The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Dr. Nicole Price's Priceless Noteworthy Voyage PART 2
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
You are not empathetic or not, you can learn to be empathetic. It is a muscle that you can, well, it's like a muscle that you can build like everything else if you practice. This is possible, and you can start wherever you want. And I give you the entire blueprint in the book, Spark the Heart, Engineering Empathy in Your Organization.
SPEAKER_04It's curved, auto, it's a good thing. I are interested. I am a great doctor. I am Africa. We are agreed. We are insurance.
SPEAKER_05I would say, you know, I I think that um I think it's the one thing that can be passed over. Like it, like with all the worries of a business owner and, you know, everything that we think about, that we think like, oh, we need to handle the things that are on fire right now, like the mad client, the the bills, this person uh called out sick. But so it's so easy that to like, as far as like the you know, empathy part and cut actually talking to people and like it seems like it's a it's not worth the time, right? It's like, oh my gosh, there's so many things. I think that um I think people just need to realize that like all the things that you think that you're worrying about actually will get better if you spend the time on the things that you think don't matter. So uh and I would say one story I have is like my wife was she's gonna thank God she's gonna be. She's not gonna hear this. No, she she hates this. So um she worked as a Starbucks manager when when she was young, and actually right across the street from here, uh and she uh uh had a ton of employees. So this was you know 20 years ago, and it was you know, with back then it we were less empathetic, uh, you know, uh as a society, let's say, you know, so it's like it's like don't show up to work, then you're blah, blah, blah. It's like just just rule based. Well, when I started scaling my insurance agency, I was spending a lot of time on the phone with like like a sales agent that was crying about something, or like, you know what I mean? It was like a lot of conversations. She's like, You're like a a therapist. What are you doing? Like, you shouldn't do that. You should just fire them if they're gonna be like that. It's like, oh, but like, well, some of the stuff that I maybe I took it a little far far of the conversations of maybe, I don't know.
SPEAKER_02I'm just saying, were you operating like a therapist completely outside your licensure?
SPEAKER_05A little bit, uh a little bit, maybe, maybe a little bit. I mean, I had a lot of people. Sometimes it's what it takes, you know. Like that's the thing, and that was the realization was that is what it takes. And sometimes that person does need a little help that's maybe outside of work a little bit, you know. I you gotta draw your own personal boundaries, I guess. But um, but like like those conversations were so important.
SPEAKER_03What were we just saying? Well, just like those situations where you make a difference and you help somebody in that same way, like when it when it comes to down the down the line when the other person is trashing you and trying to do something wrong, they're like, uh-uh. Uh-uh. They got your back. You build an army of people that have your back, and you've got a lot more protection than than just going by oh, you're late by one minute, get out of here, right? Like, right. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02I've got one tool I want to leave with your listeners. Um, so let me know when's the best time to share that. Because I I want people to try just one little thing.
SPEAKER_05Love it. I would love to hear it. Yeah, do it. So just do it. Let's go for it.
SPEAKER_02So I want and I want them to pick someone, their oldest customers, oldest, like oldest in age or oldest in tenure. Oldest in age.
SPEAKER_03Okay.
SPEAKER_02And I want them to do a ride-along and act as if the person got stopped by the police. Let's assume this is car insurance, auto insurance.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_02And I want you to help them try to find their insurance card on their phone. And then after you experience that, what do you think you need to change about your process to be able to help them?
SPEAKER_03And that's empathy, right? That yes.
SPEAKER_02That's correct. Um, because what one of the reasons why I started what I call that's I call that the empathy walk. And you can redirect it to whatever you need it to be, um, whatever you know, customers you think struggle the most, but go and spend a day in their life so you can get a chance to see. We some of our clients are lawyers and judges, and so we went to this huge conference mostly for judges. Well, use all your biases. How old do you think the people are? They're mostly judges.
SPEAKER_0350. 70.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, 67. Yeah. Wow. So we were after I to be a to be a judge, right? So these are mostly judges. So we get to um after I give my keynote, and we've got our book booth set up, and we didn't bring any paper, we just got a QR code on the thing. Some of them had flip phones. I know, and I have some strong beliefs about how in the world did you still have a flip phone in 2023? Right, it's like a fax machine, and I'm 1000% correct in my opinions. And if I'm gonna have judges as clients, how effective am I? Ineffective, ineffective because when I'm being empathetic, they first of all, if you're a judge, you are thinking that you have arrived. Nobody's gonna tell you what to do in terms of what phone's gonna work or not. Uh, number two, oftentimes they're in spaces where they can't have cameras, depending on what kind of courthouse they work in. Number three, do I want them to get the book or not? And if that flip phone is not scanning a QR code, and so I could easily have brought some books there that they could pay for right there, and I just didn't because I was not thinking about what their needs were. I was thinking about mine.
SPEAKER_05I love that perspective of just flipping it. So, how many times do do we as the average human like tend to go, I can't believe they blah blah blah blank, right? But it's like it's the opposite. I can't believe I why didn't I expect that? Like, because I didn't think about yeah.
SPEAKER_02Because if when I thought about it, I'm like, of course they don't have relevant technology. We've seen this um play out on television in a few like real life situations, and um I can choose to be right or I can choose to be effective.
SPEAKER_03Ooh, being right is ineffit insufficient for being effective. That's that's Greg's favorite. Not even favorite line. It's not even necessary to my wife all the time. She it's her favorite line that I say.
SPEAKER_02I love I love talking points.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, so I don't say it when I'm right, only when I'm wrong. Then I say being right is inefficient for being effective. Yeah. And then she goes, shut up, get out of here.
SPEAKER_02And it's like, you know, I don't want to carry inventory, I don't want to go to a conference with all these books and then have to come back with them. But the thing is, now that I've designed for the neediest, I'm actually selling more books. The QR code people have what they need, the people who don't have that have get what they need. It's win-win.
SPEAKER_03Right. Sales 101. It's get you sell them what they want and then give them what they need, and that's like you gotta give them that thing.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, it's funny. I was I was thinking about what you were saying uh with the empathetic part towards our clients, and I I and I would say as a whole, insurance agents are true like super empathetic of their clients, just like not but not their staff.
SPEAKER_02Oh my gosh, so this is good to know. So schools are like that. What do you mean? Principals are very empathetic towards the children, uh the teachers and staff, not so much. Um, and so this is good. This is good to know because what that looks like is that leaders have to remember that how you treat your people is how they treat your people.
SPEAKER_05100%.
SPEAKER_02I I will die on that hill. Like you if you think that you can berate people and then they're gonna show up in beautiful ways for your clients. I got some beachfront property to sell you right here in Missouri.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, a good, a really good buddy of mine from actually I've known since kindergarten, but um, he worked with Tony Robbins for a long time. And and uh oh, I just lost my train of thought. What the heck? Beachfront property. That's what threw me around. I thought that's what got you.
SPEAKER_02Your leaders um need to pour into their people in order for their people to oh yeah, yeah, I'm sorry.
SPEAKER_03Oh, the he would always start the thing, like when he did a talk, he'd say, Who who is your number one client? And it's you know, it's a trick question because the number one client is your staff. That's your number one client. Because if you if you don't treat them well, your clients aren't going to be treated well. And so and it is coming from that place of empathy, right? You have to understand them, you have to understand what that what drives them, what makes them tick. It's not money, usually.
SPEAKER_02And so if you pay decent, it's not money.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, if it was if it was money, then they would have a business because they would see that that's the way to get to the level of just not you know this fixed amount.
SPEAKER_05So yeah, and then I think on the other side of that, it's less empathy for their um team, more empathy for their current clients, and less empathy for the market, like, like, as in like you know, the markets changed a lot since the old day of the way things were done. So a lot of agents are very like hands-on and stuff, but like to your point, showing them how to do the like the mobile app, they're like, ah, screw the mobile thing. Like, they're not they're not moving along with that, so they're not being so empathetic with like the changing climate of what's going on in the marketplace, you know.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and maybe it's not my responsibility to teach somebody something, but again, do you want to be right or do you want to be effective? That's it. Absolutely taught people how to use video devices. I've taught people how to use the QR code. And is that my job? Absolutely not. But when I ask questions like, hey, do you want to do video chat with your grandchild? But you told me you had a grandchild. Did you want to see your grandchild every day? That's a good reason to get a smartphone. And I think I converted a couple judges right then to oh yeah, I didn't think about that, you know.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, love it.
SPEAKER_02And they can call you up on video and you can all time FaceTime, yeah. Netflix phone won't let you do that.
SPEAKER_03No, although I did have some conversations with my folks on FaceTime and it did not work very well. They couldn't figure it out. They're like, We can't see you, and I'm like, I I don't know. I can see you, I don't know what the hell's going on here.
SPEAKER_02You gotta show them when you you gotta show them when you're with them next time.
SPEAKER_03I wasn't being empathetic.
SPEAKER_02Well, I mean, it can be kind of frustrating because it's so second nature to us, right? And that if nobody listens to anything else I say, that's what it is. That's when we need to lean into empathy even more when you're like I'm so surprised, that's your indication that you you don't have enough proximity to even be able to be effective with that person. So, how can you do a better job of like getting into their shoes?
SPEAKER_03Interesting. I love it. So if you become frustrated or surprised by the thing they have, you're instead of going, get out of here, go, oh, get close the opportunity. The opportunity has come.
SPEAKER_02That's what I call it.
SPEAKER_03Get close, get close.
SPEAKER_02And breathe, okay? Because pressure will go up.
SPEAKER_05What are some things as a business owner, insurance agent, whatever, human? Um, what are some things that would help us on this journey? Just some exercises that I love the one that you just gave of you know, helping the empathy walk is my favorite one.
SPEAKER_02My second favorite one is called empathetic listening. Um, and it's so it sounds like that both of you are skilled in this, but sometimes we listen not to solve the problem, sometimes we listen just because the person needs to talk.
SPEAKER_03I'm working on that. Yeah, my wife is in the process.
SPEAKER_02The reason for listening empathetically is to benefit the speaker, not the listener. And sometimes, especially when somebody's views are drastically different from mine, I lean solidly into empathetic listening. I know. Well, you know how you practice is watch a news station that you don't typically watch.
SPEAKER_03I don't watch any of them.
SPEAKER_02Oh, have fun, watch some any of it. Give yourself like two minutes, you don't have to do it for a long time. But listen again, you're not judging what's being said, you're just saying me sitting here listening right now is benefiting the person who's talking. And I suggest doing it in those difficult points because then it's a lot easier when you're doing it for somebody on your staff when you've done it in the hardest ways.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, I love that. That's so cool.
SPEAKER_02Those are my those are my two favorite exercises. But you know, I we just finished our empathy 14, and it's um it's something you can do anytime you want, but every August 1st, I do 14 days worth of real simple exercises, like publicly, with um anybody who follows me on any of my social uh channels. Wow, and and so there's these really, yeah, you just missed it, but there's but you can do it anytime. You don't need to be with me to do it, but that's just when I do it publicly. And there's simple things like um, you know, imagine that you have a specific situation and what challenges would that cause you if you were trying to get a job as an example. So you know how people say, Oh, there's all these places to work. How are people out here with signs on the street? Well, let me take your ID, your address, your car. Now apply for a job, please. And all your money and your clothes, and you smell because you can only shower in the McDonald's.
SPEAKER_03And you're really drunk.
SPEAKER_02And it's just like, okay, um, what is that what does that look like to have to deal with that situation? And I don't expect anybody ever to be charitable if they don't want to be. And when you're judging, you're not helping.
SPEAKER_05Totally. That is such a good perspective because it's so hard to be around. It's funny, we all judge to some extent. Like, there's no getting around it. But like with yeah, well, it's so many times like you get in, like when I know when I will get judgy, it's like I'm doing the thing that I don't like. You know what I mean? It's like, ah, it's like I'm doing the thing I'm complaining about.
SPEAKER_02Yes, like you know, you know what was hardest for me when I first started like really paying attention to empathy is I would notice these naturally empathetic people, because remember, I'm not naturally empathetic, who would be so judgmental of the rest of us. Like, how could you not consider? And I was like, what? So then I start judging them for judging us. You see, it's like this horrible cycle, it's just this endless cycle, and somebody's gotta stop it. And so I'm saying, Hey, my name is Nicole, the uh honorary insurance student, and I'm going first, and I'm just inviting a whole bunch of people to join me.
SPEAKER_03Well, it's like you have to set aside the eagle, get the awareness that it's even happening because most folks don't even realize that it's happening or that it exists or that this is a thing, right? And then, oh, I'm aware, now I can be empathetic, I'll get results.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and it's gonna take practice, you know. I in this microwave society, people are like, oh, we're gonna do this like three weeks, and then I got it. Um, I've been working on this for a really long time, uh actively since 2014. And I will say that now people can't tell the difference. Like I'll just be in some random grocery store line and somebody'll start pouring their heart out to me. And I used to say, Is it do I have something printed on my forehead tell me about your problems? But someone told me once, they said it's in the eyes. People can tell that you you care about what they have to say. So I wear sunglasses. No, just that works, that works, it keeps it keeps it down.
SPEAKER_05Oh, it's funny. So I have to tell you something funny before before we uh wrap this up. Is that it's so funny that you like when I first started in this insurance agency, we had a a couple clients that were um engineers, and it got to a point when we were selling, it's like when you get an engineer, it is so hard to judge in this case. It's all numbers, it's all facts, and like they just it's like you can't you try to laugh, you try, hey, you know, like try to like nope, it's like numbers, facts, blah blah blah.
SPEAKER_03So, like send me the policy jacket, I'm gonna read it. Yeah, but I want to know if you haven't read it. Nobody reads that. We use it for kindling. Come on, yeah, kindling, just kidding.
SPEAKER_05But it's so funny because I like especially with our our staff and and stuff, the engineers are the are the toughies, they're gonna they're gonna find out because they don't care if you care about them, but they care about if you know all the information on the policy and like you went through the form. That's how you're empathetic to an engineer.
SPEAKER_02I know that's what I'm saying. You can't let me listen. I'm telling you, I that was I resemble those comments, and uh yeah, it's like who's the person who knows everything that their their car manual says? Like, I know all these weird things my phone does.
SPEAKER_03It's like just I don't, but I will so funny, like okay. So the the agent, like let full circle, right? Back to the beginning. The a your insurance agent was being empathetic, but not empathetic to your to me.
SPEAKER_02That's she was showing up in the way that she valued instead of understanding who I was at that moment and giving me what I needed.
SPEAKER_03She was being nice, not empathetic.
SPEAKER_02I've learned so much, but she was genuinely nice, though.
SPEAKER_05So that's and I was a fake nice, and I was like, This is fake nice, there's no way there's no way you were not being nice because you got the facts, you learned that she went through your social media. You had you listed out all the stuff, like if she would have came to you like this is all the stuff I've done now, presented it to you. You'd have been like, All right, you did your you did your research, yeah, incredible check.
SPEAKER_03Not sure why, but okay.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah. That's a very astute point. So she did pivot a little bit, right? Like she let me know she was incredible.
SPEAKER_03So then I don't know how she has the time to stock all the clients like that.
SPEAKER_02Maybe she doesn't. I don't know that she does, right? Like maybe she doesn't, maybe she does is genuinely stuff. Oh, the ones that show up on the insurance dudes. Yeah, the most famous, most famous.
SPEAKER_05Awesome. What's what's one thing that you want everyone to know before you leave?
SPEAKER_02And then I want to know uh how people can get a hold of you and where they can buy the book, all the books, and all you're you're not empathetic or not, you can learn to be empathetic. It is a muscle that you can well, it's like a muscle that you can build like everything else if you practice. This is possible, and you can start wherever you want, and I give you the entire blueprint in the book, Spark the Heart, Engineering Empathy in your organization. It's funny. I make a lot of fun of myself. I tell you how I get it wrong, but they're actionable tools for how to build empathy in yourself and in your leadership team if your if your team is that large. And you can find out anything about the book or me at drnicoleprice.com. And that's my same name for all my social handles, Dr.
SPEAKER_03Nicole Price. Dr. Dr or Dr. Spelled Out.
SPEAKER_02Who would spell it out? What kind of pathology makes a person? I'm just kidding.
SPEAKER_03I mean, what if I'm just trying to be empathetic and put myself in the shoes of the listeners?
SPEAKER_02Oh, so funny thing. My son is an entrepreneur and his business is Dr. Paws spelled out.
SPEAKER_05Oh, no way. And he said, Who would shorten it? It looks so unprofessional. Oh, you gotta tell him about this. I know.
SPEAKER_02But while it was coming out of my mouth, I'm like, oh gosh, I just said something bad about my own child.
SPEAKER_05No, you gotta say, Well, you know what? You know who's empathetic to you? This old guy, old insurance guy I talked to today.
SPEAKER_02Who was curious and he had questions.
SPEAKER_03I do have one more question.
SPEAKER_02What is it? I love answering.
SPEAKER_03Because you're talking about practice and and then like gaining, you know, using that muscle memory and all that. Like one of the things that's been very helpful for me is meditation. Um, and and they, you know, it's referred to as a practice, right? Because you don't just do it and then you're done. It's it's and I notice when I don't, I'm a little more scattered. The ADHD gets worse, right? Like if I don't, I I must meditate. And then, and that's for me, because you know, the thoughts still keep coming, right? And the whole point is to not like push them out, but to notice them and not judge them and just kind of let them float away. And so for me, it's been effective and interesting. I think that it's also been helpful for empathy because it it does help kind of sanitize the amount of judgment that comes out of this thing, right?
SPEAKER_02Listen, if you are uh scattered and unfocused in general, it's gonna be hard for you to be empathetic to yourself, which will also make it hard to be empathetic to other people. One of the 14 days is mindfulness, practicing, you know, you don't have to do the whole transcendental meditation class if you don't want to, but just a moment of silence to just focus the mind is helpful.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, it doesn't matter. Some breathing.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, you you want to know what oil and water is. What it's an engineer with somebody with ADHD. Like, no, but we're having a good it's like a perfect. No, I say that because I ADHD, my wife is a very much an engineer, like on the disc profile, she's got zero eye. Oh, like, yeah, and I'm like 99 eye. So talk about like empathy. Like, we're having to learn. Well, we've been together for 20 years. We're having to, we're still learning about how she thinks I do all this wacky stuff because I don't think about it, like I'm not putting enough time into it, right? But like, that's the way the ADHD brain works, and then she and then like I think about the the way that she does stuff is like, dude, you're so cold by the way you come off, you know what I mean? It's kind of and it's just so funny. Like, is she a high C?
SPEAKER_03Oh, yeah. Um her his wife and my wife have basically the same exact same profiles, disc profiles, and and Jason and I basically have the exact same disc profile, so it's very interesting. And we have the basically the same relationships with our almost equal, yeah.
SPEAKER_02We're yeah, and then s and then like hardly any c no c negative negative 50 on C. Yeah, so I'm I'm kind of not like other engineers in that way. My C is not big, yeah.
SPEAKER_03Oh, that yeah, that is interesting. That is interesting. I would expect it to be a high SC. That's why you're not in. Are you still doing engineering?
SPEAKER_02Oh no, not at all.
SPEAKER_03So see? Oh no.
SPEAKER_02When I started leading engineers, I realized my brain didn't work exactly like engineers.
SPEAKER_03Um you just have a very smart brain, so you went to engineering, but then you're like, I can't deal with this.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, it's the difference between being able to do something and loving to do something. And I was able to do that, I didn't love it. And um, a lot of my ego was taught caught up in hey, I'm an engineer or whatever, and you see, I haven't let it go. Like engineering empathy here. That's what we're doing.
SPEAKER_05Isn't it funny? It's okay, you can do that. It's so funny what the ego holds on to. It's like so self-defeating.
SPEAKER_03It's so many. Oh, and it's it's the wolf in sheep's clothing, too, because it it's telling you that it's protecting you, but it's not, it's not, it's harming you.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I think that's why I think that's why I tell people about it, right? Like, let me just tell you. Yeah, but the engineering stories about lacking empathy, I think they're hilarious, and I and would love to hear from folks if they think they're hilarious too, because today I can't even imagine that I used to show up in those ways.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, I think we all grow up. I I I have a heart for it because again, my wife is more like that, and we're two ends of the spectrum. So I it's like it is, it's oil and water, and it's just fun, like everybody takes everybody's actions completely incorrectly. You know what I mean? Like, have no idea where each other's coming from, so you do need to practice empathy, like it it does help.
SPEAKER_02It helps it does help, and sometimes I can't prove it to you, and that's okay. Some people learn pleasantly by reading a book or following somebody on social media, and there are other people like me who had to learn painfully going through a major grief event, but I do think we all learn, we just get to choose how.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, yeah, great point. Well, Dr. Nicole, this was awesome. Thank you so much. Everybody grabs spark the heart, and and I love Craig's question: where can you get it? On the internet, just googly it.
SPEAKER_02Googly it's on the phone.
SPEAKER_05Can I get there on my flip phone?
SPEAKER_02You can call me and I'll uh give me your address.
SPEAKER_03I don't have a flip phone.
SPEAKER_02But if you got a regular phone, I shouldn't say look at that regular. You see what I just did there? I want you to get it on Amazon, Barnes and Noble, Target.com, anywhere books are sold.
SPEAKER_03Awesome. They still have Target. I thought wow, I haven't been there in a long time.
SPEAKER_02You're probably saving money then.
SPEAKER_03It's the um after COVID, like I haven't gone to a lot of stores anymore. Everything gets delivered because everything gets delivered. Nah, I don't like them.
SPEAKER_02You want to be in the first store line with them telling you about their life stories, like me.
SPEAKER_05Let's preface this with Craig's been um all over the world in the last year and barely at work. So he he's getting out there.
SPEAKER_03He's not working, he's getting out there. I was in Portugal for a month and then I was in Hawaii for a few weeks.
SPEAKER_02So oh not a shame there.
SPEAKER_03It's uh not Maui, though. Not Maui, those poor people.
SPEAKER_02I know the pictures are awful.
SPEAKER_03It's awful, dude. I was on the waves that were part of that whole thing, but I was on Kauai, so we missed it, luckily. But we got the waves, and I almost died from that. So all right.
SPEAKER_02Well, why do we have to do that? I know it's a sad way to close it. Disc profile eyes do not like to close on a sad note. So we don't know.
SPEAKER_05I don't know where that came from. That's an open now. We have an open loop. Open you have a close. All right, all right, all right. Dr. Nicole, thank you so much. Uh, it's been a pleasure. It's it's a subject that I think everybody needs to think more about.
SPEAKER_02All right, thanks for having me.
SPEAKER_05Thank you.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman