The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
Shoot Us A Message!Join Jason Feltman as he discusses the crucial concept of payoff vs. payout and its impact on the success of your insurance agency!Whether purchasing an agency or building it from scratch, there is a significant investment of money and effort involved, and the subscription model in insurance, with recurring revenue and additional commission checks from renewals, plays a pivotal role in this strategy. Jason emphasizes the importance of being realistic, modeling out the numbe...
It's a playbook. I'm Jason Feldman. I'm very excited to talk to you about this one. And this is a thought that I've had a lot in the past. And this is the idea of payoff versus payout. What is the difference and why can it make so much of a difference in your bottom line in your agency? So let's dive in. Insurance students are automated to escape by our agency. Now by encouraging the state of really predictable, consistent, and profitable agency sales agent. I am a great competitor. I am Jason Foundry. We are agents. We are insurance. Payoff versus payout. I really think that amateurs look at the payout. And I've talked to a lot of agency owners about this. It's something that I think is the difference between an agency that can really take off and an agency that slightly, uh slightly moves the needle. And a lot of agencies just really look for the payout. It's almost like we're looking at our agency kind of like uh an employee would, in the sense where it's like, what's the ROI? And and when we're looking at the ROI, we're looking at the immediate payout. We're not looking at the long-term payoff. And a lot of times to make those bigger leaps, the immediate payout is going to decrease, right? I don't know if you ever if you bought your book of business or if you're you built it from scratch, but regardless of each way, there is a significant amount of money that you paid out, that you personally paid out to make that business work. So if you bought a business, you paid out a lot of money where you not only didn't make any money at the beginning, but you paid out a ridiculous amount of money for your book of business. That transaction is something that we looked at the payoff for, right? You're looking at that long-term payoff by purchasing the agency. Now that's what I did. And then silly me was thinking that whole first year, especially the first year, I didn't really understand this until a year and a half into it. Is that holy crap, I gotta actually pay out more. Like I have to spend more money to actually build the business higher. I thought like that initial purchase, all that money going out was the like that's what I did. And then I could really grow it from there without spending any money, which is insane, right? Well, I guess you can grow it, but it's going to take a ton of your human equity time or your teams. Uh, and if you don't have a big team, then I mean, it's gonna take a lot of your time. And how much can you really move the needle in that? There's only so much, right? You're gonna have to buy others time if you want to really start building the agency. But just like the concept of purchasing an agency, you purchased now. Think about this. You purchased an agency, like let's say it's a three million dollar book, right? And you purchased it for let's just say 600,000, right? Maybe maybe less these days, at least for the carrier I'm with. But let's just say you bought it for 600,000. What you just bought was three or four years worth of work by a staff of like let's say three people, four people, right? That's what you actually bought. That's what it took to build that book of business, and that's what you're buying. You're buying those all of those man hours, right? And so when you get in your agency, you need to reinvest, you need to grow that thing, and it's going to take money or time or time from others with your money to help build the agency. So, really looking at what's the payoff, are you willing to have a short-term payout or maybe even decrease, or maybe even complete like borrow money to really build the agency, or are you just worried about the little payouts? If you don't want to invest, that's totally fine. But don't think that your payout is going to increase substantially in the next few years, unless you're putting a lot into it. I mean, that's just the bottom line. And that's where we need to be real, realistic. And if you don't want to and you don't care to grow, totally cool. But don't expect to, you know, have a staff of two people, or or maybe it's yourself or staff of whatever, and expect to take these big leaps. It's just unrealistic. And you're causing yourself a lot of pain in the sense where you're wishing, hoping, and thinking that you're going to do something that's mathematically impossible. So figure that out on paper where you want to be and put it down. Like what will it take? How many people will it take? How much in marketing spend would that take? And not everybody wants to grow, and that's totally fine too. So let's talk about the payoff. It's not just that one commission check. So it's not the six month or one year commission check because they're going to be with you for let's say an average of three years. So it's all those renewals as well. That's why this model is such a good model. The subscription model literally was started with insurance, and all these companies now have built massive, massive companies on the back of it because it's such a fantastic model. And they're willing to invest massive amounts of money to make it happen. Look at it. There's really, I don't know of an industry that doesn't have some sort of subscription model attached to it now. It's fantastic. I love it. Doing the membership thing is just amazing. So this is the original membership model. So, you know, what we're making on that initial uh six-month policy or 12-month policy is not all of what we're making. Not to mention, we're getting yearly bonus commission checks as well. But are you willing to get less of a payout now for a longer-term payoff? That was the question that I asked myself when I started. And I would I took a huge pay cut when I came in uh to invest in marketing to grow because I was I actually took such a I took a 40% paid decrease to buy an agency that cost three quarters of a million dollars, which is insane. But I took a 40% decrease in pay and I said, you know what? This seems crazy. I don't know why I just did this. I and and so I got to this point where I said, screw it, I'm gonna put it all on the line. And I said, and I took every last dime and I put it into marketing and I made a little bit of a bonus. And then I said, you know what? If I did that from a little bit of money, what if I put all this bonus back into it and I kept doing that? And I did that for a few years. Well, yeah, for two or three years, and then man, it like snowballed, right? And then my payoff was much greater, and then the conversation quickly changed with peers and friends and everything else. It's like, well, you have the money to do that because your agency is this size. It's like, bro, my agency was peanuts, it was super tiny, and it was completely failing. We had zero anything for traffic or like like no walk-ins. We we had, I mean, the the book was a failing book. It wasn't the best decision. Well, wrong. It wasn't the best purchase, I would say. Let's say that it wasn't the best purchase. I I probably spent more than I should have on it, but I took that as an opportunity and I took all the opportunities that the carrier provided, and I and it was painful. Like, you know, I was watching my money and and all kinds of stuff. It was hard. It was hard, it was painful, but I delayed the payoff, or I delayed the payout for the payoff, and the payoff was worth it. And that is, and then talking to other business owners that have really made big leaps in their business, they do the same thing, they delay the payoff. They delay that. If you can delay the payoff and delay the payout a little bit and put it back into your business, grow it, you can get to the size you want. Or if you don't want to, totally cool, but don't expect to have miracles happen that just aren't going to happen. I mean, it's it's again, it's just math. But you know, this is a conversation I love to have because it's so important to look at that long term because you can build an incredible agency. You can really do anything you want to with this model. I think it's one of the best businesses to be in. And uh, I wish you the best in your agency. I know you can do anything you want to, be realistic, model out the numbers, and uh get to where you want to go. I'm DC Bel.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.