The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Dr. Nicole Price's Priceless Noteworthy Voyage PART 1
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
I love my insurance agent, but I didn't at first. In fact, she used to get on my nerves because I thought she was giving me fake empathy and fake care and concern. But over time, uh, with more questions, what I have realized is she has probably read all my products and she watches all my interviews, and she is quite interested in me. And she even remembers things like the day my mother died. So I am Dr. Nicole Price, and I am an honorary insurance dudette.
SPEAKER_03Woo! Yes. Love it.
SPEAKER_02It's all I are in. I am great. I am in the world. We are interested. We are in jerk.
SPEAKER_03So tell us about you thought that like she was just all over you, right? Like it was just it was just too much. Tell me about, like, and I love that you talked about the empathy part, especially uh, you know, regarding your book and everything. So let's dive into that a little bit.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_03And yeah.
SPEAKER_00I thought she was being fake. I thought she had gone to some insurance salesperson's class and they told her to do these 10 things. And so she did them for all her clients and she had a spreadsheet to keep up with me or something. But over time, it was very clear that that's not actually what it was that she was actually interested in the things that I was doing and uses them to run her business. So I do leadership development consulting. At the time that I first met her, I don't know that I was an empathy revolutionary as I am today. And I usually try to figure out how I could get work done despite people and did not want to talk to my insurance agent ever. Like, why are you emailing me? I pay my bill, leave me alone.
SPEAKER_04So why was she trying to connect?
SPEAKER_00Well, I think she that's just who she is, actually. Uh, but I didn't get that right away. Um, but that's probably more because that's not who I was necessarily. So I thought everybody was kind of doing the fake thing, and I'm like, girl, save yourself time. Just send me the link to pay the bill and I'll pay. You ain't gotta do all that. But one day I had done a local interview on a TV show, and she sent me a note commenting about it. And I was like, Oh, well, how'd she even know about that if she's not? I mean, it's like nine o'clock in the morning on daytime news, and I was like, Oh my gosh, she's actually following me. So then I went back and kind of read some of her emails that I was not reading. And I realized that, oh my gosh, like, who's the jerk in this relationship? That would have absolutely been me.
SPEAKER_04Wow. Oh, that's that's that's a big step to actually identify that, right? Yeah, for human, just not just you, anybody, right? For humans to admit wrong.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, listen, she's doing me a service, and I'm paying, she's trying to provide good customer service. And what would I want if I were in that role? I wouldn't want to be ignored, I wouldn't want somebody to assume the worst. I wouldn't want uh someone to act irritated every time I called them. And um that was my work to do. And apparently lots of insurance agents get treated that way until they until they're needed, and that's that's bad. We gotta maybe all of them. All so let's just claim it.
SPEAKER_03All nobody wants to talk to an insurance agent. I don't even want to talk to an insurance agent, like it's it's not the fun phone call, it's like getting a root canal, right?
SPEAKER_00And I don't want to audit my artwork. I know I should, because if something happens, I'll be so mad that I didn't get it all captured.
SPEAKER_04Right. It's that it's like, how much can I get away with before I need the thing? You know, or how much can I procrastinate?
SPEAKER_00Like it's time for me to renew my driver's uh my license plates, and I'm like, oh, where's my insurance card? Even no.
SPEAKER_04Like, I can't believe I don't have it. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00What's my password to get in? But all those things are simple. But yeah, it's you know, I think I'm the worst person to talk about empathy, and people keep telling me that that's not true, but I think I'm the worst because it's not natural. I've had to work on it, I've had to learn how to build it to try to put myself in the shoes of another person to see what they think, feel, and believe. And honestly, it makes us better business owners if we understand people better. Too often people think empathy means that you got to be nice and kind, which that's probably good for business. Um, but understanding honestly, if I could think about one thing she could have done differently, is kind of understood who I was in that moment and maybe reserved a little bit of her mental energy until I was ready for it. Because she was wasting time, yeah.
SPEAKER_04Right coming on a little strong, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_00It's like love bombing or something. I don't know.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, totally. The little BS meter starts going off, and you're like, wait a minute, why why are you being so nice?
SPEAKER_00Why are you being so nice? Am I paying extra?
SPEAKER_04Are you East Coast?
SPEAKER_00I'm actually in the Midwest, isn't that terrible? I'm like Midwest.
SPEAKER_04Oh, you're supposed to be super nice, just like me.
SPEAKER_00That's that's the bad part about the Midwest. We're all like Midwest nice, but this air quotes over here, right? Like we gotta act like it, but I was rolling my eyes and all things.
SPEAKER_04So I think like empathy is one of these things, and and um it's a tough one, right? Like it's tough to know it, understand it. And I think that a lot of people get empathy confused with other, I guess, is it an emotion, other things like compassion, kindness? It's sort of that, but not really, right?
SPEAKER_00That's right. Um, in fact, I would say when my mother died, uh, many people came up at the funeral and they talked about how she was just the kindest person ever. And I remember almost not being able to sit still because I'm like, my mom was empathetic, she was charitable, she would help you, but she wasn't nice. I wouldn't use those words now. Was she gonna feed you? Yes, but she wasn't gonna sit around talking about your puppy all day. Like it wasn't it wasn't happening, and uh, so I think sometimes when people are anti-empathy, they think um about it because they're like, oh, I gotta be nice to these people, or I've gotta I've gotta agree with people to be empathetic with to them. They have to be deserving uh for me to be empathetic. And um yeah, it in the most simplest way I say empathy is trying to understand that no matter what another person thinks, feels, or believes, it makes total sense to them. Right, makes total sense to them, and from that lens, now how should I respond?
SPEAKER_04How should I be that's it right there? I wonder how much like the the world with the social media and everything has changed the amount of empathy because it seems like people just on social media are like you know, it's it's I'm gonna yell at you louder with my opinion instead of trying to understand your opinion.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, the the algorithms don't help us.
SPEAKER_04No, they want it.
SPEAKER_00Right, they have us in these echo chambers. I tend to see things that are a little more controversial than things that are uplifting, and that's with me seeking out things about empathy and compassion and charity. That's not helping us, but also it's a little easier to not understand or be empathetic to someone when they are when we don't humanize them. When you're on the other side of a computer screen, right? Even me, like today, somebody said something in a response to me on social media, and I got ready to respond on Instagram. But you know how some people have it, you can't respond back to them, and it's like at null. And I was like, see, I didn't need to spend any of my energy on that anyway. And so what happened was the universe saved me, is what happened.
SPEAKER_04Because you were about ready to type.
SPEAKER_00I was I was getting ready, it was a statistical site, and I was telling a joke like to go along, like I was just sticking with the joke that the original person told, and someone like started treating it seriously. And I was like, wait, what? This is a satire site. If they don't know this is a satire site, they don't need to hear from me.
SPEAKER_04Like you're over there on the onion getting angry at the article.
SPEAKER_00Two way, and someone like talking to a bot.
SPEAKER_04Didn't have an understanding of empathy, and now have a book on it. So why don't you walk us through that journey? And then I'm gonna shut up and let Jason talk for a while.
SPEAKER_00Okay. So I'm an engineer by degree, and uh, people don't always think about it this way, but engineering school teaches you how to not be empathetic. So let's say I gotta get uh 200,000 parts out on Friday, and you're sick, Jason. I need to put somebody else in that spot, and I don't need to be thinking about them as a human. Right, I just need somebody I can plug into that spot and can do the job just as you did without any break in productivity, and that's what engineering is. How can I make things design so well that the show goes on? It's the reason why airplanes don't crash nearly as much anymore. It's not because pilots are better. We have engineered out the human dynamics that make it such that you can put your battery in your car wrong. You can't, you can try, but you can't. It's not possible. Right, you can't do it anymore where you used to be able to, and so I've been trained kind of to be more objective, less thoughtful about individual people and taking more of a bird's eye view. But my mom in particular is probably the primary reason why I'm not very empathetic. So she I know I've not been in therapy about this, but it's it's it's true. She was the um minister of like food at church, and so then she would feed everybody at home too. And I think that sounds good in theory until you have 50, 60 people coming by your house every day. And when you're a kid, that's just disruptive. And some of these people have had interesting backgrounds, have made interesting choices, and while they're coming to eat, they're also telling stories about you know, they've been in jail like the fourth time, or uh they don't have their kids because the state has taken them. I mean, just story after story after story, and as a child, I was overwhelmed, and I would just zone out like, do you need some toast with that? I mean, I just would just complete it was overwhelming for me. I didn't have good boundaries, and I used to think she didn't have good boundaries, and then when she passed away, there were so many people who were wanting to come to celebrate her that we had to have two services, and we had to go to a different place because there were thousands of people who wanted to celebrate her life. Touched so many lives, and what was interesting about her death was that she was killed by um a guy who was who had stolen a car and was drinking and driving and had run a red light. So we're now in this like murder trial. Oh my gosh, and I'm doing the engineering thing, right? I take off work for the little bit of time they give you, and then I go back to work, and I'm just supposed to just do my work because the show must go on. And uh you're you're grabbing your face because you know that's not how it works, yeah. And so uh for the first time in my life, my brain could not get me out of what I was emotionally feeling, and I started to notice other people who were having that same experience, and I realized that before then I was one of those people who would have never noticed ever, ever. Um, and it just drastically changed the way I think about people. And but I, you know, once I got over my grief event, I did start to try to train leaders to be better, but I wasn't thinking about empathy. I still thought about that as something HR people do, or um, I don't know, your therapists or something. But one day I was talking to one of the wealthiest people in my region, and he had sat through one of my leadership sessions, and he said, Um, you know, thank you very much. And I'm like, okay, what is he about to say next? Like, you you know, when people give me feedback, they they start giving you the good stuff first. You're like, oh my God, what's happening? What's about to come? And he goes, That was really good intellectually. Um, but I was hoping that you would help me get it emotionally. And then he said a whole bunch of things after that, but I was just stuck on. Did he just tell me he don't care nothing about what I just said? Just tell me what I just said, but it was it was an epiphany because I was like, none of this stuff we're trying to do is going to work unless we really learn how to care. Meaning, what is Jason really thinking, feeling, believing? What does he need right now? I do love my artwork. My if my agent talked to me about what would happen if there was some travesty and I lost these pieces and wasn't able to get them replaced, I'd probably do my audit, you know? I'd probably do it. But you know, I I get busy and I put prioritize other things. And I just truly believe that no matter what our jobs are, if we can lean into empathy, that it'll make us better at it. That's what I think.
SPEAKER_03Love it. So true. I I have a question. Um, now that you're I mean, you have the book out, now you're marketing your book. You probably are learning a lot about sales and marketing, and you've probably geeked out on that stuff. But isn't it crazy? Like, like the best marketers and salespeople are the most empathetic people. They are. It's and it's like one of the biggest life uh changes in my life was when like I sucked at sales and I came into the insurance agency and I started learning and trying to teach sales, and then it like completely changed my my like me. And then it changed like I started seeing all the people that it started changing, and it's like, oh my gosh, like you think sales is like evil, like you know what I mean? Like everybody, you know, can't stand that salesperson persona, but like a true salesperson and like somebody that's like marketing, and it's like the most beautiful thing because it's showing that you care about the other person and you're trying to provide a solution for them.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, they are the center and not yeah, yeah. Um, and it's interesting because my general reaction to my insurance agent at first was absolutely because I thought she was trying to manipulate me 100%, and she'd done nothing to right, but it's just that bias we have against salespeople. You say used car salesman, an image comes to mind.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. It's difficult to assume good intent, you know, especially after bad things have happened or things that didn't serve us have happened along the way, right? Like we we start to get this callus as we a I we get older and more experiences impact, and all of a sudden we're like, uh, you know, like your keyboard situation, but then the universe or God or whoever intervened and said, Nope, you're not going there. I love that.
SPEAKER_00You're you're not going there. I'm interested in knowing. Do you all like to talk to your insurance agents?
SPEAKER_03No, I don't want to talk to anybody with insurance.
SPEAKER_04I am the insurance, you know. You are your own insurance agency. Okay, yeah, we we both own insurance agencies, and then we developed a a way to a sales funnel that that works using um telemarketers and leads and all this stuff, like it it's a system, right? And so we put that together and it worked really well in our own agencies, and then people started asking us because we were talking about it on this podcast, and then we created a company. And so what the really cool thing about is we've been able to, we've actually employed over 200 people in the Philippines.
SPEAKER_00Oh, nice!
SPEAKER_04These all these women, it's well, it's like 99.9% women that have that didn't have jobs, had or if they did, they had to drive really far at night in the city, this whole thing, and now they get to work from home, and and so it's pretty cool. Like we've actually made impact on you know hundreds of lives over there, so globally, huh? Yeah, it's pretty cool.
SPEAKER_00So and so are they working with people in the Philippines or they're working with your um with a with our with other insurance agents? Oh, nice, yeah, nice.
SPEAKER_04But those calls start that way too, right? Like the person filled out a form on the internet, yeah, and uh one second after they hit enter, a telemarketer's on the phone with them and they're like, Oh no, you know, and and they say, No, no, no, but we've teached, we've taught them how to keep them on, get them over to the agent, then the agent using some of the stuff I'm sure we're gonna talk about gets you know gets them to the next step.
SPEAKER_00So gets them to the next step. That's cool. You know, it's been interesting um because spark the heart as a book is getting some of the best feedback I've ever gotten from individuals, which is good. Yeah, even had preachers preach about it at church and things like that. But what I'm struggling with is organizations aren't buying it as much. So I every book I've ever written, usually the organizations call and say, Hey, come and teach this to my people. But empathy, what I'm starting to learn is that leaders and organizations are like, I gotta hold people accountable. We don't need to be empathetic. And it's like, ah, there's empathy and accountability are not um at battle with each other, right? Empathy is not the enemy of productivity or sales, it is the catalyst to get there. And um, I don't know that I would have bought it before either, so I understand that position, but that's what I'm kind of up against, and it's been interesting to experience.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I would change just the cover and connect some sort of financial outcome to to it, and then like this is the manual of how to actually improve without without having to spend more money, it will actually help you retain your staff and you know, I like everybody's every everybody's bean counting all the time, right?
SPEAKER_04Like, oh, I need to buy this many more leads to get to the next thing, but what if my leadership actually made them want to you know follow and and be better and and help the world and you know all the things that that happen with the empathy, right?
SPEAKER_00All the things that happen with empathy. There's these interesting things that I've learned. Like uh, let's say you got diabetes and your physician is more empathetic, you are less likely to have to need a kidney transplant because you'll get your A1C scores down at like 20 points greater rate. And it's like, what? Because my doctor's empathetic. But when you dig into it, they're asking questions about lifestyle. So they're giving you solutions that you'll actually do. Um, they're thinking about like what will you eat, what won't you eat, what can you stick to, versus just giving you a standard here, this is what you need to do. Eat right, exercise, and you know, less whatever. And so I've been just fascinated by these very technical roles where outcomes have been better because of empathy.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. You know, uh, it's funny, uh, like uh somebody shot us an email uh for you to be on the podcast, uh-huh, and we get a ton of those and uh we just dismiss a lot of them, right? But like the reason why the reason why uh this one spoke so much to me is because uh like as we are running our sales teams, as we we have teams within our agencies, and uh just like on the front end, you're talking about the sales and like the empathetic aspect of a sale is the difference of the old salesperson to compare with the new sales. The old successful salesperson needed less empathy, the new successful salesperson needs more empathy. But as we've built our organizations, I've seen so many agencies that have a team and they lead more with like, oh, that that's a sales rock star. But that guy's an ass to everybody in the agency, and everybody quits, and like the actual productivity sucks. Like their agency sucks. There's their lead their staff members are are leaving. The their sales rock star really isn't that great to be to to compare with other successful organizations. So, what I've seen is like honestly, like the the whole uh idea of uh of empathy and truly caring about those around you, especially if you have a team, because I have eight hours a day or 10 hours, whatever I put into my work. But like you start stacking all the hours of your team members, and and really like if you can really care about them, they will care about you, and then all of a sudden you have an army of people, and then your care to them produces the care to your clients, it trickles down, it does.
SPEAKER_04It's like JLD, like what JLD says with the five people you hang out with the most, right?
SPEAKER_00Like how it impact, and it's you if if if they're they're uh I don't want to say monkey see monkey do, but you know, like they do what the boss does, they do what you gotta model what you want to see, and when we make excuses for people who show up in ways that are that lack human dignity for others because of their outcomes and their numbers, well, what does it cost you when you have to get a new salesperson every other week because they keep quitting because they can't work with that person?
SPEAKER_04Way more.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and what does it cost you when people are sitting around talking about that person instead of focusing on what they need to do? Um but you know, here's one thing that I hadn't considered, and it is what is the leader's responsibility to actually talk to that person about how they're showing up? Too often we allow them to continue because their numbers are so great. But what if you actually said, Hey, what do you want your relationship to be like with your peers? I've not met a person who truly does not care what other people think about them. Now, there are those who have to get past it, but you know, we want to be liked and you want to do a good job. And so sometimes because no one's ever asked you to step up in that way, then you just keep doing what you've always done. And my question to the agents is how's that working for you?
SPEAKER_04I love that. So, agents, how is that working for you?
SPEAKER_03Seriously, you should email us at the iDudes.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, and give us a dudes at the iDudes.
SPEAKER_00Dudes at the iDudes, and I'm I'm honorary insurance.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, we'll forward if they have a question for you. Well, we're gonna get your details out too. We already have them. Of course. Oh, we have them.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I knew that. I think it's interesting when I hear you talk about like it no people can't see your face, Jason, but your face when you were talking about how you became such a good salesperson and actually caring and how that just really impacted other people. I can feel it through the screen. I'm energized. You know, it's like, isn't it nice to be with someone where you feel a little more energy coming from them versus somebody who's draining it because they absolutely it's just drudgery?
SPEAKER_04Yeah, she looked right at me when she said that last part.
SPEAKER_00No, no, not that, not that way. Not that way.
SPEAKER_03She's old and tired, let's just be honest.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. So I think I would like to know from you what's what's your advice, you think, um, for how to get more more insurance agents to be more empathetic.
SPEAKER_04Well, they need to read your book. There you go. Yeah, which we'll put the reason in there.
SPEAKER_00It's an easy read, and it's on Audible too.
SPEAKER_04Oh, the Jason, yeah, that's easy for Jason.
SPEAKER_03Dude, I I hammer through Audible. I love Audibles. Me too. So good.
SPEAKER_00Unless the layer is bad, but I did the reading and I and I can read.
SPEAKER_03Oh, cool. Dude, I am I'm gonna listen to that. That's awesome.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman