The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
Shoot Us A Message!Welcome to another episode of the Insurance Dudes podcast!This is a continuation of our episode “How to Scale Your Insurance Agency Without Losing Your Sanity.”Join us as we dive deeper into the essential elements of creating a positive and effective work environment and the importance of effective communication among the team to avoid conflicts and resentment.Craig Pretzinger and Jason provide their valuable insights on how to set clear and acheivable goals and easy ways t...
Hey there, insurance dudes, and dudettes. This is Craig Petzinger, and you are tuned in to the Insurance Dudes Podcast. Welcome to the second episode of three parts, where I'm talking about how to scale your insurance agency without losing your sanity. If you still have any left. Let's dive in.
SPEAKER_00
Insurance dudes are automated to escape by our agents. How? By uncovering the secret between predictable, expensive, and profitable agency sales. I am a great project. I am Agency Felder. We are agents. We are insurance agents.
SPEAKER_01
So in our last episode, I discussed the foundational elements of running a successful insurance agency, implementing efficient systems and processes, right? Very important because if we don't have systems and processes, we're gonna have chaos when we scale, and then we will become insane. I dived into the vital role of automation, the art of uh delegating tasks, and also how a good CRNs CRM system can revolutionize your business. We also touched on the dangerous trip we all fall into, this crazy trap. I know I said trip, but I meant trap. Being perpetually busy without making any progress. Busy is not great, right? Busy is just busy. So today we're gonna take those insights just a little bit further. Um, I'm gonna be examining how those concepts could contribute to a broader goal cultivating a positive and productive work environment. A challenge, no doubt, but with the right mindset and the right tools, it's entirely achievable. So here's the first piece, right? The first piece of creating this positive and productive work environment. It's effective communication. This is one of those things we can think about any conflict that occurs, or let me take that back. Most conflicts that occur start as a result of communication breakdown, right? Where a message is sent, whether that's a verbal message, uh an email message, a text, and and really the more you take the person-to-person out of it, the greater the chance of that communication breaking down. So we have to be very mindful of the message that we're sending because it's going to be perceived and received differently by that person that's getting it if it isn't clear. So we have to be really clear. We have to be really, really clear with our communication if we want to be effective. So that involves having meetings. We've talked about it over and over and over again, but these meetings have to be focused and goal-oriented. So it requires uh that you do one-on-ones with your team, well, with your sales agents. You want you want to allow for open and honest feedback from them about you and for for you to be able to give them honest feedback, right? This isn't a beat beat each other up situation. This is a how can I be better? If we can actively listen to our team about how to be better, about what they need, sure, we may get some crazy stuff, you know. Hey, I want the perfect lead, so I want I want it to be easy, whatever, right? Likely they're not going to come to you with that. But if they do, we know that that's some some crazy stuff. They're gonna actually have to do some work, but they may have some insights into how you could manage them that may be more effective. As an example, my team uh came to me and said, Hey, the feedback is good, but we also want to hear some kudos. And it's tough sometimes when you're running the agency to remember to stop, pause, and give those kudos. So, again, effective communication is gonna be bringing positivity to that conversation. I'm gonna use a uh term if you have to deliver tough news, use part of the French, but use the shit sandwich delivery method, right? We're gonna we're gonna put that tougher piece in the middle of the sandwich, right? That's the quote unquote crap there. Uh, so the bread would be the compliment that you give at the beginning, the compliment kudos, something positive in the beginning, frame the critique in the middle, still in a positive way. Like maybe it'd be better if you tried doing it this way as opposed to this way, and then finally, of course, finish with something else positive. And that's gonna they're gonna remember the positives, and they're also gonna remember that the the feedback was delivered amongst that stuff, and uh, it should help a lot. It does help um soften the blow, if you will. So we gotta have that one-on-one. It's also about setting clear, attainable goals and tracking progress towards those goals regularly. So there should never be a situation where your sales team doesn't understand what they need to do, doesn't understand the expectations that you have for them, and um, and then how to get there, right? Again, we're gonna be providing as the agency owner, we're gonna be making a raid with the leads, right? Whichever methodology, if you're buying internet leads and using telemarketers, if you're using mailers, if uh you're generating your own leads, whatever methodology you're doing, you have to make them busy, and then you can hold them accountable, right? Uh, there just isn't enough time of the day for them to be doing all the prospecting too. So they need something to work with. You gotta you gotta give them a little bit. It is an interesting business. We've also posited on this before, but it's an interesting business in that many agents expect their salespeople to not only go out and find the opportunity to quote people, but then to also close them. Uh, and there just isn't enough time in the day. You can't do eight hours of prospecting to try to get a hold of enough of the 10 people that you need to quote if you're gonna be if you're gonna be quoting, uh obviously, and then um, and also do those 10 quotes. Very difficult, right? There aren't 16 hours in the day. Those are two full-time jobs. So set those expectations. What else? What else? What else? What else? Oh, geez, I'm so fired up here. Um, so now let's talk about um accountability. We are talking about accountability, but let's not forget how important it is. Um, so those weekly one-on-ones are going to ensure that they're on track, that they're aligned, uh, and that they understand those goals. Really critical. Strive for that clarity and um simplicity. Simps, you know, keep it simple. They say kiss, right? Keep it simple, stupid. Keep it simple in your communication. Uh, oftentimes, I think our carriers create these goals that are so convoluted and have so many different pieces and mechanisms and conversions and doing all this stuff. We don't want to make it tough for them. Make it very easy, right? In in my agency, it's it's I'm gonna fill them with each producer is gonna get a minimum of 30 leads per day per producer. They're gonna have two telemarketers dialing on those leads for them in order for them to get the 10 quotes they needed. So there should be some similar process in place in your agency, um, regardless of what the marketing source is. You need to know that funnel, right? In my case, it's the telefunnel. In your case, it could be the mailing funnel. Whatever it is, you got to make sure that everybody knows the numbers and the expectations. Well, you know the numbers that it takes to get there, and they know the numbers of what's expected so that you can hold them accountable. Accountability is critical. And finally, let's talk real quick about work-life balance. This is a term that's thrown around a lot these days, but how many of us truly, truly practice it? And how many of us push this towards our team to really ask that they too maintain a work-life balance? Full time, all the time, 168 hours a week of work is not gonna get you there because you're gonna burn out, right? It's the recipe for burnout, and then you're done, which is tough, right? And a lot of us are entrepreneurial, so we're kind of all over the place and we like to do different things. Don't go too hard, too heavy, burn yourself out, and then not want to do anything. And it's the same for the team. So they're gonna mimic the leader that's in place for them. If they see that you work 200 hours a week, a lot like I used to think that was like a badge of honor. Hey, I get there earlier, I get there, I leave there later. What worker be looks at that and thinks, boy, I sure want that, right? I think that we actually need to do a little bit of the opposite. Show that as the business owner, we don't need to be there, right? Give them something to aspire to. Now, all of them aren't gonna want to be business owners, but at the same time, many of them are. So when they see that you have that work-life balance, and then you create the opportunities for them to have the work-life balance, as in, hey, you hit your goals, maybe you get a day off at the end of the month, right? If you if you hit X. People love time off. Time is more valuable than their money, right? They don't necessarily care about the money, which is why they're the worker and and we're in the driver's seat of the agency. They may eventually aspire to be there, but they certainly aren't gonna aspire to be there if they see that you got to work 200 hours a week, right? So take that away. I might have said finally, but I forgot I had one more thing, and it just came to me team bonding. So this is more than just having fun putting bean bags in the office or a dartboard or a foosball table, making it like Google to work at. That's great, right? Having a fun at work environment is good, but it's not simply enough just to let just to tell them what to do, right? We can't just say, hey, I put some bean bags, go do it. We need to guide them towards where they're going. We need to establish the the measurable uh KPIs. And we certainly, we certainly want to make this take those KPIs and attach them to some win that they can that they can then bond as a team, right? Because if the team, as you build and scale your team, if they enjoy working together and they enjoy each other's company, they're more incentivized mentally, right? They're more checked in to come to work, they're more checked in to beat their neighbor, they're more checked in to spend more time getting it done because they're actually having fun. And this can be fun, right? I think back to some of the sales jobs that I had over the years, and some were awesome. I couldn't wait to get there, I'd bounce out of bed, and then others, not so much, right? Not so much. So, and I think this is also where we get a bad taste in our mouth about meetings, right? You hear daily meetings, I hate meetings. Sure, yeah, we hate bad meetings, but we we do like powerful meetings that move us forward. So, again, team bonding is huge. You could do retreats, you could do uh trips, you could all go somewhere, you could uh you could just go bowling, go uh go to top golf. We did a dinner at top golf. If we hit 200k one month, they were gonna go to top golf. And we did it, right? They they made it happen. Need to do one of those again. Worked well. So that, my friends, is another agency playbook. I went a little bit longer than I thought, and I hope you you played out the whole thing and you went the distance. We appreciate you. Don't forget, if you want to get more, if you love what you're hearing, uh, we do have a checklist uh for how to build how to scale and use it with internet leads because that's the way that we do it. Uh you can jump over on the website, download it, it's free. You just got to put your uh info in there and it'll unlock it. So we appreciate you listening, and we will see you on the next agency playbook for insurance suits podcast.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.