The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Surety Bonds and AI: Insider Insights Revealed with Jackson Cromer PART 1
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
The wildest thing I've ever seen happen in an insurance agency was we had an agent that was writing bonds with us, and uh the agent ended up taking the premiums that were paid by their customers, buying drugs with it, and then getting caught. So that was uh a little gnarly. Uh ended up in some doing some jail time and uh had to uh had some reparations that were there paid forward, but um my name is uh Jackson Cromer. I'm with Bond Exchange in Charlotte, North Carolina, and uh I help insurance students do debts with surety, and I'm an insurance dude. So I'm happy to be here. I'm excited. Yeah. I think is the second year that I that I was here at the agency. And uh that one was fun. That was an interesting time. We had basically our carrier asking, hey, what's going on premium payment? And had to basically go through go through them and uh figure out how they were gonna handle it.
SPEAKER_01How long did it take to catch it?
SPEAKER_00It was, I mean, that that agency was writing writing premium or writing bonds with us for I mean years and years, but I think that the instance ended up happening probably within within like eight to ten months. It wasn't a very long time, yeah.
SPEAKER_01Not a it's still a long time, right? It's like the you watch what like criminal behavior, and they'll start off super careful, right? And then they're getting away with it, and then in insurance, because everything's so low tech, and you know, it just takes forever. It's like he's really feeling he's seven months in and he's feeling good about he's like, I got my scam going, right? And then and then he gets lazy and whatever, and just it's crazy that you can actually like somebody can number one, it sits okay with them to do this in the first place, right?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, but this is a module thing that's going through my head, right?
SPEAKER_01It's just wild, like, and then to think that it's not that that you won't get caught. Yeah, like I I it's remarkable.
SPEAKER_03Next thing you know, you show up at his office, he's laying nude on his table, smoking crack with a bunch of farm animals, yeah.
SPEAKER_01And then the freaking FBI kicks in the front door, right? All the fun and games are over.
SPEAKER_00What was he doing? I believe it was cocaine. What I believe it was cocaine. Ah, yeah. Yeah, crack he's living fast and furious, yeah. Fast furious, non-stop, ready, go, go, go. Oh, yeah, that was that one was pretty gnarly.
SPEAKER_01So, Jackson, how'd you get into this thing? Like how'd you get into selling bonds to crackheads?
SPEAKER_00Uh, you know, uh my uh the journey was a little different. You know, I I got out of college and I started actually working in a wilderness therapy company. So I was out in the woods in Asheville, North Carolina for like eight days at a time. It was working with you know kids that struggle with uh mental issues and had recently been married, and we had our our first son on the way. And uh it was getting to the point it's just hey, this isn't really working anymore. Like you're gone for eight days at a time. I can't contact you. What's what's gonna happen? And I got on with perfect situation, yeah. It was it was a rough one, right? But I got on with with Bond Exchange uh in in 2016, about a month before our first son was born. And you know, I think um I really started out here as a renewal underwriter. I had no clue of what I was doing or how to uh really how to process really much of anything. But I came in and I really wanted to be a better runner. Exactly. Yeah, we're we're just kind of flying, you know, flying by the sea of our pants. Um, but I wanted to learn more and uh went through some underwriting designations, you know, got a better understanding of what the you know strategy and mission of the organization was. And you know, we took it, took it from there and really tried to accelerate the growth of the company when we launched the the website. And that happened in 2016, three months after I started. A lot of iterations since then, a lot of change, a lot of growth. Built brought on probably five or ten more folks, and you know, really continue to expand that footprint and and build out what we're doing. It's been a lot of fun.
SPEAKER_03Crazy. Crazy, crazy. So, how have you been expanding?
SPEAKER_00How we've been expanding. A lot of it, you know, we get a lot of inbound. I mean, it's it's a lot of folks that they don't know what to do with surety, a lot of agents that they need help with understanding what the nature of these requirements are. And then we do have some some carriers that send us some inbound referrals, which is really nice. Uh, you can't really go wrong with with word of mouth. Uh, it's really helpful. But recently, we've been really hammering away on our marketing, really been hammering away on some business development practices to grow that agent base. So they want again, they know who Bond Exchange is. There's some brand recognition, build the brand awareness. We've been going out to a lot of conferences too. So that's been a big change over the past probably eight months now. We just did a little beta trial of it, did four last year. And I think this year we have 48 on the books. So 10x that for this year. It's a busy travel season. Um, but we've got a great team that that goes out. I we I'll pick and choose kind of my my top five or so, and we'll be we'll head out, head out there to go visit some folks. I think let's see here, first week or second week of June, uh be out in Rhode Island and then in Texas at the end of June. I think we've got one in uh in Scottsdale. Um, I think here coming up in maybe in August, but we've got folks that are heading down to Florida for basically three weeks, get a little like mini vacation while out doing conferences should be a good time. Do you personally have to go to those? I don't, I go to I'll pick, I'll kind of pick and choose. Yeah.
SPEAKER_03I was gonna say if you got out of the previous job and smooth sailing for a while, then all 40 years, oh by the way.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah, yeah. But no, so I'll usually I'll go. I think on my docket, I'm I've got about 10 that I'm gonna go to this year. Um, and then we'll split it up. We've got a team that kind of rotates to make sure that we've got enough coverage uh to get out there where no one's getting their you know burnout on on travel too much.
SPEAKER_01So, Jackson, let's pretend that Jay Mr. Jason knows nothing about surety and you were gonna explain it to him. How how would you walk him through that?
SPEAKER_00Absolutely. You know, I think luckily with with surety, you'll have someone that's gonna be coming to you with, I need this bond, like I need X, Y, or Z. And what I usually will start with is okay, well, this person's coming to you. What's the industry that they're in? Right? Are they are they an auto dealer? Are they in construction? Are they in financial services? Are they a mortgage broker or mortgage lender? And from there, it's who's requiring this bond of them? You know, what is the what's the point of the obligation? So you'll have a lot of these state or city or county requirements that will come up, and those folks will actually say, Hey, you know, XYZ contractor, you need to have a $25,000 bond if you want to do business in the state of California or in Arizona, like they have there's a lot of different license classifications in Arizona. That's a fun one. But hey, you're a residential builder, you need a $5,000 bond requirement. Boom, go. So those are my two big questions first is what industry are you in and who's requiring the bond? From there, we can kind of get a better understanding of all right, what's the bond amount? And then what is the underwriting information that we need to be able to process this quote for you? Um, a lot of these bonds, they're they're underwritten based off of a soft credit check. So you got to kind of parse through the, hey, I need a social security number. A lot of folks don't want to give that to you. Um, but there is a way to go about that process where you know you're providing them with some of that comfort, some of that uh really understanding that you're here, you know what you're doing, and that you're there to provide them with a service and some help um so that they can take care of what they need to do to get their business running.
SPEAKER_03What's the best way is to navigate through that part of the conversation?
SPEAKER_00Sure. When I when we do that, I would always let them know basically, hey, it's a soft credit check, it's not gonna affect your credit anyway. And that you know, this gets stored in a very in a secure location that's encrypted. Once it's in there, like I can't see it. So like it's there. Um, I can see what it returns for me to be able to underwrite the account. But other than that, it's my I mean, that's it there. Like it gets it's it's tied away and it's it's gone.
SPEAKER_01Is it like other bonds forms of bonds? Like, do they like with the 25,000? Is there somebody that's investing 25,000 on the other side to fund the bond, or it's it's through the company?
SPEAKER_00It's yes, not quite. So, like with surety, it's more it's this three weird three-party obligation, right? So, like traditional insurance, two-party, you've got your the insured and the carrier. Uh, with surety, you have the principal, which is the insured or your your customer, you have the surety company, which provides the financial backing, and then you have the uh the obligation, which is the state, city, county project owner for your payment performance bonds that is requiring the bond of the principal. And what ends up happening is in the event that that principal defaults on their obligation. So let's say for a motor vehicle dealer, they sell you a car and they never give you the title. Well, that's illegal. And you can claim the bond to seek reimbursement for that loss. So you gave them a down payment of 10 grand for that car, and you can claim the bond to seek reimbursement for the 10 grand that you lost out on because they never gave you the title for the car. So it's a protection for the consumer for fraud and unethical behavior. It's a protection for taxpayers when it comes to these large payment performance bonds for federally funded construction work. So anytime those, you know, a contractor walks off of a job or they do something that um violates the terms of their contract, you know, they go over time to complete on the contract and never actually finish the project. Well, they can a bond can be claimed to provide protection to the project owner in those cases.
SPEAKER_01It's interesting. So it's it's insurance, it's just not called insurance, it's called a bond.
SPEAKER_00Exactly. Yeah, the it's a very similar vehicle, just a different way that the claims pay out because it's not a protection for the for the principal for like your your customer, it's a protection for the consumers that interact with that customer or a state, state body that has, you know, uh I'm trying to think here, that has like um, you know, citizens that need to be protected uh in the event. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01It's interesting. I wonder why they called it bond, because like bond as a financial instrument is debt, right? So exactly.
SPEAKER_00Huh. It's a little, it's it's definitely a little nuanced. Uh it's definitely it it throws, and that's one of the reasons I think you know, it really throws our agents that we work with, it can really throw them for a loop because it's a lot different than any other product that they're dealing with. It's there's no other product that they have that's like, hey, I've got this weird three-party requirement. I don't know why I have a three-party requirement. I just have a customer that needs to get this taken care of. Like, how can you help me? And so they end up throwing it our way. And you know, we we provide them with some solutions and some some technology to help make that process a lot faster, a lot more streamlined for them. So then they can work up the you know, workers' comp or they can work up uh the GL or any commercial auto or something along those lines.
SPEAKER_01Right. So this is like a front-end, like you could if if marketed properly, an agency could utilize this as kind of an front-end offer, right? It's a lower ticket, something that everybody kind of like a lot of businesses may need. So if you're marketing for this, you use this as the foot in the door and then go out to the GL, the commercial, the commercial auto, their personal and everything else.
SPEAKER_00Oh, absolutely. And that's one of the one of the big things with the surety that I see is while it's not the biggest ticket item, it's really not. Like, I mean, I think average premiums for us I mean like four or five hundred dollars, it's it's not gonna, it's not breaking the bank, right? But it creates a really sticky relationship because the underwriting and the information that you need for it's generally a little more, it's a more personal information, like you mean social security number. In some cases, you may uh need a personal financial statement or a business financial statement, you know, some things that folks generally like to hold closer to the chest. And so if get that information, create that bond, create that relationship. It usually usually allows the the retention is generally pretty strong.
SPEAKER_01I think it's a good Trojan horse strategy, right? Because you're they have to have it, yeah.
SPEAKER_00There's no going, there's no going around that.
SPEAKER_01And and then it's kind of a pain in the butt to get set up because of some of the requirements. So now they don't want to go elsewhere to do it again, and boom.
SPEAKER_00Exactly.
SPEAKER_01They can control that relationship.
SPEAKER_03What industries pay out the highest commissions on bonds? Like who needs the biggest bond? Are all the commissions for all the bonds the same? Or do some pay out more? Like if I was gonna be if I was gonna sell bonds today.
SPEAKER_00I would I would tell you to try to attack the so the biggest markets, right? I would start there, and it's gonna be construction, it's gonna be auto industry, transportation, uh, financial services, so you like mortgage brokers, mortgage lenders, money transmitters, and then you have there's a big resurgence in not resurgence, excuse me, but big market opportunities in cannabis. Those are, I mean, it's higher risk, right? But there's not a lot of market availability. And if you're someone that has capability and carriers that can ride it, I mean it's it's it's open season. As far as the commission ranges, I mean, it is they I see differentiation more on standard versus non-standard types of business. So um, like I can place this with maybe admitted market, right? And get a you know, standard commission anywhere like 20, 30 percent. If I place this with something that's not admitted or have to go to a substandard market for it, well, it may be a little bit lower. But generally speaking, it's it's still relatively strong commission percentage uh outside of uh what you see in maybe some traditional P and C lines. Uh, but yeah, I would definitely construction's gonna be the big one. The that's probably like 60% of the market when you look at just from a premium volume perspective.
SPEAKER_03And how much big how much are those premiums?
SPEAKER_00Um, it can certainly range. I mean, I think we've we've written a few that are like, you know, a couple hundred thousand in premium, and then you've written a ton of them that are like 10,000, 15,000 in premium. And you, I mean, you'll have some that a couple grand. It just kind of depends on what those project sizes are, what relationships you've established with those agents and they and then them, the agents, what they've established with those contractors.
SPEAKER_03That's awesome. Are there any flags that go up if somebody needs like like let's say construction? If somebody needs a construction bond, where's the first place that they're gonna look? Or is there something online or some kind of like indication, maybe early, like, hey, this company's gonna need a bond?
SPEAKER_00You can so uh some some cities and counties will release uh like bid specifications or requests for proposal. So you can basically kind of like pinpoint and try to attack that as far as like, okay, we know these projects are coming up. And while maybe I don't have uh maybe like one of my clients, one of my insured is not one of these contractors. Well, I can market to contract like commercial contractors in those areas, right? And try to find them. But for for us, you know, again, we're we're trying to, we're just working with uh with agents. So we will end up kind of trying to pinpoint some of the agencies or reach out to agencies that maybe have specialization in you know construction risk or like hey, you know, like you know, probate or um kind of estate type type uh attorneys or things along those lines, but it can it can it just varies. I mean, there's so it's so far reaching as far as the different industry categorizations that you can kind of you don't necessarily need to pick and choose. Um it's just it's there.
SPEAKER_03What kind of marketing tactics are working really well for some of your top agencies that are just dominating and selling these bonds? Like, what are they doing to to bring in the business?
SPEAKER_00Sure. I think a lot of what I'm seeing our our agents do. Um, we see we see some on Google AdWords again. I mean, we've we've dabbled in it as well. It's it gets expensive. You know, we we actually ran a pretty successful like print mail campaign. I don't know, I don't feel like I'm I don't want to be the last one to say like print's not dead because I mean a little bit, but it works out really well. I've seen some really successful um strategies there. Also, I mean, any sort of like kind of affinity marketing too, where they can get in with a some form of either a distributor or something along those lines and create those relationships has been really, really effective. And then, too, I mean, the SEO game isn't definitely, definitely up there. I think that you know, having some really quality curated content that demonstrates an agent's ability to like serve as an advisor. And this is really, I mean, if we're looking at digital marketing, this is like kind of some of the areas that I think I've seen some of our smart agents try to create some specialization in. But then, too, we have a lot of folks that they don't have a very up-to-date website, they don't have a way that clients can really contact them through their website outside of, hey, here's my phone number. Um, you know, but building out like, hey, I've got a chat feature on my website that'll connect you to one of the uh rep CSRs in our office suite. Um, or I have an online submission tool or something along those lines. Um, you know, we have like some form of integration that that's built in there, you know. That I think those are those have been really, really key.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. I think um a lot of agents rely on their their care, like especially captive agents will rely on their carrier um created page, but it's pretty generic. It doesn't really, you know, it's not optimized to generate leads for the agent. So um I think that that that's important stuff that you brought up, where they can create a side thing. Obviously, you can't put your carrier's name in it if it's your own thing, but you can have some other thing and create SEO in these areas that people aren't really spending money on. Because I would, you know, auto insurance, home insurance, that's gonna be tough to rank in, but something like bond, you know, construction bonds for your thing, like that may be easier, right? Right, same same type of thing. We used to run ads for uh motorcycle insurance because it was kind of like the foot in the door, right? But then everybody started doing that, so now it doesn't work anymore.
SPEAKER_00You gotta shift it, yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, you just gotta shift to something that nobody else is doing, which ironically, most people don't do anything until they see everybody else doing it.
SPEAKER_00Right. It's a liter, it's this weird catch 22, and uh yeah, uh, yeah. But you know, I think I I like that a lot. And you know, you look at, you know, all right, what's the difference between like obviously what like captive agencies are doing, and then we work a lot with independent agents, and you kind of see what the development and what those trends look like between all right, hey, this is this is where the progression is, right? Is is this like with the captive, but you have the big name, um, you know, a lot of leads that are driven from the carrier side, but like with our independent agents, I mean it's it's all on them. Um, but you get to see some cool differentiation and how they're going about those tactics and what's changed and what they're doing that's allowing them to be successful. Um, you know, I think a lot of what a lot of what we've seen, especially, I mean, we work with a lot of small, kind of more mom and pop agencies, but embracing what they're doing on the technology front, it's been a big game changer for them. Uh, where, like, hey, I have a website that is updated constantly, I have chat features, I have the ability for um, you know, COIs to go out on demand, you know, like whatever it may be, they're doing things that are allowing them to kind of get their foot up. They're creating that tech stack that's allowing them to continue to elevate themselves. And that's been it's just been a really interesting development because we are trying to be at the forefront of that on the surety side of things to make sure that we're able to provide that service to to our agents and to our customers. But then seeing that they're doing the same thing, sweet, that's awesome. And it's a win win for everybody.
SPEAKER_03I love that perspective too. I wish more agents had the perspective of hey, like we're all selling, you know, we're all selling the same stuff. Who cares? Like who wins, you know?
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman