The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Matt Sutika's Magically Marvelous Surreal Successful PART 1
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
The wildest thing that ever happened to me was starting an agency at 22 years old with a bunch of 22-year-olds, not really understanding the fact that what that would bring is hangovers, you know, things happening in the bathroom, overflowing toilets, just crazy stuff within your girlfriends showing up, you know, that they met on social media, that you know, they stood them up for a date and they found him on there. And, you know, even to the point where I think the call me maybe was like a big song. And as a joke, one of my team members put that up on our billboard of State Far Matt Sudaka, call me maybe. And we actually had people calling us, maybe not just for insurance reasons. Not a ton of crazy stuff happened in the old insurance side, but that was some wild fun times. And you know, with that, uh, I'm Matt Sudica, I'm out of Florida, I work with Obi and I'm an insurance dude.
SPEAKER_03So I like that in the series of crazy things of the 22-year-olds, there was crazy things happen in the bathroom, comma, all the toilets were overflowing. So there's like that wasn't part of the crazy stuff happening in the bathroom.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, you know what? Uh, I don't have to deal with state farm compliance anymore. Uh, so I could probably tell you a little bit more than you know what the real stuff. But you know, it's like I I wish I had the lady driving through the window to pay her premium or some crazy, you know, things happening. Uh, ours was more just the wildness of having young people, you know what? Because I had 20, 30 people right out of college and just the individual day-to-day stuff from how we would leave to do this at work and just the none of them I think had parents or that they or they remember they were brought up by parents and not by like wolves. Um, and so it was just like our version of this like boiler room meets Wolf of Wall Street, and that was my early State Farm days. So in theory, it was very wild, not as much like a crazy individual, you know, one scenario. It was just this was everyday life that it was ran like no other uh agency out there, and it's 100% the reason why is you know, State Farm might want to consider not giving a 22-year-old an agency again.
SPEAKER_03So you know, I had a friend in high school who crashed his car through the front door of a bakery in broad daylight. He wasn't drunk, it was just like he said he'd lost control of his car. He never explained exactly what happened, but the one thing that he says, and I hope he's it's true, but it doesn't really matter. He said that he got out of the car after he crashed through the thing and he walked up to the counter and said, I'll take a dozen donuts after he smashed through the it is crazy, you know.
SPEAKER_00Just like you know, elaborating on I'm now I'm now I'm thinking through this a little bit and I'm jogging, is you know, I had one day I show up and and I'm getting photos of social media because I I bought a bunch of smart cars because I thought it was cool to have my because you had to go take inspections of the homes, right? And this wasn't the only time, but the funniest one was getting these photos where one of my team members had apparently parked the Matt Sutica State Farm smart car at a gentleman's club, uh and left it overnight because apparently he had, I don't know, I guess too many beverages or whatever. Um, and so that was posted all over my social media, our our state farm account. It wasn't uh a laughing matter in the moment, but uh, you know, definitely, and I I wish that was the only time the amount of times I got photos uh because of these cars, because my team was supposed to, you know, uh drive them appropriately. And again, they were 22 years old out of college, so they were always left at a bar, you know, on the side of the road with a boot on them. Yeah, you know, always something. So uh yeah, don't buy, don't buy a bunch of smart cars uh because you know, you you want uh force your team to go take pictures of homes, and uh they all complain that they either don't have a car or they're uh don't want to pay for gas. So in theory, it seemed like a good idea.
SPEAKER_02That's so funny. That's a great story, right there. The the strip club, of course.
SPEAKER_03Isn't it ironic that it's called a gentleman's club? I think the lots of people you see are there are gentlemen. I I mean from what you've told me, Jason.
SPEAKER_02I think that they say that so that hoping that it influences the people that come in there, it's a act.
SPEAKER_03So they have a different avatar than who is actually attending, but they're trying to create a message-to-market match, or they're trying to create a market for that.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, right.
SPEAKER_03The gentlemen aren't gonna go there.
SPEAKER_00I want you to act gentlemanly while you're there.
SPEAKER_03Okay, I see that.
SPEAKER_00You know, uh, I think it's you know, just the uh nice word for someone like me who didn't know uh if we needed to be PC with the audience or not, uh the draw was happening.
SPEAKER_02So, Matt, I want to hear the story. How did you get into insurance with State Farm and everything? And then how did you get to where you're at today?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, absolutely. So uh dad, uh 40-year state farm agent, so pretty simple story. Uh, uncle, state farm agents, all up in Michigan. I was recruited simply their sales leader. I don't know what they call them now, but they're you know, district manager, whatever you want to call them, had moved from Michigan down to Indianapolis. He wanted to kind of blow things up, so he wanted to do a youth movement. I get a call from him because he met my dad in uh convention out in Las Vegas. He's like, I want your, you know, I want to grow this thing with 22-year-olds or people right out of school. I don't want uh the typical way State Farm used to do it was like go get your nose bloody and then you know get married, have kids, and then we'll give you an office because they wanted you to have experience. He thought the opposite. He wanted the gentleman's club, the Red Bulls, the the you know, bathroom overflows. He wanted that boiler room, internet lead mafia type uh uh atmosphere. So he was happy to you know bring on people that kind of had that energy. So that's why I started, uh did that for about four or five years. Uh, was pretty fortunate to be there. Um, pretty much their top new office and then like a top 20 overall office in the country. You know, we were just blowing it up. I won't go into my PL uh because at that time I was still 22 and I didn't understand that you got to be like profitable and all that stuff. Uh, I just knew like, here's how I write this much to make this trip happen and you know, win this prize and you know, win a plaque that I had to pay for, anyways, you know, things like that. That transitioned once I realized, you know, wow, I built a pretty good book here and I don't actually own it. I can't sell it. You know, uh, what do I want to do? I'm like 25, 26. So met some uh individuals uh up in Chicago uh that uh were involved with Century 21, the real estate company, talked to them. Long story short, they wanted me to come build them an insurance company to basically convert the uh homeowners uh of the realtors right at the time of sale to a homeowner's product. And so I built from scratch uh an independent agency up there in Chicago. Uh this was 2017. Uh through that, got into real estate, got into insured tech because I started to dislike the length of time it took me to get a quote or the fact that I couldn't just connect the dots. So, you know, I started to work with some of the insured tech uh carriers to see if I could access them from a as a broker. And you know, in 2017, we we probably all remember that a lot of these insured techs at that point were not very broker friendly. Uh, so I was trying to break that mold of, you know, getting in there and and representing the IA space and letting them know, hey, you know, like you have good products that are instant, like, you know, have me go over there. And then flash forward uh through that real estate journey and that tech journey led me to Obi, which is kind of a combination of the both. And I came on to Obi to um help really in that IA channel. Uh, we just launched about 30 days ago in that space. You know, we're very active. Uh, we're not completely openly where we're uh agency only, but um, we are partners and independent agent channels. So we're pretty heavy into the IA space. And um at heart, that's what I still am as uh as an IA broker and or agent, whatever you want to call yourself. And uh that's my journey.
SPEAKER_03Super cool. That's great. Um, what would you say was the earliest win? When did you really get the taste where you were like, ah, I love this? I know that it was crazy when it was Wolf of Wall Street. Like, was that the excitement? Was it that kind of thing? Or what was it?
SPEAKER_00For me, I can I can remember exactly. I was never great at sports, but I always had to beat my brother, even if I think I had to like lie about or cheat or like push him down, you know. So for me, I've always been ridiculously competitive. Going through it, I started, I just wanted to be like my dad, you know, make six figures, never miss a soccer game. That's what I thought I was starting. And I had no clue if I was gonna be good, bad, or otherwise at my state farm. But I remember getting the call uh about three months in, there's this ranking they have for new agents, right? Where they rank you. And uh I got the call and I was gonna have our first ranking out, and it came out number two. Um, and I believe at that point was really when it clicked for me that like I love this and I want I'm addicted to you know the success of it and you know the rankings. The State Farm does a really good job of like pumping you up, like I to give them credit. They should help you more on running a business and a PL and profitability and all these other things. But what they really do get you is excited to go out and write app count and like crush some crush some policies. And so that was a turning point for me. And then once we debuted number two, and then the next month we moved to number one. Uh from there, I I've just never lost this like want to be at the top, like and be competitive and you know, and really a space. And then at that point, I knew that my journey was bigger than just you know, uh make some money, never miss a soccer game, and uh really haven't looked back.
SPEAKER_02Super cool.
SPEAKER_03I'm glad you made it to number one because we know what Ricky Bobby says about number two. That's true.
SPEAKER_00Just a brief sprint there at number two.
SPEAKER_03First loser, you can't be first loser.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I don't know, I didn't want to, you know, overachieve that much and you know, I had to just start humble, you know.
SPEAKER_02There you go. You guys have an internal channel as well right now with your agency, right? Describe in the roles.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, absolutely. So OB's give or take about 80, 90 employees overall. Um, over on the insurance brokerage side, we have about 20, 30 that are uh working in a in a Costco type model, right? Where we have um all of our normal brokerage carrier relations that we're helping place business for our clients. Um, alongside that, we've been building our Kirkland brand, which is going to be our one to four unit instant product that we are actually the MGA on. So we have the internal brokerage, we do a lot of things that a lot of other IAs are doing in the space as far as you know, writing business through general carriers. And then we also have ours. And really ours is built out of necessity. We found that the uh the rental space in our industry really needed more, more forget the tech for a second, like just needs more capacity, right? Like needs more options. Home auto is just littered, right? Like there's a new carrier coming on the scene every day. But in the rental space, there's just very few true one to four unit, like true commercial. So our biggest thing is just I needed it as a broker. Like I was writing this space. So that really is what started us on the journey of getting into it. And then we've added a little tech just to make it, you know, a nicer uh experience or quicker process, more so we could help some prop tech companies on the embedded side. But yeah, pound for pound, I I see us really as just adding capacity to the rental space and and selfishly to the internal brokerage alone.
SPEAKER_03So it's interesting you bring up tech and you know what's the big buzzword right now is AI. Yeah, your chat GBT and all that kind of stuff out there. How do you see like it's interesting launching into an environment where tech is becoming king? Do you see that there's a lot of hope for the agent moving forward with the tech, or is the tech gonna be an adversary, right? Or are we gonna be buying from robots?
SPEAKER_00No, I mean, not for me, right? Like, so if you paint me with the brush, I am like team IA channel, you know, that's happens to be in the insured tech space. I I don't think so. I think it's that you know, it's like 83% of or whatever the number is of businesses still wrote by a broker or an agent. At least for us in Obi, we're not trying to change that stat. We just want of that 83%, instead of them writing it with travelers or writing it with NRIG or whoever it would be, right, to write it with with Obi. So we're we're not trying to take away the I always call the Tom Sawyer opportunity of painting the fence. We're just trying to maybe give some better paint, you know, that dries quicker and maybe costs less or you know, or whatever, or just give more opportunity for, you know, really in the rental space, if uh your viewers are writing in that space, they know right now it's not even as much of like what does it cost? It's like can you get coverage in a lot of areas in the United States? So we personally think that we're just trying to provide better tech to the broker. They already have the business, so we have no reason to not want to work with instead of work against. And I think for brokers, I don't know what's gonna happen with Mars and technology in general, anyways, as far as like the human race. Like, you know, we're getting more and more into our phones and less being able to have a conversation. But I think that it's gonna be a long time before brokers, you know, aren't important. Really, it's the same journey I was on as a broker, is what the journey we're on as an insure tech is this hybrid thing between broker and insure tech, the channel of brokers have the business, insure techs have maybe a faster, more efficient process to get policies in front of clients and combining that. So that's that's where we sit. I'm sure that you ask other people in tech, yeah, they're trying to AI drive everything away. I just think we're a long ways from that. Same with uh driving cars. There's some people who are totally fine with uh auto-drive cars, but we're probably a long time away from uh you know uh gas station shutting down, right? So that's kind of how I feel in the same in the insurance space, unless you're in California, yeah. Yeah, true, very true.
SPEAKER_03You just bought that truck. What do you you need to get it? You're gonna have to have electric pretty soon. Me? Yeah, no way, man.
SPEAKER_02Okay, it's like 20 years or something, right?
SPEAKER_00Is it it's out that's prime example, right? 20 years. It's like, all right, you know, and and again, it's it's hard to predict much longer than 10 or 20 years, maybe even in this day and age, five years, right? So it's like, do I see the broker going out or technology taking over for them anytime soon? No, and and I don't think there really needs to be. I think the the really the fix is the fact that we need to get rid of like paper apps and three-week processes to get a quote and you know, archaic stuff. I I don't think the broker has to go. I think brokers are good people and they already have the clients.
SPEAKER_03How about captive agents? How do you see technology affecting captive?
SPEAKER_00I think that uh a lot of those captive carriers are gonna have to get creative. Um, I personally, what I think is gonna happen is a lot of acquisitions. Uh selfishly, I hope it happens for us maybe. Um, but I think the state farms and the other, you know, captive carriers, what they're gonna need to do is decide. You know, for years they were like, hey, we're gonna go into banking and mutual funds and all this stuff, right? Because they could, because they they were big and dominant. I think they're gonna tighten and realize that they got to concentrate on home and auto or whatever there it is. And I think uh state farm acquires OB to be their you know their rental arm and they're gonna bring in tech that way, right?
SPEAKER_03You're that state farm. This is an offer he's putting out.
SPEAKER_00Uh we'll sell right now like five billion. You only have five minutes. That's uh Aaron and Ryan for our evaluation, but that's uh five billion, yeah. You know, and lunch. I think they gotta buy lunch. Sushi, sushi, you know, um burger. I'm a simple farm kid at heart, so you know, just you know, as long as you're buying, I'm probably eating. So uh but yeah, I think that is you know, really what I see for those captive is they're gonna need to get into the tech space for their agents or they're gonna need to provide their agents more opportunities because I think they that their agents and their brokers are good people and uh should stay. It's just that if they're not giving them the tools, you know, just like someone myself, like you're gonna outgrow the captive. You can't just like my dad hang your shingle anymore. So I really hope the captives, like I want them to survive, right? Like personally. So I'm hoping that the a lot of these captives who have a crazy good balance sheet, able to acquire some companies, that's how they get into the tech for their agents. And again, I think it's a win-win, right? Like, you wanna have Obi wrote by 18,000 state farm agents. I would love that, you know, connection, right? Like, I think that our space should think more as like, how can you be more dropbox than like competition, right? Like, how can we you know work together to ultimately write more business in an efficient way, better for the client, things like that, and less like, hey, I'm gonna take 10 hours from you so someone can take 10 hours from me. Our industry over the last 10 years, 15 years has been about discounts and saving money. I really think that the next is efficiencies, technology, and how do we gain clients that way, right? Like, how do we provide better services? Sure, we'll save them money here and there along the way, and it'll be better, but we don't need to do the 15 minutes to save 10% anymore, right? Like that's kind of on its way out.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, well, all they've done with this, with that whole thing is compress the margins, and then there's nothing to work with, so then they have to have a life company and mutual funds and all this stuff to pay for the company, but it's like now they're getting rid of that, so they have to increase margins, right?
SPEAKER_00Yep, absolutely. So I think you're gonna see a lot more insure tech to insure tech partnerships, you know, forming, you know, because they're not gonna want to, you know, an auto carrier might not want to go into workers' comps, and they might say, Hey, pie, like, you know, let's uh let's go. I think you're gonna see farmers again. I'll just always use Obi an example. I think farmers calling Obi up and saying, Hey, for our agents, let's give them an OB contract from the rental side. You know, I think you're gonna see a lot more of that happening. Selfishly, I hope it does. And realistically, I think it's the smart uh way to go forward.
SPEAKER_03It's interesting though, because at least on the captive side, I could speak to that they're very scarcity mindset about their stuff, right? Like, hey, this is my stuff, don't touch it, and you don't get any pivoting from that thinking to a Elon Musk open, you know, hey, look at here's the plans of the Tesla, you can make your own, right? Like it's a very, very wide gap.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. They they just, you know, again, it it used to work, right? Because it used to be so hard to switch, it used to be so hard to move. So, you know, I always stay for an apology because I'll just keep picking on it here. But I actually deep down inside love them very thankful what they've done for my family. So uh, you know, make sure that's that's known here. But yeah, their one-on-one training is multi-line, get as many policies as you can, like you'll never lose the business, right? Because they think of this method of like once you're so in deep, like someone it's it's too painful to switch. Well, that's not really a thing anymore, right? Like people are going. So, you know, that method doesn't really work as much anymore, where you know, you can be kind of fat and sassy and say, hey, like I don't really need to work with others or do different things like that because on my multi-line book, we got a 95% retention ratio and it's not going in there. And if I have a life policy, it's 97%. Like that just doesn't exist anymore. Not when because it used to be that life was hard to get, or a lot of people didn't do the multi-line, you know, uh, everyone's doing that now, right? And you know, realistically, I used to say with my uh state farm all the time, I would have maybe still be a state farm agent if they would have just given me like maybe let's call it three or four strategic contracts, right? So I have my main state farm, and maybe there's a rule where I gotta run it through them first or something, but give me like a substandard auto, maybe give me uh like a next insurance, I don't know, or something, you know, give me a couple things that State Farm didn't really do well. Like I was a rental and apartment guy, State Farm at the time wouldn't write those to save their life. If the premium should be around 100, they were at a million, right? Like, give me a couple contracts there, maybe one wholesaler contract with an Amwins or something, and it's good, right? 90% of my business still goes to State Farm. I did 10%, and that's my book outside my book that I eventually bring back into State Farm as you know things change, you know, etc. So personally, that's where I would like to see a lot of them go, and I think a lot of them will need to, um, or they're gonna have to downside their agency force, just gonna go from you know 18,000 down to 4,000 because you're just probably not gonna be able to compete the same way uh you did, not with the independent agents. That's the other thing, too, is the captive agents used to have better technology, better training. They used to be ahead. It used to be so hard to be an independent agent, right? And I'm not saying it's not hard to be an independent agent, but the independent channel has caught up, if not surpassed, with their ability to do things independently. They actually, I think, maybe have even, you know, like I said, surpassed the captive because they've been constantly battling to get better, constantly bringing in things to help their agency, and the captive has been like that. So stagnated. That's my thought process there.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, and the tech. I mean, speaking from experience with the tech, it just it's declined. You know, like as insure techs have developed amazing products and amazing services, amazing methods to deliver and beat the competition. You know, many carriers have not kept up with that, right? Or many of the captive carriers. Yep. I won't name any names, and certainly not the one I'm with, the majority just have it, right? Like, and they continue to build on top of what they already have instead of creating something new. So it's just as interesting what's gonna happen with those.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and to be honest with you, like selfishly, I don't think there's any insurance company that I don't like, right? Like, I guess I should throw that out there. Like, I love the insurance space and other brokers and other carriers. I just like I just can't help but think that you know, these big captives they have great policies, right? And it's just like if they could bring in some technology or bring in just a couple things, they could still dominate for another hundred years, right? Like it could still be very big players, but you know, you you do eventually have to go from square wheels to round wheels to driverless cars, like you do have to adapt. It it's not negative, it's just you know, we no longer do flip phones even. We're touching, you know, like you do have to move, but gosh, they have such a great opportunity if they can continue to move or partner or bring technology in because they really do have good, strong business models, fundamentals, probably cash-rich, uh, the whole nine. They have a good agency force, they probably have some of the better brokers who have been around for a long time or agents, like they have a lot going for them. So, like, they really do still have the forefront. Like, I always hear on Shark Tank, anytime there's a lot of times there's a good idea, you'll hear like Mr. Wonderful or someone be like, Well, why doesn't the big guy just replicate that and do that? And that's kind of still like my is I always think uh anytime I see this new thing in the insure tech space, I'm always like, All right, you know, a captive or someone could probably do this if they wanted to. They already have the distribution, you already have the the funds and the the clients, right? Like they just got to have the want and maybe just get out of that mentality of like how it's always been.
SPEAKER_02What do you think? Um, all of that going on, where's the competitive advantage for the agents what that you see like moving forward?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so I think the competitive is partnerships, right? I think and how you're accessing the agents, right? So growing up, uh, how you access clients was hanging your shingle. Uh, maybe you're the person in town, maybe you're the you know, on the local chamber of commerce and people came to you, right? Because of how things went. Then it was the age of like, I'm gonna somewhat get in front of people with uh technology through social and internet leads and everything like that, uh, event marketing, right? And now I think we need to be where people are already at, right? So instead of thinking about how do I access the homeowner, it's like, how do I access a partnership where the homeowner or the person who owns an auto uh policy is already like working with, right? Like, how do I get in as an agent with um, I don't know, the you know, of course, the lenders and realtors, that's you know, one-on-one, everyone's like, you know, get with them, but how do I get into Chase? How do I get into everybody's logging into their local soccer club, you know, website? How do I advertise within there? You know, the easiest example is like everyone goes into Amazon. Like, how do I get into Amazon, you know, and be on the right hand side with a homeowner's quote, right? So I think the next step in the evolution is really working with partners. And even if it's not through technology, even if it's still, you know, grab the phone or meet in person, but really finding those partners who are already found your client. And the reason why I like partnerships more than anything is insurance is very simple. How people come to you is how they leave you, right? If they came through an internet lead, they'll leave through an internet lead. If they came through Google, they probably leave through. If you start to double layer those relationships, right, where they come through you, like why do we like realtors and lenders? It's because you have that double layer. They come to the realtor who they also like, and then they come to you, or they come to the lender and they come to you. So meaning that they have to leave that realtor or lender's relationship to also leave you, right? So, really, that's what I would concentrate uh on there. And the way to help these partnerships out is a lot of them are dying for time too, right? And efficiencies. And so you used to uh call up a lending institution and say, hey, I can provide you quotes really fast, or I'll come down there and provide you quotes or whatever. You know, what if you could just for your, you know, um now just provide the processor in a whole lending institution your landing page uh where they could just quote homeowners' policies in 30 seconds and add them on for their closing, and you're the one that sets that up and helps out with that and answers any questions, right? You can actually help them build their business compared to like offering them like, you know, $10 and a couple donuts, you know, once a month, you know, for like thank you for the business. You can actually find a way to use insurance to help grow their business. And I think that's what people should concentrate on, or what I would concentrate on in a brokerage land is like, how do I help the people that I want to increase me grow their business? And then I'll get all the leads and opportunities that I need.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman