The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
Shoot Us A Message!Welcome to another episode of the playbook! In this episode, Craig Pretzinger dives deep into the framework of a successful agency with the 5 Ps!Purpose, being the reason why the agency exists, principles act as guiding lights, ensuring ethical behavior and aligning with the agency's purpose. Next is people and then processes followed by the last P which is performance.Craig reflects on how these five Ps, combined with their Telefunnel strategy, contributed to their remarka...
Hello and welcome to the Insurance Dudes, another playbook. This is Craig Pretzinger, and as promised, we are going to dive in to the framework that supports a thriving and income plus equity generation or growing agency. Are you ready? Let's dive in.
SPEAKER_01
We are ready.
SPEAKER_00
Let's dive into this framework. But first, before I dive into that, I I want to just go to a quick backstory. Because as I was in the last episode, I talked a little bit about being gone, about having reflecting on the freedom that's that's come about in the agency. Now ultimately, I thought that the freedom that has been built here with the help of a remarkable team and uh a really good ops manager and um having some great support. I thought that this came exclusively from installing the telefunnel and from buying the leads and just running the whole telefunnel process. I thought that was it. And it is great because that created the forward movement that there hadn't been before. It created the volume, it created the wins that we we really hadn't ever experienced. But as I thought about so many agents that we've helped, we've had a lot of agents that have done awesome, done gangbusters, and then we had other agents that haven't been successful. And I really, number one, it bugs me when somebody isn't successful using something that that we talk about. And I know that we can't want it for people more than they want it, uh that we can't walk everybody through some of the challenges, but I started to wonder what differentiated the two, what differentiated the groups, right? If two sets of folks, uh one set is successful, the other set isn't successful, and they're all of the other factors or parameters are the same, then what's the difference? And as I tossed and turned, um, you know, thinking about this, trying not to think about uh work while I'm on vacation, but difficult because I love it. I realized that the environment that my agency had become, or the the environment that we'd we'd gotten in the agency supported the installation of the telefunnel. So, what do I mean by that? Well, inadvertently, we had really optimized pieces of the puzzle that are necessary to foster an environment that's going to create huge results from the telephone. I would argue that anybody can get great results from the telefunnel, but in order to maintain a successful and equity producing version of the telefunnel, all of the all of the pieces of the puzzle of the a five piece framework need to be in place. So let's dive into what those five P's are. The five P's, and and these are the things that I realized we had installed in the agency, and it was just a matter of putting the telefunnel on top of it, getting good with the telefunnel, and then everything else supported that. So, what are the five P's? Five P's. First is purpose. That's your first P purpose. Second P is principles. What are the principles? What is it? What are the guiding lights? Uh, the people, who do you have working with you or for you, the processes in place, and then performance, and performance being tracking and measuring, and and and all those things. So these are these aren't anything new. These are the components of an effective organizational management. You could take any organizational management course, and they're probably going to throw in the five Ps. Um, but something had something came came to mind as I was trying to understand what the difference was. And it is these things, having these things in place. And it took us years and years to realize how important all of these pieces were. Uh, and I had taken it for granted because we'd we'd gotten these things done, but just didn't have the offense. So, but each one of these peas is crucial, was crucial in shaping the pretzinger agency's operations and getting us to where we needed to get with the goal. So I'm gonna go a little brief um definition and why it's important with each of these Ps, and then we'll go deeper in an episode on each one of the Ps moving forward. And then there's gonna be one in between that we're gonna talk a little bit about what stops us from doing it. And I have some examples um from my past where uh we couldn't quite get the things going, and and as I look back, some ego involved with some of it, and uh I'll beat myself up a little bit for you so you can have fun with that. Um, so the first one purpose. What is purpose? Now, this is really important, and it's one of these things that um and we just talked about it in our elite meeting, which is the uh weekly call that we do uh for folks that have that are using the telefunnel and and uh affiliate with uh Teledutes. So um, but if you're not great, then here you go. Here's some of that goodness from the meeting. Um, and we're gonna dive into that. So, what is purpose? This is the reason why. This is your reason why the agency exists and the unique value it brings to your clients and to your team. Now, when I'm looking at organizational theory and bringing up this this P, they didn't put team, but I think team is super important too. And in fact, it is one of the P's, right? It's people, but we need to define the purpose around the clients that we serve and the people that we serve who are serving our clients as well, because they are our number one client, it's our people. If we have our if we have our people dialed in, then they're gonna want to be part of this. Uh, but I don't want to get ahead of myself, and I just did. So, what's the importance? Your clear if you if you have a clear, well-defined purpose, it's going to provide the direction that your agency goes, it's gonna inspire your employees, and it's gonna guide your decision making. So it's it's kind of your checks and balances because as you make decisions for your agency and what you're going to do, what you're gonna spit allocate resources to, how you're gonna motivate your team, all has to be behind a purpose, right? So if that purpose is clear, everybody knows which way to row. If that purpose doesn't exist or isn't clear, it's just hey, we're we're here to give insurance. It's important to have the purpose. Think about any organization has the purpose. Unfortunately, a lot of very large organizations are gonna have purpose and they're gonna have all these things, they're gonna have the the next the next P, which is principles, they're gonna have all these things and maybe not necessarily follow them. Hopefully they do. Um, one of the reasons why uh my wife left the place that she had worked prior was the uh the feeling that they don't quite follow the values that they're talking about. Now, do I know whether or not they do? I don't know, but this is what I've what I've heard. I tend to believe what she says. So, but it's real important, right? I think a lot of organizations come up with these things because it's it's what you need to do as a big business, as a big corporation, uh, but not necessarily utilize them in the spirit for which they were developed. Now, we're lucky because we run small businesses and we have a lot more latitude in what we can do. We don't report to the shareholders, we report to ourselves and our team and our clients. So if we have a well-defined purpose, then it's something that our team can talk about with the clients. It's something that oozes from the language they use whilst they're talking to people. Um, so think about this. So here at the Pressinger Agency, our purpose is to serve clients, educate them in their insurance, and help them to make the best decision so that they're protected, right? We want to protect them and their family. We know that most people come to us, especially the ones that we're quoting with internet leads, and they don't have proper coverage. Of course, we have to meet them where they are. They want quick, fast, cheap, but we're always going to push for the purpose. So if if people understand that our purpose, our passion is to serve them and protect them and their their families, well, that's a lot better than, hey, we're here to get you insurance. We're here to to serve everyone. No, we're here to serve families who care about the protection of their assets and their uh and all of the family members so that in the event something terrible happens, it isn't as catastrophic because you have the the insurance in place. I think it's important for you as the agency owner to sit down and think about this. One of the things that I've learned um in some of the coaching groups that I'm in and working with some really, really successful entrepreneurs is how important this purpose is. You have to have a purpose-driven organization. And also think about organization. What does that mean, right? It's organized. There's an organization, it's not just madness. We're gonna really, really focus on a lot of this. So hope this is resonating. What's the second thing principles? So I'm gonna read this to you. The core values that guide the agency's behavior and decision making, the core values that guide your agency's behavior and decision making. One of the what uh one of the core values that we have here is honesty, honesty and ethical behavior. So this is gonna guess this is gonna guide our agency's behavior and the decision making that we do, right? If I have somebody who is writing policies and they're they're not being honest on the application and doing something that's going to make the rate better, something to manipulate, which luckily and gratefully, that isn't something that happens. But if it is, then we know we can make a quick decision. This violates our agency's core values. Somebody who violates core values cannot be part of this team. It's critical. Anyone who cannot follow or think about the core values must go. And again, it's not about the person anymore, it's about the values. So it's up to them. It's up to them. Are they gonna follow the core values? Great. If they are, awesome. That means we're all aligned. If they're not, sorry, we can't have anybody going rogue because that's not gonna help us, it's not gonna serve our clients, it's not gonna help push towards the purpose. Hope that makes sense. People, people, one of the most challenging things, right? We're gonna have a really good episode about this, and we're gonna dive into some really, really key metrics and different things, all about people, but let's talk about that. This is what's the definition of people? Why don't you say it to yourself, and then I'll give you mine. Go ahead. I'll sit here and take a sip. Yep, I didn't hear you, but this is what I'm gonna say is the team members who bring their skills, creativity, and dedication to the agency. So we want to bring people who can think. We want to we want to bring people that are skilled, and this doesn't necessarily mean they're skilled in insurance, it just means that they're skilled and that they have the skill set to be able to think critically, to be able to make decisions, somebody who isn't afraid to be daring, but understands and can follow the core values so that it doesn't do anything that it goes against what we believe in. And we're always going to hire and fire based on these core values, right? So we're looking for people that bring the skills, creativity, and dedication. Really important. We can always get somebody to understand what insurance is, they can understand the product knowledge, they can do all these things. Um, but we cannot change, or it's very difficult to change somebody's set of ethics, somebody's set of values. And so we want to find the same folks who have values that align with our agency, right? That's who we're looking for. One of the things we say about our people is our team at the Pretzinger Agency is our greatest asset. They are our greatest asset because if we don't have them, we don't have a business, we don't have an organization. Each member is going to bring their own unique skills and perspectives, but that align with the core values, right? With with the uh with the principles that we've created. So also very important. We'll get into the deeper, uh, but that's the people. Now the processes. All right, what are processes? These are the systematic series of actions that dictate how the operate, how the agency operates on a daily basis. The systematic series of actions that dictate how the agency operates on a daily basis. Why is it important? Because well-defined processes create the roadmap for handling all of the different scenarios that ensures consistency in your agency. We want consistency, right? We don't want to, oh my gosh, this thing happened. No, most things take a similar approach. So we just have to create the different processes so that we know how to handle every situation. And if we don't know how to handle a specific situation situation, that's fine. We're gonna create a process once we once that situation arises so that we can effectively solve it the same way every time moving forward, right? I don't go to McDonald's, haven't been there in years. I was almost gonna go in Portugal because I wanted to get a Royal with cheese, but I didn't. And think about McDonald's and and the way that they've they've created process to ensure consistency. What does it do? It creates that because there's consistency, somebody who loves McDonald's knows they're gonna get the same thing, whether they're in Tuscaloosa, wherever Tuscaloosa is, whether they're in Tuscaloosa or they're in Humboldt County, they're and they go to McDonald's, they're gonna get the same burger. They're gonna same same quarter pounder if they go. Uh, and for somebody who likes McDonald's, they go there because they know they're gonna get the same thing every time. Imagine if the hamburger was totally different every single time, it'd be going like to different restaurants, but that isn't the way it works, right? They've created this process that creates the same product, the same end result every single time. So we've created and established processes for every aspect of the operation. In doing so, it's it makes it very simple, it makes it very easy when a situation arises on what to do. I remember for years and years, I was basically agency Google, right? It was the Google for my agency. If somebody needed something, they wouldn't figure it out, there wasn't a process to look up. What they would do is, well, they'd come to me. So whatever I was working on would be interrupted, and that's not a good thing, especially with ADHD, because by the time I finally am focused on something, they come and interrupt me. Now I'm blown up for the next half hour because I have to get refocused again. So really important for processes to be in place and to have the process to create the processes. That's when you're going to create that confidence in the team. The team's gonna believe that that everybody knows what they're doing because there's a there's a way to do it, and it and it really takes a lot of pressure off of off of me as the agency owner, takes pressure off of you as the agency owner. The more that they can look up and handle themselves, the better. So huge. And finally, the last P is performance. So we are going to constantly track and measure the different things that we do, the different tactics that we install in our agency, and everything that can be that can be measured, we need to measure. We need to track a measure so that we can hold people accountable and uh and and hit the results that we need to. It's like having your own GPS, right? It's the GPS for the GPS. So we do regular performance evaluations here at the Pressinger Agency. We we look at at metrics daily for the telefunnel, um, and for service stuff too. We're also looking at anything that we can quantify. So we take that qualitative piece out of it. We want to take the subjectivity out of it, we want to make it very objective, and then it takes emotion away because emotion is not a good friend of business. And anybody who's gotten angry at the at their at their team or or upset, it really what I've learned is that I need to be angry at myself. And we'll we'll talk a little bit about that in the next episode where we dive into the ego just before we get into the first P and really go deep. So I appreciate you listening. Uh let's let's put a let's put a button in it now. We're gonna stop and we will circle back on the next episode. We're gonna dive into the things that prevent the peas from being installed. But I can tell you right now that these are the reasons that we were able to grow from six million to over 10 million in just under two years. And it was it was remarkable that it was the perfect storm of having the right peas in place so that when we put our offense on top of it, we were able to take off. Uh, so appreciate it. Appreciate you listening. Don't forget to leave a review if you haven't. Um if you have, thank you. And uh, we will talk to you soon.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.