The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
Shoot Us A Message!The Insurance Dudes are on a mission to find the best insurance agentsaround the country to find out how they are creating some of the top agencies. But they do not stop there, they also bring professionals from other industries for insights that can help agents take their agencies to the next level. The Insurance Dudes focus on your agency’s four pillars: Hiring, Training, Marketing and Motivation! We have to keep the sword sharp if we want our agencies to thrive.&nbs...
Welcome back to the playbook. I'm Jason Feldman, and this is the Playbook series on sales. And today we're going to be talking about the four parts of a winning PC insurance sales script. I am great. I am in the card. We are in it. We are injured. Starting with the first part of the four parts, which is the opener. The opener, which we've called the pickup line, we've called it the icebreaker. But this is really that initial part of the phone call. And if you're buying any kind of leads, this part is so important because people eject from the phone call very quickly, or eject from any communications with you for that matter. So we have to make sure that we knock this one out of the park. And there's a few principles that if you follow, you will get at least 2x better results. The first principle with the opener is to make sure that your agent does not hang up. Like no matter what, they can't be the one to hang up. I see this so many times with people, and it drives me banana sandwich. And that's when an agent calls somebody, calls a lead, and they go, okay, all right, I'll call you back. And then they hang up the phone. It's like, what are you doing? Dude, we've seen people close sales, one call closes, while uh the client was dispatching cars at their job and had to keep putting the agent on hold because they were literally working and dispatching cars. And the sales agent just kept going on hold, kept getting more and more information, but they stayed on for that. And that person did not want to stay on initially. So it can it could definitely happen. So the icebreaker, so, so important. People form an opinion within five seconds of a person. So this is why we've always trained our agents on this. Hey Sam, how's your day going? We would make sure that they would repeat whatever that opening line is for your agency, repeat it over and over and over again and make it sound welcoming, inviting, making sure that your energy is up, not give them a chance to eject from the phone call. And they're going to want to, but again, we're trying to do the law of large numbers in this whole process, which is giving us the best chance uh to uh close this sale. So within the first five seconds, we want to sound outgoing and we definitely do not want to sound like a telemarketer or an insurance agent. Why? Well, I think it's pretty obvious that they're gonna hang up on you if you sound like that. You know who they're not gonna hang up on? Their friend. So why is it that we can call our buddy and it's like, hey, what's up, man? But when we call a lead, it's like, hello, uh, this is Jason. How are you doing today, sir? Like, of course, that's the worst. You know they're gonna hang up. I'll never forget, when I, and you can relate all sales are the same, whether it's online, uh, on the phone, in person, there are principles that you can follow that'll give you the best results, right? Case in point, I went to living spaces and I wanted to buy a couch. And I walk in there and I didn't even know where the couches were. I walk in and there was a salesperson that came out and said, Hey, can I help you? And the way he did it and came at me was so salesy that just like a knee-jerk reaction, if a doctor hit my knee with one of those little hammers, I said, No, I'm okay. And I walked past him and he didn't say anything else, right? He could have approached me like a friend. Hey man, how you how's your day going? I said, Oh, pretty good, cool, awesome. Yeah, are you going to the back? Like he could have engaged in a normal human conversation to get to the point of, you know, helping me because I actually needed help. And I didn't even know where I was going in the store. So, I mean, it would have been uh much better if he would have approached it differently. But he approached it like a salesperson and he got my knee-jerk reaction. And just like a phone call that we're doing, we do not want to sound like a salesperson or a telemarketer or like everybody else. This part, again, you being an agency owner, has have the control to break out of the mold. You don't have to sound like other people. So, this step is so important. So, what we do is we got to get our agents to say something natural and to say it like they would normally say it, and to say it like that they were excited. Kind of like if they were called their friend and they were really excited about a movie that they just saw and how they would describe it. Call with that kind of like tone, call with that kind of enthusiasm. And if you're not an enthusiastic person, don't try to like push yourself in that direction. Just sound normal, like it's a friend. You want to kind of catch them off guard and oh, oh, who is this? You know, like like we want to try to get away from those knee-jerk reactions. Everybody, when they first fill out a form of insurance, and I think we said this in the other video, but uh, we need to go back and really hammer this point in. When somebody fills out something online, they had something that happened to them with their insurance company, probably the raising of rates. They got in a car accident, they didn't like the way the company handled it, something that they just didn't like about their insurance company. So they're thinking, hmm, this is a good time that you know I can shop around and find something. And these are the three things that they're motivated by. They want to find something that's cheap, quick, and easy. So let's do the inversion thinking on this. What's the opposite of that? Quick, fast, and easy. They're dreading that this is going to be expensive, that it's going to take a long time, and that it's not easy. So why don't if we're if they're thinking these things, which I guarantee you they are, I know they are because we've asked them. If they're thinking these things, what we want to do is like tell them, oh, don't worry. It's gonna be super quick. It's gonna be quick, you're paying way too much. Like automatically tell them they're paying too much, don't worry, and this is gonna be quick and easy, and then go into it. But we initially want to start off with the, hey, how's your day going? Something like that, something like a friendly, friendly conversation. And we wanna make sure that the agent doesn't hang up, oh, I don't have time for it. Oh, I totally get that. Uh, are you still at this address? Keep asking them questions. Your agent needs to keep asking them, is that is that comfortable? No. Is that natural? No. Is that how you talk to your grandma on the phone? Absolutely not. But we're not doing that. We're buying leads. We're spending a lot of money on this stuff. We want to get an ROI on our leads, right? Dude, they have to keep asking questions. And if the people don't want to answer, ask the next question, right? If the person on the phone doesn't want to answer, are you at this address? And they don't say anything. Oh, okay. Are you do you still have this car? You know, like just keep keep asking them a question as if they did answer the last one. But the last thing we want to do is just hang up. So getting them used to being uncomfortable is key. The difference between a salesperson and a service person is the salesperson should be willing to be uncomfortable. And we'll talk about this. This part of the sales script is the first sale. You have to sell them on actually talking to you. Like that's number one. It's so important. If a salesperson cannot get past step one, they're not a salesperson. Or you need to spend some time with them and make them understand that that is 100% not okay. Let's assume that the lead that they're that they got on the phone, if you actually do the math, remember of how many leads that you need to get the quotes and all that stuff, how much did that quote cost you? Probably cost you a lot of money. Probably cost you at least 20, 30 bucks, right? So tell them that quote costs 20 bucks. Do you want to pay me 20 bucks if you just hang up on them? Now, I don't think that's legal, but like, you know what I'm saying? Like, have them realize like, we don't, this is not, we're not talking to our friend here. So this is super important. You need to handle these leads in a certain way, right? And if the lead hangs up on it, who cares? They're on the phone. This is not in person, right? What do they have to lose? They only have something to gain, not something to lose. This being uncomfortable part is the thing that they need to get over. And if they can't do it, they're the wrong person on your team. I'm I hate to say it, but we're talking about way too much risk and way too much money that's being invested in them to not take this part seriously. So that's number one, that's the icebreaker. Those are some tips that I like in the icebreaker. What questions are passed? Hey Sam, how's your day going? Is just, you know, getting into the answering of more questions on the policy or just keep talking back and forth. And if they ask something, that they say something that puts up a roadblock, just get past it. Just ask something else. And just if you want to go right into like filling out the form, that's fine. You're gonna have to get back to that work family fund that we talked about the other day. But at least let's keep them on the phone because we know this is that if they are on the phone for longer than two minutes, you're most likely gonna get the quote. Most likely, right? It's very easy for somebody that once they pick up the phone, within the first few seconds, it's easy for them to hang up. But once they've stayed on the phone, it's very hard for them to leave the conversation, especially the more time they put on that call. Let's say they've talked for five minutes, it's gonna be hard for them to back out because they've already invested five minutes. You know, they'd have to agree that that five minute decision was a pretty poor decision if they decided to hang up, right? So most people and they feel bad uh because they started to talk to you. So we can get to know them later, but really the initial part of this uh call is to keep them on the phone. That's it. So that is the first play of the script opener playbook. I'm Jason Feldman. Tomorrow we're gonna get into the next second part of scripture.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.