The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Jamie Bragg's Biggest Jawdropping But Jovial Dialogue PART 2
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
In your opinion, what is the number one recommendation that you have for any agent to make the biggest impact in their agency moving forward?
SPEAKER_00To make the biggest impact, everyone has to know their role.
SPEAKER_02So how do you bring like when you when you have recruited in the past and and everything, how do you bring somebody up to the level of success that you expect?
SPEAKER_00Well, for one, I I've always been a little overbearing on processes. That's good. Yeah, I mean, and and I'm trying to recreate that here in the transition too, because um I wasn't able to bring everything over because some of it was on proprietary computers. But but you know, I've always been really big on systems and processes, having everything written out to where, you know, everybody knows the objective, everybody knows what they're supposed to do, you know, and probably training has been the the downfall of that because you know, where I always knew that, you know, definitely most agencies, you know, the the CEO or the principal needs to aspire to run it as a CEO. And you need to be able to take a step out and you need to be able to work, you know, on your business and not in it. I have always had a problem of always working in it. Um, and so we always had the processes and systems there, but being able to step out of production to like hold the new team members' hand so that they they knew exactly what they do, they could you mirror what you were doing, probably was a little bit of a probably something that I needed to work on a little bit more. Mostly most of the time, you know, I I would say the the best time that I ever did it, I had a gentleman that worked with me and I sat him across from me. So I had my desk and he I turned his desk staring at me. And so for probably six months, all he did was stare at me. Uh it was kind of awkward, but he heard every phone call. I mean, he saw every quote. He, you know, got to sit and listen to every phone call that I made when I pitched, you know, pitched a proposal. And um, you know, I wish that I could convince him to come work with me today, but you know, he has his own agency today, does phenomenally well. And I and I love to say it's probably not true, but I would love to say that it was all because he had to stare at me for six months and you know continue working with me after that, you know. But uh, you know, I think really from my standpoint, probably other others that that are in a similar boat, you know, systems and processes written down are great, but you know, you really need to invest a lot into new team members and not just telling them what to do, but showing them what to do, you know, on a daily basis.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I love that. And I don't sell yourself short. If he didn't leave the business after he had to sit across from you for six months, but ended up getting an agency himself, I think you did something good. Good wow, you made an impact. I'll take it and act like so you brought up teledudes a couple times, so I don't want this to be some teledudes commercial or have anybody think that. Like that's not the point, but the point is that we're real passionate about the process itself. So aside from the call, we don't need to talk about the callers, but let's talk about the process because you coming in, how familiar had you been with internet leads or with with creating this kind of process, right? Where you know, oh, if I buy the lead, then this is what's gonna happen. Right. How have you come had had you had experience with that before?
SPEAKER_00So I've I've always dabbled in um with internet leads. The problem always was the number of dials you had to put on them in order to get them. Always was. And it was it was something that that um we could never overcome, even myself. I mean, I guess I couldn't do it either. It was, you know, how do you stay engaged with that lead even after you have called them 10 times and they still won't pick up?
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_00So what I would do, what all my team members would do, is you know, they might call them a few times and then there goes John. John's just somewhere floating around that CRM that nobody's ever gonna talk to John anymore. And so then you've just flushed that money down the toilet. And um, you know, but the thing was is I would just crank up the lead volume until we would start writing something. You know, it's probably the bad ones because you know, it's kind of like if they walked in the door and asked for insurance, that's the customer you never want. Right. Kind of like the internet lead. If they immediately pick up and say, here's my credit card number, you probably you're not gonna keep long term.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Um, so that's always been our problem is how to put enough dials on. And so I've always thought, you know, how in the world can we overcome this? Well, you know, it used to be well, hire some telemarketers. Good luck. Find all right, let's go hire some high school students and let's go pay them eight dollars an hour and see how many dials they can make. Well, you want to talk about people leaving for lunch, like yeah, yeah, they're gonna make you know 50 calls and then they're gonna get up and go to the bathroom and they're gonna walk straight out of the front door. I mean that's just that's just what happened. And so I was always trying to figure out how to do it, and I'm lucky that I stumbled across um you know, teledudes. So not to make this an infomercial for the teledudes, but you know, I have seen people with State Farm and other captive agencies, even independent agencies that are doing personal lines, you've got to do high volume. I mean, you you do. I mean, uh I don't want to be negative on this part of the industry, but there's certain carriers we'll leave nameless that have driven so hard to commoditize personalized insurance that we it's hard to beat it out of people that it's just it's not just price. It's not it's there's way more to it than price, but that's what everybody thinks, and that's what as agents, a lot of us have become victim to that and just sell on price. And so in my mind, the only way to survive in personal lines and grow long term is to have a lot, you know, because you're gonna kind of churn a little bit. I mean, you've you're gonna have a you know lapse can that's gonna be there, but you you've got to write a lot of business, you have to put on a lot of calls, and you're gonna have to find somebody that's willing to do it. Well, yeah, these days, good luck trying to find somebody that's gonna make. I mean, and y'all might do it too, but I mean, I've always had a hard time with my team members when I go, hey, y'all need to be prepared to make a hundred outbound dials a day.
unknownRight.
SPEAKER_00People look at me like I'm crazy.
SPEAKER_03Like you got 15 heads.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, which I mean, I've got this perfect lady now that she makes 700 miles a day.
SPEAKER_03I mean, yeah, you do. I mean, I was like, wow, who? Oh, wait, I know who.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, you know who. Um, but I mean, she makes 700 outbound dials a day. I mean, there's no you couldn't even pay me enough money to do it. I don't even know if I'm capable of it.
SPEAKER_03Crazy, huh?
SPEAKER_00It is, but I mean, I I honestly think that you know, there's some things that we have to get over in the agency about being better at closing. We we definitely we've got to be better at closing, but um, in my opinion, this is the way to do it.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, but how do you get better at closing by doing it more, right?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, well, closing and doing, you know, I hate to say role playing, it's just uh I know, but you know, research training, practicing, yeah, practicing. But I mean, that's the way to do it because I know myself. I mean, I'll sit there and preach to everybody in the office about this is what we got to do, this is what we got to do. And and today I did it with a producer, you know, I was like, we are not going to talk about price, we're not gonna talk about price. And then he gets somebody on the phone and he goes, Hey, I promise you, we're gonna be the cheapest, I'm gonna save you some money, we're gonna get this cheaper. And I said, Ben, I said, I told you we're not gonna talk about price. He said, I know as soon as I came out of my mouth, I knew you were gonna say something to me. And I'm and then I get on the phone, you know, 30 minutes later and dudgum if I say the same thing. Yeah, you just have to be on top of it all the time. And and like y'all talk about too. I mean, you really you have to do it every day, just gotta be in your face in order for you to not forget it.
SPEAKER_02Yep. But I you know if it's at the beginning of that conversation, it's not too bad, you know, because because I think in the way you can shift away from that pretty easily is that when you start talking towards the end and you are giving them higher coverage and a higher price, and they can and then you say, Yeah, man, for what you're getting, this is like so cheap. Because I mean, price is just a subjective, you know what I mean? Like the the cost of it is subjective, you know.
SPEAKER_00So well, you know, it's really all about trying to, and I mean, I have I've worked so hard over the years to try to figure out a script to you know build value. You know, sometimes I believe that people care about that when I'm going through the script, and sometimes they might not. I don't know. Um, and I know that y'all have worked with them in the past. Um uh when Vlad first started, uh, I had worked with him on a script that he had. Um, and uh it was a phenomenal script. Um unfortunately, the the company that he was preaching it to did not did not like the cadence of that script, so he had to pivot. But you know, I mean it was it was great at just you know overcoming an objection, you know, uh acknowledge, empathize, go back, you know, start and just keep going and um you know try to just build a little bit more value than what they currently have.
SPEAKER_02And uh so but you know what the great thing is about what they currently have, they have zero clue. Zero clue because because one out of 20 agencies have told the this person actually what they have, the rest, it's it's all just a number, yes, uh a price. So nobody actually tells them that you got bodily injury and and like like no other policy has this, and they'd be like, Oh yeah, you know, they had they don't know, they don't know what that means.
SPEAKER_03They were like bodily, I don't even know what that means. Okay, yes, uh-huh. Right? They don't want to sound stupid, so they just say yes, and then it's some amount for something, they don't know what that is, they don't know what they're paying. Nobody knows what what and and all they're they're preconditioned to think cheapest is the best, right? Yeah, which nobody wants the cheapest. I mean, you live in this you're you're in the south, you're in the south, you probably hunt. Do you hunt?
SPEAKER_00You go hunting, not much anymore, but I sure I I do know how to do it.
SPEAKER_03Would you would you go and get gear from Kabbalah's or would you go to Walmart and get the Ozark stuff? Right? Like you're not gonna be in the you're not gonna get that Ozark brand from Walmart, yeah. You know, for hunting and and your tent. And and that's the cheap stuff, right? You want a good deal, but you don't want cheap. That's right. And and it's that that difference. And also I think it's it's important, and we talked about this on the call today, is that confidence of the of the producer who's talking about these things, especially when they close and when they're and when they're going through those objections. That's if if they get timid, and they're they're not gonna win, you know, they gotta be strongest version.
SPEAKER_00And I've thought about and and I'm horrible at this, I don't know what how y'all do it, but you know, we've always been ones where we're we try to stay away from price, but we ask how much they're paying. We don't ask. Okay, well, and so I've started like really thinking, like, why? Why even ask what we're paying? Let's let's set it up in a value proposition to get them something better than they have and just automatically try to go to the close. You know, if they say it's higher, well, I mean, we didn't say we're gonna be cheaper, we're gonna get you something better.
SPEAKER_03Uh I just I I look at every question that's asked along the way. What is the the probability that that question is gonna have an answer that helps move it towards a yes? And I think asking how much they're paying, like, hey, so how much you paying now? The answer is probably gonna be less than what we're gonna be saying. For us, it isn't it doesn't help us, right? There's a greater likelihood that now we're gonna it's gonna be some low amount because they're a guy going or wherever, and now the producer's like, Oh man, now I gotta be right. So so they're already sort of defeated, and I don't want them to feel defeated, I want them to go in strong, and who cares?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, no, I agree, yeah.
SPEAKER_03And it's it even when it's uh this is what we talk, it's very difficult for them to do this, but we push and push and push on it. It's like let's say somebody comes back, they have 50 DUIs or whatever, and supposedly they could qualify and it's six thousand a month, right? Something insane. We want them to say that to them with confidence too, because if you could say that with confidence, then you can close anybody on anything, right? You're not gonna close them, and that's okay, but at least act like it's great.
SPEAKER_00You know, if you can make me think about a story I had written this guy way back when I was at the beach. Yeah, he kept getting he he had a DUI, he kept getting these speeding tickets, and one was like evading police. And he owned a convenience store or a couple convenience stores, and the one of the evading the the the one evading the officer was his store was getting robbed, and so he was flying to the store to try to get there. Like, I don't know what he thought he was gonna do. Yeah, but he had to tackle the guy, but yeah, I mean I remember his progressive policy was like like eight thousand dollars every six months. And and I can't I can't remember his name. Um, but you know, I mean I I just I was like, you have got to quit getting speeding tickets. And I said, You definitely don't need to be getting tickets like this. And he said, uh, Mr. Jamie, he said, you know what your job is? Your job is to write my insurance. He goes, if I want to get a speeding ticket, I can afford the speeding ticket. Your job is to get my insurance. That's true. And so, but it was it was one of those things where I remember when I quoted him, I was like, There's no way this man is going to actually take this quote. But I was just like, I'm just gonna throw it out there and see if he takes it. And he did, and he did take it, it was huge. I mean, it just blew me away. I can't I can't imagine how bad the other quotes had to have been.
SPEAKER_03But thank you for sharing that. And I think that's very, very important for everybody to hear, right? $8,000 every six months. You thought there was no chance he's taking it. He said yes. Yeah, anybody at sales has had that situation where the per whatever who whatever they were selling, they thought there was no chance, and the person said yes, right? Like we never know.
SPEAKER_00No, you don't. I mean, you you cannot ever put yourself, you know, you you can't spend somebody else's money, and that's what I I mean. I've done it, my team members have tried to do it, and it's the one thing that I try to beat out of everybody is that you you have no clue what they're dealing with on the other side of the phone. Nothing.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah, that's the biggest problem. The biggest problem I've seen with salespeople is to get them to believe, and this is why I think it's hard to teach life insurance sales. Yeah, because people put their own perception, their own buying subjectivity on the sale. This is expensive, I know it's a lot of money, blah blah blah. It's like not to Donald Trump, like not to you know, not to certain people. Certain certain people, you know, your mid-level car is chump change, you know what I mean? Like to certain people, like these big expensive things are cheap. So why go into it thinking that like it's way better to go into it the opposite way? We always go into the way of thinking everything's more expensive. Why don't we go uh into it thinking that everything is uh less expensive? Like dude, this is nothing. Yeah, well, but it's five thousand dollars, dude. It's this is nothing.
SPEAKER_00That's not what y'all are saying, it's a mindset. I mean, you know, yeah, I mean it it's all a confidence mindset of where, you know. And I'm gonna do that after we get out, you know, from this uh from this call, that that is what I'm gonna go back tomorrow and tell everybody we are just not asking about how much they're paying anymore. We're just not gonna care. We're just gonna try to build value and if they take it, they take it.
SPEAKER_02And and what you can do is like if you're always going in for like a more like if you're going into it with a more expensive price, you know you're raising the coverages, right? You're always going in, raising the coverages of whatever they have. All you have to do is prove that their other policy is irrelevant and you won because then the price doesn't matter, yeah. Because it's irrelevant because that policy sucked. Like that policy was not the right fit, so it's irrelevant for the situation. Oh, but my own my other policy is only a hundred bucks and you're charging 200, but it it wouldn't have covered you, like you already told me that it that policy is irrelevant. Of course, it's only a hundred bucks, it sucks.
SPEAKER_03Might as well just be been paying your neighbor a hundred dollars a month, and it would have been the same thing.
SPEAKER_00Uh exactly.
SPEAKER_03You know, I love it.
SPEAKER_00Oh man, yeah, that makes me think of I listen to too many podcasts, and that statement of paying your neighbor a hundred bucks is like going after some of these larger commercial accounts and are like, you know, well, hey, I've got my buddy, you know, my buddy Jim. I play golf with Jim all the time, and he's just my agent. I love Jim. And I'm like, well, you know, heck, and this I'm stealing it from somebody else that said this on a podcast. But you know, heck, if you're that good of friends with Jim, I mean, I didn't know that that paying your friend fifty thousand dollars a year was that, you know, that was that special. Why don't you just let me save you this much money and just pay Jim $10,000 and y'all go play golf together? You know, I mean, like that's an expensive friendship right there, you got.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. Yeah. Another another one I was thinking of is you get on an airplane, whether you're in first class or you're in the back, you get there at the same time, right? Yeah. I mean, it's a little more comfortable than the first class, but is it is it worth four times the price to some people, right? Yeah, like I could go ask my daughter if she's gonna fly to England or wherever she's gonna go fly to. You gotta sit in first class. Hell no, I can't, I'm not spinning that, right? But somebody else is gonna say, hell yeah, there's no way I'd sit in the back, right? Like the it's worth it to them. Sure. Now, I don't think it's worth that for to get you know, you get there at the same time.
SPEAKER_02I love I love the sales conversation, it's so much fun because it really is a mental game with yourself, like that for the salesperson, it's the mental game is with themselves, it's not with the other person. No, not great because the other person's either gonna buy or not based on whatever data that they have, right? So it's literally how much can that person stand to hear now, and how much confidence will they have that they can get it, and how consistent are they gonna be to go through enough people to get to the yes and be confident along the way?
SPEAKER_00Well, you know, I I told everybody today, because uh there are three of us now of us today, and I was like, I got the phone. I had this lady on the phone, and she was telling me that she didn't have time. She didn't have time, and so I was like, Okay, well, I totally understand that you don't have any time. Um, and she was like, Let me call me back at one. I was like, I want to make sure I've got all the information that I need so that at one o'clock we can go real quick, and so I go back and ask her some more questions. She's like, Sir, you're not letting you're not listening to me. I've got to go. And I'm like, Yes, ma'am, I totally understand. I keep going. And then she goes, I've had enough. And she hangs up on me. And I throw my hands up and I said, I won! And they were like, What did you do? And I was like, Somebody hung up on me. I did not stop until they hung up on me. Love it.
SPEAKER_02So great. The best lesson that they could have learned. Yeah, you turned a no into an opportunity to teach the entire team how to do it.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, at least I got enough information so that I can actually do a quote. So Yep.
SPEAKER_02Love it. So, Jamie, in your opinion, what is the number one recommendation that you have for any agent to make the biggest impact in their agency moving forward?
SPEAKER_00To make the biggest impact, everyone has to know their role. And so, you know, just things as cheesy as, you know, having a handbook or having a price like having a script. I mean, you know, the the way to make the biggest impact is for processes to be written out, systems to be in place, and everyone knows their roles and their responsibilities. And that way, one, you never have to get on to anybody because you're not getting on to them, they're just failing to follow the systems or processes. Um, and and they're either buying into those or they're not. And so, I mean, I think that's probably the the way to have the biggest impact to the agency.
SPEAKER_03So good. Thank you, Jamie. Thank you so much for being on the uh podcast. We appreciate it. And thank you for being committed to your agency. You're on the call every Wednesday, so that's awesome.
SPEAKER_00Try my best. You know, it honestly, it's uh it's a lot of valuable information. It really is. I mean, it's it's things that that I've heard, but you know, you forget, and then it's so nice to see other people that are still trying to figure out or struggling with the same information. Sometimes you can still like feel like you're sitting on an island, and it's nice to know that you're not.
SPEAKER_02It's all you know what I always say, it's it's it's all all of it is just like spinning plates. You know, you got all these plates spinning, and as soon as you got one going, you you know, another's starting to slow down, and then you got to go back over and spin that plate. And it's like, I mean, it there's always something, right? There's always some work 100%.
SPEAKER_03Yep, like your grandma said, action takers and moneymakers.
SPEAKER_00Well, awesome. Well, sorry about it taking me forever to figure out how to work the uh headset and the microphone.
SPEAKER_03That's okay. The listeners didn't know.
SPEAKER_00Oh, that's true.
SPEAKER_03Craig and I all the time. Yeah, what do you think we were doing before you got on?
SPEAKER_00Oh, yeah, even though I always used to say if you slam uh slam a screen door on a hurricane enough times, it will close.
SPEAKER_03So oh, I like that. We don't have many hurricane jokes on this side of the country. It's a dry heat, that's all we say here. Right.
SPEAKER_00I hear you.
SPEAKER_03All right, well, thank you, and we'll uh we'll see you next Wednesday.
SPEAKER_00All right, gentlemen, y'all have a good rest of your day.
SPEAKER_03All right, you too, Jamie.
SPEAKER_00Thank you.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman