new people a little bit from the get to see if they're the right person. And you know what? If you challenge them and they're the wrong person, they expected to just chill because that's what a lot of um agencies provide is an office that's that you just chill. Well, good, and they leave, right? Well, now they left within the first week rather than six months later, and they didn't do anything, yeah. So again, it's gonna save you money, yeah.
SPEAKER_01So you don't want to chill it, you don't want to chill it or gel it.
SPEAKER_00So that's it. So we had slow down to speed up, culture is king, skills over experience, do your deal due diligence and on board like a pro. Now it's time to be on the Lakers.
SPEAKER_01Yep, you want to get your agency, take your agency higher, go higher. Go higher, and and it's possible Kobe was on the Lakers because of the Taco Bell that Shaq would give him. I don't know, it's just a theory. But if you like what you heard, make sure you subscribe, throw us a comment, a like, whatever. You know, anything. We appreciate it. Thanks for listening.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman