The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Matt Sutika's Magically Marvelous Surreal Successful PART 2
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
What would your number one recommendation be to any agent jumping into this world to be successful right out of the gate?
SPEAKER_00My number one always is that I am not a kid that was, you know, the smartest. I had no money going into it, but hard work and just going for it has led to all my success. So I think you can't get into this space unless you're a grinder.
SPEAKER_01Can you go through the whole process of how an independent agent would use Obi? Yeah, absolutely.
SPEAKER_00So uh we just uh launched with our portal. So we have a portal that you would access, just like you know, accessing Travelers or State Auto or any of your other carriers. You know, you'll get a login, you go in, and you know, from there you go through about the same uh, let's call it, the user experience that you would if you went through and got a quote off our website. And uh yeah, it's a pretty seamless, nice little process. So you go in, you know, you you got your dashboard uh with all your you know former quotes or policies that you've you know quoted about. You can do a new quote right off the dashboard. And it's a very, like what I would say, very smooth, easy way to quote. There's not a lot to a one-to-four rental, right? As far as like it's not uh a million questions, it's not like you're working like a whole package business, you know, owner's opportunity on some complex business, you know. It's it's pretty simple and you can get a quote pretty quick. But yeah, you full X, it's like it's not uh like a wholesale relationship, it's not um, you know, where like we're providing the quotes like you literally uh are a producer or broker uh for us, no different than getting a traveler's contract. And a lot of the things that you can do with travelers or any other carrier, you can do uh with us. We pay, you know, we pay good commissions, I think that are a little higher than the intranorum. I believe they're right around 15%. Is I believe my guy in agency development will kill me if I got that wrong, but I believe that's where we're at. Uh so pretty competitive from a commission standpoint. Good coverages, everything built in, they'll meet lender requirements, have the correct GLs. I would say competitive rates. I'm sure we're not always the highest, not always the lowest, you know, but competitive. And yeah, I think just overall it's just a fast, easy process that if you're in this space and you got a lot of investors, that's what you're gonna really like because it's just it's very quick and easy to you know provide your investor with a quote when they're looking to purchase an asset.
SPEAKER_02And it's just rental properties, one to four doors.
SPEAKER_00Yep, just just rental one to four units, pretty simple. We might expand that, you know, as we go, but right now I think if we expand it, it'll probably expand in unit count. So, you know, going to eight units, 20 units, everything like that. But majority of the business crazy enough in the in the rental space is in the one to four unit statistically. That has a pretty good majority of all rentals in the United States are in that you know, in that one to four unit space. So, you know, I think that'll keep us quite busy for a little while.
SPEAKER_02You created your niche and you went after it.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, absolutely. Um, really cool product. So, yes, we're looking for you know brokers or producers that are you know actively writing, you know, uh that would consider themselves either broker for real estate investors, you know, those are the people that we're bringing on first, you know, because we started with our test pilot. Now we're you know bringing on consistent flow of agencies. You know, we're we're wanting to make sure that you know we're a good value. So we're wanting people that are you know actively writing the policies. Eventually we'll probably uh you know offer it out to you know the even the individuals who are doing just a couple a year, but you know, right now uh uh on the onset, we're really uh wanting to bring on people that were just like me who are really looking for this product in the market.
SPEAKER_01Cool. What would you say are some tips for people that own units like one to four unit properties? What dangers do you see? How do you avoid them?
SPEAKER_02Would it be Airbnb properties too?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so um we can do we can do Airbnb, we can do the short-term uh rentals. We have a product we can do even when it's vacant and uh some minor builders' risk if you're doing like uh remodel where we call it more um cosmetic. You know, if you're doing full construction, then you know you'll you'd need a builder's risk uh type policy, of course. But if you're doing cosmetic, you know, redoing the kitchens can be banking for a while, we can handle that. Um, we had to have something for the Airbnb short term because that's just such a popular you know thing nowadays in the market. So if you're not doing that, it's like kind of not like having uh Uber or or ride share coverage, you know, on the auto side. Like uh yes, you just kind of have to have it, in my opinion, to have that flexibility, especially the rental side is always something going on. It's it's not as uh clean and cut as the home side, you know, home, it's primary residence, you got someone living in it all the time. Rentals, people are always maybe have a rent in there, maybe short term, maybe they're remodeling, maybe it's vagant, maybe they're fixing flip. There's just a lot more action going on in the rental space. So, you know, we're make sure we cover for that. Really, you know, some pitfalls are uh realistically um maybe not covering things correctly. Uh for us, we we run a full uh replacement cost uh using data. So we're usually pretty accurate on uh getting a good uh accurate replacement cost uh figure for you. Um I think deductibles sometimes get investors uh in trouble, you know. Uh they're not looking at their investment their deductible as like a business decision, and that's really what it is is you know, uh, do you want to and can you afford in your PL as an investor a thousand or five thousand or twenty five hundred deductible? Meaning that, you know, do you want to save the year-to-year cost of the insurance and go with the higher deductible? But if a claim does happen, would would $5,000 wipe you out to even have that in a cash reserve on a on a single family rental? Maybe, maybe you don't. So those are things that we like to have conversations on, and they're really business decisions uh using insurance as the product that we think is is pretty valuable to have conversations on. But those are the two you know biggest things because as an investor, you're looking at your opportunity different than a homeowner thinks about like, you know, if someone happened in my home, like what do I do? Where do I go? Like they're out of place. Like, so they're caring about like ALE and you know, how do I get my this like this is displacing my children and all stuff. When you're on the rental side, you're caring about like, all right, this how this just lost me income. This just, you know, how do I not, you know, go in debt because of this cash flow? I mean, you're just looking at things completely different. So I think generally what we like about just our company and being in the space is that we built our product around that same thought process, uh, because myself and our two other founders all come from the real estate space as well. So we really we get what these um owners are going through, and then we built an insurance product really for us that translates well to everybody else.
SPEAKER_02So I have a question for you. Yeah, absolutely. So it's a scenario you have two units next to each other separate, okay, different different people. This one has about 12 feet of snow on it, and the gas meter is buried under the snow. This the gas meter breaks, causing a leak, forcing the neighbor, short-term renters, to then have to evacuate.
SPEAKER_00Okay.
SPEAKER_02So none of that's covered by anybody's policy, huh?
SPEAKER_00To be frank, I think a lot of people would try to like sidestep this question or answer it. Like, I am on the like the broker side, like this is something that I would consult um Laura and our MGI or claims department or someone like I am far from like claim scenario expert, um, you know, to be able to answer that on there, whether or not even you know, that scenario, because you know, even from a standpoint of when people used to get car acts as my agency, like we would always, you know, make sure that a claim rep who's handling that day to day is looking at that. But I'm sure there's a lot of scenarios on these unique loopholes that you know happen, not just on the rental side, but homeowners, auto, you know, whatever. Like there's always, I feel like these scenarios. I remember in my state farm, there's always these things where you're like, uh, like like we had one one time where uh we had like an Iceland-Greenland scenario. I like one was called like village and the other one was called like Eagle, but Eagle had Villas addresses and uh and then Villas had uh you know Eagle's uh addresses, like like yeah, they had them flip, but it got so confusing that the lender just assumed that it was Eagle and Eagle, villas and villas, right? And when we got it sent to us, we did the same because like why would you not?
SPEAKER_02Why would you think that it would be like we would do that?
SPEAKER_00And so, you know, of course, there was a claim on on one of them, and the first thing that this carrier who would I didn't agree with was like, Oh, well, like we're not actually covering this because like we're you know over here. So you're a clerical error, right? Like it's yeah, that's yeah, they no, they ended up taking care of it or whatever, but you know, I mean, um, there's always those scenarios where I think that you hope that, and I would I'd hope this for our TPA and you know, and our MGA and Laura that runs you know us as a carrier in a claims department, that you do what makes sense, even if it doesn't technically fully black and white, maybe state that in the policy. I think there's a lot, and I've seen this with carriers, I saw it on State Farm for sure. I will give them credit for it. Is if it doesn't actually say it or it's just nothing, but like there is still a cause, you know. I I do think that uh we can still say that claims adjusters and some other people do have a heart, as much as we get such a bad rap for not paying. Yeah, I think we pay more for things that we shouldn't than not pay for things that we you know should, you know.
SPEAKER_02I agree with that. Yeah, I think the perception is that the company is doing whatever it can to not pay, right? And I I certainly agree that that may be the case with some of the 800 numbers, only because they're so unprofitable, right? They're running in and in the negative, so they have to, but they put themselves in that situation. Now we're charging more. Most of the carriers, right, are charging more, and as a result, you get a higher this gives that opportunity. And I know that when I was the agent day-to-day, you know, the guy that answered the phone and helped everybody and taught did claims, like I talked them into yeses when it started as a no, right? And I think that there that is a big value of the agent. Absolutely.
SPEAKER_00That I couldn't I couldn't agree more. I think there's always a conversation, right? Like, you know, any claim, if it's closed, there's a conversation to be had. And you know, yeah, this goes to our question from you know 30 minutes ago of like, do why do we not think brokers and agents are going away? Is you know, AI and different technology can't replace that right there. They can really only do black and white. And you see it in trading from stocks is that you know, when they use the bots, they just can trade off of the headlines, but they don't really actually maybe understand the headlines so that they just see like you know, auto sales down, they just start selling off anything that's related to an auto company, and they don't realize, you know, that you know it's maybe it's a good thing, right? Like, and you know, they just uh they just take it out of verbatim. So I uh I think that's a prime example to your point of like why agents are still important, brokers are still important, humans are still important that like we are still far from um taking that uh heart out of the tin man, you know what I mean? Like we we still need that to happen.
SPEAKER_01I look at that and I look at insure tech and I look at it all like man, I know if I was going to war, I'd want an Uzi rather than uh you know a little butter knife, like it's all tools, right? Somebody's got to man the tools. Yep.
SPEAKER_02I mean, there are such amazing tools now, and to prevent people from having those tools in their hands is bananas. Luckily, we have really good tools.
SPEAKER_00It's still they do a good job, but yeah, I'm with you. It's like you do hope that they supposedly you want to continue with them, you want to like keep going, right? Like, I think that's the the point, right? Like, you know, not to out your company or anyone's, you know, of like it's just like my dad used to call State Farm the the biscuit train with gravy wheels or whatever, or the gravy train with biscuit wheels, one of the two or whatever. Like, you want the good opportunity to keep going. So, like it's like bring on the technology, bring on the changes, let me keep growing with you, you know. Like, let us, you know, keep going. You're not allowed to, right? At probably said company, bring in your own technology and do anything, probably too much that uh they don't allow on your computer or want you to have. So it's like, like, help me help you, like, you know, bring me the technology so I can bring you more clients, you know. Like it's it's simple math.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so crazy. Well, cool. You know the captive space, you know the indie space, you know the insure tech space. What are some misconceptions each party might have of each other?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think that's you know, it's a good question. I think on the captive or independent side, what what I hear the most that you know gets my skin going a little bit because it's like so against how I am, is they always feel like you know, someone's gonna take my book, right? If I work with Obi, they're gonna eventually steal my clients, right? Like that is the big thing that I hear from the IA channel as far as insure tech. They just think that eventually, because they're direct to consumer as well, that they're eventually gonna like you know take their clients, even though like 90% of even the non-insure techs have a DTC arm as as well or some facet of it, right? Like you can go to their site and get a quote, and you know, even like some of the captives, like people can go to the site, get a quote, and get sent to another agent of that same company, and you can lose out too, right? Like, because all of a sudden they find out that you know there's a uh a state farm agent closer to them, and the next thing you know, you're getting the the BOR internally, so it happens across the board, right? So I don't like when people fear that. Uh and ultimately if if if insure tax are getting into the IA space, it's because they value the space, they see that it's profitable, they see that they they don't want to be direct to consumer, they want to be B2B to C, right? Like they want to work with that independent. Like, frankly, for me, like I think about it very simple, and that's how I explain too. Like, why would I want to have to talk to the client, service the client, answer the client, yelling at me, happy with me, all the stuff, do all that stuff. If I can just provide you the policy and you can do all that, I only pay out an expense if you write a policy. I don't want to break that model. I like that model, speaking as like the carrier or the insured tech, like it's a great business model, right? And then uh, and then the misconception I think on the you know our side is you know, I see too many people thinking that the independent agent isn't like tech savvy or isn't isn't up with the times. And and and I don't think that that is at all true. I think that we have a lot of intelligence in the IA channels and the captive channels. I think what I would challenge the space to do is to push more and not be just okay with the status quo. Like I would love to see more of the independent and captives, you know, pushing their internal captive uh to do more and bring in more technically. If I'm an independent agent, you know, really not looking to do the same thing that's worked for four years, and and my biggest thing for the space in general is don't chase the silver bullet, create it, right? Like I see way too many on the uh independent or the captive side that are uh you know on the social media channels and they're just trying to follow you know five or six people and you know and try to do what they do, it's like you know, try to do that, like go out and you know, do things to challenge and and be the person that someone wants to, you know, copy your silver bullet or who's calling you because you know you're doing something. Because if you're calling someone to like, you know, I'm not saying don't have mentors or whatever. I'm just saying, like, if you're constantly paying for the next shiny object or next piece of technology out there, and you just think that that's actually going to make you a better agent, broker, or owner, you know, that's just really not true. Uh use technology to enhance what you're already doing, right? Like be passionate, drive to do stuff and realize what you need to help you even get to the next level. Say something by myself. But like I took the opportunity to go build that insurance company for century 21. I needed technology to make that process faster, right? So that's like an example of you know what I'm getting at go find that opportunity and then go find tech and carriers who use tech or your own company, get them to bring you tech so that you can you know handle those opportunities and ultimately make some sales and bring on good clients.
SPEAKER_02That's awesome. How about what would your number one recommendation be to any agent jumping into this world to be successful right out of the gate?
SPEAKER_00My number one always is that I am not a kid that was you know the smartest. I had no money going into it, but hard work and just going for it has led to all my success. So I think you can't get into this space unless you're a grinder or want to be a grinder, especially in the early years. So that's always my advice is if you think, you know, in your head, like this is what you're gonna do and this is how hard you're gonna work, freaking triple that effort. Uh, because to me, that's where it really takes. It's it's not an easy industry. A lot of people that you talk you'll talk to are five, 10 years in and they forget about those first couple of years. Like, you know, I would think majority of people hearing me speak today have had the ramen, you know, not see their kids, like they've had those moments, uh including myself, you know, uh credit card bills, stress. Like it is it's a great industry once you get in with the renewals, but it because it's such a low commission rates and everything like that to get going and you have to build it up, that you really have to be resilient. You know, you have to be dedicated to your craft. And, you know, you'll be very helpful the faster you can start working. You know, it's it's a cliche, but working, you know, on your business and not in, that's a huge thing for people. A lot of people still are answering the phones at their own agency, and you know, you eventually got to get out of that mold and move on. And the faster you get good processes in, and you know, my last bit of advice is really concentrate on your lead source because it's really easy in this industry to just throw money at uh opportunities, whether that's internet leads or mailers or cult, you know, it's it's just so easy to do that stuff. If I'm going scratch, especially if I'm going scratch and I do have some funds. Let's just say I, you know, I got into this and I did have some money in the bank. I'd spend my whole first year just getting as many people as I can to like me because in insurance we are in the I like you game, right? Because everyone has insurance and they just got to like you better than the person that they currently have their insurance with, right? Now maybe maybe you entice them a little bit with a lower cost, but at the end of the day, uh you shouldn't be going out trying to get people to write insurance with you or call you for a quote. If you're saying stuff like that, like you're not actually doing anything. People will know you're an insurance if you're doing a good job of working hard and sharing like just what you're doing, and then show them that you're a good human, show them who you are, show them that you're a good entrepreneur, show them you're a good friend. And when every six months or every year, or when they have a problem, one of those nine triggers for insurance happens. You just want them to, you know, this was my pitch at State Farm. You know, I just want one of those happen for you to think Massautica State Farm. And that's kind of the the philosophy you want as a broker, is just get them to think about you when they're ready to go, and that will create everything for you. And then this job gets real fun and easy, right? Like then it gets then it gets dangerous. That's when you can really scale. So I know that's more than you know, probably one little thing, but uh that's great.
SPEAKER_01Matt, thank you so much. Thanks for going the distance with us. Um a lot of great stuff. It's uh really cool to see agents that you know have been in so many different worlds. I think you're the first agent with InsureTech that's been on the indie side and captive, so it's a really cool perspective, I think, coming from you because you've seen it all.
SPEAKER_00I appreciate that, and uh, you know, I think that is uh I'm very lucky to have the opportunity. It's really it's cool. I love I love the insurance space. I've always been an insurance nerd. I've always, you know, when Justin Timberlake was bringing sexy back, like that was like what I wanted to do for insurance, you know. And yeah, so yeah, I I love that I've got to be involved in it, and I hope I'm involved in like 30 more things over the the course because it is such a great industry that a lot of people just don't realize it's it's recession proof, it's in the makeup, alcohol, death taxes category, like gotta have it. Someone's forcing you to do it, things like that. And if you're in it, yeah, you love it. And um, I'm just glad that we're bringing a lot of talent and a lot of you know technology and a lot of like good people into it, and people are realizing the same thing that three of us have realized that this space is is very sexy, it is very uh you know, phenomenal space to be in.
SPEAKER_02If you're in it and you don't love it, then it's important to take a look at why, you know, what's happening there, what is making it not fun, because I know that there were years where it was not fun and I didn't even want to be at the office, and I had to take a real close look and figure out, you know, what am I doing that I hate, and it was all of it, but I was working in it, right? Like not on it. And it's a big shift. I mean, even in our coaching group that we have, uh one of our one of the members, she she said, Ah, I can't let go of anything. I have to we we like beat her with with you gotta let go, and you know what? You're taking Friday off for the next forever. You're not working Fridays anymore. And she actually came back the next week, last on Wednesday, last Wednesday, and she said, I didn't work the last two Fridays. And we we were it was awesome, right? She's like, We actually wrote more. Like, exactly. It's better when we're not there.
SPEAKER_00Yep. Messing everything up. If if your team doesn't look at you like, why are you here when you walk in the door? It's it's it's not a good thing.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I couldn't.
SPEAKER_00studio i shut the door and i leave to go to the bathroom i like i'm not out there with them too much you know and it's uh it works better that is awesome well i appreciate you guys uh having me on here uh yeah it's really really cool and uh can they can people get a demo website do you have a yeah um url on the worldwide interwebs we do it'd be really bad to be a tech company and not probably have a website but yeah uh if you see ob behind me if you add insurance to that dot com uh you can get to us uh there is a way right on the website where you can get in and get connected with our agency development team which is our our IA team okay um I'm think I'm the only Matt Sudica out on social media so if you don't like to go you know on on the line right and go that way you can go to any of the social media and probably shoot me a private message and I can get you connected as well.
SPEAKER_02Isn't it fun being the only one like Craig Pretzinger there's only one there's only yeah you know that's a that's that's a good one.
SPEAKER_00I used to always say Tigger because I'm uh my wife and I are big Disney fans of course um and I you know he'd always say that line but uh it is nice growing up I like it was challenging because no one knew how to say my name and everything now as I've done a lot of like things like this and it's like how do you get a hold of me it does make it nice that like you can search my name and I'm like the only one that uh pops up. And then even Sudica in general there's not a ton of us so I'm pretty easy to find. Uh now the opposite if I ever you know do something you know bad I'm I'm also easy to find too probably so uh kind of gotta stay on my good behavior. Yeah and Phil Collins wrote that song Sue Su Sudaka so I I thought I loved you and now I love you like an X because that is my line. So normally when I do a podcast you know a lot of times the host beforehand will say like hey how do I say your last name and I always tell him I'm like Sudica like suit like the Phil Collins song like Sue Sue Sud Sudaka yeah because I my dad growing up used to lie to us uh us boys or three boys and uh used to tell us that he you know he knew him and they he wrote that song about about us. Oh that's so it wasn't until later that I realized it was a different uh spelling and you know he really wasn't saying Sudaka because studio isn't it Susu Studio oh it's like sudio yeah you think and so yeah the amount of people I legitly told that my dad uh knew him and he wrote that song about us um the funny thing is no one ever called me out because I don't think anybody actually really oh you told everybody too because your dad I started telling people because like I mean why would my dad lie to me you know when I killed my dad right now yeah so I would tell people and it's amazing even when I tell people now for like the podcast how many people are like oh my god that's crazy so the the song's about your name you know no no like I'm just trying to help you with like the you know where like people will put in parentheses like how to pronounce it I'm like I just you know it's a good way but yeah I think it's the age old thing if if you say something with conviction and a straight face you know nine out of ten people will believe you or they won't call you out on it. You know it's kind of one of those that's so good.
SPEAKER_01We almost got to the whole interview without that golden nugget right there. So good I know I guess that's it.
SPEAKER_02That's it. Cool manobi insurance.com hopefully Idvy will throw that link in the notes down below or if you're listening then you didn't see me point so good for you enjoy the rest of your drive go to the next episode don't listen to Rogan thanks guys for having me all right thanks Matt have a great one bye
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman