The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
Shoot Us A Message!In this info-packed podcast, Jason shares his views on the most essential tricks for property and casualty insurance, targeting new and old agency owners who might be looking to step up their game.Key discussion points:The hiring and firing proces:. A quick and simple overview of the importance of hiring the right kind of people for your agency.Sales: The emphasis on the importance of looking after your sales as an agency owner, you’re the conductor of the orchestra. ...
Do you want to stand out in the crowd? Do you want to be different? Do you want your agency to be the one that they pick among the thousands of agents that are out there? Well, there's lots of ways to do that.
SPEAKER_01
I am great. I am able to do that. We are able to do that.
SPEAKER_00
And a very powerful way is the power of saying thank you. It is critically important that you are grateful to your clients and or customers that sign up with you. This is one of those things that gets overlooked. We work so hard to bring in that new business that we may just forget to do something that could be super, super simple or create these processes that can be super simple to bring a greater level of retention and keep these folks in your herd for longer. Really important, right? Because the more that we increase the retention, the less that we have to write to break even. And more of what we write becomes growth. And the more we grow, the quicker we get to that point where we can either sell the thing or take the foot off the gas, start collecting. So there's lots of different ways, and people have different outcomes for their agency. But the quickest way to growth is to make sure you're writing business and to plug that leaky bucket, right? That hole in the leaky bucket is where we can find some answers here. And it doesn't cost a lot. So I talked a little bit about Tiffany, about my Tiffany's experience with Randy from Tiffany's. I've talked about him in all of our coaching calls. Um we've talked about it everywhere. Because it's such a such an important story, right? The the power of saying thank you and the power of writing that thank you down in a card and sending it out. We can definitely create an environment and a process where this occurs, right? We could have our our sales folks every morning. The first thing they do after your sales meeting is write out their thank you cards to whoever purchased yesterday. Now, if they're selling one or two a day, this isn't a lot, right? Or you could you could lump it all into one week, wait till the end of the week, they send it on Friday. Whatever you want to do to create that process, really, really important process. Let me explain the counter, the opposite, right? Randy created a relationship between me and Tiffany's, the jewelry place, that probably went from a lifetime value of 100 to 200 bucks to a lifetime value of well in the five digits. Probably spent more than 10K there now. So he did it with that thank you card. He did it by following up, like those things I talked about. But let me talk about the opposite effect, okay? Because for me, and I think for many people, it's really important that you feel that the place who earned your business actually cares, right? That they're grateful because without gratitude, who cares? If they're not grateful that that I made the decision to work with them for whatever it is, if they're not grateful for that, or it's a not a great process or a great experience, what do I do? I'm gonna find somebody else, right? So let me talk a little bit about a recent experience that I had that was a big purchase. I bought two condos. Okay. So one of the things that we love to do is grow, right? Grow our business. And a great financial strategy is to then take that money, that you any profits, instead of buying depreciated assets like cars and boats and toys, you invest in properties. So I did that. I started an LLC, invested in two properties in Colorado, in Durango, in Ski Town, um, right outside of Purgatory, and two beautiful condos for Airbnb. So they're on Airbnb, they're doing their thing. But the process to purchasing these two condos, which were new builds, um, the process leading up to closing, I worked with uh obviously a realtor and a lender, and we're talking about about a million and a half dollar purchase for these two condos, with financed, of course. So purchase these condos, and after we closed, which was a nightmare, right? They sort of pushed really hard to have the closing date sooner than these things were actually ready. So, number one, not a great experience. In fact, a couple of the things that still needed that needed to be fixed, still not fixed almost a year after taking ownership of these condos, okay, because of the builder, because once you pay for it, they're gone. But this is what's interesting no email, no call, and no personal thank you card from the realtor. Now let's let's think about that. If the realtor on the buying side made two and a half percent off of one and a half million, they took down a pretty hefty commission, right? That's $37,500. He pulled down a $37,500 check when those things closed, and they closed early because they pushed to close it early. Um, I think it was on the builder side, maybe they were running out of money, but they needed it done. I followed their instructions and orders because they they put a little pressure saying, you know, they may back out, blah, blah, blah. So anyhoot purchased this thing, no thank you card, no, no email, no call, which for me is pretty frustrating. Will I work with this with this realtor again? Probably not. Probably not. Will I work with that lender? No, probably not. Do I have other lenders I've worked with who have showed gratitude, who uh other realtors who have showed gratitude? Absolutely. And and I wonder why I would consider working with the one who wasn't grateful versus the one that was. I wouldn't, right? So, real important, apply that to the business as we bring people in that we're not making a ton off of, but for them, they're spending a lot, right? I know that you ride a new household, maybe we're making a hundred bucks a year, 200 bucks a year, you know, a few hundred dollars for the lifetime value of this of this client, but for them, they're spending twelve hundred, fifteen hundred, a couple thousand dollars every six months. So for them, it's a lot of money coming out of their pocket. And for them, there's a high likelihood that they would be grateful to see us show gratitude, right? And what does that earn from them? I think that earns loyalty, right? If if you can just move your folks from renewing one extra time than they would have just by extending some gratitude, that can have a big impact on your retention when you're looking at your overall book and and everything that goes into it. So I can't stress enough how important those thank you cards are. Gave you that process for them, and then some other things, some other ideas that you can throw in there. We can keep track of customers' birthdays and their spouse's significant others' birthdays, and we can send something out. Now, is this gonna have a huge effect or big is it gonna be a big needle mover? Maybe, maybe not. You can get creative, put a QR code in there, that is some kind of referral program, or even uh throw in a QR code for a quote for an umbrella, whatever, right? Lots of different ideas there. Uh, sending out holiday cards, personalized letters. We can do um a client appreciation events. I know that a lot of carriers are gonna help to sponsor some of those events. So something to talk about with your carrier. So those are some great ideas that we can use to incorporate gratitude into our business that in turn is gonna create a longevity of that customerslash client, keep them with you longer. And again, we want to build the wall up higher so there's a less likelihood that they take off. That is another playbook. I'm Craig Pretziger. Make sure to follow us on all of the podcast platforms, and if you watch it on YouTube, hit that subscribe button. Thanks. See you soon.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.