The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
Shoot Us A Message!Craig Pretzinger is back with another insightful episode! This time he discusses the concept of achieving agency freedom and emphasizes the need for agency owners to build a successful and self-sustaining agency. He delves into the changing insurance landscape, explaining why the old ways of agency freedom no longer work. Craig also talks about the importance of focusing on growth and investment, not just immediate income, to create long-term equity in the agency, and intro...
Well, hello there, listeners or viewers, however, you're consuming this uh playbook. This is Craig Pretzinger. I have been out for about a month. Well, actually, it was a little bit one day over a month, I think. Wasn't too worried about being out a month. And it was some time that needed to be taken to put it into perspective. My wife left her job and she actually ended up getting an offer while we were on vacation. But we ended up going to Portugal. And while we were there, and I'm gonna highly recommend anybody listening to this when you get some free time after you implement some of the stuff we're gonna talk about, go to Portugal. It is incredible. Moving past that, while I was there, I was I did a lot of thinking about the why and the how behind being able to go away for a month, to have a little bit over 10 million in premium team and to leave and really, for the most part, not be involved very much at all. And I'm sure that a lot of folks would love to be at that point. If you are, then you know how awesome it is to be free from the agency. If you're not there yet, you certainly can, but it's a lot different than it used to be. We're gonna look at some of these things. So let's dive in to becoming free from your agency in 2023. Let's go. It's the insurance dudes. All right, we are back and welcome to another playbook. So, yeah, amazing trip with my wife. We left the kids at home, made them watch the dog, and uh that was pretty good. Came back, the house is still standing, so that is a big win. Now we have to figure out how to empty the whole house because we're going to have the floors done while we take the family and go out of town next week. So that's pretty exciting. But before that, I'm gonna lay down a few different episodes that have to do with agency freedom. So we're gonna talk about a framework that I put together while I was on vacation that I think is really important to put yourself in the position where you have that agency freedom. Now, what did agency freedom used to mean? It used to mean, and for many, many years, right? To the folks who were independents or were uh captive and with a single carrier, um, you know, when agents were depending on the carrier, some agents were in a booth and popular box store that is no longer around. They might be around, but I don't think they are. No, they went, they're they're gone. But it was a lot different. What they would do is build up their book um with the neighborhood agent, right? You build up your book to two or three million, and this is the herd, right? Most of the folks would build their book up, get to a certain point, take their foot off the gas, and kind of ease into retirement, maybe sell it, maybe give it to their kids, but certainly not put in the kind of effort that they had on the front end. And that's great. It isn't what gets you that agency freedom anymore. You can't just sit back idle and watch the premium decline without having some kind of new business coming in. Otherwise, the book is gonna die and you're just not gonna get it. Carriers are cutting back on the comp tied to your renewals, so you can't play that game anymore, right? It's it's a different world, especially the captive carriers have had to adjust because the landscape has become extremely competitive, right? It's been a long time coming. I think the captive carriers that they could wait out the discount 800 numbers, but it hasn't worked out that way. And now they have to compete head to head. So in competing head to head, they had to change some things up, right? They have to push growth and fuel growth. So that exists. We all know that. If we invest in the front end, we're gonna get paid, we're gonna increase that lifetime value of that client. And we've talked about lifetime value a ton. So I think that you're familiar with that. If you haven't listened to us for long, I encourage you to go back, listen to episodes that we talk about lifetime value. I am gonna touch on it a little bit as we get into the framework, but that's gonna be over the course of several episodes. So, number one, let's just focus on the point that A, we cannot do this the same way that we used to. We have to grow. Because if we're not growing, we're dying, and we just may as well get out of it. We have to focus on investing for that growth. It's the only way to make it happen. You can't just hope that people are gonna come in and you're gonna get enough business that way. With retention going down for many people, because quite frankly, the audience or the people that are buying insurance these days are really focused on the deal. Of course, we're gonna move them off of that and get them into the point of understanding that they need the right coverages. But when they're looking, their first thing is they're trying to find the deal, right? And you hear it from your producers because they're gonna tell you, oh, yeah, they were focused on price. Of course, that's how everybody comes to us, right? That's what they've been taught. So they've been taught by the 800 numbers, by flow, by the get-go, suggesting that they need to be trying to save money, right? And do it quick in 15 minutes. So, really important that we do that, right? There's a pendulum swinging from that. It was the agent who held the keys to the kingdom for a long time. The internet came along, it swung, and now it's over correcting the other way. Agents aren't gonna go away, at least, not anytime soon. People want to talk to people. Not everybody, but a lot of people do. Millennials ask a lot of questions. I know that there's a lot of listeners who are millennials, so you can appreciate that the folks who are millennials, sure, they're gonna enter your funnel via the internet, but they're ultimately gonna want to ask some questions and they're gonna want to talk to you human to get the business done. So, really important to focus on that. And the other thing that's happened in this world is this consolidation of smaller agencies. So, smaller agents are getting out. The ones who thought they could sit back and collect premium off into the sunset are now having to sell and they're selling at a lower multiple than the agencies were going for before. So they're really taking a hit, right? And it's sad and it's unfortunate, but there is a way out, and it is to invest in growth. Now, let's unpackage that for a second on comp, right? Because it's switched, because this thing has changed, we now have to focus on not just the income, right? For a very long time, agents would focus on income. I need to maximize my income, I need to maximize my revenue, and that's great because that's your immediate money, right? That's your cash flow. That's what's going to pay for the reinvestment into your program that is creates the offense that gets you the quotes, that then gets to your people, that then they close and you write more business. But just focusing on income alone isn't enough. And that's the old model, right? Creating the relationships, sending having people send, waiting for people to call in, not being as proactive and aggressive to bring in the new business, not necessarily investing in leads or investing in something that's going to drive more quotes to the agency. That was the old way was focusing on the income. How much can I make this month? We hear it all the time. People will sign up with teledudes, come in, and aren't always ready to wait. They're looking at, okay, we got this many quotes this month. How much did we make off of those quotes? That's the income only model. And that doesn't work. We have to focus on the equity that we build in our book, right? We get equity from all the leads that we buy and all the people that we've talked to, all the emails that we have, all the people that we can follow up with. That is equity in basically our cost of goods sold. And then our equity in the book is the overall premium that we get from growing, right? So not only does our income increase when we're focused on growing the book, our income increases, but also our exit increases. That's our equity on the exit, right? Everybody should be building a business with the intent of creating equity so that someday you can sell it, someday you could bring somebody else in, run it. Lots of different opportunities there when we have increased the value of our book. And like I said before, because the multiples may be going down, we have to increase that premium, right? We can change it, we can still get the same payoff at the end when we sell our agency, but we're gonna have to have more premium. So, how do we do that, right? We have to get more quotes, but it's not just that. If it was that easy, then all you need to do is pay for a bunch of leads and get the right system in place and have the great offense, but that is only a short-term fix. Again, it's just income. We don't want to be narrow-minded and only focused on the one thing. We need to be looking at income and equity. So, how do we do that? We need to focus on the five Ps. So, what are the five P's? I'm gonna get into the five P's, but I'm not gonna get into them right now. What I'm gonna do is stop here because we've been going a little bit. I want you to unpack the things I've talked about, really think about that, and let's circle back on the next episode. I'm gonna introduce the five Ps and we're gonna talk about why they're so important to supporting both income and equity for your agency and creating this long-term predictable, sustainable, offensive strategy and all-around successful agency. So thank you for listening. If you have any questions, please shoot us a message on Facebook or wherever else. And of course, we do appreciate if you give us a review. That's how we get more people to listen. And ultimately, we want to help other agents grow, and they can do it by listening. And the more reviews that folks put, the more people will listen. So this has been helpful for you. We appreciate it. Throw a comment on the YouTubes. Thank you so much. Talk to you soon.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.