The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Jamie Bragg's Biggest Jawdropping But Jovial Dialogue PART 1
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
The wildest thing that ever happened, it actually didn't happen to this agency. It happened at a previous agency when I was in Alabama. And we were having to re-underwrite our entire homeowner's book of business. So I had to go out to a very nice neighborhood and re-underwrite this house. And so couldn't find it. Finally had to ask a neighbor where it was at, and they didn't have a mailbox. It had been knocked down. So I had to go up to the house, and honestly, I mean it was the worst house in the neighborhood. It was a little sketch. And uh knocked on the door. It was like a very Nola type house. So it had like a like an enclosed front stoop that was like locked by a gate. And so I'm knocking on the you know the gate, trying to ring the doorbell, and nobody wants to come. And so I'm like, well, I'm I'm just getting out of here. This guy comes out and he, you know, no shirt on, shorts on that are like stained, and he is just like Coke bottle glasses and just mumbling, you know, wanting to know why I'm there. And so I had to tell him, you know, who I was, what I was doing there. And um, so he's like, All right, well, I you know, I'm busy, you know, just come in and you know, get it done. I was like, sure, no problem. So he unlocks the gate to let me in, and I walk in the door in front of, and as soon as he closes the door, he turns the lights off to the house, and it's completely black.
SPEAKER_00What?
SPEAKER_04Oh, yeah, craziest thing I've ever seen. I literally thought that like he was gonna tell me to put lotion on my skin, like Buffalo Bill or something. I was in like silence of the land.
SPEAKER_02Holy!
SPEAKER_04So, like, because I so I go like, whoa, whoa, what's going on? He's like, Oh, yeah, don't worry about it. Just you know, he flips the lights back on. I don't know what he did, and so I was like beelining it to get to the backyard so I could take pictures of the back of the house. So I got out there, took pictures, and I was like, Man, I am not going back through that house. So I go around, try to get out the other side of the gate. Well, everything is locked. I mean, there's no way to get out of the gates, there's no way anything. And so I was like, oh my god, I might have to go back through the front of this house. And so I literally like, I'm all right, I've got my pictures of the back, I'm going to the front, I'll take the pictures, I'm good to go. And he just kind of yells at me, all right. So I walk to the front and he has locked the front gate so I couldn't get out the front door. And so I was like, oh my God, this guy really, he's he's about to get me. And uh, but he he doesn't, he doesn't. He actually comes out there, unlocks the gate, and I mean, I'm talking about I'm high-stepping it, getting it in the car, but it literally was the that probably 10 seconds of like total pitch black felt like three minutes. I thought I I thought I was a goner, but uh, but yeah, that's about the craziest thing I ever had happen.
SPEAKER_01That is insane.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, so I'm Jamie Bragg with Binders Insurance Group out of Carrollton, Georgia, and I am a teledude.
SPEAKER_01Oh dude, that is incredible. I thought that you were gonna say, and then he he said, You know where you are, you're in the jungle. You're gonna die.
SPEAKER_04Wow. Yeah, it was it was creepy.
SPEAKER_02Describe your emotional state when the lights went out.
SPEAKER_04Um, kind of like the uh feeling you get when you jump out of the back of a plane. You just know you're gonna die, right? You just know it's gonna happen.
SPEAKER_02You were like, I've now accepted my death. This is it. This weird house.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. But uh he flipped the lights back on, thank goodness.
SPEAKER_02How weird. I wonder what that was all about.
SPEAKER_04And to be honest with you, it was a I mean, it was a very, very nice neighborhood. And and uh this obviously was just one of the sketchy houses in there. I guess that's why it needed to be re-underwritten.
SPEAKER_02Strange.
SPEAKER_01You're like, I'm not going to any more houses.
SPEAKER_04No, I was done after that.
SPEAKER_01Oh, so good. So, Jamie, let's dive into what got you into the insurance business. What was life like before that? And what was the catalyst that brought you into the insurance business?
SPEAKER_04Wow. Um, I actually wanted to do insurance. It was strange. Most people never say that. Um, out of college, I had a bunch of um economics courses that focused on it. And and about the only interviews that I could get were for life insurance companies, solely life insurance, and it was going to be commission only, and I just really didn't have the guts to do it at that point in time. And so I had done uh political science in college. So I actually ended up working for who ultimately became the insurance commissioner of Georgia, just ended up kind of falling in my lap. I ended up getting uh uh on with a guy that was opening up a big red agency down in South Alabama, and so I went to work with him and we did pretty good. He ended up getting his contract. I wanted to stay on with him, and um but at that point in time, State Farm was not appointing anybody down on the Gulf. They had um appointed somebody in the city where I was gonna go. Uh, and so I said, Well, I'm gonna go independent. I had a guy that I was friends with because at that point in time, you we had a percentage growth we could write, so we could only grow in fire, which we call fire homeowners, by like three percent. So I was sending business out left and right to everybody. I'm like, good lord, why can't I write any of this? We're just writing tons of cars, can't write any homeowners cat exposure. So um this was you know, uh Ivan. So, you know, we were limited on what we could write in homeowners, and so we were just referring a bunch of it out. And when yeah, so when I didn't have a spot, I said, Well, I'm gonna try my hand at going independent. And so I did that and loved it, uh, but had some things go on, ended up being with an agency that got acquired by Arthur J. Gallagher, and um just really didn't fit at that time, so went back uh captive and ultimately I'm from Carrollton, so I wanted to come back home and uh have my own agency, and so fell in my lap that State Farm had an opportunity in Bremen, which is about 12 miles from Carrollton. So I took that over in 14 and uh did that for a while, and the independent itch just never left me. So, you know, we kept trucking along with State Farm and it was great, but uh ultimately just you know, y'all are in the same market that that everybody's in. It's become a little bit of a hard market, and my me and my wife have been talking about it for a while that it might be an opportunity to switch because she actually is in this business too, so she's had an agency since 16.
SPEAKER_03Oh, cool.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, so I decided to jump ship and go work with her. I say with her, she probably says for her. I choose my battles.
SPEAKER_01Wow, I didn't know I didn't know your wife had an agency. That's so cool. With the uh state farm opportunity, was that hard to let go?
SPEAKER_04It's hard to let go of the money that was just rolling into my checking account every month. But I will say it it was not hard to let go in the fact that I I do love to produce and I had just gotten to the point of where I was really complacent and we just weren't growing at a level that we used to. And I don't know, my heart wasn't in it really, uh you know. So um, but yeah, I tell you, when you go from um that check hitting your account twice a month to walking out the door going, Hey, I've got to figure out how to recreate this, it's it's a nerve-wracking feeling, right?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and and then then also trying to figure out how to not just have the job that you were doing, right? Where you're doing all those things plus a whole bunch of other stuff, right? So it's it's that that's that balance, like shifting to the ownership mentality. Yeah, what was the earliest big like win as an agent that made you just say, I love this. This is this is the way to go. And I doubt it was when the light, when the lights got turned out.
SPEAKER_04No, it was not it. So when I left and went independent then when I was working on the coast, uh I decided, and it kind of fell in my lap. I had this gentleman that he was a private client, pretty much private client group um through like AIG. And I was like, man, I tell you, I can I can do this. You know, I understood the product and really started going after a lot of high-value um personalized clients, and um ended up getting this one guy that had four or five houses spread out through a couple of states and a plane. And I mean, I I think all in all he was probably $70,000, $80,000 in premium at that point. Might have been more than that. That that was the big win where I was like, well, this can be something good. So I I enjoyed doing that. It's a lot easier to find some of those customers sitting down at the beach with you know million-dollar homes there than it is at Carrollton. But uh that was the that was the first big win that that told me I really really wanted to continue doing this.
SPEAKER_01So you've been in multiple agencies. What is your team like now? And what kind of teams have you been a part of and have you grown with?
SPEAKER_04So relatively they've all been small other than one. You know, most of the agencies that I've been with have been under, you know, five or under. Um, they've always been personalized other than one. Um, I was a part of, and that's the one that got taken over by Gallagher. Um, I was with um an independent firm that they were the largest uh condominium association insurer on the coast. So back then there were around 315 condominium associations. So we're saying like you know, the big 20-story at the beach condos. Um, so there were around about 315 and they insured maybe 130 of them. And so there was about uh 15 or 20 people there, and it was huge. Um, you know, it was one of those things where you know you write you write one of those condos and everybody's high-fiving and uh celebrating, you lose one of those condos, and then somebody's just threatened to be fired. They're big. Yeah, but yeah, most yeah, that's tough.
SPEAKER_02You get the big premiums, it's it is so exciting, but then it's like they're gonna leave, and then that's not gonna be great.
SPEAKER_04Yep. But um, my state farm agency, we got as large as six, had a bunch of cubicles all stacked everywhere. That was interesting. Um, and then uh now we are there are four of us.
SPEAKER_02Cool. So how's that set up? Do you have a bullpen or is it offices?
SPEAKER_04Uh it's offices right now. Um I've I've still got the cubicles. I threatened to bring them out, but nobody's jumping on board with those.
SPEAKER_02So we don't even have cubes. So a bunch of people um in you know, intelligence or whatever came out to my office a couple years ago, and and so they know, but we have like a bullpen, so they're all jammed in this area. COVID, we kind of spread out a little bit because I didn't want to get in trouble, but they didn't want to be spread out, like so. It's interesting because once they get used to that bullpen thing, they really like it. Yeah, because there's a lot of energy.
SPEAKER_04Our problem is the noise.
SPEAKER_02Well, if you have the right headphones, then it it they don't hear the outside noise and the mic doesn't pick up the noise, so it doesn't sound like a scammer call room coming from India or whatever.
SPEAKER_04Well, you know, these days, I mean, after COVID, I mean, really, you have to second guess how much space you really need. You don't need that much. I mean, heck, if you if you run out of space, you just send somebody home and say work remote.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah. And I have two now that are remote and they're doing it's working out pretty well. So we'll see how that goes. Much easier to hire, but um, how about the culture? Like, what have you done to create that culture in your agency? I'm assuming that it's pretty tight.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, I mean, the the culture's good in that we're all friends. Uh I I will say probably my weakness is producing a really good culture. Um, I'm one of those people that I just put my head down and just beat up the phone or work too many hours, and then I look up and try to figure out if everybody's happy or upset or not. I'll say this, you know, really being a part of Teledudes and having the Slack channel, I I think has helped out our culture a lot because we're all more engaged in trying to create a motivating, positive environment. Um I'll I'll say that definitely does help out, uh, other than the fact that I still feel like we're running like a boiler room um with all these leads coming in, everybody on the phones. But um, you know, that's that's the one thing that we're trying to do is just, you know, beat up Slack, stay positive, you know, congratulate each other when uh, you know, when we have a a cell and it doesn't hurt that you know, uh we use agency zoom. Every time you have that cell, that explosion of confetti goes on.
SPEAKER_02So you know it's it's a real confetti too. Shoot at it.
SPEAKER_04I need to do that. I need to just get a gun and just fire it at somebody, blow it up, and that that'll bring the enthusiasm.
SPEAKER_01It doesn't take much to like to get the team going. And I I I agree with you with when it comes to like having something like Slack, because that's how we communicate now a lot more, right? Is through text and stuff like that. So just having like the team and you know, little emojis here and there, it's it does. It's like it creates more of an engaging environment. It's a it's a little thing, but it's kind of a big thing.
SPEAKER_04No, I agree. I mean, anything that can keep the, you know, I look at it, anything that can keep the camaraderie and conversation going without anybody actually standing up to come walk in there to talk to you. Like that's that's a positive because the last thing I want is you standing up there trying to, you know, shoot the breeze with me. I'd just shoot me an emoji on slack and let's keep going.
SPEAKER_01And it's crazy too, because I mean talking about COVID, that was the first time I realized like we we I mean, we just we didn't know uh when we were gonna have to pack it up, and all of a sudden one day they're like, Okay, pack it up. You gotta go home. And it was like, I mean, we were up and running within two hours, and everybody was at home, uh, business as usual, like no change at all, no negative change within numbers, our KPIs and stuff, and no change in behavior because of Slack and all the tools that we were using, because we I guess we operated more like uh a remote agency at the time, unknowingly, you know. And um yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_04My people were begging to go back into the office during COVID. We were the most uh dysfunctional remote, remote agency on the planet, even though yeah, I you know code aside, it was a horrible, horrible thing, but we made more money in 2020 than than I had made since 2017. I mean, it was it was unreal I guess everybody was at home. I wish we could, you know, I wish we could go back to the day where everybody was at home and we could just blow up the phones again.
SPEAKER_02Just go go to Wuhan and then come back. Yeah, it is remarkable. Like as much as everybody complained about 2020, I have yet to find many uh business owners who are still in business who have negative things to say about the finances that resulted from 2020. I mean, that's when we launched Teledudes, that's how we everything grew. We our agencies were it was big, you know. It was very helpful to have people home because our contact rates went up. Um, they it's interesting though, we were we learned so much through that time that we were able to fine-tune and get fairly close to the same level of those contact rates afterwards. Yeah, like we have pretty good, pretty solid contact now.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, I um I I wish that I would have had teledudes back then. I mean, we were so inefficient at following up on leads, and even though at State Farm, you wouldn't have been able to implement uh that strategy um just because there's too many um compliance things that would have thrown you off. But you know, with the first time that I heard uh the the podcast and what y'all were doing, it was like a light bulb went off, and I was like, oh my god, that is what I've been searching for for forever. How in the world, how in the world do I implement it? And it was like nope, you can't implement it. Nope, you can't implement it. And I was like, all right, well, I'm I'm gonna do something where I can figure out how to implement this.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Well, and even a state farm, I think there's enough ways that you can get around it.
SPEAKER_04You just don't want to get caught.
SPEAKER_02Well, yeah.
SPEAKER_01I don't know. You just can't have anything installed on your computers, right? Is that the the deal?
SPEAKER_04That's right, yeah. I mean, if it's not their software, it you cannot have it installed.
SPEAKER_01So you can't even have Slack. That's so crazy. So crazy.
SPEAKER_04Well, when you house more data than the Library of Congress, they want to make sure that nothing slips out.
SPEAKER_01Right.
SPEAKER_04Yeah.
SPEAKER_01But but you have a cell, like everybody has a cell phone.
SPEAKER_04That's true, yeah. I mean, and there and there are ways, because I mean I I tried to do it before I actually pulled the trigger this time to do it. Um, and I don't even remember who I spoke to. It was like I think you had a it was a lady Haley or something, and she and I were trying to game plan how in the world I could get this to work, and I just I couldn't figure it out. And she was like, Well, you can bring in additional laptops or cell phones or um ways to try to do it.
SPEAKER_02But I mean, the only thing is Slack, right? I mean, that's the big issue.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, I mean, because you really don't need I mean, because photo murdering all you're doing is just yeah, is just trans transferring the phone call in, so that's not really a a big deal. But at that time I thought it was because I thought we were supposed to have like seats on phone burner and all that kind of stuff, and that that's not the case.
SPEAKER_02Right. Yeah, that's where some of our messaging Yeah, because I I really did.
SPEAKER_04I mean, even when I pulled the trigger this time, I thought that I was gonna have to have four seats on phone burner, and Laney was like, no, no, I mean, that's not not anything, what you have to do.
SPEAKER_02So right. Yeah, I I guess maybe that's a messaging thing on our head.
SPEAKER_01So let's talk about your recruiting process. How how have you brought people into the agency uh historically?
SPEAKER_04Historically, I always used uh we had an um a deal with a a vendor called Career Plug, but it was always piggybacking off of Indeed and then um LinkedIn, and then there was another one, Zip Recruiter. Uh, we used that, and um it used to be so easy. I I promise you, coming into 2020, it was the easiest thing in the world to find just hundreds of resumes to try to get people, but then after that, it was like literally everybody became a ghost. Um, and then mainly it was you know more if we were going to recruit, it was from a an existing team member that we were trying to get them to send over somebody that they knew. Uh it really just cut down on well, it's kind of like you know, having to put so many people through the pipeline in order to get one to show up for an interview and then to move them forward to hire. So we just kind of started using our existing team members to recruit their friends. Right now we're at, you know, you know, if y'all could reach through the computer and slap me, you probably would when I say this. But right now I'm not recruiting it. Well, it's really because uh we kind of have a family affair going on right now, so it's highly likely anybody would leave, but it's always possible. But uh really the only recruiting that I'm doing right now is just talking to people about what I'm doing. If they seem interested, we're carrying on that conversation. I haven't posted anything on indeed or anything like that.
SPEAKER_02My experience has been that when I take my foot off the gas on on the recruiting, it puts me in a very dangerous position if somebody does leave. Yes. No, and it did with me. And uh and you never know when you pretty much this.
SPEAKER_04I mean, and I and I say nobody would ever leave, and hopefully they don't, but you you say you never know, you always know somebody's gonna leave. I mean, it was just it's inevitable. And right, I just mean you never know when they're gonna leave you, they're gonna leave you when you're on vacation, or leave you when you've got something big that's gotta close, and the most inopportune time is exactly when it's gonna happen.
SPEAKER_02I mean, they will go to lunch and just never come back.
SPEAKER_04I actually had that happen before.
SPEAKER_02I have too.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, just got up, said I'm going to lunch, never came back. And I was like, oh yeah, rough.
SPEAKER_02It's a classic, really. It's interesting. Why not just say something? But you know, it's people are funny. Yeah, we're a funny animal. Funny animal.
SPEAKER_01I just saw that tactic on uh 90-day fiance. Have you guys seen that show?
SPEAKER_02Uh-uh.
unknownUh-uh.
SPEAKER_01It's the worst. It's really not good. It's not good to you, but like my wife and I will watch it. But like, so they it's all about uh, and this is a total side tangent, but it's all about somebody, you know, from different countries, and uh they either come over here or they go over there and they have 90 days to get the visa, and they so they have a long distance relationship and they gotta be together. I saw this one the other day, and they're like, She goes to like Colombia to meet her future wife, and then they go shopping for a food truck, and then all of a sudden, like in the food truck, she's like, I didn't think this out very clearly. And then it's like, what? And then and then she's like, Yeah, and then all this is excuses about her having to go home, then she goes home and she doesn't ever come back. That's a big time, that's a big time lunch break version. Side tangent, sorry.
SPEAKER_02I'm gonna go go down to Colombia and grab a whatever you grab down there and grab a Pablo Escobar and see you later. All right, wow, wow, side tangent.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman